Method and apparatus for electromagnetic exposure of planar or other materials

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6396034
  • Patent Number
    6,396,034
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, April 12, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 28, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
A path for a material passes through an opening and along a segment through an off-peak region of an electric field. An E-plane bend delivers an electromagnetic wave to the segment. A standing wave is used to heat the material. The peaks or valleys are pushed or pulled by a movable surface or by changing the frequency of the electromagnetic wave. A rectangular choke flange is used at the opening to the segment. A curved segment connects the segment to another segment for heating the material. According to another aspect of the invention, a segment is used to heat just the edge of a planar material.
Description




BACKGROUND




The invention relates to electromagnetic energy, and more particularly, to electromagnetic exposure of planar materials.




One drawback with conventional waveguides is that the microwave signal attenuates as it moves away from its source. This attenuation versus propagation distance increases when lossy planar materials are introduced into the waveguide. As a result, a material fed into the waveguide through a slot is heated more at one end of a segment (closer to a source ) than at the other end (farther from a source). Prior art structures have not made use of the slot's orientation as a means for addressing this problem. In a traditional slotted waveguide, there is a field peak midway between two conducting surfaces. In the prior art, the slot is at this midway point. See, for example, U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,471,672, 3,765,425, and 5,169,571.




One way to address this drawback is disclosed in our co-pending and co-assigned application Ser. No. 08/848,244, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,958,275. Another way to address this drawback is disclosed in our co-pending and co-assigned application Ser. No. 09/350,991. In our two earlier applications, which are incorporated herein by reference, a path has a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface and a first end and a second end. A source is capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end. The path has a slot that extends in a direction from the first end to the second end. The planar material is passed through the slot in a direction perpendicular to the propagation of the electromagnetic wave.




The structure disclosed in our two earlier applications is extremely useful for heating wider materials. In some applications, it may be advantageous to heat the material by passing the material in a direction parallel to the propagation of the electromagnetic wave. One possible way to heat a material by passing a material in a direction parallel to the propagation of the electromagnetic wave is disclosed in Metaxas et al, “Industrial Microwave Heating,” Peregrinus on behalf of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, London, United Kingdom, 1983 (hereinafter, referred to as “Metaxas”).




Referring now to

FIG. 1

, Metaxas discloses that a microwave power input provides an electromagnetic wave (not shown) to a TE


10


waveguide


30


. The waveguide


30


has a mitre bend


20


and rod supports


55


. A conveyor belt


50


passes through a choke


42


along a path that is halfway between the top conductive surface


31


and the bottom conductive surface


32


.

FIG. 2

further illustrates that “[t]he conveyor belt is supported at intervals so that the mid-depth plane of the workload is coincident with the mid-points of the broad faces of the waveguide[.]” Id. at 114.




Mitre bend


20


is usually referred to as a H-plane bend. In a H-plane bend, the long side a in

FIG. 2

remains in the same plane. In an E-plane bend, the short side b in

FIG. 2

remains in the same plane. In

FIG. 1

, the H-plane bend is oriented so that the electric field travels through the conveyor belt


50


.




There are at least six drawbacks with the wave applicator disclosed in Metaxas's book. The first drawback is that the microwave signal attenuates as it moves away from the microwave power input


10


. This attenuation versus propagation distance increases when lossy planar materials are introduced into the waveguide. As a result, a material fed into the waveguide


30


is heated more at the end of the waveguide closer to the input (end


33


) than at the other end (end


34


).




A second drawback is that the electric field is disrupted when the electric field travels through conveyor belt


50


. In addition, there is better coupling if the electric field sees a narrow dimension, as opposed to a wide dimension, of conveyor belt


50


. Metaxas fails to recognize that there is better coupling and the conveyor belt


50


is heated more uniformly if the electromagnetic wave travels across, as opposed to through, conveyor belt


50


.




A third drawback is that a traveling wave is used to heat the planar material. Metaxas specifies on page 114 that. “[i]n some cases where the workload has a very high loss factor, the traveling wave applicator is terminated in a short circuit because there is only negligible residual power.” Metaxas fails to recognize that it is possible to use a standing wave and continuously change the length or effective length of the waveguide or the frequency of the standing wave so as to even out the hot spots of the standing wave.




