The present application relates to diagnosing and/or prognosticating of diseases and medical conditions and in particular, to such diagnosing and/or prognosticating using lipidomic biomarkers.
One embodiment is a method of assessing a Hepatitis C infection or a condition caused by or associated with said infection. This method comprises: (a) obtaining a biological sample from a subject in need thereof; (b) determining a level of at least one Hepatitis C lipidomic biomarker in said biological sample; and (c) comparing said level of (b) with a control level of said Hepatitis C lipidomic biomarker to assess the Hepatitis C infection or the condition caused by or associated with said infection in the subject.
Another embodiment is a method for assessing a response to a therapy, comprising: (a) administering an agent to a subject in need thereof; (b) then obtaining a biological sample from the subject; (c) determining a desaturation index of at least one of glucosylceramide, lactosylceramide and sphingomyelin of the biological sample; and (d) comparing a value of the desaturation index to a control desaturation index value to assess a response to said agent, wherein a higher value of the determined desaturation index value compared to a control value indicates that the subject responds to the agent and/or that a therapeutic benefit is provided.
Yet another embodiment is a method of identifying of a Hepatitis C patient, who is unlikely to respond to a hepatitis C treatment comprising at least one of interferon and ribavirin. The method comprises: (a) obtaining a biological sample from a subject having a Hepatitis C infection; (b) determining a value of a desaturation index of at least one of glucosylceramide, lactosylceramide and sphingomyelin in lipoproteins of the biological sample; and (c) comparing the determined value to a control desaturation index value, wherein if the determined value is higher than the control value of the desaturation, the subject is likely not to respond to a hepatitis C treatment comprising at least one of interferon and ribavirin and/or is likely not to receive a therapeutic benefit.
a-b provide results of analysis of total cellular fatty acid composition of hepatoma cells under treatment with various compounds from
a-f provide comparisons of a percentage of a particular fatty acids in total cellular fatty acid composition between different types of cells. a) mead acid; b) Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA); c) oleic acid; d) linoleic acid; e) palmitoleic acid w9; f) palmitoleic acid w7.
a-b provide global desaturation index and global elongation index under the influence of infection and iminosugar compounds. Data from the global fatty acid analysis by fatty-acid methyl ester analysis (
a-g present plots of fatty acid composition of lysophosphatidylcholine under the influence of infection and iminosugars. The compositional abundance (percent) of each lyso-PC species is indicated. Light bars=uninfected, dark bars=infected cells.
a-f present plots of cellular abundance of sphingolipids under the influence of infection and iminosugars. The cellular abundance of the sphingolipids ‘ceramide’ (Cer), glycosylceramide (GlcCer) and lactosylceramide (LacCer) is indicated in nanomoles per mg of protein, under the various treatments.
a-d presents plots of desaturation index (24:1/24:0) for GlcCer in cells under the influence of infection and iminosugar compounds. Following PCA and discriminant analysis described in
Unless otherwise specified “a” or “an” means one or more.
The present inventors discovered that one may assess a Hepatitis C infection and/or an associated condition, such as liver fibrosis, cirrhosis, and hepatocellular carcinoma, by determining a level of one or more lipidomic biomarkers, which may be a lipid metabolite, in a biological sample obtained from a subject and comparing the determined level with a control level.
The term “lipidomic marker” or “lipidomic biomarker” may refer to a particular difference in a lipid composition between a biological sample from a subject with a disease or condition, such as hepatitis C and/or an associated condition, and a control biological sample, which may be a sample of one or more healthy individuals or a sample of one or more individuals without the disease or condition. In some embodiments, the term “lipidomic marker” or “lipidomic biomarker” may refer to a particular difference in absolute abundance of one or more lipid components or metabolites thereof between a biological sample from a subject with a disease or condition, such as hepatitis C and/or an associated condition, and a control biological sample. Yet in some embodiments, the term “lipidomic marker” or “lipidomic biomarker” may refer to a particular difference in relative abundance between lipid components or metabolites thereof or between a biological sample from a subject with a disease or condition, such as hepatitis C and/or an associated condition, and a control biological sample.
“Biological sample” encompasses a variety of sample types obtained from an organism that may be used in a diagnostic or monitoring assay. The term encompasses blood and other liquid samples of biological origin, solid tissue samples, such as a biopsy specimen, or tissue cultures or cells derived there from and the progeny thereof. Additionally, the term may encompass circulating tumor or other cells. The term specifically encompasses a clinical sample, and further includes cells in cell culture, cell supernatants, cell lysates, serum, plasma, urine, amniotic fluid, biological fluids, and tissue samples. The term also encompasses samples that have been manipulated in any way after procurement, such as treatment with reagents, solubilization, or enrichment for certain components
The biological sample may be a sample of a body fluid or a body tissue of the subject. For example, the biological sample may be a sample of blood, plasma, serum, saliva, bile, urine, feces or cerebrospinal fluid or samples derived from cells, tissues, or organs, such as a liver, from the subject. In many embodiments, it may be preferred to use blood, plasma or serum as a biological sample. A variety of techniques are available for obtaining a biological sample.
“Individual,” “subject,” “host,” and “patient,” used interchangeably herein, refer to any animal subject, such as a mammalian subject for whom diagnosis, treatment, or therapy is desired. In one preferred embodiment, the individual, subject, host, or patient is a human. Other subjects may include, but are not limited to, cattle, horses, dogs, cats, guinea pigs, rabbits, rats, primates, woodchucks, ducks, and mice.
In some embodiments, the biological sample may be pretreated prior to determining the level of the lipidomic biomarker. Such pretreatment may, for example, involve separating at least one fraction of the biological sample and performing determination of the level of the lipidomic marker in the separated fraction. Such a separation fraction may be, for example, a lipoprotein fraction, such as a very low density lipoprotein fraction or a low-density protein fraction, a glyceride fraction, such as a triglyceride fraction, or a phospholipid fraction. In some embodiments, the separation fraction may be a high density lipoprotein fraction or exosome fraction, see e.g. Keller, Sanderson et al (see REFERENCES section below). For separation of a particular fraction, a suitable separation technique, such as centrifugation, extraction, fractioning, ultrafiltration, protein precipitation, or chromatographical separation, may be used.
Yet in some embodiments, the determining the level of the lipidomic marker may be performed on an unpretreated or unfractionated sample.
In some embodiments, it may be preferred to perform determining the level of the lipidomic marker an unpretreated or unfractionated sample obtained from a subject in a fasted state, which may mean at least 1 hour or at least 1.5 hours or at least 2 hours or at least 2.5 hours or at least 3 hours after the latest meal, for example, in the morning before breakfast.
Yet in some embodiments, determining the level of the lipidomic marker an unpretreated or unfractionated sample obtained from a subject in a fasted state obtained from a subject in a postprandial state.
Determining the level of a lipidomic biomarker may be quantitative or semi-quantitative. In some embodiments, quantitative determination may involve determining an absolute amount or concentration of one or more lipid metabolites. Yet in some embodiments, quantitative determination may involve determining a relative amount or concentration of one or more lipid metabolite's with respect to one or more other metabolites. For example, in some embodiments, one may determine a ratio of the amount or concentration of at least one metabolite A with respect to the amount or concentration of at least one metabolite B.
Determining the level of a lipidomic marker may be performed using a number of techniques. In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve using a chromatographic technique, such as liquid chromatography (LC), high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), gas chromatography (GC), thin layer chromatography, size exclusion or affinity chromatography. In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve using a mass spectrometry technique, such as gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC-MS), liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS), direct infusion mass spectrometry or Fourier transform ion-cyclotrone-resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR-MS), capillary electrophoresis mass spectrometry (CE-MS), high-performance liquid chromatography coupled mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS), quadrupole mass spectrometry, any sequentially coupled mass spectrometry, such as MS-MS or MS-MS-MS, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), pyrolysis mass spectrometry (Py-MS), ion mobility mass spectrometry or time of flight mass spectrometry (TOF). Suitable techniques are disclosed in, e.g., Nissen, Journal of Chromatography A, 703, 1995: 37-57, U.S. Pat. No. 4,540,884 or U.S. Pat. No. 5,397,894.
