Leakage-modeling adaptive noise canceling for earspeakers

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 9142205
  • Patent Number
    9,142,205
  • Date Filed
    Monday, December 3, 2012
    11 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 22, 2015
    8 years ago
Abstract
A personal audio device, such as a headphone, includes an adaptive noise canceling (ANC) circuit that adaptively generates an anti-noise signal from a reference microphone signal that measures the ambient audio, and the anti-noise signal is combined with source audio to provide an output for a speaker. The anti-noise signal causes cancellation of ambient audio sounds that appear at the reference microphone. A processing circuit uses the reference microphone to generate the anti-noise signal, which can be generated by an adaptive filter. The processing circuit also models an acoustic leakage path from the transducer to the reference microphone and removes elements of the source audio appearing at the reference microphone signal due to the acoustic output of the speaker. Another adaptive filter can be used to model the acoustic leakage path.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field of the Invention


The present invention relates generally to personal audio devices such as headphones that include adaptive noise cancellation (ANC), and, more specifically, to architectural features of an ANC system in which leakage from an earspeaker to the reference microphone is modeled.


2. Background of the Invention


Wireless telephones, such as mobile/cellular telephones, cordless telephones, and other consumer audio devices, such as MP3 players, are in widespread use. Performance of such devices with respect to intelligibility can be improved by providing noise canceling using a reference microphone to measure ambient acoustic events and then using signal processing to insert an anti-noise signal into the output of the device to cancel the ambient acoustic events.


When the acoustic path from the transducer to the reference microphone is not highly attenuative, for example when the transducer and reference microphone are included on an earspeaker, or when a telephone-mounted output transducer is not pressed to the user's ear, the ANC system will try to cancel the portion of the playback signal that arrives at the reference microphone.


Therefore, it would be desirable to provide a personal audio device, including a wireless telephone that provides noise cancellation that is effective and/or does not generate undesirable responses when leakage is present from the output transducer to the reference microphone.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The above stated objectives of providing a personal audio device having effective noise cancellation when leakage is present, is accomplished in a personal audio system, a method of operation, and an integrated circuit.


The personal audio device includes an output transducer for reproducing an audio signal that includes both source audio for playback to a listener, and an anti-noise signal for countering the effects of ambient audio sounds in an acoustic output of the transducer. The personal audio device also includes the integrated circuit to provide adaptive noise-canceling (ANC) functionality. The method is a method of operation of the personal audio system and integrated circuit. A reference microphone is mounted on the device housing to provide a reference microphone signal indicative of the ambient audio sounds. The personal audio system further includes an ANC processing circuit for adaptively generating an anti-noise signal from the reference microphone signal, such that the anti-noise signal causes substantial cancellation of the ambient audio sounds. An adaptive filter can be used to generate the anti-noise signal by filtering the reference microphone signal. The ANC processing circuit further models an acoustic leakage path from the acoustic output of the output transducer to the reference microphone, and removes elements of the acoustic output appearing at the reference microphone signal. The leakage path modeling may be performed by another adaptive filter.


The foregoing and other objectives, features, and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following, more particular, description of the preferred embodiment of the invention, as illustrated in the accompanying drawings.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1A is an illustration of a wireless telephone 10 coupled to an earbud EB, which is an example of a personal audio device in which the techniques disclosed herein can be implemented.



FIG. 1B is an illustration of electrical and acoustical signal paths in FIG. 1A.



FIG. 2 is a block diagram of circuits within wireless telephone 10 and/or earbud EB of FIG. 1A.



FIG. 3 is a block diagram depicting signal processing circuits and functional blocks within ANC circuit 30 of CODEC integrated circuit 20 of FIG. 2 in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention.



FIG. 4 is a block diagram depicting signal processing circuits and functional blocks within an integrated circuit in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention.





DESCRIPTION OF ILLUSTRATIVE EMBODIMENT

The present invention encompasses noise canceling techniques and circuits that can be implemented in a personal audio system, such as a wireless telephone and connected earbuds. The personal audio system includes an adaptive noise canceling (ANC) circuit that measures the ambient acoustic environment at the earbuds or other output transducer and generates a signal that is injected in the speaker (or other transducer) output to cancel ambient acoustic events. A reference microphone is provided to measure the ambient acoustic environment, which is used to generate an anti-noise signal provided to the speaker to cancel the ambient audio sounds. A model of a leakage path from the speaker output to the reference microphone input is also implemented by the ANC circuit so that the source audio and /or the anti-noise signal reproduced by the transducer can be removed from the reference microphone signal. The leakage path audio is implemented so that the ANC circuit does not try to adapt to and cancel the source audio and anti-noise signal, or otherwise become disrupted by leakage.



FIG. 1A shows a wireless telephone 10 proximity to a human ear 5. Illustrated wireless telephone 10 is an example of a device in which the techniques herein may be employed, but it is understood that not all of the elements or configurations illustrated in wireless telephone 10, or in the circuits depicted in subsequent illustrations, are required. Wireless telephone 10 is connected to an earbud EB by a wired or wireless connection, e.g., a BLUETOOTH™ connection (BLUETOOTH is a trademark or Bluetooth SIG, Inc.). Earbud EB has a transducer, such as speaker SPKR, which reproduces source audio including distant speech received from wireless telephone 10, ringtones, stored audio program material, and injection of near-end speech (i.e., the speech of the user of wireless telephone 10). The source audio also includes any other audio that wireless telephone 10 is required to reproduce, such as source audio from web-pages or other network communications received by wireless telephone 10 and audio indications such as battery low and other system event notifications. A reference microphone R is provided on a surface of a housing of earbud EB for measuring the ambient acoustic environment. Another microphone, error microphone E, is provided in order to further improve the ANC operation by providing a measure of the ambient audio combined with the audio reproduced by speaker SPKR close to ear 5, when earbud EB is inserted in the outer portion of ear 5. While the illustrated example shows an earspeaker implementation of a leakage path modeling noise canceling system, the techniques disclosed herein can also be implemented in a wireless telephone or other personal audio device, in which the output transducer and reference/error microphones are all provided on a housing of the wireless telephone or other personal audio device.


