This application relates to furnaces, and more particularly relates to calibrating furnaces to avoid undesirable combustion tones.
Heating systems, such as residential and commercial furnaces, include one or more burners for combusting a fuel such as natural gas. Hot flue gas from the combustion of the fuel proceeds from the burner and through a heat exchanger. The hot flue gas transfers thermal energy to the heat exchanger, from which the thermal energy is then dissipated by a flow of air driven across the heat exchanger by, for example, a blower.
One type of burner used in a furnace is a premix burner in which fuel and air are mixed in a burner inlet tube prior to injection into a combustion zone where the mixture is ignited. Compared to other burners (e.g. inshot burners), premix burners typically emit lower levels of nitrogen oxides (NOx), the emissions of which are tightly regulated and restricted by many jurisdictions.
During operation of a premix combustion furnace, it is possible that an undesirable combustion tone will occur that is unpleasant to those in the vicinity of the furnace. Unlike a normal “furnace roar” sound that sounds like white noise, is generally quiet, and only heard in proximity to the furnace, a “combustion tone” is more horn-like and can be heard throughout a home, for example. Such combustion tones would be considered unacceptable by a resident of a home in which the tone occurred.
A method of calibrating a furnace according to an example of the present disclosure includes determining a first flame stabilization period for a furnace that avoids detachment of a flame from a burner within a burner box of the furnace, determining a second flame stabilization period that is longer than the first flame stabilization period and avoids emission of a combustion tone, and configuring a controller of the same or another furnace to utilize a third flame stabilization period that has a duration between the first and second flame stabilization periods. Each flame stabilization period commences upon ignition of a premixed mixture of air and fuel at the burner while an inducer fan that is in fluid communication with the burner box operates within a first range of fan speeds, and terminates when the rotational speed of the inducer fan increases to a second range of fan speeds that is greater than the entire first range.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, said configuring a controller of the same or another furnace to utilize the third flame stabilization period that has a duration between the first and second flame stabilization periods includes determining a median of the first and second flame stabilization periods, and configuring the controller to use the median as the third flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the furnace is cycled OFF and ON in each of a plurality of iterations, each iteration using a different respective one of a plurality of flame stabilization periods, as part of said determining a first flame stabilization period and said second flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the first flame stabilization period includes determining a shortest flame stabilization period of the plurality of flame stabilization periods that avoids detachment of the flame from the burner.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the shortest flame stabilization period includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that causes detachment of a flame from the burner. The initial flame stabilization is increased in each of one or more subsequent iterations until a particular flame stabilization period is determined that avoids detachment of a flame from the burner. The particular flame stabilization period is selected as the first flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the shortest flame stabilization period includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that avoids detachment of a flame from the burner. The initial flame stabilization is decreased in each of one or more subsequent iterations until a particular flame stabilization period of a particular iteration is determined that detaches of a flame from the burner. The flame stabilization period from the last iteration prior to the particular iteration is selected as the first flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the second flame stabilization period includes determining a longest flame stabilization period of the plurality of flame stabilization periods that avoids emission of a combustion tone from the furnace.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the longest flame stabilization period includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that causes a combustion tone from the furnace, decreasing the initial flame stabilization period in each of one or more subsequent iterations until a particular flame stabilization period is determined that avoids emission of a combustion tone from the furnace, and selecting the particular flame stabilization period as the second flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, determining the longest flame stabilization period includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that avoids a combustion tone from the furnace, increasing the initial flame stabilization period in each of one or more subsequent iterations until a particular flame stabilization period of a particular iteration is determined that causes emission of a combustion tone from the furnace, and selecting the flame stabilization period from the last iteration prior to the particular iteration as the second flame stabilization period.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the following are performed during each iteration: turning ON an igniter, opening a gas valve of the furnace to provide a flow of gas to the burner while the igniter is turned ON, and detecting a flame from ignition of a premixed mixture of air and fuel at the burner, performed using a flame sensor that is spaced apart from the igniter.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, during each iteration, the opening of the gas valve is performed after turning ON the igniter.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, during each iteration, the inducer fan is operated within a third range of fan speeds to purge the burner box prior to turning ON the igniter and opening the gas valve.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the third range of fan speeds is greater than the entire first range of fan speeds and the entire second range of fan speeds.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, during each iteration, the inducer fan is turned OFF after the purging, and turned ON within the first range of fan speeds after turning ON the igniter but before opening the gas valve.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, during each iteration the rotational speed of the inducer fan is lowered from the third range of fan speeds for the purge to the first range of fan speeds for the flame stabilization period without turning OFF the inducer.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the furnace includes a heat exchanger, and the burner box is part of a burner assembly, and the method includes measuring a heat exchanger pressure drop (HXDP) across the heat exchanger and burner assembly. The first range of inducer fan speeds provides an HXDP at or within a predefined tolerance of a first HXDP target. The second range of inducer fan speeds provides an HXDP at or within a predefined tolerance of a second HXDP target that is greater than the first HXDP target.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, during the flame stabilization period of each iteration, the first HXDP target is utilized as a setpoint, and the rotational speed of the inducer fan is adjusted based on the measured HXDP to approach the first HXDP target.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the controller is configured to utilize the second range of fan speeds for steady state operation of the furnace.
