Patent Application
20240101436
This present disclosure relates to catalysts for both (1) cracking ammonia into a mixture of nitrogen, hydrogen, and ammonia and (2) synthesizing ammonia from a mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen. Methods of fabricating the catalysts and cracking and/or synthesizing NH3 using the catalyst are also described herein.
Human-caused emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) are causing global warming, climate changes, and ocean acidification, each of which threaten humanity's continued economic development and security. To counter this threat, energy sources that are substantially free of CO2 emissions are highly sought after in both industrialized and developing countries. While several CO2-free energy generation options have been extensively developed, none presently include a practicable CO2-free fuel.
Ammonia (NH3) can be burned as a fuel according to the following reaction equation (1):
4 NH3 (g)+3 O2→2 N2+6 H2O (g)+heat (1)
NH3 can be used directly as a carbon-free fuel or as a hydrogen source if it is thermally reformed into hydrogen and nitrogen gases. It can also be used in a mixture of NH3, H2, and N2 to tailor its combustion characteristics to specific processes or equipment. It has a higher energy density, easier storage conditions, and cheaper long-term storage and distribution than gaseous hydrogen, liquid hydrogen, or batteries.
The main industrial procedure for the production of ammonia is the Haber-Bosch process, illustrated in the following reaction equation (2):
N2 (g)+3 H2 (g)→2 NH3 (g) (ΔH=−92.2 kJ/mol) (2)
In 2005, Haber-Bosch ammonia synthesis produced an average of about 2.1 tonnes of CO2, per tonne of NH3 produced; about two thirds of the CO2 production derives from the steam reforming of hydrocarbons to produce hydrogen gas, while the remaining third derives from hydrocarbon fuel combustion to provide energy to the synthesis plant. As of 2005, about 75% of Haber-Bosch NH3 plants used natural gas as feed and fuel, while the remainder used coal or petroleum. Haber-Bosch NH3 synthesis consumed about 3% to 5% of global natural gas production and about 1% to 2% of global energy production.
The Haber-Bosch reaction is generally carried out in a reactor containing an iron oxide or a ruthenium catalyst at a temperature of between about 300° C. and about 550° C. and at a pressure of between about 90 bar and about 180 bar. The elevated temperature is required to achieve a reasonable reaction rate. Due to the exothermic nature of NH3 synthesis, the elevated temperature drives the equilibrium toward the reactants, but this is counteracted by the high pressure.
Recent advances in ammonia synthesis have yielded reactors that can operate at temperatures between about 300° C. and about 600° C. and pressures ranging from 1 bar up to the practical limits of pressure vessel and compressor design. When designed for lower operating pressures, this newer generation of reactors can reduce equipment costs and gas compression costs, but they also reduce the fraction of the N2 and H2 reactants converted to NH3 during each pass through the catalyst bed. This increases the number of re-circulations required to make a given quantity of NH3, which can increase the heat loss for a given quantity of NH3 unless the reactor heat is recycled efficiently with an appropriate heat exchanger. The higher number of reactant re-circulations can also increase the recirculation pump energy requirements unless a catalyst bed with high gas conductance is used.
Thermal cracking of NH3 can require temperatures of 700-900° C. using today's commercial catalysts. Even higher temperatures are required if catalysts are not used. Such high temperatures are not desirable because they increase the energy required for cracking the NH3 and because they can cause many materials to deform or degrade. Ruthenium on an alumina support is known to catalyze NH3 cracking, but it requires relatively high metal loading and relatively high (about 700° C.) operation. High ruthenium loading is not desirable because it increases catalyst cost. Ruthenium is a platinum group metal, which are relatively scarce and have a high cost per gram. A 700° C. operating temperature is also not desirable because it is still hot enough to quickly degrade or deform low-cost steels and stainless steels.
NH3-fueled equipment that starts and stops frequently, such as automobiles and peaking power plants, require a NH3 cracker design that can be heated to its operating temperature quickly and that can maintain good catalyst adhesion after many temperature cycles. Equipment that must fit into a constrained space requires a compact NH3 cracker design. Equipment that requires substantial volumes of fuel or that has highly variable fuel flow requirements can benefit from a NH3 cracker that has high gas conductance to minimize fuel pressure drop during high flow operation.
