The present invention relates to transducers for detecting one or more properties of a fluid, and sensors incorporating or using such transducers, in particular wherein the transducer includes a mechanical resonator arranged to exhibit a resonant frequency which is dependent upon one or more properties of the fluid such as pressure.
Pressure sensors which use a resonant beam coupled to a diaphragm are known for example from U.S. Pat. No. 5,195,374, WO98/29722 and US2011/0107838. In each case a resonant beam is excited into resonant vibration, for example using an optical or electrical excitation signal. Mechanisms for stimulating the resonance can be, for example, thermal, piezoelectric and electrostatic. The resonant beam is coupled to a diaphragm which distorts under the pressure to be measured in such a way that a resonant frequency of the beam is related to the pressure. The diaphragm and resonant beam of such sensors are typically fabricated by micromachining from silicon or another suitable material.
Similar sensors may be used to measure other parameters of an adjacent fluid such as density and viscosity, for example as described in GB2470399.
The resonant frequency of the beam or other resonant structure can be detected in various ways, including through piezo-resistance, electrostatically and optically. In U.S. Pat. No. 5,195,374 the resonant beam partly defines a Fabry Perot optical cavity, and a continuous optical detection signal is directed at this cavity via the same optical fibre as used to carry an optical excitation signal. In WO98/29722 sensing piezoresistors are used. US2011/0107838 mentions reading out the resonant frequency using resistive, capacitive or optical sensing methods.
The resonant frequency of the beam typically changes with temperature by virtue of the temperature dependence of the Young's modulus of the material of the beam. Typically, the temperature dependence may be of the order of 100 to 300 ppm/° C. and therefore not negligible in high accuracy applications such as those in the oil and gas industries calling for 0.01% or better long term accuracy. As a result, for accurate pressure measurements the simultaneous knowledge of temperature at the transducer is also required in order to carry out active temperature compensation.
U.S. Pat. No. 4,972,076 also describes a resonant beam pressure sensor, and proposes correcting for effect of temperature on the resonant frequency of a first beam by providing a second resonant beam for temperature detection. This second beam is arranged such that, unlike the first beam, it is insensitive to the pressure applied to the diaphragm, but both are excited into resonance by an optical driving signal delivered using the same optical fibre so that their respective temperature coefficients of frequency will track each other in a predictable way. Optical detection of resonant frequency of the beams of U.S. Pat. No. 4,972,076 by use of Fabry-Perot cavities whose widths vary with the vibrations of the resonant beams is described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,195,374.
Optical driving and interrogation of sensors provides advantages over electrical interrogation, for example because driving and interrogation signals can be carried along one or more optical fibres, thereby eliminating possible electrical interference and potentially hazardous electrical discharges. Optical fibres can allow much longer distances between sensors and interrogators. Optical sensor heads coupled to optical fibres also allow operation at temperatures much higher than can be achieved using a sensor head incorporating electrical circuitry or components such as a feedback loop. Generally, electronic circuits cannot be designed to operate reliably above about 270° C., and positioning sensor electronics at significant or long distances from the sensor head can give rise to unwanted noise, for example from cable capacitance or electromagnetic interference.
The present invention therefore seeks to address problems of the related prior art in providing improved mechanical resonator transducers for optical interrogation and improved optical interrogation of and readout from such transducers.
The invention provides a transducer for detecting one or more properties of a fluid, comprising: a mechanical resonator arranged to exhibit a vibration frequency, and in particular a resonant frequency which is dependent upon one or more properties of the fluid, and a sensor comprising such a transducer. The transducer may typically also comprise a diaphragm arranged to be exposed to or influenced by a fluid, and the mechanical resonator may then be coupled to the diaphragm so as to exhibit a resonant frequency which is dependent upon one or more properties of the fluid such as pressure.
In this document, the term fluid is intended to cover both liquid and gas. The mechanical resonator may be coupled directly to the diaphragm which is exposed to the fluid, or coupled indirectly for example via various types of coupling mechanisms which could include, for example, a secondary internal diaphragm, which could be coupled to the fluid exposed diaphragm using a coupling fluid.
According to a first aspect of the invention, the transducer also comprises a temperature sensing optical cavity arranged to vary in optical path difference in correspondence with changes in temperature of the transducer.
Embodiments of the invention make use of additional structural members that are usually present in this type of transducer to perform an optical temperature measurement without having to modify the mechanical design. For example, the temperature sensing optical cavity may be defined by one or more static components of the sensor head such as surfaces of a substrate and/or other static structures or layers. If the transducer is a micro-machined element, for example made from silicon or another suitable material, which comprises the mechanical resonator and a substrate, then some or all of the temperature sensing optical cavity may be provided by material of the substrate.