In a further embodiment of any of the foregoing embodiments, the mixture of air and fuel is premixed in the burner box, and the mixture is provided to the burner.
A furnace according to an example of the present disclosure includes a heat exchanger, a burner assembly, an inducer fan, and a controller. The burner assembly is in thermal communication with the heat exchanger, and includes a mixing tube that provides a premixed mixture of air and fuel to a burner. The inducer fan is operable to extract combustion gases from the burner. The controller is operable to control a rotational speed of the inducer fan to provide a flame stabilization period that commences upon ignition of the premixed mixture while the inducer fan operates within a first range of fan speeds, and terminates when the rotational speed of the inducer fan increases to a second range of fan speeds that is greater than the entire first range. The flame stabilization period has a duration that is long enough to avoid detachment of a flame from the burner and short enough to avoid emission of a combustion tone.
The embodiments, examples, and alternatives of the preceding paragraphs, the claims, or the following description and drawings, including any of their various aspects or respective individual features, may be taken independently or in any combination. Features described in connection with one embodiment are applicable to all embodiments, unless such features are incompatible.
A typical prior art construction of a burner is shown in
A burner assembly 26 is operatively associated with each inlet 23. A gas valve 37 controls a flow of gas from a source (not shown) through a conduit 38, to the burner assembly 26. The burner assembly 26 introduces a flame and combustion gases (not shown) into the heat exchanger cell 22. Vent 27 releases the combustion gases to atmosphere (through a flue or the like) after the heat of the flame and combustion gases are extracted by the heat exchanger 21 through collection box 28. Extraction of the combustion gases are aided by an inducer fan 29 having a motor 30. The motor 30 is controlled by a controller 31, which may be part of an integrated furnace control (IFC), for example.
The controller 31 includes a processor 32 operatively connected to memory 33. The processor 32 may include one or more microprocessors, microcontrollers, application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), or the like, for example. The memory 33 may include one or several types of memory such as read-only memory (ROM), random-access memory, cache memory, flash memory devices, etc.
In order to extract heat from the heat exchanger 21, an indoor blower assembly 34 may be provided to create significant airflow across the heat exchanger cells 22. As the air circulates across the cells 22, it is heated and can then be directed to a space to be heated, such as a home or commercial building for example, by way of appropriate ductwork as indicated by arrow 35. The furnace 20 may also include a return 36 to enable air from the space to be recirculated and/or fresh air to be introduced for flow across the heat exchanger cells 22.
A pressure transducer, schematically shown as 39, is provided to measure a heat exchanger pressure drop (HXDP) of the heat exchanger 21 and the burner assembly 26, and to output a signal representative of the pressure drop to the controller 31.
Operation of the inducer fan 29 contributes to the HXDP of the furnace 20, and the controller 31 has a mapping of inducer fan speeds to corresponding HXDP values stored in memory 33. The rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 can be controlled to achieve a desired HXDP (e.g., using the HXDP as a feedback in a closed loop control).
Optionally, an acoustic sensor 40 (shown in dotted lines) may also be provided that is configured to detect combustion tones and notify the controller 31 of such detected tones.
In the illustrated example, the mixing tube 44 receives a supply of fuel and air from a fuel and air source, respectively. The fuel enters the mixing tube 44 through an inlet 50 to a fuel inlet tube 48 in fluid communication with the conduit 38, and the air enters to mixing tube 44 through an air inlet 52 that surrounds the fuel inlet tube 48. The mixing tube 44 also includes a mixing plate 45 that increases turbulence in the air entering the inlet 52 to encourage mixing of the air and fuel prior to an elbow 46 in the mixing tube 44 changing a direction of flow through the mixing tube 44 and into the burner box 42.
The air and fuel mixture continues to mix as it travels through the mixing tube 44 and into the burner box 42 through opening 56, and also continues to mix as it travels along an internal path (not shown) within the burner box 42 to a burner distribution plate 72.