NH3 fuel is now being used by alkaline fuel cell manufacturers. It is a leading contender for decarbonizing maritime shipping and for providing seasonal energy storage for carbon-free electricity grids. It is also the most likely solution to for decarbonizing internal combustion engines for long-distance trucking.
Recently developed NH3 synthesis reactors and NH3 cracking reactors for NH3 fuel use expose a need in the art for NH3-active catalyst beds that (a) can operate well below 700° C., (b) can be heated quickly to their operating temperature, (c) experience minimal degradation from thermal cycles, (d) require only small platinum group metal loading or no platinum group metals at all, and (e) have high gas conductance.
Described herein are various embodiments of a cobalt-decorated and a ruthenium and cobalt-decorated barium calcium aluminum oxide catalyst that is suitable for both synthesizing NH3 from a N2+H2 mixture and cracking NH3 into a N2+H2+NH3 mixture, and corresponding methods of synthesizing and cracking NH3 using the disclosed catalysts. Also described herein are various embodiments of a ruthenium-decorated barium calcium aluminum oxide catalyst suitable for NH3 cracking and associated methods of cracking NH3 using the disclosed catalyst. Thus, as described herein, the disclosed catalysts can use either a low ruthenium loading, a cobalt loading (no ruthenium at all), or a mixture of ruthenium and cobalt. The catalyst described herein can be bonded to a metal structure, which improves thermal conductivity and gas conductance. The technology described herein improves upon the state of the art at least by (a) providing a highly NH3-active catalyst with low or no platinum group metal loading, (b) reducing the temperature required for cracking NH3, and/or (c) providing a catalyst that can be robustly bonded to precisely designed metal monoliths that reduce the catalyst bed thermal mass, increase its thermal conductivity, and increase its gas conductance.
The present disclosure references “B2CA,” which is a cement chemistry notation in which B=BaO (barium oxide), C=CaO (calcium oxide), and A=Al2O3 (aluminum oxide). Thus, as used herein, the term “B2CA”=Ba2CaAl2O6, a barium calcium aluminum oxide compound. Using similar cement chemistry notation, the present disclosure also references additional barium calcium aluminum oxide compounds, such as B21C16A3 (Ba21Ca16Al6O46), BCA2 (BaCaAl2O6), B5C7A4, (Ba5Ca7Al8O24), B3C3A2 (Ba3Ca3Al2O12), B2C5A (Ba2Ca5Al2O10), and BCA (BaCaAl2O5).
The catalysts described herein, and which are generally suitable for use in the NH3 cracking and synthesis methods described herein, are prepared by first synthesizing a B2CA powder or related barium calcium aluminum oxide composition. Any method of synthesizing the B2CA or related barium calcium aluminum oxide composition can be used. The barium calcium aluminum oxide compound used in preparing the catalyst described herein can also have some or all of the aluminum oxide replaced with boron oxide. In some embodiments, the method of preparation of the barium calcium aluminum oxide compound, including preparation of the barium calcium aluminum oxide compound having some or all of the aluminum oxide replaced with boron oxide, is similar or identical to the methods described in International Publication No. WO 2018/213305, the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference.
The resulting powder is then decorated with either 0.1 wt % to 10 wt % ruthenium, 0.1 to 50 wt % cobalt, or a combination of ruthenium and cobalt within these previously stated ranges. Decoration of the barium calcium aluminum oxide powder with a catalytically active metal can be carried out using any suitable methodology, including but not limited to in a manner similar or identical to the methods described in WO 2018/213305. When following the methods described in WO 2018/213305, decoration is generally carried out by (a) stirring the powder in a metal salt+acetone solution to decorate its surface with a salt of the desired metal, and (b) annealing the resulting material in hydrogen-containing atmosphere to reduce the metal salt to a metal. Non-limiting examples of suitable metal salts are RuCl3 hydrate for Ru decoration and CoCl2 hexahydrate for Co decoration. A Ru+Co metal decoration mixture can be produced by either using a solution that contains both Ru and Co salts or by depositing the metals in succession. The water present in the hydrated salts does not appear to damage the barium calcium aluminum powder by hydrating it. RuCl3 hydrate is typically cheaper to purchase and dissolves more easily in acetone than anhydrous RuCl3, and therefore may be preferable in some embodiments.
