One or more embodiments relate to conversion of CO2 to CO or synthesis gas streams using Group II metal ferrites. More specifically, one or more embodiments relate to development of novel Group II metal ferrites such as Mg, Ca, Ba and Sr ferrites, for conversion of CO2 to CO or synthesis gas. In one embodiment, the Group II metal ferrites are used as catalyst for methane dry reforming process with CO2 to produce synthesis gas; which in another embodiment Group II metal ferrites are used in chemical looping dry reforming with CO2 to produce CO and in another embodiment Group II metal ferrites are used in coal gasification with CO2 to produce CO.
CO2 activation to produce useful products for chemical processes through a wide variety of approaches have been reported for CO2 utilization to control greenhouse gas emissions. Three different methods for converting CO2 to CO or synthesis gas using Group II metal ferrites. CO and synthesis gas are useful precursors for various chemical processes and are used as a fuel for energy production.
Catalytic dry reforming illustrated in reaction 1 is a process that converts two greenhouse gases, methane and carbon dioxide into a useful product, synthesis gas.
CH4+CO22 H2 ΔHR=+205 kJ mol−1 at 298 K [1]
Natural gas which mainly consist of methane is an abundant resource. Natural gas is flared in refineries and is necessary to develop cost effectives routes to convert natural gas to useful products. Steam methane reforming (SMR) shown in reaction [2] is the commercial process to produce synthesis gas and H2 from methane.
CH4+H2OCO+3H2 ΔHR=247 kJ mol−1 at 298 K [2]
However, the SMR process has many disadvantages: the H2/CO ratio obtained in the product stream is very high (>3) for direct downstream conversion processes; and excess steam is introduced requiring additional energy for steam generation.
The production of syngas from CO2 and CH4 via dry reforming as in reaction [1] is a promising alternative and has received industry attention as it offers several advantages such as mitigation of greenhouse gases CO2 and methane and converting these gasses into valuable syngas with a H2/CO ratio 1 which may be used to produce valuable chemicals downstream.
A technoeconomic analysis (See Kartick Monda, Sankar Sasmal, Srikant Badgandi, Dipabali Roy Chowdhury & Vinod Nair, Dry reforming of methane to syngas: a potential alternative process for value added chemicals—a techno-economic perspective, Environ Sci Pollut Res (2016) 23:22267-22273 DOI 10.1007/s11356-016-6310-4) indicates that dry reforming of natural gas/CO2 is a competitive process with lower operating and capital costs in comparison with steam refot ming assuming a negligible cost of CO2 import.
Various catalysts have been used for the dry reforming process (See Jean-Michel Lavoie, Review on dry reforming of methane, a potentially more environmentally- friendly approach to the increasing natural gas exploitation, Frontiers in chemistry, published: 11 Nov. 2014 doi: 10.3389/fchem.2014.00081, and WO Patent No. 2014/1645592 A1 to Meissner et al, titled Systems and methods for generating carbon dioxide for use as a reforming oxidant in making synthesis gas).
Supported noble metals (Pt, Pd, Rh, Ru) have shown promising results for methane dry reforming but are very expensive. Non-noble transition metals such as Ni, Co, Fe which are relatively less expensive have been used and Ni has shown the most promising results. However, Ni based catalysts tend to deactivate and there are environmental concerns with Ni. Therefore, it is necessary to develop more effective catalysts.
There is a need for catalysts used in a methane dry reforming process that improve performance, are inexpensive and environmentally safe.
In this process reported in the literature conversion of CO2 to CO is accomplished using CO2 as an oxidant in a process called “Chemical Looping Dry Reforming” (CLDR) (See Vladimir V. Galvitaa, Hilde Poelmana, Christophe Detavernierb, Guy B. Marin, “Catalyst-assisted chemical looping for CO2 conversion to CO”, Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 164 (2015) 184-191; and WO Patent No. 2014/016790 A1 to Al-Shankitiet al, titled Catalyst for thermochemical water splitting).
In the CLDR process, carbon dioxide is used for oxidizing a reduced oxygen carrier instead of using air as an oxidant as used in conventional chemical looping combustion (CLC) or in place of steam in the chemical looping steam reforming process. Either methane or coal may be used as the fuel for initial reduction of the oxygen carrier (MeO) to produce reduced metal (Me) while oxidizing the fuel. Instead of combusting the fuel fully, this initial reduction reaction of MeO may also be used to produce useful products such as CO or synthesis gas from fuel as shown in reactions [3], [4] and [5]. Then the reduced oxygen carrier (M) is oxidized with CO2 to form CO and MeO as shown in reaction [6].