In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve using one of the following techniques: nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), Fourier transform infrared analysis (FT-IR), ultraviolet (UV) spectroscopy, refraction index (RI), fluorescent detection, radiochemical detection, electrochemical detection, light scattering (LS), dispersive Raman spectroscopy or flame ionization detection (FID). In some embodiments, one may use fatty acyl ester analysis for determining, for example, fatty acyl composition of a particular lipoprotein fraction, such as a particular blood lipoprotein fraction. In some embodiments, LC-MS may be used for determining individual lipid species, such as phospholipids or sphingolipids.
In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve using gas chromatography with online mass spectrometry (GCMS) and/or LCMS2 (high performance liquid chromatography with online two-dimensional mass spectrometry) with suitable internal standards using software tools, such as lipid mass spectrum analysis software (LIMSA), see e.g. Haimi et al. Methods Mol. Biol. 2009, 580, 285-94, for data processing.
In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve a specific chemical or biological essay. The essay may utilize one or more agents that can specifically recognize the chemical structure of a lipid metabolite or are capable of specifically identifying the lipid metabolite based on its capability to react with other compounds or its capability to elicit a response in a biological read out system. For example, in some embodiments, an immunoassay may be used wherein an agent, such as an antibody, that is specific for the analyte in question is used to measure the abundance of the target species.
In some embodiments, determining the level of a lipidomic marker may involve using two or more techniques disclosed above.
In some embodiments, a Hepatitis C lipidomic marker may be an abundance, i.e. an amount or concentration, of Mead acid in the biological sample. A higher value of the Mead acid's abundance compared to a control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, the Mead acid's abundance may be used as a biomarker of Hepatocellular Carcinoma. In such a case, a higher value of the Mead acid's abundance compared to a control abundance value may indicate that the subject has Hepatocellular Carcinoma.
The sample for determining Mead acid's abundance may be a sample of a biological fluid, such as plasma, blood or serum. In some embodiments, determining Mead acid's abundance may be performed on an untreated or unfractionated sample. Yet in some embodiments, determining Mead acid's abundance may be performed on a particular fraction of the sample, such as, for example, a very low density lipoprotein fraction.
In some embodiments, a biological sample for determining Mead acid's abundance may be obtained when the subject is in a fasted state, which may mean at least 1 hour or at least 1.5 hours or at least 2 hours or at least 2.5 hours or at least 3 hours after the latest meal. In some embodiments, it may be preferred that the fasting time does not exceed 24 hours. Yet in some embodiments, a biological sample for determining Mead acid's abundance may be obtained when the subject is in a postprandial state.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. an amount or concentration, of at least one non-essential fatty acid by-product of de novo lipogenesis, such as palmitoleic acid (C16:1 omega 9 and omega 7) and oleic acid (C18:1 omega 9) may be used as a biomarker of Hepatitis C or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, a lower value of the determined abundance compared to a control abundance value may indicate that that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, a desaturation index of non-essential fatty acids, which may be, for example, a desaturation index of non-essential fatty acids present in lipids of blood lipoprotein fraction(s), such as VLDL fraction, may be used as a biomarker of Hepatitis C or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, a lower value of the desaturation index compared to a control desaturation index value may indicate the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such a biomarker may be a better measure of liver damage compared to some other biomarkers, such as viraemia. The desaturation index may be, for example, a ((16:1 ω-7+16:1ω-9)/16:0) ratio, i.e. a ratio between a combined abundance of 16:1 ω-7 and 16:1ω-9 fatty acids with to an abundance of 16:0 fatty acid.
In some embodiments, a degree of elongation of non-essential fatty acids in the biological sample may serve as serve as a biomarker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, a higher value of the elongation degree determined for the biological sample compared to a control elongation value may indicate the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such biomarker may be a better indicator of liver damage compared to some other biomarkers, such as viraemia. The elongation degree may be determined, for example, using a (18:1 omega-7/16:1 omega-7) ratio, i.e. a ratio between an abundance of 18:1 omega-7 fatty acid and 16:1 omega-7 fatty acid.
In some embodiments, a lipidomic biomarker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection may be an abundance of at least one polyunsaturated omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acid, such as arachidonic acid and docohexaenoic acid. In such a case, a higher value of such abundance determined in the biological sample compared with a control abundance value, which may be an abundance value for one or more healthy individual not infected with HCV, may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such biomarker may be a better indicator of progress of liver damage compared to some other biomarkers, such as viraemia.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or amount, of one or more fatty acids in a cholesterol ester profile of the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic biomarker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. For measuring a cholesterol ester profile, cholesterol esters may be purified from the biological sample using a separation technique, such as chromatographic purification. In certain cases, such fatty acid may be at least one polyunsaturated essential omega-3 or omega-6 fatty acid, such as a 20:4 fatty acid, a 20:5 fatty acid, a 22:6 fatty acid and a 22:5 fatty acid. In such a case, a higher value of the abundance determined in the one or more of such polyunsaturated fatty acids compared to a control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such biomarker may be a better indicator of the progress of liver damage compared to some other biomarkers, such as viraemia. In certain cases, the paucity of certain fatty acids in the cholesterol ester profile may be indicative of the presence or effect of HCV upon liver cells in an infected individual. In such cases, the fatty acid may be at least one monounsaturated fatty acid, which may be, for example, a 16:1 fatty acid and a 18:1 fatty acid. In such a case, a lower value of the abundance determined in the one or more of such monounsaturated fatty acids compared to a control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or an amount, of one or more triglycerides in the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic biomarker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such triglyceride may be, for example, C54:5-C18:0 triglyceride; C54:6-C18:1 triglyceride; C56:5-C20:4 triglyceride or C56:7-C22:6 triglyceride. In such a case, a higher value of the abundance of the triglyceride compared to a control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, determining the abundance of a triglyceride biomarker may be performed in an untreated or unfractionated biological sample, such as a plasma, blood or serum sample. Yet in some embodiments, determining the abundance of a triglyceride biomarker may be performed in a fraction of the biological sample, such as a very low density lipoprotein fraction and a triglyceride fraction. In some embodiments, determining the abundance of a triglyceride biomarker may be performed in a biological sample obtained from a subject in a fasted state, i.e. at least 1 hour or at least 1.5 hours or at least 2 hours or at least 2.5 hours or at least 3 hours after the latest meal. Yet in some embodiments, determining the abundance of a triglyceride biomarker may be performed in a biological sample obtained from a subject in a postprandial state. For determining an abundance of C54:5-C18:0 triglyceride; C56:5-C20:4 triglyceride or C56:7-C22:6 triglyceride, it may be preferred to use an unfractionated biological sample, such as plasma, blood or serum sample, obtained from a subject in a fasted state. Alternatively, for these biomarkers, one may use a fraction of a biological sample, such as a very low density lipoprotein fraction and a triglyceride fraction. Determining an abundance of C54:6-C18:1 triglyceride may be performed in a unfractionated biological sample, such as plasma, blood or serum sample, obtained from a subject in a fasted or postprandial state.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or an amount, of one or more fatty acids among phospholipids of the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic marker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or an amount, of one or more fatty acids among ester bonded phospholipids of the biological sample may serve as such a lipidomic marker. For example, in some embodiments, an abundance of at least one fatty acid in a diester form of phosphatidylcholines of the biological sample may be the lipidomic marker. Such fatty acid may be selected, for example, from a PC 32:1 species, a PC 32:0 species, a PC 34:0 species, a PC 34:4 species and a PC 34:5 species. In such a case a higher value of the abundance of at least one of the PC 32:0 species, the PC 34:0 species, the PC 34:4 species and the PC 34:5 species compared to a respective control value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. A lower value of the abundance of the 32:1 species compared to a respective control value may also indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, an abundance, such as a concentration or amount, of at least one fatty acid in a diester form of phosphatidylethanolamines of the biological sample may be used as a lipidomic marker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such fatty acid may be selected, for example, from a) a Mead acid; b) at least one palmitoleic acids, such as 16:1 omega-7 and omega-9 acids; or c) at least one of essential omega-3 or omega-6 fatty acids, such as 20:3 omega-3, 20:4 omega-6, 20:5 omega-3, 22:6 omega-3, 22:5 omega-3 and 22:4 omega-6. In such a case, a higher value of the abundance determined of the Mead acid or the at least one essential omega-3 or omega-6 compared to its respective control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. A lower value of the abundance of the at least one palmitoleic acid compared to its respective control value may also indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or amount, of at least one fatty acid in a diester form of phosphatidylserines of the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic marker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such fatty acid may be, for example, a 38:3 species or a 40:6 species. In such a case, a higher value of the abundance of the at least one of the 38:3 species and the 40:6 species compared to its respective control value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or amount, of at least one fatty acid in a diester form of phosphatidylionositol of the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic marker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such fatty acid may be, for example, a PI 38:3 species; a PI 36:4 species, a PI 38:4 species or a PI 38:5 species. In such a case, a higher value of the determined abundance of the PI 38:3 species compared to a respective control abundance value or a lower value of the abundance of the at least one of the PI 36:4 species, the PI 38:4 species and the PI 38:5 species compared to a respective control abundance value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, an abundance, i.e. a concentration or amount, of at least one fatty acid among at least one of lyso-phosphatidylcholines of the biological sample may serve as a lipidomic marker of a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. Such fatty acid may be a 16:1 species, a 16:0 species, a 20:4 species or a 22:6 species. In such a case higher value of the determined abundance of at least one of the 16:0 species, the 20:4 species and the 22:6 species compared to its respective control value or a lower value of the 16:1 species compared to its respective control value may indicate that the subject has a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection.
