The present invention relates to a method for measuring the weight applied to the ground by at least one vehicle axle.
The present invention also relates to a device for measuring the weight applied to the ground by at least one vehicle axle.
The increasing power of commercial road vehicles allows vehicles which are increasingly heavily loaded to travel on the road network in an apparently normal way. This results in an increasing stress on the road infrastructure, and a risk of accelerated ageing or even breakage of certain pieces of equipment. Bridges are particularly exposed to this type of risk.
The authorities currently carry out checks by installing, for example in a parking area, a weighbridge onto which vehicles which the traffic police have intercepted from among the traffic may be driven at very low speed. This method produces precise results but setting it up for a series of inspections is tiresome. For a road haulier, the chances of being stopped while travelling with an excess load are extremely small. Therefore the protection of the road infrastructure is not ensured.
It has also been envisaged to install special carriageway elements which would be sensitive to the stress resulting from the passage of an axle. Even if vehicles were slowed down, the results obtained would be extremely imprecise because the complex deformation of a carriageway element is converted by strain gauges into a signal in the form of a dome which is very difficult to interpret in terms of applied load.
The object of the invention is to propose a method and/or a device which makes it considerably easier to check the weight of road vehicles, and if appropriate implement appropriate measures if an authorized limit is exceeded.
According to a first aspect of the invention, the method for measuring the weight applied to the ground by at least one vehicle axle is characterized by the step of detecting the sudden variation experienced by a vertical dimension of a structure of a bridge beneath an end bearing line embodied by one end of a floor of the bridge when the axle crosses said end bearing line when travelling along the road.
When a vehicle axle passes the first bearing line of a bridge, the weight that the axle applies to the ground is suddenly transferred from an essentially rigid and fixed solid body to a floor of the bridge. When the axle crosses the last bearing line, the weight that it applies to the ground is suddenly transferred from a floor (the same as before or another one) to an essentially rigid and fixed solid body.
The notion of “end bearing lines” must thus be understood as describing the two horizontal transverse lines of the carriageway between which the weight applied by the axles is transferred to the structure of the bridge, which can be deformed relative to the solid bodies between which the bridge extends.
According to the invention, there is taken advantage of the sudden dimensional variation experienced by the subjacent structure at the end of the floor of the bridge when a vehicle axle comes to rest on this end corresponding to the first bearing line of the bridge, or, in the other direction of traffic, when a vehicle axle removes the load from the floor of the bridge when it passes the last bearing line of the bridge.
It was found according to the invention that a remarkably clear display of the load represented by the axle in question was thus available. The floor serves as a means of direct transmission between the axle and the infrastructure supporting the end of the floor. According to the invention, a dimensional variation is directly converted into a measurement of applied load. This differs from the prior art where it was wished to measure a distribution of stress in space and time in order to try to deduce an applied load value from same.
The method according to the invention does not call for vehicles to be slowed down. It can therefore be in constant operation. Consequently, if for example the presence of the measuring system is announced before the bridge, the bridge will probably no longer or practically no longer be crossed by vehicles which are overloaded and/or which exceed the tonnage limit authorized for traffic on the bridge in question.
In order to detect the sudden variation in vertical dimension, a variation in vertical dimension of a bearing interposed between the floor of the bridge and a bridge abutment supporting said end of the floor is preferably detected.
A variation in vertical dimension of a bridge support, in particular a ridge abutment, supporting the end of the floor can also be detected.
When the bearings are of a relatively flexible type, for example of neoprene, the sensitivity can be sufficient if only the variation in vertical dimension of the bearing is detected. On the other hand, in the case of relatively rigid bearings, such as those made of metal, the reduction in height of the bearing when an axle passes over, even when heavily loaded, can be very small. Thus according to the invention it is preferred to detect the variation in vertical dimension along the height of the bridge support, for example over several metres of height beneath the floor. The detection can include at the same time the bearing and some of the height of the bridge supporting such as the abutment.
The method is particularly advantageous if, in order to detect the dimensional variation, a detection method is used with instantaneous appearance and transmission, without dead time, of a detection signal between the detection site at the end of the floor and the processing site. Such a detection method is preferably of the type using the alteration of an optical signal. Optical fibre detectors which make use of the particular property of optical fibres of attenuating transmitted light when they are stretched are envisaged in particular. EP-B 0264 622 describes such a detector which can measure a variation in distance between two points separated by for example several metres. EP-B 0649 000 describes such a detector which is very robust with regard to fatigue stress and capable of detecting very small variations in dimension between two points which can be relatively close, transforming the variations in dimension into bending variations of the optical fibre.
In this type of detector, a constant light power is applied to one end of the fibre and the light power received at the other end constitutes an input signal indicating in real time and without a delay the variations in dimension experienced by the detector.