In some embodiments, step (b) can be omitted, such as when it is desired to reduce the metal salt to a metal in a NH3 synthesis or cracking apparatus the first time it is heated to operating temperature under a H2 or NH3 flow. However, if this is done, care must be taken that the evolved anion of the salt (chlorine, for example) does not damage downstream equipment in the synthesis or cracking apparatus.
A Co/barium calcium aluminum oxide catalyst can be converted to a Co-oxide/barium calcium aluminum oxide catalyst by annealing the Co/barium calcium aluminum oxide in an oxygen-containing atmosphere. For some cobalt loadings, the oxidized version of the catalyst performs better than the metal version for NH3 synthesis. An example of annealing the Co/barium calcium aluminum oxide to form Co-oxide/barium calcium aluminum oxide is annealing the Co/barium calcium aluminum oxide in a 50% oxygen/50% nitrogen atmosphere using a 5° C./minute ramp to 400° C., 2 h dwell at 400° C., and then a 5° C./minute ramp to room temperature.
Thus formed, the metal-decorated barium calcium aluminum oxide composition can be formed into a catalyst bed by any of the methods described in International Publication No. WO 2018/213305, or via any other suitable method. The methods described in WO 2018/213305 include, as examples, using the material as a powder, extruding it into pellets, pressing it into pellets, and bonding it to structural supports. It has been found that metal monoliths with a thin layer of metal-decorated barium calcium aluminum oxide bonded to their surface are particularly beneficial for NH3 synthesis and cracking due to their high gas conductance, high thermal conductivity, and high catalyst utilization.
Methods of fabricating a metal-decorated barium calcium aluminum oxide catalyst-coated metal monolith generally include three steps: fabricating the monolith, coating the monolith with a barium calcium aluminum oxide compound, and decorating the barium calcium aluminum oxide coating with the catalytically active metal.
The metal monolith can be formed in whatever specific shape is required by engineering requirements such as gas conductance, thermal conductivity, and surface area per unit length of monolith. Metal monoliths are available from commercial vendors in a variety of configurations.
The monolith sheet metal can be selected based on its temperature tolerance, chemical compatibility, and/or catalyst adhesion characteristics, as well as any other characteristics. In the case of NH3 cracking, the sheet metal is preferably tolerant of reducing atmospheres (H2 and NH3 in particular) at temperatures up to at least 450° C., and preferably up to 700° C. It is also desirable that barium calcium aluminum oxide compound adhere well to the monolith sheet metal. Fecralloy (the trade name of an aluminum-containing stainless steel), aluminized stainless steel (stainless steel dip-coated with aluminum in a process similar to galvanization), and stainless steel alloys can satisfy these conditions and are commercially available. Aluminized mild steel alloys may be suitable.
The metal monolith can be oxidized to promote barium calcium aluminum oxide adhesion. In the case of Fecralloy or aluminized stainless steel monoliths, the oxidation causes a well-bonded layer of aluminum oxide to form on the sheet metal surface. This aluminum oxide layer can promote barium calcium aluminum oxide adhesion. Surface oxidation can also promote barium calcium aluminum oxide adhesion to stainless steel. An example of an annealing profile to oxidize Fecralloy is a 6 hour anneal at 1015° C. in a 50% O2+50% N2 atmosphere. An example of an annealing profile to oxidize aluminized stainless steel is a 6 hour anneal at 700° C. in a 50% O2+50% N2 atmosphere.
In some embodiments, the metal monolith can be designed and fabricated to allow a current to be passed through it so it can be electrically heated. An example of such a monolith is the EmiCat metal monolith produced by Continental Corporation.
