The present invention is directed to methods and systems for inducing ferroelectric properties in a hexagonal diatomic layered material.
The ability to locally switch a confined electrical polarization is a key requirement in modern technologies, where storing and retrieving a large volume of information is vital. Today, after decades of intense research, it is possible to squeeze a tera (1012) of polarized islands in a cm2 chip composed of high-quality three-dimensional (3D) crystals. The need to further reduce the dimensions of individually polarized domains, however, from the ˜100 nm2 scale towards the atomic scale is rising. The main challenges involve long-range dipole interactions which tend to couple the individual domain polarization orientations. Likewise, surface effects and external strains that are difficult to control become dominant once the surface-to-volume ratio increases. Venues to overcome the abovementioned difficulties become straightforward when considering 2D crystals, in particular, in layered materials such as hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN) and transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD), where the bulk volume can be reduced to the ultimate atomic-thickness limit whereas the crystalline surface remains intact.
It is still rare to find a spontaneous net electric polarization in 2D that is sufficiently large to read and write under ambient conditions. In common systems such as hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN) and transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD) crystals, polarization is eliminated by a centrosymmetric van der Waals (vdW) structure which is lower in energy than other stacking configurations. Hence, in such crystals, the lattice stacking structure of these materials is such that they do not exhibit polarization. The inventors of the technology disclosed herein have been able to develop a novel methodology which enables induction of ferroelectricity in diatomic hexagonal structures, at room temperature.
As used herein, the term ‘crystal’ is used alongside with ‘material’, both referring to the diatomic hexagonal layered material induced with polarization or ferroelectric properties.
Six different high symmetry stacking configurations of bilayer h-BN or hexagonal TMDs are possible. The six configurations are shown in
To explore the different configurations, two exfoliated h-BN flakes were artificially stamped on top of each other, each comprising a few AA′ stacked layers, with a minute twist-angle between the otherwise parallel interfacial layers. The small twist imposes interlayer translations that evolve continuously and form a Moiré pattern owing to the underlying crystal periodicity (
To measure variations in the electrical potential, VKP, at surface regions of different stacking configurations, an h-BN sandwich was placed on a conducting substrate (graphite or gold), and scanned by an atomic force microscope (AFM) operated in a Kelvin probe mode (KPFM),
It is noted that similar values for ΔVKP were obtained for several samples (
While the force field calculations for slightly twisted bilayer h-BN show a uniform triangular lattice of alternating AB and BA stacked domains (
To trace the microscopic origin of the measured polarization, a set of density functional theory (DFT) calculations were applied on finite bilayer and quad-layer h-BN flakes. For the finite bilayer calculations, two model systems were constructed, where hydrogen passivated h-BN flakes of eithe r 1 nm2 or 3 nm2 surface area are stacked in the AB stacking mode (see
It is instructive to further translate the measured potential difference into intra-layer displacements in a simplistic point-like charges model (see Δd in
To quantify these arguments, a reduced classical bilayer model was presented that captures the intricate balance between Pauli, vdW, and Coulomb interatomic interactions at different stacking modes. In this model, the interfacial energy
includes a Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential characterized by the cohesive energy, ε, and the interlayer spacing scale σ, and Coulomb interactions between the dimensionless partial atomic charges on the boron and nitrogen sites q=±qi/e. Although neglecting any charge transfer processes between the layers that are explicitly taken into account in the DFT calculations, this model captures both the magnitude and orientation of the polarization by adjusting the ratio between ε and Coulomb scales∝q2/σ (see
The emergence of permanent polarization observed in separated domains, which dimensions can be tuned by the twist-angle, each exhibiting a distinct and stable potential, opens the door for novel applications. It is noteworthy that polarization inversion can be achieved by reversible switching between AB and BA configurations which, in turn, can be realized by relative lateral translation by one atomic spacing (1.44 Å) as illustrated in
The results therefore demonstrate that the broken symmetry at the interface of parallel-stacked h-BN flakes gives rise to an out-of-plane two-dimensional polarization confined within a few interfacial layers that can be locally detected and controlled. While the h-BN system, with its only two different light atoms, offers a comfortable experimental and computational testbed and allows for intuitive interpretations, similar phenomena is expected to occur in other more complex bi-atomic vdW crystals, such as various TMDs. Notably, the origin of the polarization and the inversion mechanism developed herein are fundamentally different from the common deformations of tightly-bonded atoms in non-centrosymmetric 3D bulk crystals. The “slidetronics” switching involves lateral domain-wall motion in a weakly-coupled interface under ambient conditions. The sensitivity of the system to the delicate interplay between van der Waals attraction, Pauli repulsion, Coulomb interactions and charge redistribution implies that external stimuli such as pressure, temperature, and/or electric fields may be used to control the polarization, thus offering many opportunities for future research.
