The present disclosure relates to a method and devices for controlling a flow control system in a Heating, Ventilating and Air Conditioning (HVAC) system. Specifically, the present disclosure relates to a method and a control device for controlling a flow control system in an HVAC system, and a flow control system for the HVAC system with an actuated valve for adjusting the flow of fluid in the HVAC system.
By regulating the flow of fluid through a thermal energy exchanger of an HVAC system, it is possible to adjust the amount of energy exchanged by the thermal energy exchanger, e.g. to adjust the energy transfer rate of a thermal energy exchanger to heat or cool a room in a building. While the fluid transport through the fluid circuit of the HVAC system is driven by one or more pumps, the flow (i.e. the flow of fluid or the flow rate) is typically regulated by varying the orifice (opening) or position of valves, e.g. manually or by way of actuators. It is known that the efficiency of thermal energy exchangers, e.g. heat exchangers, is reduced at high flow rates where the fluid rushes at an increased rate through the thermal energy exchangers, without resulting in a significant increase in energy exchange.
WO 2012/065275, in the name of the applicant, describes a method and a control device for controlling the opening of a valve in an HVAC system to regulate the flow of fluid through a thermal energy exchanger and thereby adjust the amount of thermal energy exchanged by the thermal energy exchanger. The opening of the valve is controlled depending on an energy-per-flow gradient which is determined by measuring at consecutive points in time the flow through the valve and the amounts of thermal energy exchanged by the thermal energy exchanger at these points in time. The energy-per-flow gradient is determined dynamically and is used as a basis for setting a slope threshold for the thermal energy exchanger so that there is no need to store fixed threshold values.
WO 2020/114668, in the name of the applicant, describes a method and a control system for controlling the orifice of a valve in an HVAC system to regulate the flow of a through a thermal energy exchanger and thereby adjust the energy transfer rate of the thermal energy exchanger. In a first mode of operation, the flow of fluid through the thermal energy exchanger is controlled within efficiency constraints on the energy transfer rate with respect to an efficiency threshold value. Upon receiving an override signal, the orifice of the valve is controlled in a second mode of operation where the flow of fluid through the thermal energy exchanger is not controlled with respect to the first efficiency threshold value.
Nevertheless, thermal energy exchangers, particularly heat exchangers, exhibit nonlinear transfer characteristics, indicated by a nonlinear relationship between flow and transferred thermal energy or power, respectively.
In connection with pressure dependent valves, typically, (mechanical) control valves with equal percentage inherent valve characteristics are used, as the equal percentage characteristics of the valve are approximately inverse to typical transfer characteristics of thermal energy exchangers, and the combination of the valve characteristics and transfer characteristics produces at least approximately linear combined characteristics.
In connection with (electronic) pressure independent valves, where fluctuations of flow caused by pressure variances are controlled with a feedback flow control loop, the nonlinearity of the transfer characteristics of thermal energy exchangers is accounted for at least to some extent by way of setpoint conditioning. Setpoint conditioning adjusts the flow setpoint, e.g. provided by a building automation system or an air temperature controller, inverse to the transfer characteristics of the thermal energy exchanger.
However, both known solutions, using control valves with equal percentage inherent valve characteristics and setpoint conditioning, provide merely an approximation of an overall linear performance, because the actual transfer characteristics of thermal energy exchangers, as installed in an HVAC system, are not precisely known and change in a dynamic HVAC system. Furthermore, using linear feedback flow controllers, such as PI (D) controllers (Proportional, Integral, Derivative), with fixed control parameters, for controlling actuated valves to adjust the flow through a thermal energy exchanger, fail to provide consistent control performance over the entire operating range of the actuated valves and thermal energy exchangers.
It is an object of the present disclosure to provide a method and a control device for controlling a flow control system in an HVAC system, and a flow control system for an HVAC system, which method, control device, and control system do not have at least some of the disadvantages of the prior art. In particular, it is an object of the present disclosure to provide the method, the control device, and the flow control system for an improved control of the flow of fluid in the HVAC system.
According to the present disclosure, these objects are achieved through the features of the independent claims. In addition, further advantageous embodiments follow from the dependent claims and the description.
