Matrix bed for generating non-planar reaction wave fronts, and method thereof

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6257869
  • Patent Number
    6,257,869
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, October 13, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, July 10, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A matrix bed is disclosed in which a non-planar reaction wave front is formed during operation. This is accomplished by heating the matrix bed, containing heat-resistant material, until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for a plurality of reactant gas streams to react. Next, the reactant gas streams are directed through the matrix bed in a manner so as to form at least a Bunsen, Burke-Schumann, inverted-V, or some other type of non-planar reaction wave front at the portion of the matrix bed that is heated above the reactant gas streams reaction temperature. At the non-planar reaction wave front, the reactant gas streams react to produce a reaction product gas stream that is then exhausted from the matrix bed.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Description




This invention relates to reacting a plurality of reactant gas streams in a matrix bed of heat-resistant matter. More particularly, this invention relates to increasing the volumetric reaction rate of the matrix beds.




2. Description of the Related Art




The prior art discloses reacting a plurality of reactant gas streams in a reactor having a matrix bed of heat-resistant material such that a planar reaction wave front is formed within the matrix bed. Examples of such reactors include stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizers and recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizers, as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,320,518 to Stilger et al. entitled “Method and Apparatus for Recuperative Heating of Reactants in an Reaction Matrix” (“Stilger”), which is incorporated herein in its entirety by reference. In general, flameless thermal oxidizers operate by flamelessly thermally oxidizing gases within a porous matrix bed of heat-resistant material. The oxidation is called “flameless” because it may occur outside the normal premixed fuel/air flammability limits. Other examples and variations of flameless thermal oxidizers are disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,688,495; 4,823,711; 5,165,884; 5,533,890; 5,601,790; 5,635,139; 5,637,283; and 6,126,913, all of which are incorporated by reference herein in their entireties.




Prior Art

FIG. 1

shows an example of a stabilized wave flameless thermal oxidizer. The oxidizer comprises a processor


10


having a matrix bed


11


of heat-resistant packing material supported at the bottom by a plenum


12


for distributing a mixture of a plurality of reactant gases


18


entering the matrix


11


. The packing material may be comprised of ceramic balls, saddles, or ceramic foam of varying shapes and sizes or of other suitable heat-resistant packing. A void


13


over the top of the matrix


11


precedes an exit means


25


that penetrates the end wall


14


through which exhaust gases


22


exhaust. Through the bottom of the processor


10


is an inlet means


23


through which reactant gases


18


are introduced into the processor


10


. The reactant gases


18


include control air, fuel, and process gas. If necessary, the fuel, air, or process gas may be heated prior to introduction to processor


10


by applying external heat to the mixed process gas prior to entering the processor


10


. The plenum and lower portion of the matrix


11


may be heated by a suitable preheater


19


that, for example, may pass forced heated air into the processor


10


, or heat the bed by electrical means. At various points in the matrix


11


are located temperature sensing devices such as thermocouples


20


from which the output is fed into a microprocessor or programmable logic controller


21


that, in turn, controls the proportions, volumetric flowrate, and temperature of the input gases entering the processor


10


. The term “volumetric flowrate” shall be understood to refer to volumetric flowrate and/or mass flowrate.




Referring now to Prior Art

FIG. 2

, there is shown a schematic of the internal temperature zones and reaction wave front


22


of the stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer. Typically, during operation, there will be a cool zone


27


below the uniform oxidation or combustion temperature that is being maintained within the reaction wave front. A planar reaction wave front


22


occurs in the matrix and has a stable shape with a radial, substantially uniform temperature distribution. Above the planar reaction wave front


22


will be a hot region


26


. By using temperature sensors


20


, the planar reaction wave front


22


may be relocated within the matrix by controlling the volumetric flows and conditions at the input end of the processor


10


.




Referring now to Prior Art

FIG. 3

, a processor


80


of a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer has an inlet port


88


, an exhaust port


90


, a heating port


92


, a barrier


100


, and a matrix bed


104


. The inlet port


88


leads to an inlet plenum


94


at the bottom of the processor


80


. A number of feed tubes


96


extend through an impermeable, rigid tubesheet


98


preferably made of steel or metal alloy, and a heat-resistant ceramic insulating barrier


100


at the roof of the plenum


94


. The tubesheet


98


provides mechanical support for the tubes


96


. The lower ends of the feed tubes


96


are provided with caps


102


to retain the matrix bed


104


inside the tubes


96


. The caps


102


are provided with orifices


106


to permit the flow of gases from the inlet plenum


94


to the tubes


96


. The matrix bed


104


is made up of heat-resistant packing material, as with the stabilized wave flameless thermal oxidizer, that is supported by the barrier


100


. The packing material fills the region between the barrier


100


and the void


108


at the top of the processor


80


including the interior of the feed tubes


96


. The matrix bed


104


may be heated by forcing heated gases, such as air, in through the heating port


92


, and extracting the heated gases through the exhaust port


90


. Alternatively, the bed may be heated by electric heaters or other means. During preheating, a low volumetric flow of ambient air may be bled through the inlet port


88


and up through the heat exchanger/feeding tubes


96


to ensure the tube material is not overheated, and to help establish the desired system temperature profile. Once the matrix bed


104


of the recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer has been preheated, the gases are introduced to the processor


80


through the inlet port


88


. An adjusting means (not shown), that is analogous to the microprocessor or programmable logic controller


21


shown in Prior Art

FIG. 1

, also controls the volumetric flowrate and composition of the process gases to maintain a stable, planar reaction wave front that is similar to the planar reaction wave front


22


shown in Prior Art FIG.


2


. Exhaust gases are extracted from the processor


80


through the exhaust port


90


.