Thus, according to the invention, the end of the floor immediately and directly experiences the load variation due to the passage of an axle over the first or the last corresponding bearing line, and the immediate dimensional variation which results from it is immediately converted into an input signal for a process of developing measurement signals and/or appropriate control signals and action, in particular when the authorized limits are exceeded. Moreover this absence of dead time between the event and its consequence in terms of detection automatically eliminates the influence of the spurious effects, in particular those which are due to any deformation of the floor and its inertia.
Thus recordings can be made which very precisely relate the variations in dimension experienced by the bridge at said end on the one hand to the time scale on the other hand. It is also provided according to the invention to make a video recording of the vehicular traffic on said end of the bridge, with a time scale using the same clock as the one associated with the above-mentioned recording of the variations in dimension. It is therefore possible, in cases of doubt or a dispute, to ascertain which vehicle caused a determined series of sudden variations in dimension, and to determine whether, during this period, a particular phenomenon was able to disturb the measurement.
In particular when the floor rests on the support by at least two bearings, it is advantageous to detect the dimensional variation at at least two different points of the width of the end of the floor, each point preferably being adjacent to one of the bearings.
Particularly preferably, the dimensional variation is detected by connecting a deflectometer to each bearing of the end of the floor.
For a carriageway with two traffic lanes, the distribution of the dimensional variation on one and the other bearing indicates in which lane the vehicle whose axle is producing the dimensional variation is travelling. This distribution can be used to distinguish between two vehicles travelling more or less side-by-side. An axle of a determined vehicle produces a simultaneous variation on the two bearings but with a distribution which is characteristic of the lane along which this axle is travelling,
The weight applied by the axle can very easily be calculated according to the elastic rigidity of each bearing and the vertical deformation of each bearing. In practice, calibration curves or correspondence laws are preferably used which give the applied load as a function of the detection signal generated by the corresponding vertical deformation of the bearing. Such correspondence laws are established before the device is commissioned. In particular they allow account to be taken of the dynamic effects which can cause the deformation experienced by a bearing during the passage of a moving axle to be greater or smaller than the deformation which would be due to an equal, but immobile, weight on the end of the floor. They also allow account to be taken of any hyperstatic properties of the floor on its bearings.
Different correspondence laws can be provided for different passage speeds. In this case, the method provides for an evaluation of the speed of travel of the axle that produced the sudden dimensional variation. The speed can be assessed from the interval which separates the successive sudden dimensional variations caused by the passage of a vehicle, or by a speed-measuring device, using for example the Doppler effect, placed above the carriageway, or from the slope of the dimensional variation from the high level of the jump corresponding to the sudden dimensional variation which is considered to correspond to the passage of an axle. During the sudden dimensional variation, the high level corresponds to the presence of the axle on the floor and the low level to its absence. From the high level, the axle moves from the end towards the centre of the floor and the stress on the bearing diminishes at a rate (slope of the chronogram of the deformation detection signal) which is a function of the speed at which the vehicle is moving. In the other direction of travel, the stress increases until the axle reaches the end of the floor (last bearing line), at which point the stress due to this axle suddenly disappears.
According to the speed determined for the vehicle, or speed range in which the speed of the vehicle is situated, the appropriate correspondence law is chosen to relate a measured axle weight to a detected sudden dimensional variation.
In some cases, the real correspondence law between the sudden dimensional variation and the axle weight can shift over time. For example, neoprene bearings can become less elastic. It can also happen that the carriageway join between the end of the floor and the carriageway on solid ground deteriorates over time, which can modify the dynamic effect during the passage of the axle. The response curve of the detectors can itself shift over time. It is provided according to the invention to keep, preferably automatically, at least one set of statistics on the weight evaluations carried out. If for example the average recorded weight differs from a pre-determined reference variable by more than a pre-determined value, it is deduced that a recalibration is necessary. Such a recalibration can be carried out automatically as a function of the recorded difference and the direction of this difference.
In a preferred version of the method according to the invention, the series of dimensional variations which are caused by the successive axles of the same vehicle is identified.
The total weight of a vehicle can thus be calculated by adding together the weights applied to the ground by its different axles.
According to a second aspect of the invention, the device for measuring the weight applied to the ground by at least one vehicle axle is characterized in that it comprises:
Other features and advantages of the invention will emerge from the description below, which relates to non-limitative examples.
In the attached drawings:
In the example shown in
At each end of its length, the floor 1 rests by means of two bearings 2 on a shoulder 3 of the bridge abutment. The end of the floor 1 which is crossed first (
Beyond the ends of the floor 1, the carriageway 9p of the floor 1 continues as a carriageway 9av before the bridge and as a carriageway 9ap after the bridge, the carriageways 9av, 9p and 9ap together constituting “the carriageway 9”.
