1. Technical Field
The present invention relates to a method and apparatus for compacting a slug of product.
2. Description of Related Art
Product often settles after it has been packaged making the package appear less than full. Thus, often a package appears full once it is manufactured, but after further settling appears less full. One example is that of a traditional flex bag containing snacks such as potato chips. Such flex bags are traditionally made and filled in a vertical form, fill, and seal machine.
During shipping and handling the product within the package begins to settle, increasing the void space at the top of the package. A package which has sat on a retail shelf, after transportation and handling, will often look less full than a package taken directly from the bagmaker. This results in a variety of problems. First, a package appearing and feeling less full is less appealing to a customer compared to a fuller package. Second, many consumers are unpleased to open a package to realize the package is about half full. Third, due to the increased void space after the product settles, the prior art package is larger than needed at this point relative to its contents. Such a package unnecessarily takes up valuable space on a retail shelf space, in shipping trucks, in warehouses, and in consumers' pantries. Further, manufacturing materials such as plastic films are wasted in forming such a package.
For the above reasons, attempts have been made to decrease the void space in a package. One attempt disclosed in commonly owned U.S. Publication No. 2006/0165859 which teaches that randomly shaped product tends to settle less over time than uniformly shaped product and thus discloses producing randomly shaped product. One drawback of this method, however, is that is it not always desirable to produce randomly shaped products.
Another known method is partially filling the package with product, vibrating the package to settle the product within the package. Thereafter additional product is added to the package and the process repeated. Unfortunately, this process is very slow and cannot be conducted at high rates on a traditional vertical form, fill, and seal machine.
Accordingly, one object of the instant invention is to provide an apparatus and method which results in increased compaction of product within a package. Furthermore, because many packages involve a vertical form, fill, and seal machine, it is desirable that the apparatus and method be easily adapted for use on such a machine, preferably with only minor modification and without significantly decreasing bag rates.
The novel features believed characteristic of the invention are set forth in the appended claims. The invention itself, however, as well as a preferred mode of use, further objectives and advantages thereof, will be best understood by reference to the following detailed description of illustrative embodiments when read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein:
Several embodiments of Applicants' invention will now be described with reference to the drawings. Unless otherwise noted, like elements will be identified by identical numbers throughout all figures.
Generally, this invention relates to a method and apparatus for compacting a slug of product and increasing compaction of product within a package. Compaction refers to the density of product within a package. A goal is to form and compact an intermediate slug of product which is subsequently discharged into a packaging apparatus and eventually into a package. An additional goal in one embodiment is to ensure the increased compaction remains throughout the packaging operation. Applicants have found forming and compacting an intermediate slug and then discharging said slug for packaging results in increased product compaction. A slug of product refers to a collected charge of product.
Because of the resulting increased compaction of the product at the bagmaker, less settling occurs during the subsequent, shipping, handling, and displaying of the package. Thus, the apparatus and method of this invention ensures that the package displayed on the shelf will more resemble the package as seen at the bagmaker. As used herein, a bagmaker refers to any packaging apparatus. The method and apparatus can be utilized on a wide variety of bagmakers including but not limited to a vertical form, fill, and seal machine and horizontal form, fill, and seal machines, bag in a box apparatus, as well as boxing machines. Likewise, a packaging apparatus referred to as a fill seal bagmaker, whereby premade bags are opened, filled, and sealed, can also be utilized. The final packages described herein can comprise traditional flex packages associated with snack product, vertical packages, box packaging, bag in a box packaging, and other products containing product which is subject to settling.
The apparatus and method can be utilized to increase compaction of a variety of products including food products such as chips, pretzels, cookies, noodles, nuts, cereal, and seeds. Likewise, this invention also applies to individually wrapped products such as individually wrapped mints or other candies which are susceptible to settling. The apparatus and method also works for other various dry products including dog food, cat food, pens, etc.
As depicted the settling device 207 comprises a single settling chamber 204, a vibrator 208, and a gate 206. A settling device, as used herein, refers to a device which receives and captures an amount of product in order to form an intermediate slug of compacted product. A settling chamber 204 is a distinct chamber which receives and retains product. In one embodiment the settling chamber 204 has four vertical walls and an open top and bottom.