Now referring to Prior Art

FIG. 4

, a regenerative bed destruction system


210


, an example of which is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,188,804 to Pace et al., entitled “Regenerative Bed Incinerator and Method of Operating Same” (“Pace”), and which is incorporated herein in its entirety by reference, may also be used to treat plurality of reactant gas streams


203


. The destruction system


210


comprises a housing


212


enclosing a matrix bed


214


, a lower gas plenum


216


disposed subadjacent the matrix bed


214


, and an upper gas plenum


218


disposed superadjacent the matrix bed


214


. Both the lower gas plenum


216


and the upper gas plenum


218


are provided with gas flow aperture openings


220


and


220


′, respectively. These openings


220


and


220


′ alternately serve as gas flow inlets or outlets depending upon the general direction of the flow of the reactant gas streams mixture through the matrix bed, which is periodically reversed as discussed hereinafter. A heating means


222


, such as an electric resistance heating coil, is embedded within the central portion of the matrix bed


214


. The heating means


222


is selectively energized to preheat the material in the central portion of the matrix bed


214


to a temperature sufficient to initiate and sustain a planar reaction wave front similar to the planar reaction wave front


22


shown in Prior Art FIG.


2


.




During operation of the regenerative bed destruction system


210


, the gas stream


203


flows into the bed


214


through either the lower gas plenum


216


or the upper gas plenum


216


. The gas stream


203


flows through a supply duct


240


to a valve means


230


. The valve means


230


receives the stream


203


through a first port


332


and selectively directs the received streams


203


through either the second port


234


or the third port


236


. When the gas stream


203


is directed through the second port


234


, the gas stream flows through duct


260


and opening


220


and into the lower plenum


216


. When the gas stream


203


is directed through the third port


236


, the gas stream flows through the duct


260


′ and opening


220


′ and into the upper plenum


218


. The fourth port


238


of the valve means


230


is connected to the exhaust duct


270


through which the reactant product gas stream


205


is vented to the atmosphere. At spaced time intervals, the valve means


230


is actuated by controller


280


to reverse the flow of gases through the matrix bed


214


. Every time that the flow is reversed, the role of the lower and upper gas plenums


216


and


218


is reversed with one going from serving as an inlet plenum to serving as an outlet plenum for the destruction system


210


, while the other goes from serving as an outlet plenum to serving as an inlet plenum for the destruction system


210


. In this manner, the upper and lower portions of the matrix bed alternately absorb heat from the reactant product gas stream leaving the central portion of the matrix bed from the shifting planar reaction wave front (not shown).




As previously noted, it is necessary to redirect the flow of gas stream


203


through the regenerative bed destruction system


210


to maintain a proper, planar, temperature profile within the matrix bed


214


. Optimally, the planar temperature profile is hottest in the bed's center and cooler at its upstream and downstream edges. During proper operation, the reaction wave front migrates back and forth in the central portion of the matrix bed


214


in a direction parallel to the gas flow. If the gas flow direction is not properly switched, the reaction wave front will move out of the central portion of the matrix bed


214


and destroy the optimum temperature profile. To switch the gas flow direction, a controller means


280


activates the gas switching means


230


at timed intervals to reverse the direction of flow of the process exhaust gases. The controller means


280


also selectively activates the gas switching valve means


230


in response to the temperature of the reactant product gas stream


205


. To this end, a temperature sensing means


290


, such as a thermocouple, is disposed in the exhaust gas duct


270


at a location downstream of the gas switching valve means


230


for measuring the temperature of the reactant product gas stream


205


. The temperature sensing means


290


generates a temperature signal


295


that is indicative of the temperature of the stream


205


leaving the downstream portion of the matrix bed


214


, and transmits the temperature signal


295


to the controller means


280


.




Other regenerative bed destruction systems may have multiple matrix beds, as is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,267,152 to Benedick entitled “Anti-Pollution Thermal Regeneration Apparatus” (“Benedick”); U.S. Pat. No. 3,895,918 to Mueller entitled “High Rate Thermal Regeneration Anti-Pollution System” (“Mueller”); U.S. Pat. No. 3,870,474 to Houston entitled “Regenerative Incinerator Systems for Waste Gases” (“Houston”); and U.S. Pat. No. 4,741,690 to Heed entitled “Process for Combustion or Decomposition of Pollutants and Equipment Therefor” (“Heed”), all of which are incorporated herein in their entireties by reference. In these systems (not shown), the plurality of reactant gas streams react in a first matrix bed, pass through an incinerator, and pass through a second matrix bed. The flow of the plurality of reactant gas streams is later reversed such that streams react in the second matrix bed, pass through the incinerator, and through the first matrix bed. As the gases react in the initial matrix bed through which they flow, they may or may not form a reaction wave. These and other matrix bed reactor systems that form a reaction wave have an overall volumetric reaction rate limited by the area of the wave front. The overall volumetric reaction rate is the reactions occurring per matrix bed volume per time. The volumetric flowrates of the reactant gas streams are adjusted to establish and maintain the planar reaction wave front within the matrix bed. The overall volumetric reaction rate of the reactant gas streams cannot be raised by merely increasing the gas stream volumetric flowrates as this would push the planar reaction wave front out of the matrix bed, regardless of matrix bed length. To accommodate increased volumetric flowrates, the cross-sectional area of the matrix bed needs to be increased, thereby increasing the area of the planar reaction wave front.




However, simply increasing the area of the existing planar reaction wave front to accommodate increased reactant gas streams increases the size, and cost, of the matrix bed. Matrix bed reactor systems that generate planar reaction wave fronts have limits on their overall volumetric reaction rates based on their cross sectional areas. As a result, the volume of the matrix bed is dictated by the amount of reactions that will occur in the planar reaction wave front, preventing the design of a reduced-size matrix bed for applications with limited available space.




Thus, a need exists to provide a matrix bed with an increased overall volumetric reaction rate for reacting a plurality of reactant gas streams in a reaction wave front with the matrix bed having reduced fabricating costs and/or reduced space requirements.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is directed toward matrix beds providing optimized overall volumetric reaction rates that are configured so as to react a plurality of reactant gas streams in at least a non-planar wave front.




Accordingly, it is an alternative object of the invention to provide a method for increasing the overall volumetric reaction rate of one or more reactant gas streams reacting to form one or more non-planar reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed comprising heat-resistant matter. The non-planar reaction wave front may take the form of a Bunsen reaction wave front, a Burke-Schumann reaction wave front, an inverted-V reaction wave front, a non-planar reaction wave front that corresponds to a non-planar surface of the matrix bed, a non-planar reaction wave front that is the result of using a matrix bed having a plurality of flow control portions, or a combination thereof. All of the methods for producing these types of reaction wave fronts have a number of similar steps comprising heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for the reactant gas streams to react; introducing the reactant gas streams into the matrix bed in a manner to form a reaction wave front in the reaction portion of the matrix bed; and the reaction creating a reaction product gas stream that is then exhausted from the matrix bed.