The temperature sensing optical cavity may be a reflective type optical cavity such as a Fizeau or Fabry-Perot optical cavity, or some other optical cavity type may be used.
The transducer may be optically coupled to an interrogator, for example using one or more optical fibres, to form the above mentioned sensor. The interrogator may include functional elements such as a resonator driver arranged to drive vibration of the mechanical resonator at or near the resonant frequency; and a detector arranged to detect temperature, or equivalently optical path difference of the temperature sensing optical cavity, at the transducer from optical interference due to the temperature sensing optical cavity, in light received at the detector from the transducer. Typically, the detector will also be arranged to detect the vibration frequency of the mechanical resonator, and typically also to generate an indication of said one or more properties of the fluid from the detected vibration frequency of the mechanical resonator. The detector may also provide other outputs such as the detected temperature or optical path difference of the temperature sensing optical cavity.
The detector may be arranged to compensate the indication of said one or more properties of the fluid for variations in temperature at the transducer, using the detected temperature or optical path difference.
Embodiments of the invention may make use of selection and measurement of the temperature sensing optical cavity using a spectral approach. For example, the detector may comprise a spectrometer or spectral engine arranged to detect, in said light received from the transducer, an interference spectrum caused at least partly by the temperature sensing optical cavity, the detector being arranged to detect the optical path difference from a transform of said interference spectrum.
The transform typically provides a distribution over a dimension corresponding to optical path difference of the temperature sensing optical cavity, and may for example be provided by a Fourier transform or a cross-correlation. The optical path difference and therefore temperature at the transducer may, for example, correspond to position of a peak in a Fourier transform and/or cross-correlation of the interference spectrum, or may be derived using phase information from the Fourier transform at such a peak. According to some embodiments, a Fourier or similar spectral transform may be used to obtain a first, coarse temperature sensing signal which is then used to derive a refined temperature or optical path difference sensing signal, for example using a cross-correlation of the interference spectrum.
A second aspect of the present invention provides optical means for measuring and/or controlling the amplitude of the oscillations of the mechanical resonator, and to this end transducer may comprise a vibration sensing optical cavity arranged to vary in optical path difference in correspondence with vibration of the mechanical resonator.
One end or facet of the vibration sensing optical cavity may be defined, for example, by a surface of the mechanical resonator. The transducer could be a micro-machined element which comprises said mechanical resonator and a substrate, and another end of the vibration sensing optical cavity could be provided by a surface or facet of the substrate.
The vibration sensing optical cavity may be a reflective type optical cavity such as a Fizeau or Fabry-Perot optical cavity, or some other optical cavity type may be used.
A sensor may therefore be provided which includes the above transducer, a resonator driver arranged to drive vibration of the mechanical resonator at or near the resonant frequency; and a detector arranged to detect amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator from optical interference in light received at the detector from the transducer, the optical interference being at least partly caused by the vibration sensing optical cavity. For example, this interference could be caused by an interaction between the vibration sensing optical cavity and aspects of the detector such as a receive interferometer located at the detector. The sensor may also be arranged to detect the vibration frequency of the mechanical resonator, for example from the same optical interference.
The detector may also provide temperature sensing functionality using a temperature sensing optical cavity in the transducer as already mentioned above, and may similarly be arranged to generate an indication of said one or more properties of the fluid from the detected vibration frequency of the mechanical resonator.
The resonator driver may typically comprise a light source such as a laser emitting pulsed drive light which is incident on a surface of the mechanical resonator, causing periodic localised heating, but other types of resonator driver may be used. The resonator driver may be arranged to control amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator responsive to the amplitude of vibration detected by the detector, and in particular may control amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator such that the amplitude of vibration remains substantially constant, so that the dependence of the frequency of vibration on the amplitude is effectively removed. Alternatively the detector may be arranged to compensate the indication of said one or more properties of the fluid generated from the detected resonant frequency of the resonator for changes in amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator detected by the detector.
In order to sense properties of the vibration sensing optical cavity in the transducer, the detector may comprise a receive interferometer, for example a Mach Zehnder interferometer, which is optically coupled to the vibration sensing optical cavity. The receive interferometer has an optical path difference matched to the optical path difference of the vibration sensing optical cavity such that said optical interference in light received at the detector is caused by a combination of said receive interferometer and said vibration sensing optical cavity. An exact match is not required, but the vibration sensing optical cavity and receive interferometer should together provide a suitable interference signal in broad band light, for example from a superluminescent diode. A photo-detector may then be arranged to detect the optical interference and output a corresponding interference signal. This interference signal will then comprise temporal oscillations due to oscillations in the vibration sensing optical cavity which correspond to vibrations of the mechanical resonator. To this end, the sensor may therefore comprise a broad band light source such as a super luminescent diode. The broad band light source may be arranged to deliver broad band light to the transducer, and to sense properties of the vibration sensing optical cavity from optical interference in said broadband light at the detector.
