Magnetic dipole antenna structure and method

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6567053
  • Patent Number
    6,567,053
  • Date Filed
    Monday, February 12, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 20, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
The spiral sheet antenna allows a small efficient antenna structure that is much smaller than the electromagnetic wavelength. It achieves the small size by introducing a high effective dielectric constant through geometry rather than through a special high dielectric constant material. It typically includes a rectangular cylinder-like shape, with a seam. The edges of the seam can overlap to make a high capacitance, or they can make a high capacitance by simply having the edges of the seam very close to each other. The high capacitance serves the same role as a high dielectric constant material in a conventional compact antenna.
Description




BACKGROUND INFORMATION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates generally to the field of wireless communication, and particularly to the design of an antenna.




2. Description of Related Art




Small antennas are required for portable wireless communications. To produce a resonant antenna structure at a certain radio frequency, it is usually necessary for the structure to be of a size equal to one-half of the electromagnetic wavelength, or for some designs, one-quarter of the electromagnetic wavelength. This is usually still too large.




A conventional solution, to reduce the size further., is to reduce the effective wavelength of the electromagnetic waves, by inserting a material of a high dielectric constant. Then, the internal wavelength is reduced by the square root of the dielectric constant. This requires special high dielectric constant materials that add cost, weight and cause an efficiency penalty. Accordingly, the present invention addresses these needs.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides an effective increase in the dielectric constant purely by geometry, using a spiral sheet configuration. The dielectric material can have a dielectric constant >1, or it can simply be air with dielectric constant 1. Therefore cheaper dielectric materials can be used. Indeed there is nothing cheaper than air.




An antenna, comprising a first plate and a second plate, the combination of the first and second plates serving as a capacitive structure; and a third metallic structure, coupled to the first and second plates, thereby producing a cylindrical or substantially cylindrical current distribution, with two openings or holes at either end of the cylinder-like shape. Although a cylindrical current distribution is described, other shapes of current distribution can be practiced provided that the current is distributed around two openings or holes, that would construct an antenna without departing from the spirit of the present invention. In effect, the overlap between the first and second plates, on the edge of the cylinder, forms a seam between the two holes at the ends of the cylinder-like structure.




Advantageously, the present invention discloses an antenna structure that is more compact, reducing the overall size of a wireless device. The present invention further advantageously reduces the cost of building an antenna by using air as the dielectric. .




Other structures and methods are disclosed in the detailed description below. This summary does not purport to define the invention. The invention is defined by the claims.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a cross-sectional view of a spiral sheet antenna for producing a spiral sheet current distribution in accordance with the present invention. The overlapping plates


11


and


12


form a seam between the two openings at the ends.





FIGS. 2A-2B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating a perspective view of two similar antenna structures having different aspect ratio in length and width, respectively, of a spiral sheet antenna for producing a spiral sheet current distribution in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 3

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a first possible drive configuration for a spiral sheet antenna in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 4

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a second possible drive configuration for a spiral sheet antenna in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 5

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a first embodiment of a cylinder-like antenna having two holes at the ends, with a seam between the two holes for producing a circular current distribution with a double parallel plate in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 6

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a perspective view of a cylinder-like antenna having two holes at the ends, with a seam between the two holes for producing a circular current distribution with a double parallel plate in accordance with the present invention.





FIGS. 7A-7B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating a perspective view and a cross-section view, respectively, of a third drive configuration of the cylinder-like antenna shown in

FIG. 6

for exciting a circular current distribution with a double parallel plate seam in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 8

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a third embodiment of a magnetic dipole sheet antenna having two holes at the ends, with a slot seam between the two holes, allowing a circular current distribution in accordance with the present invention.





FIGS. 9A-9B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating a perspective view and a side cross-section view, respectively, of a first embodiment of a shielded spiral sheet antenna having two holes at the ends and an overlapping seam between the holes, providing shielding from absorbers adjacent to the antenna.





FIGS. 10A-10B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating side views of an operational mathematical technique for determining shielding effectiveness in a shield spiral sheet antenna in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 11

is a pictorial diagram illustrating an operational procedure for determining the center of a hole in a shielded spiral sheet antenna in accordance with the present invention.





