Information
-
Patent Grant
-
6747253
-
Patent Number
6,747,253
-
Date Filed
Wednesday, May 7, 200321 years ago
-
Date Issued
Tuesday, June 8, 200420 years ago
-
Inventors
-
Original Assignees
-
Examiners
Agents
-
CPC
-
US Classifications
Field of Search
US
- 219 602
- 219 603
- 219 632
- 219 634
- 219 635
- 219 659
- 219 646
- 219 667
- 219 645
- 219 647
- 072 211
- 072 60
- 072 54
- 072 709
- 228 157
- 228 193
- 228 25271
-
International Classifications
-
Abstract
An apparatus and method for heat treating a structural member, for example, to relieve stresses therein, are provided. The structural member is restrained in a die cavity by one or more inflatable bladders so that a desired dimensional accuracy is achieved. The structural member can be heated by an electromagnetic field generator, such as an induction coil, that heats one or more susceptors to a characteristic Curie temperature. The apparatus can be used to process structural members of various sizes and shapes, and the heating and cooling cycle can be performed relatively quickly.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1) Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to heat treating of structural members and, more particularly, relates to an apparatus and associated method for mechanically restraining structural members during induction heat treatments such as a stress relief cycle.
2) Description of Related Art
Residual stresses can result in structural members from various manufacturing and treatment processes. For example, if pieces of stock material are welded to form a more complex structural member, the member can include residual stresses that result from the welding process. These residual stresses can cause undesirable changes to the dimensional characteristics and material properties of the member. Conventional heat treatments are well known as a method of relieving stresses and thereby changing the mechanical and material properties of materials. For example, the structural member can be heated to a heat treatment temperature and then cooled. However, if the member is not mechanically restrained during the thermal cycle, the dimensions of the member may change during the heat treatment.
According to one proposed method of stress relief, tooling is positioned proximate to the structural member such that the tooling restrains the structural member. The structural member and the tooling are then heated in a furnace to the heat treatment temperature. The tooling restrains the structural member during the heating and subsequent cooling to maintain the dimensional accuracy. However, it can be difficult to provide tooling that is sufficiently strong and dimensionally accurate throughout the temperature range of the heat treatment cycle. Additionally, each structural member that is formed can require unique tooling for restraint during heat treatment, adding to the overall cost of the structural members. Further, even if such tooling can be provided, the process is time-consuming because it takes time for the furnace to heat the member and tooling to the heat treatment temperature. The time required for the subsequent cooling of the furnace, member, and tooling can also be lengthy.
Thus, there exists a need for an apparatus and associated method for heat treating structural members of various shapes and sizes. The apparatus should maintain the dimensional accuracy of the members during heat treatments such as a stress relief cycle. Preferably, the method should not be overly time-consuming.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention provides an apparatus and method for heat treating a structural member, for example, to relieve stresses in the structural member. The structural member can be restrained during a heating and cooling cycle so that a desired dimensional accuracy is achieved. Further, structural members of various sizes and shapes can be restrained, and the heating and cooling cycle can be performed relatively quickly.
According to one embodiment, the apparatus includes first and second co-operable dies that are structured to define a die cavity therebetween for at least partially receiving the structural member. At least one susceptor is in thermal communication with the die cavity. Each susceptor has a Curie temperature at which the susceptor becomes paramagnetic, and the Curie temperature can be about equal to the heat treatment temperature of the structural member. An electromagnetic field generator, such as at least one induction coil, is configured to induce a current within at least a portion of the susceptors. A coolant source can be fluidly connected to the coils and configured to circulate a cooling fluid through a passage of the coils to cool the coils. At least one rigid tool is positioned in the die cavity proximate to the structural member. Each tool defines a surface corresponding to at least a portion of the structural member. Further, at least one bladder is positioned in the die cavity, each bladder configured to receive a pressurized fluid for expanding the bladder and thereby urging the structural member against the corresponding surfaces of the tools so that a distortion of the structural member is restrained while the structural member is heat treated.
According to one aspect, a pressure source is fluidly connected to the bladders to supply the pressurized fluid to the bladders. Two or more bladders can be positioned in the die cavity, and a pressure regulation device in fluid communication with each bladder can be configured to maintain a substantially equal pressure in each bladder. The bladders can also be configured opposite a portion of the structural member so that the bladders restrain the structural member therebetween, or the bladders can be configured between opposed portions of the structural member so that the bladders urge the opposed portions to a predetermined dimension. The bladders can be formed of titanium or titanium alloys.
According to another aspect, an inflatable susceptor engagement seal is disposed at an interface of first and second portions of the at least one susceptor and configured to be inflated to electrically engage the first and second portions. An inflatable cavity seal can be disposed at an interface of the first and second dies and configured to receive a pressurized fluid to inflate the seal to hermetically seal the die cavity.
The present invention also provides a method of heat treating a structural member. According to one embodiment, the method includes providing the structural member at least partially in a die cavity, positioning at least one bladder in the die cavity proximate to the structural member, and injecting a pressurized fluid into the at least one bladder and thereby expanding the bladder to at least partially fill a space in the die cavity and restrain the structural member in a predetermined configuration.
One or more tools are also positioned in the die cavity proximate to the structural member so that the structural member is urged against a corresponding surface of the tools. An electromagnetic field generator, such as at least one induction coil, is energized to induce a current within at least a portion of the susceptor to heat the structural member to a heat treatment temperature, such as a Curie temperature at which the susceptor becomes paramagnetic. A cooling fluid can also be circulated through the at least one induction coil. Thus, the structural member is restrained by the at least one bladder at least partially during the energizing of the coil so that the bladder restrains a distortion of the structural member. The structural member can be maintained at the heat treatment temperature for a predetermined interval to relieve stresses in the structural member. The structural member can also be cooled according to a predetermined temperature schedule while restraining the structural member with the bladders in the die cavity.
According to one aspect, at least two bladders are positioned in the die cavity, for example, opposite a portion of the structural member so that the bladders restrain the structural member therebetween. A substantially equal pressure can be maintained in each of the bladders. The bladders can be formed of titanium or titanium alloys. According to another aspect, an inflatable susceptor engagement seal is disposed at an interface of first and second portions of the susceptor and pressurized to electrically engage the first and second portions. The die cavity can be formed by engaging first and second cooperable dies, and an inflatable cavity seal at an interface of the dies can be pressurized to hermetically seal the die cavity. Gas can be purged from the die cavity, for example, before the bladders are expanded.
