Lock detector for delay or phase locked loops

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6798858
  • Patent Number
    6,798,858
  • Date Filed
    Friday, February 4, 2000
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 28, 2004
    22 years ago
Abstract
The present invention discloses a lock indicator circuit used to indicate a phase lock condition between logic signals. The lock indicator circuit uses a phase detector that generates a pulse width proportional to the phase difference between a reference signal and a feedback signal. Another circuit generates, on each positive edge of the reference and the feedback signals, pulses whose widths are primarily dependent on fixed delay elements. These fixed pulse determine a window in which the pulse from the phase detector will fall as the two signals approach phase lock. Phase lock is signaled by the logic AND of the window pulse and the phase detector pulse. Other circuitry generates a phase lock indication signal if the phase lock signal remains true for a number of consecutive transitions of the reference signal. Likewise a phase unlock indication signal is generated if after phase lock indication, phase unlock occurs and remains for a number of consecutive transitions of the reference signal.
Description




TECHNICAL FIELD




The present invention relates in general to data processing systems, and in particular, to circuitry for detecting when a delay locked or phase locked loop is in a locked or unlocked condition.




BACKGROUND INFORMATION




The use of phase locked loops (PLLs) or delay locked loops (DLLs) is common for clock synthesis and synchronization. These sophisticated analog circuits lock to an incoming reference frequency signal and thus provide a synthesized and synchronized clock for use in many applications such a communications, digital processing, microprocessing, etc. Phase locking is a dynamic process that begins when an input data signal is applied to a phase locking circuit. A reference signal is the other input to the phase locking circuit. When the input data signal is applied, an error signal is generated which is applied to a feedback correction circuit that operates to reduce the value of the error signal. A phase locked loop circuit, like any feedback circuit, has a characteristic response that is determined by the values of circuit elements. Typical of feedback circuits, it takes some time for the circuit to stabilize to an acceptable error condition. For a phase locked loop the circuit would stabilize at an acceptable phase error and after stabilization the synchronization will remain locked provided the input data signal does not change at a rate outside the dynamics of the particular circuit. The lock time of a typical PLL may vary three to four times from a best to a worst case determined by variables comprising temperature, power supply, etc. Because of this variation, for applications using a PLL without a lock indicator, the longest possible lock time is used to insure that the PLL has acquired a lock condition. In a noisy environment, the lock point could be missed, and the PLL potentially could require two or three times a typical lock time “searching” for the lock point. Because of these considerations designers specify a very inflated lock time and thus may cause degradation to a system's performance. There is a need for a lock indication method for PLLs or DLLs that will reduce lock time and give a reliable indication when a phase locked loop is locked.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention employs a circuit that generates a pulse with a width proportional to the phase error between two signals and a pulse when the lagging signal occurs. As the two signals approach phase lock the two pulses become approximately equal. Another similar circuit generates pulses of fixed width dependent on delay elements on each positive edge of the two signals generating a window signal. When the two signals approach phase lock, the pulses generated by the phase detector will fall within the window signal and will have a phase error dependent on the delay of the delay element. Logic that ANDs the phase detector pulse and the window pulse generates a phase lock signal. Additional circuits generate a phase lock indicator if the phase lock signal is true for a number of consecutive transitions of the reference signal. Likewise a phase lock indication is generated if after a phase lock indication the phase lock signal is false for a number of consecutive transitions of the reference signal. In this manner, noise transients and other spurious signals are masked preventing false indications of phase lock or unlock on two signals.




The foregoing has outlined rather broadly the features and technical advantages of the present invention in order that the detailed description of the invention that follows may be better understood. Additional features and advantages of the invention will be described hereinafter which form the subject of the claims of the invention.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




For a more complete understanding of the present invention, and the advantages thereof, reference is now made to the following descriptions taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:





FIG. 1

is a circuit diagram of a prior art phase/frequency detector;





FIG. 2

is an illustration of the waveforms from the prior art phase/frequency detector;





FIG. 3

is an illustration of the waveforms from the prior art phase/frequency detector when in lock;





FIG. 4

is a circuit diagram for a circuit used in embodiments of the present invention;





FIG. 5

is a circuit diagram showing details of a circuit function used in embodiments of the present invention;