Thus, in a first of its aspects, the invention provides a process for inducing polarization in a stacked multilayered diatomic hexagonal material, the process comprising orienting any two stacked layers of a diatomic hexagonal material into a stacked parallel lattice orientation to induce internal interfacial electric field normal to the layers plane at an interface between the two stacked material layers. In other words, by achieving parallel lattice orientation, internal interfacial electric field normal to the layer plane of the crystal may be achieved.
As used herein, orientation of any two stacked layers may be achievable by a variety of methodologies, as disclosed hereinbelow. In some embodiments, orientation is achieved by positioning two or more layers or flakes of the material atop of each other in a parallel lattice orientation as disclosed herein. Reference to “any two stacked material layers” is to any two material layers that are immediately on top of each other, not separated by a further layer. For example, in a multilayered structure comprising three material layers, a, b and c, the expression refers to layers a and b or layers b and c. Polarization is measurable at an interface between any two layers a and b, or b and c, in the specific example, of the multilayered material, as an internal interfacial electric field normal to the layer plane of the crystal. In a three-layered material, two layer interfaces are present. Polarization orientation in each interface may be the same or different.
The invention also provides a process for inducing polarization in a stacked multilayered diatomic hexagonal material, the process comprising layering two or more flakes of a diatomic hexagonal material such that a stacked multilayered material is obtained wherein each layer in the multilayered material is in a parallel lattice orientation, said stacked multilayered material exhibiting polarization at an interface between any two material layers in said multilayered material.
In an exemplary case of a method for manufacturing a stable h-BN ferroelectric crystal, a process according to the invention may comprise:
This process may be employed on any diatomic hexagonal multilayered or layered material as disclosed herein.
In some embodiments, the process of inducing polarization comprises layering two or more flakes of a diatomic hexagonal material such that a stacked multilayered material is obtained wherein each layer in the multilayered material is in a parallel lattice orientation.
In some embodiments, the process comprising depositing a layer of a diatomic hexagonal material on top a layer of same diatomic hexagonal material such that a stacked multilayered material is obtained wherein each layer in the multilayered material is in a parallel lattice orientation.
In some embodiments, the process comprising
In other embodiments, the process comprising
In some embodiments, the two or more flakes are obtained from exfoliating layers of a diatomic hexagonal multilayered crystal or material.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is at least two.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is two or three or more.
In some embodiments, the number of polarization states is equal to the number of internal interfaces between stacked layers in the multilayered material.
In some embodiments, the number of polarization states is one, or is at least two.
In some embodiments, the process is for obtaining a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having one or more same or different internal interfacial polarized states.
In other embodiments, the process is for obtaining a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having two or more same or different internal interfacial polarized states.
Non-limiting examples of diatomic hexagonal (multi) layered materials which can be used in accordance with aspects and embodiments of the invention include hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN), transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD), hexagonal-aluminum-nitride (h-AlN), hexagonal-zinc-oxide (h-ZnO), hexagonal-gallium-nitride (h-GaN), etc.
Hexagonal boron nitride, h-BN, is a ceramic material known for its high thermal conductivity, inertness, and tribological properties that render it interesting in a variety of applications. The material also finds its unique applications in polymer composites for high temperature applications and sp3 bonding in extreme temperature and compression conditions. The structural texture of h-BN is a layered structure, wherein the boron atoms and atoms of nitrogen are bound strongly due to covalent bonds present in-plane and van der Waals forces that hold the layer together. Due to it is thermal conductivity, h-BN is fascinating for various electronic applications. h-BN may possibly be used as filler material which insulates electricity for thermal radiators, polymer or ceramic composites, UV emitters and field emitters.
Transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD) are 2D materials exhibiting unique electrical, mechanical, and optical properties and are therefore of virtually unlimited potential in various fields, including electronic, optoelectronic, sensing, and energy storage applications. Non-limiting examples of these layered materials include MoS2, WS2, MoSe2 and WSe2.
Thus, in some embodiments, the diatomic hexagonal layered material is selected from h-BN, TMD such as MoS2, WS2, MoSe2 and WSe2 and others.
Diatomic hexagonal layered materials which may be used according to the invention are generally 2D materials having hexagonal lattice with three-fold symmetry and which permits minor plane symmetry and/or inversion symmetry. The materials are provided as exfoliated layers or alternatively in a grown layered form, for example by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) or by any similar growth method of thin layers, which can be assembled into a stack in a parallel lattice orientation of the individual layers, as disclosed herein. The thickness of the stack can be as thin as two layers only. Thicker stacks with more than two layers exhibit a larger polarization that depends on the number of parallel interfaces as calculated in
In other words, the magnitude of polarization, as known in the art, of a multilayered stack structure of the invention is thus dependent on the number of layer interfaces present in the structure such that the value of the magnitude may be calculated or determined by determining the magnitude of polarization of a single interface and multiplying said value by the number of interfaces in the structure. In some embodiments, the polarization magnitude of a structure of the invention is the polarization magnitude of a single layer interface multiplied by the number of interfaces in the structure. Depolarization effects in a structure of the invention are minimized to the extent that the linear enhancement of the polarization may be predicted based on a measurable polarization for a single interface.
Thus, in some embodiments, in a material or a crystal having three or more material layers, the magnitude of polarization of the material is equal to a polarization measured or determined for a single interface between two stacked layers multiplied by the number of layer interfaces.
In some embodiments, the material or crystal may therefore be characterized by a linear enhancement of polarization, wherein the magnitude of polarization being dependent on the number of interfaces between any two stacked layers. The material or crystal may also be characterized by diminished depolarization surface effects.
In some embodiments, the number of material layers is three or more, each interface between two layers having a polarization orientation that is same or different to a polarization orientation present at an interface between any two other layers of the multilayered material.
The invention also provides a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material or crystal, the material comprising two or more material layers oriented in a parallel orientation to each other, wherein each two stacked layers exhibiting polarization.
Also provided is a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, the material comprising two or more material layers oriented in a parallel lattice orientation to each other, exhibiting or having internal interfacial electric field normal to the layers plane
In some embodiments, the material or crystal comprises three or more material layers and two or more polarization orientations, each polarization orientation being associated with a different pair of stacked material layers.
In another aspect there is thus provided a multipolarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, the material comprising two or more material layers oriented in a parallel lattice orientation to each other and two or more polarization domains.
In some embodiments, the polarized or multipolarized system is stable at room temperature, as defined herein.
Polarization orientation may be switched by applying electric field to the polarized multilayered material. By inducing electric field, ferroelectricity may be induced that is stable at room temperature, namely at a temperature up to 200° C. In some embodiments, stability is measured at an ambient temperature, namely at a temperature between 20 and 200° C. As used herein, the term “room temperature stable” or any variation thereof refers to the fact that a polarized material or a ferroelectric material according to the invention does not exhibit diminishing or loss of electric field (polarization) or ferroelectricity at temperatures as high as room temperature, or up to 200° C.
Thus, it is an object of the present application to further provide a process for inducing ferroelectricity to a polarized diatomic hexagonal layered material, such as h-BN and TMD, the process comprising applying a local electric field normal to a polarized diatomic hexagonal (multi) layered material causing domain wall sliding, thereby flipping the polarization orientation and inducing the ferroelectricity.
Also provided is a process for manufacturing a room temperature stable ferroelectric crystal, the process comprising forming or obtaining a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having a layered stacking configuration, wherein the material layers are stacked in a parallel lattice orientation to exhibit internal interfacial electric field normal to the layer plane of the crystal and applying electric field to said layered material to induce room temperature stable ferroelectric properties.
The term “ferroelectricity” is attributed to a polarized material or system that can switch its internal polarization orientation by applying external electric field.
This electric polarization can be reversed in direction by the application of an opposite electric field to the polarized domains. The polarization and its switching process are stable at room temperature and ambient conditions.
In some embodiments, electric field is applied by scanning a biased tip above the hexagonal diatomic layered material surface to induce a local electric field normal to interface.