A fourth drawback is that the circular choke flange


42


is too wide at its widest point. Metaxas fails to recognize that a rectangular choke flange can limit the amount of energy that is lost through the opening.




A fifth drawback is that Metaxas does not disclose how to pass a planar material along more than one straight section of a serpentine waveguide. Metaxas specifies that “[a]t each end a mitre bend (usually 90°E-plane) permits connection to the generator and terminating load. The mitre plates of the bends have holes with cutoff waveguide chokes to permit the belt and workload to enter and leave the applicator.” Id. at 115. While Metaxas describes in the next section, meander (or serpentine) traveling wave applicators, Metaxas makes it clear that the material travels perpendicular to the long sections of the waveguide. Metaxas fails to recognize that it is possible to pass a material along (as opposed to across) multiple straight sections of a serpentine waveguide.




A sixth drawback is that in Metaxas it is not possible to heat just the edge of the planar material. In

FIGS. 1 and 2

, the entire conveyor belt


50


passes through the waveguide


30


. In some applications, it is either not necessary or it is detrimental to heat the entire planar material. There is a need for a device that can heat just the edge of a planar material.




SUMMARY




The present invention overcomes many of the problems associated with electromagnetic exposure of planar materials. According to one aspect of the invention, a path for a material passes through an opening and along a segment through an off-peak region of an electric field.




According to another aspect of the invention, an E-plane bend delivers an electromagnetic wave to the segment.




According to another aspect of the invention, a standing wave is used to heat the material. The peaks or valleys are pushed or pulled by a movable surface or by changing the frequency of the electromagnetic wave.




According to another aspect of the invention, a rectangular choke flange is used at the opening to the segment.




According to another aspect of the invention, a curved segment connects the segment to another segment for heating the material.




According to another aspect of the invention, a segment is used to heat just the edge of a planar material.




An advantage of the invention is that it is possible to uniformly heat the material at different points along the segment. Another advantage is that it is possible to improve coupling and decrease disruption of the electric field. Another advantage is that a standing wave is more efficient than a traveling wave, the energy loss associated with traveling waves is avoided. Another advantage is that it is possible to decrease the amount of electromagnetic energy that escapes through the opening. Another advantage is that it is possible to provide extended heating despite space constraints. Another advantage is that is possible to heat just the edge of a material.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The foregoing, and other objects, features, and advantages of the invention will be more readily understood upon reading the following detailed description in conjunction with the drawings in which:





FIG. 1

is an illustration of a traveling wave applicator;





FIG. 2

is a cross-section of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

is an illustration of a device for heating planar or other materials;





FIGS. 4



a


and


4




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials;





FIGS. 5



a


and


5




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials;





FIGS. 6



a


and


6




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials;





FIG. 7

is an illustration of a device for heating the edge of a planar material;





FIG. 8

is an illustration of a device for heating two edges of a planar material;





FIG. 9

is an illustration of a device for heating the edge of a planar material; and





FIGS. 10



a


and


10




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION




In the following description, specific details are discussed in order to provide a better understanding of the invention. However, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the invention can be practiced in other embodiments that depart from these specific details. In other instances, detailed descriptions of well-known methods and circuits are omitted so as to not obscure the description of the invention with unnecessary detail.




Referring now to the drawings,

FIG. 1

is an illustration of a traveling wave applicator and

FIG. 2

is a cross-section of FIG.


1


.

FIG. 3

is an illustration of a device for heating planar or other materials. Segment


30


has a first conductive surface


31


and a second conductive surface


32


. Segment


30


has a first end


33


and a second end


34


.




A curved segment


20


connects microwave power input


10


with segment


30


. Microwave power input


10


provides an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end


33


to the second end


34


. The electromagnetic wave creates an electric field between the first conductive surface


31


and the second conductive surface


32


.




Segment


30


has an opening


40


at the first end


33


. The opening


40


creates a path


50


for a material. The path


50


can be a conveyor belt for planar materials such as semiconductor wafers, a tube for liquid or gel-like materials, a roll of paper or textiles, or any other means of passing the material through opening


40


and along segment


30


.