Applicants have found that collecting product discharged from the weigher 101 and holding product, for a period of time, in the settling chamber 204 facilitates settling of the product and increases compaction of the product. Increasing the settling of the product during packaging results in a decrease of post manufacturing settling. The settling chamber 204 can be jostled or vibrated via a vibrator 208 to facilitate and speed up the settling of the product. The time necessary and the amount of external energy, such as vibrations, required to facilitate settling is dependent upon many factors including but not limited to the geometry of the product, the size and geometry of the settling chamber, the size of the slug, and the level of compaction desired. Those skilled in the art will be able to determine the amount of time and energy required to yield a desired level of compaction. Other movements such as vertical, horizontal, rotational, vibrational, and mixtures thereof can also be imparted to the settling chamber to facilitate settling of the product which results in increased compaction. The vibrator 208, which is optional, can comprise any device which vibrates the settling chamber 204. The vibrator 208 can be located in various places throughout the settling device 207.
Applicants have found that the geometry of the settling chamber 204 has an effect on the shape of the packaged slug as well as the shape of the final package, especially if the final package is a traditional flex bag. In one embodiment the cross-sectional shape of the settling chamber 204 is substantially similar to the desired shape of the slug. For example, in one embodiment the settling chamber 204 has a substantially oval cross-section to mimic the substantially oval cross-section of a traditional flex bag. Other cross-sections may be utilized including but not limited to a circular and square cross-section.
The height of the settling chamber 204 can be varied according to the desired size and shape of the intermediate slug which ultimately dictates the size and shape of the finished product. In one embodiment the size of the settling chamber 204 is approximately 0.5 to 2.5 times the height of the final package, and in one embodiment the settling chamber 204 is approximately 1.25 times the height of the final package. The size of the chamber is dependent upon a variety of factors including the amount of settling required. In one embodiment, the height of the settling chamber 204 is chosen so as to properly fit between the weigher and the packing apparatus without raising the weigher.
In one embodiment, the bottom of the settling chamber 201 has a larger opening than the top of the settling chamber. For some products susceptible to bridging, having a larger exit diameter minimizes bridging. This helps the product maintain its desired compact shape and results in faster and more efficient discharges.
At the bottom of the settling chamber 204 is a gate 206. The gate 206 can comprise many types of gates including sliding and swinging gates. In one embodiment the gate 206 is a sliding gate which allows for quick and efficient discharge of the product from the settling chamber 204.
Downstream of the gate 206 is the product delivery cylinder 103. In some embodiments there is an intermediate funnel 209 which directs product discharged from the gate 206 to the product delivery cylinder 103. The intermediate funnel 209 can comprise one or more funnels which can comprise straight or slanted walls. Further, the intermediate funnel 209 can comprise a variety of shapes. In one embodiment, the intermediate funnel 209 has a shape similar to the shape of the settling chamber 204.
In some embodiments, as the process moves downstream from the receiving funnel 102 to the product delivery cylinder 103, each subsequent downstream transition point has a larger diameter than the upstream transition point. Thus, in such an embodiment, the intermediate funnel 209 has a larger diameter than the settling chamber 204 but a smaller diameter than the product delivery cylinder 103. Such an arrangement minimizes bridging and any other disruption to the united slug.
Thus, the method for compacting a slug of product begins by weighing an amount of product in a weigher. Then, the product is directed and received into a settling device. Once the product is in the settling device, the product is compacted to form a slug of product. As discussed, this can be accomplished by storing the product for a time, or by jostling, rotating, and/or vibrating the settling device. After compacting the product, the product is discharged to a product delivery cylinder. It should be noted that the product can be directly discharged into the product delivery cylinder or it can be discharged into an intermediate funnel or chute before reaching the product delivery cylinder. Thereafter the slug is deposited from the product delivery cylinder into a package. As discussed above, the settling device is located downstream from a weigher and upstream from the product delivery cylinder. Further, the settling device can comprise only a single settling chamber, or the device can comprise more than one settling chamber.
In one embodiment the settling device 207 comprises only a single settling chamber 204. However, in other embodiments the settling device 207 comprises more than one settling chamber 204. In one embodiment, two or more settling chambers 204 act in parallel, each discharging its slug to the downstream product delivery cylinder 103. In other embodiments at least two chambers 204 act in series whereby a first chamber is located below a second chamber and product is partially settled in a first chamber before being deposited for further settling in a second chamber. In one embodiment, one or more settling chambers 204 are located on a rotary settling device. In one embodiment each subsequent chamber results in increased settling.