Wireless telephone 10 includes adaptive noise canceling (ANC) circuits and features that inject an anti-noise signal into speaker SPKR to improve intelligibility of the distant speech and other audio reproduced by speaker SPKR. Exemplary circuit 14 within wireless telephone 10 includes an audio CODEC integrated circuit 20 that receives the signals from reference microphone R, near speech microphone NS, and error microphone E and interfaces with other integrated circuits such as an RF integrated circuit 12 containing the wireless telephone transceiver. In other embodiments of the invention, the circuits and techniques disclosed herein may be incorporated in a single integrated circuit that contains control circuits and other functionality for implementing the entirety of the personal audio device, such as an MP3 player-on-a-chip integrated circuit. Alternatively, the ANC circuits may be included within a housing of earbud EB or in a module located along a wired connection between wireless telephone 10 and earbud EB. For the purposes of illustration, the ANC circuits will be described as provided within wireless telephone 10, but the above variations are understandable by a person of ordinary skill in the art and the consequent signals that are required between earbud EB, wireless telephone 10 and a third module, if required, can be easily determined for those variations. A near-speech microphone NS is provided at a housing of wireless telephone 10 to capture near-end speech, which is transmitted from wireless telephone 10 to the other conversation participant(s). Alternatively, near-speech microphone NS may be provided on the outer surface of a housing of earbud EB, or on a boom affixed to earbud EB.



FIG. 1B shows a simplified schematic diagram of an audio CODEC integrated circuit 20 that includes ANC processing, as coupled to reference microphone R, which provides a measurement of ambient audio sounds Ambient that is filtered by the ANC processing circuits within audio CODEC integrated circuit 20. Audio CODEC integrated circuit 20 generates an output that is amplified by an amplifier Al and is provided to speaker SPKR. Audio CODEC integrated circuit 20 receives the signals (wired or wireless depending on the particular configuration) from reference microphone R, near speech microphone NS and error microphone E and interfaces with other integrated circuits such as an RF integrated circuit 12 containing the wireless telephone transceiver. In other configurations, the circuits and techniques disclosed herein may be incorporated in a single integrated circuit that contains control circuits and other functionality for implementing the entirety of the personal audio device, such as an MP3 player-on-a-chip integrated circuit. Alternatively, multiple integrated circuits may be used, for example, when a wireless connection is provided from earbud EB to wireless telephone 10 and/or when some or all of the ANC processing is performed within earbud EB or a module disposed along a cable connecting wireless telephone 10 to earbud EB.


In general, the ANC techniques illustrated herein measure ambient acoustic events (as opposed to the output of speaker SPKR and/or the near-end speech) impinging on reference microphone R, and also measure the same ambient acoustic events impinging on error microphone E. The ANC processing circuits of illustrated wireless telephone 10 adapt an anti-noise signal generated from the output of reference microphone R to have a characteristic that minimizes the amplitude of the ambient acoustic events at error microphone E. Since acoustic path P(z) extends from reference microphone R to error microphone E, the ANC circuits are essentially estimating acoustic path P(z) combined with removing effects of an electro-acoustic path S(z) that represents the response of the audio output circuits of CODEC IC 20 and the acoustic/electric transfer function of speaker SPKR. The estimated response includes the coupling between speaker SPKR and error microphone E in the particular acoustic environment which is affected by the proximity and structure of ear 5 and other physical objects and human head structures that may be in proximity to earbud EB. Leakage, i.e., acoustic coupling, between speaker SPKR and reference microphone R can cause error in the anti-noise signal generated by the ANC circuits within CODEC IC 20. In particular, desired downlink speech and other internal audio intended for reproduction by speaker SPKR can be partially canceled due to the leakage path L(z) between speaker SPKR and reference microphone R. Since audio measured by reference microphone R is considered to be ambient audio that generally should be canceled, leakage path L(z) represents the portion of the downlink speech and other internal audio that is present in the reference microphone signal and causes the above-described erroneous operation. Therefore, the ANC circuits within CODEC IC 20 include leakage-path modeling circuits that compensate for the presence of leakage path L(z). While the illustrated wireless telephone 10 includes a two microphone ANC system with a third near speech microphone NS, a system may be constructed that does not include separate error and reference microphones. Alternatively, when near speech microphone NS is located proximate to speaker SPKR and error microphone E, near-speech microphone NS may be used to perform the function of the reference microphone R. Also, in personal audio devices designed only for audio playback, near speech microphone NS will generally not be included, and the near-speech signal paths in the circuits described in further detail below can be omitted.


Referring now to FIG. 2, circuits within wireless telephone 10 are shown in a block diagram. The circuit shown in FIG. 2 further applies to the other configurations mentioned above, except that signaling between CODEC integrated circuit 20 and other units within wireless telephone 10 are provided by cables or wireless connections when CODEC integrated circuit 20 is located outside of wireless telephone 10. In such a configuration, signaling between CODEC integrated circuit 20 and error microphone E, reference microphone R and speaker SPKR are provided by wired or wireless connections when CODEC integrated circuit 20 is located within wireless telephone 10. CODEC integrated circuit 20 includes an analog-to-digital converter (ADC) 21A for receiving the reference microphone signal and generating a digital representation ref of the reference microphone signal. CODEC integrated circuit 20 also includes an ADC 21B for receiving the error microphone signal and generating a digital representation err of the error microphone signal, and an ADC 21C for receiving the near speech microphone signal and generating a digital representation ns of the error microphone signal. CODEC IC 20 generates an output for driving speaker SPKR from an amplifier A1, which amplifies the output of a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) 23 that receives the output of a combiner 26. Combiner 26 combines audio signals is from internal audio sources 24, and the anti-noise signal anti-noise generated by ANC circuit 30, which by convention has the same polarity as the noise in reference microphone signal ref and is therefore subtracted by combiner 26. Combiner 26 also combines an attenuated portion of near speech signal ns, i.e., sidetone information st, so that the user of wireless telephone 10 hears their own voice in proper relation to downlink speech ds, which is received from radio frequency (RF) integrated circuit 22. Near speech signal ns is also provided to RF integrated circuit 22 and is transmitted as uplink speech to the service provider via antenna ANT.