FIG. 6

is an illustration of waveforms illustrating timings and relationships of signals in embodiments of the present invention;





FIG. 7

is an illustration of waveforms of circuitry of the present invention illustrating a locked condition; and





FIG. 8

is an illustration of waveforms of circuitry showing signals prior to and after a lock condition.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION




In the following description, numerous specific details are set forth to provide a thorough understanding of the present invention. However, it will be obvious to those skilled in the art that the present invention may be practiced without such specific details. In other instances, well-known circuits have been shown in block diagram form in order not to obscure the present invention in unnecessary detail. For the most part, details concerning specific timing considerations and the like have been omitted in as much as such details are not necessary to obtain a complete understanding of the present invention and are within the skills of persons of ordinary skill in the relevant art.




Refer now to the drawings wherein depicted elements are not necessarily shown to scale and wherein like or similar elements are designated by the same reference numeral through the several views.





FIG. 1

is a diagram of a circuit used in prior art phase locked loops. UP


103


and DOWN


108


are logic signals that indicate a relationship between logic signals REF


105


and FDBK


110


. The waveforms for the case where the circuit is employed to phase lock two signals of the same frequency are shown in FIG.


2


. FF


1




102


and FF


2




111


, shown in

FIG. 1

, are data latches or D-latches known in the art. A D-latch is one that has a “Q” output (positive true) that follows the D input (data) whenever the clock (CLK) is in one state and latches the value of the D input whenever the clock goes to the other state. A reset (RST) on a D-latch will set the Q output to a logic zero. In the example of

FIG. 1

, the D input is coupled to a positive power supply voltage VDD


101


. The Q output (UP


103


) will be set to a logic zero if the output


106


of OR gate OR


1




107


is at a logic zero. The output


106


of OR


1




107


is at a logic one if either UPBAR


104


or DOWNBAR


109


are at a logic one. Since both FF


1




102


and FF


2




111


have their inverted outputs “Q


B


” set to zero whenever the CLK inputs REF


105


and FDBK


110


go positive, UP


103


and DOWN


108


have pulse widths that are a measure of how much lead or lag exists between REF


105


and FDBK


110


. In

FIG. 2

, UP


WIDTH


is a measure of how much FDBK


110


lags REF


105


. TDFF


1


illustrates a delay time before UP


103


goes positive once REF


105


goes positive. Correspondingly, TRESET


DN


represents the time that it takes a FF


2




111


to reset after it is set. TRESET


DN


undergoes a delayed time TDFF


2


propagating through FF


2




111


. UPBAR


104


and DOWNBAR


109


are the complements of UP


103


and DOWN


108


.





FIG. 3

illustrates waveforms of the circuit of

FIG. 1

when REF


105


and FDBK


110


are locked. When REF


105


and FDBK


202


both go positive simultaneously, during lock, the widths of UP


103


and DOWN


108


are determined only by the reset times TRESET


UP


, and TRESET


DN


of FF


1




102


and FF


2




111


respectively. UPBAR


104


and DOWNBAR


109


are again complement outputs of FF


1




102


and FE


2




111


respectively.




The signal FDBK


110


is an exemplary signal, in embodiments of the present invention, which is being altered to bring it into phase lock with and exemplary reference signal REF


105


. UP


WIDTH


, in this case, would be a measure of an error which reduces to a minimal value (depending on gate delays) whenever FDBK


110


and REF


105


are phase locked.




The circuit in

FIG. 5

is an embodiment of the present invention operable to generate pulses on the rising edges of exemplary reference signal REF


105


and feedback signal FDBK


110


.

FIG. 5

illustrates a modification of the phase detector illustrated in FIG.


1


. In this modified phase detector of

FIG. 5

, a delay


514


and delay


513


are inserted in the reset paths of FF


3




502


and FF


4




511


respectively. The two circuits comprising FF


3




502


and FF


4




511


are used to generate pulses on every rising edge of input signals REF


105


and FDBK


110


, the CLK signals of FF


3




502


and FF


4




511


respectively. On each rising edge of REF


105


. for example, FF


3




502


sets its output R_UP


503


to a logic one with VDD


101


as the data input. The output OR gate OR


1




507


will go to a logic zero and after the delay of DELAY


514


and will reset FF


3




501


via RST


506


. The propagation delays of the OR gate OR


1




507


and the DELAY


514


set the width of the pulse on output R_UP


503


. R_DOWN


508


is set in a like manner using FF


4




511


, DELAY


513


and OR


2




514


and RST


512


. R_UPBAR


504


and R_DOWNBAR


509


are the complements of R_UP


503


and R_DOWN


508


respectively.