According to the invention, a respective detector has been installed between the under-surface of the floor 1 and the shoulder 3, along each bearing 2. More particularly the detector associated with the bearing 2d is numbered 11d, and the detector associated with the bearing 2g is numbered 11g (
In the variant represented in
The device according to the invention comprises a processing unit 14 comprising inputs 16 for receiving the signals coming from the detectors such as 11d, 11g, and one or more outputs 17 connected to a video screen 18 displaying measurements, to a camera with a flashlight 19 for photographing vehicles breaking the law, or the like, such as audible or visual alarms, automatic closure of a barrier, etc.
The processing unit 14 comprises means for developing, from the signals received at the inputs 16, one or more signals at the output 17 which are representative of the weights transmitted to the carriageway by the vehicles crossing the end of the bridge.
The time-point when the wheels of the front axle 21 of the vehicle 6d have crossed the first bearing line and come to rest on the floor 1 is called t1. It is presumed that before time-point t1 the recorded compression was mil, i.e. there is taken as the origin of the deformations the state of compression of the bearing 2 of the floor 1 under the weight of the floor 1 when there is no vehicle on the floor 1.
When the axle 21 comes to rest this causes a sudden dimensional variation designated BV1. In theory, this variation in deformation is equal to:
Q·PB21/K
in this expression:
Q is a factor, between 0 and 1, representing the fraction of the weight of the axle which bears on the bearing considered;
PB21 is the weight of the vehicle which is transmitted to the ground by the axle 21; and
K is the elastic constant of the bearing 2 considered.
If the variations in deformation of the two bearings 2d and 2g are measured at the same time, these two deformations can be added together and the total deformation can then be considered equal to:
PB21/K
Knowing K on the one hand, and on the other hand the correspondence law between the levels at the signal and the levels of deformation of the bearings, this formula allows direct determination of the weight PB21 in a theoretical way.
The above calculations presume that the floor 1 rests isostatically on the two bearings 2d and 2g. Moreover their use requires, in most cases, calibrations relating to the value of K for the two bearings 2d and 2g and relating to the response of each of the two detectors 11d and 11g to a given dimensional variation. Moreover, the calculation is accurate only if the value of K is the same for the two bearings, and if the dynamic effects are negligible.
This is why it is preferred, according to the invention, to undertake a prior calibration in order to establish at least one correspondence law between each axle weight and the detection signals which take account of the corresponding deformations on the two bearings, when the vehicle is in the right-hand lane and when the vehicle is in the left-hand lane. In other words, according to the invention, it is preferred to pass directly from the detection signals, for example a variation in the restituted light power, to an evaluation of weight, without necessarily seeking to learn either the real deformation or especially the corresponding real stress.
It is also preferred according to the invention to establish a different correspondence law for each of several speed ranges at which the vehicle crosses the end of the floor 1.
Thus, either in a more or less theoretical way or preferably on the basis of a prior calibration, the amplitude of the sudden variation BV1 of the signal allows evaluation of a weight transmitted to the ground by the front axle 21 of the vehicle.
Then, as is shown in
At time-point t2, the rear axle 22 of the lorry of the lorry-trailer combination 6d comes in turn to rest on the end of the floor 1 and this results in a fresh sudden variation BV2 (
The signal thus collected for the whole vehicle comprises as characteristic elements, independent for example of the vehicle speed, the number of sudden variations, the respective amplitude of each of the sudden variations and their relative spacings parallel to the time axis of the chronogram. This set of characteristics of the signal generated by the passage of the vehicle is called a vehicle signature. This signature allows identification of the type of vehicle and consequently allows reference to be made to the maximum authorized gross vehicle weight for this type of vehicle.
Moreover, as is shown in
It is provided according to the invention that the processing unit 14 which has recorded the vehicle's signature when it enters the floor 1 (
If for example one of the two measurements has been disturbed by the simultaneous presence of another vehicle, for example if an axle of one of the vehicles has crossed one of the end bearing lines of the bridge at exactly the same time as an axle of the other vehicle, the signature of a vehicle with n axles is then constituted by the n-1 sudden variations which are not disturbed. For the n-th axle, that measurement of the two which is not disturbed is used.
The analysis of this succession of signals allows determination of the time intervals corresponding to the series T6d, T26d, T35d, during which sudden variations occur with a time difference “e” between them which is variable but which never exceeds a relatively small determined value. The processing device interprets each period during which sudden variations occur separated by such small time intervals as corresponding to the period of crossing of the same vehicle, respectively. Between these periods, the processing device detects longer intervals of time E corresponding to spaces between vehicles. According to the evaluation of the speed of travel of the vehicles, obtained for example from the slope of the progressively variable parts VP of each series of signals, or by a measuring device working above the carriageway, the processing unit chooses a duration threshold between successive sudden variations beyond which it considers that there are two separate vehicles. And in particular this threshold is given a value which decreases when the speed of travel increases. Thus, the maximum distance between two successive axles considered as belonging to the same vehicle can be made constant and independent of the speed of travel of the vehicles.