A flow control system in an HVAC system comprises an actuated valve for adjusting the flow of fluid in a fluid transport circuit of the HVAC system.
According to the present disclosure, the above-mentioned objects are particularly achieved in that in a method for controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system, an electronic circuit performs the following steps: receiving and storing, during operation of the flow control system, a plurality of flow values measured in the fluid transport circuit by a flow sensor for respective valve positions of the actuated valve; determining, during operation of the flow control system, installed valve characteristics of the actuated valve as installed in the HVAC system, using the plurality of flow values for the respective valve positions; and controlling the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit, using the installed valve characteristics.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit further receives a flow setpoint, determines a feedforward control value from the flow setpoint and the installed valve characteristics, and uses the feedforward control value to control the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit. For example, the electronic circuit determines the feedforward control value using the inverse installed valve characteristics.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit further determines a feedback control value from the flow setpoint and a current flow value measured in the fluid transport circuit by the flow sensor, and further uses the feedback control value to control the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit further determines a feedback control value from a flow setpoint, using a current flow value measured in the fluid transport circuit by the flow sensor and the installed valve characteristics, and uses the feedback control value to control the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the feedforward control value and the feedback control value, and uses the feedforward control value and the feedback control value, to control the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit adjusts control parameters to determine the feedback control value with reduced responsiveness in a lower operating range of the actuated valve.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit adjusts control parameters to determine the feedback control value depending on a rate of change of the flow setpoint. For example, the electronic circuit adjusts the control parameters with reduced responsiveness for a high rate of change of the flow setpoint, above an upper change rate threshold; and/or adjusts control parameters to determine the feedback control value with increased responsiveness for a low rate of change of the flow setpoint, below a lower change rate threshold.
In an embodiment, to determine the feedback control value, the electronic circuit adjusts the control parameters based on the installed valve characteristics.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the installed valve characteristics to indicate for any particular valve position, in an operating range of the actuated valve, the flow of fluid at that particular valve position of the actuated valve for a particular differential pressure over the fluid transport circuit and/or normalized for any differential pressure over the fluid transport circuit.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the installed valve characteristics for a complete operating range of the actuated valve, from a minimum valve position, particularly a fully closed valve position, to a maximum valve position, particularly a fully open valve position. Typically, in the minimum valve position, there is no flow.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the installed valve characteristics by iteratively adjusting parameters of a mathematical approximation function which defines the installed valve characteristics, using the plurality of flow values for the respective valve positions.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the installed valve characteristics by fitting a mathematical approximation function to the plurality of flow values for the respective valve positions over a complete operating range of the actuated valve and/or over a partial operating range of the actuated valve around a current operating point.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines an estimated current differential pressure over the fluid transport circuit, using the installed valve characteristics and temporal changes of the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit; and generates an output signal indicative of the estimated current differential pressure.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit stores a first set of the plurality of flow values and respective valve positions of the actuated valve, measured when the respective valve positions are attained by the actuated valve in a process of reducing the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit; stores a second set of the plurality of flow values and respective valve positions of the actuated valve, measured when the respective valve positions are attained by the actuated valve in a process of increasing the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit; determines, during operation of the flow control system first installed valve characteristics, using the first set of the plurality of flow values, second installed valve characteristics, using the second set of the plurality of flow values, and/or intermediate installed valve characteristics, using the first set of the plurality of flow values and the second set of the plurality of flow values; and controls the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit, using the first installed valve characteristics, the second installed valve characteristics, and/or the intermediate installed valve characteristics.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit receives a temperature value, and uses the temperature value for determining a flow setpoint for the flow control system providing through the fluid transport circuit the flow of fluid to a thermal energy exchanger.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit determines the installed valve characteristics using inherent valve characteristics of the actuated valve.
In addition to the method of controlling a flow control system in an HVAC system, the present disclosure also relates to a control device for controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system. The control device comprises an electronic circuit configured to perform the method of controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system.