Referring now to FIG. 3, details of ANC circuit 30 are shown. A combiner 36A removes an estimated leakage signal, which in the example is provided by a leakage-path adaptive filter 38 that models leakage path L(z), but which may be provided by a fixed filter in other configurations. Combiner 36A generates a leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref. An adaptive filter 32 receives leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref′ and under ideal circumstances, adapts its transfer function W(z) to be P(z)/S(z) to generate the anti-noise signal anti-noise, which is provided to an output combiner that combines the anti-noise signal with the audio to be reproduced by speaker SPKR, as exemplified by combiner 26 of FIG. 2. The coefficients of adaptive filter 32 are controlled by a W coefficient control block 31 that uses a correlation of two signals to determine the response of adaptive filter 32, which generally minimizes the error, in a least-mean squares sense, between those components of leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref′ present in error microphone signal err. The signals processed by W coefficient control block 31 are the leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref′ shaped by a copy of an estimate of the response of path S(z) (i.e., response SECOPY(z)) provided by filter 34B and another signal that includes error microphone signal err. By transforming leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref with a copy of the estimate of the response of path S(z), response SECOPY(z), and minimizing error microphone signal err after removing components of error microphone signal err due to playback of source audio, adaptive filter 32 adapts to the desired response of P(z)/S(z).


In addition to error microphone signal err, the other signal processed along with the output of filter 34B by W coefficient control block 31 includes an inverted amount of the source audio including downlink audio signal ds, internal audio ia, and a portion of near speech signal ns attenuated by a side tone attenuator 37, which is provided from a combiner 36B. The output of combiner 36B is processed by a filter 34A having response SE(z), of which response SECOPY(z) is a copy. By injecting an inverted amount of source audio and sidetone that has been filtered by response SE(z), adaptive filter 32 is prevented from adapting to the relatively large amount of source audio and the sidetone information (along with extra ambient noise information in the sidetone) present in error microphone signal err. By transforming the inverted copy of downlink audio signal ds and internal audio ia with the estimate of the response of path S(z), the source audio and sidetone that is removed from error microphone signal err before processing should match the expected version of downlink audio signal ds and internal audio ia reproduced at error microphone signal err. The source audio and sidetone amounts match because the electrical and acoustical path of S(z) is the path taken by downlink audio signal ds, internal audio ia and sidetone information to arrive at error microphone E. Filter 34B is not an adaptive filter, per se, but has an adjustable response that is tuned to match the response of adaptive filter 34A, so that the response of filter 34B tracks the adapting of adaptive filter 34A.


To implement the above, adaptive filter 34A has coefficients controlled by SE coefficient control block 33. Adaptive filter 34A processes the source audio (ds+ia) and sidetone information, to provide a signal representing the expected source audio delivered to error microphone E. Adaptive filter 34A is thereby adapted to generate a signal from downlink audio signal ds, internal audio is and sidetone information st, that when subtracted from error microphone signal err, forms an error signal e containing the content of error microphone signal err that is not due to source audio (ds+ia) and the sidetone information st. A combiner 36C removes the filtered source audio (ds+ia) and sidetone information from error microphone signal err to generate the above-described error signal e. Similarly, leakage path adaptive filter 38 processes the source audio (ds+ia) and sidetone information, to provide a signal representing the source audio delivered to reference microphone R through leakage path L(z). Leakage path adaptive filter 38 has coefficients controlled by LE coefficient control block 39 that also receives source audio (ds+ia) and the sidetone information and controls leakage path adaptive filter 38 to pass those components of source audio (ds+ia) and the sidetone information appearing in leakage-corrected reference microphone signal ref, so that those components are minimized at the input to adaptive filter 32. Alternatively, the sidetone information may be omitted from the signal introduced into leakage path adaptive filter 38. In a calibration mode, the error microphone signal and the reference microphone signal are exchanged. In the calibration mode, the processing circuit models the acoustic leakage path by removing the source audio from the reference microphone signal to provide the error signal, and the processing circuit generates the anti-noise signal from the error microphone signal. During calibration, coefficients of the secondary path adaptive filter are captured to provide coefficients of the leakage path adaptive filter that are subsequently applied in the normal operating mode.


Referring now to FIG. 4, a block diagram of an ANC system is shown for implementing ANC techniques as depicted in FIG. 3, and having a processing circuit 40 as may be implemented within CODEC integrated circuit 20 of FIG. 2. Processing circuit 40 includes a processor core 42 coupled to a memory 44 in which are stored program instructions comprising a computer-program product that may implement some or all of the above-described ANC techniques, as well as other signal processing. Optionally, a dedicated digital signal processing (DSP) logic 46 may be provided to implement a portion of, or alternatively all of, the ANC signal processing provided by processing circuit 40. Processing circuit 40 also includes ADCs 21A-21C, for receiving inputs from reference microphone R, error microphone E and near speech microphone NS, respectively. In alternative embodiments in which one or more of reference microphone R, error microphone E and near speech microphone NS have digital outputs, the corresponding ones of ADCs 21A-21C are omitted and the digital microphone signal(s) are interfaced directly to processing circuit 40. DAC 23 and amplifier Al are also provided by processing circuit 40 for providing the speaker output signal, including anti-noise as described above. The speaker output signal may be a digital output signal for provision to a module that reproduces the digital output signal acoustically.


While the invention has been particularly shown and described with reference to the preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that the foregoing and other changes in form, and details may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.