Reduction of Oxygen Carrier (MO):
3MeO+2C=3Me+CO+CO2 [3]
MeO+2C+H2O=Me+2CO+H2 [4]
MeO+CH4=Me+CO+2H2 [5]
Oxidizer:
Me+CO2=MeO+CO [6]
Since CO2 is a highly stable molecule and a weak oxidant, selection of an oxygen carrier to perform the oxidation reaction is critical for this process. Stability of oxygen carriers at extended high-temperature cyclic operation and carbon formation during oxidation with CO2 are additional challenges. Additionally, slower oxidation kinetics using CO2 in place of oxygen (air) that is used in CLC need to be addressed.
Thermodynamic studies have shown that Fe-based carriers were the most suitable oxygen carriers but the reactivities of Fe based structures were low. Finding a suitable oxygen carrier to convert CO2 to CO has been a challenge.
There is a need for oxygen carriers for chemical looping dry reforming to convert CO2 to CO.
Process 3: Conversion of CO2 to CO Via Gasification of Coal with CO2 with an Oxygen Carrier
Coal gasification with CO2 as illustrated in reaction [7] has been reported to produce CO. (See Muhammad F. Irfan, Muhammad R. Usman b, K. Kusakabe, Coal gasification in CO2 atmosphere and its kinetics since 1948: A brief review, Energy 36 (2011) 12e40)
C+CO2→2CO [7] ΔHr=+172 mJ/kmol at 25 C and 1 atm
Alkali and alkali earth metals in the carbonate forms and iron have been used to promote the reaction [7]. Evaporation of these promoters and processing of coals with promoter solutions have been challenging issues for the process.
There is a need for promoters for the CO2 conversion to CO via coal gasification.
The invention provides Group II metal ferrites for conversion of CO2 to CO or synthesis gas via three methods: catalytic dry reforming with methane and CO2, chemical looping dry reforming via oxidation of the reduced metal ferrite with CO2 and promoting the coal gasification reaction with CO2. The metal ferrite comprises MzFexOy, where MzFexOy is a chemical composition with 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤6 and M is selected from Ca, Ba, Mg, Sr and/or combinations thereof. For example, MzFexOy may be one of CaFe2O4, BaFe2O4, MgFe2O4, SrFe2O4 and/or combinations thereof. Metal ferrite can also be supported on an inert support such as alumina, silica, zirconia, alumina-silicates or titania or the metal ferrite containing reactor bed may be diluted with the inert material.
In one embodiment, the invention provides a metal ferrite as a catalyst for dry-reforming of methane and carbon dioxide to produce syngas not diluted with nitrogen. The methane containing gas stream and carbon dioxide containing gas stream are introduced simultaneously to the metal ferrite catalyst. The metal ferrite oxygen carrier gets continuously reduced by methane while producing syngas but immediately gets oxidized by carbon dioxide. The reduction of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier and oxidation of the methane at the reducing temperature generates a product stream comprising at least 50 vol. % CO and H2. In an embodiment, the reducing and oxidizing temperatures are from about 500° C. to about 1100° C. The process is operated continuously. Group II metal ferrite catalyst may be in the oxidized form or in the reduced form. For example, the Group II metal ferrite may be in the form MzFexOy where z>0, 0<x<4 and 0<y<5.
In another embodiment, the Group II metal ferrite oxygen carrier may be utilized for the chemical looping dry reforming by delivering the metal ferrite oxygen carrier to a fuel reactor and introducing a fuel such as methane or coal to the metal ferrite oxygen carrier at a reducing temperature, such that some portion of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier is reduced and some portion of the fuel is oxidized. Within the fuel reactor, the metal ferrite oxygen carrier interacts with the fuel, generating a reduced carrier comprising an MzFexOy, MO and the FecOd component where c>0 and d≥0. For example, the FecOd component may be Fe or may be an iron oxide such as Fe3O4, among others. The reduction of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier may oxidize the fuel fully to produce CO2 and H2O or partially oxidize the fuel at the reducing temperature generating a product stream comprising at least 50 vol. % CO and/or H2. After the reduction of the oxygen carrier is completed, the reduced oxygen carrier is transferred to the oxidation reactor for oxidation with carbon dioxide containing gas stream to produce CO. The oxidized oxygen carrier after oxidation with carbon dioxide is transferred back to the fuel reactor for the next cycle. In an embodiment, the reducing and oxidizing temperatures are from about 500° C. to about 1100° C.
