The disclosure relates generally to a method, system, theory, and apparatus for measuring large load that in some instances can be classified as mega loads or weights. In a more specific aspect of the invention it provides a system, apparatus, theory, and method for precisely measuring loads or the weight of an object directly in units of force or mass with an error of less 0.1%.
Measuring applied loads of a solid object over 10 metric tons to over 1000 metric tons is a challenging technology. In this heavy load range it is impractical to compare the applied load with the dead weight, which yields directly the applied load in force units of newton or kg. Most of the commercially available load cells are based on some sorts of arranged strain gages attached on the surface of a load carrying member and their outputs are amplified electrical quantities in proportion to the applied load. Therefore, the strain-gage based load cells are usually calibrated against the dead weight to know their real outputs. These load cells also drift with time and so they should be occasionally calibrated. Calibration could be expensive and difficult in the force range higher than one mega newton. Other type of load cells based on displacement, such as a proving ring and linear variable differential transformer (LVDT), etc., also need to be calibrated, because their outputs are not in units of force or mass. The load cells based on torque or moment also require calibration because of the same reason. At present it appears there is no load cell or load gauge that directly outputs the applied load in units of force or mass.
Thus, it is an objective of the present invention to provide a system, apparatus and method to measure loads directly in units of force or mass. It is an objective of the present invention to provide a system, apparatus, theory and method that eliminates the need to calibrate against a known dead weight. It is also an objective to provide a system, apparatus and method that can measure dead weights in excess of a few metric tons and in fact measure dead weights of up to 1,000 metric tons or more.
These and other objectives are achieved by providing new theoretical formulations, (which are later explained in detail below) and a method of measuring enormous loads directly in units of mass or force having the steps of: a) providing a load carrying member (LCM) capable of carrying large loads without undergoing plastic deformation; b) taking the following readings while there is a zero load on the LCM: i) recording an ambient temperature, ii) measuring the lateral dimensions and cross-sectional area of the LCM, iii) measuring round trip travel times of three types of ultrasonic waves through an interior of the LCM between opposite lateral flat surfaces of the LCM; c) applying a load to be weighed to the LCM and taking the following readings: i) recording an ambient temperature; ii) measuring lateral dimensional changes of the LCM; iii) measuring round trip travel times of three types of ultrasonic waves through an interior of the LCM between opposite lateral flat surfaces of the LCM; d) during steps b) and c), three types of the ultrasonic waves are: longitudinal, vertically polarized shear and horizontally polarized shear waves, all propagating in the horizontal lateral direction perpendicular to the vertical loading direction 3 and accounting for potential ambient temperature change and; e) calculating a force or mass of the applied load with an Absolute Precision Load Gauge Algorithm (APLGA) built on basis of the developed new theory with measurements taken b) and c) above.
In a further aspect of the invention the method of the step of accounting for potential ambient temperature changes is selected from one of the following options: a) maintaining the load carrying-member at a constant ambient temperature, and b) providing a zero reference member that is substantially the same as the load-carrying member and making the zero reference load member subject to the same ambient temperature as the load-carrying member, keeping the zero reference member at a zero load at all time during the measuring process and subtracting dimensional changes of the zero reference load member from that of the load-carrying member. In a further aspect of the invention the step of calculating the load with the APLGA comprises: a) calculating τ33 thermodynamic stress; and b) calculating the load using P=Aaλ3τ33, where Aa is the zero load cross sectional area of the load carrying member, and λ3 is the vertical principal stretch.
In another aspect of the invention it provides a load carrying member for use in directly measuring a large load in units of force and mass made of a) a material that is: i) isotropic or nearly isotropic at a zero load state; ii) able to bear a load to be measured up to the elastic limit before yielding to plastic deformation; b) structurally a portion of the column of the load carrying member (LCM) with its entire cross-section exhibiting uniform stress distribution when a load is applied to it.
In another aspect of the invention the load-carrying member's length is long enough so that a midsection of the load-carrying member will have uniform stress when a load is applied to the load-carrying member. These dimensions can be varied. By way of example and depending on the application the LCM's length could be 360 mm and its width is 122.6 mm.
In a further aspect of the invention the load-carrying member is cylindrically shaped with four flat surfaces running up and down the length of the load-carrying member each flat surface positioned so that is parallel to the flat surfaces on the opposite side of the load-carrying member and its plane is 90° to a plane of the two adjacent flat surfaces. In further aspect of the invention the load-carrying member can be made from: fused quartz, 7075 Aluminum alloy or (001) oriented silicon.
In additional aspects of the invention it provides: a) A single transducer or two or three separate ultrasonic transducers can be adopted to launch three types of ultrasonic waves to the load carrying member (LCM); b) a single linear encoder digital displacement probe is in contact with the lateral flat side of the load carrying member to measure the lateral dimensions of the LCM both at zero load and under load; and c) the zero reference member is employed to compensate for the dimensional changes of the LCM due to the drifts of the ambient temperatures. Additionally, the following types of transducers can be used among others: contact type piezoelectric transducers and non-contact type electromagnetic acoustic transducers (EMAT).