In some embodiments, for determining abundances of fatty acids among ester bonded phosphadylcholines and ester bonded phosphatylethanolamine, it may be preferred to use a fraction of the biological sample, such as a very low density lipoprotein fraction of the biological sample.
The present biomarkers may be used for diagnosing a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, the control level or the control value may refer to a level or value of the biomarker determined in a healthy individual, who does not have the Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. The control level or value may be also a level or value averaged over a pool of healthy individuals.
The present biomarkers may be used for assessing the progression or regression a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, the control level or the control value may refer to a level or value of the biomarker determined in the same subject at an earlier time.
The present biomarkers may be used for assessing an effect of an agent on a Hepatitis C infection or a condition associated with or caused by such infection. In such a case, the control level or the control value may refer to a level or value of the biomarker determined, for example, prior to administering the agent to the subject.
The present biomarkers may be also used for assessing a response to a treatment for the Hepatitis C infection or a related condition. In such a case, the control level or the control value may refer to a level or value of the biomarker determined, for example, prior to administering the treatment to the subject.
The present inventors also discovered a response to a therapy, which may involve administering a therapeutic agent to a subject, using a lipidomic biomarker, which may be a desaturation index in at least one of glucosylceramide, lactosylceramide and sphingomyelins of a biological sample obtained from the subject. A higher value of the determined desaturation index value compared to a control value, i.e. a value determined in a sample of the subject obtained prior to administering the agent, may indicate that the subject responds to the agent. Such a desaturation index may be a 24:1/24:0 ratio.
In some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in a very low density lipoprotein fraction of the biological sample.
In some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in one of glucosylceramide and lactosylceramide. Yet in some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in both of glucosylceramide and lactosylceramide.
In some embodiments, a response to a therapy may be further assessed using an abundance, i.e. a concentration or amount, of glucosylceramide of the biological sample in addition to the desaturation index marker. In such a case, a reduced abundance of glucosylceramide, particularly in the VLDL blood fraction, compared to a control value, i.e. a value prior to administering the agent, may indicate that the subject responds to the therapy.
In some embodiments, the subject may be a subject with a Hepatitis C infection or an associated condition, such as a hepatic fibrosis or hepatocellular carcinoma. An agent administered to such subject may be an iminosugar, which may be effective against hepatitis C. Such iminosugar may be, for example, one of N-substituted deoxynojrimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof, N-substituted deoxygalactonojirimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof and N-substituted Me-deoxygalactonojirimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof. Exemplary iminosugars may include, but not limited to, N-butyl deoxynojirimycin and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof and N-(7-oxa-nonyl)-1,5,6-trideoxy-1,5-imino-D-galactitol and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof. Iminosugars effective against hepatitis C are disclosed, for example, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,612,093 and 6,465,487.
In some embodiments, the subject may be a subject with a lysomal storage disorder, such as Gaucher disease or Niemann-Pick type-C disease. An agent administered to such subject may be an iminosugar, which may be effective against a lysosomal storage disorder. Such iminosugar may be, for example, one of N-substituted deoxynojrimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof, N-substituted deoxygalactonojirimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof and N-substituted Me-deoxygalactonojirimycins and pharmaceutically acceptable salts thereof. Exemplary iminosugars may include, but not limited to, N-butyl deoxynojirimycin and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof; N-nonyl deoxynojirimycin and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof and N-butyl deoxygalactonojirimycin and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof. Iminosugars effective against hepatitis C are disclosed, for example, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,472,969; 5,525,616; 5,580,884; 5,656,641; 5,786,369; 5,798,366; 5,801,185; 6,291,657; 6,465,488; 6,495,570; 6,610,703; 6,660,749; 6,696,059; 7,348,000.
In some embodiments, the subject may be a subject with diabetes, e.g. with a type II diabetes. An agent administered to such subject may be an insulin sentisizing agent, which may be, for example, an iminosugar, a biguanide or a thiazolidinedione. One example of insulin sentisizing iminosugar may be N-(5-adamantane-1-yl-methoxypentyl)-DNJ and a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof. Examples of thiazolidinedione insulin sensitizing agents include, but not limited to, Pioglitazone and Rosiglitazone. One non-limiting example of a biguanide insulin-sensitizing agent is metformin. In general, biguanides and insulin sentisizing agents are generally known to those of ordinary skill in the art.
The present inventors also hypothesize that a Hepatitis C patient, who is unlikely to respond to a hepatitis C treatment comprising administering at least one of interferon, such as pegylated interferon alpha, and ribavirin, (a non-responder patient) may be identified through determining a value of a desaturation index of at least one of glucosylceramide, lactosylceramide and sphingomyelin in lipoproteins of a biological sample obtained from such patient. If the determined value of the desaturation index turns out to be higher than a control desaturation index value, the patient is likely not to respond to a hepatitis C treatment comprising at least one of interferon and ribavirin. In such a case, the identified non-responder patient may be administered an alternative therapy, in addition to the interferon and/or ribavirin therapy or instead of the interferon and/or ribavirin therapy. Such alternative therapy may involve administering an iminosugar, which may be effective against hepatitis C, such as those disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 7,612,093 and 6,465,487. The desaturation index may be a 24:1/24:0 ratio. In some embodiments, the alternative therapy may include administering a direct acting antiviral agent, which may be, for example, an inhibitor of HCV protease, such as Telaprevir or Boceprevir, or a polymerase inhibitor.
In some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in a very low density lipoprotein fraction of the biological sample.
In some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in one of glucosylceramide and lactosylceramide. Yet in some embodiments, the desaturation index may be determined in both of glucosylceramide and lactosylceramide.
The present application also provides kits, which may include (a) one or more reagents for measuring a level of one or more lipidomic biomarker and (b) instructions for use. Such a kit may provide 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 10, 15, 20, or more reagents for measuring the level of 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 10, or more lipidomic biomarkers. In some embodiments, the kit may include one or more reagents for an immunoassay. In some embodiments, the kit may include one or more reagents for an MS assay. In some embodiments, the reagent may be an antibody to lipid metabolite, such as a fatty acid. Methods of making antibodies are known to those of ordinary skill in the art.