In another embodiment, the Group II metal ferrite may also be used as a promoter for gasification of coal. The coal and metal ferrite can be mixed and a carbon dioxide containing gas stream is supplied to the metal ferrite/coal. The reaction of coal in the presence of the metal ferrite generates a product stream comprising at least 50 vol. % CO. In an embodiment, the reducing and oxidizing temperatures are from about 500° C. to about 1100° C. Group II metal ferrite promoter may be in the oxidized form or the reduced form. For example, the Group II metal ferrite may be in the form MzFexOy where z>0, 0<x≤4 and 0<y≤5. The process is operated continuously.
One or more embodiments relate to a method of producing synthesis gas from methane. The method includes delivering a metal ferrite catalyst comprising MzFexOy to a catalytic reactor, where 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤5, and where M is at least one Group II alkali earth metal, and where the MzFexOy comprises at least 30 wt. % of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. One continuous gas stream containing methane comprising at least >1 vol. % of the one continuous gas stream is delivered and another continuous gas stream containing carbon dioxide comprising at least >1 vol. % of the other continuous gas stream is delivered. The catalytic reactor at a reaction temperature is maintained, where the reaction temperature is sufficient for the reaction of methane and carbon dioxide, and generating a continuous stream of gaseous products containing H2 and CO gas; and a product stream from a fuel reactor is withdrawn, where the gaseous products comprise the product stream, and where at least >50 vol. % of the product stream consists of CO and H2.
Still another embodiment relates to a method for chemical looping dry reforming of methane. The method includes delivering a metal ferrite oxygen carrier comprising MzFexOy to a fuel reactor, where 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤6, and where M is at least one of Mg, Ca, Ba, Sr and/or combinations thereof; and delivering a fuel stream to the metal ferrite oxygen carrier in the fuel reactor and maintaining the fuel reactor at a reducing temperature, where the reducing temperature is sufficient to reduce some portion of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier and oxidize some portion of the fuel stream, and generating gaseous products containing H2, CO or CO2 gas in the fuel reactor. The reduced metal ferrite is delivered to an oxidation reactor; the reduced carrier is oxidized by contacting the reduced carrier and carbon dioxide at an oxidizing temperature, where the oxidizing temperature is sufficient to generate an oxidizing reaction, where reactants of the oxidizing reaction comprise some portion of the carbon dioxide, some portion of the M component, and some portion of the FecOd component, and where a product of the oxidizing reaction is CO and a re-oxidized carrier, where the re-oxidized carrier comprises some portion of the MzFexOy. The method further includes withdrawing a product stream CO from the oxidation reactor, where the gaseous products comprise the product stream, and where at least >50 vol. % of the product stream consists of CO.
Yet another embodiment relates to a method of producing carbon monoxide from solid carbonaceous. The method includes delivering a metal ferrite promoter comprises MzFexOy to a gasification reactor, where the metal ferrite promoter comprises MzFexOy where 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤5, and where M is at least one of Mg, Ca, Ba, Sr or combinations thereof, where the MzFexOy comprises at least 30 wt. % of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. A solid carbonaceous fuel comprised at least one of coal, biomass, carbon, and municipal waste is delivered; and a continuous gas stream containing carbon dioxide of at least >1 vol. % is delivered. The gasification reactor is maintained at a reaction temperature, where the reaction temperature is sufficient for the reaction of coal and carbon dioxide, and generating a continuous stream of gaseous products containing CO gas; and a product stream is withdrawn from the gasification reactor, where the gaseous products comprise the product stream, and where at least >50 vol. % of the product stream consists of CO.
Embodiments of the Group II metal ferrite oxygen carriers disclosed are further demonstrated and described in the following description.