In yet another aspect of the system of the invention it includes a computer operatively connected to the three ultrasound transducers and a single linear probe, and the computer is programmed to measure a load applied to the load-carrying member based on readings obtained by the three ultrasonic transducers capable of generating three types of ultrasonic waves, and the a single linear displacement probe.
In yet a further aspect of the invention the system computer is programmed with an Absolute Precision Load Gauge Algorithm (APLGA) to compute the load based on the readings obtained by three piezoelectric transducers and a temperature compensated linear displacement probe. A variation as discussed below uses a single ultrasonic EMAT transducer and a single linear displacement probe.
In yet another aspect of the system of the invention the apparatus for dealing with potential ambient temperature changes is selected from one of the following possible options: a) a system to maintain the ambient temperature unchanged, and b) a zero reference load member positioned so that it is subjected to the same ambient temperature changes to which the load-carrying member may be subject, and an apparatus to subtract dimensional changes of the zero reference load member from those of the load carrying member. In a further aspect of the system of the invention a single ultrasonic transducer, such as a dual mode electromagnetic acoustic transducer (EMAT) can generate: a vertically polarized ultrasound shear wave, a horizontally polarized ultrasound shear wave, and a longitudinal ultrasound wave.
The accompanying drawings are included to provide a further understanding, and are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification. The drawings illustrate one or more embodiment(s), and together with the description serve to explain principles and operation of the various embodiments.
Overview of the System, Apparatus and Method
The present invention, the Absolute Precision Load Gauge (APLG), provides a method, system, theory, and apparatus for measuring an applied load directly in units of force—newtons or mass—kilograms or any other acceptable units of force or mass. (At some points in this specification, in particular equations for calculating, the applied load will be represented by the capital P.) The invention or inventions use among other things a unique algorithm developed by the inventor and an apparatus developed by the inventor which includes a unique load-carrying member. As will be discussed in detail below, specific measurements are taken of the load carrying member without a load applied to it, while it is in the zero load state. Then the load or object to be weighed is applied to the load-carrying member and the same measurements are taken. With the results obtained the applied load in units of force or mass is calculated for the load or object being measured using an Absolute Precision Load Gauge Algorithm (APLGA), a unique algorithm developed by the inventor. One of the unique and important features of the system, apparatus, theory, and method is that it can be used to measure loads that are well over 10 metric tons, loads that in fact can range up to a few thousand metric tons or more. As noted above and be discussed below in detail it does this by measuring changes in various parameters in the load-carrying member between a zero load state and then a fully loaded state when the load-carrying member is subjected to the full load or weight of the object being weighed. In this disclosure one of the key elements of the invention as the “load carrying member”, this will be described in detail below. In referring to it we will use its full name load carrying member or using the acronym “LCM”.
In this disclosure we will be referring to the quantity measured as the “load” or the “applied load”. Load in engineering sense means force(s) acting on an object or structure and are expressed in units of newton, which is a unit of force. Mass of an object is equal to the density of the object times its volume and is a measure of inertia and expressed in units of kilogram. When mass is multiplied by the gravitational constant 9.806 m/s2, it becomes weight, which is expressed in units of force (newton). Mass and weight are usually used interchangeably, because they can be converted by using the gravitational constant. We measure our body weight in a scale which expresses our body weight in units of mass, such as kilogram or pound, by using the conversion factor, gravitational constant. A floating mass or weight is not a load, but becomes a load on an object when the mass sits on or pulls the object. In addition to mass/weight, load can be generated by many other means, which include pushing, pulling, shoving the object. In a tensile or compression machine, load is generated not by the mass/weight but by a pulling or pushing the object. Pulling or pushing the object is a force generated by the tensile or compressive machine. In this case we cannot use the phrase “weighting the load or weight of the load”. We can instead properly use the phrase “measure or determine the (applied) load”.
As noted the invention uses unique formulas developed by the inventor to calculate the applied load. The calculations by the unique formulas are based on the following measurements:
The three ultrasonic waves are generated by ultrasonic transducers. Among the types of transducers that can be used to generate the waves includes but are not limited to: i) contact-type piezoelectric longitudinal and shear transducers, ii) non-contact type electro-magnetic acoustic transducers (EMATS), and iii) high-intensity laser irradiation and detection methods.
The lateral dimensional change caused by the applied load to the load-carrying member can be measured by, among other systems: i) A non-contact type of laser interferometric system, or ii) A linear optical encoder displacement probe, which is a contact type of system with a resolution of 50 nm.