Claims
  • 1. An integrated circuit for implementing at least a portion of a personal audio device, comprising: an output for providing an output signal to an output transducer including an anti-noise signal for countering the effects of ambient audio sounds in an acoustic output of the output transducer and source audio for playback to a listener;a reference microphone input for receiving a reference microphone signal indicative of the ambient audio sounds;an error microphone input for receiving an error microphone signal indicative of the acoustic output of the output transducer and the ambient audio sounds at the output transducer; anda processing circuit that adaptively generates the anti-noise signal from a corrected reference microphone signal and in conformity with the error microphone signal such that the anti-noise signal causes substantial cancellation of the ambient audio sounds, wherein the processing circuit combines the anti-noise signal with a source audio signal to generate the output signal, wherein the processing circuit further models an acoustic leakage path from the output transducer to the reference microphone with an adaptive filter that filters the source audio signal to generate filtered source audio and removes the filtered source audio from the reference microphone signal to generate the corrected reference microphone signal.
  • 2. The integrated circuit of claim 1, wherein the processing circuit models the acoustic leakage path by providing source audio of a predetermined characteristic as the audio signal reproduced by the output transducer and measuring a resulting response in the reference microphone signal.
  • 3. The personal audio device of claim 2, wherein the source audio of predetermined characteristic is a noise burst.
  • 4. The integrated circuit of claim 1, wherein the processing circuit comprises an adaptive filter having a response that shapes the anti-noise signal to reduce the presence of the ambient audio sounds heard by the listener and another leakage path adaptive filter that models the acoustic leakage path dynamically.
  • 5. The integrated circuit of claim 4, wherein the processing circuit comprises a secondary path adaptive filter having a secondary path response that shapes the source audio and a combiner that, in a normal operating mode, removes the source audio from the error microphone signal to provide the error signal, wherein the processing circuit generates the anti-noise signal in conformity with the error signal, wherein, in a calibration mode, the processing circuit models the acoustic leakage path by removing the source audio from the reference microphone signal to provide the error signal, wherein also in the calibration mode, the processing circuit generates the anti-noise signal from the error microphone signal, and wherein coefficients of the secondary path adaptive filter are captured during the calibration mode to provide coefficients of the leakage path adaptive filter that are subsequently applied in the normal operating mode.
  • 6. The integrated circuit of claim 4, wherein adaptation of the leakage path adaptive filter is performed continuously except when a ratio of an amplitude of the source audio to an amplitude of the ambient audio sounds is less than a predetermined threshold.
  • 7. The integrated circuit of claim 4, wherein the processing circuit determines that modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and, responsive to determining that the modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and determining that an amplitude of the source audio is greater than a threshold, halts adaptation of the adaptive filter that generates the anti-noise signal.
  • 8. The integrated circuit of claim 4, wherein the processing circuit provides the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 9. The integrated circuit of claim 4, wherein the source audio includes sidetone information generated from a near speech microphone.
  • 10. The integrated circuit of claim 9, wherein the processing circuit provides the sidetone information combined with the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 11. A method of countering effects of ambient audio sounds by a personal audio device, the method comprising: first measuring ambient audio sounds with a reference microphone to produce a reference microphone signal;second measuring an output of the transducer and the ambient audio sounds at the transducer with an error microphone;adaptively generating an anti-noise signal from a corrected reference microphone signal in conformity with a result of the second measuring for countering the effects of ambient audio sounds in an acoustic output of a transducer;providing the anti-noise signal to the transducer;combining the anti-noise signal with a source audio signal to generate the output signal;modeling an acoustic leakage path from the output transducer to the reference microphone with an adaptive filter that filters the source audio signal to generate filtered source audio; andremoving the filtered source audio from the reference microphone signal to generate the corrected reference microphone signal.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, wherein the modeling of the acoustic leakage path comprises: providing source audio of predetermined characteristic as a portion of an audio signal reproduced by the output transducer; andmeasuring a resulting response to the providing in the reference microphone signal.
  • 13. The method of claim 12, wherein the source audio of predetermined characteristic is a noise burst.
  • 14. The method of claim 11, further comprising: shaping the anti-noise with an adaptive filter to reduce the presence of the ambient audio sounds heard by the listener; andmodeling the acoustic leakage path dynamically with a leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 15. The method of claim 14, further comprising: in a normal operating mode, removing the source audio from the error microphone signal to generate the error signal and modeling the acoustic leakage path by removing the source audio from the reference microphone signal to provide an error signal, wherein the adaptively generating generates the anti-noise signal in conformity with the error signal;in a calibration mode, removing the source audio from the reference microphone signal, generating the anti-noise signal from the error microphone signal, and capturing coefficients of the secondary path adaptive filter to provide coefficients of the leakage path adaptive filter; andin the normal operating mode, subsequently applying the captured coefficients in the modeling of the acoustic leakage path by the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 16. The method of claim 14, wherein the modeling of the acoustic leakage path adapts the leakage path adaptive filter continuously except when a ratio of an amplitude of the source audio to an amplitude of the ambient audio sounds is less than a predetermined threshold.
  • 17. The method of claim 14, wherein the determining comprises modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and, responsive to the determining that the modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and determining that an amplitude of the source audio is greater than a threshold, halting adaptation of the adaptive filter that generates the anti-noise signal.
  • 18. The method of claim 14, further comprising providing the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 19. The method of claim 14, wherein the source audio includes sidetone information generated from a near speech microphone.
  • 20. The method of claim 19, further comprising providing the sidetone information combined with the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 21. A personal audio device, comprising: a personal audio device housing;a transducer mounted on the housing for reproducing an audio signal including an anti-noise signal for countering effects of ambient audio sounds in an acoustic output of the output transducer and source audio for playback to a listener;a reference microphone mounted on the housing for providing a reference microphone signal indicative of the ambient audio sounds;an error microphone mounted on the housing in proximity to the transducer for providing an error microphone signal indicative of the acoustic output of the transducer and the ambient audio sounds at the transducer; anda processing circuit within the housing that adaptively generates the anti-noise signal from a corrected reference microphone signal and in conformity with the error microphone signal such that the anti-noise signal causes substantial cancellation of the ambient audio sounds, wherein the processing circuit combines the anti-noise signal with a source audio signal to generate the output signal, wherein the processing circuit further models an acoustic leakage path from the output transducer to the reference microphone with an adaptive filter that filters the source audio signal to generate filtered source audio and removes the filtered source audio from the reference microphone signal to generate the corrected reference microphone signal.
  • 22. The personal audio device of claim 21, wherein the processing circuit models the acoustic leakage path by providing source audio of a predetermined characteristic as the audio signal reproduced by the output transducer and measuring a resulting response in the reference microphone signal.
  • 23. The personal audio device of claim 22, wherein the source audio of predetermined characteristic is a noise burst.
  • 24. The personal audio device of claim 22, wherein the processing circuit comprises an adaptive filter having a response that shapes the anti-noise signal to reduce the presence of the ambient audio sounds heard by the listener and another leakage path adaptive filter that models the acoustic leakage path dynamically.
  • 25. The personal audio device of claim 24, wherein the processing circuit comprises a secondary path adaptive filter having a secondary path response that shapes the source audio and a combiner that, in a normal operating mode, removes the source audio from the error microphone signal to provide the error signal, wherein, in a calibration mode, the processing circuit models the acoustic leakage path by removing the source audio from the reference microphone signal to provide the error signal, wherein also in the calibration mode, the processing circuit generates the anti-noise signal from the error microphone signal, wherein the processing circuit generates the anti-noise signal in conformity with the error signal, and wherein coefficients of the secondary path adaptive filter are captured during the calibration mode to provide coefficients of the leakage path adaptive filter that are subsequently applied in the normal operating mode.
  • 26. The personal audio device of claim 24, wherein adaptation of the leakage path is performed continuously except when a ratio of an amplitude of the source audio to an amplitude of the ambient audio sounds is less than a predetermined threshold.
  • 27. The personal audio device of claim 24, wherein the processing circuit determines that modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and, responsive to determining that the modeling of the acoustic leakage path is ineffective and determining that an amplitude of the source audio is greater than a threshold, halts adaptation of the adaptive filter that generates the anti-noise signal.
  • 28. The personal audio device of claim 24, wherein the processing circuit provides the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
  • 29. The personal audio device of claim 24, wherein the source audio includes sidetone information generated from a near speech microphone mounted on the housing.
  • 30. The personal audio device of claim 29, wherein the processing circuit provides the sidetone information combined with the source audio to a filter input of the leakage path adaptive filter.
Parent Case Info