FIG. 6

is an illustration of the waveforms resulting when signals REF


105


and FDBK


110


are inputted to exemplary circuits as shown in FIG.


1


and

FIG. 5

respectively. In

FIG. 6

outputs UP


103


, DOWN


108


, UPBAR


104


and DOWNBAR


109


are from the circuit depicted in FIG.


1


and R_UP


503


, R_DOWN


508


, R_UPBAR


504


and R_DOWNBAR


509


are from the circuit depicted in FIG.


5


. The waveforms in

FIG. 6

result when the two signals REF


105


and FDBK


110


are out of phase.

FIG. 7

show the same outputs when REF


105


and FDBK


110


are in phase. Note that whenever the two signals are in phase in

FIG. 7

the positive edge of UPBAR


104


(shown as


701


) falls within R—UP


503


. Since the width of R—UP


503


is determined by a delay element, the amount of coincidence between the positive edge of UPBAR


104


and R—UP


503


can be controlled. Signals UP


103


and R_UP


503


are generated off the same edge of REF


105


, however R_UP


503


goes to a logic zero when UP


103


goes to a logic one. When REF


105


and FDBK


110


are out of phase the width of UP


103


being greater the width of R_UP


503


guarantees that there is some time during which both signals are positive. However, when REF


105


and FDBK


110


are in phase UP


103


will fall within the negative portion of R_UP


503


and the two signals are never positive at the same time. Signals DOWNBAR


109


and R_DOWN


508


are generated on the same edge of FDBK


110


. DOWNBAR


109


is a pulse width determined essentially by a D-latch reset time while R_DOWN


508


is set by a delay element whose delay time is longer that the D-latch reset time. As long as FDBK


110


lags REF


105


these two signals will have a time during which they are both positive. If REF


105


lags FDBK


110


the characteristics of the UP signals and the DOWN signals become reversed.





FIG. 4

is a circuit schematic of a phase lock indicator in one embodiment of the present invention. Main PFD


401


is comprised of the circuitry illustrated in

FIG. 1

which generates a signal (UP


420


) proportional to the phase error between REF


418


and FDBK


419


, when REF


418


leads FDBK


419


. If REF


418


leads FDBK


419


, DOWN


422


is a pulse synchronous with the positive edge of FDBK


419


and with a width essentially the reset time of one D-latch making up Main PFD


401


. UPBAR


421


is the complement of UP


420


, and DOWNBAR


423


is the complement of DOWN


422


. Replica PFD


402


in

FIG. 4

generates fixed pulse widths and their complements of the positive edges of both REF


418


and FDBK


419


. These pulses are used as windows to indicate when the two signals are in phase.




The circuit made up of gates AND


1




403


, NAND


1




404


and latch DFF


1




407


generates a phase lock signal A and the circuit made up of like gates AND


2




405


, NAND


2




406


and latch DFF


2




408


generates an enable signal B when REF


418


leads FDBK


419


. The roles of these two circuits swap when FDBK


419


leads REF


418


. Only the case where REF


418


leads FDBK


419


will be discussed in detail since the other case is the same with only the roles of REF


418


and FDBK


419


reversed.




As discussed earlier, when REF


418


is out of phase with FDBK


419


an UPBAR


421


signal is never at a logic one the same time as an R_UP


424


. Since these two signals are ANDed in AND


1




403


, signal A is always a logic zero when REF


418


is out of phase with FDBK


419


. Likewise, as discussed earlier, when REF


418


is out of phase with FDBK


419


a signal UP


420


is always at a logic one for a time coincident with a signal R_UPBAR


425


being at a logic one. These two signals are ANDed in NAND


1




404


and signal B is at a logic zero when the phase difference of REF


418


and FDBK


419


is such that the width of UP


420


is larger than the width of R_UPBAR


425


. As long as REF


418


and FDBK


419


are out of phase, signal A is at a logic zero and signal B is at a logic zero at the positive edge of a REF


418


cycle; signal A never clocks latch DFF


1




407


to a one and signal B keeps latch DFF


1




407


reset to a logic zero and acts as an enable signal. As soon as UP


420


falls into the window set by the Replica PFD


402


, signal B removes the reset to DFF


1




407


and the first positive transition of signal A sets latch DFF


1




407


to a logic one signaling that the signals REF


418


and FDBK


419


are in phase.