For the most accurate measurements the system works best when the load-carrying member is initially an isotropic solid at a zero load with a high acoustoelastic constant. An example of such a material is amorphous fused quartz. A highly accurate LCM of the APLG that can be extended to a cubic single crustal, such as silicon with a low density. The LCM in the present invention can also be made of a material that possesses nearly isotropic but slightly transverse isotropic symmetry. 7075 aluminum alloy is such a material of which the load-carrying member can be fabricated. Aluminum alloy 7075's advantages include a low density and a high acoustoelastic constant. Also, it can be easily fabricated in the form and structure for its use as a load-carrying member. The load-carrying member must also able to bear the load being measured without undergoing plastic deformation. Amorphous fused quartz, cubic silicon, and aluminum 7075 can bear such heavy before yielding to plastic deformation. As will be discussed elsewhere herein aluminum 7075 of 123 mm diameter can bear up to 480 metric tons without undergoing plastic deformation.
Because of the need for high sensitivity and resolution in the measurement of the dimensional change of the load-carrying member it must be maintained at a constant temperature or at least account for potential temperature changes. Providing an environment for the load-carrying member of a constant ambient temperature or accounting for changes in temperature can be accomplished in a number of ways. One such way is to isolate the load-carrying member in an environment where the temperature is kept constant during the process of taking the various necessary measurements. However, another alternative is to have a second substantially identical zero reference load member, which is substantially the same as the load carrying member, but is kept load free and adjacent to the load-carrying member to which the load to be measured is applied and thus both the zero reference load member and the actual load-carrying member are subject to the same temperature change. In such a dual setup, changes in the zero reference load member's dimensions are simultaneously recorded by appropriate means, such as a linear encoder displacement probe. The output from the device reading the dimensions on both the actual and the zero reference load members is combined in real-time in subtraction mode so that the outputs of the displacement probes due to temperature change or drift are nulled or compensated, to thereby correct for any temperature change.
A Detailed Description of the System, Apparatus and Method
Load-carrying member 51 is the key to the entire system and method. As noted, the load-carrying member can be fused quartz, aluminum 7075, or materials with similar properties. Because of its properties and ease of fabrication, aluminum 7075 is used in the embodiment of the invention described herein.
Referring back to
Referring back to
Referring to the load-carrying member 77 depicted in
Referring back to
Referring to
Another alternative is to provide an identical load free member 52, identified as the zero reference load member, substantially identical to the load carrying member with its own linear displacement probe 63. Zero reference member 52 is within the proximity of the load-carrying member 51 and thus is subject to the same ambient temperature changes as the load-carrying member 51. Both probes 61 and 63 are positioned to detect changes in dimensions of the respective load-carrying member and zero reference member to which they are adjacent. Data transfer communication line 61A connects probe 61 to digital readout meter 65 and data transfer communication line 63A connects probe 63 to digital read out meter 65. Digital readout 65 is set in subtraction mode to thereby remove any dimensional changes caused by a temperature change in load carrying member 51 and only transfer the actual dimensional changes to load carrying member 51 caused by the applied load. In turn this information is transmitted via line 65A to Computer 75 to be used in the subject calculations.
An example of an appropriate digital read out meter with the appropriate subtraction mode is model DR600 made by Solartron, Inc. It also has the capability of displaying the output of the individual probes in real time. However, any similarly capable device could be used.
Various types of linear displacement probes 61 and 63 can be used. Among them are: 1) a non-contact type of laser interferometric system, or 2) a linear optical encoder displacement probe, which is a contact type of system. Obviously, other types of probes or systems which can accomplish the same results can be used. Additionally, the dimensional changes, they can also be measured by adopting a laser interferometric technique. Examples of potential interferometers are a Fabry-Perot Interferometer (FPI) or Michelson Interferometer.
As noted above three different types of ultrasonic waves are generated by an array of three ultrasonic transducers. As depicted in
In the embodiment of the system depicted in
The types of transducers that can be used include i) contact-type piezoelectric longitudinal and shear transducers, ii) non-contact type electro-magnetic acoustic transducers (EMATS), and iii) high-intensity laser irradiation and detection methods. In the embodiment depicted in
System 201 could be located at a port facility, a rail yard or truck depot. Typically these cargo containers are moved around by large cranes. Cargo containers such as container 203 can typically carry a load of up to 26 metric tons. As noted
Overview of APLG System
The present invention uses a system of equations an algorithm to calculate the applied load directly in force units of newtons or mass units of kilograms. The algorithm, the Absolute Precision Load Gauge Algorithm (APLGA) is used to calculate the applied load based on readings of the speed of the three different ultrasonic waves through the load-carrying member and the cross-sectional dimensions of the load-carrying member in the zero load state and under the full weight of the applied load to be measured as discussed elsewhere herein.
Setup the APLGMS Measuring System 300
1. Start APLGMSRT@ZL with data at Reference Temperature Tr kept constant and a zero load on the load-carrying member (LCM) 302.