Before the structural member is placed in the die cavity, a fixture member that corresponds in shape to the structural member can be positioned in the die cavity. The bladders can be positioned in the die cavity proximate the fixture member and formed by heating the bladders to a forming temperature higher than the heat treatment temperature of the structural member and injecting a fluid to at least partially expand the bladders and urge the bladders at least partially against the fixture member. The fixture member is then removed from the die cavity. A forming susceptor having a Curie temperature about equal to the forming temperature can be provided in thermal communication with the die cavity, and a current can be induced in the forming susceptor to heat the bladders to the forming temperature.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The foregoing and other advantages and features of the invention, and the manner in which the same are accomplished, will become more readily apparent upon consideration of the following detail description of the invention taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, which illustrate preferred and exemplary embodiments and which are not necessarily drawn to scale, wherein:
FIG. 1
is an elevation view illustrating an apparatus for heat treating a structural member, according to one embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 2
is a plan view illustrating the apparatus of
FIG. 1
;
FIG. 2A
is a plan view of one die of an apparatus according to another embodiment of the present invention, shown with the die cavity open and with a structural member, tools, and a bladder arranged in the die cavity;
FIG. 3
is an exploded perspective view illustrating a structural member and four tools according to one embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 3A
is an exploded perspective view illustrating the structural member and tools of
FIG. 2A
;
FIG. 4
is a section view illustrating the apparatus of
FIG. 1
as seen along line
4
—
4
of
FIG. 2
, shown with the bladders expanded;
FIG. 4A
is a section view illustrating the apparatus of
FIG. 1
, shown with the bladders partially expanded against a fixture member in the die cavity;
FIG. 5
is a fragmentary perspective view illustrating part of the die and induction coil of the apparatus of
FIG. 1
;
FIG. 6
is a partial section view illustrating the seals and electrical connection pins of the apparatus of
FIG. 1
, as seen along line
6
—
6
of
FIG. 2
;
FIG. 7
is an enlarged view of the susceptor seal of
FIG. 6
;
FIG. 8
is a section view of the apparatus of
FIG. 1
, as seen along line
8
—
8
of FIG.
2
and shown with the bladders installed and connected to a fluid source;
FIG. 9
is plan view illustrating a susceptor having an induced electromagnetic field, according to one embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 10
is an elevation view illustrating the susceptor of
FIG. 9
;
FIG. 11
is a plan view illustrating the susceptor of
FIG. 9
wherein a portion of the susceptor has reached its Curie temperature and become paramagnetic;
FIG. 12
is an elevation view illustrating the susceptor of
FIG. 9
wherein a portion of the susceptor has reached its Curie temperature and become paramagnetic;
FIG. 13
is a partial section view illustrating an apparatus according to another embodiment of the present invention having two susceptors with different Curie temperatures;
FIG. 14
is an enlarged view of the susceptor seals of
FIG. 13
, shown with the portions of the first susceptor electrically engaged and the portions of the second susceptor disengaged;
FIG. 15
is an enlarged view of the susceptor seals of
FIG. 13
, shown with the portions of the second susceptor electrically engaged and the portions of the first susceptor disengaged;
FIG. 16
is a graph illustrating a temperature, pressure, and power profile for heat treating a structural member according to one embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 17
is graph illustrating a temperature profile for heat treating a structural member according to another embodiment of the present invention, as compared to a conventional temperature profile;
FIG. 18
is a flow chart illustrating the operations performed in heat treating a structural member according to one embodiment of the present invention; and
FIG. 19
is a flow chart illustrating the operations performed in heat treating a structural member according to another embodiment of the present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The present invention now will be described more fully hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which some, but not all embodiments of the invention are shown. This invention may be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will be thorough and complete, and will fully convey the scope of the invention to those skilled in the art. Like numbers refer to like elements throughout.
Referring now to the drawings, and in particular to
FIGS. 1 and 2
, there is illustrated a heat treatment apparatus
10
, according to one embodiment of the present invention. The apparatus
10
can be used to heat treat at least one structural member
12
to improve the material properties of the structural members
12
, for example, by relieving stresses induced during preceding manufacturing processes. The apparatus
10
includes first and second dies
14
,
16
that are co-operable and configured to define a die cavity
18
therebetween that is structured to at least partially receive the at least one structural member
12
. The first and second dies
14
,
16
are generally mounted on and supported by first and second strongbacks
20
,
22
respectively, which may be secured using a mechanical support structure comprising a base
24
and perpendicular members
26
. A “strongback” is a stiff plate, such as a metal plate, that acts as a mechanical constraint to keep the first and second dies
14
,
16
together and to maintain the dimensional accuracy of the dies
14
,
16
.
Various methods can be used for configuring the dies
14
,
16
. For example, as shown in
FIG. 1
, first nuts
28
that are adjustable on the perpendicular members
26
are structured to support the first strongback
20
and the first die
14
. Second nuts
30
support the second strongback
22
and the second die
16
. The second strongback
22
can translate on the perpendicular members
26
so that as the second nuts
30
are adjusted away from the first strongback
20
, the second strongback
22
can be separated from the first strongback
20
and, hence, the dies
14
,
16
can be opened. Similarly, the second nuts
30
can be adjusted toward the first strongback
20
to adjust the second strongback
22
toward the first strongback
20
and thereby adjust the second die
16
toward the first die
14
to close the die cavity
18
. If the strongbacks
20
,
22
are oriented as shown in
FIG. 1
so that the second strongback
22
is below the first strongback
20
, gravity can be used to adjust the second strongback
22
away from the first strongback
20
, i.e., downward, to open the dies
14
,
16
. Air bladders
32
can be provided between the base
24
and the second strongback
22
to adjust the second strongback
22
toward the first strongback
20
and close the dies
14
,
16
. The air bladders
32
are fluidly connected to a source of pressurized air (not shown) and configured so that filling the bladders
32
with air urges the second strongback
22
away from the base
24
, and releasing air from the bladders
32
allows the second strongback
22
to be adjusted toward the base
24
. Alternatively, other types or arrangements of bladders can be used to adjust the dies
14
,
16
, or other adjustment devices can be used such as hydraulic cylinders, mechanical jacks, levers, and the like.