During the time that REF


418


and FDBK


419


are in phase or while REF


418


leads FDBK


419


, latch DFF


2




408


is always set to a logic one and signal F enables gate AND


3




411


. When the first phase lock is signaled by the signal E, gate AND


3




411


sets the data input to D-latch DFF


3




409


to a logic one. The next positive transition of REF


418


will likewise set DFF


3




409


to a logic one. Correspondingly, the output of DFF


3




409


sets the data input to DFF


4




410


and a succeeding positive transition on REF


418


will set latch DFF


4




410


to a logic one. In the embodiment in

FIG. 4

, the phase lock signal E must remain at a logic one for three consecutive transitions on REF


418


before all three signals J, I, and H are at a logic one, and signal K will set latch DFF


6


to a logic one generating LOCK


416


the phase lock indication. When any one of the signals J, I, or H are at a logic one gate OR


1




415


removes the reset from DFF


6




413


. In a similar manner as described above REF


418


and FDBK


419


, once a lock indication was signaled on LOCK


416


, would have to lose and maintain an unlock condition before a logic zero would propagate through latches DFF


3




409


, DFF


4




410


and DFF


5




412


setting J, I and H to a logic zero and resetting latch DFF


6




413


via reset input L. As stated earlier, when REF


418


lags FDBK


419


, the roles of latches DFF


1




407


and DFF


2




408


reverse and the same explanation describes the circuit operation.




The phase lock indicator in

FIG. 4

requires a lock signal G and three consecutive transitions of REF


418


to generate a lock indicator signal LOCK


416


. Additional latches may be added in series with DFF


5




412


along with addition inputs to gates AND


4




414


and OR


1




415


to create a requirement of more than three consecutive transitions of REF


418


to set a LOCK


416


indication. It is possible using embodiments of the present invention and an independent chain of D-latches feeding an OR gate like OR


1




415


to create a different number of transitions required for the set of a lock indication than the number of transitions required to reset a lock indication.





FIG. 8

is a logic timing diagram of the nodes of the circuitry in

FIG. 4

showing signals before and after a lock condition.




