The invention is based on a priority application EP 02360140.4, which is hereby incorporated by reference.
The inventions relates to development, analysis and improvement of optical components.
In more particular, the invention relates to an Method for analysis optical components, in particular passive optical components, based on a inverse Fourier transform or an Z-transform and a computer program for executing the method.
The performance of passive optical components depends on the propagation of the light through a more of less complex set of optical paths of the device. A measurement technique able to provide the characterising parameters, for example phase and amplitude of the propagation of the light through the device is a very powerful tool for the analysis, development and improvement of passive optical components.
Arrayed waveguide gratings (AWG) are key components for high-speed large-capacity dense wavelength division multiplexing (DWDM) photonic networks. They are good candidates for dense channel de/multiplexers and building blocks of devices with other functionalism e.g.: dispersion compensators, optical add and drop multiplexers, gain equalisers, etc. Due to the increasing of the transmission rate per channel, the specification regarding the slope of the group delay (GD) and the differential group delay (DGD) are becoming narrower, so that new high precision characterisation methods and equipment are required. From other side, the amplitude and phase distributions of the light propagating through each kth arrayed path, (αk, φk), is a very useful information to investigate and improve the fabrication process of the AWGs.
A solution based on Fourier Spectroscopy Technique, namely the so called Optical Low Coherence (OLC) method, is known from IEEE Journal of Lightwave Technology, 1996, 14, pp. 1677–1689; TAKADA, K. YAMADA H., INOUE, Y. “Optical Low Coherence Method for Characterizing Silicia-Based Arrayed-Waveguide Grating Multiplexers”. The OLC method is in particular useful to characterise and improve AWG's, because it provides the amplitude and phase distributions (ηk, φk) of the light propagating through each arrayed waveguide of the array, k. By applying the Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (FTS), using a low coherence interferometer, an interferogram with a series of isolated fringes is provided, from which the amplitude and phase (αk, φk) of each arrayed-wave guide can be derived using the OLC method.
However, the solution is from basic principles and has a limited application, because it is not possible to analyze optical devices with a small or large optical path differences. The applicability of the OLC method is limited on the one hand by the coherence length of the available light sources, because it must be shorter than the delay increment (ΔL) of the AWG. In other words: In order to get the isolated fringes, it is necessary to apply a broadband light source with a coherence length shorter than the ΔL of the AWG. Thus, the applicability of this method to AWG designs with narrow ΔL is therefore limited by the bandwidth of the available light sources. On the other hand, it is limited by the maximum retardation of the interferometer, which is required to be more that half the maximum optical path difference among the arrayed waveguides. This is impossible for infinite impulse response filters.
It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a method for determining physical characteristics of an optical component that overcomes the aforementioned limitation.
Another object of the present invention is to provide a computer program and a device for performing the method.
These objects are achieved by a method according to claim 1, a computer program according to claim 9 and a device according to claim 10.
The invention provides a non-limited and very accurate method to measure and to analyse the propagation of the light through the optical device, which is a very important information to develop, analysis and improve passive optical components, for example filters, like FIR-filter, IIR-filter, discrete-time-delay optical filters etc.
The method is based in general on the Z-transform and in particular on the Direct and Inverse Fourier Transform and it can be implemented on any type of measurement of the complex transmission spectrum, e.g. Fourier Spectroscopy measurement techniques or a direct measurements of the transmission performance of the device.
The invention comprises in particular a new method to obtain the amplitude and phase distributions of AWG's. This method overcomes the limitations of previous phase characterisation methods and it can be generalised to analyse other discrete-time-delay optical filters for example FIR filter, IIR filter, ring resonator etc.
Following, a short description of the invention is given for two application examples, an AWG and a Ring Resonator.
First, with respect to an AWG a basic formula for the algorithm is an Inverse Fourier Transform implementation
and for the Ring Resonator application or other optical digital filters it is a Z-transform implementation:
which leads to an analogue expression of (AWG 1) where the factor neff*ΔL or neff*(L/2) represents a so called basic effective index step increment of the discrete-time-delay optical filter. It should be noted that the expression (RR1) represents also an Inverse Fourier Transform using the alternative definition of the Fourier Transformation. Due to that we have in (RR 1) T instead of 1/T and j2π instead of −i2π.