The following description is provided to enable any person skilled in the art to use the described embodiments and sets forth the best mode. Various modifications, however, will remain readily apparent to those skilled in the art, since the principles relate to conversion of CO2 to CO or synthesis gas streams using Group II metal ferrites. More specifically, one or more embodiments relate to the development of novel Group II metal ferrites such as Mg, Ca, Ba and Sr ferrites, for conversion of CO2 to CO or synthesis gas. In one embodiment, the Group II metal ferrites are used as catalyst in a methane dry reforming process with CO2 to produce synthesis gas; while in another embodiment Group II metal ferrites are used in a chemical looping dry reforming process with CO2 to produce CO. In another embodiment Group II metal ferrites are used in coal gasification with CO2 to produce CO.
In one or more embodiments, Group II ferrites such as Ba, Ca, Mg and Sr ferrites are used as catalysts in the methane dry reforming process are described. These ferrites are inexpensive and environmentally safe.
In at least one embodiment Group II metal ferrite oxygen carriers are used for chemical looping dry reforming to convert CO2 to CO. Very high conversions of CO2 to CO were observed via reaction [6].
In one or more embodiments Group II metal ferrites are used as promoters for the CO2 conversion to CO via coal gasification reaction [7]. The metal ferrites may promote the CO2 conversion to CO via reactions [3] and [6]. The metal ferrites may be added to coal separately without impregnating the coal with metal ferrite solutions making it a simple process for operation.
Another embodiment relates to a catalytic process using Group II ferrites combined with methane and carbon dioxide gas streams to produce a continuous stream of synthesis gas stream free of nitrogen. Group II metal ferrites such as barium and calcium ferrites have unique properties. They react with methane to produce CO and H2 reducing the metal ferrites while being oxidized with carbon dioxide. The Group II metal ferrites have lower reaction rates with the CO and H2, making it easier to control the reaction at the synthesis stage.
In another embodiment, Group II metal ferrites are oxygen carriers for chemical looping dry reforming to produce CO from CO2. In this process, oxidized Group II metal ferrite reacts with a fuel such as coal or methane to form reduced metal ferrite and oxidation of reduced metal ferrite with CO2 produces CO.
In another embodiment, Group II metal ferrites are promoters for the coal gasification reaction with carbon dioxide.
Embodiments provide a metal ferrite oxygen carrier having improved durability and reactivity over metal oxides currently used in the dry reforming of methane, chemical looping dry reforming of fuels such as coal and methane and coal gasification with CO2. The metal ferrite oxygen carrier comprises MzFexOy with 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤6 where M is one of Ca, Ba, Mg, Sr and/or combinations thereof.
In another embodiment, the metal ferrite oxygen carrier comprises MFe2O4. In particular embodiments, the MzFexOy comprises at least 30 wt. % of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. In certain embodiments, the metal ferrite oxygen carrier further comprises an inert support. The inert support material does not participate in the oxidation and reduction reactions of the MzFexOy comprising the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. In an embodiment, the inert support comprises from about 5 wt. % to about 70 wt. % of the metal ferrite and the MzFexOy comprises at least 30 wt. % of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. Dry reforming of methane or coal with the metal ferrite and CO2 generates a product stream of CO or syngas comprising at least 50 vol. % of the product stream.
A system 100 within which the Group II metal ferrite catalyst disclosed here may be utilized is illustrated in
The reaction involved in the catalytic reactor 101 between methane 103 and carbon dioxide 105 in the presence of metal ferrites 102 is described in reaction [1]. Within the catalytic reactor 101 metal ferrites 102 may be used in the oxidized form or in the reduced form where the metal ferrite is MzFexOy with 0<x≤4, z>0 and 0<y≤6 where M is at least one of Ca, Ba, Mg, Sr and/or combinations thereof. For example, the metal ferrite catalyst 102 comprises CaFe2O4 on the inert support or CaFe2O4 may be mixed with inert material in the reactor bed. The metal ferrite catalyst 102 may also comprise reduced forms of CaFe2O4 which is a mixture of CaO, CaFe2O5, Fe, and FeO. In the catalytic reactor 101, the reaction between methane 103 and carbon dioxide 105 in the presence of metal ferrites 102 produces syngas comprises of CO and H2 104. At the exhaust, at least 50 vol. % of the product stream comprises CO and H2. In an embodiment, at least 90 vol.+% of the product stream comprises CO and H2.