The term “structural member” is not meant to be limiting, and it is understood that the die cavity
18
can at least partially receive one or more structural members
12
at a time. The structural members
12
processed in the die cavity
18
can be simple or complex, and can be formed of such materials as titanium, titanium alloys, aluminum, aluminum alloys, steel, other metals, composites, and the like. In one embodiment of the invention, the structural member
12
is formed by connecting multiple stock or specially formed members. The structural members
12
can be connected by various types of weld joints, including arc weld joints, friction weld joints, and the like, or by fasteners such as rivets, bolts, screws, and the like. According to one embodiment, the structural member
12
is a titanium spar with longitudinally opposed caps that are welded to a corrugated web, as shown in
FIGS. 3 and 3A
. As shown in
FIG. 3A
, the structural member
12
can be a curved or tapered spar. The spars can be used in a variety of applications, for example, as a structural support in an aircraft wing, aircraft fuselage, other aeronautical vehicles, and the like. Structural members for a wide variety of other applications can be fabricated including, without limitation, structural members for automotive or marine applications or the like.
The first and second dies
14
,
16
preferably are formed of a material having a low thermal expansion, high thermal insulation, and a low electromagnetic absorption. For example, the dies
14
,
16
can be formed of a material having a thermal expansion of less than about 0.45/(° F.×10
6
) throughout a temperature range of between about 0° F. and 1850° F., a thermal conductivity of about 4 Btu/(hr)(ft)(° F.) or less, and substantially no electromagnetic absorption. According to one embodiment of the present invention, the dies
14
,
16
are formed of cast ceramic, for example, using a castable fusible silica product such as Castable
120
available from Ceradyne Thermo Materials of Scottdale, Ga. Castable
120
has a coefficient of thermal expansion less than about 0.45/(° F.×10
6
), a thermal conductivity of about 0.47 Btu/(hr)(ft)(° F.), and a low electromagnetic absorption.
The dies
14
,
16
can be at least partially contained within an outer structure such as a box-like structure
34
formed of phenolic material. Further, the dies
14
,
16
and phenolic box
34
can be reinforced with fibers and/or fiberglass reinforcing rods
36
. The rods
36
can extend both longitudinally and transversely through the phenolic structure
34
and the first and second dies
14
,
16
, as illustrated in FIG.
1
. To provide a post-stressed compressive state to the first and second dies
14
,
16
, the rods
36
can be placed through the phenolic structure
34
and secured within the first and second dies
14
,
16
at the time of casting. Thereafter, nuts
38
at the ends of the rods
36
can be tightened to provide the post-stressed compressive state to prevent cracking or other damage to the dies
14
,
16
. The first and second dies
14
,
16
, the phenolic structure
34
, and the reinforcement rods
36
are described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,683,608 entitled “Ceramic Die for Induction Heating Work Cells,” which issued on Nov. 4, 1997, and which is assigned to the assignee of the present invention and is incorporated herein by reference.
The first and second dies
14
,
16
can define one or more surfaces that correspond to the shape of the structural member
12
. Additionally, the apparatus
10
can include one or more tools
40
,
42
, illustrated in
FIGS. 3 and 3A
, that can be configured in the die cavity
18
with the structural member
12
. The tools
40
,
42
define corresponding surfaces that are structured to correspond to the structural member
12
or to a desired configuration of the structural member
12
. For example, end tools
40
correspond to the flat caps
12
a
of the spar-shaped structural members
12
of
FIGS. 3 and 3A
, and side tools
42
correspond to the corrugated web
12
b
of the structural members
12
. As shown in
FIG. 3A
, the tools
40
,
42
can also be curved or tapered to correspond to the shape of the structural member
12
. The tools
40
,
42
can be formed of a rigid material that is adapted to withstand the temperature and pressure associated with the heat treatment process without substantial deformation. Further, each tool
40
,
42
can have a low coefficient of thermal expansion. For example, the tools
40
,
42
can be formed of
420
stainless steel.
Additionally, while the tools
40
,
42
can correspond to the complex or detailed contours of the structural members
12
, each tool
40
,
42
can also correspond to the die cavity
18
so that the tools
40
,
42
and, hence, the structural member
12
, are restrained in the die cavity
18
during processing. Advantageously, the tools
40
,
42
can generally have simple features that correspond to the die cavity
18
so that different tools can be used in a single die cavity
18
to correspond to different structural members
12
. Thus, the dies
14
,
16
can define contours that are easy to form and resilient to wear and degradation, while the tools
40
,
42
define the specific contours that correspond to the structural members
12
. Further, the tools
40
,
42
can include one or more locating features
41
as shown in FIG.
3
A. Each locating feature
41
can be a flange, pin, or other portion that engages a corresponding aperture or contour defined by the dies
14
,
16
so that the tools
40
,
42
can be located as desired in the die cavity
18
.
The tools
40
,
42
can be urged against the structural member
12
by one or more inflatable bladders
44
to restrain the structural member
12
and prevent the structural member
12
from distorting during the heat treatment process. Thus, the structural member
12
can be heat treated and cooled in a desired, predetermined shape. For example, as shown in
FIG. 4
, the tools
40
,
42
and the structural member
12
are configured in the die cavity
18
and two bladders
44
are positioned in an opposing configuration relative to the web portion
12
b
of the structural member
12
. As shown, the bladders
44
can be expanded between the structural member and the dies
14
,
16
. The bladders
44
can be configured to contact the structural member
12
or to contact one or more of the tools
40
,
42
and urge the tools
40
,
42
against the structural member
12
. Further, the bladders
44
can be positioned between portions of the structural member
12
, for example, between the end caps
12
a
as shown, such that the expansion of the bladders
44
urges the end caps
12
a
outward and to a desired configuration defined by the tools
40
and/or the dies
14
,
16
.