Barium calcium aluminum oxide powder is deposited on the metal monolith from an organic solvent slurry containing an organic binder. The organic solvent preferably has low viscosity to facilitate slurry flow through the monolith and a high vapor pressure to facilitate rapid evaporation of solvent from the slurry-coated monolith. An example of a suitable organic solvent is acetone. An example of a suitable organic binder is citric acid. It has been found that 10 mg of citric acid per mL of acetone provides good binding properties for tested monoliths; however, the specific citric acid concentration can be adjusted to tailor the slurry properties to the specific application. Water is preferably not used as a substantial component of the solvent for the barium calcium aluminum oxide slurry because barium calcium aluminum oxide is a cement-former that will hydrate when exposed to water. This hydration can change its physical and chemical properties.
Barium calcium aluminum oxide slurry can be formed by adding finely ground barium calcium aluminum oxide compound to the organic solvent+binder solution. An example of “finely ground” is powder that has been planetary ball milled to around 4 m2/g surface area as measured by nitrogen BET analysis. Powders with substantially lower surface area may not stay suspended in the organic solvent+binder solution to form a slurry. Barium calcium aluminum oxide powders with higher surface area can work well, but are not strictly necessary.
The barium calcium aluminum oxide can be applied to the monolith by dipping the monolith in the slurry, by pouring the slurry through the monolith, or by pumping the slurry through the monolith, as well as by any other suitable means. In all cases, after enough slurry has drained from the monolith to allow the channels to open, the monolith can be rotated from “right-side up” to “up-side down” to encourage a uniform slurry coating. Rotation can be continued until enough solvent has evaporated from the slurry that it no longer flows on the monolith surfaces.
The dried slurry-coated monolith can be annealed in an oxygen atmosphere to evaporate residual solvent, burn away the organic binder, and promote bonding of the barium calcium aluminum oxide grains to each other and to the monolith. Examples of an oxygen atmosphere include 50% oxygen in nitrogen and ambient air. An example of an annealing profile for bonding the barium calcium aluminum oxide to the metal monolith is a 5° C./minute ramp to 700° C., a 6 hour dwell at 700° C., and a 5° C./minute ramp to room temperature. Other annealing profiles can be used, and may be selected based on the monolith temperature tolerances and trade-offs between final barium calcium aluminum oxide surface area and bonding strength. The annealing temperature preferably does not exceed 1200° C. because that will melt the barium calcium aluminum oxide and, as a result, likely damage the metal monolith.
The barium calcium aluminum oxide coating on the monolith can be decorated with Ru or Co or both by either immersing the monolith in an appropriate metal salt solution or pouring an appropriate metal salt solution through its channels. An example of a Co solution is cobalt chloride hexahydrate dissolved in acetone. Cobalt loadings of 0.1 to 50 wt % (referenced to the mass of barium calcium aluminum oxide on the monolith) can be used, with 15 to 25 wt % Co being one preferred range. An example of a Ru solution is RuCl3 hydrate dissolved in acetone. Ru loadings of 0.1 to 10 wt % (referenced to the mass of barium calcium aluminum oxide on the monolith) can be used, with 1 to 5 wt % Ru being one preferred range. In both cases, the metal salt adsorbs onto the barium calcium aluminum oxide from the solution, causing the solution color to lighten. The desired metal loading can be achieved by either using a small amount of concentrated solution or a larger amount of dilute solution. For narrow channeled monoliths, the acetone solution may be held in the channel by capillary action, causing it to have a very long evaporation time. In this case, metal salt deposition can also be fostered by blowing the metal salt solution out of the monolith channels and into a container with compressed gas, continuing to flow the compressed gas to evaporate the residual solvent from the channels, and then pouring the captured solution back through the monolith. This process can be repeated until the solution is consumed. The metal chloride decoration can be converted to metal by annealing. In some embodiments, annealing in a hydrogen atmosphere is preferable because hydrogen encourages the chlorine to leave the metal chloride to become HCl gas, allowing the anneal to occur at a lower temperature (as low as 200° C.). The anneal can also occur in nitrogen, but a higher temperature is required (for example, 500° C.). An example of an anneal in a hydrogen atmosphere to convert the metal chloride to metal is a 5° C./minute ramp to 400° C., 2 h dwell at 400° C., and then a 5° C./minute ramp to room temperature. Another example is annealing in a hydrogen atmosphere for 12 hours at 240° C.