The interference signal typically appears as a sinusoidal form under variations in optical path difference of either the vibration sensing optical cavity or the receive interferometer. A number of different techniques may be used to detect or control amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator from the optical interference. In a first technique the amplitude of the mechanical resonator is controlled to a fixed value using a special phase point such as a π peak. In particular, the detector is arranged to control the resonator driver such that the amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator remains at a level where the interference signal oscillates between turning points, for example a maximum and a minimum, of signal value equal to each other, for example corresponding to an amplitude of vibration of the vibration sensing optical cavity of one quarter of the wavelength of the light carrying the interference signal.
According to a second technique, the detector is arranged to detect amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator using one or more ratios or other combinations of a fundamental and/or higher harmonics of the frequency of vibration of the mechanical resonator present in the interference signal. One such suitable combination is the ratio of the fundamental and third harmonics in the interference signal, but a ratio of the second and fourth harmonics may be used, or a combination of these two ratios. The fundamental and/or harmonics in the interference signal may for example be found by expansion of the interference signal in terms of Bessel functions, and may be detected from a Fourier or other spectral transform of the interference signal. The second technique may therefore provide measurement and/or control of the amplitude using Bessel function expansion of a photo-detector receive voltage that provides common-mode rejection of drifts in the calibration curve relating the voltage and phase shift observed in the interference signal.
The fundamental and harmonics of the frequency of vibration are preferably measured at particular DC phase offsets of the interference signal, which can conveniently be set and/or controlled using the or a receive interferometer. Suitable DC phase offsets are either zero or multiples of π, for example to select even Bessel function harmonics, and quadrature points such as π/2 to select odd Bessel function harmonics.
According to a third technique the detector is arranged to vary the optical path difference of the receive interferometer to determine the full range of amplitude of the interference signal, i.e the maximum available amplitude under such variations, and to calibrate oscillations in the interference signal which are due to vibration of the mechanical resonator using the determined maximum amplitude, to thereby detect amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator from the oscillations in the interference signal which are due to vibration of the mechanical resonator. To this end, the detector may be arranged to vary the optical path difference of the receive interferometer to determine a maximum amplitude of change in the interference signal under such variations by sweeping the receive interferometer across at least a peak and a trough in the interference signal.
Because varying the optical path difference of the receive interferometer through turning points in the interference signal gives rise to corresponding times when the interference signal is not sensitive to changes in optical path difference, the detector may further comprise a second receive interferometer also coupled to the vibration sensing optical cavity, and also having an optical path difference matched to the vibration sensing optical cavity, the second receive interferometer being used to detect oscillations in the vibration sensing optical cavity. The second receive interferometer can therefore be used to detect frequency and/or phase of such oscillations, for example to determine the one or more properties of the fluid such as pressure and/or to control a driving signal for the mechanical resonator.
Generally, the detector may be arranged to detect a phase of the oscillating interference signal discussed above and to provide feedback control to the receive interferometer such that the interference signal is centred about a phase quadrature point. The detector may be arranged to detect the frequency and/or phase of vibration of the mechanical resonator from corresponding oscillations in the interference signal detected from the or a receive interferometer.
Aspects of the transducer or sensor for detecting temperature at the transducer and/or providing temperature compensation may be combined with aspects for detecting amplitude of vibration and effecting suitable compensation or control, for example as set out in the detailed description of embodiments below. In any case, the light received at the detector from the transducer, in which the optical interference is detected, may be broad band light, for example generated using one or more superluminescent diodes arranged to deliver the broad band light to the transducer, and the same broad band light may be used to sense both the temperature and amplitude at the transducer, so that a common broad band light source may be used for both functions.
The invention also provides methods corresponding to the above apparatus, and as described in the detailed embodiments, for example corresponding methods of fabricating a transducer, interrogating a transducer, sensing one or more properties of a fluid using the transducer, compensating a measurement of one or more such properties for temperature at the transducer for example of the bulk of the mechanical resonator, and compensating a measurement for or controlling the transducer to minimise variations in amplitude of oscillation of the mechanical resonator.
Embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, of which:
a and 8b illustrate harmonics of the interference signal at fundamental (20 kHz) and higher harmonics of the resonant frequency of the mechanical transducer;
Referring now to
Typically, a property of the fluid to be detected may be pressure, and changes in pressure of the fluid give rise to distortions of the diaphragm 16 and therefore to changes in the resonant frequency of the mechanical resonator 14 which can be used to determine the pressure from an unambiguous relationship between the two using a suitable calibration.
The transducer may typically be fabricated using micromachining methods, for example from silicon, with the diaphragm 16 and mechanical resonator 14 supported above a substrate 15.