In a rotary settling device 304, the settling chambers 204a-h can be arranged in a variety of positions. In one embodiment, the centers of each settling chamber are evenly spaced along the turret table 305. In one embodiment the chambers are evenly spaced and oriented like a wagon spoke. As depicted, the settling chambers 204 are angled relative to the turret table 305 to maximize the number of chambers which will fit on the turret table 305.
In the embodiment depicted, the settling chambers 204 have an open top and bottom so the product is maintained within the settling chambers 204 by the presence of the stationary turret table 305. In such an embodiment the settling chambers 204 glide and rotate over the turret table 305. There is an opening 308 in the turret table 305 located above the gate 306. In one embodiment, the shape of the opening corresponds to the shape of the settling chamber 204. The chamber located in the position above the gate 306, and aligned with the opening 308, is referred to as the discharge chamber 204a. The product in the discharge chamber 204a is maintained by the gate 306. Accordingly, when the gate 306 is opened, via sliding or otherwise, the product falls through the opening 308 in the turret table 305 and passes the open gate 306. Those skilled in the art will understand that there are other ways of maintaining product within each settling chamber such as having a separate gate for each settling chamber.
In one embodiment, downstream and below the gate 306 is the product delivery cylinder 103. In such an embodiment, the compacted slug is discharged from the discharge chamber and into the product delivery cylinder 103 where it is subsequently packaged in a bagmaker.
The settling chambers 204 can be filled in a variety of locations. In one embodiment, the discharge chamber 204a is also the same settling chamber which receives product, called the receiving chamber. In such an embodiment, after discharging product in the discharge chamber 204a the gate 306 will close. Thereafter, the discharge chamber 204a will then receive product. All of the settling chambers 204 in turn will then move one spot in the progression, during which time the product in the settling chamber settles and becomes more compact. Thus, in some embodiments the receiving and discharging do not take place simultaneously.
After the receiving chamber 204c has received its product, it rotates clockwise throughout the positions until it again becomes the discharge chamber 204a. While the example has been described as rotating clockwise, this should not be deemed limiting as the device can also rotate counterclockwise.
While the settling chambers 204 are rotating, the product becomes more compact. In one embodiment, a vibrator 208 vibrates the product within the settling chambers 204 to facilitate settling of the product. The vibrator 208 can be placed on a variety of places, including but not limited to, on the stationary turret table 305, attached to the chambers 204, or otherwise attached to the rotary settling device 304 or other supporting structure.
As shown in
In
As depicted, the intermediate funnel 209 and the product receiving cylinder 103 are depicted downstream of the opening 308. In
In one embodiment, the product in the package comprises product from only a single settling chamber. In such an embodiment, the amount of product received in the receiving chamber is equal to the amount of product in the final package.
In still other embodiments, the final package comprises two slugs of product. In one embodiment the package comprises product from at least two different settling chambers. In other embodiments the package comprises two slugs of product from the same chamber. In such an embodiment a first slug is first formed and discharged and then subsequently a second slug is formed in the same chamber and then discharged.
Applicants have found that in some products the compaction is further increased when two or more smaller slugs are compacted separately and then added into a single package. For example, if the final product is to comprise two slugs of product, then the slugs formed from two different chambers will both be deposited to a single package. Referring back to
In one embodiment, the height of each chamber is selected so that existing apparatuses can be retrofitted with charge compaction without, for example, raising the weigher. As an example, in one embodiment, due to the multi-charge method, the settling chambers can be made shorter in height, due to the height being spread amongst multiple chambers, and as a result the weigher does not have to be moved. This results in decreased capital costs to retrofit an existing apparatus.
Applicants have found that after inducing settling the slug maintains its shape and compaction as it is packaged. This results in less settling after packaging giving the consumer a fuller package which more resembles the fuller look of a bag at the bagmaker. As previously discussed, increasing settling during packaging reduces post package settling which results in several benefits. One such benefit is the ability to use a comparatively smaller package for the same product weight. This results in decreased production costs as less material is required to manufacture the package. Additionally this results in decreased shipping costs as more packages can fit in a given volume. Further, this allows more packages to be displayed on the retail shelf as smaller packages occupy less space. Likewise, a smaller package allows a consumer to store the same amount of product in a smaller space, thus freeing valuable pantry space.