In exemplary catalyst cracking methods, the cracking catalyst bed or monolith is heated to 300 to 650° C. and NH3 gas is directed through it. The NH3 input stream can be preheated before it is directed into the catalyst bed. NH3 cracking is an endothermic process, so the cracking bed requires heating to maintain its temperature during use.
When the NH3 gas flows through the hot catalyst bed, it cracks into a N2+H2+NH3 mixture. The N2 and H2 will be in the stoichiometric 3 H2:1 N2 ratio dictated by the composition of the NH3 reactant. The concentration of residual NH3 in the cracked product gas can vary depending on (a) whether the reaction proceeded to equilibrium in the cracker, and (b) the thermodynamic equilibrium concentration of NH3 in a N2+H2+NH3 mixture for the temperature and pressure used in the cracker.
The equilibrium concentration of NH3 in the product stream can be reduced by increasing the catalyst bed temperature or reducing its pressure. The equilibrium concentration of NH3 in the product stream can be increased by reducing the catalyst bed temperature or increasing its pressure.
For a given catalyst bed volume, temperature, and pressure, the fraction of the incoming NH3 that is cracked to N2+H2 can be brought closer to the thermodynamic equilibrium value by increasing the residence time in the catalyst bed by reducing the NH3 flow rate. If only partial cracking of the NH3 gas is desired, the fraction of the NH3 that is cracked in the reactor can be reduced by decreasing the residence time in the catalyst bed by increasing the NH3 flow. For a constant NH3 input flow, pressure, and catalyst bed volume, the cracked NH3 fraction can be increased by increasing the bed temperature and decreased by decreasing the bed temperature.
In exemplary catalyst synthesis methods, the synthesis catalyst bed or monolith is heated to 200 to 650° C. and a N2+H2 gas mixture is directed through it. The reactant pressure can range from 0.1 bar to 500 bar. The reactant input stream can be preheated before it is directed into the catalyst bed. When the N2+H2 gas mixture flows through the hot catalyst bed, a portion of it is converted to NH3. The concentration of NH3 in the product gas can vary depending on (a) whether the reaction proceeded to equilibrium in the reactor, and (b) the thermodynamic equilibrium concentration of NH3 in a N2+H2+NH3 mixture for the temperature and pressure used in the reactor.
The equilibrium concentration of NH3 in the product stream can be increased by reducing the catalyst bed temperature or increasing its pressure. NH3 synthesis is an exothermic process, so the cracking bed can become hotter as NH3 is synthesized. This can be particularly important at high operating pressures, for which heat removal mechanisms may be required to keep the reactor from overheating.
For a given catalyst bed volume, temperature, and pressure, the fraction of the incoming N2+H2 that is converted to NH3 can be brought closer to the thermodynamic equilibrium value by increasing the residence time in the catalyst bed by reducing the NH3 flow rate.
A B2CA powder was prepared and decorated with 1 wt % Ru metal according to the methods described in International Publication No. WO 2018/213305. The Ru-decorated powder was cold-pressed into pellets with no binder. The pellets were crushed to produce a range of granule sizes and the resulting mixture was sieved to select the approximately 20 mesh granules. 0.2 g of Ru-decorated B2CA granules were mixed with 0.4 g catalyst-free alumina granule diluent and the catalyst-diluent mixture was loaded into a catalyst holder.
The cracking capability of the catalyst-diluent mixture was tested in a laboratory apparatus that included a NH3 gas supply, NH3 flow controller, tube furnace, NH3 preheating tube, catalyst holder, and a gas chromatograph. The NH3 preheating tube and the catalyst holder were both located in the tube furnace. NH3 gas passed sequentially through the NH3 flow controller, preheating tube, and catalyst holder. The product gas passed through tubing to allow it to cool to room temperature and was then sampled by the gas chromatograph to determine its composition.