FIGS. 12A-12B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating a second embodiment of a shielded spiral sheet antenna with overlapping capacitive seam structure in accordance with the present invention.

FIG. 12B

is a side cross-section view showing the path


128


-


129


followed by magnetic field lines B.





FIG. 13

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a multi-frequency, multi-tap antenna with spring contacts W


1


and W


2


in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 14

is a pictorial diagram illustrating the placement of internal circuit boards inside an antenna in accordance with the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENT(S)





FIG. 1

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a cross-sectional view of a spiral sheet antenna


10


, resembling a rectangular cylindrical shape, with two holes at the ends, and a capacitive seam connecting the two holes, for producing a cylindrical current distribution. The spiral sheet antenna


10


can constructed with three plates, a first plate


11


, a second plate


12


, and a third plate


13


. The variable d


14


represents the spacing between the first plate


11


and the second plate


12


, and the variable t


15


represents the thickness of all three plates. A vertical connection


16


connects between the third plate


13


and the first plate


11


, while the third plate


13


connects to the second plate


12


via a vertical connection


17


. The length of the third plate


13


, between vertical connections


16


and


17


is selected to be less than a quarter wavelength, λ/4n, where n is the square root of the dielectric constant.




The structure of the spiral sheet antenna


10


increases the effective dielectric constant by a factor of t/d. Effective increase in capacitance is due to overlapping plates between the plate


11


and the plate


12


. In effect, the spiral antenna


10


produces a large dielectric constant, without the need for a high dielectric constant material, just from electrode geometry alone, i.e. ε


relative


=t/d. Effectively, treating the spiral sheet antenna as a patch type antenna, the required length of the patch then becomes







a
=


λ
4




d
t


×

1


ε
r





,










where ε


r


is the relative dielectric constant of the capacitor dielectric.





FIG. 2A

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a perspective view of a spiral sheet antenna


20


for producing a cylinder-like current distribution. The spiral sheet antenna


20


has a first hole


21


and a second hole


22


, at the ends, and a capacitive seam connecting the two holes. The alternating current (AC) magnetic field vector B


ω


, is shown entering hole


21


and exiting hole


22


.





FIG. 2B

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a spiral sheet antenna


25


for producing a cylinder-like current distribution with a different aspect ratio, with a first hole


26


and a second hole


27


. The structure shape in

FIG. 2B

is the same as the structure shape in FIG.


2


A. However, the aspect ratio, in

FIG. 2B

, is different from the aspect ratio in FIG.


2


A. The curved vector I represents the general direction of the AC currents.




The spiral antennas


20


and


25


in

FIGS. 2A and 2B

operate like a single-turn solenoids. A single-turn solenoid consists of a cylinder-like current distribution. A significant portion of the electromagnetic radiation produced by the spiral antennas


20


and


25


arises from the alternating current (AC) magnetic field vector B


ω


that enters and exits from the holes at the end of the single turn solenoid.




Advantageously, the antennas


20


and


25


do not require a high dielectric constant ceramic to attain a small dimensional size. The inherent capacitance in the structure of the antennas


20


and


25


allows a low frequency operation according to the formula: ω={fraction (


1


/LC)}, where ω is the frequency in radians/second, L is the inductance of the single turn solenoid formed by


11


,


16


,


13


,


17


and


12


in

FIG. 1.

, and C is the capacitance from the thin overlapping region labeled as the thickness d


15


, or the spacing


14


.





FIG. 3

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a first drive or feed configuration


30


for a spiral sheet antenna producing a cylindrical current distribution. The first drive configuration


30


has a first plate


31


, a second plate


32


, a third plate


33


, a first hole


34


, and a second hole


35


. A drive cable


36


attaches and drives the spiral sheet antenna


20


. In this embodiment, the co-axial drive cable


36


matches any desired input impedance. An optional vertical short circuit wire,


37


, can assist in providing an impedance matching shunt to the spiral sheet antenna


20


.