This U.S. Patent Application claims priority under 35 U.S.C. 119(e) to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/638,602 filed on Apr. 26, 2012.

US Referenced Citations (185)
Number Name Date Kind
5251263 Andrea et al. Oct 1993 A
5278913 Delfosse et al. Jan 1994 A
5321759 Yuan Jun 1994 A
5337365 Hamabe et al. Aug 1994 A
5359662 Yuan et al. Oct 1994 A
5410605 Sawada et al. Apr 1995 A
5425105 Lo et al. Jun 1995 A
5445517 Kondou et al. Aug 1995 A
5465413 Enge et al. Nov 1995 A
5548681 Gleaves et al. Aug 1996 A
5586190 Trantow et al. Dec 1996 A
5640450 Watanabe Jun 1997 A
5699437 Finn Dec 1997 A
5706344 Finn Jan 1998 A
5740256 Castello Da Costa et al. Apr 1998 A
5768124 Stothers et al. Jun 1998 A
5815582 Claybaugh et al. Sep 1998 A
5832095 Daniels Nov 1998 A
5946391 Dragwidge et al. Aug 1999 A
5991418 Kuo Nov 1999 A
6041126 Terai et al. Mar 2000 A
6118878 Jones Sep 2000 A
6219427 Kates et al. Apr 2001 B1
6278786 McIntosh Aug 2001 B1
6282176 Hemkumar Aug 2001 B1
6418228 Terai et al. Jul 2002 B1
6434246 Kates et al. Aug 2002 B1
6434247 Kates et al. Aug 2002 B1
6522746 Marchok et al. Feb 2003 B1
6683960 Fujii et al. Jan 2004 B1
6766292 Chandran Jul 2004 B1
6768795 Feltstrom et al. Jul 2004 B2
6850617 Weigand Feb 2005 B1
6940982 Watkins Sep 2005 B1
7058463 Ruha et al. Jun 2006 B1
7103188 Jones Sep 2006 B1
7181030 Rasmussen et al. Feb 2007 B2
7330739 Somayajula Feb 2008 B2
7365669 Melanson Apr 2008 B1
7680456 Muhammad et al. Mar 2010 B2
7742790 Konchitsky et al. Jun 2010 B2
7817808 Konchitsky et al. Oct 2010 B2
8019050 Mactavish et al. Sep 2011 B2
8249262 Chua et al. Aug 2012 B2
8290537 Lee et al. Oct 2012 B2
8325934 Kuo Dec 2012 B2
8379884 Horibe et al. Feb 2013 B2
8401200 Tiscareno et al. Mar 2013 B2
8442251 Jensen et al. May 2013 B2
8737636 Park et al. May 2014 B2
8908877 Abdollahzadeh Milani et al. Dec 2014 B2
20010053228 Jones Dec 2001 A1
20020003887 Zhang et al. Jan 2002 A1
20030063759 Brennan et al. Apr 2003 A1
20030185403 Sibbald Oct 2003 A1
20040047464 Yu et al. Mar 2004 A1
20040165736 Hetherington et al. Aug 2004 A1
20040167777 Hetherington et al. Aug 2004 A1
20040202333 Csermak et al. Oct 2004 A1
20040264706 Ray et al. Dec 2004 A1
20050004796 Trump et al. Jan 2005 A1
20050018862 Fisher Jan 2005 A1
20050117754 Sakawaki Jun 2005 A1
20050207585 Christoph Sep 2005 A1
20050240401 Ebenezer Oct 2005 A1
20060035593 Leeds Feb 2006 A1
20060069556 Nadjar et al. Mar 2006 A1
20060153400 Fujita et al. Jul 2006 A1
20070030989 Kates Feb 2007 A1
20070033029 Sakawaki Feb 2007 A1
20070038441 Inoue et al. Feb 2007 A1
20070053524 Haulick et al. Mar 2007 A1
20070076896 Hosaka et al. Apr 2007 A1
20070154031 Avendano et al. Jul 2007 A1
20070258597 Rasmussen et al. Nov 2007 A1
20070297620 Choy Dec 2007 A1
20080019548 Avendano Jan 2008 A1
20080107281 Togami et al. May 2008 A1
20080144853 Sommerfeldt et al. Jun 2008 A1
20080177532 Greiss et al. Jul 2008 A1
20080181422 Christoph Jul 2008 A1
20080226098 Haulick et al. Sep 2008 A1
20080240455 Inoue et al. Oct 2008 A1
20080240457 Inoue et al. Oct 2008 A1
20090012783 Klein Jan 2009 A1
20090034748 Sibbald Feb 2009 A1
20090041260 Jorgensen et al. Feb 2009 A1
20090046867 Clemow Feb 2009 A1
20090060222 Jeong et al. Mar 2009 A1
20090080670 Solbeck et al. Mar 2009 A1
20090086990 Christoph Apr 2009 A1
20090175466 Elko et al. Jul 2009 A1
20090196429 Ramakrishnan et al. Aug 2009 A1
20090220107 Every et al. Sep 2009 A1
20090238369 Ramakrishnan et al. Sep 2009 A1
20090245529 Asada et al. Oct 2009 A1
20090254340 Sun et al. Oct 2009 A1
20090290718 Kahn et al. Nov 2009 A1
20090296965 Kojima Dec 2009 A1
20090304200 Kim et al. Dec 2009 A1
20090311979 Husted et al. Dec 2009 A1
20100014683 Maeda et al. Jan 2010 A1
20100014685 Wurm Jan 2010 A1
20100061564 Clemow et al. Mar 2010 A1
20100069114 Lee et al. Mar 2010 A1
20100082339 Konchitsky et al. Apr 2010 A1
20100098263 Pan et al. Apr 2010 A1
20100098265 Pan et al. Apr 2010 A1
20100124336 Shridhar et al. May 2010 A1
20100124337 Wertz et al. May 2010 A1
20100131269 Park et al. May 2010 A1
20100150367 Mizuno Jun 2010 A1
20100158330 Guissin et al. Jun 2010 A1
20100166203 Peissig et al. Jul 2010 A1
20100195838 Bright Aug 2010 A1
20100195844 Christoph et al. Aug 2010 A1
20100207317 Iwami et al. Aug 2010 A1
20100246855 Chen Sep 2010 A1
20100272276 Carreras et al. Oct 2010 A1
20100272283 Carreras et al. Oct 2010 A1
20100274564 Bakalos et al. Oct 2010 A1
20100284546 Debrunner et al. Nov 2010 A1
20100291891 Ridgers et al. Nov 2010 A1
20100296666 Lin Nov 2010 A1
20100296668 Lee et al. Nov 2010 A1
20100310086 Magrath et al. Dec 2010 A1
20100322430 Isberg Dec 2010 A1
20110007907 Park et al. Jan 2011 A1
20110026724 Doclo Feb 2011 A1
20110106533 Yu May 2011 A1
20110129098 Delano et al. Jun 2011 A1