Mechanical oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14 may be achieved in various ways, including by expansion and contraction under localised heating of the mechanical resonator 14 itself, or of another structure coupled to the mechanical resonator 14, the heating being driven by a light source that is pulsed at or close to the resonant frequency. Ways in which this can be implemented include absorbing light at a thin metal layer deposited on the resonator itself as described in Venkatesh and Culshaw, Electronics Letters, 1985, vol 21, no. 8, or in sections of doped silicon as described in Palit et al, Proceedings of the 37th workshop on geothermal reservoir engineering, Stanford University, Jan. 30-Feb. 1 2012, SGP-TR-194.
In use, the transducer 10 is coupled to an optical fibre 20. The optical fibre is used to deliver pulsed drive light to the transducer which drives oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14 as discussed above. The optical fibre 20 may also be used to detect parameters of the mechanical resonator. Such parameters may include one or more of phase of the mechanical resonator for example in order to control the pulsed drive light, the frequency of resonance of the mechanical resonator 14 for example in order to detect pressure or some other property of the fluid 12, and the amplitude of resonance of the mechanical resonator 14. These parameters of the transducer 10 can be detected from optical interference resulting from a vibration sensing optical cavity 24 which is arranged to vary in optical path difference in correspondence with vibration of the mechanical resonator 14. The vibration sensing optical cavity may be defined, for example, by opposing faces of the mechanical resonator 14 and the substrate 15.
The optical fibre may also be used to detect other properties of the transducer 10. For example, the transducer may include a temperature sensing optical cavity 26 which has an optical path difference which varies in correspondence with changes in temperature of the transducer, and in particular with changes in a quasi steady state or bulk temperature of the transducer rather than a rapidly changing temperature of a part of the transducer being used to drive oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14. The temperature sensing optical cavity 26 may, for example, comprise silicon or some other material of the transducer, such that temperature dependence of the refractive index and/or thermal expansion of the material give rise to changes in optical path difference of the temperature sensing optical cavity under changes in temperature of the transducer.
The resonant frequency of the mechanical resonator 14, for a given fixed value of a property such as pressure of the fluid to be detected, will typically vary depending on the temperature of the transducer, for example due to thermal expansion and changes in bulk mechanical properties of the material of the transducer under changes in temperature, and also under changes in the amplitude of the oscillations of the mechanical resonator 14. The detected temperature and amplitude can therefore be used to correct or compensate for these effects in detecting one or more properties of the fluid, as discussed in more detail below.
The optical cavities in the transducer 10 to be used for detecting parameters of the transducer 10 may conveniently be Fabry Perot cavities, although other cavity types and configurations may be used.
A sensor 100 incorporating the transducer 10 of
The drive light could, for example, have a wavelength of about 1310 nm and the probe light a wavelength of about 1550 nm. The first light source could be a narrow band, laser source, or could be a broadband source such as a superluminescent diode. The second light source is preferably a broadband source such as a superluminescent diode, so that optical cavities in the transducer can be interrogated using white light interferometry techniques for which the coherence length of the light source should be less than the optical path difference of any optical cavity to be detected.
The probe light returning along the optical fibre 20 from the transducer 10 is directed by the coupling arrangement 116 and a circulator 118 to a detector function 120 which detects parameters of the sensor head such as temperature, and frequency, phase and amplitude of the mechanical resonator 14, from optical interference in the probe light arising from the temperature sensing optical cavity 26 and the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 of the probe light in one or more ways. The interference signals can be detected using techniques such as white light interferometry.
On the basis of the detected parameters the detector function 120 outputs one or more feedback signals F and output signals Y. The one or more feedback signals F may be used, for example, to control the first light source through the first light source driver 113, for example by controlling the phase, power and/or frequency of pulsing of the first light source. The one or more output signals Y may represent properties of the transducer and/or the fluid adjacent to the transducer such as pressure.
In one configuration, the detector function uses interference properties of the received probe light due to the vibration detecting optical cavity 24 to detect the phase and frequency of oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14. These are then used to derive suitable feedback signals F sent to the driver 113 to modulate the power of the first light source at the resonant frequency with a suitable phase delay, for example with a phase lag of 90 degrees. The detected frequency of oscillation is then also used to provide an output signal directly representing the oscillation frequency, and/or an output signal representing pressure at the transducer 10 through a calibrated relationship between frequency of oscillation and pressure.
Typically, however, the resonance frequency of the mechanical resonator 14 exhibits a significant temperature dependence of the order of 100 to 300 ppm/° C. In order to compensate for this temperaturedependence the detector function 120 may use interference properties of the received probe light due to the temperature detecting optical cavity 26 to detect temperature at the transducer 10. The detected temperature may be used in generating an output signal representing temperature compensated pressure at the transducer, may be output as a separate temperature output signal, and/or may be used in deriving or providing suitable feedback signals F.