When the speed of travel decreases and reaches very low values (in the case of a traffic jam), it is common for the vehicles to follow each other very closely and the distance between the last axle of a vehicle and the first axle of the one following it can even become smaller than the maximum possible distance between two successive axles of the same vehicle. In this case, it is necessary to either not measure the total weight of each vehicle, and measure only its weight applied to the ground for each axle, or to use other means to distinguish the sudden variations which can be associated with each vehicle. It is also possible that even when the speed of travel is higher the progressively variable parts VP of the signal are too distorted to allow an evaluation of the speed overall.
In order to remedy all of this, according to the invention means for detection of presence are proposed which have a field of action above the carriageway 9.
To this end, in
The means for distinguishing between two vehicles travelling side-by-side will now be described with reference to
In
In a step 41, the presence of a sudden variation in the signals arriving via the inputs 16 is detected.
The step 42 involves ascertaining whether the sudden variation detected is stronger on the bearing 2d or on the bearing 2g, in order to determine the traffic lane used by the vehicle whose axle has produced the sudden variation (step 43).
In a step 44, the speed of travel of the vehicle is determined, for example by a device, using the Doppler effect, which has a field of action above the carriageway.
In step 46 the weight applied by the axle is determined by selecting from a memory 47 for the correspondence laws the law corresponding to the speed evaluated in step 44. The weight applied by an axle travelling in the left-hand lane is called PEg and the weight applied by an axle travelling in the right-hand lane is called PEd. The determination takes into account the two signals dd and dg. The two loads corresponding to the two sudden variations respectively can for example be added together if there is a correspondence law for each bearing. By way of a variant, for each speed range there can be a single, but more complex correspondence law, giving a weight for each combination of two sudden-variation values on the two detectors.
In step 48, the evaluated weight PEd or PEg is communicated so that it is displayed on the screen 18 of
In step 49, a test determines whether the weight calculated for the axle exceeds a pre-determined limit PELIM. If it does, an “alarm/action” step is carried out consisting for example of triggering the picture-taking apparatus 19. If it does not, or after step 51 if it does, a step 52 adds the axle weight PEg or PEd to the value of a parameter PTg or PTd respectively representative of the total weight of the vehicle which is crossing the end of the floor.
Then, a test 53 determines whether the axle whose weight has just been evaluated is the last axle of the vehicle. For this, one of the methods described above is used. If it is not, return to step 41 to wait for the following axle.
If, on the other hand, the axle which has just been measured is the last of the vehicle, proceed to a step 54 to communicate the total weight PTg or PTd of the vehicle, for example for display on the screen 18.
A step 56 calculates the new average (M(PT)) of the total weights of the vehicles which have crossed the bridge for example in the last three months.
A test 57 checks whether the new average differs, compared with a reference variable C by an amount that is larger than or equal to a pre-determined value Ec. If it does, the conclusion is that there has probably been a shifting of the device and a step of self-calibration 58 is initiated which modifies the correspondence laws contained in the memory 47. In addition, join the negative output of the test 57 and proceed to another test 59 which checks whether the total weight PTg or PTd exceeds a total-weight limit PTLIM authorized on the bridge. If it does, an “alarm/action” step 62 is carried out, consisting for example of an activation of the picture-taking apparatus 19. If the weight limit PTLIM is not exceeded, or after step 61 if it is exceeded, the parameter PTg or PTd is set equal to zero; return to step 41 to wait for the following sudden variation.
Of course, the invention is not limited to the examples described and represented.
For example, the speed of travel of the vehicles could be evaluated from the period between two sudden variations belonging to the same variation series. In the software, if the vehicle speed is determined by the analysis of particular properties of the series of dimensional variations, the development of the measurement must be slightly delayed relative to the acquisition of the detection signal.
Generally, the invention can be credited with having discovered that the end of the floor of a bridge can serve as a means for direct transmission of the vertical stresses between a vehicle axle and a load-bearing structure which the invention uses as a dynamometer. Within the meaning of a bridge, the invention also covers structures constituted by a very short floor installed on bearings above a hollowed-out part of the subjacent infrastructure with the sole objective of measuring the weight of travelling vehicles. It is also within the scope of the invention to mount the device on a structure of the bridge type situated in front of a more fragile structure in order that overloaded vehicles can be intercepted before reaching the more fragile structure. It is also within the scope of the invention to fit a device according to the invention to several structures situated on various possible routes between two sites in order to prevent overloaded vehicles from making detours to avoid a thus-fitted bridge.
Within the meaning of the invention, the measurement of weight can consist of a single binary signal the low level of which corresponds to a weight which conforms to the regulations and the high level to a weight exceeding an authorized limit.