The bladders
44
can be formed of a pliable material that can withstand the temperatures associated with heat treating the particular structural member
12
that is being treated. For example, the bladders
44
can be formed of titanium or titanium alloys, such as Ti 6-4 (6% aluminum, 4% vanadium, balance titanium). According to one embodiment of the present invention, the bladders
44
are formed by welding a perimeter of two flat sheets of 0.40 inch thick Ti 6-4 and then injecting a pressurized fluid between the flat sheets to superplastically form each bladder
44
to the desired size and shape. For example, as illustrated in
FIG. 4A
, the bladders
44
can be positioned in the die cavity
18
with a fixture member
46
that defines the desired shape and size of the structural member
12
. The fixture member
46
can be formed of a material that remains dimensionally accurate and strong at high temperatures, for example, nickel-chromium alloys such as one of various Inconel® alloys, a registered trademark of Inco Alloys International, Inc. and The International Nickel Company, Inc. The bladders
44
can be positioned with the fixture member
46
and the tools
40
,
42
in the die cavity
18
and fluidly connected to a pressurized fluid source
48
, such as a pressurized source of argon or another inert gas. The fluid source
48
can be a pressure generation device, such as a compressor, or the source
48
can be a pressure vessel that contains the pressurized fluid. The pressure source
48
can include a pressure regulation device in fluid communication with each of the bladders
44
and configured to maintain a substantially equal pressure in each bladder
44
.
The bladders
44
are inflated with the pressurized fluid and expanded to be superplastically formed against the tools
40
,
42
, the fixture member
46
, and/or the dies
14
,
16
. The bladders
44
can be formed of a material that is superplastically formable at a temperature higher than the heat treatment temperature of the structural member
12
. The fixture member
46
can be removed from the die cavity
18
, and the structural member
12
can be positioned in the die cavity
18
with one or more of the tools
40
,
42
and the formed bladders
44
, as shown in FIG.
4
. The tools
40
,
42
, dies
14
,
16
, and the bladders
44
are then used to restrain the structural member
12
during the heat treatment process as described above.
The structural member
12
is heated to the heat treatment temperature by at least one heater. The heater can comprise any known heating device including, for example, a gas or electric oven. According to one advantageous embodiment of the present invention, at least one of the first and second dies
14
,
16
includes at least one susceptor
70
, as described more fully below, and the heater comprises an electromagnetic field generator. The electromagnetic field generator can be a plurality of induction coils
50
, such as a solenoid coil shown in
FIGS. 2 and 5
, for inducing a current in the susceptor
70
. Each induction coil
50
typically includes a plurality of elongate tube sections
52
that are interconnected by curved tube sections
54
to form coils that are positioned proximate to the die cavity
18
and the corresponding susceptor
70
in which the current is to be induced. The elongate tube sections
52
can be formed, for example, of 1.0 inch diameter copper tubing with a 0.0625 inch wall thickness. The tube sections
52
can alternatively be formed of tubular sections of other sizes and/or with other cross sectional shapes, for example, square or triangular tubes. The tube sections
52
are generally formed of an electrically conductive material such as copper. Lightly drawn copper tubing can be used so that the tube sections
52
can be adjusted as necessary to correspond to the configuration of the corresponding die
14
,
16
. The tube sections
52
can be positioned relatively close to, such as about 0.75 inches from, the susceptor
70
. The curved tube sections
54
are typically disposed outside the dies
14
,
16
.
Each curved tube section
54
can be formed of a flexible, non-conductive material such as plastic, and each tube section
52
can be disposed within only one of the two dies
14
,
16
so that the tube sections
52
,
54
can form separate fluid paths in the first and second dies
14
,
16
, i.e., the curved tube sections
54
connect the tube sections
52
to other tube sections
52
that are in the same die
14
,
16
. The tube sections
52
of the two dies
14
,
16
can also be electrically connected by pin and socket connectors
56
,
57
as shown in
FIG. 6
, which can be disconnected when the dies
14
,
16
are opened to expose the die cavity
18
. The pin and socket connectors
56
,
57
are preferably formed of a conductive material such as brass or copper. Thus, the pin and socket connectors
56
,
57
maintain electrical conductivity between the tube sections
52
while the generally non-conductive curved sections
54
maintain fluid communication between the tube sections
52
. Further, because the tube sections
52
,
54
can form separate fluid paths in the first and second dies
14
,
16
, the dies
14
,
16
can be opened without disconnecting the tube sections
52
,
54
. Therefore, the dies
14
,
16
can be separated by disconnecting only the pin and socket connectors
56
,
57
, which can be quickly and easily connected and disconnected, thus simplifying the opening and closing of the die cavity
18
.
The induction coil
50
is capable of being energized by one or more power supplies
58
. The power supplies
58
provide an alternating current to the induction coil
50
, e.g., between about 3 and 10 kHz. This alternating current through the induction coil
50
induces a secondary current within the susceptor
70
that heats the susceptor
70
and, thus, the structural member
12
. The temperature of the susceptor
70
and the structural member
12
can be inferred by monitoring electrical parameters within the one or more power supplies
58
, as described in U.S. application Ser. No. 10/094,494, entitled “Induction Heating Process Control,” filed Mar. 8, 2002, and which is assigned to the assignee of the present invention and is incorporated herein by reference.
Due to the low electromagnetic absorption of the dies
14
,
16
, the induction coil
50
induces a current within the susceptor
70
without inducing an appreciable current in the dies
14
,
16
. Therefore, the susceptor
70
can be heated to high temperatures without heating the dies
14
,
16
, thereby saving energy and time. Due to the low thermal expansion of the dies
14
,
16
, the induction coil
50
can be kept relatively cool while the susceptor
70
heats the structural member
12
without inducing stresses in the dies
14
,
16
sufficient to cause spalling or otherwise degrading the dies
14
,
16
. Additionally, the low thermal conductivity of the ceramic dies
14
,
16
reduces heat loss from the die cavity
18
and, thus, the structural member
12
.
As illustrated in
FIGS. 2 and 5
, the induction coil
50
can define a passage
60
for circulating a cooling fluid, such as water, from a coolant source
62
. A pump (not shown) circulates the cooling fluid from the coolant source
62
through the passage
60
. The cooling fluid cools the induction coil
50
to maintain low electrical resistivity in the coil
50
. In addition, by positioning the induction coil
50
uniformly relative to the susceptor
70
, the induction coil
50
can be used to heat the susceptor
70
uniformly, and the cooling fluid can be used to transfer thermal energy from the susceptor
70
to cool the susceptor
70
.