In

FIG. 3

, segment


30


is a rectangular waveguide. Sides


35


and


36


are longer than sides


31


and


32


. As a result, it is possible to keep the electromagnetic wave in TE


10


mode. If the electromagnetic wave is in TE


10


mode, the electric field has a peak that is halfway between the top surface


31


and the bottom surface


32


. If supports


51


and


53


are positioned near the bottom surface


32


and support


55


is positioned near a point halfway between the top surface


31


and the bottom surface


32


, it is possible to create a path


50


that passes through opening


40


and along segment


30


from the first end


33


to the second end


34


through a region that is an off-peak region of the electric field.




If the material is relatively lossy, the angle of the path


50


should be increased. If the material is relatively un-lossy, the angle of the path


50


should be decreased. If segment


30


is built for heating a particular material with a particular degree of lossiness, it is not necessary to adjust the angle of path


50


. If exposure segment


30


is built for heating different materials with different degrees of lossiness, it may be advantageous to adjust the angle or effective angle of path


50


.




If the curved segment


20


is oriented like the H-plane bend in

FIG. 1

, the electric field is disrupted when the electric field travels through conveyor belt


50


. There is better coupling if the electric field sees a narrow dimension, as opposed to a wide dimension, of conveyor belt


50


. To overcome this problem, a E-plane bend should be used to connect input


10


to segment


30


. It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that a mitre bend can cause losses. A curved segment can be used instead of a mitre bend to decrease the amount of loss.




A choke flange


42


should be used to limit the amount of electromagnetic energy that escapes through opening


40


. The opening


40


needs to be large enough to allow the planar material to pass through opening


40


. As the size of the opening


40


increases, the amount of electromagnetic energy that can escape through opening


40


tends to increase. Therefore, in order to minimize leakage, the optimum size of opening


40


will depend on the size of the planar material. A circular opening like the one in

FIG. 1

is too wide at the center point above path


50


. A rectangular opening decreases the width at the center point above path


50


, and therefore, decreases the amount of electromagnetic energy that can escape.





FIGS. 4



a


and


4




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials. In both figures, the path


50


passes through a more off-peak region to a less off-peak region to a more off-peak region. It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that in some applications it is advantageous to gradually increase the heating and then gradually decrease the heating. These variations in heating can be achieved by varying the slope and direction of path


50


. In

FIG. 4



a


, path


50


has a curved shape. In

FIG. 4



b,


path


50


has a straight shape that passes through the peak of the electromagnetic field.





FIGS. 5



a


and


5




b


are illustrations of a device for heating planar or other materials. In both figures, segment


30


and segment


70


are connected by a curved segment


60


. Segment


70


terminates at point


72


. The electromagnetic wave in segments


30


,


60


, and


70


has peaks and valleys. If point


72


is a short circuit, the electromagnetic wave is a standing wave and the locations of the peaks and the valleys are stationary. If the peaks and valleys are stationary, the peaks and valleys tend to create hot spots and cold spots along segment


30


. This is why conventional applicators tend to use a traveling wave.




It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the location of the peaks and valleys is a function of the combined length of segments


30


,


60


, and


70


. If the combined length of segments


30


,


60


, and


70


changes, so does the location of the peaks and valleys. It is possible to use a standing wave and continuously change the combined length (or effective length) of segments


30


,


60


, and


70


to simulate a traveling wave. There are several ways to continuously change the combined length of segments


30


,


60


, and


70


.





FIG. 5



a


illustrates a motor


71


that is attached to a movable plate


72


. As plate


72


slides either towards segment


60


or away from segment


60


, the peaks and valleys of the standing wave are pushed and pulled along segments


30


,


60


, and


70


. If plate


72


is moved back and forth at a rate significantly faster than the rate at which the planar material


40


moves along segment


30


, it is possible to effectively smooth the hot spots in segment


30


without having to use a traveling wave.





FIG. 5



b


illustrates a motor


81


that is attached to a dielectric structure


82


. As dielectric structure


82


turns, the peaks and valleys are “pushed” or “pulled” along segments


30


,


60


, and


70


. If structure


82


is rotated at a rate significantly faster than the rate at which the planar material moves along segment


30


, it is possible to effectively smooth the hot spots in segment


30


.