FIG. 4

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a second drive configuration


40


of a spiral sheet antenna for producing a rectangular cylinder-like current distribution. The second drive configuration


40


has a first plate


41


, a second plate


42


, a third plate


43


, a first hole


44


, and a second hole


45


at the rear opening of the rectangular cylinder. A feed or drive cable


46


attaches and drives the spiral sheet antenna


20


, with an optional impedance matching vertical shunt wire


47


connecting between the second plate


42


and the third plate


43


. Preferably, the material used to construct an antenna might have a high electrical conductivity, e.g. copper depending on the required antenna Q-factor.





FIGS. 3 and 4

illustrate two sample drive configurations applied to the spiral sheet antenna


20


, and are not meant to be an exhaustive listing since many possibilities abound. One of ordinary skill in the art should recognize that there are numerous other similar, equivalent, or different drive configurations that can be practiced without departing from the spirit of the present invention. A spiral sheet antenna


20


produces an AC magnetic field that radiates efficiently in a structure that is smaller than







λ

4



ε
r




,










that is a typical restriction for a patch antenna, where λ is the electromagnetic wavelength in vacuum, and {square root over (ε


r


)} is the microwave refractive index.




The antenna being described here can be regarded as a rectangular metallic enclosure with two openings, (at the ends of the rectangle), and a seam connecting the two holes. The seam functions as a capacitor and can be implemented in several different ways. First, the seam can be constructed as an overlapping region as shown in


20


. Second, a seam can be constructed as slot between two metal sheets as shown in


80


where two edges meet. Third, a seam can be constructed with a slot under which there is an additional metal sheet underneath as shown in


60


.





FIG. 5

is a pictorial diagram


50


illustrating a first embodiment of a rectangular cylindrical sheet antenna with an opening at each end of the rectangular cylinder, and with a seam connecting the two holes at the ends. The seam comprises of a slot over a double parallel plate. The rectangular cylindrical current distribution structure


50


has a second plate


52


overlapping with a first plate


51


in two areas on either side of the slot or seam to provide capacitance. The third plate


53


is far from the first and second plates


51


and


52


, and therefore contributes little to the capacitance. The rectangular cylindrical current distribution structure


50


thus yields the benefit of a large dielectric constant, without the need for a special dielectric material. However, the capacitance is diminished by a factor


4


due to the two capacitors in series from the overlap of the first and second plates


51


and


52


,compared to the same two plates in parallel.





FIG. 6

is a pictorial diagram


60


, a perspective view illustrating the second embodiment of a seam configuration in a rectangular cylindrical sheet antenna. A first hole


61


is positioned in the front of the pictorial diagram


60


, while a second hole


62


is positioned at the back of the pictorial diagram


60


.The rectangular cylindrical sheet antenna may be driven in a number of different ways. A possible approach is to place a wire parallel to the long axis, but off-center to drive currents across the slot.

FIG. 7A

is a pictorial diagram


70


illustrating this, the second type of drive configuration (of the third seam example, illustrated in

FIG. 6

) for the rectangular cylindrical sheet antenna. A coaxial feed cable


74


extends and connects through a third plate


73


, a second plate


72


, and a first plate


71


, to an off-center drive wire


75


.

FIG. 7B

is a pictorial diagram


76


illustrating a side view of this second type of drive configuration. A drive wire


77


is shown in cross-section in FIG.


7


B.





FIG. 8

is a pictorial diagram


80


illustrating a third embodiment of a rectangular cylindrical sheet antenna with a slot seam for producing a magnetic dipole current distribution. The pictorial diagram


80


will not operate at as low a frequency as the spiral sheet structure, all other things being equal, since the capacitance of a slot seam is less than the capacitance of the over-lapping sheets in the spiral sheet structure.





