The invention relates to a method for quickly detecting a fault, a ground fault or fault between phases for example, in a medium- or low-voltage electrical network. The electrical network may be either overhead or underground. This method is based on the analysis of the amplitude of a signal that is representative of the current flowing in the network. The invention also relates to a detection device that is capable of implementing this method.
Fault detection devices in three-phase electrical networks allow the protection for the loads to be tripped and/or help with locating said faults. For example,
The outgoing lines 4, 4′, composed of overhead lines and/or underground cables, may be subject to various faults and it is important that they are detected and located in order to mitigate the problems caused: power failure, deterioration of the withstand strength of the insulation materials, etc. A fault detection device 6i, 6′, installed on the outgoing lines 4′ or line sections 4, may serve to indicate the occurrence of a fault, by lighting up an indicator light 7, for example. Additionally, a device 6 may be combined with or integrated in a protection relay 8 that is capable of controlling the opening of the contacts of the circuit breaker 5.
Among these faults, the most common are single-phase faults, of short circuit type, that are located outside the source substation, in which one phase is in contact with ground, or an overhead cable breaks, especially in the event of bad weather. Furthermore, faults are also sometimes non-permanent or intermittent, in particular in overhead networks: some disappear naturally before the protection functions come into play, others are removed by a more or less slow restart cycle.
To take the potential necessary precautions or implement the devices that are adapted to characterizing and locating the fault, fault detection must be quick, of the order of a few milliseconds, or even less in the case of transient faults, and of course reliable.
In the management of medium-voltage (MV) and low-voltage (LV) distribution networks, the state of the network, of equipment or of industrial processes is conventionally monitored via the measurement of electrical quantities, such as voltages and intensities, that may be single phase or three phases depending on the context. This monitoring allows the state of the network, as well as the operating mode conditions (normal function or malfunction, linked, for example, to a current overload, short circuit or supply undervoltage etc.), to be determined.
In practice, two possibilities for carrying out this monitoring are distinguished:
In addition, the document EP0297418 describes a method for detecting frequency faults in an electrical network. In this method, multiple measurement samples of a signal to be analysed are used to calculate an estimated frequency. However, the method is recursive and in a closed loop, i.e. the calculation of the estimated frequency at an instant t also takes into account the estimated frequency at the preceding instant t−1 and will also be used for calculating the estimated frequency at the subsequent instant t+1. This method may therefore be complicated to implement, as it is necessary to know the preceding estimated frequency in order to calculate the new estimated frequency. Furthermore, as this method is recursive and in a closed loop, the time taken for converging towards the exact value of the calculated amplitude is non-negligible, thereby equally delaying the acquisition of a precise result. What is more, any interruption of the process, linked, for example, to opening the network, delays an “on the fly” resumption of the system when the network is re-energized: this convergence phase must once again be passed through, generating inertia. The same applies if there is a disruption, of electromagnetic type for example, skewing the measurement of a particular sample.
Document EP0322518 describes a method for detecting faults in a protection relay of an electrical network, which is based on the acquisition of three samples of the sinusoidal current flowing in the network, at a sampling frequency close to four times of the nominal frequency. However, the calculation of the current amplitude depends on the sampling frequency value, which depends on the current real frequency value. So it provides a more complex calculation and does not provide expected results, especially for detecting transitory faults.
However, in electrical distribution networks, in particular in medium-voltage networks, the detection of a malfunction must be able to be done very quickly in order to take the necessary precautions both for equipment and personnel. It is especially the case for equipment for protecting against and detecting faults of short circuit type (between phases or phase-ground), which must react in a few milliseconds so as to be able to manage these faults with very high responsiveness, or even to be able to pre-empt them. This detection is generally done by exceedence of a threshold (upper or lower) of a variable that is representative of the electric current. Thus, certain types of protection will monitor overcurrents, overvoltages or undervoltages, active/reactive power exceedences, etc.