Another way to “push” or “pull” the peaks and valleys is to sweep the frequency at the power input


10


. The source can adjust the range of frequencies and the rate at which the frequencies are swept. If the wave is a traveling wave, the sweeping can be used to increase or decrease the rate at which the peaks and valleys propagate along the path. If the wave is a standing wave, the sweeping can be used to move the peaks and valleys so as to prevent the formation of hot and cold spots along the path. If the source sweeps a large range of frequencies, it may be more advantageous to use a short and a standing wave. If the source sweeps a small range of frequencies to merely prevent arcing, it may be more advantageous to use a matched load and a traveling wave.




If the source is a swept frequency source, benefits of a diagonal path can still be realized, particularly if the frequency sweep is such that the electromagnetic wave is maintained in the lowest order mode (TE


10


). This may be accomplished by sweeping the frequency somewhere between the range of no less than f


c


and slightly less than 2f


c


where f


c


is the cutoff frequency of the path, that is, the lowest frequency that will propagate in the path. Although the diagonal path may still provide benefits at frequencies greater than 2f


c


, the greatest benefits occur if operation is maintained in the TE


10


mode.





FIGS. 6



a


and


6




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials. Both devices comprise a second segment


170


that has a first conductive surface


131


, a second conductive surface


132


, a first end


133


, and a second end


134


. A curved segment


160


connects end


34


to end


133


. The path for the material passes through the first segment


30


from end


33


to end


34


and through the second segment


170


from end


133


to end


134


.




In

FIG. 6



a,


segment


30


has an opening


140


at end


34


. Segment


170


has an opening


240


at end


133


. The path exits opening


140


and enters opening


240


. The structure shown allows the material to be treated or cooled before being heated in segment


170


.




In

FIG. 6



b,


the path passes through the first segment from end


33


to end


34


, through the curved segment


160


, and through the second segment


170


from the end


133


to end


134


. The path passes around a roller


180


as it passes through the curved segment


160


. The structure shown allows the material to be continuously heated. In either device, the path can follow a curved or straight shape so as to pass through a region that is off-peak.





FIG. 7

is an illustration of a device for heating the edge of a planar material. Segment


330


has a first conductive surface


331


, a second conductive surface


332


, a first end


333


, and a second


334


. Segment


330


has an opening


340


for an edge of material


50


.




A source generates an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end


333


to the second end


334


(direction x). The electromagnetic wave creates an electric field between surfaces


331


and


332


. A motor pushes or pulls material


50


so that the edge of material


50


passes from the first end


333


of segment


330


to the second end


334


of segment


330


inside segment


330


and the middle of material


50


passes from the first end


333


of segment


330


to the second end


334


of segment


330


outside segment


330


. Segment


330


has small openings for to facilitate vapor removal and/or pressurized air.





FIG. 8

is an illustration of a device for heating two edges of a planar material. A second segment


430


has a first conductive surface


431


, a second conductive surface


432


, a first end


433


, and a second end


434


. The second segment


430


has an opening


440


for a second edge of material


50


.




A motor or any other means pushes or pulls material


50


so that the first edge of material


50


passes from the first end


333


of the first segment


330


to the second end


334


of the first segment


330


inside the first segment


330


, the second edge of the material passes from the first end


433


of the second segment


430


to the second end


434


of the second segment


430


inside the second segment


430


, and the middle of material


50


passes from the first end of both segments to the second end of both segments outside both segments.





FIG. 9

is an illustration of a device for heating the edge of a planar material. Segment


330


has an opening


340


that is more off-peak at the first end


333


than at the second end


334


. If the material is relatively lossy, the angle of the opening


134


should be increased. If the material is relatively un-lossy, the angle of opening


134


should be decreased. If segment


330


is built for heating a particular material with a particular degree of lossiness, it is not necessary to adjust the angle of opening


134


. If segment


330


is built for heating different materials with different degrees of lossiness, it may be advantageous to adjust the angle or effective angle of opening


134


.





FIGS. 10



a


and


10




b


are illustrations of devices for heating planar or other materials. Both devices comprise a second segment


470


that has a first conductive surface


431


, a second conductive surface


432


, a first end


433


, and a second end


434


. A curved segment


460


connects end


334


to end


433


. The path for the material passes through the first segment


330


from end


333


to end


334


and through the second segment


470


from end


433


to end


434


.