Second, the derivation of the basic formula for a AWG is exemplary described. The transmission through an AWG consisting of two star couplers of radii R1 and R2 and propagation constants βs1(σ) and βs2(σ) joined by a set of M waveguides with lengths L(k) and propagation constant βc(σ), from a port at angle θ1 in start coupler 1 to a port at angle θ2 in start coupler 2 can be described by:
where σ is the wavenumber σ=1/λ, a1(k,θ1) and a2(k,θ2) are the coupling coefficients between the fields produced at the end of the port at θn and of the end of the arrayed waveguide k. The αn(k) are the corresponding angles.
In order to characterize the AWG transmission for fixed input and output ports, Eq (1) can be simplified to:
if we substitute:
Ck=α1(k,θ1)·α2(k,θ2)·exp(i[−βs1(σ)R1α1(k)θ1−βs2(σ)R2α2(k)θ2]) (3)
The module of the complex coefficients Ck and their phase are usually described as the amplitude values |Ck|=ak and phase factors Argument(Cp)=φk, of the light passing through the kth path.
Any deviations from the designed parameters will turn out to a degradation of the transmission performance of the AWG. Index and core dimension inhomogeneities of the planar and channel waveguides will increase the crosstalk values. Even though the deviation from the designed parameter takes place in the array of waveguides or in the star couplers, they can be regarded as deviations from the ideal values of the complex coefficients Ck. Those deviations are described as amplitude and phase errors.
In case of an ideal AWG where the amplitude and phase coefficients and the effective index do not depend on a and the path-length difference between neighboring arrayed waveguides is defined by ΔLk, the transmission of an AWG can be seen as a complex periodic function H(σ) defined by a Fourier series with complex coefficients. Ck. if k=1, . . . , M and Ck=0 for (k<1 and k>M):
The period of the function is λc2/neffΔL, which corresponds to the free spectral range (FRS) of the AWG and λc is the central wavelength of the spectral range. The periodicity is obtained from the analysis of the complex transmission function. The analysis can be performed with either the real part or the imaginary part of the transmission function. But also the complex function can be used.
Due to the fact the Eq. (4) is a Fourier series, it is then possible to obtain the complex coefficients through an inverse Fourier Transformation:
where T is the period of the H(σ) function.
Therefore, once we have a measurement of the complex transmission of an AWG over the free spectral range and we know the optical step increment, it is possible to characterize the AWG through its amplitude and phase coefficients.
The complex transmission of the AWG can be obtained from different measurement techniques. It is possible to do that from a direct measurement of the magnitude transmission and time delay or from Fourier Transform spectroscopy. In one case we demonstrate the accuracy of the method with the OLC (optical low coherence) method. In such a way it is possible to compare the results obtained from the same measurement using the IFT (inverse Fourier Transform) and OLC methods.
The invention provides a non-limited and very accurate method to measure and to analyze the propagation of the light through the optical device which is a very important information to develop, analysis and improve passive optical components. That is a very important tool and it leads to a major breakthrough of the capabilities to develop Arrayed Waveguide Gratings.
Further advantages and developments of the invention are apparent from the description and the accompanying drawings.
It is to be understood that the aforementioned features and the features explained below can be used not only in the respective combinations described but also in other combinations or alone without departing from the scope of the present invention.
Preferred embodiments of the present invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings in which
a/b shows a further comparison of the phase and amplitude distribution o a AWG;
a/b show results from an AWG with a narrow path-length difference;
a/b show a calculated magnitude and phase transmission spectrum of a Symmetric Double Coupler Ring Resonator (SDCRR);
a/b show the calculated magnitude and phase of the impulse response of the SDCRR;
a/b show the experimental magnitude and phase of the transmission spectrum of the SDCRR,
a/b show the magnitude and phase of the impulse response obtained from the transmission measurement of
a/b to
a/b to
According to the invention a method for characterising optical components, in particular Arrayed-Waveguide Gratings (AWG) and Double Coupler Ring Resonator (DCRR), as well a computer program and a device for executing the method is provided.
Following the Inverse Fourier Transform (IFT) method according to the invention is exemplary described for characterising an Arrayed-Waveguide Gratings (AWG).