In some embodiments, the process of the invention thus aims at achieving a dynamic flipping of polarization orientation by domain-wall sliding. This is achieved, in some embodiments, by a process comprising:
In place of a scanning biased tip, an electrode may be used.
The “domain wall” defines a boundary between or an interface separating crystallographic domains in the material or crystal. In “domain wall sliding” a relative lateral shift by one interatomic distance occurs in one of the layers of the layered materials, relative to an underlining layer, which causes switching of the layers stacking configuration. The switched stacking is equivalent to flipping of the structure and its normal polarization orientation. In other words, the lateral domain walls sliding increases the area of the domains that point along the external electric field at the expense of the domains that point in the opposite direction as shown in
Thus, the invention further provides a process for manufacturing a room temperature stable ferroelectric crystal, the process comprising applying a local electric field normal to a polarized crystal of a diatomic hexagonal layered material, such as h-BN and TMD crystals to thereby cause sliding of layers in said layered material relative to each other, to provide an array of permanent and switchable polarization domains in the crystal.
Further provided is a process for manufacturing a room temperature stable ferroelectric crystal, the process comprising forming a crystal of a diatomic hexagonal layered material having a layered stacking configuration, such as h-BN crystal, wherein the material layers are stacked in a parallel lattice orientation to exhibit internal interfacial electric field normal to the layer plane of the crystal (namely to having polarization) and applying electric field to said layered material to induce ferroelectric properties.
In another aspect of the invention, there is provided a ferroelectric diatomic hexagonal layered material, such as h-BN and TMD crystals.
Also provided is a polarized diatomic hexagonal layered material or crystal, namely a material or a crystal exhibiting internal interfacial electric field normal to a layer plane of the material or crystal.
Further provided is a diatomic hexagonal layered material or crystal exhibiting multiple polarization states or orientations normal to a layer plane of the material or crystal. In other words, each polarization state or orientation being located at a different internal interface between layers of the material or crystal.
In some embodiments, the polarized or ferroelectric material is manufactured according to any of the processes of the invention.
Ferroelectric materials of the invention or materials manufactured according to processes of the invention may be implemented in a variety of devices and can be used in a variety of applications. In most general terms, a device is provided that comprises a ferroelectric material according to the invention. The device may be an electronic or a photoelectric or an optical device.
Ferroelectric materials of the invention offer significant advantages in integrated circuits, particularly integrated circuit memories. As known in the art, integrated circuit memories, including conventional Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM), are volatile memories, in which the stored information remains only so long as power is applied to the integrated circuit. Non-volatile memories, such as flash-type memories, are low in storage density, require extremely high voltage applied for long periods to write and erase data, and generally have a more limited erase and write lifetime than DRAMs. The ferroelectric materials having polarization states that can be selected or switched by application of an electric field, and these polarization states remain after the electric field is removed can be used as capacitors possibility for simple, low cost, high density, non-volatile memories.
Apart from the memory units, ferroelectric materials of the invention may be utilized in ferroelectric field effect transistors, high capacity dynamic random access memories (DRAMs), CCD multiplexer read-out systems, integrated pyroelectric detectors, integrated surface acoustic wave devices, spatial light monitors, and microwave devices as well as in ferroelectric tunnel junction, ferroelectric transistors, sensors and strain sensors, and a variety of optical devices.
Also provided is use of a ferroelectric material according to the invention in constructing an electronic or a photoelectric or an optical device, as detailed herein.
As noted above, polarization and polarization magnitude of a multilayered structure according to the invention may be determined. Having the ability to pre-set or pre-define the polarization states in a multilayered structure enables designing a multi-switch device having pre-determined multi-switch polarization states. Thus, devices of the invention may be configured also as having pre-determined multi-switch polarization states, each of said states being determined by summing up the (total) number of interfaces having a polarization pointing in one direction (e.g., “up”) normal to the multilayer plane, minus the number of interfaces with a polarization pointing in the opposite direction (e.g., down).
As noted herein, polarization states can be reversed in direction by the application of an opposite electric field to the polarized domains. The polarization and its switching process are stable at room temperature and ambient conditions.