In some aspects, the kit may comprise (a) an antibody to a lipid metabolite, such as a fatty acid; and (b) instructions for use. In some embodiments, the kit may further comprise: (c) a second antibody to a second lipid metabolite, such as a fatty acid. In some embodiments, the kit further comprises (d) a third antibody to a third lipid metabolite, such as a fatty acid.
The present invention can be illustrated in more detail by the following example, however, it should be understood that the present invention is not limited thereto.
The lipid composition of hepatoma cells was studied under the influence of infection with replication-competent hepatitis-C virus (HCVcc) and under the influence of treatment with various antiviral iminosugar compounds which are inhibitors of ER glucosidases and/or of glucosylceramide synthase. In the absence of infection, untreated hepatoma cells showed markedly elevated levels of unsaturated non-essential fatty acids in the global fatty acid profile of the cells indicating a constitutive state of essential fatty acid deprivation. In particular, Mead acid (eicosatrienoic acid, 20:3 omega-9) was highly elevated. Infection markedly inhibited de novo biosynthesis of fatty acids (evident from decreased content of Mead acid and monounsaturated fatty acids) and brought about enrichment in highly polyunsaturated essential omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids. Infection elevated the fatty acid content of cells and markedly changed the fatty-acyl composition of phospholipids, triglycerides and cholesterol esters, increasing length and saturation of endogenously synthesized non-essential fatty acyl chains, and increasing the incorporation of essential highly polyunsaturated fatty acids into membrane and storage lipid forms Iminosugar compounds reduced the abundance of glucosylceramide, but surprisingly also increased its unsaturation. These changes in abundance and saturation of glucosylceramide in response to iminosugars were present in both the infected and uninfected state. The iminosugars, in contrast to the effects of HCV, stimulated de novo lipogenesis and Mead acid production, but only in the uninfected state. These newly observed changes in cellular lipid composition, indicative of oncogenic transformation, HCV infection and response to iminosugar treatments, may serve as diagnostic and/or prognostic markers of hepatitis-C disease activity and for the diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma.
Approximately 3 percent of the world's population is infected with hepatitis-C virus (Marcellin 1999, for citations see section REFERENCES below) which is a leading cause of chronic liver disease including liver fibrosis, cirrhosis, and hepatocellular carcinoma. Moreover, hepatitis-C virus infection is the most common indication for liver transplantation in the US and Europe (Chen and Morgan 2006). The infection is ‘curable’ (i.e. there is a sustained virological response) in about 50% of cases by combination therapy with PEGylated interferon alpha in combination with Ribavirin (interferon+ribavirin), although the side effects of such therapy, which requires up to one year of treatment, are significant (e.g. the influenza-like symptoms of interferons) (Awad, Thorlund et al. 2010; Pawlotsky 2011). Cure rates are increasing with new ‘direct acting’ antiviral agents recently licensed (e.g. the protease inhibitors Telaprevir and Boceprevir) and with drugs in development such as Gilead's GS-7977 (formerly PI-7977), a nucleotide analog polymerase inhibitor. These new drugs hold considerable promise, but the extent to which they will be successful long-term in the face of the high mutability of the virus, and the extent to which they will be successful in combination with other drugs that might be needed to prevent resurgence of the infection while avoiding the use of interferons and their attendant side effects, remains to be seen (Pawlotsky 2011). Also, the newly licensed drugs are expensive, and insurance and healthcare budgets are limited—such that it may be important, for pharmacoeconomic reasons, to know which patients are likely to require the expensive new therapies, and who may fare adequately on the historically-established standard of care (interferon+ribavirin). Likewise, it may be important to be able to predict which patients will experience a rapid progression of disease and are likely, sooner than others, to require more-aggressive treatment, or liver transplantation.
One might expect that the amount of hepatitis-C virus in the bloodstream would be a good measure of the severity of underlying liver disease in infected patients. However, this has proven not to be the case: i.e. there is no clear relationship between viraemia (quantity of virus in the blood, assessed by the relatively non-invasive method of blood sampling), compared to liver biopsy which (though painful and posing significant risks to the patient) is regarded as the most reliable indicator of liver pathology (Hollingsworth R C 1996). To date, the focus of non-invasive prognostic investigations has been to detect the onset and progress of fibrosis (a predictor of subsequent cirrhosis) by measuring protein biomarkers in the blood. To this end, panels of protein biomarkers have been developed (e.g. the FibroTest, known as FibroSure in the USA) (Castéra, Vergniol et al. 2005) (Gangadharan, Bapat et al. 2012). These protein biomarker tests may have the ability to detect fibrosis indicating the onset of cirrhosis at the preclinical stage (FibroTest), and furthermore protein biomarkers such as the novel ones we have discovered have the potential to act as useful indicators of disease activity. Increasingly however, there is a need to obtain an early indication of the impact of the virus on liver pathology, using non-invasive or minimally-invasive methods. Also, there is an interest in identifying biomarkers or biomarker panels, that would predict responsiveness to a particular treatment, in order to ensure that patients are treated with appropriate drugs or drug combinations that they are most likely to respond to, i.e. so-called ‘personalized’ or ‘stratified’ medicine. Such endeavors balance the best interests of the patient, with the best interests of society (including other patients with different diseases with similar magnitude of medical need), given inherently limited healthcare budgets.
The best-established example to date of a biomarker that predicts treatment response in hepatitis-C virus infection is polymorphism of the IL28B gene which is predictive of sustained virological response to PEG-interferon-alpha in combination with Ribavirin (which until recently was the ‘Standard of Care’ for the treatment of hepatitis-C patients). However, the predictive value of IL28 polymorphism is not so strong, on its own, that it is yet used in the clinical judgment of deciding whether a patient will respond to any particular treatment regimen. It seems likely however, that IL28 polymorphism may have additive or synergistic value with other genetic polymorphisms or could be used likewise in combination with other biomarker strategies (e.g. protein based biomarkers) to help make decisions about treatment, in an emerging therapeutic environment where there is greater choice of drugs as a result of newly licensed drugs and new drugs in development (Clark and Muir 2012). To date however, biomarker strategies for hepatitis-C virus infection have concentrated upon protein and genetic markers, and have not, so far, investigated or identified the possibility of using lipid biomarkers.
Hepatitis-C virus is remarkably dependent upon cellular lipid metabolism, particularly cholesterol metabolism, of the hepatocyte for its replicative cycle (Barba, Harper et al. 1997; Sagan, Rouleau et al. 2006; Aizaki, Morikawa et al. 2008; Amemiya, Maekawa et al. 2008; Burlone and Budkowska 2009; Lyn, Kennedy et al. 2009; McLauchlan 2009; Ogawa, Hishiki et al. 2009; Diamond, Syder et al. 2010; Herker, Harris et al. 2010; Syed, Amako et al. 2010; Merz, Long et al. 2011; Miyoshi, Moriya et al. 2011; Clark, Thompson et al. 2012; Moriishi and Matsuura 2012; Rodgers, Villareal et al. 2012). In vivo, hepatitis-C virus progeny emerge from the endoplasmic reticulum of the cell as enveloped virions (i.e. lipid-membrane-enveloped virus particles) associated with very low density lipoprotein (VLDL) in the form of a lipoviral particle′. In order to infect a new cell, the particle may have to bind to cell surface receptors (including tetraspanin, scavenger receptor-B1 and LDL-receptor), SRB 1 and LDL-R are lipoprotein receptors. The receptors are associated with ‘lipid rafts’ (membrane microdomains that are enriched with cholesterol and saturated glycosphingolipids). Once inside the endosome of the cell, the virus may have to further interact with a cholesterol receptor ‘Niemann-Pick type-C disease like protein 1’ (NPCL1) in order to escape into the cytoplasm (Sainz, Barretto et al. 2012). Once inside the cytoplasm of the cell, the virus subverts the lipid metabolism of the endoplasmic reticulum to create its own organelle, the ‘membranous web’, to support the function of its own replicative apparatus. Assembly of virions occurs on the lipid droplet (the immediate precursor of VLDL in the ER), initiated by the binding of core protein to the surface of the droplet. The intact virions then emerge as lipoviral particles associated with VLDL and the whole cycle repeats.