In addition to the method of controlling a flow control system in an HVAC system, and the control device for controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system, the present disclosure also relates to a flow control system for an HVAC system. The flow control system comprises an actuated valve configured to adjust a flow of fluid in a fluid transport circuit of the HVAC system, a flow sensor configured to measure a flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit, and an electronic circuit configured to perform the following steps: receiving and storing, during operation of the flow control system in the HVAC system, a plurality of flow values measured in the fluid transport circuit by the flow sensor for respective valve positions of the actuated valve; determining, during operation of the flow control system in the HVAC system, installed valve characteristics of the actuated valve as installed in the HVAC system, using the plurality of flow values for the respective valve positions; and controlling the actuated valve to adjust the flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit, using the installed valve characteristics.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit is further configured to perform the method of controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system.
In addition to the method of controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system, the control device for controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system, and the flow control system for the HVAC system, the present disclosure also relates to a computer program product. The computer program product comprises a non-transient computer readable medium having stored thereon computer program code configured to control a processor of a flow control system in an HVAC system, such that the processor performs the method of controlling the flow control system in the HVAC system.
The present disclosure will be explained in more detail, by way of example, with reference to the drawings in which:
In
The present disclosure is directed particularly to controlling the flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10. In a two-circuit installation, where a primary fluid circuit 11 is coupled via a thermal energy exchanger X to a secondary fluid circuit 12, the fluid transport circuit 10 is part of the primary fluid circuit 11.
As illustrated in
There is a distinction between inherent valve characteristics and installed valve characteristics of a valve. The inherent valve characteristics of a valve define the relationship between valve position and flow of fluid ϕ at a constant differential pressure over the valve. The inherent valve characteristics of a valve are typically published by the manufacturer of the valve and are based on tests performed in a test system where the differential pressure across the valve is held constant at all valve positions and flow rates, i.e. the flow of fluid ϕ measured for the respective valve position. The installed valve characteristics of a valve define the relationship between valve position and flow of fluid ϕ in the actual, specific HVAC system 1, where the valve is installed. Thus, the installed valve characteristics take into account any changes in the differential pressure across the valve which are caused by piping pressure losses, for example. These piping pressure losses include various pressure losses caused by components in the fluid transport circuit 10 of the HVAC system which are fluidly connected to the valve V. These components include, for example, pipes, fittings, heat exchangers, chillers, filters, and/or other valves etc.
As illustrated in
In any case, the control device 2 is configured to transfer control signals to the electric motor via a wired or wireless communication link. Furthermore, the control device 2 is configured to receive from the electric motor operational data via the communication link.
As illustrated in
As is further illustrated in
In the following paragraphs, described with reference to
In
As illustrated in
In step S1, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 receives or obtains a measurement of the current flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10, as indicated by reference numeral m. The electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 further determines the current valve position of the actuated valve V, more specifically, the valve position for which the current flow of fluid ϕ was measured. Depending on the embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 has recorded and stored the valve position, as previously commanded to the actuated valve V, or the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 receives or obtains the current valve position from the actuated valve V or its electric motor, respectively. Depending on the embodiment and/or configuration, the valve position is determined directly at the valve V, e.g. using a potentiometer and/or an encoder, derived from the motor position or angle, e.g. by counting motor rotations and considering the gear ratio, or by merely using the position setpoint for the valve V or its motor, respectively.
As illustrated in
In step S2, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 stores the measured flow of fluid ϕ linked to the valve position for which the flow was measured. In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 further stores a time stamp and/or a sequence number linked to the performance data, which includes the recorded flow and valve position. As the measurement process M is ongoing or at least periodically repeated, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 thus determines and records a temporal course of measured flow and respective valve positions.
As illustrated in
In step S3, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses the performance data measured and recorded by the measurement process M to determine the actual installed valve characteristics of the actuated valve V. More specifically, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 determines the actual installed valve characteristics of the actuated valve V from the plurality of stored sets of performance data, each set including a data point with the measured flow of fluid ϕ and respective valve position for which the flow of fluid ϕ was measured.
Depending on the embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 determines the installed valve characteristics of the actuated valve V by learning the entire curve ƒ of the installed valve characteristics or uses the known inherent valve characteristics of the actuated valve V and learns the valve authority and the differential pressure across the fluid transport circuit 10. Alternatively, instead of the valve authority, determined is the flow rate coefficient (or corresponding pressure loss coefficient) of the fluid transport circuit 10, without the valve V.