FIG. 9A

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a perspective view, and

FIG. 9B

illustrating a side view, of a first embodiment of a shielded spiral sheet antenna


90


for producing a cylinder-like current distribution. The structure in the shielded spiral sheet antenna


90


is similar to the structure in the spiral sheet antenna


20


. A first hole


91


is at one end of the rectangle, and a second hole


92


is at the other end of the rectangle. An over-lapping seam


93


, connects the two holes together. In the case of a cellphone the pair of holes


91


and


92


is positioned to face away from a user's ear. A base plate


94


, of the shielded spiral sheet antenna


90


, is positioned facing the human body, extending


94




a


beyond the third plate


13


at one end and extending


94




b


beyond the third plate


13


at the other end. The shielded spiral sheet antenna


90


therefore faces away from the human body. The width of the border w and w′ determines the degree of front-to-back shielding ratio. If w≈t and w′≈t, then a shielding ratio of 3 dB or better can be achieved.





FIGS. 10A and 10B

are pictorial diagrams illustrating side views of a operational mathematical technique for defining a shielded spiral sheet antenna. To define the shielded spiral sheet antenna


100


, two center points are chosen, a geometrical center point of a top opening


101


and a geometrical center point of a bottom opening


102


. A path


103


, L


s


, represents the shortest path between the geometrical center point of a top opening


101


and the geometrical center point of a bottom opening


1


(


12


on the short side. A path


104


, L


e


, represents the longest path between the geometrical center point of a top opening


101


and the geometrical center point of a bottom opening


102


on the longer side. The path


103


is shorter than the path


104


that faces a user.




The mathematical relationship between the different variables should be governed by the following inequality, L


s


−L


e


>αt, Eq. (1), in order to provide a good shielding, front-to-back. A value of α≈1 provides some good degree of shielding.





FIG. 11

is a pictorial diagram


110


illustrating an operational procedure for determining the center of a hole for the purposes of our operational mathematical technique for defining a shielded spiral antenna. The geometrical center of the top and bottom openings can be defined as a type of geometrical “center-of-gravity”:













edges





of





opening




(


R
ω

-


R
ω

0


)


=
0




Eq
.





(
2
)














where R


ω


is the set of position vectors at the edges of the opening, and R


ω




0


is the center-of-gravity center point that satisfies the Eq. (2).




This equation defines the center point for use in the mathematical specification in Eq (1). The point around which all the vectors sum to zero, defines the center of the hole, or opening. The type of metallic shielding specified

FIGS. 9A

,


9


B,


10


A, and


10


B, are useful for shielding cell phone antennas from the user.





FIG. 12A

is a pictorial diagram


120


illustrating a perspective view of a second embodiment of a shielded spiral sheet antenna (with overlapping capacitive structure). A first hole


124


and a second hole


125


are positioned to face away from the user. In effect, both the first and second holes


124


and


125


are facing the front. A seam


126


connects between the first hole


124


and the second hole


125


.





FIG. 12B

is a pictorial diagram


127


illustrating a side cross-sectional view of

FIG. 12A

, with AC magnetic field illustrated. The structure diagram has two holes for the magnetic field entering


128


and exiting


129


the antenna. The rectangular openings shown, may be smaller than the width of the rectangle. A rectangular container is intended as an illustration. The rectangular container may be in a shape resembling a cell phone body instead.





FIG. 13

is a pictorial diagram illustrating a dual frequency, dual-tap antenna


130


with a first hole


131


, a second hole


132


, and a third hole


133


. A first seam


135


connects between the first hole


131


and the third hole


133


. A second seam


136


connects between the hole


132


and the hole


133


. Spring contacts w


1


and w


2


can connect to different circuits on a circuit board, such as for operating with main cell phone bands including Personal Communication System (PCS) at 1900 MHz, Global Positioning Systems (GPS) at 1575 MHz, bluetooth, Advanced mobile phone system (amps) at 850 MHz, and 900 MHz cell phone bands. The spring contacts are only an example. The concept is to use multiple taps for the different frequencies that might be needed in a wireless system. The multi-taps would be derived from a single antenna structure.




In general, the antenna structure consists of a metallic enclosure, with holes, or openings. For each independent antenna, or for each frequency band, an additional hole or opening must be provided on the metallic enclosure. For the example in

FIG. 13

, two frequencies, require 3 holes. Likewise n-frequencies would require (n+1) holes or openings, connected by n seams. Some of the n-frequencies might be identical, for the purpose of space or polarization diversity.