20110130176 Magrath et al. Jun 2011 A1
20110142247 Fellers et al. Jun 2011 A1
20110144984 Konchitsky Jun 2011 A1
20110158419 Theverapperuma et al. Jun 2011 A1
20110206214 Christoph et al. Aug 2011 A1
20110222698 Asao et al. Sep 2011 A1
20110249826 Van Leest Oct 2011 A1
20110288860 Schevciw et al. Nov 2011 A1
20110293103 Park et al. Dec 2011 A1
20110299695 Nicholson Dec 2011 A1
20110305347 Wurm Dec 2011 A1
20110317848 Ivanov et al. Dec 2011 A1
20120135787 Kusunoki et al. May 2012 A1
20120140917 Nicholson et al. Jun 2012 A1
20120140942 Loeda Jun 2012 A1
20120140943 Hendrix et al. Jun 2012 A1
20120148062 Scarlett et al. Jun 2012 A1
20120155666 Nair Jun 2012 A1
20120170766 Alves et al. Jul 2012 A1
20120207317 Abdollahzadeh Milani et al. Aug 2012 A1
20120215519 Park et al. Aug 2012 A1
20120250873 Bakalos et al. Oct 2012 A1
20120259626 Li et al. Oct 2012 A1
20120263317 Shin et al. Oct 2012 A1
20120300958 Klemmensen Nov 2012 A1
20120300960 Mackay et al. Nov 2012 A1
20120308021 Kwatra et al. Dec 2012 A1
20120308024 Alderson et al. Dec 2012 A1
20120308025 Hendrix et al. Dec 2012 A1
20120308026 Kamath et al. Dec 2012 A1
20120308027 Kwatra Dec 2012 A1
20120308028 Kwatra et al. Dec 2012 A1
20120310640 Kwatra et al. Dec 2012 A1
20130010982 Elko et al. Jan 2013 A1
20130083939 Fellers et al. Apr 2013 A1
20130243225 Yokota Sep 2013 A1
20130272539 Kim et al. Oct 2013 A1
20130287219 Hendrix et al. Oct 2013 A1
20130301842 Hendrix et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130301846 Alderson et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130301847 Alderson et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130301848 Zhou et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130301849 Alderson et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130343556 Bright Dec 2013 A1
20130343571 Rayala et al. Dec 2013 A1
20140044275 Goldstein et al. Feb 2014 A1
20140050332 Nielsen et al. Feb 2014 A1
20140086425 Jensen et al. Mar 2014 A1
20140177851 Kitazawa et al. Jun 2014 A1
20140211953 Alderson et al. Jul 2014 A1
20140270222 Hendrix et al. Sep 2014 A1
20140270223 Li et al. Sep 2014 A1
20140270224 Zhou et al. Sep 2014 A1
20150092953 Abdollahzadeh Milani et al. Apr 2015 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (21)
Number Date Country
102011013343 Sep 2012 DE
1880699 Jan 2008 EP
1947642 Jul 2008 EP
2133866 Dec 2009 EP
2216774 Aug 2010 EP
2395500 Dec 2011 EP
2395501 Dec 2011 EP
2401744 Nov 2004 GB
2455821 Jun 2009 GB
2455824 Jun 2009 GB
2455828 Jun 2009 GB
2484722 Apr 2012 GB
H06-186985 Jul 1994 JP
WO 03015074 Feb 2003 WO
WO 03015275 Feb 2003 WO
WO 2004009007 Jan 2004 WO
WO 2004017303 Feb 2004 WO
WO 2007007916 Jan 2007 WO
WO 2007113487 Nov 2007 WO
WO 2010117714 Oct 2010 WO
WO 2012134874 Oct 2012 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (67)
Entry
U.S. Appl. No. 14/228,322, filed Mar. 28, 2014, Alderson, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/762,504, filed Feb. 8, 2013, Abdollahzadeh Milani, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/721,832, filed Dec. 20, 2012, Lu, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/724,656, filed Dec. 21, 2012, Lu, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/252,235, filed Apr. 14, 2014, Lu, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/968,013, filed Aug. 15, 2013, Abdollahzadeh Milani, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/924,935, filed Jun. 24, 2013, Hellman.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/896,526, filed May 17, 2013, Naderi.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/101,955, filed Dec. 10, 2013, Alderson.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/101,777, filed Dec. 10, 2013, Alderson et al.
Abdollahzadeh Milani, et al., “On Maximum Achievable Noise Reduction in ANC Systems”,2010 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics Speech and Signal Processing, Mar. 14-19, 2010, pp. 349-352, Dallas, TX, US.
Cohen, Israel, “Noise Spectrum Estimation in Adverse Environments: Improved Minima Controlled Recursive Averaging”, IEEE Transactions on Speech and Audio Processing, Sep. 2003, pp. 1-11, vol. 11, Issue 5, Piscataway, NJ, US.
Ryan, et al., “Optimum Near-Field Performance of Microphone Arrays Subject to a Far-Field Beampattern Constraint”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am., Nov. 2000, pp. 2248-2255, 108 (5), Pt. 1, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Cohen, et al., “Noise Estimation by Minima Controlled Recursive Averaging for Robust Speech Enhancement”, IEEE Signal Processing Letters, Jan. 2002, pp. 12-15, vol. 9, No. 1, Piscataway, NJ, US.
Martin, Rainer, “Noise Power Spectral Density Estimation Based on Optimal Smoothing and Minimum Statistics”, IEEE Transactions on Speech and Audio Processing, Jul. 2001, pp. 504-512, vol. 9, No. 5, Piscataway, NJ, US.