The inventors hypothesize that HCV, because it manipulates and exploits so many aspects of hepatocyte lipid metabolism for its own replication, is bound to have specific and measurable effects on the lipid composition of the cell, and to realize moreover, that these changes will be manifest in the blood in the form of altered lipid composition of blood lipoproteins secreted by the liver (particularly components of VLDL), as well as being accessible to analysis as changes in the lipid composition of liver biopsy specimens. In addition, the inventors have realized that the ‘lipidomic imprint’ of HCV on infected cells, being a measure of the effect of the virus on its host cell, i.e. its impact on liver lipid metabolism, may be a better marker of disease activity than is viraemia, since it may more directly reflect the adverse effects of the virus on liver function and pathology, and since it represents the summation of a complex cellular metabolic response to virus infection, which will likely be influenced by multiple gene polymorphisms—each having a minor contribution, and being of limited predictive value individually. Furthermore, the inventors have recognized that the prognostic value of lipidomic signatures in plasma and biopsy specimens of hepatitis-C infected patients, represent a so-far untapped resource of biomarkers, which can be used in concert with genetic polymorphisms and proteomic biomarkers to achieve enhanced predictive accuracy of response to particular treatment regimens, and the risk and rate of development of fibrosis, cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma. The inventors have also recognized that hepatocellular carcinoma itself, being derived from liver cells which are very active in lipid metabolism, will have its own characteristic lipidomic signature—reflecting changes in lipid metabolism characteristic of the transformed state of the hepatocyte, and that signatures of hepatocellular carcinoma in the form of blood lipoprotein lipid composition can be used for the early detection of liver cancer, which is currently unreliable with existing biomarkers such as alpha-foetoprotein, which is not universally expressed by HCC (expressed in about 80% of cases (Huo, Hsia et al. 2007)). Accordingly, the inventors have studied the effects of infection with replication-competent HCVcc upon the lipidome of hepatocellular carcinoma cells (Huh7.5), and the lipidomic composition and lipidomic response of uninfected and infected cells to iminosugar drugs which are inhibitors of ER alpha-glucosidases and of glucosylceramide synthase, and which have known effects on protein folding (via glucosidase inhibition) (Branza-Nichita, Durantel et al. 2001; Chapel, Garcia et al. 2006; Chapel, Garcia et al. 2007) and/or upon lipid metabolism via inhibition of glucosylceramide synthase (Platt, Reinkensmeier et al. 1997; Butters, Dwek et al. 2003; Butters, Dwek et al. 2005), and by inhibition of beta-glucosidase-2 (GBA2)—a neutral extra-lysosomal glucosylceramidase (Boot, Verhoek et al. 2007).
The total fatty acid content (free plus lipidic fatty acyl chains) of hepatoma cells in the uninfected and infected state was measured (
In order to gain an overall impression of the effects of infection and iminosugars on the lipidome of the host cells, the total fatty acid composition of uninfected cells (as fatty acid methyl esters) after acidic transmethylation of total lipid extracts was first examined. This analysis includes non-esterified and esterified fatty acids (the latter comprising parts of cholesterol esters, triglycerides and various phospholipids as well as sphingolipids)
Mead acid is grossly elevated by conditions of essential fatty acid deprivation in vivo in man and animals (Siguel, Chee et al. 1987; Duffin, Obukowicz et al. 2000). Elevation of Mead acid therefore indicates that the uninfected host cells were effectively deprived of essential fatty acids, namely linoleic acid (18:2 omega-6) and alpha-linolenic and (18:3 omega-3) which are the predominant dietary essential fatty acids (being required for the synthesis of the highly polyunsaturated fatty acids, including omega-6 arachidonic acid and omega-3 docosahexaenoic acid).
This observation may suggest that hepatoma cells in HCC patients, unlike healthy liver cells, may secrete Mead acid as the fatty acyl chains of lipid elements of lipoproteins such as VLDL, and moreover that such changes in VLDL composition may be maintained in the face of dietary fluctuations in essential fatty acids. Unlike alfa-foetoprotein, which is a clinically useful protein biomarker of heptatocellular carcinoma, the inventors hypothesize that these changes in VLDL composition may manifest more universally in HCC patients, independently of whether they are positive for serum alfa-foetoprotein (the classical biomarker for HCC). As such, the inventors hypothesize that a diagnostic test based on elevated Mead acid in VLDL may be a more sensitive and reliable indicator of underlying hepatocellular carcinoma than is alfa-foetoprotein (which is elevated in a subset of about 80% of patients), and that such a test may be complementary to at least one another test in the diagnosis of HCC providing synergistic or added value in terms of accuracy and reliability of the diagnosis.
Infection with HCV reduced the cellular content of Mead acid dramatically (over 20-fold,
In principle, the reduction of Mead acid in the infected state could be a consequence either of reduced desaturase enzyme activities as noted above, or of reduced elongation, since both classes of enzyme are required for its synthesis. However, fatty acid elongation was not decreased by infection, rather there was evidence to the contrary (in the global fatty acid profile) of increased elongation of fatty acids in the infected state as assessed by the ratio of (18:1 omega-7/16:1 omega-7) (
In the uninfected state, the iminosugars, in general, were found to increase the already high Mead acid component of the global fatty acid composition at antiviral concentrations (
The stimulation of Mead acid production by iminosugars appears to be a consequence of further-increased activity of desaturase enzymes delta-6 and delta-5, i.e. over and above the constitutively high levels in these cultured cells as evident from their already high Mead acid content. This effect of the iminosugars was strikingly opposite to that of HCV infection but, paradoxically, was not detectable in the infected state, which was very much dominated by the effects of the virus. This effect of the iminosugars in the uninfected state may indicate an increased sensitivity to insulin brought on by iminosugar treatment of the cells. Thus, one of these compounds (AMP-DNJ, also known as AMP-DNM), improves hepatic insulin sensitivity, decreases fatty acid synthase activity and abolishes hepatic steatosis in obese mice (Bijl, Sokolovic et al. 2009). Moreover, insulin stimulates delta-6 desaturase expression and activity (which is rate-limiting for Mead acid synthesis (Wang, Botolin et al. 2006), which may support the hypothesis that the iminosugars are increasing insulin sensitivity. The inventors hypothesize that the observation that type-II diabetes is a negative prognostic indicator for treatment response (to interferon+ribavirin) in HCV infected subjects, and that patients cured of HCV infection are also cured of insulin resistance (Clement, Pascarella et al. 2009; Eslam, Khattab et al. 2011) may suggest that the insulin-sensitizing effect of the iminosugars may be advantageous in antiviral treatment with iminosugar drugs by counteracting an underlying metabolic defect in hepatocytes that favors replication of the virus.
The essential fatty acids linoleic and alpha linolenic acid cannot be synthesized by mammalian cells. Moreover, it was discovered (above) that the cells are very deficient in these essential fatty acids. Thus, it was surprising to find markedly increased abundance of highly polyunsaturated omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids such as arachidonic and docosahexaenoic acid in the infected state. Although the present invention is not limited by its theory of operation, the increased relative abundance of the these highly polyunsaturated species in the infected state may simply reflect the fact that they are no longer being diluted by endogenously synthesized fatty acids from de novo lipogenesis, which is suppressed by the virus.
Given that polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), such as docosahexaenoic acid, in the free state, are antiviral vs. HCV in both replicon and infectious virus systems (Leu, Lin et al. 2004; Kapadia and Chisari 2005; Miyoshi, Moriya et al. 2011), the high content of such PUFA in the infected cells is all the more surprising. Although the present invention is not limited by its theory of operation, it is possible that the high omega-3 and omega-6 PUFA content of cholesterol esters and triglycerides in the infected state (see below) may reflect a tendency of the virus to favor sequestration of these fatty acids into the lipid droplet, where their ability to inhibit viral replication is limited.