The at least one susceptor
70
can be cast within the corresponding first and second dies
14
,
16
or otherwise disposed thereon. The susceptor
70
is formed of a material that is characterized by a Curie temperature at which the susceptor
70
becomes paramagnetic, for example, a ferromagnetic alloy such as an alloy comprising iron and nickel. Susceptors having Curie temperatures at which each susceptor becomes non-magnetic, or paramagnetic, are described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,728,309 entitled “Method for Achieving Thermal Uniformity in Induction Processing of Organic Matrix Composites or Metals,” which issued on Mar. 17, 1998; U.S. Pat. No. 5,645,744 entitled “Retort for Achieving Thermal Uniformity in Induction Processing of Organic Matrix Composites or Metals,” which issued on Jul. 8, 1997; and U.S. Pat. No. 5,808,281 entitled “Multilayer Susceptors for Achieving Thermal Uniformity in Induction Processing of Organic Matrix Composites or Metals,” which issued on Sep. 15, 1998, each of which is assigned to the assignee of the present invention and is incorporated herein by reference. The susceptor
70
can define a contoured surface and can include an oxidation resistant nickel aluminide coating, which can be flame-sprayed or otherwise disposed on the surface of the susceptor
70
. A description of a susceptor with a nickel aluminide coating is provided in U.S. application Ser. No. 10/032,625, entitled “Smart Susceptors with Oxidation Control,” filed Oct. 24, 2001, and which is assigned to the assignee of the present invention and is incorporated herein by reference.
The susceptors
70
can be provided separately on the first and second dies
14
,
16
so that when the dies
14
,
16
are opened, the susceptors
70
are also opened and the structural members
12
, tools
40
,
42
, and/or bladders
44
can be inserted or removed from the die cavity
18
. As illustrated in
FIG. 7
, the outer edges of the susceptors
70
can be connected to the respective dies
14
,
16
by studs
72
, rivets, or other connectors such as screws, bolts, clips, weld joints, and the like. The susceptors
70
can be configured on the dies
14
,
16
such that the edges of the susceptors
70
make electrical contact when the dies
14
,
16
are closed. Further, one or more inflatable susceptor engagement seals
74
can be used to urge the edges or other portions of the susceptors
70
together and electrically engage the susceptors
70
, as shown in
FIGS. 6 and 7
. The susceptor seals
74
, which can be formed of stainless steel, such as 300 series austenitic stainless steel, can extend around the perimeter of the susceptors
70
. The susceptor seals
74
can be connected to the dies
14
,
16
, for example, by the studs
72
or by a T-shaped flange of each seal
74
that engages a corresponding slot in the respective die
14
,
16
.
Each susceptor seal
74
can be connected to a fluid source (not shown) that provides a pressurized fluid such as compressed air to the susceptor seals
74
and inflates the seals
74
to urge the susceptors
70
together. The fluid source for inflating the susceptor seals
74
can be the fluid source
48
that is used to expand the bladders
44
, or a different fluid source can be used. Alternatively, the susceptor seals
74
can be used without a fluid source. For example, each susceptor seal
74
can be deformed against the susceptors
70
when the dies
14
,
16
are closed so that the susceptor seals
74
urge the susceptors together. Although two susceptor seals
74
are shown in
FIG. 7
, a single seal
74
can alternatively be used. For example, the single susceptor seal can urge the edges of both susceptors
70
against a fixed portion of one of the dies
14
,
16
.
Due to the electrical contact between the susceptors
70
, eddy currents induced in the susceptors
70
by the induction coils
50
, as explained more fully below, can flow throughout the susceptors
70
. Additionally, the susceptors
70
can include contacts
76
that enhance the electrical connection between the susceptors
70
, for example, by increasing the durability or oxidation resistance of the susceptors
70
at the interface therebetween. The contacts
76
can be formed of copper, gold, or other electrical conductors that are plated, welded, or otherwise provided on the susceptors
70
.
As shown in
FIGS. 6 and 8
, the apparatus
10
can also include a cavity seal
78
that is disposed between the dies
14
,
16
, for example, between the susceptors
70
at a location between the die cavity
18
and the susceptor seals
74
. The cavity seal
78
can be a tube-like structure that extends continuously around the die cavity
18
so that the cavity seal
78
can be used to seal the die cavity
18
. The cavity seal
78
can be formed of a variety of materials including, but not limited to, metals such as austenitic stainless steel, for example, 304, 316, or 321 stainless steel. Typically, the cavity seal
78
is formed of a material that can operate at the elevated temperatures associated with the heat treatment process. The cavity seal
78
can also be fluidly connected to a fluid source (not shown) that provides a pressurized fluid, such as air, to the cavity seal
78
, thereby inflating the cavity seal
78
and urging the cavity seal
78
outwards against the susceptors
70
to form a hermetic seal around the die cavity
18
. The fluid source that is used to inflate the cavity seal
78
can be the same fluid source that is used to inflate the susceptor seals
74
, the fluid source
48
that is used to expand the bladders
44
, or a different fluid source. One or more pipes
80
, tubes, or other fluid communication devices can extend through the cavity seal
78
, through one of the susceptors
70
, or between the cavity seal
78
and one of the susceptors
70
as shown in
FIGS. 2A and 8
. The pipes
80
fluidly connect the bladders
44
in the die cavity
18
and the pressurized fluid source
48
, so that the fluid source
48
can supply fluid to the bladders
44
while the die cavity
18
is sealed by the cavity seal
78
during processing.
As illustrated in
FIGS. 9-12
, the susceptor
70
is heated through eddy current heating to the Curie temperature of the susceptor
70
, whereupon the susceptor
70
becomes paramagnetic and does not heat further. If some portions of the susceptor
70
are heated more quickly than other portions, the hotter portions will reach the Curie temperature and become paramagnetic before the other, cooler portions of the susceptor
70
. As illustrated in
FIGS. 11 and 12
, the eddy currents will then flow through the cooler magnetic portions, i.e., around the hotter, paramagnetic portions of the susceptor
70
, causing the cooler portions to also become heated to the Curie temperature. Therefore, even if some portions of the susceptor
70
heat at different rates, the entire susceptor
70
is heated to a uniform Curie temperature. Eddy current heating of the susceptor
70
results from eddy currents that are induced in the susceptor by the electromagnetic field generated by the induction coil
50
. The flow of the eddy currents through the susceptor
70
results in resistive heating of the susceptor
70
. Preferably, the susceptor
70
acts as a magnetic shield that prevents the induction coil
50
from inducing a current in the structural member
12
. As such, the induction coil
50
does not heat the structural member
12
directly, but rather heats the susceptor
70
, which, in turn, acts as a heat source in contact with the structural member
12
.
