Method and device for range imaging

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 9363484
  • Patent Number
    9,363,484
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, August 21, 2013
    11 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 7, 2016
    8 years ago
Abstract
A method for range imaging allows determining respective distances to multiple objects, based on a single image. The image is captured through a component having a transmittance function of which the Fourier transform is inscribed on a circle within a plane of spatial frequencies. A Fourier transform of the captured image is calculated in order to obtain a total spectrum for the image content. The distance to each object is then calculated based on several homothetic superimpositions of a reference spectrum with the total spectrum, so that said reference spectrum coincides with a portion of the total spectrum each time.
Description
RELATED APPLICATIONS

This invention claims priority to French patent application No. FR 12/02273, filed Aug. 22, 2012, the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference.


FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The invention relates to a method and device for range imaging.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

There are many applications which require not only detecting objects within a field of view, but also determining the distance to each detected object. Such applications include power line detection to ensure the safety of moving helicopters, runway light detection to assist jets during landing, etc. Outside of stereographic imaging methods, the usual optical imaging methods do not allow rapid and precise determination of the distance to objects captured in an image.


Stereographic imaging requires capturing at least two images of the same object from different angles of view. This requirement leads to the following difficulties:

    • at least two image capture devices must be installed in parallel, with precisely defined positions relative to each other;
    • the images must be captured at the same moment if the captured object is moving; and
    • image correlation software is required for comparing the positions of the same object in the images captured separately by the two devices.


Planar optical components are known, in which the transmittances vary as a function of two coordinates inside the plane of each component, and have two-dimensional Fourier transforms which consist of peaks located on a circle of a determined radius. Such components are said to be continuously self-imaging and are described in the article entitled “Exact solutions for nondiffracting beams. I. The scalar theory,” J. Durnin, Journal of the Optical Society of America A, Vol. 4, pp. 651-654, 1987, and in the article which defines continuously self-imaging gratings and which is entitled “Generation of achromatic and propagation-invariant spot array by use of continuously self-imaging gratings,” N. Guérineau et al., Optics Letter, Vol. 26, pp. 411-413, 2001.


In addition, the presentation by Piponnier et al. which is entitled “Analysis and development of non-diffracting arrays for the design of advanced imaging systems,” Journées scientifiques de l'Ecole Doctorale Ondes & Matiéres (EDOM), 7-8 Mar. 2011, proposes associating such a continuously self-imaging component with an image sensor for applications involving detection, identification, or accurate location determination for simple objects.


An object of the present invention is therefore to propose a new method of range imaging which does not have the disadvantages cited above for the stereographic methods.


In particular, one object of the invention is to determine the respective distances to multiple objects contained within a field of view, based on a single image captured.


Another object of the invention is to determine simply the distances to the objects without requiring significant computational capacity.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

To this end, the invention proposes a method which comprises the following steps:

    • /1/ obtaining a planar optical component having a transmittance t which varies as a function of two coordinates in a plane of the component, and which has a two-dimensional Fourier transform T consisting of peaks located on a base circle of radius ρ;
    • /2/ arranging the component perpendicular to an optical axis Z which is oriented towards the field of view;
    • /3/ arranging an image sensor in a plane perpendicular to the axis Z, at a distance df from the component and on the side of the component which is opposite the field of view;
    • /4/ using the sensor to capture an image formed by light originating from the objects through the component; and
    • /5/ calculating a Fourier transform of the captured image, in order to obtain a spectrum Stot of spatial frequencies corresponding to peaks of the Fourier transform of the captured image, this spectrum for the captured image comprising multiple concentric components which are each inscribed in a respective circle.


According to the properties of the transmittance t of the optical component which are indicated in step /1/, this component is continuously self-imaging.


The method of the invention is characterized in that, in step /1/, the Fourier transform T of the transmittance t of the component consists of a finite number N of peaks which are distributed on the base circle having radius ρ. In addition, the method comprises the following additional steps, which are performed after step /5/:

    • /6/ providing a reference spectrum Sref, which corresponds to peaks of a Fourier transform of a reference image as produced by a point light source located at infinite distance away on axis Z, through the component onto the sensor, this reference spectrum Sref consisting of reference spatial frequencies and being inscribed in the reference circle of radius 2ρ, equal to twice the radius of the base circle;
    • /7/ in a common reference system, concentrically superimposing the spectrum of spatial frequencies of the captured image Stot and the reference spectrum Sref;
    • /8/ digitally transforming, by a homothety centered in the common reference system, the reference spectrum Sref inscribed in the reference circle of radius 2ρ into a transformed reference spectrum Si which is inscribed in a circle of variable radius 2ρ, by varying a homothety ratio Hi which is equal to 2ρi/2ρ;
    • /9/ storing the homothety ratio Hi, when all the peaks of the transformed reference spectrum Si are superimposed with peaks of the spectrum of the captured image Stot, the transformed reference spectrum Si then coinciding with one of the components of the spectrum of the captured image Stot; and
    • /10/ calculating the distance to one of the objects in the field of view, using the formula di=d/(Hi−1).