The surprising elevation of cellular omega-3 and omega-6 highly polyunsaturated fatty acids observed in the infected state, may indicate that elevated plasma levels of these fatty acids could indicate quantitatively the extent of HCV infection, or the metabolic impact of HCV infection upon liver function, however, these essential fatty acids (EFA) are common dietary components (abundant in meat (omega-6) and abundant in fish (omega-3)), such that a biomarker strategy based on abundance of these fatty acid markers in the global plasma fatty-acid profile may be easily confounded by changes in diet. A more sophisticated analytical approach may be needed, mindful of the potential confounding effects of diet on the total lipid fatty acid profile.
Cholesterol Esters
The most common fatty acid species of cholesterol esters were measured in both the uninfected and infected state.
Infection brought about marked changes in the fatty acid composition of cholesterol esters (
Triglycerides
Triglycerides form the major component of the lipid droplet, which forms (along with cholesterol esters) the core of secreted VLDL and lipoviral particles. Given our rationale developed here that blood VLDL/lipoviral lipid composition is likely to be a sensitive indicator of the effect of HCV infection on hepatocyte metabolism, triglycerides are therefore of particular interest. Unlike cholesterol esters, where there is only one fatty acyl chain per molecule, in the case of triglycerides there are three, and the three positions are not equivalent with respect to the fatty acyl chains which tend to be found in each position, reflecting substrate preferences of synthetic enzymes as well as the availability of free fatty acid precursors in the cell (Berry 2009). These features of triglyceride biosynthesis provide more degrees of freedom for a greater diversity of fatty acyl isomeric compositions than for other lipid classes.
Notably, the compositional abundance of the most abundant species of triglyceride ‘C52:2-C16:1’ containing palmitoleic acid (16:1), representing one quarter to one third of all triglyceride species, was virtually unchanged by infection. However, there were very marked changes in some of the more minor triglyceride species. Thus, nine triglyceride species were reduced in abundance >2 fold, whereas six triglyceride species were increased in abundance >2 fold. The biggest changes were in the following triglyceride species which were increased upon infection >15-fold:—
C54:5-C18:0
C54:6-C18:1
C56:5-C20:4
C56:7-C22:6
Notably, C54:6-C18:1, was increased 96-fold by infection, although it still represented only 1.7% of the triglyceride composition in the infected state. Changes such as these may not be apparent in traditional blood analysis of triglycerides as used in routine clinical diagnostic tests, because these tests measure total triglyceride and do not break down triglyceride species according to their fatty acid composition or molecular species. Notably also, species containing very high numbers of double bonds and explicitly containing essential fatty acids, C56:5-C20:4 (containing arachidonic acid 20:4), and C56:7-C22:6 (containing docosahexaenoic acid) were highly elevated in the infected state (>16-fold), although still comprising only minor components of the total cellular triglyceride pool (
The entirely saturated species C44:0-C16:0 was reduced five-fold in the infected state, such that reduction in the abundance of this triglyceride species in blood triglycerides or VLDL could be useful in determining the effects of hepatitis-C virus upon liver lipid metabolism. The iminosugar compounds had no systematic effect upon triglyceride fatty acid composition, except for a tendency to increase the abundance of this saturated species in the uninfected state and paradoxically, to reduce the abundance of this species in the infected state. The minor effects of iminosugars on this particular triglyceride species are not expected to be of particular diagnostic or prognostic significance.
Phosphatidylcholine
In contrast to the ether bonded form of PC (see below), the fatty acid composition of the ester-bonded phospholipids PC, PE, PS and PI were extensively remodeled by infection, as was the lyso form of PC. In the case of the PC diester form, the level of the monounsaturated PC32:1 species was decreased while saturated PC32:0 and 34:0 and PUFA-enriched PCs (PC34:4 and PC38:5) were elevated by infection (
The fatty acid composition of the ether-phospholipid form of PC (i.e. the ‘plasmalogen’ form synthesized in the peroxisome) was virtually unaltered by infection (
The analysis of lyso-PC (
Phosphatidylethanolamine
In the case of the analysis of the diester form of PE (
Phosphatidylserine
In the case of the diester form of PS, infection brought about a >2-fold reduction in the 38:3 species, presumed to comprise 18:0 and Mead acid (20:3 omega-9), indicating a lesser plasticity to the prevailing changes in the global fatty acid profile than for the other lipid classes (
Phosphatidylionositol
The diester form of PI, having only four molecular species, showed marked changes in fatty acid composition upon infection (
Significance of Phospholipid Fatty-Acid Profiles for Biomarker Identification
The liver secretes HCV virions as part of the lipoviral particle (described above) which comprises the HCV virion associated with a VLDL particle. Although the present invention is not limited by its theory of operation, the inventors hypothesize that because the lipidic surface of VLDL particles comprises predominantly PC and PE, any effects of the virus on cellular fatty acid profile of PC and PE will be reflected as alterations in the fatty acid profile of VLDL in the blood of infected patients. In the case of PC, only changes to the fatty acid profile of the diester form upon infection were observed. It may follow that changes in the diester form of PC in VLDL may be of most interest from the point of view of identifying biomarkers, and that the composition of the ether form may be a useful control. First, in this regard, it is notable that the PC32:1 species was decreased while saturated PC32:0 and 34:0 and PUFA-enriched PCs (PC34:4 and PC38:5) were elevated by infection. Thus decrease of 32:1 combined with elevation of (32:0; 34:0; 34:4 and 38:5) species of diester PC would indicate the activity of HCV upon phospholipid metabolism of the hepatocyte.
In the case of PE, there was elevated Mead acid in the uninfected state, which would be reflected in elevated Mead-acid in hepatocellular carcinoma derived blood VLDL particles, such that blood VLDL Mead acid content would serve as a useful marker of hepatocellular carcinoma. Furthermore, infection brings about a marked decrease in palmitoleic acids (16:1 omega-7 and omega-9) and a marked increase in the essential omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids (20:3 omega-3; 20:4 omega-6; 20:5 omega-3; 22:6 omega-3; 22:5 omega-3; and 22:4 omega-6). This latter constellation of changes in plasma VLDL characteristic of the infected state may be indicative of the impact of HCV infection upon liver hepatocytes, and may have utility for biomarker purposes.
PI and PS being only minor phospholipid constituents of VLDL, may be less useful as biomarkers of HCV infection. Nevertheless reduced levels of Mead acid in PI in VLDL, or of the 38:3 species of PI may be useful indicators of the impact of infection with HCV. Also, increased levels of PI and PS (normally confined to the intracellular leaflet of the plasma membrane and ER) in VLDL may signify HCV infection. Thus, apoptosis of hepatocytes occurring during HCV infection may result in increasing membrane asymmetry with consequent enrichment of lipids such as PI and PS, normally largely excluded from VLDL, now appearing in greater abundance in the surface phospholipid monolayer of VLDL.
Treatment of infected or uninfected cells with iminosugars at antiviral concentrations strongly reduced the cellular concentrations of ‘glycosylceramide’ (the present mass spectrometric analysis makes no distinction between glucosyl and galactosyl forms), via inhibition of glucosylceramide synthase (
However, unexpectedly, it was also found that the fatty acid composition of glucosyl ceramide was altered by iminosugar treatment, although, surprisingly (given the above observations of extensive remodeling of major and minor cellular lipids by infection, and changes in the delta-9 global desaturation index), the fatty acid composition of GlcCer was not changed by infection. In contrast, iminosugars caused both chain elongation and desaturation of GlcCer (the latter effect being the stronger of the two effects). These phenomena (desaturation and chain elongation) were present in the infected and the uninfected state alike.