The Curie temperature of the susceptor
70
can be equal to the heat treatment temperature of the structural member
12
, i.e., the temperature at which the structural member
12
can be heat treated. Thus, the susceptor
70
can be used to heat the structural member
12
uniformly to the heat treatment temperature so that the structural member
12
can be heat treated, for example, to relieve stresses in the structural member
12
that were induced during preceding manufacturing processes. The susceptor
70
can be formed of a variety of materials including cobalt, iron, nickel, and alloys thereof, and the composition of the susceptor
70
can be designed to achieve a desired Curie temperature that is appropriate for a particular type of material. For example, susceptors with Curie temperatures between about 1000° F. and 1500° F. can be used for heat treating structural member that are formed of titanium and some titanium alloys. In one embodiment, the susceptor
70
is formed of 430 F. stainless steel, which typically includes carbon, manganese, phosphorus, sulfur, silicon, chromium, nickel, molybdenum, and iron, for example, approximately 0.065% or less carbon, 0.80% or less manganese, 0.03% or less phosphorous, 0.25% to 0.40% sulfur, 0.30% to 0.70% silicon, 17.25% to 18.25% chromium, 0.60% or less nickel, 0.50% or less molybdenum, and a remaining balance of iron. This alloy has a Curie temperature of about 1240° F., at which temperature titanium and certain titanium alloys can be heat treated. The structural member can be held at the heat treatment temperature for a predetermined period of time, such as about 5 to 60 minutes, and preferably about 20 to 40 minutes for titanium and titanium alloys, and thereby heat treated.
The susceptors
70
can be removable from the dies
14
,
16
so that the susceptors
70
can be replaced if they become worn or if it is desired to install susceptors
70
with a different Curie temperature. For example, a first set of susceptors
70
with a Curie temperature corresponding to a forming temperature of the bladders
44
can be installed in the dies
14
,
16
, and the apparatus
10
can be used to superplastically form the bladders
44
against the fixture member
46
in the die cavity
18
, as discussed above in connection with FIG.
4
A. The first set of susceptors
70
can then be removed from the die cavity
18
, and a second set of susceptors
70
with a Curie temperature corresponding to a relatively lower heat treatment temperature of the structural member
12
can be installed therein. The apparatus
10
can then be used to heat treat the structural member
12
, for example, as discussed above in connection with FIG.
4
. Thus, the bladders
44
can be formed at a forming temperature to a desired configuration using the fixture member
46
, and the formed bladders
44
can then be inserted into the die cavity
18
with the structural member
12
to restrain the structural member
12
during heat treatment.
Alternatively, multiple susceptors
70
a,
70
b
with different Curie temperatures can be provided in the apparatus
10
, as shown, for example, in
FIGS. 13-15
. The first susceptor
70
a
can be disposed on the dies
14
,
16
in the die cavity
18
, and the second susceptor
70
b
can be disposed on the first susceptor
70
a.
The susceptors
70
a,
70
b
can be configured so that either of the susceptors
70
a,
70
b
can be energized by the electromagnetic field generator, e.g., the induction coil
50
, to heat the structural member
12
as described above. For example, the first susceptor
70
a
can have a Curie temperature that is equal to the heat treatment temperature of the structural member
12
, and the second susceptor
70
b
can have a Curie temperature that is equal to the relatively higher forming temperature of the bladders
44
. An insulative layer, such as a thermally sprayed oxide dielectric coating, can be provided between the susceptors
70
a,
70
b
to electrically isolate the susceptors
70
a,
70
b.
Each of the susceptors
70
a,
70
b
can have multiple portions, such as a first portion disposed on the first die
14
and a second portion disposed on the second die
16
. One or more first susceptor engagement seals
74
a
can be used to urge the edges of the portions of the first susceptor
70
a
together to electrically engage the first susceptor portions as shown in FIG.
14
. Second susceptor engagement seals
74
b
can be used to urge the edges of the portions of the second susceptor
70
b
together to electrically engage the second susceptor portions as shown in FIG.
15
. The first and second susceptor engagement seals
74
a,
74
b
can be actuated separately by a pressure source as described above. Further, each of the engagement seals
74
a,
74
b
can be evacuated to disengage each susceptor
70
a,
70
b.
For example, when the edges of the portions of the first susceptor
70
a
are engaged in
FIG. 14
, the edges of the portions of the second susceptor
70
b
can be disengaged so that current does not flow between the portions of the second susceptor
70
b.
Similarly, when the edges of the portions of the second susceptor
70
b
are engaged, as shown in
FIG. 15
, the edges of the portions of the first susceptor
70
a
can be disengaged so that current does not flow between the portions of the first susceptor
70
a.
Thus, the edges of the portions of the first susceptor
70
a
can be disengaged while forming the bladders
44
so that current does not flow between the portions of the first susceptor
70
a,
and the edges of the portions of the second susceptor
70
b
can be disengaged during the heat treatment of the structural member
12
so that current does not flow between the portions of the second susceptor
70
b.
The frequency of the power supply
58
can also be adjusted to efficiently induce a current in one of the susceptors
70
a,
70
b
while not substantially inducing a current in the other susceptor
70
a,
70
b.
Further, even if the first susceptor
70
a
is heated during the forming of the bladders
44
, the first susceptor
70
a
can be heated to the Curie temperature of the first susceptor
70
a
upon which the first susceptor
70
a
becomes paramagnetic so that the current is induced in the second. susceptor
70
b
and heats the second susceptor
70
b
to the Curie temperature of the second susceptor
70
b.
Although the bladders
44
may be formed before the heat treatment of the structural member
12
, the bladders
44
may undergo some deformation during the heat treatment so that the structural member
12
is urged to, and held in, the desired configuration. For example, as shown in
FIG. 4
, the bladders
44
are positioned in the die cavity
18
between the cap portions
12
a
of the structural member
12
so that, when the bladders
44
are pressurized during the heat treatment of the structural member
12
, each bladder
44
urges the cap portions
12
a
of the structural member
12
outward to a desired configuration. In this way, the structural member
12
can be restrained in a desired configuration defining desired dimensions with narrow tolerances and stress relieved in that configuration so that the resulting heat treated structural member
12
accurately defines the desired dimensions. For example, the cap portions
12
a
can be urged to and restrained in a configuration in which the overall length between the cap portions
12
a
defines a desired length. Further, the bladders
44
can be slightly deformed when inserted into the dies
14
,
16
prior to the heat treatment operation, for example, so that the bladders
44
can be fit between the cap portions
12
b
that define a distance therebetween that is smaller than desired. Each bladder
44
can be re-used during multiple heat treatment operations for multiple structural members
12
.