The sequence of steps /8/ to /10/ is then repeated until it is no longer possible to perform step /9/ with a new value for the homothety ratio Hi that is different from the previously stored values. Each distance di obtained during one of the executions of step /10/ then corresponds to one of the objects contained in the field of view.


Thus, in the method of the invention, the image capture step /4/ is only executed once for determining the respective distances of multiple objects. The distances which are determined relate to one same moment of time, the moment when the image is captured, with no need to take into account a possible movement of the imaging device. The invention therefore allows a simple calculation of the distances to multiple objects, as these distances are at the same moment of time.


Because of the linearity of the Fourier transform, the Fourier transform of the image of multiple objects which is calculated in step /5/ is identical to the sum of the respective Fourier transforms which would each be produced by only one of the objects.


Due to the fact that the Fourier transform T of the transmittance t of the component consists of a finite number N of peaks which are distributed over the base circle, the spatial frequency spectrum which is produced by an object present in the field of view has gaps. These gaps allow distinguishing the respective contributions of the objects in the spectrum Stot of the captured image, in step /9/, and then individually calculating the distance to each object in step /10/.


It is possible to supplement the method by counting the objects present in the field of view, distinguished from each other by their distances. To this purpose, the iterations of the sequence of steps /8/ to /10/ which produce different values for the homothety ratio Hi are counted, and the number n of objects contained in the field of view is determined as being equal to the number of these iterations.


In preferred implementations of the invention, the component may be a periodic continuously self-imaging grating. In this case, the peaks of the Fourier transform T of the transmittance t of the component are located simultaneously on a periodic grating and on the reference circle of radius ρ. This facilitates the search for coincidence performed in step /9/, between the spatial frequencies of the reference spectrum Sref and at least a portion of the spectrum Stot of the image which has been captured. It is then easier to determine with precision the respective distances to multiple objects which may be close to each other within the field of view.


The invention also proposes a range imaging device which comprises:

    • the planar optical component, possibly of the periodic continuously self-imaging grating type;
    • the image sensor, which is arranged parallel to and at a distance df from the component, on the side of the component that is opposite the field of view, with the optical axis Z perpendicular to the component and to the sensor;
    • a storage unit, which is adapted for storing an image captured by the sensor, and for storing the reference spectrum Sref; and
    • a computation unit, which is adapted for executing steps /7/ to /10/ of a method as described above, repeating the sequence of steps /8/ to /10/ as long as a new value for the homothety ratio Hi is obtained in step /9/.


In the device of the invention, the component is adapted so that the Fourier transform T of its transmittance t consists of a number N of peaks distributed on the base circle of radius ρ, the number N being finite or limited.


It is possible for the component to be a phase grating. It can then be designed and implemented more easily using manufacturing methods which are available and well understood.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Other features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following description of some non-limiting examples, with reference to the attached drawings, in which:



FIG. 1 schematically represents a range imaging device according to the invention;



FIG. 2 is a chart of the properties and the steps involved during a use of the device of FIG. 1;



FIGS. 3a to 3c show three examples of transmittance which can alternatively be used for the device of FIG. 1, and FIGS. 4a to 4c show the associated Fourier transforms;



FIG. 5a shows yet another example of transmittance which can be used for the device of FIG. 1, and FIG. 5b shows the associated reference spectrum;



FIG. 6a shows an image captured by the device of FIG. 1 when the transmittance of FIGS. 5a and 5b is used, and FIG. 6b shows the associated full spectrum; and



FIG. 7 is a diagram summarizing the steps executed during a use of the device of FIG. 1.





For clarity, the dimensions of the elements represented in these figures do not correspond to actual dimensions nor to actual ratios between dimensions. In addition, when same references are used in different figures they indicate identical elements or elements with identical functions.