Metal monoliths were coated with 10, 15, and 20 wt % Co/B2CA as described above. The monoliths were fitted with tubing connections as shown in
The catalyst monolith was heated to temperatures ranging from 300 to 650° C. while a 1 standard liter per minute (sLm) flow of ambient pressure NH3 was provided to it. For these monoliths, that flow equates to a 300 hr−1 GHSV and a NH3 residence time of 12 seconds. The hydrogen content of the gas exiting the catalyst monolith was measured with the thermal conductivity device.
A metal monolith was coated with 20 wt % Co/B2CA as described above. The monolith was fit with tubing connections as shown in
The cracking fraction as a function of flow is shown in
The 20 wt % Co/B2CA monolith used in Example 2 was placed in the benchtop NH3 cracking test apparatus depicted in
After the 90 hour test was completed, the monolith's cracking fraction as a function of temperature was measured at 1 sLm NH3 flow.
Co/B2CA and Co-oxide/B2CA powders were prepared with 1 wt %, 5 wt %, 10 wt %, 15 wt %, and 20 wt % cobalt loadings using the methods described above. In this case, the cobalt salt was deposited on the B2CA powder by making a solution of cobalt chloride hexahydrate in acetone with the desired amount of cobalt, mixing B2CA powder into it, and then repeatedly stirring the mixture until the acetone had evaporated. As the acetone evaporated, the mixtures changed from blue to pink, indicating that the cobalt chloride salt ions had re-bonded.
The cobalt salt decorated B2CA powders were reduced to cobalt metal by annealing them in 50% H2+50% N2 gas flow for four hours at 700° C. After annealing the samples had all changed color to shades of black, indicating that the salt had reduced to cobalt metal. The Co/B2CA samples' NH3 synthesis characteristics were measured in a benchtop differential NH3 synthesis reactor. After that testing, the samples were oxidized by annealing in a tube furnace under a 50% N2+50% 02 flow for 4 hours at 700° C. After annealing in oxygen, the sample colors were unchanged except for the 1 wt % cobalt, which had a slightly reddish hue. The oxidized samples were then retested in the benchtop NH3 synthesis reactor.
For testing both the metallic cobalt and cobalt oxide decorations, one gram of catalyst powder was placed in the reactor. A 10 bar mixture of 75% H2+25% N2 was flowed through the powder catalyst bed at flows ranging from 2 to 20 sLm and temperatures ranging from room temperature to 625° C.
The effect of the barium calcium aluminum oxide composition on ruthenium-decorated and cobalt-decorated catalyst performance for NH3 synthesis was examined. Seven compositions in the BaO—CaO-Al2O3 ternary space were synthesized. The specific compositions were B21C16A3, BCA2, B5C7A4, B3C3A2, B2C5A, BCA, and B2CA. Each composition was divided into two samples that were decorated with either 20 wt % cobalt or 1 wt % ruthenium. The NH3 synthesis characteristics for 1 gram of each metal-decorated sample was examined in a benchtop differential NH3 synthesis reactor at temperatures up to 625° C. in a constant flow of 4 sLm of 75% H2+25% N2. at 10.6 bar.
From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that specific embodiments of the invention have been described herein for purposes of illustration, but that various modifications may be made without deviating from the scope of the invention. Accordingly, the invention is not limited except as by the appended claims.
This application claims priority and the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 119(e) to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Serial Nos. 62/799,595 (“Metal-Decorated Barium Calcium Aluminum Oxide Catalyst for Cracking NH3”), filed on 31 Jan. 2019; 62/801,578 (“Metal Monolith Supported Catalysts for NH3 Synthesis and Cracking”), filed on 5 Feb. 2019; and 62/931,537 (“Cobalt-Decorated Barium Calcium Aluminum Oxide for NH3 Synthesis and Cracking”), filed on 6 Nov. 2019, each of which is incorporated herein in its entirety by reference. This application is related to International Publication No. WO 2018/213305, entitled “Metal-Decorated Barium Calcium Aluminum Oxide and Related Materials for NH3 Catalysis” which was filed on 15 May 2018. It is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62799595 | Jan 2019 | US | |
| 62801578 | Feb 2019 | US | |
| 62931537 | Nov 2019 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 16779348 | Jan 2020 | US |
| Child | 18451768 | US |