As illustrated schematically in the examples of
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 fits the mathematical approximation function ƒ to the data points D with the measured flows of fluid ϕ and respective valve positions by iteratively adjusting parameters c1 . . . cn of the mathematical approximation function ƒ. For example, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses a measure to determine how well the mathematical approximation function ƒ fits the plurality of data points D with the measured flows of fluid ϕ and respective valve positions, and determines the function parameters c1 . . . cn and thus the mathematical approximation function ƒ by minimizing the measure J with an optimization algorithm. In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 determines the function parameters c1 . . . cn iteratively, for example, by executing the optimization algorithm repeatedly in defined iteration intervals.
Typically, for a valve V with inherent equal percentage valve characteristics, the curve of the installed valve characteristics has an S-shaped form. Accordingly, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses a mathematical approximation function ƒ (x, c1, . . . , cn) which captures the S-shaped form, whereby x is the valve position and c1 . . . cn are the parameters of the mathematical approximation function ƒ. The person skilled in the art will understand, that for a valve with an inherent linear valve characteristic, the curve of the installed valve characteristics has the shape of a line bent upwards (referred to as a quick opening curve).
Below, functions ƒ1, ƒ2, and ƒ3 are given as different examples of the function ƒ (x, c1, . . . , cn):
whereby x is the relative valve position and ci (i=1 . . . n) are the function parameters.
Below, an example of the measure J of fit is indicated:
Furthermore, nlocal indicates the number of measurements around the current operation point, nglobal is the number of measurements distributed over the complete operating range, Wlocal indicates the weighting of local measurements, Wglobal indicates the weighting of global measurements, {dot over (V)}meas(i) is the measured flow of fluid ϕ, and xmeas(i) is the respective valve position recorded.
Depending on the embodiment, the installed valve characteristics are determined such that they indicate for any particular valve position, in an operating range of the actuated valve V, the flow of fluid ϕ at that particular valve position of the actuated valve V for a particular differential pressure over the fluid transport circuit 10 (or the primary fluid circuit 11, respectively) or normalized for any differential pressure over the fluid transport circuit 10 (or the primary fluid circuit 11, respectively).
In an embodiment, the installed valve characteristics are determined by taking into account the hysteresis of the actuated valve V that is exhibited when the actuated valve V, and correspondingly its motor, is operated in different directions, i.e. upon change of its operating direction. In the opening direction, the orifice of the valve is increased to increase the flow of fluid ϕ. In the opposite closing direction, the orifice of the valve is decreased to reduce the flow of fluid ϕ. For the purpose of considering hysteresis, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 stores two different sets of data points with the measured flow of fluid ϕ and respective valve position, one set of data points measured when the actuated valve V is operated in the opening direction, when the actuated valve V is in the process of increasing the flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10; and another set of data points measured when the actuated valve V is operated in the closing direction, when the actuated valve V is in the process of decreasing the flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10. Depending on the embodiment and/or configuration, during operation O of the flow control system 3, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 determines two different installed valve characteristics for the actuated valve V, one for the opening direction, using the set of data points measured for the opening direction, and another one for the closing direction, using the set of data points measured for the closing direction, and/or an intermediate installed valve characteristics, using both sets of data points. Alternatively, the hysteresis is determined separately, e.g. by measuring the opening position (when the valve is operated in opening direction) and the closing position (when the valve is operated in closing direction) at a fixed flow rate, e.g. 5% flow. The intermediate characteristic is then “shifted” by this learned hysteresis.
As illustrated in
The desired flow of fluid in the fluid transport circuit 10 is determined by a flow setpoint r. Depending on the application and configuration, the flow setpoint r is determined by a building control system, a room controller, a thermostat, or the like, arranged at the control device 2 or external to the control device 2.