There is shown in
FIG. 16
a heat treatment profile for a titanium alloy according to one embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 16
illustrates the pressure variation in the bladders
44
, the power variation of the power supply
58
,. and the temperature variation of 9 points on the structural member
12
in the die cavity
18
during the heat treatment processes. As illustrated, the pressure in the bladders
44
and the temperature of the structural member
12
begin at initial conditions, which can be ambient conditions. The pressure in the bladders
44
is increased to about 14 psi by injecting gas from the source
48
through the pipe
80
and into the bladders
44
. The bladders
44
are expanded by the gas and thereby restrain the structural member
12
in a predetermined configuration. The power supply
58
is energized, generating a current in the induction coils
50
and heating the susceptor
70
and the structural member
12
to the heat treatment temperature, for example, 1250° F., during a period of about 25 to 35 minutes. Although the 9 measured points on the structural member are heated at slightly different rates, each point reaches, and does not substantially exceed, the heat treatment temperature. The structural member
12
is held at the heat treatment temperature for between about 5 and 20 minutes, thereby effecting a stress relief heat treatment of the structural member
12
. The output of the power supply
58
is then reduced and the pressure in the bladders
44
is held substantially constant as the structural member
12
cools in the die cavity
18
. Output of the power supply
58
can be terminated during cooling, or reduced so that the power supply
58
is used to control the rate of cooling of the structural member
12
, for example, according to a predetermined temperature schedule. The structural member
12
can be cooled to the ambient temperature in the apparatus
10
or can be removed after cooling to a temperature below which distortion is unlikely to occur, for example, below about 400° F. Thus, the structural member
12
is held in the desired configuration during the heating and cooling, and distortion of the structural member
12
is prevented. The pressure in the bladders
44
can be released shortly before opening the dies
14
,
16
.
FIG. 17
illustrates a simple temperature profile, designated by reference numeral
90
, for heat treating a structural member
12
formed of a titanium alloy to relieve stresses in the structural member
12
according to one embodiment of the present invention. The structural member
12
is heated to a heat treatment temperature of about 1250° F. during a time period of between about 30 and 45 minutes. The structural member
12
is held at the heat treatment temperature for a time period of between about
20
and
40
minutes. The structural member
12
is then cooled at least partially in the die cavity
18
. There is also shown in
FIG. 17
a temperature profile, designated by reference numeral
92
, for a conventional process for stress relief. According to the conventional process, the structural member is heated in a furnace to a heat treatment temperature, held at that temperature, and cooled. However, the conventional process can take up to about 12 hours due, in part, to the relatively longer periods required for heating and cooling the structural member in the furnace.
Referring now to
FIG. 18
, there are illustrated a number of operations, some or all of which can be performed in processing a structural member according to embodiments of the present invention. A structural member is at least partially, and most commonly, completely provided in a die cavity. See block
110
. At least one bladder is positioned in the die cavity proximate to the structural member. For example, two or more bladders can be provided, and the bladders can be positioned opposite a portion of the structural member to restrain the structural member therebetween. The bladders can be formed of material such as titanium and titanium alloys. See block
112
. At least one tool can be positioned in the die cavity. Each tool can define a surface corresponding to at least a portion of the structural member and can be positioned opposite the structural member from at least one of the bladders. See block
114
. Gas can be purged from the die cavity. For example, an inert gas such as argon can alternately be injected into and evacuated from the bladders or other portions of the die cavity so that the gas in the bladders or die cavity is replaced with the inert gas. See block
116
. An inflatable susceptor engagement seal can be disposed at an interface of first and second portions of at least one susceptor so that the seal electrically engages the first and second portions. See block
118
. First and second cooperable dies can be engaged to form the die cavity and an inflatable cavity seal at an interface of the dies can be pressurized to hermetically seal the die cavity. See block
120
. A pressurized fluid is injected into the at least one bladder, expanding the bladder to at least partially fill a space in the die cavity and restrain the structural member in a predetermined configuration. For example, the structural member can be urged against a corresponding surface of a tool in the die cavity. See block
122
. If more than one bladder is used, a substantially equal pressure can be maintained in each of the bladders. See block
124
. An electromagnetic field generator, such as an induction coil, is energized to induce a current within at least a portion of the at least one susceptor, thereby heating the structural member to a heat treatment temperature. See block
126
. The at least one susceptor can be heated to a Curie temperature at which the susceptor becomes paramagnetic. See block
128
. The structural member can be maintained at the heat treatment temperature for a predetermined interval to thereby relieve stresses in the structural member. See block
130
. A cooling fluid can be circulated through the at least one induction coil, and the structural member can be cooled according to a predetermined temperature schedule while restraining the structural member with the at least one bladder in the die cavity. See block
132
.
FIG. 19
illustrates the operations performed in processing a structural member according to another embodiment of the present invention. One or more of the operations illustrated in
FIG. 19
are performed before one or more of the operations of FIG.
18
. For example, a fixture member is positioned in the die cavity. The fixture member corresponds in shape to the structural member. See block
210
. At least one bladder is positioned in the die cavity proximate the fixture member. See block
212
. The bladders are heated to a forming temperature higher than the heat treatment temperature of the structural member. For example, a forming susceptor can be provided in thermal communication with the die cavity, the forming susceptor having a Curie temperature about equal to the forming temperature of the bladders. A current can be induced in the forming susceptor to heat the bladders to the forming temperature. See block
214
. A fluid is injected into the bladders to at least partially expand the bladders and urge the bladders at least partially against the fixture member. See block
216
. The fixture member is removed from the die cavity. See block
218
. Thereafter, the structural member can be processed according to one or more of the operations described in connection with FIG.
18
.