In order to better understand the subject matter that is disclosed herein and to exemplify how it may be carried out in practice, embodiments will now be described, by way of non-limiting example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
As disclosed herein, the invention provides a process for inducing polarization in a stacked multilayered diatomic hexagonal material, the process comprising orienting any two stacked layers of a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material into a stacked parallel lattice orientation to induce internal interfacial electric field normal to the layers plane at an interface between the two stacked material layers.
In some embodiments, the process comprises layering two or more flakes of a diatomic hexagonal material such that a stacked multilayered material is obtained wherein each layer in the multilayered material is in a parallel lattice orientation.
In some embodiments, the process comprises depositing a layer of a diatomic hexagonal material on top a layer of same diatomic hexagonal material such that a stacked multilayered material is obtained wherein each layer in the multilayered material is in a parallel lattice orientation.
In some embodiments, the process comprises providing a diatomic hexagonal multilayered crystal or material, separating layers making up the crystal or material into separate layers and stacking at least one of the separated layers on top of another, such that an internal interfacial electric field normal to the layers plane of the material is formed at an interface between the two stacked material layers.
In some embodiments, the process comprises
In some embodiments, the two or more flakes are obtained from exfoliating layers of a diatomic hexagonal multilayered crystal or material.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is at least two.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is two or three or more.
In some embodiments, the number of polarization states is equal to the number of internal interfaces between stacked layers in the multilayered material.
In some embodiments, the number of polarization states is one or is at least two.
In some embodiments, the process is for obtaining a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having one or two or more same or different internal interfacial polarized states.
In some embodiments, the diatomic hexagonal multilayered material is selected from hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN), transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD), hexagonal-aluminum-nitride (h-AlN), hexagonal-zinc-oxide (h- ZnO) and hexagonal-gallium-nitride (h-GaN).
In some embodiments, the material is hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN) or transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD).
In some embodiments, the TMD is selected from MoS2, WS2, MoSe2 and WSe2.
In some embodiments, the process is for inducing polarization in a h-BN crystal.
In some embodiments, the process is for inducing polarization in a TMD crystal.
Also provided is a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, the material comprising two or more material layers oriented in a parallel lattice orientation to each other, exhibiting or having internal interfacial electric field normal to the layers plane.
In some embodiments, the material has one or more internal interfacial electric fields (or polarization domains), each being at a different interface between two stacked layers.
Further provided is a multipolarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, the material comprising two or more material layers oriented in a parallel lattice orientation to each other and two or more polarization domains.
In some embodiments, the diatomic hexagonal multilayered material is selected from hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN), transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD), hexagonal-aluminum-nitride (h- AlN), hexagonal-zinc-oxide (h- ZnO) and hexagonal-gallium-nitride (h- GaN).
In some embodiments, the material is hexagonal-boron-nitride (h-BN) or transition-metal-dichalcogenides (TMD).
In some embodiments, the TMD is selected from MoS2, WS2, MoSe2 and WSe2.
In some embodiments, the material is stable at room temperature.
In some embodiments, the material is prepared by a process according to processes of the invention.
In some embodiments, the material has three or more material layers, a magnitude of polarization of the material is equal to a polarization measured or determined for a single interface between two stacked layers multiplied by the number of layer interfaces.
In some embodiments, the material is characterized by a linear enhancement of polarization, wherein the magnitude of polarization being dependent on the number of interfaces between any two stacked layers.
In some embodiments, the material is characterized by diminished depolarization surface effects.
The invention further provides a process for inducing ferroelectricity to a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, the process comprising applying a local electric field normal to a polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material causing domain wall sliding, to thereby induce the ferroelectricity.
In some embodiments, the process comprises applying a local electric field by an electrode or a biased tip above the hexagonal diatomic multilayered material surface.
In some embodiments, the process is for manufacturing a room temperature stable ferroelectric crystal, the process comprising applying a local electric field normal to a polarized crystal of a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material, to thereby cause sliding of layers in said layered material relative to each other, to provide an array of permanent and switchable polarization domains in the crystal.
A process is also provided for manufacturing a room temperature stable ferroelectric crystal, the process comprising forming or obtaining a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having a layered stacking configuration, wherein the material layers are stacked in a parallel lattice orientation to exhibit internal interfacial electric field normal to the layer plane of the crystal and applying electric field to said layered material to induce room temperature stable ferroelectric properties.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is at least two.
In some embodiments, the number of layers in the multilayered material is two or three or more.