Start with APLGMS@LOAD under applied load 304, with the following steps 305:
In the finite deformation theory the thermodynamic stress T33 is calculated using the complex formulae and measured data. (Note mathematical numeration and quantities, variables or symbols used in equations mathematical derivations etc. are identified in the glossary of terms set out at paragraph [0081] below) Dimensional changes are measured in the isothermal condition. The applied Cauchy stress σ33 is obtained from τ33 and fractional dimensional changes in lateral and vertical directions. Wave propagation is an adiabatic process that yields adiabatic second order elastic constants. Third order elastic constants obtained from the wave speed data and the dimensional change are mixed elastic constants. These adiabatic and mixed elastic constants are converted into isothermal values using the thermodynamics of finite deformation of elastic solids developed by the inventor. Then the isothermal second order elastic compliance constant S33T and the isothermal third order elastic compliance constant S333T are calculated. Finally applied load P is expressed in elegant simple form as P=Aaτ33 [1+S33Tτ33+(½) (S333T−S33T
According to the linear elasticity theory in the uniaxial homogeneous loading, say in the vertical direction 3, on an initially isotropic specimen at zero load, strain ε33 is linearly related to the Cauchy stress σ33 by the Hooke's law ∝33=Eε33 where E=1/S11 is the Young's modulus of a load-carrying specimen and can be easily and accurately obtained by measuring the longitudinal and shear wave-speeds, which also yield the Poisson's ratio ν=S12/S11.
Measuring the strain ε33 accurately in the loading direction is much more difficult than the horizontal strain ε11 or ε22, which can be easily and accurately measured by measuring the dimensional change of the specimen in the horizontal direction. Here, S11 and S33 are the elastic compliance constants referred to horizontal and vertical direction, respectively. Then vertical strain ε33 equal to −ε11/ν when multiplied by E, yields the Cauchy stress σ33. σ33 multiplied by the cross-sectional area of the specimen in situ finally yields the applied load. However, a slight complication arises in this method. The Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio obtained from the longitudinal and shear wave-speeds are adiabatic constants, while the dimensional changes are measured in the isothermal condition. The adiabatic Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio can be easily converted into isothermal values by using the thermodynamics of elastic solids.
The isothermal Young's modulus and isothermal Poisson's ratio should be used to calculate the applied load. The applied load using the linear elasticity theory is fairly accurate within a few percent error but may not be accurate enough in most cases that require a higher accuracy. To improve the accuracy of the load measurement, the finite deformation theory of elastic solids is adopted to derive the formulas for the applied load. In finite deformation theory, the internal or mechanical energy contains not only harmonic potential but also anharmonic terms that contribute to the nonlinear elastic behavior of the material.
Among other things the APLGA is used to derive equations for calculation of P the load to be measured. As will be shown in detail below various forms for calculating the value of P are formulated. The following six variations are derived in the sections covering the detailed derivation of the APLGA algorithm:
a. P=Aaλ12σ33
b. P=Aaλ3τ33
C. P=Aa(1+2η33)1/2τ33
d. P=Aaτ33 (1+η33−η322/2+ . . . )
e. P=Aaτ33 [1+S33T τ33+(S333T−S33T
f. P=Aaτ33 [1+E(a)−1τ33+(S333T−E(a)−2)τ332/2]+ . . .
While theory and derived algorithms and the equations listed above may seem complex and convoluted in one embodiment of the invention it can be reduced to merely solving the following equation:
P=Aaλ3τ33
where P is the weight of the object or applied load, Aa the cross sectional area of the load-carrying member at zero load, and τ33 is the thermodynamic stress on the load-carrying member when the load to be measured is applied on it. τ33 as shown in detail below is calculated using the APLGA algorithm. Use of equation P=Aaτ33 results in an error of less than 1% as will be shown below.
For example as will be discussed in more detail below in the fifth equation listed above P=Aaτ33[1+S33Tτ33+(S333T−S33T
Experimental Verification
Referring back to
Referring to
Referring back to
Referring to
Shown in
The linear encoder digital displacement probe 179 is a product of Solartron, Inc., model LE/25/S with a displacement resolution of 50 nm. The dimension of the load-carrying member under an applied load changes as the ambient temperature drifts with time. To compensate for the dimensional variations due to the temperature drift, a second probe 167 (see
A 200 MHz bandwidth Panametrics Pulser-Receiver 171 with 5 ns rise time is used to feed excitation pulses to three transducers via a switch box 169. The sound waves launched from transducers 161, 163 and 165 travel across load-carrying member 153, reflect back on the opposite flat face 153C and return to the transducers. They are amplified by the Pulser-Receiver and displayed on the 500 MHz Tektronix digital oscilloscope 173. The round trip travel times of echoed pulses are measured on the oscilloscope with an accuracy of a few parts in 100,000. The oscilloscope signals are brought into the digital computer via 73 (see
Finally, the output of the digital readout of the DR600 is brought into a digital computer, which processes the four measured quantities obtained both at zero load and applied load P through MatLab software “CalbFree_LoadCell” using the formulae shown in the theoretical discussions that start at paragraph [0079]. Computer 175 running the software on the cited formulae outputs C11T, C12T, S11T, S12T, C111T, C112T, C123T, S111T, S112T, λ1, λ3, τ33, σ33 and finally the applied load P.