A system/process 200 within which the Group II metal ferrite oxygen carrier disclosed here may be utilized is illustrated in
Within fuel reactor 201, metal ferrite oxygen carrier interacts with fuel 205, and the MzFexOy comprising the metal ferrite oxygen carrier that reduces to a reduced carrier comprising one or more M components and a FecOd component. The M components comprise some portion of the M comprising the MzFexOy and MO. The FecOd component comprises some portion of the Fe comprising the MzFexOy, with c>0 and d≥0. For example, the FecOd component may be Fe or may be an iron oxide such as FeO, Fe0, and Fe3O4, among others. In an embodiment, the FecOd component is FeOt, where 0≤t≤1.5. For example, in an embodiment where the metal ferrite oxygen carrier is CaFe2O4 on the inert support, the CaFe2O4 interacts with fuel 205 in reactor 201 and generates a reduced carrier comprising CaO, Fe, Fe3O4, and Ca2Fe2O5. In this embodiment, the M components CaO and Ca2Fe2O5 generated by the reduction comprises some portion of the Ca comprising the CaFe2O4, and Fe and Fe3O4 comprise the FecOd component FeOt where 0≤O≤1.5. In an embodiment, the M components comprise some portion of the M comprising the MzFexOy and having an absence of the Fe comprising the MzFexOy, such as for example CaO.
The reducing temperature is sufficient to reduce some portion of the MzFexOy oxygen carrier and oxidize some portion of methane, generating products CO2, CO or syngas 206 in the fuel reactor 201. The CO2, CO or syngas products 206 are withdrawn from fuel reactor 201 as a product stream at exhaust, and the reduced carrier 203 may exit the fuel reactor. The reduced carrier 203 exiting fuel reactor may subsequently enter oxidation reactor 202. Oxidation reactor 202 further receives a flow of carbon dioxide 206 and facilitates contact between the reduced carrier 203 and carbon dioxide, generating a re-oxidized carrier 204 and a product stream CO 207 as shown in reaction [6].
The product of the oxidizing reaction is the re-oxidized carrier 204, where the re-oxidized carrier comprises MaFebOc on the inert support. Generally, the MaFebOc comprising the re-oxidized carrier 204 is substantially equivalent to the MzFexOy comprising the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. For example, when the metal ferrite oxygen carrier comprises CaFe2O4 on the inert support and the reduced carrier 203 comprises CaO, CaFe2O5, Fe, and FeO, then the oxidation reaction generates a re-oxidized carrier 204 comprising CaFe2O4 on the inert support. Oxidation reactor 202 is at an oxidation temperature sufficient to oxidize at least a portion of the reduced carrier by carbon dioxide. In an embodiment, the oxidizing temperature ranges from about 500° C. to about 1100° C.
Within embodiments described herein, to “reduce some portion of the metal ferrite oxygen carrier” refers to the loss of oxygen from the MzFexOy comprising the metal ferrite oxygen carrier. For example, the reduction of a MzFexOy composition to FeO, Fe3O4, and/or Fe and an M component, where the M component comprises some portion of the M comprising the MzFexOy, or alternatively, the reduction of a MzFexOy composition to a MaFebOc composition, where y/(z+x)>c/(a+b). In an embodiment, MzFexOy is one of CaFe2O4, BaFe2O4, and/or combinations thereof. The inert support when present does not participate in the oxidation and reduction reactions of the MzFexOy. In an embodiment, the inert support is alumina or zirconia.
Another system 300 within which the Group II metal ferrite oxygen carrier disclosed here may be utilized is illustrated in
CaFe2O4 was prepared by mixing metal nitrate precursors. The mixture was heated in an oven to 1000° C. at a ramp rate of 3° C./min in air and kept at 1000° C. for 6 h. These oxygen carriers can also be prepared mixing CaO and Fe2O3 instead of nitrate precursors.