In the alternative objective of the invention that produces a Bunsen reaction wave front, the reactant gas streams are mixed and divided to form one or more individual gas streams. The individual gas streams are introduced into the bed at one or more introduction locations, resulting in the Bunsen reaction wave fronts forming in the reaction portion of the matrix bed.




In the alternative objective of the invention that produces Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts, first and second portions of the reactant gas streams are mixed to form first and second mixed gas streams. The first and second mixed gas streams may be fuel and oxidizer, respectively. The first mixed gas stream is divided to form one or more individual gas streams. The individual gas streams are introduced into the matrix bed at one or more introduction locations disposed downstream of a gas permeable surface of the matrix bed. The second mixed gas stream is then directed through the gas permeable matrix bed surface. The individual gas streams react with the second mixed gas stream and form the Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts in the reaction portion of the matrix bed.




In the alternative objective of the invention that produces one or more inverted-V reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed, wave holders anchor portions of the front to form the inverted-V reaction wave front.




In the alternative objective of the invention that produces one or more non-planar reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed that correspond to a non-planar surface of the matrix bed, the reactant gas streams are directed through the non-planar surface of the matrix bed in a plurality of directions in a manner so as to form at least a non-planar reaction wave front in the matrix bed.




In the alternative objection of the invention that produces one or more non-planar reaction wave fronts as a result of using a matrix bed having a plurality of flow control portions, the flow control portions are defined by their linear gas velocity characteristics. The flow control portions are arranged to enable the formation of the non-planar reaction wave fronts.




Other and further objects and advantages will appear hereinafter.











BRIEF DESCRIPTIONS OF THE DRAWINGS




Prior Art

FIG. 1

is a schematic view of a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer.




Prior Art

FIG. 2

is a schematic view of the stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer of Prior Art

FIG. 1

showing the planar reaction wave front in the matrix bed.




Prior Art

FIG. 3

is a schematic view of a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer.




Prior Art

FIG. 4

is a schematic view of a regenerative bed incinerator system.





FIGS. 5 and 6

are detailed views of embodiments of the present invention having non-planar, Bunsen reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed.





FIGS. 7 and 8

are detailed views of embodiments of the present invention having non-planar, Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed.





FIGS. 9 and 10

are detailed views of embodiments of the present invention having non-planar, inverted-V reaction wave fronts in a matrix bed.





FIG. 11

is a detailed view of an embodiment of the present invention having a plurality of flow control portions that enable the formation of non-planar reaction wave fronts.





FIG. 12

is a detailed view of an embodiment of the present invention having a non-planar matrix bed surface that enables the formation of non-planar reaction wave fronts.





FIG. 13

is an isometric view of an embodiment of the present invention having a cylindrically-shaped matrix bed with reactant gas streams flowing radially therethrough.





FIG. 14

is a lateral cross-sectional view through line


14





14


of the cylindrically-shaped matrix bed of FIG.


13


.





FIG. 15

is an axial cross-sectional view through line


15





15


of the cylindrically-shaped matrix bed of FIG.


13


.





FIG. 16

is a cross-sectional view of an embodiment of the present invention having a spherically-shaped matrix bed.





FIGS. 17A-D

are detailed views of a lateral cross-section of an embodiment of the present invention having a cylindrically-shaped matrix bed with Bunsen conical, Burke-Schumann, inverted-V, and non-planar wave fronts.





FIG. 18

is a lateral cross-sectional view of an embodiment of the present invention having a cylindrically-shaped matrix bed with circular rods disposed therein.





FIG. 19

is an axial cross-sectional view of an embodiment of the present invention having a cylindrically-shaped matrix bed with circular rods disposed therein and an inverted-V reaction wave front extending therefrom.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring now to the figures, wherein like reference numerals refer to like elements, and in particular to the inventive embodiment of

FIG. 5

, a plurality of non-planar, Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


are formed by the reaction of a mixed gas stream


302


of a plurality of reactant gas streams flowing through tubes


304


extending through a planar surface


326


and into the matrix bed


301


. The term “non-planar” shall be understood to mean that all of the elements of a feature do not define a single plane, even through individual elements of the feature may define one or more planes. The terms “Bunsen” and “Bunsen cone” shall be understood to mean a combustion reaction wherein an oxidizable gas and oxygen are premixed prior to combustion and forms a conical reaction wave front. The plurality of gas streams comprises gases that react rapidly with each other and form a reaction wave front when intermixed in the proper ratios and elevated to a reaction temperature, i.e., oxidizable gases mixed with air and/or oxygen in a proper ratio combust rapidly in a reaction wave front when elevated to above the oxidizable gases auto-ignition temperature.




The surface


326


of the matrix bed


301


is adjacent to, and supported by, a bed support


306


, although other embodiments of the invention may have matrix beds that do not require bed supports. As with the reactors previously described, at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed


301


is preheated to a temperature that will sustain the fronts


300


, prior to the stream


302


entering it. The bed support


306


is a gas flow prevention surface, thereby directing all the gases to flow through the tubes


304


extending therethrough. Other embodiments of the invention may have a bed support that gases do flow through for preheating the matrix bed


301


or other purposes.




The tubes


304


extend through the bed support


306


and the surface


326


and divide the mixed gas stream


302


into a plurality of individual gas streams


303


. In the embodiment shown, the streams


303


flow into a first open end


308


of each tube that is located at the bed support


306


, but other embodiments of the invention may have the first open end located at some other position at, or upstream of, the surface


326


or connected directly with the source of stream


302


. The gases flow out of each tube


304


through a second open end


310


and into the matrix bed


301


. The second open end


310


is located downstream of the surface


326


at an introduction location. The second open end


310


is circular in shape, but other embodiments of the invention may have openings of other shapes. The height


312


and the diameter


314


of the tubes


304


varies depending upon application. Further, the distances


316


between the tubes


304


and the arrangement of the tubes (not shown) may vary between embodiment. Alternatively, tubes


304


may be omitted such that reaction wave


300


may form adjacent to the holes


308


in bed support


306


.