Arrayed-Waveguide Gratings (AWG):
The Inverse Fourier Transform method (IFT) has been developed to measure the phase and amplitude distributions of an AWG in advantageous manner. The IFT method according to the invention is a first application of a wavelength-domain measurement instead of to a Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (FTS) based measurement. In such a way, a single measurement of the complex transmission of the AWG and its IFT analysis provides a full characterisation of the AWG.
The method according to the invention enables a characterisation of phase and amplitude errors in AWGs based on Inverse Fourier Transformation (IFT). It overcomes the limitations of previous Optical Low Coherence methods (OLC), allowing the characterisation of AWGs with any step increment (ΔL). The method has been successfully used to characterise an AWG with a ΔL of only 22 μm. A comparison between the results from IFT and OLC methods shows a standard deviation of the phase errors of 2° for an AWG with a ΔL of 51 μm.
Measurement Principle:
The transmission of an AWG can be described as a complex periodic function H(σ), defined by a Fourier series with complex coefficients, Ck, and the period of the function is the free spectral range (FSR) of the AWG. The module of the complex coefficients Ck and their argument correspond, respectively, to the (αk, φk) distributions and the value of the Ck parameters can be obtained by the application of the IFT method to the complex transmission of the AWG along the FSR. The next section describes the obtaining of the complex amplitude transmission of the AWG from a measurement of its power transmission and group delay (GD). In parallel, the known OLC method was used to obtain the amplitude and phase distribution (αk, φk) and test the accuracy of the new method.
The transmission through an AWG consisting of two star couplers of radii R1 and R2 and propagation constants βs1(σ) and βs2(σ) joined by a set of M waveguides with lengths L(k) (k=1, . . . , M) and propagation constant βc(σ), from a port at angle θ1 in star coupler 1 to a port at angle θ2 in star coupler 2 can be described by:
H(σ,θ1,θ2)=Σk=−∞∞{a1(k,θ1)a2(k,θ2)exp(i[βc(σ)L(k)−βs1σ)R1α1(k)θ1−βs2(σ)R2α2(k)θ2])}
where i=v−1, σ=1/λ is the wave number, a1(k,θ1) and a2(k,θ2) are the coupling coefficients between the fields produced at the end of the port located at the angle θn (n=1,2) and at the end of the arrayed waveguide k and αn(k) are the corresponding angles. The transmission of an ideal AWG, where the described parameters do not depend on the wavenumber, can be described as a complex periodic function H(σ), defined by a Fourier series with complex coefficients, Ck.
If
Ck=0 for (k<1 and k>M)
then
H(σ)=Σk=−∞∞[Ck exp(i2πσk neff ΔL)], Eq. (1).
And the period of the function is the free spectral range (FSR) of the AWG. The complex coefficients Ck summarise all the design characteristics,
Ck=a1(k,θ1)a2(k,θ2)exp(i[βc(σ)(L(k)−k·ΔL)−βs1(σ)R1α1(k)θ1−βs2(σ)R2α2(k)θ2]),
where ΔL is the mean value of the path lengths of the arrayed waveguides. The module of the complex coefficients Ck and their argument correspond to the amplitude and phase distributions (|Ck|=ηk, Arg(Cp)=φk)=φk) of the light passing through the kth path. The factor exp(i[βc(σ)(L(k)−k·ΔL)]) takes into account a possible chirping of the path lengths and describes them as an extra phase. Any deviation from the designed parameters will produce a degradation of the transmission performance of the AWG. For example, index and core dimension inhomogeneities of the arrayed waveguides will increase the crosstalk values. Those deviations will be shown as discrepancies from the ideal values of the complex coefficients Ck and they are called amplitude and phase errors.
Due to the fact that Eq. (1) is a Fourier series, it is possible to obtain the complex coefficients through an inverse Fourier Transformation:
Ck=(1/T)∫σσ+TH(α)exp(−i2παk neff ΔL)dα. Eq. (2)
where T is the period of the H(σ) function. Therefore, based on a measurement of the complex transmission of an AWG along the FSR, it is possible to characterise the AWG through its amplitude and phase coefficients. The complex transmission of the AWG can be obtained from different measurement techniques. It is possible to perform a direct measurement of the transmittance and the time delay or to apply FTS. In order to compare the results obtained from IFT method according to the invention and OLC method of the state of the art, a fiber-optic Mach-Zehnder interferometer, which is similar to the one reported for the OLC, has been used for the measurements.