The burner box 42 includes a back wall 58, a pair of opposite end walls 60, and a pair of opposite sidewalls 62. The end walls 60 and sidewalls 62 at least partially define an opening opposite the back wall 58 for accepting the burner distribution plate 72.
Referring again to
As shown in
The burner distribution plate 72 includes perforated sidewalls 88 and perforated end walls 90 that surround a partially perforated back wall 92. In the illustrated example, the back wall 82 includes multiple perforated discs 94 that protrude from the back wall 92 of the burner distribution plate 72. As shown in
An igniter 96 extends through the sidewall 62 shown in
Undesired combustion tones can occur in connection with furnace start-up based on differences in acoustical impedance and/or flue gas density. In general, a premix combustion system, such as that of the furnace 20, can be divided into two sub-systems when referring to the flow path of the fuel, air, flames and combustion byproducts (flue gases), with the burner mesh 95 serving as a divider. Both the upstream and downstream systems have corresponding acoustical impedance values, Z_upstream and Z_downstream. If Z_upstream is less that Z_downstream, then an undesirable combustion tone can occur. As used herein, a “combustion tone” refers to a horn-like tone from a premix burner furnace. “Combustion tone” does not include a typical “furnace roar” sound that occurs in all natural gas furnaces.
Also, immediately after ignition of the premixed mixture of air and fuel at the burner mesh 95 of the premix burner box 42, the combustion byproducts (flue gas) are relatively dense. The longer the burner box 42 burner operates, the density of the flue gas decreases (get thinner), until the furnace 20 reaches steady state operation where the flue gas density is no longer changing. During this transient flue gas density time period, the thermal acoustics of the entire combustion system can be affected in an undesirable manner and can produce an undesirable combustion tone.
Operation of the inducer fan 29 helps to reduce the density of flue gas. However, if the rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 is increased too rapidly, a flame from combustion of the premixed mixture at the burner mesh 95 may become detached from a burner portion of the burner box 42 (e.g., the burner mesh 95 itself), which is also undesirable. To avoid flame detachment, a “flame stabilization period” can be used to allow the flame to stabilize at the burner mesh 95. However, if the flame stabilization period is too long, an undesired combustion tone is more likely to occur.
Each flame stabilization period commences upon ignition of the mixture of air and fuel at the burner mesh 95 while the inducer fan 29 that is in fluid communication with the burner box 42 operates within a first range of fan speeds. Each flame stabilization period terminates when the rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 increases to a second range of fan speeds that is greater than the entire first range.
Determining and utilizing a flame stabilization time period as described in the method of flowchart 100 will reduce the transient flue gas density time period and a likelihood of occurrence of an undesired combustion tone.
In one example, the configuring of step 106 includes determining a median of the first and second flame stabilization periods, and configuring the controller 31 to use the median as the third flame stabilization period.
In one example, the method includes cycling the furnace 20 OFF and ON for each of a plurality of iterations, with each iteration using a different respective one of a plurality of flame stabilization periods to determine the first and second flame stabilization periods.
In one example, the determination of the first flame stabilization period (step 102) includes determining a shortest flame stabilization period of the plurality of flame stabilization periods from the iterations that avoids detachment of the flame from the burner mesh 95.
In the same or another example, the determination of the second flame stabilization period (step 104) includes determining a longest flame stabilization period of the plurality of flame stabilization periods that avoids emission of a combustion tone from the furnace 20.
In one example, determining the first flame stabilization period (step 102) includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that causes detachment of a flame from the burner mesh 95, increasing the initial flame stabilization in each of one or more subsequent iterations (e.g., by a same predefined amount interval in each iteration) until a particular flame stabilization period is determined that avoids detachment of a flame from the burner mesh 95, and that particular flame stabilization period is selected as the first flame stabilization period.
In another example, determining the first flame stabilization period (step 102) includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that avoids detachment of a flame from the burner mesh 95, decreasing the initial flame stabilization period in each of one or more subsequent iterations (e.g., by a same predefined interval in each iteration) until a particular flame stabilization period of a particular iteration is determined that detaches of a flame from the burner mesh 95, and selecting the flame stabilization period from the last iteration prior to the particular iteration as the first flame stabilization period.
One way to determine whether flame detachment occurs is based on a signal from the flame sensor 97, which has a different signal profile for a steady flame and a flame detachment scenario.
In one example, determining the second flame stabilization period (step 104) includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that causes a combustion tone from the furnace 20, decreasing the initial flame stabilization in each of one or more subsequent iterations (e.g., by a same predefined interval in each iteration) until a particular flame stabilization period is determined that avoids emission of a combustion tone from the furnace 20, and selecting the particular flame stabilization period as the second flame stabilization period.