Besides the tubes


304


, other arrangements may be used to establish and maintain the non-planar, Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


. Referring to

FIG. 6

, a manifold


320


has an inlet


322


into which the mixed gas stream


302


flows. The inlet


322


is located at the surface


326


. The manifold


320


divides the gas stream


302


into the individual gas streams


303


that flow out of the manifold


320


through outlets


324


located in the matrix


301


at introduction locations that are downstream of the surface


326


. Other embodiments of the invention may have the inlet located upstream of the surface


326


, extending through a side wall of the reactor, or some other suitable configuration.




An embodiment of the invention may have the matrix bed


301


in a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer. An additional alternative embodiment of the invention may have the manifold inlet extending through the matrix bed


301


like the feed tubes


96


of the recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer in Prior Art

FIG. 3

such that the mixed gas stream


302


recoups thermal energy from the matrix bed. A further embodiment of the invention may have multiple manifolds with outlets


324


at different depths in the matrix bed


301


such that the position of the wave


300


may change as is necessary in a regenerative bed incinerator system such as shown in Prior Art FIG.


4


and the like.




As the Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


are non-planar, they have an increased area of the reaction wave front per cross-sectional area (or plan area) of the matrix bed


301


compared to a planar reaction wave front. This increased area of the reaction wave front results in increased reactions per volume of the matrix bed, thus increasing the matrix bed's overall volumetric reaction rate. As a result, a less expensive and smaller matrix bed with a Bunsen reaction wave front will react the same volume flow of reactant gases as a more expensive and larger matrix bed with a planar reaction wave front.




Now referring to

FIG. 7

, which illustrates an alternative embodiment of the present invention, a plurality of non-planar, Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


are formed by the reaction of portions


334


and


336


of the plurality of reactant gas streams in the matrix bed


301


. The term “BurkeSchumann” shall be understood to describe a combustion reaction where an oxidizable gas and the oxygen are diffused together under conditions such that combustion occurs. This type of combustion reaction is also know as a “diffusion flame” and is described in Burke, S. P and Schumann, T. E. W.,


Diffusion Flames,


First Symposium (International) on Combustion, p. 2, (1954), which is incorporated in its entirety by reference herein. In this preferred embodiment of the invention, the portion


334


is a mixture of the reactant gas streams that comprise air and/or oxygen and the portion


336


is a mixture of the reactant gas streams that comprise oxidizable gases. As with the reactors previously described, the matrix bed


301


is preheated to a temperature that will initiate the self-sustained reaction fronts


330


.




In the embodiment of the invention shown in

FIG. 7

, tubes


340


extend through the bed support


306


and the surface


326


and divide the portion


336


of the reactant gas streams into a plurality of individual gas streams


342


. The streams


342


flow into a first open end


344


of each tube


340


. The first open ends


344


are operatively connected to an oxidizable gas source through a manifold means (not shown). The gases flow out of each tube


340


through a second open end


346


and into the matrix bed


301


. The second open end


346


is located downstream of the surface


326


. In the preferred embodiment, the second open end


310


is circular in shape, but other embodiments of the invention may have openings of different shapes. The height


350


and the diameter


352


of the tubes


340


varies depending upon application and may also vary between individual tubes


340


in the same matrix bed. Further, the distances


354


between the tubes


340


and the arrangement of the tubes (not shown) may vary as well.




The air and/or oxygen gas stream portion


334


of the plurality of gas stream flows through the surface


326


and into the matrix bed


301


. The portion


334


diffuses into the individual gas streams


342


after they have passed through the second open ends


346


. Additionally, the temperature of the matrix bed


301


in the region of the second open ends


346


is above the temperature required for the portion


334


and streams


342


to react. When the portions


334


and individual gas streams


342


interdiffuse, they react and form the Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


. An embodiment of the invention may flow the oxidizable gases through the surface


326


and the air and/or oxygen gas stream through the tubes


340


. Another embodiment of the invention may preheat either one of the streams.




Besides the tubes


340


, other arrangements may be used to establish and maintain the non-planar, Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


. Referring to

FIG. 8

, a manifold


360


receives the portion


336


of the reactant gas streams and divides the gas stream into the plurality of individual gas streams


342


that flow out of the manifold


360


through outlets


362


located in the matrix


301


and downstream of the bed support


332


at introduction locations. The outlets


362


are circular in shape, but other embodiments of the invention may have outlets of other shapes. In an embodiment of the invention, the inlet (not shown) of the manifold


360


may extend through the bed support


306


, as did the manifold inlet


332


of the embodiment of the invention shown in FIG.


6


. In another embodiment of the invention, the manifold


360


inlet may extend through a side wall of the reactor. In a further embodiment of the invention, the manifold


360


inlet may extend through the matrix bed


301


similarly to the feed tubes


96


of the recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer in Prior Art

FIG. 3

such that the oxidizable gas portion


336


recoups thermal energy from the matrix bed. In an additional embodiment of the invention, the matrix bed may be in a regenerative bed incinerator system of Prior Art FIG.


4


and the like, the matrix bed having multiple manifolds at different depths in the matrix bed


301


such that the position of the wave


330


may change as necessary.




As described previously in connection with the Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


, the Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


are non-planar with an increased area of the reaction wave front per cross-sectional area of the matrix bed


301


compared to a planar reaction wave front. This increased area enables an increased amount of reactions per volume of the matrix bed, thus increasing the matrix bed's overall volumetric reaction rate. As a result, a less expensive and smaller matrix bed with a Burke-Schumann reaction wave front will react the same volume flow of reactant gases as a more expensive and larger matrix bed with a planar reaction wave front.