In FIG. 1, the references indicated have the following significance:



1 planar optical component,



101 image sensor,



102 unit for storing an image captured by the sensor 101, denoted MEM,



103 computation unit denoted CPU, which is adapted for processing image data stored in the unit 102,


Z optical axis of the imaging device, perpendicular to the component 1 and to the sensor 2,


df distance between the component 1 and the sensor 2, measured parallel to axis Z,



100 field of view extending around axis Z,


O1-O4 objects contained within the field of view 100, producing or reflecting light to the sensor 101 through the component 1,


O1 light-emitting object located on axis Z within the field of view 100, at a finite distance from the component 1,


O2 light-emitting object located on axis Z within the field of view 100, at a distance from the component 1 which can be considered as infinite,



2 planar wave originating from object O2 and reaching the sensor 101 through the component 1,



3 resultant wave produced by the component 1 from the planar wave 2,


d1 distance between object O1 and the component 1, measured parallel to axis Z, and



9 spherical wave originating from object O1 and reaching the sensor 101 through the component 1.


DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The electromagnetic radiation originating from each of the objects O1-O4 may be monochromatic or may consist of any number of radiations at respective distinct wavelengths. It may be within any of the wavelength ranges used for optically detecting or observing objects, particularly far infrared, mid infrared, near infrared, visible, etc. The sensor 101 is then selected accordingly, as a function of its frequency range of sensitivity. In addition, the radiation from the objects O1-O4 may be spatially coherent or incoherent.


The component 1 is translucent within an opening which may be rectangular in a plane perpendicular to the axis Z, and denoted by two Cartesian axes x and y inside this plane. The sensor 101 may consist of an array of photosensitive elements which are aligned parallel to the axes x and y.


Inside the opening of the component 1, the transmission from the component, denoted t, is a function of the two coordinates x and y: t(x, y). The Fourier transform of the transmittance t(x, y) relative to the two coordinates x and y is denoted T(σx, σy). Thus, σx is the spatial frequency corresponding to the x coordinate, and σy is the spatial frequency corresponding to the y coordinate. For the invention, the component 1 is selected such that the function T(σx, σy) consists of a finite number N of peaks which are all located on a given circle in the plane of spatial frequencies identified by the axes of σx and σy. This circle is called base circle and is centered on the point of origin of the two axes of spatial frequencies σx and σy, and its radius is denoted ρ.


In practice, the function T(σx, σy) is first selected, then the transmittance function t(x, y) is calculated by reverse Fourier transform. The component 1 can then be manufactured by locally adjusting its transmittance at each point inside its opening. Such an adjustment may be performed by digitally modulating an amount of irradiation which is successively focused at each point on a grid in the opening of the component 1, when a film of appropriate photosensitive material is placed in this opening. A person skilled in the art will understand that the peaks of the function T(σx, σy) are not infinitely thin, but have a width which depends on the dimensions of the opening in the component 1.


Due to the fact that the function T(σx, σy) consists of peaks which are located on the base circle with radius ρ and center σxy=0, the radiation 3 which results from the plane wave 2 after passing through the component 1 has an intensity distribution which is translation-invariant parallel to axis Z. This intensity is proportional to the square of the transmittance modulus t(x, y): |t(x, y)|2, in any plane perpendicular to axis Z between the component 1 and the detector 101.


This intensity distribution is the one produced by the light-emitting object O2 in a plane parallel to the component 1. It is denoted 4 in the chart in FIG. 2, and is called reference image. It is formed on the sensor 101. The decomposition 5 of this reference image by Fourier transformation produces a series of N′ peaks which are respectively located at value pairs for the spatial frequencies σx and σy, N′ being a non-zero whole number. The set of these value pairs for the spatial frequencies σx and σy then constitutes a reference pattern, which is called the reference spectrum and is denoted Sref. Through the properties of Fourier transformation, the reference spectrum Sref is the autocorrelation of the Fourier transform T(σx, σy) of the transmittance t(x, y) (property 6 of FIG. 2). It is inscribed in a circle of radius fc=2ρ and of center σxy=0, referred to as reference circle. In the present invention, the circle in which a spectrum is inscribed, or the circle circumscribing the spectrum, is the smallest circle which contains all peaks of this spectrum, with certain peaks possibly being located on the circle itself.