As shown in TABLE I below, calculated APLG loads closely match the corresponding compressor loads with a small difference. The compressor load is only approximate, as the compressor machine did not function smoothly and its pressurizing oil medium under the piston leaked slowly during compression, and therefore it was difficult to maintain constant piston pressures. However, the close match between them provides a strong validity to the theory and experimental methods described in this article. An ultimate test lies in comparing the output of a strain-gage based load cell recently certified by the National Institute of Science and Technology (NIST) with the APLG output under the same high capacity loading machine, whether the specimen is in tension or in compression. The second term S33Tτ33 in the parenthesis of equation P at the bottom of table 1 contributes 0.3% or less to the APLG load P. The third term (S333T−S33T
At zero load natural state, the acoustic path length between two opposite flat faces of the specimen is 121.18 mm and the measured density ρa, cross-sectional area Aa and S11T are
ρa=2808.3 kg/m3 Aa==1.1772×10−2m2 S11T=1.4048×10−11(Pa)−1.
Ordinary engineering polycrystalline materials exhibit a slight anisotropy, which is difficult to characterize. During the manufacturing processes they may be heat-treated and also rolled. The rolling process induces texture in the rolled material and some of the textured materials may be characterized as possessing nearly isotropic but slightly transversely isotropic symmetry about the rolled direction. One should choose a loading direction 3 that coincides with the axis of transverse isotropy of the textured specimen. The transversely isotropic material has five second order elastic (SOE) constants, which can easily be determined at zero load natural state to calculate S33T, S12T and S13T. The transversely isotropic material possesses a total of 9 third order elastic (TOE) constants, which are usually measured with a significant error. A similar approach can be extended to a slightly orthotropic specimen. The details of the texture effects on the APLG load lie outside the scope of this work and will be treated elsewhere.
A more suitable specimen material may be chosen with amorphous isotropic fused quartz, because it has higher acoustoelastic constants due to its low density (2202 kg/m3), less than that of 7075 aluminum alloy, and because the difference between its isothermal and adiabatic values are very small due to its low thermal expansion coefficient and may be safely ignored. Therefore, fused quartz with an approximately 100 mm cross-sectional diameter may be an ideal candidate. The drawback is that it is expensive to manufacture and fabricate such a large piece of fused quartz. Another ideal specimen candidate may be a (001) oriented single crystal of silicon with an approximately 100 mm diameter cross-sectional area. The theory can be extended without difficulty to a cubic single crystalline specimen with necessary additional measurements of the sound waves propagating in the [100] and [110] directions.
The three piezoelectric ultrasonic transducers used in this experiment are a contact type, which requires a slight lateral stress on the specimen to provide a solid coupling. This coupling pressure problem can be overcome by adopting non-contact type ultrasonic transducers, such as a dual mode EMAT (electromagnetic acoustic transducer) with a single magnet and a pancake coil. This type of EMAT is capable of measuring the sound speeds of L, SV, and SH waves with a single EMAT and may be ideally suited for construction of the APLG. Better accuracy and resolution in lateral displacement can be achieved by adopting a laser interferometric technique, a Fabry-Perot Interferometer (FPI) or Etalon could be used for this measuring technique.
Synopsis of APLG Theory
Calculation of an applied load P on a vertically loaded specimen, which was initially isotropic at zero load state, is carried out using four physical quantities measured both at the initial state of zero load and under subsequent applied load. They are the travel times of horizontally propagating longitudinal (L), vertically polarized shear (SV), horizontally polarized (SH) shear waves, and the specimen dimension along the acoustic path in the horizontal direction. Prior to these four measurements, the specimen density ρα is separately determined from the precisely measured specimen volume and mass at zero load condition.
Detailed Derivation and Explanation of the Theory
Consider a load-carrying specimen that is loaded in the vertical direction 3. The Cauchy stress σij (i,j=1, 2, 3) applied in the vertical direction is specified by σij=σ33δi3δj3 and likewise the thermodynamic stress τij=τ33δi3δj3 The coordinates of a particle of the stressed body is said to be in the initial state and is denoted by the Cartesian coordinates X. The corresponding Cartesian coordinates under the stress-free zero load are denoted by vector a. As the stress level of the initial state X is arbitrary, it can include a stress free state a as a special case. For the sound wave propagating in the horizontal direction, say direction 1, with a wave normal n=[1,0,0], Christoffel equation is expressed as
where CαβS(X; X) are adiabatic thermodynamic elastic stiffness coefficients referenced to and evaluated at the initial state X, ρX is the density of the material at the stressed initial state and V is the sound wave speed. The former X and the latter X inside the parenthesis represent an evaluation state and a zero reference state, respectively. When the reference and evaluation states are the same in the notation of the thermodynamic elastic coefficients, it is henceforth understood that the parenthesis of the thermodynamic elastic stiffness coefficients is denoted with the single argument, as in the following examples:
The same convention applies to the compliance coefficients as
The solution of Eq. (1) yields
ρXVL2(X)=C11S(X)ρXV212(X)=C66S(X)βXV312(X)=C55S(X), (2)
where VL(X), V21(X), and V31(X) denote velocities of the longitudinal wave, horizontally polarized shear (SH) wave in the direction 2 and vertically polarized shear (SV) waves in the direction 3, respectively, all propagating in the direction 1 and measured at the initial state X.