Now referring to

FIG. 9

, another embodiment of the present invention uses wave holder means


374


to anchor the reaction of the mixed gas stream


302


. The mixed gas stream


302


flows through the bed support


306


, through the surface


326


, and into the matrix bed


301


. A non-planar, inverted-V reaction wave front


370


forms when the matrix bed


301


immediately downstream of the wave holder means


374


is at the reaction temperature required for the mixed gas stream


302


to react in a front and the linear gas velocity of the stream is greater than the reaction velocity. The linear gas velocity is the average rate of motion of the gas stream, expressed in units of length/time, as contrasted with the volumetric flow rate having units of volume of gas/time or mass/time. The reaction velocity is the rate at which a reaction wave front progresses upstream. Without the wave holder means


374


, the reaction wave front will “blow out of,” or cease to exist in, the matrix bed


301


when the linear gas velocity of the stream is greater than the reaction velocity. By using the wave holder means


374


, the matrix bed


301


can process a higher volumetric flow rate of mixed gases and, therefore, have a higher overall volumetric reaction rate.




In the embodiment of the invention as shown in

FIG. 9

, the wave holder means


374


are rods extending through the matrix bed


301


and across the direction of the gas flow. The rods are bluff bodies that hold the reaction wave front through recirculation flow patterns in the vicinity of the rods. Other embodiments of the invention may use other bluff bodies to hold the reaction wave. Additional embodiments of the invention may heat the bluff bodies and other wave holder means


374


with a heating means (not shown) by electrical resistance, corona discharge, U.V. photolysis or some other means. Still further embodiments of the invention may use wave holder means


374


in the recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer as shown in Prior Art FIG.


3


and the like. Still further embodiments of the invention may use multiple levels of wave holder means


374


at a variety of depths in the matrix bed


301


such that the position of the wave front


370


may change as necessary in the regenerative bed incinerator system as shown in Prior Art FIG.


4


and the like.




Now referring to

FIG. 10

, another embodiment of the invention uses pilotas


378


(or ignitors) from pilot holes


376


to anchor and form the non-planar, inverted-V reaction wave front


370


. A manifold


382


preferably delivers a combustible gas to the pilot holes


376


to form raw fuel jets. Alternatively, manifold


382


may deliver a raw liquid fuel, or any combination of gaseous fuel, liquid fuel, air, and oxygen. The term “raw” as used herein and in the appended claims refers to a fuel stream or a fuel-rich stream. The present invention encompasses employing any such combination to form pilot


378


. The pilots


378


operate in the same manner as previously described for rods


374


and other structures as a wave holder means to form a front and may be used in a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer, a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer, or a regenerative bed incinerator system. To accomplish suitable wave holding, the pilots


378


preferably are 100 degrees F to 1500 degrees F hotter than the adiabatic reaction temperature of the product stream of the bulk gases. Even more preferably, the pilots


378


are approximately 400 degrees F hotter than the adiabatic temperature of the product stream. An equivalent to using pilots


378


is to locally ionize the gases to initiate and anchor the wave front.




Now referring to

FIG. 11

, another embodiment of the invention uses an engineered matrix bed


500


with a first flow control portion


502


and a second flow control portion


504


to form a non-planar reaction wave front


506


. The engineered matrix bed


500


may be made out of any suitable heat-resistant material. In the embodiment of

FIG. 11

, the first flow portion


502


has a relatively high linear gas velocity characteristic and the second flow portion


504


has a relatively low linear gas velocity characteristic. A linear gas velocity characteristic is the propensity of a gas flowing through the matrix bed to have a certain linear velocity. The first and second flow portions


502


meet at a convoluted interface


508


that extends approximately parallel with the surface


326


of the first flow portion


502


.




In an embodiment of the invention, the shape and linear gas velocity characteristics of the engineered matrix bed portions


502


and


503


are such that the reaction wave front


506


approximates the shape of the interface


508


between the portions when the reaction portion


510


of the matrix bed


500


is in the vicinity of the interface


508


. During operation of the engineered matrix bed


500


, the mixed gas stream


302


enters the first flow portion


502


through the surface


326


and flows to the interface


508


. The reaction portion


510


of the matrix bed


500


, which has been preheated to above the autoignition temperature of the gas stream


302


, extends from just upstream of the interface


508


to just downstream of the interface


508


. The mixed gas stream


302


oxidizes in the reaction portion


510


in a reaction wave front


506


.

FIG. 11

shows the non-planar reaction wave front


506


just downstream of the interface


508


and in the approximate shape of the interface


508


.




By positioning the reaction portion


510


of the matrix bed


500


in the vicinity of the interface


508


, the shape of the front


506


approximates the contours of the interface


508


. Portions of the front


506


that drift into the first flow portion


502


are blown back to the interface


508


by the relatively high velocity of the gas stream


302


in portion


502


compared to the reaction velocity of the stream


302


. Portions of the front


506


that drift into the second flow portion


502


migrate back to the interface


508


because the reaction velocity of the stream


302


is greater than the gas stream


302


flow in portion


504


. Other embodiments of the invention may have differently shaped interfaces that result in non-planar wave fronts of other shapes. Further embodiments of the invention may have more than two flow portions. The engineered matrix bed


500


may be made of any suitable heat-resistant material.




As with the Bunsen and Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts, a matrix bed with the non-planar, inverted-V wave front


370


can process a high flowrate of mixed gases and, therefore, has a relatively high overall volumetric reaction rate. This results in being able to use a smaller matrix bed, at a lower cost, to process the same amount of reactant gas streams as a larger matrix bed designed for use with a planar reaction wave front.




Now referring to

FIG. 12

, which illustrates another embodiment of the invention, a non-planar reaction wave front


390


is formed by flowing the mixed gas streams


302


through a non-planar surface


394


of the matrix bed


301


. The non-planar reaction wave front


390


occurs approximately the same distance


396


downstream from any part of the non-planar surface


394


, the distance


396


measured in a direction normal to the tangent of the part of the non-planar surface


394


. The non-planar surface


394


enables a non-planar reaction wave front


390


that is larger in area than a planar reaction wave front extending over the same cross-sectional area of the matrix bed


301


, and thus increases the overall volumetric reaction rate of the matrix bed. While the shown embodiment of the invention has a bed support


392


at the non-planar surface, other embodiments of the invention may not have a support. Additional embodiments of the invention may use matrix beds with non-planar surfaces in a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer, a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer, or a regenerative bed incinerator system.