Transmission and Group Velocity Dispersion Measurements:
The used sample is a 16×100 GHz AWG module with 121 arrayed-waveguides and ΔL=80,3 μm. The power transmission and group delay (GD) measurement has been done with the state of the art, Agilent 81910A “All Parameter Test Solution” equipment.
To facilitate a measurement of the complex transmission of the AWG, H(σ), the transmission phase has been calculated by an integration process of the GD measurement.
Phase and Amplitude Characterisation:
The amplitude and phase distributions (αk, φk) are obtained by applying the basic formula of the AWG (equation AWG1) to the measured complex transmission.
Thereby, the calculating the coefficients Ck takes place by an iterative process based on product (neff ΔL). neff is the effective refractive index and
First the product of the effective refractive index neff and the step size ΔLk,i, i.e. the effective index step increment of the AWG is set to the free spectral range (FSR) of the AWG. Then the phase distribution of the AWG is calculated from the imaginary part of the coefficients Ck.
In
In
Set-up Description:
In parallel, a FTS measurement of the same AWG module has been done.
Comparison of Results from the IFT and the OLC Methods:
In order to apply the IFT method, the complex transmittance function of the sample, H(σ), has been obtained from a Fourier transformation of the interferogram and the emission spectrum of the LED. Applying Eq. (2) we can calculate the complex coefficients Ck and the amplitude and phase distributions.
There is a general good agreement between the results obtained from both methods. Despite of it, some differences can be noticed and they are attributed to the polarisation dependency of the (αk, φk)distributions.
a) and 7b) shows a further comparison of the phase and amplitude values obtained from IFT and OLC methods. These are results from an AWG with a designed ΔL=51.3 μm, wherein the phase distributions (
The IFT method has been applied to characterise this AWG with a designed step increment ΔL=22.4 μm and the results are shown in
The amplitude of the first and the last 100 path numbers are quite close to the mentioned noise level and this is the reason for the high phase errors of those channels. In order to check the precision of the results, and due to the lack of results from the OLC method, we have calculated the magnitude transmittance for that AWG. The calculated profile is compared with a direct measurement of the transmittance in
Estimation of the Measurement Errors:
The numerical subroutine to calculate the complex coefficients Ck, gives as result a set of copies of the C1 to CM values, spaced by the inverse of the non-dimensional sampling rate (Δσ neff ΔL). The sampling rate of the transmittance function depends on the scan length of the interferogram and it was long enough to provide a sampling rate under the Nyquist rate. The aliasing between adjacent copies is then avoided. The value of complex coefficients between two neighbouring copies should be zero. Instead of that, we got a floor line with a mean value of 6.02 10−4. We have also tested through numerical simulations that if we introduce an extra error in the measurement of the complex transmittance function the level of the floor between adjacent copies lift up proportionally. Because of that, we interpret the value of this floor as an estimation of the mean value of the error in the determination of the values of the amplitude distribution. As a consequence, the mean value of the error in the determination of the values of the phase distribution, ˜sin−1[(6.02·10−4)/ηk], depends also on the errors in the determination of the amplitude.
Conclusion of the AWG Example:
A very good agreement of the results obtained from the IFT method according to the invention in comparison with OLC method has been achieved. The new method has been applied to an AWG with a small ΔL of 22 μm where the other methods fail. The precision of this measurement is demonstrated by a good agreement between the transmittance obtained from direct measurement and from calculation using the amplitude and phase distributions.
Although the IFT method is described in connection with measurement results based on a FTS measurement, the method can be applied to any experimental technique that provides a measurement of the complex transmittance of an optical component, e.g. an AWG.
Further improvements comprises defined TE and TM polarisation input states for the die level measurement and Muller-matrix method for the module. The Inverse Fourier Transform method according to the invention provides the amplitude and phase distributions of an AWG from a measurement of its transmission and GD. Using defined AWG-input polarisation states this measurement and the IFT analysis provides a full characterisation of the AWG. This method is also applicable to other optical filter components like Ring Resonators.
Following the IFT method according to the invention is exemplary described for a further embodiment, namely in case of a Ring Resonator.