Although the present invention and its advantages have been described in detail, it should be understood that various changes, substitutions and alterations can be made herein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A method of phase lock indication of a first logic signal and a second logic signal comprising the steps of:generating a phase lock signal when said first and second logic signals are in phase and a phase unlock signal when said first and second logic signals are not in phase; counting a number N of consecutive transitions of said first logic signal occurring during said phase lock signal; and setting a lock indication circuit to one state indicating a lock condition when said number N is reached by said counting step.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, further comprising the steps of:counting a number M of consecutive transitions of said first logic signal occurring during said phase unlock signal; and resetting said lock indication circuit to another state indicating an unlocked condition when said number M is reached.
  • 3. The method of claim 2, wherein N and M are equal.
  • 4. The method of claim 1, wherein generating said phase lock signal comprises the steps of:generating first and second digital phase error signals, said first digital phase error signal having a pulse width proportional to the phase error between like transition edges of said first and second logic signals and commencing on the leading of said first and second logic signals, said second digital phase error signal having a fixed pulse width and commencing on the positive transition of the lagging of said first and second logic signals; generating the complements of said first and second digital phase error signals; generating, on like transition edges of said first and second logic signals, first and second window pulses each having a width; said window pulse widths proportional to fixed delay elements; generating from said digital phase error signals, said complement digital phase error signals, and said window pulses an enable signal and said phase lock signal, said phase lock signal being logic true when said phase error signals are coincident and within said window pulses; counting a number N of consecutive transitions of a reference signal occurring while said phase lock signal is logic true; and setting a lock indication latch to one state indicating said lock condition when said number N is reached.
  • 5. The method of claim 4, further comprising;counting a number M of consecutive transitions of said first logic signal occurring when said phase lock signal is a logic false; and resetting said lock indication circuit to another state indicating an unlocked condition when said number M is reached.
  • 6. The method of claim 5, wherein N and M are equal.
  • 7. A system for indicating the phase lock of a first logic signal and a second logic signal comprising:a phase detector circuit receiving as inputs said first and second logic signals and generating phase detector output signals; a window pulse generator receiving as inputs said first and second logic signals and generating window pulse output signals; a phase lock circuit receiving said phase detector output signals and said window pulse output signals and generating a phase lock signal; a counting circuit receiving said phase lock signal and said first logic signal and generating a first and second count signal; and a phase lock indicator circuit, said phase lock indicator circuit having a phase lock indicator signal, said phase lock indicator signal set to a logic one by said first count signal and reset to a logic zero by said second count signal.
  • 8. The system of claim 7, wherein said phase detector output signals comprise:a first phase detector and complement first phase detector output signals with pulse widths proportional to the difference in phase between like transitions of said first and second logic signals; and a second phase detector and complement second phase detector output signals with fixed pulse widths independent of said phase difference and commencing on an edge of said first logic signal.
  • 9. The system of claim 7, wherein said window pulse output signals comprise:a first window and complement first window output signals with pulse widths dependent on a delay element and commencing on a first transition edge of said first logic signal; and a second window and complement second window output signals with pulse widths dependent on said delay element and commencing on said same first transition edge of said second logic signal.
  • 10. The system of claim 7, wherein said phase lock signal is generated when one of said phase detector output signals is coincident with one of said window output signals indicating a phase lock of said first and second logic signals.
  • 11. The system of claim 10, wherein said phase lock signal is set to a logic one when said first and second logic signals are phase locked and reset to a logic zero when said first and second logic signals are not phase locked.
  • 12. The system of claim 7, wherein said counting circuit comprises:a multistage D-latch shift register, said multistage D-latch shift register receiving said phase lock signal as an input and said first logic signal as a clock; a multiple input AND gate, said AND gate receiving as input an output of each of said D-latches in said shift register; an AND gate having as inputs each output of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator clock; and an OR gate having as inputs each of said outputs of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator reset.
  • 13. The system of claim 12, wherein said phase lock indicator circuit is a D-latch with said first count signal as said clock and said second count signal as a reset.
  • 14. The system of claim 13, wherein said first count signal is said phase lock indicator clock.
  • 15. The system of claim 13, wherein said second count signal is said phase lock indicator reset.
  • 16. A processor system, comprising:one or more microprocessor integrated circuits; random access memory (RAM); and interconnecting circuitry for connecting said microprocessor integrated circuit(s) and said RAM; said microprocessor integrated circuit(s), said RAM, and said interconnecting circuitry further comprising loop circuitry comprising one or more loops, each loop being either a PLL or a DLL, said loop circuitry further comprising: a phase detector circuit receiving as inputs first and second logic signals and generating phase detector output signals; a window pulse generator receiving as inputs said first and second logic signals and generating window pulse output signals; a phase lock circuit receiving said phase detector output signals and said window pulse output signals and generating a phase lock signal; a counting circuit receiving said phase lock signal and said first logic signal and generating a first and second count signal; and a phase lock indicator circuit, said phase lock indicator circuit having a phase lock indicator signal, said phase lock indicator signal set to a logic one by said first count signal and reset to a logic zero by said second count signal.