Depending on the neutral regime type of the network, it is easier to see a fault from an overcurrent (direct neutral, resistive neutral) or from an overvoltage (isolated neutral) or a mixture of the two (compensated neutral). Aside from the type of fault, their nature is also differentiated: permanent fault (not removed by the restart cycle of the network) or non-permanent (removed before the end of this restart cycle).
In the rest of the document, the term “amplitude A” denotes the absolute value of the peak amplitude of a sinusoidal signal Z, of the type Z=A·sin(xt+y).
One of the aims of the invention is to propose a quick and simple method that allows a fault to be detected in an electrical network by analysing the amplitude of a signal (voltage or current) that is representative of the current flowing in the electrical network.
The invention aims to overcome some drawbacks of the existing fault detection devices and methods, and to optimize fault detection. By virtue of the invention, it may be possible to pre-empt a fault sufficiently quickly before it actually occurs.
To this end, the invention describes a method for detecting a fault in an electrical network through which an AC current flows. The method comprises a step of acquiring three samples of a sinusoidal signal that is representative of the current flowing in the network, the acquisition of each sample being spaced apart by a fixed sampling time, the sampling time corresponding to a sampling frequency being more than or equal to three times the nominal frequency. The method then comprises a step of calculating an amplitude of the signal, the calculation of the amplitude depending solely on the three acquired samples and being independent of the sampling time, then comprises a step of determining a fault if the calculated amplitude is above a first predetermined threshold or if the calculated amplitude is below a second predetermined threshold.
The invention also relates to a device for detecting a fault that is capable of implementing such a method for detecting a fault. The detection device comprises an acquisition module that is capable of obtaining three samples of a sinusoidal signal that is representative of the current flowing in the network, the acquisition of each sample being spaced apart by a fixed sampling time, a calculation module that is capable of calculating an amplitude of the signal, the calculation of the amplitude depending solely on the three samples acquired by the acquisition module and being independent of the sampling time, a fault determination module that is capable of determining a fault if the amplitude calculated by the calculation module is above a first predetermined threshold or if the calculated amplitude is below a second predetermined threshold.
According to one feature, the detection device comprises means for storing the three samples. The storage means may also store information relating to the detected faults.
The invention also relates to a protection relay for the purpose of monitoring an electrical network or any electrical switch unit that is connected to an electrical network comprising such a device for detecting faults in the electrical network.
Other features and advantages will become more clearly apparent in the following description of particular embodiments of the invention, which are shown in the following appended figures:
The outgoing lines 4, 4′ are composed of overhead lines and/or underground cables and may be subject to various faults, and it is important that they are detected and located in order to mitigate the problems caused: power failure, deterioration of the withstand strength of the insulation materials, etc. Fault detection devices 6, 6i, 6′, installed on the outgoing line 4′ or line sections 4, serve to detect faults. Once a fault has been detected, the detection device 6 may comprise fault signalling means, such as a warning indicator 7, means for memorizing information relating, for example, to the presence of the fault, the type of fault and the duration of the fault. The detection device 6 may also comprise means for transmitting memorized fault information to a control station or a device for monitoring/controlling the electrical network 1.
Such a device 6 may also be integrated in a unit for monitoring all or part 4, 4′ of the electrical network 1, in particular in a protection relay 8 that is capable of controlling the opening of the contacts of the circuit breaker 5, or may be directly implanted in a circuit breaker so as to be able to quickly open the line 4 of the electrical network 1 in the event of a fault.
Among these faults, the most common are single-phase faults, of short circuit type, that are located outside the source substation, in which one phase is in contact with ground, or an overhead cable breaks, especially in the event of bad weather. However, high capacitance values 9 may occur for example between the line conductors 4 and ground that result in large homopolar currents I0 flowing in the event of a ground fault 10.
The homopolar current I0 is zero in the absence of faults. The term “homopolar current” I0 (or “zero sequence current”) is understood to be, to a potential factor of close to three, the vector sum of the various phase currents, or even the current corresponding to the instantaneous resultant of the phase currents, sometimes called residual current, that potentially corresponds to the ground fault current or to the leakage current. It should be noted that it is possible to escape this situation, in particular with a non-zero homopolar current/voltage, and the network may comprise another number of phases; additionally, the neutral regime does not have to be compensated.