In

FIG. 10



a,


segment


330


has an opening


440


at end


334


. Segment


470


has an opening


540


at end


433


. The path exits opening


440


and enters opening


540


. The structure shown allows the material to be treated or cooled before being heated in segment


470


.




In

FIG. 10



b,


the path passes through the first segment from end


333


to end


334


, through the curved segment


460


, and through the second segment


470


from the end


433


to end


434


. The path passes around a roller


380


as it passes through the curved segment


460


. The structure shown allows the material to be continuously heated. In either device, the path can follow a curved or straight shape so as to pass through a region that is off-peak.




While the foregoing description makes reference to particular illustrative embodiments, these examples should not be construed as limitations. For example, the description frequently refers to a planar material that is passed through a slotted waveguide. However, it will be evident to those skilled in the art that the disclosed invention can be used to heat a wide range of materials in a wide range of cavities. Thus, the present invention is not limited to the disclosed embodiments, but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the claims below.



Claims
  • 1. A device for heating the edge of a material, the device comprising:a segment having a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface, the segment having a first end and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for an edge of a material; a source capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end, the electromagnetic wave creating an electric field between the two conducting surfaces; means for passing the edge of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment inside the segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment outside the segment; a second segment having a first conductive surface, a second conductive surface, a first end, and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for a second edge of the material; the means for passing configured to pass the first edge of the material from the first end of the first segment to the second end of the first segment inside the first segment, the second edge of the material from the first end of the second segment to the second end of the second segment inside the second segment, and the middle of the material from the first end of both segments to the second end of both segments outside both segments.
  • 2. A device as described in claim 1, wherein the conductive surfaces are opposite sides of a rectangular waveguide.
  • 3. A device as described in claim 2, wherein the electromagnetic wave is in TE10 mode.
  • 4. A device as described in claim 2, wherein the edges pass through a region that is a more off-peak region of the electric field at the first end than at the second end.
  • 5. A device as described in claim 2, wherein the edges travel along a diagonal path from the first end to the second end.
  • 6. A device as described in claim 5, wherein the angle of the diagonal path is adjusted according to the lossiness of the material to be heated.
  • 7. A device as described in claim 2, wherein the edges pass through a more off-peak region to a less off-peak region to a more off-peak region.
  • 8. A device as described in claim 1, the segment comprising small openings for vapor removal and/or pressurized air.
  • 9. A device as described in claim 1, the device further comprising a smooth bend, the smooth bend connecting the source to at least one of the segments.
  • 10. A device as described in claim 1, the device further comprising a E-plane bend, the E-plane bend connecting the source to at least one of the segments.
  • 11. A device as described in claim 10, the opening through the E-plane bend.
  • 12. A device as described in claim 1, the device further comprising:a third segment, the third segment connected to the first segment by a curved segment; a short, the short operable to create a standing wave in the first segment and the third segment, the standing wave comprising a plurality of peaks and valleys; and a movable surface, the movable surface operable to push and pull the plurality of peaks and valleys to achieve more uniform heating of the material.
  • 13. A device as described in claim 1, the segment having a cutoff frequency, the source sweeping a frequency of the electromagnetic wave between the cutoff frequency and double the cutoff frequency.
  • 14. A device as described in claim 1, the device further comprising:a rectangular choke flange, the rectangular choke flange extending outward from an opening at the first end of the segment.
  • 15. A device as described in claim 1, the device further comprising:a third segment having a first conductive surface, a second conductive surface, a first end, and a second end; and a curved segment, the curved segment connecting the second end of the first segment to the first end of the third segment, the edge passing through the first segment from the first end of the first segment to the second end of the first segment and through the second segment from the first end of the second segment to the second end of the second segment.
  • 16. A device as described in claim 15, the edge passing through a region that is more off-peak at the first end of the third segment than at the second end of the third segment.
  • 17. A device as described in claim 15, the device further comprising a first opening at the second end of the first segment and a second opening at the first end of the third segment, the edge exiting the first opening and entering the second opening.
  • 18. A device as described in claim 15, the edge passing through the first segment from the first end of the first segment to the second end of the first segment, through the curved segment, and through the third segment from the first end of the second segment to the second end of the second segment.
  • 19. A device as described in claim 18, the device further comprising a roller, the edge passing around the roller as it passes through the curved segment.
  • 20. A device for heating the edge of a material, the device comprising:a segment having a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface, the segment having a first end and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for an edge of a material; a source capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end, the electromagnetic wave creating an electric field between the two conducting surfaces; means for passing the edge of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment inside the segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment outside the segment; the edge of the material passing through a region that is more off-peak at the first end of the segment than at the second end of the segment.
  • 21. A device for heating the edge of a material, the device comprising:a segment having a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface, the segment having a first end and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for an edge of a material; a source capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end, the electromagnetic wave creating an electric field between the two conducting surfaces; means for passing the edge of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment inside the segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment outside the segment; a second segment, the second segment connected to the first segment by a curved segment; a short, the short operable to create a standing wave in the first segment and the second segment, the standing wave comprising a plurality of peaks and valleys; and a movable surface, the movable surface operable to push and pull the plurality of peaks and valleys to achieve more uniform heating of the edge of the material.
  • 22. A device for heating the edge of a material, the device comprising:a segment having a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface, the segment having a first end and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for an edge of a material; a source capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end, the electromagnetic wave creating an electric field between the two conducting surfaces; means for passing the edge of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment inside the segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment outside the segment; the segment having a cutoff frequency, the source sweeping a frequency of the electromagnetic wave between the cutoff frequency and double the cutoff frequency.
  • 23. A device for heating the edge of a material, the device comprising;a segment having a first conductive surface and a second conductive surface, the segment having a first end and a second end, the segment comprising an opening for an edge of a material; a source capable of generating an electromagnetic wave that propagates in a direction from the first end to the second end, the electromagnetic wave creating an electric field between the two conducting surfaces; means for passing the edge of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment inside the segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the segment to the second end of the segment outside the segment; a second segment having a first conductive surface, a second conductive surface, a first end, and a second end; and a curved segment, the curved segment connecting the second end of the first segment to the first end of the second segment, the means for passing configured to pass the edge of the material from the first end of the first segment to the second end of the first segment inside the first segment and from the first end of the second segment to the second end of the second segment inside the second segment and the middle of the material from the first end of the first segment to the second end of the first segment outside the first segment and from the first end of the second segment to the second end of the second segment outside the second segment.
Parent Case Info