From an optical point of view, the transducer 10 shown in
For an air/silicon interface with na=1 and nSi=3.5, about 30% of the probe light is reflected back. This leads to multiple reflections from the various interfaces present in the transducer forming a multitude of optical cavities. In particular, reflections from the inner and outer surface of the substrate form a temperature sensing optical cavity with an optical path difference (OPD) of:
OPDT=2nSidSi, eqn. 2
where dSi denotes the thickness of the (silicon) substrate. By virtue of the temperature dependence of the refractive index and the geometrical thermal expansion of the substrate or other component OPDT is an unambiguous function of temperature. Hence, OPDT can be used as a parameter of the transducer to be measured optically that is related unambiguously to temperature. From equation 2, the change in OPDT for a given temperature change dT can then be calculated as follows:
with αSi denoting the linear thermal expansion coefficient of the (silicon) substrate material. For example, considering a 500 μm thick silicon substrate and using the thermal expansion coefficient αSi=3.5 ppm/° C. and the thermo-optic coefficient dnSi/dT=1.86×10−4/° C., the rate of change of OPDT can be estimated as 0.2 μm/° C. Hence, the substrate can act as a temperature sensing optical cavity and the temperature at the transducer may be determined from the corresponding optically measured OPDT via a calibration curve T=f(OPDT).
Of course, various other static structures in the transducer can be used to measure temperature, through similar detection of variations in optical path difference, and such structures may be formed of silicon or some other material.
The measurement functionality used to detect a temperature dependent optical path difference in the transducer can be implemented within the detector function 120 shown generally in
Using a broad-band light source such as, for example, a super-luminescent diode (SLD) as the second light source 114 of
One way of carrying out analysis of the interference spectrum is discussed in Liu and Fernando, “A frequency division multiplexed low-finesse fibre optic Fabry-Perot sensor system for strain and displacement measurements”, Rev. Sci. Instrum., vol 71, no. 3 (2000). In accordance with this document, a discrete Fourier transform of the interference spectrum is calculated by the transform function 142, and the positions of the one or more peaks in the Fourier transform output correspond to the optical path differences of the one or more optical cavities in the sensor head, including the temperature sensing optical cavity 26. The peak corresponding to the temperature sensing optical cavity 26 can then be selected and the corresponding OPD measured, resulting in a detection of temperature at the transducer 10. The equivalent use of a cross-correlation function is discussed in Zhenguo and Qingxu, Proceedings of the sixth International Symposium on Test and Measurement, Dalian, China, 1-4 June 2004, volume 4 page 3509, 2005.
A technique enabling a more accurate determination of the optical path difference OPD corresponding to the temperature sensing optical cavity is described in GB1204673.6, filed by the same assignee/applicant as the present application before the UK Intellectual Property Office on the 16 Mar. 2012. The content of this patent application is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety for all purposes. Using this technique, the spectral engine 140 outputs an interference spectrum arising from interaction of the probe light with the temperature sensing optical cavity 26. The transform function 142 then comprises a coarse detector function which carries out a coarse analysis of the interference spectrum to derive a coarse temperature sensing cavity output, for example based on a peak of a Fourier transform of the interference signal or a peak of an envelope of a cross correlation of the interference signal with a set of periodic functions. Based on the coarse temperature sensing cavity output and the interference spectrum, a refined detector function then derives a refined temperature sensing cavity output which provides the detected temperature signal desired, by locating or tracking fine structure peaks in a cross correlation of the interference spectrum.
The use of coarse and refined detector functions as outlined above adds the advantage of much finer resolution in measurements over a larger range than can be achieved, for example, by using only a detected peak in a Fourier transform of the interference spectrum. However, special care has to be taken when applying the technique of coarse and refined detector functions to a substrate that exhibits optical dispersion, i.e. the refractive index of which varies with the wavelength of light as it is the case for silicon. In this case the outputs of the coarse and refined detector functions will be governed by the group and phase index of the substrate material, respectively. Without further considerations, this will lead to mismatches over large enough variations in temperature, resulting in the refined detector function receiving an unsuitable input provided by the coarse detector function. To address this issue, a variable offset can be applied to the signal from the coarse detector function to compensate for different rates of change of the coarse and fine optical path difference signals due to dispersion in the optical cavity.
In order to establish a calibration f between detected optical path difference of the temperature sensing optical cavity and a temperature signal, i.e. T=f(OPDT), the OPD may be measured together with the temperature of the transducer 10 at a number of set temperature points. The reference temperature measurement can be carried out, for example, by placing a suitable thermocouple in direct contact with the transducer.