In another example, said determining the second flame stabilization period (step 104) includes utilizing an initial flame stabilization period in a given iteration that avoids a combustion tone from the furnace 20, increasing the initial flame stabilization period in each of one or more subsequent iterations (e.g., by a same predefined interval in each iteration) until a particular flame stabilization period of a particular iteration is determined that causes emission of a combustion tone from the furnace 20, and selecting the flame stabilization period from the last iteration prior to the particular iteration as the second flame stabilization period.
The combustion tones can be detected by a human operator and/or by the acoustic sensor 40, for example.
In one example, during each iteration, the igniter 96 is turned ON from an OFF state and the gas valve 37 is turned ON from an OFF state to provide a flow of gas to the burner mesh 95 (which is premixed with air within the mixing tube 44 and within the burner box 42). A flame from ignition of the premixed mixture is detected by the flame sensor 97, which is spaced apart from the igniter 96.
Operation of the inducer fan 29 contributes to the HXDP of the furnace 20, and the controller 31 has a mapping of inducer fan speeds to corresponding HXDP values stored in memory 33. The rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 can be controlled to achieve a desired HXDP.
At a time 206, the inducer fan 29 is turned ON and initiated to operate in a range of fan speeds corresponding to HXDP window 230 in
During operation of the inducer fan 29, the output of the pressure transducer 39 serves as an input for a closed loop feedback input for the controller 31 to adjust the inducer fan 29 speed as needed to approach and/or meet a given HXDP target/window.
At time 210, the hot surface igniter 96 is turned ON for warmup. Also, the inducer fan 29 can optionally be turned off at time 210.
At time 212, a rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 is increased to operate within a range of rotational speeds corresponding to the HXDP window 240 (e.g., based and/or centered on a setpoint 242). In the example of
At time 213, the HXDP overshoots the setpoint 242, after which the inducer fan 29 speed and HXDP are reduced to the setpoint at time 214.
The gas valve 37 is opened at time 214, and ignition is detected by the flame sensor 97 at time 216. Thus, in the example of
From time 213 to time 218, the inducer fan 29 continues to operate within the range corresponding to HXDP window 240 of values corresponding to HXDP window 240, but at time 218 the rotational speed of the inducer fan 29 is increased to a range of values corresponding to HXDP window 244.
In the example of
Also, in the example of
In one example, each window 230, 240, 244 is centered around a respective setpoint (e.g., within a predefined tolerance of its respective setpoint).
The “flame stabilization period” of
In one example, time 0 indicates the start of an iteration of the method 100, and time 220 indicates an example time at which a given iteration could be terminated, after which the inducer fan 29, gas valve 37, and igniter 96 can be turned OFF prior to turning ON again as part of a subsequent iteration.
The example of
The same HXDP target 242 could be used as a setpoint for adjusting the fan speed of the inducer fan 29 during the flame stabilization period of each subsequent iteration of the method 100.
The method of flowchart 100 provides the benefit of maintaining a short flame stabilization time period that reduces the transient flue gas density time period, thereby preventing premix combustion tones, and also avoiding flame detachment.
Although example embodiments have been disclosed, a worker of ordinary skill in this art would recognize that certain modifications would come within the scope of this disclosure. For that reason, the following claims should be studied to determine the scope and content of this disclosure.
This application claims the benefit of Provisional Application No. 62/830,816, filed on Apr. 8, 2019, which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4653998 | Sohma et al. | Mar 1987 | A |
6343927 | Eroglu et al. | Feb 2002 | B1 |
7536274 | Heavner, III et al. | May 2009 | B2 |
7635264 | Strobel et al. | Dec 2009 | B2 |
8146584 | Thompson | Apr 2012 | B2 |
8167610 | Raleigh et al. | May 2012 | B2 |
9476589 | Newby | Oct 2016 | B2 |
9784448 | Bertelli | Oct 2017 | B2 |
20080081301 | Hannum et al. | Apr 2008 | A1 |
20080318173 | Schaller | Dec 2008 | A1 |
20090317756 | Hoverson et al. | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20120135360 | Hannum et al. | May 2012 | A1 |
20130213378 | Schultz | Aug 2013 | A1 |
20140030662 | Noman | Jan 2014 | A1 |
20160003471 | Karkow et al. | Jan 2016 | A1 |
20170167725 | Robertson | Jun 2017 | A1 |
20180259199 | Batson | Sep 2018 | A1 |
20180259223 | Reed et al. | Sep 2018 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2018152394 | Aug 2018 | WO |
2019018675 | Jan 2019 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200318829 A1 | Oct 2020 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62830816 | Apr 2019 | US |