FIG. 14

is a pictorial diagram


140


illustrating the placement of one or more internal circuit boards


143


inside an antenna. Radio Frequency Magnetic fields enter a first hole


141


and exit through a second hole


142


. The internal volume in an antenna can be wisely utilized as not to waste any unused empty space. The extra space can be filled with one or more active circuit boards


143


for operation of a cell phone. The internal circuit boards do not interfere much with the internal AC RF magnetic fields inside the antenna structure. This allows the antenna volume to be put to good use in a small volume cell phone.




The above embodiments are only illustrative of the principles of this invention and are not intended to limit the invention to the particular embodiments described. For example, the basic concept in this invention teaches a metallic structure with at least two holes, and a seam. One of ordinary skill in the art should recognize that any type of antenna structure, which possesses these types of characteristics, is within the spirit of the present invention. Furthermore, although the term “holes” are used, it is apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art that other similar or equivalent concepts may be used, such as opening, gaps, spacing, etc. Accordingly, various modifications, adaptations, and combinations of various features of the described embodiments can be practiced without departing from the scope of the invention as set forth in the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An antenna, comprising:a metallic structure having a first hole at the front opening and a second hole at the rear opening; and at least one seam connecting between the first hole at the front opening and the second hole at the rear opening, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure of a spiral sheet type, the at least one seam being constructed between a top plate and a middle plate, the top plate overlapping with the middle plate, the top plate having a left edge connected to the metallic structure, the middle plate having a right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 2. The antenna of claim 1, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure.
  • 3. The antenna of claim 1, further comprising a pair of wires coupled to the antenna, the pair of wires providing energy to the antenna.
  • 4. The antenna of claim 1, further comprising a wire and a ground, the wire and the ground coupled to the antenna for providing energy to the antenna.
  • 5. The antenna of claim 1, wherein an electrical length of the antenna is less than one-quarter wavelength.
  • 6. The antenna of claim 1, wherein the first and second holes are on the same side of the metallic structure.
  • 7. The antenna of claim 1, wherein the position of the first and second holes are facing in the same direction.
  • 8. An antenna, comprising:a metallic structure having a first hole at the front opening and a second hole at the rear opening; and at least one seam connecting between the first hole at the front opening and the second hole at the rear opening, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure of a slot type, the at least one seam being constructed in a gap between a top left plate and a top right plate, the top left plate having a left edge connected to the metallic structure, the top right plate having a right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 9. The antenna of claim 8, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure.
  • 10. The antenna of claim 8, further comprising a pair of wires coupled to the antenna, the pair of wires providing energy to the antenna.
  • 11. The antenna of claim 8, further comprising a wire and a ground, the wire and the ground coupled to the antenna for providing energy to the antenna.
  • 12. The antenna of claim 8, wherein an electrical length of the antenna is less than one-quarter wavelength.
  • 13. The antenna of claim 8, wherein the first and second holes are on the same side of the metallic structure.
  • 14. The antenna of claim 8, wherein the position of the first and second holes are facing in the same direction.
  • 15. An antenna, comprising:a metallic structure having a first hole at the front opening and a second hole at the rear opening; and at least one seam connecting between the first hole at the front opening and the second hole at the rear opening, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure of a double parallel plate type, a top left plate having a left edge and a right edge, a top right plate having a left edge and a right edge, the at least one seam being constructed between a gap on the right edge of the top left plate and on the left edge of a top right plte, the top left plate overlapping with a middle plate, the top right plate overlapping with the middle plate, the top having plate having the left edge connected to the metallic structure, the top right plate having the right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 16. The antenna of claim 15, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure.