Now referring to

FIGS. 13

,


14


, and


15


, an embodiment of the invention provides for a matrix bed


400


comprising heat-resistant material, with an exterior surface


402


and a non-planar interior surface


404


. The interior surface


404


extends to an opening


406


in the exterior surface


402


. The interior surface


404


and the exterior surface


402


define co-axial cylinders. The mixed gas stream


302


is directed through the opening


406


and into an interior space


410


defined by the interior surface


404


. The mixed gas stream


302


then flows through a bed support


412


that is adjacent to the non-planar surface


404


and into the matrix bed


400


in a radial direction. Other embodiments of the invention may not have a bed support


412


.




The matrix bed


400


has been preheated to produce a radially increasing temperature profile such that the reaction temperature of the mixed gas stream


302


occurs in a cylindrical region nested between the interior surface


404


and the exterior surface


402


. In this region, the mixed gas stream


302


rapidly reacts and forms a non-planar, cylindrical reaction wave front


414


. The reactions occurring in the front


414


produce a reaction products gas stream


408


that exits the matrix bed through the exterior surface


402


. This arrangement provides for a matrix bed with a high area of reaction wave front to volume of matrix bed and, therefore, a high overall volumetric reaction rate compared to matrix beds having a conventional planar reaction wave front along a latitudinal cross-section. Other embodiments of the invention may have the interior surface


404


defining more than two openings


406


for the mixed gas stream to enter the interior space


410


, such as an opening at both ends of the cylindrically shaped matrix bed


400


.




Now referring to

FIG. 16

, the non-planar interior surface may have other shapes, such as a spherical, non-planar interior surface


420


of a spherical matrix bed


422


having a spherical exterior surface


430


that is concentric with the interior surface


420


. The matrix bed


422


is comprised of the same heat-resistant matter as in the matrix bed


301


. The interior surface


420


defines a spherical space


432


and a passage


426


extending therefrom to the exterior surface


430


, defining an opening


424


thereat. The mixed gas stream


302


is directed into the opening


424


, through the cylindrical passage


426


and into the spherical space


432


. From the space


432


, the stream


302


flows radially through the interior surface


420


and into the matrix bed


422


.




The matrix bed


422


has been preheated to produce a radially increasing temperature profile such that the reaction temperature of the mixed gas stream


302


occurs in a spherical reaction portion of the bed nested between the interior surface


420


and the exterior surface


430


. In this portion, the mixed gas stream


302


rapidly reacts and forms a non-planar, spherical reaction wave front


428


. The reactions occurring in the front


428


produce a reaction products gas stream


408


that exits the matrix bed through the exterior surface


430


. Other embodiments of the invention may have interior surfaces of other, non-planar shapes, such as hemispherical, and other exterior shapes that are not necessarily the same shape as the space formed by the interior surface. Further embodiments may have a plurality of interior surfaces, such as a matrix bed having a cubical exterior surface and a plurality of cylindrically shaped interior spaces. Additional embodiments of the invention may use matrix beds with non-planar interior surfaces in a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer, a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer, or a regenerative bed incinerator system.




Now referring to

FIGS. 17A-D

, segments of a cylindrically-shaped matrix bed


440


are shown with four alternative embodiments of the invention for generating a reaction wave front of a larger area than the wave front


414


in the embodiment of the invention shown in FIG.


14


. The matrix bed


440


has been previously heated to produce a radially increasing temperature profile such that the reaction temperature of the mixed gas stream


302


occurs in a cylindrical reaction portion nested between the space


410


and the exterior surface


444


.




Now referring to

FIG. 17A

, the mixed gas stream


302


flows radially from space


410


, into a first open end


446


of a plurality of tubes


448


, and out through a second opening


450


, with each tube extending through an interior surface


442


. Upon entering the matrix bed


440


, the mixed gas streams react to form the non-planar, Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


as described previously, with the second openings


450


forming a non-planar locus of points. Other embodiments of the invention may utilize a manifold, as previously described in connection with the Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


.




Now referring to

FIG. 17B

, the portion


334


of the plurality of reactant gas streams flows through the bed support


452


with the other portion


336


of the plurality of reactant gas streams flowing from a manifold


454


having outlets


331


downstream of an interior surface


442


adjacent to the bed support. The outlets


331


form a non-planar locus of points. As previously described, in the preferred embodiment of the invention, the portion


334


is a mixture of the reactant gas streams that comprise air and/or oxygen and the portion


336


is a mixture of the reactant gas streams that comprise oxidizable gases. Upon the portions entering the matrix bed


440


and interdiffusing, the non-planar, Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


are formed as previously described.




Now referring to

FIG. 17C

, a plurality of rods


374


extend parallel to the central axis of the matrix bed


440


, forming the wave holder means. As the mixed gas stream


302


flows from the space


410


and into the matrix bed


440


, the stream reacts and forms the non-planar, inverted-V reaction wave front


370


, as previously described. In the embodiment of the invention shown in

FIG. 17C

, an apex


371


of each inverted-V reaction wave front


370


extends in a direction parallel to the central axis of the matrix bed.




Now referring to

FIG. 17D

, the interior surface


456


of the matrix bed


440


is convoluted compared to interior surface


456


of the cylindrical matrix bed shown in FIG.


14


. The mixed gas stream


302


passes from the space


410


, through the interior surface


456


, and into the matrix bed


440


. The mixed gas stream


302


reacts the same distance


460


from the interior surface


456


to form a convoluted, non-planar reaction wave front


390


, having a larger area than the non-planar, reaction wave front


414


of the embodiment of the invention shown in FIG.


14


. Other embodiments of the invention may use the previously described engineered matrix beds


500


to generate a reaction wave front of a larger area than the wave front


414


in the embodiment of the invention shown in

FIG. 14

(not shown).




Now referring to

FIGS. 18 and 19

, a cylindrical matrix bed


400


has a plurality of rods


466


disposed between the interior surface


404


and the exterior surface


402


. Each rod


466


is formed into a circle that is concentric with the central axis of the matrix bed


400


and that forms a plane that is normal to the axis of the matrix bed. The rods


466


are bluff bodies that create a plurality of non-planar, inverted-V reaction wave fronts


370


, with the apex


371


of each front extending circumferentially about the central axis of the matrix bed, as shown in FIG.