Ring Resonators:
Ring resonators (RRs) recently gained great attention due to their potential for DWDM-applications, e.g. dispersion compensation and ultra-compact Add&Drop multiplexers. At present, however, the application of RRs is restricted to niche applications due to the high FSR (Free Spectral Range) and the performance required for DWDM-systems. Meanwhile, first ring resonators with FSR-values in the THz-range have been demonstrated and intensive research is performed aiming at the realization of devices ready for system applications. The motivation for this work is to extend phase sensitive characterization methods successfully demonstrated on AWGs (Arrayed Waveguide Gratings) to ring resonators. This is demanding since data rates exceed the range of 10 Gb/s with a scope of 160 Gb/s.
Theory:
where α is the loss per length, L is the perimeter of the ring, β is the propagation constant of the waveguide ring, γ is the excess loss of the coupler, and y is related to the coupling efficiency η, by y=√{square root over (1−η)}. In order to study the information available by a Fourier Spectroscopy analysis of the transmission from a SDCRR, a simulation
The calculated magnitude and phase transmission spectrum of a SDCRR according to Equation (1) is shown in
As evident from equation (1) and
where an, bm and hp, they are in general complex magnitudes and hp is called the impulse response of a filter. Also, a region of convergence of the power series has to be specified, for example by rmin≦|z|≦rmax, were rmin and rmax are radii. The case |z|=1 is called the unit circle, because the filter's frequency response is found by evaluating H(z) along z=exp(jω), where ω is the normalized angular frequency, ω=2πν/FSR.
The Z-transform of the SDCRR can be obtained by the substitution exp(−jβL/2)=z−1 in Eq (1). It can be demonstrated by a Taylor expansion of Eq (1), that the Z-transform function of the SDCRR can be described by the infinite series:
The Eq (3) means that the transmission of a DCRR through its Output (peak) is equivalent to a Fourier Transform of an infinite set of impulses, each one corresponds to an odd number of unit delays. Once we have a Z-transform description of the filter as shown in Eq. (3), it is then possible to obtain the value of the impulse responses of the filter, hp, by applying the Cauchy integral:
It should be noticed that the Cauchy integral of Eq (4) is an integral along a closed circle of the complex plane. From the other side, a measurement of the complex transmission of a RR corresponds to values of the function H(z) along the unit circle z=exp(jω). Due to that, the impulse responses hp can be obtained from the application of the Cauchy integral to the complex transmission of the RR along a FSR.
By substituting exp(−jβL/2)=z−1 in Eq (4), the basic formula for the ring resonator is achieved
It can be observed that it is possible to determine the magnitude and phase of the impulses in a dynamic range of ˜5 orders of magnitude. This can be use as an estimation of the actual precision of the method. For the case used in the simulation, it covers more than 40 impulses. The impulse analysis of the transmission through the Output (peak) provides a characterization of the half round turn loss x the √{square root over (1-coupling excess loss)} of the SDCRR, which can be obtained from the relative value of two consecutive magnitude impulses.
Experimental Results:
The magnitude and phase (peak) transmission through the Output (peak) of a SDCRR have been obtained from a measurement of the transmission and time delay.
Applying the Cauchy integral to the experimental data of
The results are achieved by a similar iterative algorithm as described for the AWG, based on the basic formula (RR1) for the ring resonator.
First the product of the effective refractive index neff and the step size ΔLk of the RR, i.e. the effective index step increment of the RR is set to the free spectral range (FSR) of the RR. Then the phase distribution of the AWG is calculated from the imaginary part of the coefficients Ck.
In
The IFT method according to the invention has been also applied to the transmission of the Single Coupler Ring Resonator (SCRR). It is possible, in this case, to obtain the value of the excess loss of the coupler, the coupling efficiency, the round-trip loss and the optical length (L*neff) of the RR.
The IFT method according to the invention, which could be also called as a Fourier Spectroscopy Analysis provide a new way to characterize the basic parameters of optical components like AWG, resonator, filter etc. It is possible also to apply the IFT method to any design/optical component which can be described using the Z-transformation and provides a measurement of the coefficients of those Z-transformation.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5841919 | Akiba et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
6298186 | He | Oct 2001 | B1 |
6374013 | Whiteaway et al. | Apr 2002 | B1 |
6728442 | Missey et al. | Apr 2004 | B2 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20040098432 A1 | May 2004 | US |