Preferably, the component 1 may additionally be a periodic grating. Its transmittance function t(x, y) then consists of a base two-dimensional pattern which is repeated in order to fill the opening of the component 1. This base pattern may be of any shape that can be used to tile the opening of the component 1. In this case of periodic grating, the peaks of the Fourier transform T(σx, σy) are additionally located on at least some of the nodes of a periodic grid in the plane of the spatial frequencies σx and σy. FIG. 3a shows a first example of base pattern, which is square in shape with sides of length ao. The horizontal and vertical sides of the base pattern may respectively be parallel to the axes x and y. FIG. 4a shows the Fourier transform T(σx, σy) which is associated with the transmittance t(x, y) of FIG. 3a. The horizontal and vertical directions of FIG. 4a are those of the axes of the spatial frequencies σx and σy. This Fourier transform is composed of 16 peaks associated with distinct orders of diffraction, which are located both on the nodes of a grid of spacing 1/a0 due to the periodic grating nature of the component 1, and on the base circle due to the continuously self-imaging nature of the component 1. In this example, the radius ρ of the base circle is equal to 651/2/a0.



FIGS. 3b and 4b respectively correspond to FIGS. 3a and 4a, for another square base pattern of the transmittance t(x, y). The Fourier transform T(σx, σy) is again composed of 16 orders of diffraction for which the peaks are located at some nodes in a grid of spacing 1/a0. But these diffraction peaks are now located on a base circle which has the radius ρ=1451/2/a0, with an angular distribution in the plane of spatial frequencies σx and σy which is different from FIG. 4a.



FIGS. 3c and 4c also respectively correspond to FIGS. 3a and 4a, for yet another square base pattern of the transmittance t(x, y). The Fourier transform T(σx, σy) is then composed of 24 diffraction peaks which are again located at some nodes in a grid of spacing 1/a0, but while simultaneously belonging to the base circle having the radius ρ=3251/2/a0.


One should keep in mind that although the Fourier transform T(σx, σy) is composed of a finite number of orders of diffraction which are angularly separated in the case where the component 1 is constituted by a periodic grating, these orders combine spatially so that the light intensity distribution between the component 1 and the sensor 101 remains translation-invariant parallel to axis Z.



FIG. 5a again corresponds to FIG. 3a in another example of a base pattern of the transmittance t(x, y), when the component 1 is again a periodic grating with square tiling. FIG. 5b shows the positions of the peaks of the Fourier transform (FT) of the function which consists of the square of the transmittance modulus t(x, y): FT|t(x, y)|2x, σy) in the plane of spatial frequencies σx (horizontal direction in FIG. 5b) and σy (vertical direction in FIG. 5b): this is the reference spectrum for the component 1 where the transmittance t(x, y) has the pattern of FIG. 5a.


Independently, for the spherical incident wave 9 originating from the object O1 located at the finite distance d1 on axis Z, the intensity 10 (FIG. 2) which is propagated downstream from the component 1 is continuously homothetic to itself along axis Z, between the component 1 and the sensor 101. The intensity distribution which is thus produced in the plane of the sensor 101, meaning at the fixed distance df downstream from the component 1 in a plane which is perpendicular to axis Z, is called a dilated image. This dilated image results from a homothety 11 which is applied to the reference image with a homothety ratio H1 of 1+df/d1. The decomposition 12 of the dilated image into spatial frequencies, by Fourier transformation for the two coordinates x and y, produces a set of peaks which are located at a set of value pairs for the spatial frequencies σx and σy, called dilated spectrum Sdil. This dilated spectrum Sdil consists of N′ peaks which have the same relative distribution in the plane of spatial frequencies as the N′ peaks of the reference spectrum Sref. The peaks of the dilated spectrum are located within a circle of radius fc′=2ρ/H (property 13 in FIG. 2).


When n distinct objects 14, n being an integer greater than one, for example the three objects O1, O3 and O4, simultaneously produce light through the component 1 to the sensor 101, the total image Itot in the plane of the sensor is the sum 15 of the images Ii which are respectively produced by all the objects i, i being equal to 1, 3 or 4 in the example represented. However, the Fourier transformation is a linear mathematical operation 16. As a result, the total spectrum Stot of the entire image Itot produced by the n objects together is the sum 17 of the spectra Si which would be respectively and separately produced by all the objects i. In other words, each spectrum Si is a component of the total spectrum Stot.


Given that:


7: the Fourier transform T(σx, σy) of the transmittance t(x, y) consists of a finite number N of peaks which are distributed on the base circle of radius ρ;


8: the reference spectrum Sref consists of a set of N′ peaks inscribed within the reference circle of radius 2ρ; and


18: the spectra Si are discrete and inscribed in respective circles of different radii fci′,


the spectra Si which are produced separately by all the objects i located on axis Z are separate within the plane of spatial frequencies σx and σy.