As discussed, this apparatus and method provide the opportunity to package the same quantity of product in a comparatively smaller package. The smaller package can have a decreased height, width, or combinations thereof compared to the previous package. In one embodiment the width of the package is not altered and only the height dimension is changed. Such an embodiment minimizes the modifications required to the bagmaker.
The following examples demonstrate the effectiveness of one embodiment of the instant invention and are for illustrative purposes only. Accordingly, the following examples should not be deemed limiting.
Control
A trial was conducted using chips with a product weight of 21.5 ounces. The wheat chips were thin wafers having ridges. A settling device was not used on the control. The bags had a width of 12 inches, a total height of 18.75 inches and a usable height of 17.75 inches after deducting one inch for the top and bottom seals. The void space in each package was measured and the fullness level of each bag calculated. The void space was measured by measuring the average level of product in the package. The packages removed from the bagmaker, which was a vertical form, fill, and seal machine, were approximately 86% full on average and had an average product level of 15.25 inches. Thereafter to determine the conditions of the packages after sitting on the shelf, the packages were subjected to a simulated retail process which included simulating the transporting, handling, and shelf time of a typical package. After simulation, the void space was measured and the fullness of each bag was calculated to be approximately 78% on average with a product level of 13.85 inches. Thus, the fullness of the packages decreased by about 8% on average after the shelf simulation, and the product level decreased by an average of 1.4 inches.
Single Charge
In the next trial, a non-rotary settling apparatus comprising a single settling chamber, similar to that of
Multi-Charge
In the next trial, the same apparatus was utilized using the multi-charge method wherein the final package comprised two slugs of product. Thus, in this embodiment, the settling chamber formed and discharged a slug, and then the same settling chamber subsequently formed and discharged a second slug into the same package as the first discharged slug. The same size bag as the single charge was also used in the multi-charge trial. At the bagmaker the packages were approximately 87% full and had product levels of about 13.65 inches. After the shelf simulation, the packages were approximately 83% full and had a product level of about 13.15 inches. Thus, compared to the single-charge method, the multi-charge method resulted in a fuller bag both at the bagmaker and after shelf-simulations.
In both the single-charge and the double-charge, a smaller package was produced which held the same quantity of product as the larger bag in the control, but which required less material to manufacture. Accordingly, compacting the product results in decreased manufacturing costs, decreased shipping costs, an increased number of packages available for a given amount of retail space, a package which required less pantry space, and a package which appeared fuller to the retail consumer.
Referring back to
Now referring to
In one embodiment the holes do not begin in the first three inches of the product delivery cylinder 103. Applicants have found that some product comprising edges or corners can catch on the holes 510, and thus disrupt the flow of the product. To overcome this problem, in one embodiment the product is allowed to build momentum in a section of the product delivery cylinder 103 which does not comprise holes before introducing the product into a section of the product delivery cylinder 103 comprising holes 510. In another embodiment the holes 510 are sized so as to minimize product catching on the holes 510. As depicted
The vacuum holes 510 can be implemented in any bagmaker comprising a product delivery cylinder 103 which comprises a collar 511. In one embodiment, the bagmaker comprises a vertical form, fill, and seal bagmaker comprising a weigher and product delivery cylinder.
As those skilled in the art will understand, many products, such as potato chips, are often nitrogen flushed to extend shelf life. Thus, the product packaged is flushed with nitrogen to remove air. Previously, a nitrogen port was positioned within the product delivery cylinder 103 to pipe nitrogen to the formed package. This was accomplished with a port or tube running within the product delivery cylinder 103. It was also accomplished by using a product delivery cylinder 103 comprising two concentric pipes, whereby the inner pipe allowed for the flow of product and the outer pipe acted as a port to allow for the flow of nitrogen. In still another embodiment, nitrogen was added by sectioning off a portion of the product delivery cylinder 103 with a wall forming a port through which nitrogen was fed. However, Applicants have discovered that in these embodiments at least some cross-sectional area of the product delivery cylinder 103 was sacrificed to provide for the nitrogen. As such, the use of a nitrogen port necessarily changes the available cross section of the product delivery cylinder 203 which affects the compaction of the product. To compensate for the sacrificed sectional area lost to the nitrogen port, in one embodiment the area of the product delivery cylinder 103 must be altered. Changing this area undesirably affects the compaction of the product. In one embodiment, increasing the area of the product delivery cylinder 103 decreases the compaction of the product. Applicants have discovered a novel and non-obvious method of eliminating or minimizing the need for a separate nitrogen port.