This application is a divisional of application Ser. No. 09/372,749, filed on Aug. 11, 1999, now U.S. Pat. No 6,246,037.

US Referenced Citations (36)
Number Name Date Kind
2467230 Revercomb et al. Apr 1949 A
2549511 Nelson Apr 1951 A
2650291 Kinn Aug 1953 A
3471672 White Oct 1969 A
3474209 Parker Oct 1969 A
3491457 Schreiber et al. Jan 1970 A
3622732 Williams Nov 1971 A
3622733 Smith Nov 1971 A
3632945 Johnson Jan 1972 A
3666905 Muller et al. May 1972 A
3761665 Nagao et al. Sep 1973 A
3765425 Stungis et al. Oct 1973 A
3765985 Siard et al. Oct 1973 A
3843861 Van Amsterdam Oct 1974 A
3851132 Van Koughnett Nov 1974 A
4108147 Kantor Aug 1978 A
4160144 Kashyap et al. Jul 1979 A
4234775 Wolfberg et al. Nov 1980 A
4401873 Berggren et al. Aug 1983 A
4446348 Huang et al. May 1984 A
4476363 Berggren et al. Oct 1984 A
RE32664 Osepchuk et al. May 1988 E
4760230 Hässler Jul 1988 A
4859821 Meyer et al. Aug 1989 A
4999469 Dudley et al. Mar 1991 A
5107602 L{umlaut over (oo)}f Apr 1992 A
5169571 Buckley Dec 1992 A
5278375 Berteaud et al. Jan 1994 A
5369250 Meredith Nov 1994 A
5402672 Bradford Apr 1995 A
5457303 Shute et al. Oct 1995 A
5536921 Hedrick et al. Jul 1996 A
5798395 Lauf et al. Aug 1998 A
5804801 Lauf et al. Sep 1998 A
5879756 Fathi et al. Mar 1999 A
5958275 Joines et al. Sep 1999 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
1-274381 Nov 1989 JP
2-223186 Sep 1990 JP
WO 9849870 Nov 1998 WO