Martin, Rainer, “Spectral Subtraction Based on Minimum Statistics”, Signal Processing VII Theories and Applications, Proceedings of EUSIPCO-94, 7th European Signal Processing Conference, Sep. 13-16, 1994, pp. 1182-1185, vol. III, Edinburgh, Scotland, U.K.
Booij, et al., “Virtual sensors for local, three dimensional, broadband multiple-channel active noise control and the effects on the quiet zones”, Proceedings of the International Conference on Noise and Vibration Engineering, ISMA 2010, Sep. 20-22, 2010, pp. 151-166, Leuven.
Kuo, et al., “Residual noise shaping technique for active noise control systems”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 95 (3), Mar. 1994, pp. 1665-1668.
Lopez-Caudana, Edgar Omar, “Active Noise Cancellation: The Unwanted Signal and the Hybrid Solution”, Adaptive Filtering Applications, Dr. Lino Garcia (Ed.), Jul. 2011, pp. 49-84, ISBN: 978-953-307-306-4, InTech.
Senderowicz, et al., “Low-Voltage Double-Sampled Delta-Sigma Converters”, IEEE Journal on Solid-State Circuits, Dec. 1997, pp. 1907-1919, vol. 32, No. 12, Piscataway, NJ.
Hurst, et al., “An improved double sampling scheme for switched-capacitor delta-sigma modulators”, 1992 IEEE Int. Symp. on Circuits and Systems, May 10-13, 1992, vol. 3, pp. 1179-1182, San Diego, CA.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/686,353, filed Nov. 27, 2012, Hendrix, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/795,160, filed Mar. 12, 2013, Hendrix, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/722,119, filed Dec. 20, 2012, Hendrix, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/727,718, filed Dec. 27, 2012, Alderson, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/784,018, filed Mar. 4, 2013, Alderson, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/787,906, filed Mar. 7, 2013, Alderson, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/729,141, filed Dec. 28, 2012, Zhou, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/794,931, filed Mar. 12, 2013, Lu, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/794,979, filed Mar. 12, 2013, Alderson, et al.
Pfann, et al., “LMS Adaptive Filtering with Delta-Sigma Modulated Input Signals,” IEEE Signal Processing Letters, Apr. 1998, pp. 95-97, vol. 5, No. 4, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Toochinda, et al. “A Single-Input Two-Output Feedback Formulation for ANC Problems,” Proceedings of the 2001 American Control Conference, Jun. 2001, pp. 923-928, vol. 2, Arlington, VA.
Kuo, et al., “Active Noise Control: A Tutorial Review,” Proceedings of the IEEE, Jun. 1999, pp. 943-973, vol. 87, No. 6, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Johns, et al., “Continuous-Time LMS Adaptive Recursive Filters,” IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems, Jul. 1991, pp. 769-778, vol. 38, No. 7, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Shoval, et al., “Comparison of DC Offset Effects in Four LMS Adaptive Algorithms,” IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems II: Analog and Digital Processing, Mar. 1995, pp. 176-185, vol. 42, Issue 3, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Mali, Dilip, “Comparison of DC Offset Effects on LMS Algorithm and its Derivatives,” International Journal of Recent Trends in Engineering, May 2009, pp. 323-328, vol. 1, No. 1, Academy Publisher.
Kates, James M., “Principles of Digital Dynamic Range Compression,” Trends in Amplification, Spring 2005, pp. 45-76, vol. 9, No. 2, Sage Publications.
Gao, et al., “Adaptive Linearization of a Loudspeaker,” IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, Apr. 14-17, 1991, pp. 3589-3592, Toronto, Ontario, CA.
Silva, et al., “Convex Combination of Adaptive Filters With Different Tracking Capabilities,” IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, Apr. 15-20, 2007, pp. III 925-III 928, vol. 3, Honolulu, HI, USA.
Akhtar, et al., “A Method for Online Secondary Path Modeling in Active Noise Control Systems,” IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems, May 23-26, 2005, pp. 264-267, vol. 1, Kobe, Japan.
Davari, et al., “A New Online Secondary Path Modeling Method for Feedforward Active Noise Control Systems,” IEEE International Conference on Industrial Technology, Apr. 21-24, 2008, pp. 1-6, Chengdu, China.
Lan, et al., “An Active Noise Control System Using Online Secondary Path Modeling With Reduced Auxiliary Noise,” IEEE Signal Processing Letters, Jan. 2002, pp. 16-18, vol. 9, Issue 1, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Liu, et al., “Analysis of Online Secondary Path Modeling With Auxiliary Noise Scaled by Residual Noise Signal,” IEEE Transactions on Audio, Speech and Language Processing, Nov. 2010, pp. 1978-1993, vol. 18, Issue 8, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