  • 17. The processor system of claim 16, wherein said phase detector output signals comprise:a first phase detector and complement first phase detector output signals with pulse widths proportional to the difference in phase between like transitions of said first and second logic signals; and a second phase detector and complement second phase detector output signals with fixed pulse widths independent of said phase difference and commencing on an edge of said first logic signal.
  • 18. The processor system of claim 16, wherein said window pulse output signals comprise:a fist window and complement first window output signals with pulse widths dependent on a delay element and commencing on a first transition edge of said first logic signal; and a second window and complement second window output signals with pulse widths dependent of said delay element and commencing on said same first transition edge of said second logic signal.
  • 19. The processor system of claim 16, wherein said phase lock signal is generated when one of said phase detector output signals is coincident with one of said window output signals indicating a phase lock of said first and second logic signals.
  • 20. The processor system of claim 19, wherein said phase lock signal is set to a logic one when said first and second logic signals are phase locked and reset to a logic zero when said first and second logic signals are not phase locked.
  • 21. The processor system of claim 16, wherein said counting circuit comprises:a multistage D-latch shift register, said multistage D-latch shift register receiving said phase lock signal as an input and said first logic signal as a clock; a multiple input AND gate, said AND gate receiving as input an output of each of said D-latches in said shift register; an AND gate having as inputs each output of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator clock; and an OR gate having as inputs each of said outputs of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator reset.
  • 22. The processor system of claim 21, wherein said phase lock indicator circuit is a D-latch with said first count signal as said clock and said second count signal as a reset.
  • 23. The processor system of claim 22, wherein said first count signal is said phase lock indicator clock.
  • 24. The processor system of claim 22, wherein said second count signal is said phase lock indicator reset.
  • 25. A processor, comprising:loop circuitry comprising one or more loops, each loop being either a PLL or a DLL, said loop circuitry further comprising: a phase detector circuit receiving as inputs first and second logic signals and generating phase detector output signals; a window pulse generator receiving as inputs said first and second logic signals and generating window pulse output signals; a phase lock circuit receiving said phase detector output signals and said window pulse output signals and generating a phase lock signal; a counting circuit receiving said phase lock signal and said first logic signal and generating a first and second count signal; and a phase lock indicator circuit, said phase lock indicator circuit having a phase lock indicator signal, said phase lock indicator signal set to a logic one by said first count signal and reset to a logic zero by said second count signal.
  • 26. The processor of claim 25, wherein said phase detector output signals comprise:a first phase detector and complement first phase detector output signals with pulse widths proportional to the difference in phase between like transitions of said first and second logic signals; and a second phase detector and complement second phase detector output signals with fixed pulse widths independent of said phase difference and commencing on [[and]] an edge of said fist logic signal.
  • 27. The processor of claim 25, wherein said window pulse output signals comprise:a first window and complement first window output signals with pulse widths dependent on a delay element and commencing on a first transition edge of said first logic signal; and a second window and complement second window output signals with pulse widths dependent of said delay element and commencing on said same first transition edge of said second logic signal.
  • 28. The processor of claim 25, wherein said phase lock signal is generated when one of said phase detector output signals is coincident with one of said window output signals indicating a phase lock of said first and second logic signals.
  • 29. The processor of claim 28, wherein said phase lock signal is set to a logic one when said first and second logic signals are phase locked and reset to a logic zero when said first and second logic signals are not phase locked.
  • 30. The processor of claim 25, wherein said counting circuit comprises:a multistage D-latch shift register, said multistage D-latch shift register receiving said phase lock signal as an input and said first logic signal as a clock; a multiple input AND gate, said AND gate receiving as input an output of each of said D-latches in said shift register; an AND gate having as inputs each output of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator clock; and an OR gate having as inputs each of said outputs of said multistage D-latch shift register and generating as an output a phase lock indicator reset.
  • 31. The processor of claim 30, wherein said phase lock indicator circuit is a D-latch with said first count signal as said clock and said second count signal as a reset.
  • 32. The processor of claim 31, wherein said first count signal is said phase lock indicator clock.
  • 33. The processor of claim 31, wherein said second count signal is said phase lock indicator reset.
US Referenced Citations (17)
Number Name Date Kind
4970475 Gillig Nov 1990 A
5111160 Hershberger May 1992 A
5189379 Saito et al. Feb 1993 A
5327103 Baron et al. Jul 1994 A
5359635 Atriss et al. Oct 1994 A
5394444 Silvey et al. Feb 1995 A
5410571 Yonekawa et al. Apr 1995 A
5485484 Williams et al. Jan 1996 A
5525932 Kelkar et al. Jun 1996 A
5539357 Rumreich Jul 1996 A
5699020 Jefferson Dec 1997 A
5818304 Hogeboom Oct 1998 A
5870002 Ghaderi et al. Feb 1999 A
5886582 Stansell Mar 1999 A
5905410 Holmes et al. May 1999 A
5956379 Tarleton Sep 1999 A
6265902 Klemmer et al. Jul 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
0 866 559 Sep 1998 EP