The changes in GlcCer fatty acid composition (increased desaturation in response to iminosugars in the infected and uninfected state alike) may be counter in some respects to the observations and inferences (made earlier) of reduced desaturase activity in the infected state, although, in accord with the observations above, the degree of iminosugar-induced desaturation of GlcCer was less in the infected state. These changes may be conveniently expressed as a ‘desaturation index’ for GlcCer, i.e. ratio of abundance of C24:1/C24:0 (i.e. the molar ratio of nervonic acid/lignoceric acid fatty-acyl chains) (
Since GlcCer and LacCer are major precursors of gangliosides (Butters, Dwek et al. 2005; Fuller 2010), and because gangliosides are important components of lipid rafts (along with sphingomyelin and cholesterol) (Quinn 2010), the inventors hypothesize that reduction in cellular abundance of GlcCer might be expected to reduce the abundance and/or size of cellular membrane rafts, or to change their functional properties. Moreover, since HCV is highly dependent upon lipid rafts for several stages of its replicative cycle (Aizaki, Lee et al. 2004; Matto, Rice et al. 2004; Aizaki, Morikawa et al. 2008; Weng, Hirata et al. 2010), it may follow that reduced abundance or altered functionality of lipid rafts caused by iminosugars might explain their antiviral effects against HCV. Moreover, it was observed that, in addition to reducing the abundance of GlcCer, iminosugar inhibitors of glucosylceramide synthase also, surprisingly, increase the desaturation of GlcCer, which might also be expected to influence the quantity and properties of lipid rafts: i.e. incorporation of unsaturated gangliosides into lipid rafts (which are characteristically ‘saturated’ microdomains) may alter their structure and function. Since pathological accumulation of gangliosides entraps cholesterol in cellular membranes (as in the ganglioside storage diseases such as Gaucher disease), it may be that the iminosugars may influence cholesterol compartmentalization or trafficking. For example, the depletion of ganglioside components of lipid rafts may liberate cholesterol from rafts increasing its ‘free’ concentration in the membrane. Thus, the iminosugars, in addition to their direct effects on lipid rafts, may mediate their antiviral effect by liberating cholesterol from membrane rafts, as a consequence of changes in the abundance or fatty acid composition of GlcCer.
Liberation of cholesterol from lipid rafts would falsely signify a state of ‘cholesterol overload’ to the cell, causing feedback inhibition of cholesterol synthesis by liberated cholesterol, depriving the virus of the cholesterol it needs for replication.
It may follow from the above that the abundance of glucosylceramide and the desaturation index of both glucosylceramide and lactosylceramide in blood lipoproteins may be used as indicators of the effectiveness of antiviral therapy vs. HCV when using iminosugars therapeutically. Likewise, these indices may be used as a measure of response to treatment with inhibitors of glucosylceramide synthase in genetic lysosomal storage disorders such Gaucher and Niemann-Pick type-C disease. Although the abundance of a ganglioside product of glucosylceramide (i.e. leucocyte surface GM3) has been used experimentally as a biomarker for treatment response in Gaucher disease, there has been no suggestion of using the desaturation index of glucosylceramide as a biomarker for treatment response to inhibitors of glucosylceramide synthase in such diseases. Likewise, although the abundance of nervonic acid (24:1) in the global plasma fatty acid profile and in sphingolipids (namely ceramide, sphingomyelin and cerebrosides) is decreased in rat and murine models of type-I diabetes (Fox, Bewley et al. 2011), until now there has been no suggestion that the desaturation index of glucosylceramide may be used as a marker of disease activity or response to insulin sensitizing agents in type-II diabetes. Here the inventors suggest that metabolic syndrome and type-II diabetes may be characterized by elevation of the desaturation index of glucosylceramide in VLDL (due to hyperinsulinaemia), and that treatment with insulin sensitizing agents (such as select iminosugars, biguanides and thiazolidinediones) may reduce this index towards normality, by improving insulin sensitivity (specifically with respect to the glucose-uptake response of the tissues stimulated by insulin, and reduction of glucose production by the liver) and correcting hyperinsulinemia.
Given that metabolic syndrome and type-II diabetes are adverse prognostic indicators for treatment response in HCV with interferon+ribavirin (Clement, Pascarella et al. 2009; Eslam, Khattab et al. 2011), it may also follow that the desaturation index of blood VLDL GlcCer and/or LacCer may be used to identify HCV-infected subjects who are unlikely to respond to interferon+ribavirin. For example, an HCV-infected patient presenting with an abnormally high desaturation index of GlcCer or LacCer expressed as the ratio of 24:1/24:0 (e.g. having hyperinsulinaemia due to undiagnosed metabolic syndrome) may be less-likely to respond to interferon+ribavirin, and may require more aggressive treatment with newly licensed drugs (either alone, or in combination with each other or with interferon+ribavirin). Likewise, such a patient would be more likely than other HCV infected patients to respond to therapy with an iminosugar inhibitor of glucosylceramide synthase, which would reduce hyperinsulinaemia by improving insulin sensitivity in the tissues (including liver). By making sure that hepatitis-C patients receive drugs that they are more likely to respond to, patients may benefit and the cost of treatment may be reduced.
Although the desaturation index of palmitoleic 16:1/16:0, in blood VLDL triglycerides, has been advocated as a marker of metabolic disease (Peter, Cegan et al. 2009), i.e. is elevated in metabolic syndrome, this marker strategy does not anticipate the particular value of the glucosylceramide desaturation index identified here, which is especially relevant to insulin sensitivity by dint of the insulin-sensitizing effects of the iminosugars exemplified by the adamantly compound AMP-DNJ/AMP-DNM, which demonstrates the involvement of glycosphingolipids in the regulation of insulin signaling. Moreover, the present results may indicate that the 16:1/16:0 ratio (unlike the desaturation index of glucosylceramide) would tend to be reduced in infected cells, where HCV infection reduces this ratio (at least in the context of the global fatty acid profile of infected cells) limiting its usefulness as a marker of metabolic disease in the context of HCV infection.
Blood contains several different lipoprotein forms, some of which vary dynamically over time following ingestion of food. For example, fats are absorbed in the form of chylomicrons which are highest following a meal and which disappear quite rapidly postprandially (within six hours). The chylomicrons contain predominantly dietary fats and comprise triglycerides, diglycerides, cholesterol esters, free cholesterol, phospholipids and free fatty acids. In contrast, VLDL is a product of the liver and contains remodeled and repackaged triglycerides and cholesterol esters, as well as surface phospholipids, all of which, according to the inventors' hypothesis, may be influenced by the metabolic effects of HCV infection upon cellular lipid metabolism. Although for some of the identified various lipid biomarkers suitable for the assessment of the metabolic impact of HCV upon the liver cell their measurement in blood plasma may be liable to be confounded by the varying background of dietary lipids in the form of chylomicrons, some other identified markers, such as C54:6-C18:1 triglyceride (elevated 96-fold by infection) may still be useful if measured in unfractionated plasma, either in the fasted or postprandial state. Moreover, recent studies of the global fatty acid profile of human plasma have shown that the abundance of the various fatty acid species is controlled within narrow limits (Lamaziere, Wolf et al. 2012), suggesting that the effect of background dietary fluctuations on the lipid molecular profile biomarkers of hepatitis-C described here would not be so severe as to negate their use as biomarkers of the metabolic impact of HCV infection, although it is recognized that the straightforward global fatty acid profile of blood plasma may have limited usefulness for biomarker purposes (Flowers 2009). However, there may be at least two solutions to the confounding effect of dynamic variation in dietary plasma lipids.
Under fasting circumstances, VLDL is the predominant lipoprotein reservoir of triglycerides in the blood (Flowers 2009; Peter, Cegan et al. 2009). Thus, plasma triglyceride composition may be equivalent to VLDL triglyceride composition under fasting circumstances. Thus, at least with respect to the triglyceride molecular species profile characterized here as indicative of the effects of HCV infection on liver metabolism, one may expect, in the fasted state, that analysis of unfractionated plasma may be adequate for the biomarker purposes described here.
A second solution to the confounding problem of background dietary lipids may be a separation of VLDL from blood by an appropriate separation technique, such as density gradient ultracentrifugation or by a chromatographic method. Likewise (in the case of triglycerides) purification of triglycerides from blood plasma can be achieved by thin-layer chromatography or HPLC. Suitable methods for the isolation of VLDL and triglyceride fractions from human plasma are described in, for example, Peter et al. 2009.