The resonant frequency of the mechanical resonator 14 may depend on the amplitude of the resonator oscillations as well as on temperature and on the one or more properties of the fluid to be detected. Hence, for accurate measurements of the one or more properties, the amplitude of the oscillations δda also should be detected and used by the detector function 120, either to actively compensate for this dependence or to keep the amplitude constant or otherwise controlled via a feedback loop through the first optical source driver 113 by controlling the optical power of the first light source. Varying the optical power of the first light source changes the amount of heat delivered to the mechanical resonator 14, which in turn will affect the amplitude of oscillation. Different ways of optically measuring the amplitude of the oscillations of the mechanical resonator 14 will be discussed later in this document.
As explained above, a transducer 10 as shown in
A coherence-multiplexing approach may therefore be used instead, employing a receive interferometer 150 as shown in
Various ways in which a receive interferometer can be controlled in this way to track the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 are described in WO90/22775, WO99/60341 and WO2012/140411. However, in other arrangements, the receive interferometer controller may be omitted, for example when the receive interferometer does not include any adjustment mechanism such as the phase modulators 152 mentioned below.
An effect of employing a receive interferometer 150 is the measurement of the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 without being affected by other optical cavities in the system, for example the temperature sensing optical cavity 26. For this purpose, the receive interferometer 150 is placed in series with the vibration sensing optical cavity 24, for instance, in the return path of the probe light. In
In
Advantageously, an integrated version of an MZI may be used in which the OPD of the receive interferometer 150 is accurately pre-defined by a mask used for lithography during manufacture. The MZI may also contain one or two Phase Modulators (PM) 152 that can modulate the OPD of the MZI to a certain extent. The modulation speed and range of the PMs depends on the type of MZI and PM design. Consider, for instance, an integrated MZI realised in silicon and employing thermal phase modulators. Such PM's may have a dynamic range of several π radians and a modulation bandwidth from hundred's of Hz to several kHz depending on design, for example referring to the discussion in Clark et al., “Thermo-Optic Phase Modulators in SIMOX Material”, Integrated Optics Devices IV, Proceedings of SPIE VOI. 3936 (2000) p 16. Integrated MZIs realised in other materials such as LiNbO3 or silica on silicon could also be employed.
As already discussed above in respect of the detection of temperature at the transducer 10, the second light source 114 may be provided by a broad-band light source such as a Super-Luminescent Diode (SLD). The importance of the broad-band nature is that these types of light source have a limited coherence length Lc. As a typical example, for an SLD with a centre wavelength of 1550 nm and a bandwidth of 50 nm, the coherence length would be of the order of Lc∞(1550)2/50˜50 μm, which is suitable to detect interference caused by the optical cavities in the transducer 10 in combination with the wavelength specificity of the spectral engine and the matched OPD of the receive interferometer 150, but which is shorter than any of the OPDs to be detected so that no interference results solely from the action of any optical cavities in the transducer 10.
Referring for example to Rao and Jackson, Meas. Sci. Technol. Vol. 7 (1996) p. 981, it can be shown that the transfer function of the vibration sensing optical cavity in tandem with the receive interferometer 150 of the interrogator 120 is given by:
Here, OPDa is the optical path difference of the vibration sensing optical cavity 24, OPDMZ denotes the optical path difference of the receive interferometer 150, λ2 is the centre wavelength of the probe light in vacuum, I is the optical intensity at the photo-detector 155 and I0 is the total power arriving at the photo-detector. V describes the opening or visibility of the resulting fringes and depends on the power distribution and states of polarisation between the interfering light beams, for example the light reflected from each end of the vibration sensing optical cavity 24. Its maximum value in the set-up shown in
OPDT,OPDa,OPDMZ>>Lc eqn. 6
In this equation OPDT denotes the OPD of the temperature sensing optical cavity as defined in equation 2. If this condition holds then no interference occurs due to any of the optical cavities in the transducer 10 or interrogator 110 in their own right because probe light reflected from the two ends of each optical cavity is respectively delayed by more than the coherence length. By designing or tuning the receive interferometer 150 so that its OPDMZ is matched to the OPDa of the vibration sensing optical cavity, portions of the probe light reflected from the two interfaces of the vibration sensing optical cavity can be brought back into phase through traversing the receive interferometer 150 and an interference signal from only the vibration sensing optical cavity is generated at the photo-detector 155. More precisely, one has to fulfil the condition:
|OPDa−OPDMZ|<<Lc eqn. 7
In this case, the exponential function in equation 4 roughly equals one and the initial equation 4 can therefore be approximated by:
The size of the vibration sensing optical cavity da can be written as the sum of a (quasi)-static part d0 and an oscillation part δda of amplitude y0 at the frequency of oscillation of the mechanical resonator fosc:
d
a(t)=d0+δda(t) eqn. 9
where
δda(t)=y0 cos(2πfosct+φ) eqn. 10
If many copies of transducer 10 are produced by micro-machining, the (quasi)-static part d0 will vary by a few μm between transducer copies, and will drift by a similar amount due to changes with temperature due to thermal expansion of the transducer material, and may also vary with applied pressure.