In some embodiments, the polarized diatomic hexagonal multilayered material has one or more same or different internal interfacial polarized states.
In some embodiments, the process is for inducing ferroelectric properties to h-BN crystal.
In some embodiments, the process is for inducing ferroelectric properties to TMD crystal.
Also provided is a diatomic hexagonal multilayered material having room temperature stable ferroelectric properties.
In some embodiments, the material is h-BN or TMD.
In some embodiments, the material is prepared by a process according to the invention.
A use is provided of a ferroelectric material according to the invention in constructing an electronic or a photoelectric or an optical device.
A device may be any such device implementing a ferroelectric material according to the invention. The device may be selected from integrated circuits, such as an integrated circuit memory.
In some embodiments, the device is selected from Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM), a flash-type memory, a ferroelectric field effect transistor, a CCD multiplexer read-out system, an integrated pyroelectric detector, an integrated surface acoustic wave device, a spatial light monitor, a microwave device, a ferroelectric tunnel junction, a ferroelectric transistor, a sensor and strain sensor.
A device implementing a material according to the invention may have pre-determined multi-switch polarization states, each of said states being determined by summing up the number of interfaces having a polarization pointing in one direction normal to the multilayer plane, minus the number of interfaces with a polarization pointing in the opposite direction.
In the following description, numerous details are set forth for the purpose of explanation. However, one of ordinary skill in the art will realize that the invention may be practiced without the use of these specific details.
h-BN flakes of various thicknesses (1-5 nm) were exfoliated onto a SiO2 surface. A particular flake is selected to have several topographic steps of a few-layers thickness. The flake is ripped off into two pieces which are stacked together by a polymer stamp. During the stamping processes we make sure to minimize any twist orientation. Finally, the two-flakes-sandwich is placed on a conducting graphite flake or alternatively on a gold substrate, using the same dry transfer method.
Topography and Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM) measurements are acquired simultaneously (
To switch the domain orientation biased scans are performed in a pin-point mode. Here the tip approaches the surface vertically at each pixel in the scanned area. The estimated maximum force during this approach is 50 nN. This mode minimizes lateral forces between the tip and the surface.
The AFM tip and the sample are treated as a parallel-plate capacitor model. The charge induced on the tip and the substrate is affected by the voltage applied between them, and potential drops related to the sample.
The applied voltage on the tip consists of DC and AC components. The total voltage is given by:
V=V
DC
+V
AC sin(ωt)+VCPD
where VCPD is the contact potential difference, which originates from the different work function of the tip and the substrate. The force acting on the tip is:
where A is the effective area of the capacitor, ϵ is the dielectric constant and ρ is the two-dimensional charge density. The latter can be extracted from:
where d is the distance between the plates, and Vint is the voltage drop at the h-BN interface. This claim holds assuming the sample is neutral and the field outside the sample from the charges distribution in the sample is zero. After inserting it in the force equation, we get the first harmonic of the force:
F(ω)∝(Vint−VDC−VCPD)AC sin(ωt)
It vanishes for VDC=Vint−VCPD. The main principle of KPFM is to apply a DC voltage that nullifies the first harmonic, so Vint signal can be extracted from variation in the KPFM signal, VDC, at different lateral positions above the surface.
To study the structural properties of twisted h-BN interfaces we constructed a model system consisting of two h-BN layers with an interlayer misfit angle of ˜0.5°. To mimic the experimental scenario, a laterally periodic supercell was constructed with a triangular lattice of periodicity L=|n{right arrow over (a)}1+m{right arrow over (a)}2|, where the primitive lattice vectors are given by {right arrow over (a)}1=ahBN(√{square root over (3,)} 0) and
ahBN2.505 Å based on the Tersoff potential equilibrium bond-length of bBN=1.446 Å. The indices n=195 and m=1 were chosen to fulfil the condition:
The corresponding moiré pattern dimension is
The parallelepiped supercell was then multiplicated to construct a rectangular supercell consisting of more than 300,000 atoms.