19


.




As is shown in embodiments of the invention of

FIGS. 17A-D

,


18


and


19


, the relatively smooth, non-planar reaction wave front


414


of the matrix bed


400


will have an increased area if the matrix bed is modified to generate either the Bunsen reaction wave fronts


300


, Burke-Schumann reaction wave fronts


330


, the inverted-V reaction wave front


370


, the convoluted reaction wave front


458


, or a combination thereof. This increased area translates into an increased overall volumetric reaction rate of the matrix bed. Further, other embodiments of this invention may use matrix beds modified to generate the above-mentioned non-planar reaction wave fronts in a stabilized reaction wave flameless thermal oxidizer, a recuperative heating flameless thermal oxidizer, or a regenerative bed incinerator system.




Therefore, by modifying the design of the matrix bed such that the area of the reaction wave front of a plurality of reactant gas streams reacting in the matrix bed increases, the overall volumetric reaction rate of the matrix bed increases. With the overall volumetric reaction rate increase, a given matrix bed will process more of the reactant gas streams with low additional cost.




Although the present invention has been described above with respect to particular preferred embodiments, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that numerous modifications and variations can be made to those designs. For example, any of the above embodiments of the invention may have a means to monitor the temperature profile of the matrix bed and a means for adjusting the non-planar reaction wave front by varying the flowrates of at least a portion of the reactant gas streams, as is disclosed in the prior art. However, in the context of the present invention, “adjusting” shall be understood to mean maintaining or changing the position of the reaction wave front in the matrix bed, the shape of the reaction wave front, the character of the reaction wave front (i.e. temperature, composition, etc.), or a combination thereof. The descriptions provided are for illustrative purposes and are not intended to limit the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A method of increasing the overall volumetric reaction rate within a matrix bed, comprising heat-resistant material and having at least a matrix bed surface, by forming at least a Bunsen reaction wave front therein, comprising the steps of:(a heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for one or more reactant gas streams to react; (b mixing at least a portion of the reactant gas streams to form a first mixed gas stream; (c dividing the first mixed gas stream into a one or more individual gas streams; (d introducing the individual gas streams into the matrix bed at one or more introduction locations downstream of the matrix bed surface in a manner so to form the Bunsen reaction wave front in the reaction portion of the matrix bed, and a reaction product gas stream; and (e exhausting the reaction product gas stream from the matrix bed.
  • 2. A method of increasing the overall volumetric reaction rate within a matrix bed comprising heat-resistant material and having a non-planar surface, comprising the steps of:(a heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for one or more reactant gas streams to react; (b directing the reactant gas streams through the non-planar surface of the matrix bed and into the matrix bed in a plurality of directions in a manner so as to form at least a non-planar reaction wave front in the reaction portion of the matrix bed and a reaction product gas stream; and (c exhausting the reaction product gas stream from the matrix bed.
  • 3. The method of claim 2 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing the reactant gas streams through the reaction portion of the matrix bed such that one or more wave holders anchor an inverted-V reaction wave front.
  • 4. The method of claim 2 further comprising the steps of:(a monitoring the temperature profile of the matrix bed; (b adjusting the location or shape of the reaction wave front by varying the flowrates of at least a portion of the reactant gas streams; (c recuperating heat into the reactant gases from the matrix bed by passing the reactant gas streams through pipes that extend through the heated matrix bed; and (d steering the reactant gas streams through an opening in a matrix bed exterior surface and into an interior space defined by a matrix bed interior surface that comprises the non-planar surface prior to the directing step.
  • 5. The method of claim 4 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing at least a portion of the reactant gas streams to flow radially through at least a portion of the non-planar surface, wherein the non-planar surface defines at least a portion of a generally cylindrical interior space.
  • 6. The method of claim 4 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing at least a portion of the reactant gas streams to flow radially through at least a portion of the non-planar surface, wherein the non-planar surface defines at least a portion of a generally spherical interior space.
  • 7. A method of increasing the overall volumetric reaction rate within a matrix bed comprising heat-resistant material by forming a non-planar reaction wave front therein, comprising the steps of:(a heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for one or more reactant gas streams to react; (b directing the reactant gas streams through the reaction portion of the matrix bed to create a reaction gas product stream, wherein at least a portion of the matrix bed comprises a plurality of flow control portions arranged to enable forming the non-planar reaction wave front; and (c exhausting the reaction product gas stream from the matrix bed.
  • 8. A method of increasing the overall volumetric reaction rate within a matrix bed comprising heat-resistant material by forming at least an inverted-V reaction wave front therein, comprising the steps of:a) heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for one or more reactant gas streams to react; b) directing the reactant gas streams through the reaction portion of the matrix bed such that: i) one or more wave holders anchor the inverted-V reaction wave front; and ii) a reaction product gas stream is produced; and c) exhausting the reaction product gas stream from the matrix bed.
  • 9. The method of claim 8 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing the reactant gas streams past one or more bluff bodies disposed in the matrix bed.
  • 10. The method of claim 9 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of heating the bluff bodies.
  • 11. The method of claim 9 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing the reactant gas streams past one or more rods disposed in the matrix bed.
  • 12. The method of claim 8 wherein the directing step further comprises the step of directing the reactant gas streams past one or more pilots disposed in the matrix bed.
  • 13. The method of claim 8 further comprising the step of injecting at least one of a raw gaseous fuel, a raw liquid fuel, and a combination of at least one of the raw gaseous fuel, the raw liquid fuel, and an air stream through one or more pilots disposed in the matrix beds.
  • 14. A thermal reactor for optimizing the reaction rate of one or more reactant gas streams by forming one or more Bunsen reaction wave fronts therefrom, comprising:a) a matrix bed of heat-resistant material comprising at least a matrix bed surface having an upstream side and a downstream side adjacent to the matrix bed; b) heating means for heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for the reactant gas streams to react and to form a reaction product gas stream therefrom; c) gas entry means for directing the reactant gas streams into the matrix bed through one or more introduction locations located downstream of the matrix bed surface and forming the Bunsen reaction wave fronts in the matrix bed reaction portion; d) temperature means for monitoring a temperature profile of the matrix bed; e) adjusting means for varying the reactant gas streams flowrates in response to the monitored temperature profile; and f) exit means for the reaction product gas stream to exit the matrix bed.
  • 15. The reactor of claim 14 wherein the gas entry means comprises at least a manifold having one or more outlets located at the introduction locations, respectively.
  • 16. The reactor of claim 14 wherein the gas entry means comprises one or more tubes extending through the matrix bed surface, each tube having a first and a second open end, and wherein the first open end of each tube is located at, or upstream of, the matrix bed surface, and the second open end of each tube is located at the introduction locations, respectively.
  • 17. A thermal reactor for optimizing the reaction rate of one or more reactant gas streams by forming one or more inverted-V reaction wave fronts therefrom, comprising:a) a matrix bed of heat-resistant material comprising at least a matrix bed surface having an upstream side and a downstream side adjacent to the matrix bed; b) heating means for heating the matrix bed until at least a reaction portion of the matrix bed is above the temperature required for the reactant gas streams to react and to form a reaction product gas stream therefrom; c) gas entry means for directing the reactant gas streams into the matrix bed and through the matrix bed reaction portion; d) wave holder means disposed in the matrix bed reaction portion for anchoring the inverted-V reaction waves fronts; e) temperature means for monitoring a temperature profile of the matrix bed; f) control means for varying the reactant gas streams' flowrates in response to the monitored temperature profile; and g) exit means for the reaction product gas stream to exit the matrix bed.
  • 18. The reactor of claim 17 further comprising heating means for heating the wave holder means.
  • 19. The reactor of claim 18 wherein the wave holder means comprises one or more bluff bodies disposed in the matrix bed reaction portion.
  • 20. The reactor of claim 17 wherein the wave holder means comprises one or more pilots disposed in the matrix bed reaction portion.
  • 21. The reactor of claim 20 wherein the one or more pilots comprise one or more raw fuel jets.
Parent Case Info