Knowledge of the resonator phase φ may also be required by the first laser source driver 113 to drive the mechanical resonator 14; hence this may be one of the feedback parameters F generated by the detector function 120. Clearly, as soon as the size of the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 is measured at timescales comparable to the oscillation frequency this phase information becomes available. This applies to various techniques discussed below for obtaining an amplitude signal from the vibration sensing optical cavity 24, so will not be outlined in detail in each case.
Using equations 5, 9 and 10 in equation 8, and taking into account that by design the MZI or other receiver interferometer 150 approximately matches the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 (2d0≈OPDMZ) in accordance with equation 7, the AC part of the voltage output by the photo-detector which corresponds to the received intensity I is given by:
V
AC
=I
0VG cos[φ0cos(2πfosct+φ)+φDC], eqn. 11
where the optical phase offset φDC contains only slow moving or drifting components (e.g., change in cavity size due to applied pressure or temperature, drift in OPDMZ) and any contributions from the one or more phase modulators 152 in the receive interferometer 150. G is an effective gain, including for example the responsivity of the photo-detector 155 and electronic gain of the trans-impedance amplifier 157.
The voltage at the amplifier output is related to the light intensity I at the photo-detector 155 by voltage=IG. The optical phase amplitude φ0 corresponding to the vibration amplitude y0 is given by
The AC part of the amplifier output (equation 11) is now analysed in more detail. First, consider gradually increasing the optical phase amplitude φ0 whilst keeping the offset φDC fixed at π/2. This point is commonly called the quadrature point. At quadrature, a small phase signal will be translated into a maximum intensity signal as it is the most linear part of the transfer function. The relationship between the oscillation of the mechanical resonator and the output of the photodiode at the quadrature point 171 is schematically illustrated in
For small phase amplitudes φ0 one finds analytically from equation 11 that:
V
AC(t)≈−I0VGφ0 cos(2πfosct+φ) eqn. 13
This demonstrates that for small movements of the mechanical resonator 14 the AC voltage at the photo-detector 155 is an inverted form of the resonator phase (
We will now describe a number of ways in which the amplitude of oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14 can be determined, or controlled in a feedback loop, using interference caused by the vibration sensing optical cavity 24 and the receive interferometer 150 in combination, and the corresponding interference signal in the output of the photo-detector 155. In each case, the frequency and phase of oscillations of the vibration sensing optical cavity can also be detected from the photo-detector signal, although this is not described in detail here.
According to a first approach, the analysis function 145 receives an input Z representing the interference signal output by the photo-detector, and provides feedback control F to the vibration sensing cavity driver 113 to maintain the amplitude of oscillations of the vibration sensing optical cavity (and therefore the amplitude of oscillations of the mechanical resonator) at a constant level. In particular, the feedback may control the amplitude such that the interference signal, and therefore the phase, oscillates in time between controlled endpoints in the phase or time dimension, where these endpoints correspond to turning points of the signal in the phase or time dimension which are equal to each other in signal value, typically corresponding to endpoints or turning points of equal voltage output by the photo-detector 155. This can be achieved if the amplitude of vibration of the vibration sensing optical cavity is one quarter of the wavelength of the light carrying the detected interference signal.
Gradually increasing the amplitude of oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14 about the quadrature point (φDC=π/2 radians) illustrated in
Further increasing φ0 beyond π results in a crossover of the points A and B (
In practical terms, processing of the interference signal output by the photo-detector could be carried out by the detector function 120 as follows. Referring to
Depending on design criteria, it may not always be practical for the mechanical resonator 14 of a transducer 10 to operate with an amplitude of a quarter of the wavelength of the probe light. Therefore, the second and third approaches discussed below enable determination and/or control of the amplitude of oscillation, along with determinations of frequency and phase if desired, at much lower amplitude levels.
According to a second approach, the analysis function 145 receives an input Z representing the interference signal output by the photo-detector and detects the fundamental and/or higher harmonics of the vibration frequency of the mechanical resonator in the interference signal. The analysis function 145 then derives an amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator from one or more ratios or other functional dependencies of these harmonics. In particular, portions of the interference signal at the fundamental and third harmonics of vibration may be used, especially if the interference signal is controlled to oscillate approximately about the quadrature point 171 as discussed above. However, other ratios and combinations of ratios may be used. The derived amplitude may be actively used to compensate an output derived from the resonant frequency for changes in amplitude, or may be used in a feedback loop to control the amplitude, for example to maintain the amplitude at a constant level. This technique is advantageous in providing common-mode rejection of drifts in the relationship between the interference signal output of the photo-detector and the phase shift.