The invention therefore proposes an algorithm 19 for detecting the n objects and determining their respective distances di. Based on the measurement of the radius fci′ which is individually associated with each object i in the plane of the spatial frequencies σx and σy, the radius fc being known a priori, the homothety ratio Hi is equal to the quotient fc/fci′ for the object i concerned. Lastly (step 20 in FIG. 2), the distance to each object i is obtained individually by the relation di=df/(Hi−1).


Thus (step 21 of FIG. 2), the method of the invention allows detecting multiple objects which are located at different distances away within the field of view, from a single image capture. It then allows clearly separating, in the plane of the spatial frequencies, the respective contributions to the total image which are produced by the different objects, then calculating the distance to each object. The technical problem of providing a range imaging device without any moving element is therefore solved.



FIG. 6a shows a total image Itot which has been captured by the sensor 101 for three objects simultaneously located near axis Z, when the component 1 corresponds to FIGS. 5a and 5b. The three objects are, for example, O1, O3 and O4 of FIG. 1. The white arrows indicate the positions of these three objects, where O1 is on axis Z and O3 and O4 are offset relative to axis Z (zero offset is at the center of the figure). FIG. 6b shows the Fourier transform of the total image Itot of FIG. 6a, with respect to both coordinates x and y. It consists of three sets of peaks which are inscribed in circles of distinct radii 2ρi, with the index i equal to 1, 3 or 4 identifying the circles respectively corresponding to the three objects O1, O3 and O4. The greater the radius 2ρi of the circle in the plane of the spatial frequencies σx and σy, the further away the corresponding object i is from the component 1.


With reference to the diagram of FIG. 7 and to FIGS. 5a, 5b, 6a and 6b, the use of the range imaging device of FIG. 1 comprises the following steps:


Step S1: inserting the component 1 which has the transmittance function t(x, y) of FIG. 5a, into the device of FIG. 1;


Step S4: capturing the image of FIG. 6a, referred to as the total image Itot;


Step S5: calculating the Fourier transform of the image of FIG. 6a, producing the total spectrum Stot of FIG. 6b;


Step S7: superimposing the reference spectrum Sref of FIG. 5b onto the total spectrum Stot of FIG. 6b, using the same central point of coordinates σx=0 and σy=0 for the two spectra;


Step S8: in the superposition, homothetically varying the reference spectrum Sref within the plane of the spatial frequencies σx and σy, so that the radius of circumscribed circle becomes equal to the radius 2ρi of the circumscribed circle for one of the component spectra Si of the total spectrum Stot;


Step S9: identifying the homothety ratio Hi for which the transformation of the initial radius 2ρ of the circumscribed circle for the reference spectrum Sref becomes equal to the radius 2ρi of the circumscribed circle for spectrum Si; then


Step S10: based on the value of the homothety ratio Hi, calculating the distance di to the object i which produced the spectrum Si.


Steps S8 to S10 are repeated for each spectrum Si which can be distinguished with a distinct radius within the total spectrum Stot.


Lastly, in the next step S11 which is optional, the number of repetitions of the sequence of steps S8 to S10 corresponds to the number of distinct isolated objects which are present in the field of view 100 and which are sending light through the component 1 to the sensor 101.


An object which is contained in the field of view 100 can extend for a non-zero length parallel to the optical axis Z. In this case, the sequence of steps S8 to S10 can be repeated for any values of the homothety ratio H which are within a continuous interval between two limit values. The length of this interval provides the length of the object along axis Z by means of the formula d=df/(H−1), where d is the distance to a current point of the object relative to the component 1.