Many modifications and other embodiments of the invention will come to mind to one skilled in the art to which this invention pertains having the benefit of the knowledge presented in the foregoing descriptions and the associated drawings. For example, the structural member
12
can be aged according to a predetermined aging schedule in the apparatus
10
following the stress relief cycle by heating the structural member to an aging temperature and holding the structural member at the aging temperature for a predetermined period before cooling. Therefore, it is to be understood that the invention is not to be limited to the specific embodiments disclosed and that modifications and other embodiments are intended to be included within the scope of the appended claims. Although specific terms are employed herein, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purposes of limitation.
Claims
- 1. An apparatus for heat treating a structural member, the apparatus comprising:first and second co-operable dies structured to define a die cavity therebetween for at least partially receiving the structural member; at least one susceptor in thermal communication with said die cavity, each susceptor having a Curie temperature at which said susceptor becomes paramagnetic; an electromagnetic field generator configured to induce a current within at least a portion of said at least one susceptor; at least one bladder positioned in said die cavity, each said bladder configured to receive a pressurized fluid for expanding said bladder; and at least one rigid tool disposed in said die cavity, said tool defining a contour surface corresponding to the structural member, wherein said at least one bladder is configured to urge said at least one tool against the structural member and thereby restrain a distortion of the structural member while the structural member is heat treated.
- 2. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein said at least one tool is disposed in said die cavity between said at least one bladder and the structural member.
- 3. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein said at least one tool is disposed in said die cavity between at least one of said dies and the structural member.
- 4. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein the Curie temperature of said at least one susceptor is about equal to the heat treatment temperature of the structural member.
- 5. An apparatus according to claim 1 further comprising a coolant source and wherein said electromagnetic field generator is at least one induction coil, said coolant source being fluidly connected to a passage defined by said at least one induction coil and configured to circulate a cooling fluid through said passage and cool said at least one induction coil.
- 6. An apparatus according to claim 1, further comprising a pressure source fluidly connected to said at least one bladder and configured to supply the pressurized fluid to said at least one bladder.
- 7. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein at least two of said bladders are positioned in said die cavity and further comprising a pressure regulation device in fluid communication with each bladder, said pressure regulation device configured to maintain a substantially equal pressure in each bladder.
- 8. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein at least two of said bladders are positioned in said die cavity and configured opposite a portion of the structural member such that said bladders restrain the structural member therebetween.
- 9. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein at least one of said bladders is positioned in said die cavity and configured between opposed portions of the structural member such that said bladders urge the opposed portions to a predetermined dimension.
- 10. An apparatus according to claim 1 wherein each bladder comprises at least one of the group consisting of titanium and titanium alloys.
- 11. An apparatus according to claim 1 further comprising an inflatable susceptor engagement seal disposed at an interface of first and second portions of the at least one susceptor and configured to be inflated to electrically engage the first and second portions.
- 12. An apparatus according to claim 1 further comprising an inflatable cavity seal disposed at an interface of said first and second dies and configured to receive a pressurized fluid to inflate said seal and hermetically seal the die cavity.
- 13. A method of heat treating a structural member, the method comprising:providing the structural member at least partially in a die cavity; positioning at least one bladder in the die cavity proximate to the structural member; positioning at least one tool in the die cavity proximate to the structural member, each tool defining a surface corresponding to at least a portion of the structural member; injecting a pressurized fluid into the at least one bladder and thereby expanding the bladder to at least partially fill a space in the die cavity and restrain the structural member in a predetermined configuration against the corresponding surface of the at least one tool; and energizing an electromagnetic field generator to induce a current within at least a portion of at least one susceptor, thereby heating the structural member to a heat treatment temperature, wherein the structural member is restrained by the at least one bladder during at least part of said energizing step such that the bladder restrains a distortion of the structural member.
- 14. A method according to claim 13 wherein said first positioning step comprises positioning at least two of the bladders in the die cavity opposite a portion of the structural member such that the bladders restrain the structural member therebetween during at least a portion of said energizing step.
- 15. A method according to claim 13 wherein said energizing step comprises heating the at least one susceptor to a Curie temperature at which the at least one susceptor becomes paramagnetic.
- 16. A method according to claim 13 wherein said energizing step comprises maintaining the structural member at the heat treatment temperature for a predetermined interval to thereby relieve stresses in the structural member.
- 17. A method according to claim 13 wherein said energizing step comprises electrically energizing at least one induction coil and further comprising circulating a cooling fluid through the at least one induction coil.
- 18. A method according to claim 13 further comprising cooling the structural member according to a predetermined temperature schedule while restraining the structural member with the at least one bladder in the die cavity.
- 19. A method according to claim 13 wherein said injecting step comprises maintaining a substantially equal pressure in at least two of the bladders.
- 20. A method according to claim 13 further comprising providing the at least one bladder, each of the bladders comprising at least one of the group consisting of titanium and titanium alloys.
- 21. A method according to claim 13 further comprising purging gas from the die cavity prior to said heating step.
- 22. A method according to claim 13 further comprising pressurizing an inflatable susceptor engagement seal disposed at an interface of first and second portions of the at least one susceptor and thereby electrically engaging the first and second portions.
- 23. A method according to claim 13 further comprising engaging first and second cooperable dies to form the die cavity and pressurizing an inflatable cavity seal at an interface of the dies to hermetically seal the die cavity.
- 24. A method according to claim 13 wherein said second positioning step comprises positioning the at least one tool in the die cavity opposite the structural member from at least one of the bladders such that the bladder urges the structural member against the corresponding surface of the tool.
- 25. A method according to claim 13 further comprising, prior to said providing step:positioning a fixture member in the die cavity, the fixture member corresponding in shape to the structural member; positioning the at least one bladder in the die cavity proximate the fixture member; heating the at least one bladder to a forming temperature higher than the heat treatment temperature; injecting a fluid into at least one bladder to at least partially expand the at least one bladder and urge the at least one bladder at least partially against the fixture member; and removing the fixture member from the die cavity.
- 26. A method according to claim 25 further comprising providing a forming susceptor in thermal communication with the die cavity, said forming susceptor having a Curie temperature about equal to the forming temperature, and inducing a current in the forming susceptor to heat the bladder to the forming temperature.
- 27. A product obtained by the method of claim 13.
- 28. A product according to claim 13 wherein the product is formed of at least one of the group consisting of titanium and titanium alloys.
US Referenced Citations (52)