Ohtsuka, “Dynamic displacements of small displacements by laser interferometry”, Trans. Inst. Meas. Contr., Vol. 4 (1982), p. 115 discusses methods for retrieving the dynamic optical phase of an optical cavity that is illuminated with a coherent light source. In a similar vein, expanding the AC component of the photo-detector voltage represented by equation 11 in terms of Bessel functions of the first kind yields:
V
AC(t)=−2I0VGJ2(φ0)cos[2φosc(t)]cos(φDC)+2I0VGJ4(φ0)cos[4φcos(t)]cos(φDC)−−2I0VGJ1(φ0)cos[φosc(t)]sin(φDC)+2I0VGJ3(φ0)cos[3φosc(t)]sin(φDC)+higher harmonics eqn. 14
where
φosc(t)=2πfosct+φ eqn. 15
is the total time dependent phase of the oscillations of the vibration sensing optical cavity. Note that at particular values of the optical phase shift φDC, only even (for φDC=0) or odd (for φDC=π/2) Bessel function harmonics of the resonator frequency are present. Note that φDC=π/2 corresponds to the quadrature point illustrated in
V
1=2I0VG|J1(φ0)sin(φDC)| measured @ 2πfosc,
V
3=2I0VG|J3(φ0)sin(φDC)| measured @ 3(2πfosc). eqn. 16
Note that V1 and V3 are always non-negative because the FFT provides a magnitude. By calculating the ratio V1/V3 possible drifts in the value of the common factor I0VG are cancelled out and a stable calibration curve determining φ0 and therefore y0 (via equation 12) from the ratio V1/V3 can be established.
Advantageously, the exact value of φDC is not crucial for this procedure either as long as it approximately equals π/2 (quadrature point of
In
A third approach for deriving the amplitude of oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14 from the interference signal, which is suitable for small amplitudes of oscillation, is therefore now described. According to this approach the optical path difference of the receive interferometer is swept or varied in order to determine the maximum amplitude range of the interference signal under such variations. This amplitude range is then used to calibrate the smaller oscillations in the interference signal which are due to vibration of the mechanical, to thereby detect amplitude of vibration of the mechanical resonator. This calibration sweep or variation in the optical path difference of the receive interferometer can be achieved using a calibration sweep of the optical path difference that corresponds to a π radian phase shift if the variation is accurately centred on the quadrature point, or more generally of at least 2π to guarantee finding both a peak and a trough in an uncentred interference signal.
Because the receive interferometer is modulated to find turning points in the interference signal at which small changes in optical path difference at the vibration sensing optical cavity have little or no effect on the interference signal, the third approach may use a second receive interferometer to detect the frequency and/or phase of oscillations of the mechanical resonator 14.
This third approach may be implemented using an arrangement as shown in
Following the low pass filter 216, the calibration sweep interference signal 212 then appears as the cosine function of equation 11 in which the sweeping of the OPD of the receive interferometer 150 is represented by a sweeping of φDC, with the peak to peak range providing a current value for I0VG which can be assumed to be stable over at least multiple mechanical oscillator periods.
The current value for I0VG is then used in equation 11, for example by the receive interferometer controller 159, as a constant or calibration factor relating the photo-detector output to total phase shift. The quasi-DC effect, relative to the frequency of oscillation of the mechanical resonator, of the calibration sweep on the photo-detector signal is removed using a high pass filter 214 to yield a resonator interference signal 216. The amplitude of this resonator interference signal 216 varies with the calibration sweep, but the maximum amplitude will typically appear as the calibration sweep passes the quadrature point in the photo-detector output signal, and the current value of I0VG can then be used to translate this maximum amplitude or another amplitude value of the oscillations of the photo-detector signal into a signal Z representing the amplitude of oscillation of the mechanical resonator 14.
Because the amplitude of the resonator interference signal 216 fades as the calibration sweep approaches ±π/2 radians from the quadrature point, it may not be suitable for rapid monitoring of the frequency and phase of oscillation of the mechanical resonator. As shown in
The peak to peak voltage or other amplitude measure of the waveform of signal Y may be monitored and the OPD of the second receive interferometer controlled by a second receive interferometer controller 259 in conjunction with one or more phase modulators 252 in the second receive interferometer 250 to keep the peak to peak voltage at a maximum, at or close to the quadrature point, thereby preventing phase drift in the system from extinguishing the signal. From the signal Y, both frequency and phase information of the resonator are available continuously and without interruption.
Although specific detailed embodiments of the invention have been described, the skilled person will appreciate that modifications and variations on these can be carried out without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
1223074.4 | Dec 2012 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/GB2013/053274 | 12/12/2013 | WO | 00 |