This Application is a divisional of application Ser. No. 08/921,815, filed Sep. 2, 1997, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,989,010.

US Referenced Citations (70)
Number Name Date Kind
1812341 Jaeger Jun 1931
2795054 Bowen, III Jun 1957
2976853 Hunter et al. Mar 1961
3661497 Castelluci et al. May 1972
3769922 Furlong et al. Nov 1973
3807090 Moss Apr 1974
3810732 Koch May 1974
3870474 Houston Mar 1975
3888193 Kishigami et al. Jun 1975
3895918 Mueller Jul 1975
3900554 Lyon Aug 1975
3942264 Zenkner Mar 1976
4047876 Rice Sep 1977
4252070 Benedick Feb 1981
4259088 Moss Mar 1981
4267152 Benedick May 1981
4284401 Tatebayashi et al. Aug 1981
4285666 Burton et al. Aug 1981
4355504 Liu et al. Oct 1982
4380149 Ludecke Apr 1983
4400356 McVay et al. Aug 1983
4441971 Ishiguro et al. Apr 1984
4475884 Shang et al. Oct 1984
4481767 Stark Nov 1984
4520624 Kiyota et al. Jun 1985
4529374 Malik Jul 1985
4535588 Sato et al. Aug 1985
4627812 Kelly et al. Dec 1986
4643667 Fleming Feb 1987
4646660 Björkman et al. Mar 1987
4649703 Dettling et al. Mar 1987
4688495 Galloway Aug 1987
4702075 Jenny Oct 1987
4716844 Koch Jan 1988
4741690 Heed May 1988
4785768 Brown et al. Nov 1988
4807695 Ward Feb 1989
4823711 Kroneberger et al. Apr 1989
4828481 Weil et al. May 1989
4838782 Willis Jun 1989
4870824 Young et al. Oct 1989
4941415 Pope et al. Jul 1990
4953512 Italiano Sep 1990
4969328 Kammel Nov 1990
4974530 Lyon Dec 1990
4987738 Lopez-Crevillen et al. Jan 1991
4989408 Leonhard et al. Feb 1991
5028405 Erdmannsdoerfer et al. Jul 1991
5097665 Kammel Mar 1992
5141714 Obuchi et al. Aug 1992
5147201 Xiong Sep 1992
5165884 Martin et al. Nov 1992
5188804 Pace et al. Feb 1993
5279630 Brinkmann Jan 1994
5320518 Stilger et al. Jun 1994
5394692 Teuber-Ernst Mar 1995
5410875 Tanaka et al. May 1995
5426936 Levendis et al. Jun 1995
5457945 Adiletta Oct 1995
5533890 Holst et al. Jul 1996
5547650 Edgar et al. Aug 1996
5601790 Stilger et al. Feb 1997
5628186 Schmelz May 1997
5635139 Holst et al. Jun 1997
5637283 Stilger et al. Jun 1997
5650128 Holst et al. Jul 1997
5800790 Imamura et al. Sep 1998
5989010 Martin et al. Nov 1999
6003305 Martin et al. Dec 1999
6015540 McAdams et al. Jan 2000
Non-Patent Literature Citations (8)
Entry
Burke, S.P. et al., “Diffusion Flames”, First Symposium (International) on Combustion, 1954, 2-11.
“California could end heavy diesel vehicle sales”, Oil and Gas J., 1994, 42 and 44.
Control of Air Pollution from New Motor Vehicles and New Motor Engines, Federal Register, 1993, 58(55), 15781-15802.
“Focus on Industry Solutions for Exhaust Pollution Control”,Automotive Engineer, 1994, pp. 18,20,22,24, 26,27,28,29.
Haynes, B.S. et al., “Soot Formation”, Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 1990, 7, 229-273.
Kahair, M.K. et al., “Design and Development of Catalytic Converters for Diesels”, SAE paper 921677, 1992, 199-209.
Keeney, T.R.E., Auto Emissions, 1995, 5, 4 Sheets.
Wagner et al., “SCR succeeds at Logan Generating Plant”, Power Engin., 1997, 28-32.