The dimensional change of the load-carrying member in the [100] direction is measured in an isothermal condition, while the elastic constants obtained from the wave speed measurements are adiabatic values. Isothermal elastic coefficients CαβT and SμνT can be calculated from the adiabatic values by the following conversion formulae
S
μν
T
=S
μν
S
+Tα
μ
ταντ/(ρXCτ)(μ,ν=1,2, . . . 6), (3b)
[SαβT]=[CαβT]−1, (3c)
where αμτ is the thermal expansion coefficient at constant thermodynamic stress τ, T is the absolute temperature, SμνT and SμνS are respectively isothermal and adiabatic thermodynamic elastic compliance coefficients, and Cη and Cτ are the specific heat at constant Lagrange strain ηij and at constant thermodynamic stress τij, respectively. The isothermal third order elastic constants are related to the mixed order constants CαβγM ≡(∂CαβS/∂ηγ)T by
S
αβγ
T
=−S
αν
T
S
βμ
T
S
γλ
T
C
νμλ
T. (4b)
With respect to equations 3a, 4a and 4b and elsewhere herein Einstein's convention is used namely that summation over the repeated indices is implied, unless otherwise specified.
When the direction of the applied load coincides with that of the principal strain or stress, it is convenient to introduce the principal stretches defined by
Note that λ1=λ2 and ρX/ρa=1/(λ12λ3) apply to isotropic solids and also apply to cubic, and transversely isotropic solids when the applied loading direction coincides with one of cubic axes and the symmetry axis of transversely isotropic solids, respectively. For the case of σij=σ33δi3δj3 and τij=τ33δi3δj3
λ12=λ22=1+2η11=1+2S13Tτ33+S133Tτ33+ . . . (6a)
λ32=1+2η33=1+2S33Tτ33+S333Tτ332+ . . . , (6b)
where η11 and η33 are Lagrange principal strains in the directions 1 and 3, respectively. Let La1 and ΔLa1 denote the specimen length in horizontal direction 1 at the strain-free state and dimensional change in direction 1 under an applied load, respectively. λ1=λ2 is given by
λ1=λ2=(La1+ΔLa1)/La1. (6c)
Denoting the Young's modulus of a specimen material to be E(a) at the strain-free natural state, note that for isotropic solids at zero load
S33T=S11T=S22T=1/E(a)S13T=S12T=S23T S333T=S111T. (6d)
Cauchy stress σ33 is related to thermodynamic stress τ33 by Murnaghan equation as
Now we introduce natural velocity W, which is defined by the original length La1 at zero load in direction 1, divided by the travel time of the sound wave at a stressed state X. For the longitudinal waves
ρaWL2(X)=λ3ρXVL2(X)=λ3C11S(X) (8a)
λ3C11T(X)=C11T(a)+[S12T(a)(2C11T(a)+C111T(a)+C112T(a))+S11T(a)C112T(a)]τ33+ . . . (8b)
Making use of Eq. 3a and C11S(a; a)=ρaWL2(a), it can be seen that
For shear waves, difference between isothermal and adiabatic values vanishes. Therefore,
ρa(W212(X)−W212(a))=[2S1T(a)ρaW212(a)+S12T(a)C111T(a)/2+(S11T(a)−S12T(a))C112T(a)/2−S11T(a)C123T(a)/2]τ33+ . . . (9b)
ρa(W312(X)−W312(a))=[2S11T(a)ρaW312(a)+(S11T(a)+S12T(a))C111T(a)/4−(S11T(a)−S12T(a))C112T(a)/4−S12T(a)C123T(a)/2]τ33+ . . . . (9c)
The two terms in Eq. 9a involving the thermal expansion coefficients and specific heats can be approximated to be linearly proportional to τ33. We first notice that Cη(X) is equal to CV(a) at a strain free state for isotropic and cubic solids. Its change with strain or stress is negligible within the elastic limit of solids.
where β=3ατ(a) is the volume thermal expansion coefficient and BT=(C11T(a)+2C12T(a))/3 is the isothermal bulk modulus at zero load natural state a. For simplicity of notation, hence we drop the notation (a) when the physical variables are evaluated at zero load natural state a. In Eqs. 10a-10d we use for specific heat and temperature coefficients of and S11T(a) and S12T(a) the values quoted in literature.