With respect to measurement of the desaturation index (24:1/24:0) of glucosylceramide, it should be recognized that VLDL (being derived from liver) is also the appropriate blood lipoprotein to analyze, as for the other markers described above (e.g. particular triglyceride species). However, it is recognized that sphingomyelin is much more abundant among circulating sphingolipids than is glucosylceramide (Hammad, Pierce et al. 2010). In addition to measuring the desaturation of glucosylceramide in VLDL, it may be convenient or more sensitive to measure the 24:1/24:0 desaturation index of sphingomyelin, which the inventors have found to be affected by iminosugars in a similar way to glucosylceramide with respect to desaturation index.
Huh7.5 and Jc1 HCV Cell Culture:
Methods for cell culture of replication-competent HCV in human hepatoma cells were essentially as described (Pollock, Nichita et al. 2010). Huh7.5 cells (Apath, LLC) were grown in DMEM supplemented with 100 U/ml penicillin, 100 μg/ml streptomycin, 2 mM L-glutamine, 1×MEM, and 10% FBS. All incubations were at 37° C./5% CO2. The effect of iminosugar treatment on cellular lipid profiles was determined for both uninfected and HCVcc-infected cells. In order to infect cells with HCV strain Jc1 (genotype 2a), Huh7.5 cells were incubated for 1 h in the presence of the virus at a multiplicity of infection (MOI)=0.02 using a viral stock of known titer. Cells were passaged for approximately 2 weeks to allow the infection to reach close to 100% of cells as determined by HCV core protein immunofluorescence, in order to avoid dilution of ‘infected’ lipidomic signatures by uninfected cells in partially infected cultures. Both HCV-infected and uninfected cells were then incubated in the presence or absence of iminosugars for 4 days, at which point they were harvested using trypsin/EDTA, washed 3 times in cold PBS, counted using trypan blue staining, and final cell pellets were resuspended in methanol:acetone (vol 1:1) prior to lipid profiling, A small volume of each sample was used for total protein estimation using the Bradford protein assay (Bio-Rad).
“Total Lipid” Fatty Acid Profiling:
The procedure for “total lipid” FA measurements by GCMS has been described previously (Wolf 2008; Quinn, Rainteau et al. 2009) Briefly, pellets of cultured hepatoma Huh7.5 cells were extracted with chloroform using the method of Bligh & Dyer (Bligh and Dyer 1959). Briefly, chloroform lipid extracts of pelleted cultured hepatoma Huh7.5 cells was added with heptadecanoic acid as the internal standard. The solvent extract was dried in vacuo and the dry lipid film was transmethylated with methanol/H2SO4 (18N, 2% vol/vol) at 70° C. for 1 hour. An inert nitrogen/argon atmosphere, and addition of butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) as antioxidant. Teflon-sealed disposable glass tubes were used to minimize peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids. After cooling, water (1/2: vol/vol) was added and FA methyl esters (FAME) were extracted into hexane. The hexane extract was concentrated under a stream of nitrogen gas and transferred to an autosampler vial fitted with a 200 μl glass insert (Agilent 5975; 91940 Les Ulis, France). An aliquot of 1 μl was injected in the splitless mode of the GCMS apparatus (Agilent 5975; 91940 Les Ulis, France). Unsaturated FAME isomers (omega double-bond position at n3, n6, n7, n9) were separated on a polar bonded polyethylene-glycol capillary column (Omegawax; Sigma-Aldrich, L'Isle d'Abeau Chesnes 38297 Saint-Quentin Fallavier, France). Adducts (FAME+NH+4) were assayed in chemical ionization mode with ammonia as the reagent gas (≈10−4 Torr, source temperature ≈100° C.). Quantification was performed by peak area integration after normalization relative to the internal standard (heptadecanoic acid) and calibration of the response coefficient with a Ponderal calibration mixture (Mix-37; Supelco-Sigma-Aldrich L'Isle d'Abeau Chesnes 38297 Saint-Quentin Fallavier, France).
Total Cholesterol (GCMS):
Total (esterified and non estified) cholesterol and sterol metabolites were derivatized to trimethylsilylether and profiled by GCMS as described in (Chevy, Illien et al. 2002; Chevy, Humbert et al. 2005). Briefly, the lipid chloroform extracts were added with d7-choroform (Avanti Polar Lipids, Lipid MS standards, Alabaster, Ala. 35007) and epicoprostanol (Sigma-Aldrich) as the internal standard. After fatty acid transmethylation as indicated above for the FAME preparation, the hexane extract was dried under a stream of nitrogen gas. Sterols were silylated for 60 min at 60° C. with 0.5 ml BSTFA (N,O-bis(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide) and TMCS 1% (trimethylchlorosilane) (Supelco Sigma-Aldrich 38297 Saint-Quentin-Fallavier Cedex). Excess reagent was evaporated and silylated sterols dissolved in hexane for GC injection. The separation of cholesterol and metabolites was performed between 200 and 250° C. on a medium polarity bonded diphenyl-dimethyl-polysiloxane capillary column (RTX50; Restek France Lisses France 9109). Detection and quantification relative to a Ponderal calibrator mixture was achieved by peak integration of characteristic ion-fragments in the positive mode (electron impact energy 70 eV).
LCMS2 Lipidomic Measurements:
The LCMS2 procedure has been detailed previously in methodological reviews (Ivanova, Milne et al. 2007; Myers, Ivanova et al. 2011). Briefly, the phospholipid chloroform extracts are prepared from pelleted Huh7.5 cells. A mixture of internal lipid standards was added to the extract (Avanti Polar Lipids, Lipid MAPS MS standards, Alabaster, Ala. 35007). The lipid classes were separated by HPLC (Agilent 1200 Series) on a polyvinyl-alcohol functionalized silica column (PVASil, YMC, ID 4 mm, length 250 mm, Interchim, Montluçon 03100, France). Less polar lipids (triglycerides, diglycerides, cholesterol esters, ceramides, glucosyl- and lactosylceramides) are eluted between 5 and 15 minutes by the solvent system hexane/isopropanol/water ammonium acetate 10 mM (40/58/2 vol/vol). Phospholipids were subsequently eluted by the solvent hexane/isopropanol/water ammonium acetate 10 mM (40/50/10 vol/vol) as a function of an increasing polarity between 15 and 60 minutes in the following order: phosphatidylethanolamine, lysophosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylinositol, phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin, lysophosphatidylcholine. Eluted lipids were channeled into the electrospray interface of the spectrometer (Turbolon, Framingham, Mass. 01701, USA). The lipid ionization was run in positive mode for M+NH4+ and M+H+ detection. The source was coupled to a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer (API3000, ABSciex, Toronto, Canada) run in the “collision induced dissociation” mode (or “precursor” mode) for monitoring the characteristic fragment ions of the successively eluted lipid classes. Precursor molecular species of the characteristic fragment ion were identified in a library prepared for cultured hepatoma cells with the software LIMSA (Haimi, Chaithanya et al. 2009). Molecular species of lipids being identified, a list of ion pairs (precursor/product ion) was prepared for quantification by multiple reaction monitoring (MRM). The corresponding MRM peaks are time-integrated. The lipid amounts were calculated relative to the appropriate lipid class standard assuming an even response coefficient of all molecular species in the class.
Statistical Methods:
Statistical procedures comparing lipid and fatty acid profiles were performed using the software XLStat® (version 2011. 2; Addinsoft, France). Parametric tests, multivariate analysis, correlation tests and regression procedures were applied as detailed (Golmard 2012).
Although the foregoing refers to particular preferred embodiments, it will be understood that the present invention is not so limited. It will occur to those of ordinary skill in the art that various modifications may be made to the disclosed embodiments and that such modifications are intended to be within the scope of the present invention.
All of the publications, patent applications and patents cited in this specification are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/818,621, filed on May 2, 2013, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety into the present disclosure.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US14/36102 | 4/30/2014 | WO | 00 |