As noted above, vacuum relief holes 510 placed on the product delivery cylinder 103 pull air into the product delivery cylinder 103. Applicants have discovered that by placing a shroud or nitrogen source 612 over the vacuum relief holes 510, nitrogen, rather than air, is pulled into the product delivery cylinder 103.
In one embodiment a nitrogen blanket is placed around the vacuum relief holes 510. In another embodiment the vacuum relief holes 510 are in fluid communication with a nitrogen source 612. In still another embodiment, the product delivery cylinder 103 is in fluid communication with a nitrogen source 612. In one embodiment the nitrogen source is connected by one or more tubes to the product delivery tube 103 so that nitrogen from the nitrogen source 612 can be pulled within the product delivery tube 103. In one embodiment a nitrogen flow rate of about 2 to about 12 cubic feet per minute is employed.
As discussed above, in one embodiment the settling device 207 is installed without adjusting the height or location of the weigher 101. Often, moving or adjusting the weigher 101 or the sealing machine is prohibitively expensive. Thus, in one embodiment, rather than moving the weigher 101 or the sealing machine, an offset receiving funnel 102 is employed.
The size and shape of each settling chamber 204a-c can be the same or the size and shape can vary. As an example, in one embodiment the first settling chamber 204a is larger than the subsequent chambers 204b,c. In one embodiment, each downstream chamber is smaller in size than the immediate upstream chamber.
In another embodiment, rather than sealing the package the partial package is first filled with product. The package is formed without a top seal creating a partial package and then filled with an amount of product. Thereafter, the packages are manipulated to increase compaction of the product within the unsealed package. The manipulation can comprise any method discussed above in reference to the settling device and includes vibrating, jostling, moving, etc. Thus, the product within the partial package is settled. Thereafter, a final seal on the partial package is created to form a final package. In one embodiment the package is sealed to allow for a decreased package. In such an embodiment, the final seal is placed such that the bulk density of the package is increased. The excess packaging material is then removed.
In still another embodiment the package is sealed with a first seal after filling. Thereafter the package is subject to manipulation to increase compaction as discussed above. The bag is then resealed with a final seal resulting in a comparatively smaller package. The excess packaging material and the first seal can then be cut from the package and removed.
Referring to
Referring to
Likewise, the sensor can be used to determine if the product level is too low. This would indicate that the weigher 101 malfunctioned and deposited too little product. Furthermore, if the product level is too high this could indicate further malfunction in the weigher 101. Thus, the use of sensors can be used to monitor the performance of the weighers 101 and eliminate or decrease the need for inspection of the packages.
Furthermore, the sensor can also be placed at or downstream from the discharging chamber 204a to ensure that all product was discharged. For example, a sensor can be placed above the chamber 204b downstream from the discharge chamber 204a. If product remains in this chamber 204b then there was a malfunction and the previous bag was not properly filled. This can eliminate or decrease the need for inspection of bags to ensure they have the proper weight.
Sensors can also be placed along the height of the chamber 204. These sensors can also monitor the product level in the chamber 204. In one embodiment these sensors are attached to one or more chambers 204. In one embodiment these sensors can monitor the change in product level over time. Thus the sensor or sensors can be used to determine the rate of filling and discharging. If the rate of discharge is less than desired then this could mean that bridging had occurred. Further, if the rate of discharge is less than desired this could mean that some product will end up in the end seal which can result in an improper seal. This allows an opportunity to eliminate inspections of the final packages. The sensor or sensors can also be used to monitor the rate of settling. They can also be used to determine the proper bag size for a charge. For example, the sensor can be used to make sure the bag size is just large enough to accommodate the settled charge.
Referring once again to
Line 1202 illustrates another embodiment comprising forward and backward motion over time. In this embodiment the chamber is still rotated between positions, however, the chamber is exposed to forward and backward motions. This backward motion is referred to as a superimposed motion because it is superimposed on the forward motion. In one embodiment the superimposed motion helps settle the product during the rotating stage.
In one embodiment the dwell stage comprises vibrating the chamber. In one embodiment this vibrating comprises high frequency but low amplitude. This ensures that the gate 206 of the chamber 204 properly aligns with the product delivery cylinder 103.