To detect the occurrence of a fault in an electrical network, it is known practice to measure, using sensors, at least one signal S that is representative of the current flowing in the portion of the network to be tested. This representative signal S may, for example, be the voltage between one of the phases and ground, the voltage between two phases, the current flowing in one of the phases or the current of the set of phases. In the absence of faults, the signal S is a sinusoidal signal of nominal amplitude A0 and nominal frequency f0, corresponding to the nominal frequency of the current flowing in the electrical network, e.g. 50 Hz or 60 Hz.
In the presented embodiment, to detect a fault 10 in the line 4, the detection device 6 comprises an acquisition module comprising a sensor that allows an analogue signal S that is representative of the current flowing in the line 4 to be acquired, such as, for example, a current sensor 14 or a voltage sensor 12.
The acquisition module is configured to obtain at least three samples S1, S2, S3 of the representative signal S, the acquisition of each signal being spaced apart by a fixed sampling time T. That is to say, as indicated in
For the requirements of the invention, the sampling time T must correspond to a sampling frequency F that is more than or equal to three times the nominal frequency f0 of the signal S, thereby giving a sampling time T<=6.66 ms for a nominal frequency of 50 Hz of the electrical network 1.
Preferably, in order to accelerate the detection of a fault and to be capable of detecting extremely brief transient faults, a sampling frequency F that is equal to 1800 Hz is chosen, i.e. a sampling time T of 0.556 ms.
The acquisition module also comprises means, such as an analogue filter, for filtering the measurements carried out by the sensors 12 or 14, as well as sampling means allowing the signal S that is sampled to be obtained with the desired sampling time.
The detection device next comprises a calculation module that receives the successive samples originating from the acquisition module. The calculation module comprises storage means for memorizing various received samples of the signal S. These storage means allow at least three samples S1, S2, S3 to be memorized, or allow samples of the signal S to be stored in a sliding manner for a longer duration.
According to the invention, the calculation module determines the amplitude A of the signal S simply on the basis of the values S1, S2, S3. The sinusoidal signal S is of the form:
S(t)=A·sin(2·π·f·t+φ), where A represents the amplitude, f the frequency and φ the angular phase. Consequently, the three successive measurements S1, S2, S3 being spaced apart by T, it may be stated that:
S
1
=S(t1)=S(t2−T)=A×sin(2·π·f·(t2−T)+φ)
S
2
=S(t2)=A×sin(2·π·f·t2+φ)
S
31
=S(t3)=S(t2+T)=A×sin(2·π·f·(t2+T)+φ)
Giving:
By means of a change of origin in order to carry out the abstraction of the angular phase φ and the introduction of the angular frequency ω=2·π·f, we get:
S
1
=A×cos(ω·t2−2·π·f·T)
S
2
=A×cos(ω·t2)
S
3
=A×cos(ω·t2+2·π·f·T)
The trigonometric properties of the sine function then allow the following equation to be obtained:
We therefore get:
It is thereby shown that the calculation of the amplitude A depends only on three successive measured values, S1, S2, S3, without involving the frequency of the signal S or the sampling time T, without requiring previously calculated prior amplitude values to be known and without needing to mathematically model the system. The calculation method according to the invention is therefore advantageously non-recursive and non-iterative. Being independent of the sampling time T largely simplifies the calculation of the amplitude A. Moreover, when this sampling time depends on the real frequency of the signal, the sampling time must be re-calculated based on this real frequency to obtain the amplitude.
Thus, by assuming that the detection device measures a fourth sample S4 at an instant t4 that is equal to t2+2T, then the calculation module will directly re-calculate a new amplitude value A based only on the samples S2, S3, S4, without using the sample S1 or previously calculated amplitude values.
One of the points of interest of this method is therefore to be able to very quickly determine the amplitude of the signal S with only three samples, in contrast to approaches that generally require at least one network period in order to estimate this amplitude, and in contrast to iterative approaches that require a non-negligible time to converge towards an exact value and to refine the calculation of the amplitude. Thus, for example after restarting the electrical network following an interruption of the network, the “on the fly” resumption of the process is quickly achieved as soon as the three samples are measured, without having to pass through a convergence phase that generates inertia.