In order to demonstrate the catalytic dry reforming methane with CO2 in the process 100 illustrated in
Performance data on catalytic dry reforming methane with CO2 with calcium ferrite diluted with zirconia at 900° C. is shown in
Performance data on catalytic dry reforming methane using CO2 with calcium ferrite diluted with alumina at 850° C. is shown in
In order to demonstrate the chemical looping dry reforming process 200 in
The performance data of chemical looping dry reforming with calcium ferrite is shown in
In order to demonstrate the process 300, gasification of Wyodak coal with CO2 was conducted in the presence of calcium ferrite in a fixed bed flow reactor. The fixed-bed flow reactor (inner diameter 7 mm) tests were conducted with a 4.5 g sample of calcium ferrite and 0.6 g of Wyodak coal. The metal ferrite -coal sample was heated in in 10% CO2 in He at a flow rate of 100 cm3/min (0.1 L/min) from ambient to 850° C. (ramp rate of 4° C./min). For comparisons, coal without the oxygen carrier was used in another experiment. The outlet gas compositions (CO2, H2, CH4, and CO) from the reactor were measured using a MS (Pfeiffer Omnistar). The effluent CO concentrations during the temperature ramp in 10% CO2 with and without Ca ferrite are shown in
Embodiments of the present invention provide one or more of the following:
Conversion of greenhouse gas, CO2 to useful chemical precursors such as CO and syngas using Group II metal ferrites are described in this invention;
Use of Group II metal ferrites as a catalyst to produce synthesis gas continuously via dry reforming of methane and carbon dioxide is described. Complete consumption of methane and CO2 to produce syngas was observed and the process demonstrated for 12 hours without any deactivation. Group II metal ferrites are low cost and environmentally safe unlike the Ni based materials reported for the process in the past;
Use of Group II ferrites in chemical looping dry reforming of fuel and CO2 to produce syngas and CO is also described. The process involves reacting the Group II ferrites with methane or coal to form synthesis gas and reduced metal ferrite in the fuel reactor followed by oxidation of the reduced metal ferrite with carbon dioxide to form CO in the oxidation reactor. Production of CO with Wyodak coal/calcium ferrite and oxidation of reduced calcium ferrite with carbon dioxide to from CO was demonstrated. High CO yields were obtained in the process;
Use of Group II ferrites for promotion of CO2 gasification of coal to produce CO is described. Production of CO at higher rates with Wyodak coal/CO2/Ca ferrite than that with Wyodak coal/Ca ferrite was demonstrated.
In addition to improved performance, Group II metal ferrites are low cost and environmentally safe as compared to materials previously used for these processes.
Having described the basic concept of the embodiments, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the foregoing detailed disclosure is intended to be presented by way of example. Accordingly, these terms should be interpreted as indicating that insubstantial or inconsequential modifications or alterations and various improvements of the subject matter described and claimed are considered to be within the scope of the spirited embodiments as recited in the appended claims. Additionally, the recited order of the elements or sequences, or the use of numbers, letters or other designations therefor, is not intended to limit the claimed processes to any order except as may be specified. All ranges disclosed herein also encompass any and all possible sub-ranges and/or combinations of sub-ranges thereof. Any listed range is easily recognized as sufficiently describing and enabling the same range being broken down into at least equal halves, thirds, quarters, fifths, tenths, etc. As a non-limiting example, each range discussed herein may be readily broken down into a lower third, middle third and upper third, etc. As will also be understood by one skilled in the art all language such as up to, at least, greater than, less than, and the like refer to ranges which are subsequently broken down into sub-ranges as discussed above. As utilized herein, the terms “about,” “substantially,” and other similar terms are intended to have a broad meaning in conjunction with the common and accepted usage by those having ordinary skill in the art to which the subject matter of this disclosure pertains.
As utilized herein, the term “approximately equal to” shall carry the meaning of being within 15, 10, 5, 4, 3, 2, or 1 percent of the subject measurement, item, unit, or concentration, with preference given to the percent variance. It should be understood by those of skill in the art who review this disclosure that these terms are intended to allow a description of certain features described and claimed without restricting the scope of these features to the exact numerical ranges provided. Accordingly, the embodiments are limited only by the following claims and equivalents thereto. All publications and patent documents cited in this application are incorporated by reference in their entirety for all purposes to the same extent as if each individual publication or patent document were so individually denoted.
This application is a divisional application of prior application Ser. No. 15/599,988 filed May 19, 2017, the complete subject matter of which is incorporated herein by reference.
The United States Government has rights in this invention pursuant to an employer/employee relationship between the inventors and the U.S. Department of Energy, operators of the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL). s
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 15599988 | May 2017 | US |
Child | 16550747 | US |