Letting
Z0≡2S12TC11T+Δ[2S12TC11T+(4/3)(S11T+2S12T)C12T+2β−1C11T(∂S11T/∂T)+2β−1(C11T+C12T)(∂S12T/∂T)] (11a)
Z1≡S12T(1+2Δ/3), Z2≡S11T(1+4Δ/3)+S12T(1+8Δ/3), Z3≡(2Δ/3)(S11T+S12T), (11b)
Eqs. 9a, 9b, and 9c can be written as
Z1C111T+Z2C112T+Z3C123T=ρa(WL2(X)−WL2)/τ33−Z0 (12a)
(½)S12TC111T+(½)(S11T−S12T)C112T−(½)S11TC123T=ρa(W212(X)−W212)/τ33−2S12TρaW212 (12b)
(¼)(S11T+S12T)C111T−(¼)(S11T−S12T)C112T−(½)S11TC123T=ρa(W312(X)−W312)/τ33−2S11TρaW312. (12c)
C111T, C112T and C123T in terms of τ33 are expressed with the following determinants:
C
111
T
=E
a/τ33−Ed, C123T=Eb/τ33−Ee, C123T=Ec/τ33−Ef (14)
Note that all the physical variables appearing in Eqs. 13a-13g can be obtained from the four measured quantities as aforementioned with the thermal variables that can found in the literature.
Using Eq. 4b, S133T in Eq. 6a can be expressed for an isotropic solid in terms of CαβγT. Then,
n11=(λ12−1)/2=S12Tτ33+S112Tτ33/2+ . . . =S12Tτ33−(gC111T+hC112T+2gC123T)τ332+ . . . =(S12T−gEa−hEb−2gEc)τ33+(gEd+hEe+2gEf)τ332+ . . . , (15)
where
g≡S12T(S11T
The last equation of Eq. 15 is a quadratic equation of τ33, which can be solved with measured λ1 or η11. When η11 is positive under a compressive load, the negative root of τ33 is taken by convention. The positive root of τ33 is taken by convention for the case of η11 being negative under a tensile load. C111T, C112T, and C123T are then calculated via Eq. 14. S333T=S111T for an isotropic solid is obtained using Eq. 4b. S111T is expressed as
S111T=−[(S11T
Finally, using Eqs. 7 and 6b, one obtains the applied load P on the load-carrying member of the APLG as
where Aa and E(a) are respectively the cross-sectional area and Young's modulus of the specimen at the zero load natural state. Note that for an isotropic solid, S33T=S11T, S13T=S12T, and S333T=S111T. (see Eqs. 6d)
Background Anisotropic and Isotropic Wave Modes
Regarding the launching, propagation and detection of three types of ultrasonic waves, longitudinal, fast shear and slow shear waves in elastic solids as discussed herein. The longitudinal waves propagate substantially faster than the shear waves. For a longitudinal wave, the direction of a particle vibration is very close to the direction of its propagation. For a shear wave, its direction of particle vibration is nearly perpendicular (or transverse) to the direction of propagation. Because of the shear wave vibration characteristics, shear wave is sometimes called “transverse wave”.
The distinction between isotropic solids and anisotropic solids has significance with respect to the invention herein. The word “isotropic” means that in all directions inside the solids, physical properties including particular mechanical, acoustic, and electrical properties are the same. Longitudinal waves propagate at the same speed in every three dimensional direction inside the solids. Likewise for shear waves. In isotropic solids there exist only two distinctive ultrasonic waves that are longitudinal and shear waves. A longitudinal waves vibrates in the exactly same direction as its propagation. A shear wave vibrates exactly perpendicular to its propagation direction.
However, in anisotropic solids, physical properties are directionally dependent. Longitudinal and shear wave speeds depend on the direction of their propagation inside the anisotropic solids. Moreover, the shear waves launched into a solid from the attached transducer decompose into fast shear (fast transverse (FT)) and slow shear (slow transverse (ST)) waves, whose wave speeds are respectively directionally dependent. In other words, in the anisotropic solids, there exist three types of ultrasonic waves, one longitudinal and two shears which are FT and ST waves. Longitudinal waves vibrate close to their propagation direction and they are sometimes called quasi-longitudinal (QL). The FT and ST modes vibrates nearly perpendicular to their propagation direction and are called respectively quasi-FT (QFT) and quasi-ST (QST) waves. However, these three QL, QFT and QST waves vibrate mutually perpendicular to each other. In particular symmetry directions called pure mode directions of anisotropic solids, QL becomes a pure longitudinal wave whose vibration direction coincides with the propagation direction, and QFT and QST become respectively pure FT and pure QT, whose vibration direction is exactly perpendicular to the propagation direction.
Isotropic solids include amorphous glass materials, fused quartz, plastics such as nylon, flexi glass, polystyrene, etc. Many polycrystalline metals, such as aluminum, steel, stainless steel, and their alloys are nearly isotropic and they are usually treated as virtually isotropic materials. 7075 aluminum alloy I have used as an APLG load carrying member is such a case.