As those skilled in the art will understand, the actual velocity, dwell time, and vibrating time are a function of bag size and product geometry. These factors can be adjusted to maximize the best settling against the acceptable amount of breakage. For example, while aggressive vibrating and quick rotating will increase settling, it can also lead to increased breakage. In one embodiment velocity, dwell time, and vibrating speed and time are adjusted to maximize settling within an acceptable amount of breakage.
The methods described herein have led to many surprising advantages. One advantage is that the stringout of product has been significantly reduced. The stringout refers to the amount of time from when the first product enters the package until the last product enters the package. As the prior art disclosed loosely packed product, the product was very spread out which led to a high stringout. Low bulk density product tends to string out as it falls from the weigher to bagmaker resulting in a large stringout. The stringout affects the speed in which the bags can be formed and filled. Thus, the prior art speed was limited as the bagmaker was forced to wait until all product had been received in the partial package. Reducing stringout increases the bag making and filling speed.
As an example, a 2 ounce bag of Sunchips, made by Frito-Lay North America, Plano, Tex., could previously be made at speeds of 70 bags per minute. However, utilizing the methods and devices described herein, specifically a settling device as well as vacuum relief holes in the former, speeds as high as 100 bags per minute have been achieved. Likewise, 1 ounce bags of Sunchips using the methods and devices previously described have been produced at speeds of 150 bags per minute compared to the traditional speed of 100 bags per minute without the method and devices described herein. Thus, the methods and devices described herein allow for the manufacture of bags at significantly increased speeds.
Due in part to the reduced stringout, in one embodiment strippers and settlers can be eliminated. As described above, previously due to product stringout it was common to have crumbs or fines float in behind the product charge. Strippers are used to wipe the end seals prior to sealing to remove these crumbs as well as push any product out of the sealing area. Again, because stringout is reduced, the product is delivered as a compact slug. Applicants have discovered that utilizing the devices and methods described herein, that the need for strippers has been eliminated.
Likewise, Applicants have discovered that utilizing the methods and devices described herein, the need for settlers has been reduced. Settlers were previously used to shake the bag prior to filling, specifically for low density product. However, now that a compact slug is delivered to the package, the settler is no longer necessary. Reducing settlers and strippers decreases capital and operating costs. Furthermore, by not requiring settlers and strippers a more generic bag maker can be used for a variety of product rather than obtaining specific bag makers for specific products. As such, this ability increases adaptability.
While the invention has been particularly shown and described with reference to a preferred embodiment, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
The following clauses are offered as further description of the disclosed invention.
5. The vertical form, fill, and seal machine according to clause 4 wherein at least a portion of said nitrogen source surrounds at least a portion of said product delivery cylinder.
This application is a continuation-in-part of co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/604,748, filed Oct. 23, 2009, the technical disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3040490 | Virta | May 1960 | A |
3561504 | Tanner | Feb 1971 | A |
3584697 | Danielson | Jun 1971 | A |
3703796 | Inoue | Nov 1972 | A |
3853190 | Delesdernier | Dec 1974 | A |
4073121 | Greenawalt | Feb 1978 | A |
4365460 | Cress | Dec 1982 | A |
4398612 | Mikami et al. | Aug 1983 | A |
4516644 | Fukuda | May 1985 | A |
4561510 | Sugioka et al. | Dec 1985 | A |
4629017 | Shroyer | Dec 1986 | A |
4729210 | Galliano | Mar 1988 | A |
4820315 | DeMarco | Apr 1989 | A |
4832178 | Anderson | May 1989 | A |
5029735 | Dennis | Jul 1991 | A |
5289724 | Hafner | Mar 1994 | A |
5473866 | Maglecic | Dec 1995 | A |
5540035 | Plahm et al. | Jul 1996 | A |
5613590 | Simionato | Mar 1997 | A |
5732532 | Fujisaki | Mar 1998 | A |
6119438 | Bacon et al. | Sep 2000 | A |
6199351 | Mount | Mar 2001 | B1 |
6665999 | Dierl et al. | Dec 2003 | B1 |
6718739 | Kohl | Apr 2004 | B2 |
7028448 | Engesser | Apr 2006 | B2 |
7099741 | Baranowski | Aug 2006 | B2 |
7328544 | Yokota | Feb 2008 | B2 |
20010005974 | Kondo | Jul 2001 | A1 |
20040026029 | Martin | Feb 2004 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20110154783 A1 | Jun 2011 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 12604748 | Oct 2009 | US |
Child | 12909242 | US |