Claims
  • 1. A method for range imaging, for determining respective distances to multiple objects contained within a field of view, based on a single captured image, the method comprising the following steps: /1/ obtaining a planar optical component having a transmittance t, said transmittance varying as a function of two coordinates (x, y) in a plane of the component, and having a two-dimensional Fourier transform T consisting of a finite number N of peaks located on a base circle of a radius ρ∞;/2/ arranging the component perpendicularly to an optical axis Z oriented towards the field of view;/3/ arranging an image sensor in a plane perpendicular to the axis Z, at a distance df from the component and on the side of said component which is opposite the field of view;/4/ using the sensor to capture an image formed by light originating from the objects through the component; and/5/ calculating a Fourier transform of the captured image, in order to obtain a spectrum Stot of spatial frequencies corresponding to peaks of the Fourier transform of the captured image, said spectrum for the captured image comprising multiple concentric components which are each inscribed in a respective circle;/6/ providing a reference spectrum Sref, corresponding to peaks of a Fourier transform of a reference image as produced by a point light source located at infinite distance away on axis Z, through the component onto the sensor, said reference spectrum Sref consisting of reference spatial frequencies and being inscribed in a reference circle of a radius 2ρ∞, equal to twice the radius of the base circle;/7/ in a common reference system, concentrically superimposing the spectrum of spatial frequencies of the captured image Stot and the reference spectrum Sref;/8/ digitally transforming, by a homothety centered in the common reference system, the reference spectrum Sref inscribed in the reference circle of radius 2ρ∞, into a transformed reference spectrum Si inscribed in a circle of variable radius 2ρi, by varying a ratio Hi of said homothety which is equal to 2ρi/2ρ∞;/9/ storing the homothety ratio Hi, when all the peaks of the transformed reference spectrum Si are superimposed with peaks of the spectrum of the captured image Stot, the transformed reference spectrum Si then coinciding with one of the components of the spectrum of the captured image Stot; and/10/ calculating the distance to one of the objects in the field of view, using the formula di=d/(Hi−1); then
  • 2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the iterations of the sequence of steps /8/ to /10/ are counted, and the number n of objects contained in the field of view is determined as being equal to the number of said iterations.
  • 3. The method according to claim 1, wherein the component is a periodic continuously self-imaging grating.
  • 4. A device for range imaging, comprising: a planar optical component having a transmittance t, said transmittance varying as a function of two coordinates (x, y) in a plane of the component, and having a two-dimensional Fourier transform T consisting of peaks located on a base circle of radius ρ∞;an image sensor, arranged parallel to and at a distance df from the component, on the side of said component that is opposite the field of view, with an optical axis Z perpendicular to the component and to the sensor;a storage unit adapted for storing an image captured by the sensor, and for storing a reference spectrum Sref corresponding to peaks of a Fourier transform of a reference image as produced by a point light source located at infinite distance away on axis Z, said reference spectrum Sref consisting of reference spatial frequencies and inscribed in a reference circle of radius 2ρ∞, equal to twice the radius of the base circle; anda computation unit adapted for executing steps /7/ to /10/ of a method according to claim 1, repeating the sequence of steps /8/ to /10/ as long as a new value for the homothety ratio Hi is obtained in step /9/;
  • 5. The device according to claim 4, wherein the component is a periodic continuously self-imaging grating.
  • 6. The device according to claim 5, wherein the component is a phase grating.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
12 02273 Aug 2012 FR national
US Referenced Citations (6)
Number Name Date Kind
3832029 Bryngdahl Aug 1974 A
20040037355 Allie Feb 2004 A1
20080137059 Piestun et al. Jun 2008 A1
20090316240 Hara Dec 2009 A1
20100310130 Beghuin Dec 2010 A1
20120057023 Yang Mar 2012 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (7)
Number Date Country
2309718 Apr 2011 EP
9602009 Jan 1996 WO
2007106657 Sep 2007 WO
2007115281 Oct 2007 WO
2009019362 Feb 2009 WO
2009106996 Sep 2009 WO
2010080030 Jul 2010 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (6)
Entry
INPI (Institut National de la Propriete Industrielle), Preliminary Search Report issued Apr. 10, 2013, in corresponding French patent application No. 1202273, filed Aug. 22, 2012.
Montgomery, W. Duane, Self-Imaging Objects of Infinite Aperture, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Jun. 1967, pp. 772-778, vol. 57, No. 6, Arlington, Virginia.
Park, Jae-Hyeung and Jeong, Kyeong-Min, Frequency Domain Depth Filtering of Integral Imaging, Optics Express, Sep. 12, 2011, vol. 19, No. 19, pp. 18729-18741.
Durnin, J., Exact Solutions for Nondiffracting Beams. I. The Scalar Theory, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Apr. 1987, vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 651-654.
Guerineau, N., et al., Generation of Achromatic and Propagation-Invariant Spot Arrays by Use of Continuously Self-Imaging Gratings, Optics Letters, Apr. 1, 2001, vol. 26, No. 7, pp. 411-413.
Piponnier, Martin, Etude et developpment de tableaux non diffractants pour la conception de systemes imageurs avances, Journees Scientifiques de I'Ecole doctorale Ondes et Matieres (EDOM), Mar. 2011.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20140055606 A1 Feb 2014 US