Campbell, Mikey, “Apple looking into self-adjusting earbud headphones with noise cancellation tech”, Apple Insider, Jul. 4, 2013, pp. 1-10 (10 pages in pdf), downloaded on May 14, 2014 from http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/07/04/apple-looking-into-self-adjusting-earbud-headphones-with-noise-cancellation-tech.
Jin, et al. “A simultaneous equation method-based online secondary path modeling algorithm for active noise control”, Journal of Sound and Vibration, Apr. 25, 2007, pp. 455-474, vol. 303, No. 3-5, London, GB.
Erkelens, et al., “Tracking of Nonstationary Noise Based on Data-Driven Recursive Noise Power Estimation”, IEEE Transactions on Audio Speech and Language Processing, Aug. 2008, pp. 1112-1123, vol. 16, No. 6, Piscataway, NJ, US.
Rao, et al., “A Novel Two State Single Channel Speech Enhancement Technique”, India Conference (INDICON) 2011 Annual IEEE, IEEE, Dec. 2011, 6 pages (pp. 1-6 in pdf), Piscataway, NJ, US.
Rangachari, et al., “A noise-estimation algorithm for highly non-stationary environments”, Speech Communication, Feb. 2006, pp. 220-231, vol. 48, No. 2. Elsevier Science Publishers.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/968,007, filed Aug. 15, 2013, Hendrix, et al.
Parkins, et al., “Narrowband and broadband active control in an enclosure using the acoustic energy density”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Jul. 2000, pp. 192-203, vol. 108, issue 1, US.
Feng, et al.., “A broadband self-tuning active noise equaliser”, Signal Processing, Oct. 1, 1997, pp. 251-256, vol. 62, No. 2, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. Amsterdam, NL.
Zhang, et al., “A Robust Online Secondary Path Modeling Method with Auxiliary Noise Power Scheduling Strategy and Norm Constraint Manipulation”, IEEE Transactions on Speech and Audio Processing, IEEE Service Center, Jan. 1, 2003, pp. 45-53, vol. 11, No. 1, NY.
Lopez-Gaudana, et al., “A hybrid active noise cancelling with secondary path modeling”, 51st Midwest Symposium on Circuits and Systems, MWSCAS 2008, Aug. 10-13, 2008, pp. 277-280, IEEE, Knoxville, TN.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/197,814, filed Mar. 5, 2014, Kaller, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/210,537, filed Mar. 14, 2014, Abdollahzadeh Milani, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/210,589, filed Mar. 14, 2014, Abdollahzadeh Milani, et al.
Black, John W., “An Application of Side-Tone in Subjective Tests of Microphones and Headsets”, Project Report No. NM 001 064.01.20, Research Report of the U.S. Naval School of Aviation Medicine, Feb. 1, 1954, 12 pages (pp. 1-12 in pdf), Pensacola, FL, US.
Peters, Robert W., “The Effect of High-Pass and Low-Pass Filtering of Side-Tone Upon Speaker Intelligibility”, Project Report No. NM 001 064.01.25, Research Report of the U.S. Naval School of Aviation Medicine, Aug. 16, 1954, 13 pages (pp. 1-13 in pdf), Pensacola, FL, US.
Lane, et al., “Voice Level: Autophonic Scale, Perceived Loudness, and the Effects of Sidetone”, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Feb. 1961, pp. 160-167, vol. 33, No. 2., Cambridge, MA, US.
Liu, et al., “Compensatory Responses to Loudness-shifted Voice Feedback During Production of Mandarin Speech”, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Oct. 2007, pp. 2405-2412, vol. 122, No. 4.
Paepcke, et al., “Yelling in the Hall: Using Sidetone to Address a Problem with Mobile Remote Presence Systems”, Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology, Oct. 16-19, 2011, 10 pages (pp. 1-10 in pdf), Santa Barbara, CA, US.
Therrien, et al., “Sensory Attenuation of Self-Produced Feedback: The Lombard Effect Revisited”, PLOS One, Nov. 2012, pp. 1-7, vol. 7, Issue 11, e49370, Ontario, Canada.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/029,159, filed Sep. 17, 2013, Li, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/062,951, filed Oct. 25, 2013, Zhou, et al.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/578,567, filed Dec. 22, 2014, Kwatra, et al.
Widrow, B., et al., Adaptive Noise Cancelling; Principles and Applications, Proceedings of the IEEE, Dec. 1975, pp. 1692-1716, vol. 63, No. 13, IEEE, New York, NY, US.
Morgan, et al., A Delayless Subband Adaptive Filter Architecture, IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, IEEE Service Center, Aug. 1995, pp. 1819-1829, vol. 43, No. 8, New York, NY, US.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20130287218 A1 Oct 2013 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
61638602 Apr 2012 US