The structural properties of the twisted h-BN interface were calculated using the Tersoff intra-layer potential in conjunction with the recently developed dedicated interlayer potential (ILP). We first optimized the geometry of the top layer atoms with fixed supercell size using the Fire algorithm and keeping the bottom layer rigid. This was followed by optimization of the supercell dimensions by the conjugate gradient (CG) algorithm while scaling the rigid bottom layer according to the simulation box size. This two-step energy minimization procedure was repeated for ten times, which is sufficient to obtain well converged results (see
The local registry index (LRI) (
where SiJK,opt and SiJK,worst are SiJK evaluated at the optimal and worst local stacking modes, respectively (AA′ and AA in the case of h-BN, respectively, see
Plotting the LRI following geometry relaxation as discussed above (
To evaluate the dipole moment developing in the system we considered a finite AB stacked hexagonal h-BN bilayer model with a surface area of 1.1 nm2 and armchair edges. The flake was initially constructed with uniform B—N bond lengths of 1.446 Å and the edges were saturated by hydrogen atoms with initial B—H and N—H bond lengths of 1.200 Å and 1.020 Å, respectively (
To verify that the flake size used is sufficiently large, we repeated the dipole moment calculation for a bilayer flake with surface area of 2.9 nm2. As seen in Table 1 the obtained values are within 20-25% with those of the smaller flake, indicating that edge effects are relatively small and validating the qualitative value of the results. This is further supported by the Mulliken charge analysis map provided in
Our minimalistic model provides a classical estimate of the out-of-plane polarization of the AB bilayer interface treating the boron and nitrogen atoms as point charges (see FIG. S4A,B), interacting via Pauli and van der Waals (VdW) forces (described by the Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential), and Coulomb interactions. The total interlayer energy is written as follows:
where ε is the cohesive energy with σ≡3.3 Å. We note that realistic models of h-BN should take atom specific ε and σ values. Here, however we are interested in a qualitative description of the system and hence, for simplicity, we limit the treatment for uniform parameter values. The differences in electronegativity of the boron and nitrogen atoms are effectively taken into account by assigning dimensionless partial charges located at the nuclear centers q=±qi/e for i∈B, N respectively. The parameter q2/εσ controls the relative strength between the Coulomb and LJ interactions. As we will demonstrate, this competition determines the sign of the polarization at the AB interface. We denote by α the atomic sites in one layer that reside above hexagon centers in the other layer (termed herein as hollow sites). Correspondingly, β denotes atomic sites in one layer that reside above oppositely charged sites on the adjacent layer (termed herein as eclipsed sites). In each layer we use hα or hβ to denote vertical heights of α and β atomic sites, measured with respect to the midplane of the AB interface. To compute the polarization, we minimize the classical energy with respect to hα, h62 , via an approximate two-step protocol:
As a reference, we first consider two h-BN layers in the AA′ stacking configurations with hα=hβ=h/2. The total force per atom is:
The Coulomb contribution can be written as FAA′C=−F11C+F12C (with F11C, F12C>0), where
Here, {right arrow over (R)}11={right arrow over (R)}n1,n2 denote in plane lattice vectors connecting equivalent atoms, namely Bravais lattice vectors, and {right arrow over (R)}12={right arrow over (R)}n1,n2−{circumflex over (x)}R0 denote in plane lattice vectors connecting inequivalent atoms, where {circumflex over (x)}R0 is a vector connecting nearest-neighbors. The corresponding Bravais lattice vectors of the honeycomb lattice are given by {right arrow over (R)}n
with R0=1.4 Å. Quick convergence of FAA′C, is guaranteed if for any pair of integers n1, n2 the term F11C(h) is combined with F12C(h) calculated for −n1, −n2 and the sums are taken over the range −nm≤n1, n2≤nm with sufficiently large nm. The force then converges as 1/nm2 (not shown) in
into the meV regime, comparable with the VdW scale ε43.
Similarly, the LJ force can be split as FAA′LJ=F11LJ+F12LJ, where
The zero-force condition yields the optimal interlayer distance h, marked in
We note that a reasonable approximation for FAA′LJ(h), for small R0/h, consists of treating the particles as a uniform mass distribution, i.e. replacing the sum over {right arrow over (R)} by integration, yielding
Now consider two h-BN layers at the AB stacking configuration. The corresponding interlayer force can be written as FAB=FABLJ+FABC. The unit cell consists of two types of atomic sites, one type where atoms of the two layers reside atop of each other (eclipsed) and the other type where an atom of one layer resides atop a hexagon center of the other layer (hollow sites). Note that the Coulomb contribution of the hollow sites vanishes due to symmetry considerations. Hence, we only have the Coulomb contribution from the eclipsed atomic sites. Since the latter have the exact same configuration in the AA′ and AB stacking modes (see
For the VdW part, similar to the AA′ stacking case, the eclipsed atomic sites give F11LJ+F12LJ of Eq. S10, whereas the hollow atomic sites give 2F12LJ due to the unique symmetry of the AB stacked bilayer hexagonal lattice. Therefore, in total we obtain for the LJ force contribution per atom that
The zero-force condition yields the optimal AB stacking interlayer distance, marked by the dashed gray line in
1.5 meV. Specifically, when q→0 our model corresponds to the case of graphite with optimal AB stacking mode.