To more quickly and simply determine the amplitude A from the signal S based on the formula above, the calculation module may favour an approach based on finite expansions of the sine and arccosine trigonometric functions, or even of the square root function, thereby avoiding the requirement for overly large calculation means. Depending on the desired precision, the chosen sampling frequency and the specifications of the microprocessor that is integrated in the calculation module, the polynomial used in the finite expansions will be of the first to the fourth order. For example, a second-order finite expansion for a sampling frequency of 1800 Hz is used.
The detection device 6 next comprises a fault determination module that is capable of triggering a fault if the amplitude A calculated by the calculation module is above a first predetermined threshold M+, called the upper threshold (corresponding, for example, to an overcurrent) or if the calculated amplitude (A) is below a second predetermined threshold M−, called the lower threshold (corresponding, for example, to an undervoltage, or to a flicker type effect etc.). Preferably, the thresholds are centred on the nominal amplitude A0 of the network.
The upper threshold may be set on the basis of the nominal amplitude A0 to which a first margin or a first percentage of the nominal amplitude A0 is added, and the lower threshold may be set on the basis of the nominal amplitude A0 from which a second margin or a second percentage of the nominal amplitude A0 is taken. For example, standard NF EN50-160 considers a MV (Medium Voltage) voltage to be functioning normally at −10%/+10% of its nominal value and a LV (Low Voltage) voltage to be functioning normally at −15%/+10% of its nominal value; beyond these permissible bands there is a malfunction.
Advantageously, the fault determination module may also memorize the type and the duration of a fault, in particular for being able to distinguish between permanent faults (not removed by the restart cycle of the network) and transient faults (removed before the end of this restart cycle).
While the index k is smaller than 3, meaning that three successive samples are yet to be acquired, the detection method is not capable of detecting a fault and therefore forces the calculated amplitude A to the nominal value A0, for example, of the signal S. Conversely, as soon as k is greater than or equal to 3, then the amplitude Ak is calculated as being a function of the three last successive samples Sk-2, Sk-1, Sk, according to the algorithm described above.
Next, the detection method memorizes the value of the sample Sk in the storage means of the detection device and incrementally increases the index k at each sampling time T before carrying out a new cycle, with the measurement of a new sample Sk and a new calculation of the amplitude Ak. Thus, the calculation of the amplitude is regularly updated at each sampling time T.
Then, to determine the presence of a fault, the detection method passes through a determination step in which it is detected whether the calculated amplitude Ak is above the first predetermined threshold M+ or whether the calculated amplitude Ak is below the second predetermined threshold M− in order to determine whether the amplitude Ak is within a permissible band.
Optionally, in order to avoid dividing by a number too close to zero, which could cause calculation errors, the detection method makes provision for carrying out a test on the value of the median sample, namely Sk-1 if the three samples are Sk-2, Sk-1, Sk (or S2 if the samples are S1, S2, S3), as the value of the median sample is used as the denominator in the proposed formula. Hence if the absolute value of the median sample Sk-1 is below or equal to a minimum threshold ε, then the amplitude Ak is not calculated but remains equal to the preceding calculated value Ak-1. For example, the minimum threshold E is of the order of 0.2% of the nominal value A0 of the signal S.
The graph of
The graphs of
In
The invention also covers an electrical unit comprising such a protection device, in such a way as to be able to interrupt the electrical network in the event of a fault. Specifically, the protection device of the invention may be implanted in various types of unit, such as, for example, a protection relay, a circuit breaker or switch or a remote monitoring/control station.
In a unit, the protection device described in the invention may also potentially be combined with another device that monitors, for example, the frequency of the current flowing in the electrical network, in such a way that the decision-making takes into account the overall set of results obtained by the various devices.
For monitoring a polyphase, e.g. three-phase, electrical network, an electrical unit preferably comprises a protection device for each of the three phases.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
15 55458 | Jun 2015 | FR | national |