Anisotropic materials include single crystals of metals, ionic materials and semiconductors, etc. (001) oriented cubic silicon is a semiconductor single crystal. A hexagonal zinc single crystal is an anisotropic material which is having a transversely isotropic symmetry about its symmetry axis [0001]. These single crystals are anisotropic at stress-free zero load state.
Every physical property is stress-dependent. Longitudinal and shear wave speeds change as a function of stress. Isotropic materials at zero load stress-free state becomes anisotropic, which can be characterized as “slightly transversely isotropic but nearly isotropic” when they are loaded in a uniaxial vertical direction, just as in the APLG case. Induced anisotropy of initially isotropic materials are quite small. However, with up-to-date precision wave speed measurements we can detect anisotropy-induced small changes of longitudinal and shear wave speeds. Under the loaded state, pure transverse (shear) wave of initially isotropic solids decomposes into fast transverse (FT) and slow transverse (ST) modes, which propagate at slightly different wave speeds. In an APLG case under compressive loads, vertically polarized shear mode is pure FT mode and horizontally polarized shear mode is pure ST mode. Under tensile loads, the role reverses, i.e., vertically polarized shear mode is pure ST mode and horizontally polarized shear mode is pure FT mode.
Most of commercially available transducers are a contact-type planar thin-disk piezoelectric element, which activates either a longitudinal wave or a shear wave. When the longitudinal transducer is excited by a high-voltage electric signal, the generated longitudinal wave vibrates normal to the plane of thin piezoelectric disk and propagates into a contacted solid normal to the plane of the thin disk. A shear transducer vibrates in a particular direction (called polarization direction) parallel to the plane of the thin disk. The shear wave launched into an anisotropic material from the shear transducer decomposes into FT and ST waves, which propagate normal to the thin planar disk. The vibration (or polarization) direction of the shear transducer is indicated usually as the direction of high-voltage electrode into which high-voltage electric signals are fed. In our experiment we align the vibration (or polarization) direction of one shear transducer along the vertical loading direction, so that the shear transducer launches and detects only the vertically polarized FT mode. The vibration direction of the other shear transducer is aligned in the horizontal direction, so that it launches and detects only the horizontally polarized ST wave. The difference between FT and ST wave speeds in our experiment is so small that it is better to use two shear transducers, which separately detects FT and ST waves. However, for an anisotropic material such as a silicon crystal, the FT and ST modes propagate at substantially a different wave speed, and therefore one shear transducer whose polarization direction is aligned quite apart from either vertical or horizontal direction will distinctly detect both FT and ST waves that arrive at quite a different time. Thus with an anisotropic material used as an APLG load-carrying member, one needs one longitudinal and one shear transducers, which will somewhat simplify the task.
The noncontact EMAT (electromagnetic acoustic transducer) with single magnet and a pancake coil generates and detects three wave modes in a conducting anisotropic material. The physics of the generation and detection of the longitudinal, FT and ST modes are complicated and will not be elaborated here. Because it is non-contact and one transducer detects three modes of waves, it is ideally suited for an APLG construction.
It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications and variations can be made without departing from the spirit or scope of the invention. Since modifications, combinations, sub-combinations and variations of the disclosed embodiments incorporating the spirit and substance of the invention may occur to persons skilled in the art; the invention should be construed to include everything within the scope of the appended claims and their equivalents.
This application claims the benefit of priority under the applicable laws of the United States of: U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 62/732,612 filed on Sep. 18, 2018 entitled Design and Construction of an Absolute Load Gauge, and U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 62/799,398 filed on Jan. 31, 2019 entitled Method and Apparatus of an Absolute Precision Load Gauge, U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 62/766,623 filed on Mar. 22, 2019 entitled Method and Apparatus of an Absolute Precision Load Gauge, the contents of which are relied upon and incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4522071 | Thompson | Jun 1985 | A |
4601207 | Steblay | Jul 1986 | A |
5004059 | Webster | Apr 1991 | A |
5016200 | Passarelli | May 1991 | A |
5170366 | Passarelli | Dec 1992 | A |
6424922 | Bray | Jul 2002 | B1 |
6477473 | Bray | Nov 2002 | B2 |
Entry |
---|
The Theory of Themodynamic-Acoustoelelastic Stress Guage; Kwang Yul Kim and Wofgnig Sachse Journal of Applied Physics 80, 4934 (1996). |
Nonlinear Elastic Equaiton of State of Solids Subjected To Uniaxial Homogeneous Loading; Kwang Yul Kim and W. Sachse Journal of Material Science, 35 (2000) 3197-3205. |
Thermodynamics at Finite Deformation of an Anisotropic Elastic Solid; Kwang Yul Kim Physical Review B, vol. 54, No. 9 (Sep. 1, 1996—I). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62732612 | Sep 2018 | US | |
62799398 | Jan 2019 | US | |
62766623 | Mar 2019 | US |