On top of the interlayer spacing, we now allow a small opposite motion of the hollow site (α) and eclipsed site (β) atoms: ha=h/2+Δd,hβ=h/2−Δd, (S8) as marked in
Δd2 around Δd2=0. The assumption that Δd<<R0 can be justified by the experimental estimate of Δd˜10−3 Å (see main text). Our simple model considered here, similar to an Einstein model for lattice vibrations, assumes that the Δd coordinates are independent Harmonic oscillators with spring constant
Crucially, Δd=0 is not a minimum due to the reduced symmetry of the AB interface, with alternating eclipsed and hollow sites, which imposes a finite normal force (per atom) of:
where FΔdC and FΔdLJ are defined as the relative displacement force contributions of the Coulomb and LJ terms. Note that FΔd is the difference between the forces acting on the eclipsed versus the hollow sites.
Since, for Δd=0, hollow site atoms see a locally charge-neutral configuration on the other layer the Coulomb part of this linear force originates only from the eclipsed atomic sites. For the latter, the atom in the upper layer is attracted to the one residing exactly below it in the other layer. However, it is repelled by its next nearest neighbors in the other layer, and so on. When performing the entire lattice sum for the eclipsed site we obtain that the overall force is always attractive:
On the other hand, the LJ potential, which can be written as the difference between the hollow site (2F12LJ(h)) and the eclipsed site (F11LJ(h)+F12LJ(h)) contributions yields a repulsive force per atom near the equilibrium interlayer distance:
This signifies that at the equilibrium interlayer distance, the eclipsed site contribution is more repulsive than that of the hollow site counterpart, mainly due to the fact that the eclipsed atoms are forced to reside within the steep Pauli repulsion wall side of their pairwise interaction.
Overall, from Eqs. S15 and S16 our crude estimate yields
KΔd in Eq. (S17) can be evaluated from the model parameters (see next section). Nevertheless, for simplicity we take it to be equal to the corresponding out-of-plane force constant in graphite KΔd˜5 N/m44.
The resulting relative displacement is plotted in
The experimentally measured voltages indicate that Δd in AB stacked bilayer h-BN is of the order of 10−3 Å and our DFT calculations indicate that it is positive suggesting that
see
Finally, it should be noted that our simplistic classical approach is sufficiently flexible to allow to study additional effects such as the dependence on the number of layers as well as external perturbations like pressure or electric field, as well as an additional in-plane component of the polarization, which we leave for future work.
To determine
we note that it has contributions from the interlayer LJ and Coulomb forces, as well as from the intra-layer forces. Its interlayer LJ contribution is obtained from the corresponding contribution to the energy
The first (second) term represents the interaction of atoms at eclipsed (hollow) sites, and
One can obtain a good approximation for the spring constant
by replacing the sums Σ{right arrow over (R)}
For ε=3 meV this yields a spring constant of KΔdLJ=3 N/m. While additional contributions are expected from intra-layer interactions, as well as Coulombic inter-layer interactions, this value is comparable to the measured out-of-plane force constant in graphite KΔd˜5 N/m44. Since Eq. S13 captures the order of magnitude of KΔd, we can use
with a factor of order unity
and obtain an approximate expression for the relative displacement, see Eq. (S17), fully in terms of our model's parameters,
Having thus described several embodiments for practicing the inventive method, its advantages and objectives can be easily understood. Variations from the description above may and can be made by one skilled in the art without departing from the scope of the invention.
Accordingly, this invention is not to be limited by the embodiments as described, which are given by way of example only and not by way of limitation.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/IL2021/051166 | 9/26/2021 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63083947 | Sep 2020 | US |