  • 17. The antenna of claim 15, further comprising a pair of wires coupled to the antenna, the pair of wires providing energy to the antenna.
  • 18. The antenna of claim 15, further comprising a wire and a ground, the wire and the ground coupled to the antenna for providing energy to the antenna.
  • 19. The antenna of claim 15, wherein an electrical length of the antenna is less than one-quarter wavelength.
  • 20. The antenna of claim 15, wherein the first and second holes are on the same side of the metallic structure.
  • 21. The antenna of claim 15, wherein the position of the first and second holes are facing in the same direction.
  • 22. An antenna comprising:a metallic enclosure with a plurality of openings or holes, each opening of hole corresponding to a different frequency band; and one or more capacitive seams connecting the openings together, the capacitive seams including slots in the metal or allow for overlap of metal at the capacitive seam, to provide more capacitance, wherein the at least one or more seams comprises a capacitive structure of a spiral sheet type, the at least one seam being constructed between a top plate and a middle plate, the top plate overlapping with the middle plate, the top plate having a left edge connected to the metallic structure, the middle plate having a right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 23. The antenna of claim 22, wherein the one or more capacitive seams comprises a spiral sheet type, a slot type, or a double plate parallel type.
  • 24. An antenna comprising:a metallic enclosure with a plurality of openings or holes, each opening of hole corresponding to a different frequency band; and one or more capacitive seams connecting the openings together, the capacitive seams including slots in the metal or allow for overlap of metal at the capacitive seam, to provide more capacitance, wherein the one or more seams comprises a capacitive structure of a slot type, the at least one seam being constructed in a gap between a top left plate and a top right plate, the top left plate having a left edge connected to the metallic structure, the top right plate having a right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 25. The antenna of claim 24, wherein the one or more capacitive seams comprises a spiral sheet type, a slot type, or a double plate parallel type.
  • 26. An antenna comprising:a metallic enclosure with a plurality of openings or holes, each opening of hole corresponding to a different frequency band; and one or more capacitive seams connecting the openings together, the capacitive seams including slots in the metal or allow for overlap of metal at the capacitive seam, to provide more capacitance, wherein the at least one seam comprises a capacitive structure of a double parallel plate type, a top left plate having a left edge and a right edge, a top right plate having a left edge and a right edge, the at least one seam being constructed between a gap on the right edge of the top left plate and on the left edge of a top right plte, the top left plate overlapping with a middle plate, the top right plate overlapping with the middle plate, the top having plate having the left edge connected to the metallic structure, the top right plate having the right edge connected to the metallic structure.
  • 27. The antenna of claim 26, wherein the one or more capacitive seams comprises a spiral sheet type, a slot type, or a double plate parallel type.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application relates to concurrently filed, co-pending application U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/781,779, entitled “Spiral Sheet Antenna Structure and Method” by Eli Yablonovitch et al., owned by the assignee of this application and incorporated herein by reference, filed on Feb. 12, 2001. This application relates to concurrently filed, co-pending application U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/781,780, entitled “Shielded Spiral Sheet Antenna Structure and Method” by Eli Yablonovitch et al., owned by the assignee of this application and incorporated herein by reference, filed on Feb. 12, 2001. This application relates to concurrently filed, co-pending application U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/781,723, entitled “Internal Circuit Board in an Antenna Structure and Method Thereof” by Eli Yablonovitch et al., owned by the assignee of this application and incorporated herein by reference, filed on Feb. 12, 2001.

US Referenced Citations (9)
Number Name Date Kind
3648172 Nakahara et al. Mar 1972 A
3845487 Lammers Oct 1974 A
4328502 Scharp May 1982 A
5184144 Thombs Feb 1993 A
5337065 Bonnet et al. Aug 1994 A
5726666 Hoover et al. Mar 1998 A
5754143 Warnagiris et al. May 1998 A
5764190 Murch et al. Jun 1998 A
5900843 Lee May 1999 A
Non-Patent Literature Citations (2)
Entry
Wheeler, Harold A., Small Antennas, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation. Jul. 1975.
Sievenpiper, D.; Zhang, L.; Broas, Romulo F. Jimenez; Alexopolous, Nicholas G; Yablonovitch, Eli. High-Impedance Electromagnetic Surfaces With a Forbidden Frequency Band—IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol. 47, No. 11, Nov., 1999.