As illustrated in
Using the flow setpoint r, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 generates a control value or control signal c for the actuated valve V. More specifically, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses the determined installed valve characteristics to generate the control value or control signal c for the actuated valve V to adjust the flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10 to obtain the desired flow of fluid defined by the flow setpoint r. As illustrated in
As illustrated in
As further illustrated schematically in
As illustrated in
In a gain-scheduled controller architecture, the controller gains are “scheduled” with one or more scheduling variables, such as a measured output or a system state. Gain scheduling makes it possible, to design controllers for nonlinear controlled systems based on linear system theory. This may be achieved by linearizing a nonlinear plant model at different operating conditions to obtain linear models that describe plant behaviour in the vicinity of the operating point that a linear model corresponds to. Different controller gains may be determined for the linear plant models.
In an embodiment the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses the measured flow value m and the determined installed valve characteristics to implement gain scheduling. That means that the controller gain is scheduled with the measured flow value m.
In another embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses the current valve position x and the determined installed valve characteristics to implement gain scheduling.
In a particular embodiment the gain of an I-controller is be changed in dependence of the local slope of the determined installed valve characteristic f(x), in order to guarantee a stable controller behaviour over the entire operating range. Here the controller parameter is chosen to be inversely proportional to the local slope of the installed flow characteristic which may be obtained by deriving the valve characteristic f(x) with respect to the valve position x.
In another adaptive control method, the determined installed valve characteristic is used to directly compensate for non-linearities of the flow control system. This is achieved by applying the inverse function of the determined installed valve characteristic to the controller output signal to obtain a corrected valve position setpoint. Alternatively, the inverse function is applied to the measured flow value.
As illustrated in
In the case that the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 implements both the feedback control block B and the feedforward control block F, in step S43, the control value or control signal c for the actuated valve V is generated by the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 using the feedforward control value w and the feedback control value b. More specifically, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 generates the control value or control signal c for the actuated valve Vas a sum of the feedforward control value w and the feedback control value b.
Otherwise, in the case that the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 implements only one of the control blocks, the feedback control block B or the feedforward control block W, in step S43, the control value or control signal c for the actuated valve V is generated by the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 using only the feedforward control value w or the feedback control value b, respectively.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 adjusts control parameters of the feedback control block B to determine the feedback control value b in step S42 with reduced responsiveness in a lower operating range and/or with increased responsiveness in a higher operating range of the actuated valve V. The person skilled in the art will understand that the term “responsiveness” indicates the response characteristics of the feedback control block B to react to deviations of the measured flow value m from the flow setpoint r, as indicated by the error value e. With a reduced responsiveness in the lower operating range, the feedback control block B reacts more slowly to deviations when the actuated valve V operates in a lower operating range. The lower operating range of the actuated valve may be defined by a lower range of valve position, as determined by position threshold values and/or position boundary functions, and/or by low flow values, as determined by flow threshold values and/or flow boundary functions. Thereby, the responsiveness is implemented as a function which depends on valve position and/or flow.
In a further embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 adjusts control parameters of the feedback control block B to determine the feedback control value b in step S42 with reduced responsiveness for a high rate of change of the flow setpoint r, i.e. for great changes of the flow setpoint r, e.g. indicated by exceeding an upper change rate threshold, as defined by an upper threshold value or an upper threshold function. Furthermore, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 adjusts control parameters of the feedback control block B to determine the feedback control value b in step S42 with increased responsiveness for a low rate of change of the flow setpoint, i.e. for small changes of the flow setpoint r, e.g. indicated by remaining below a lower change rate threshold, as defined by a lower threshold value or a lower threshold function. Thus, the responsiveness changes as a function of the rate of change of the flow setpoint. For example, the function is implemented as a linear dependency, as a fixed threshold, or as another (nonlinear) dependency. In combination with the feedforward control block W, the reduced responsiveness of the feedback control block B for a high rate of change of the flow setpoint r has the advantage that for great changes of the flow setpoint r control of adjusting the flow of fluid is significantly left (passed) to the feedforward control block W. This has the advantage that the overall control system, i.e. the flow control system (inner control loop) and an overlaying temperature control system (outer control loop), becomes more stable, because the flow control system performs like a pure steering mechanism and, therefore, avoids problems caused by conflicting cascaded control loops. On the other hand, the increased responsiveness of the feedback control block B for a low rate of change of the flow setpoint r has the advantage that for small changes of the flow setpoint r when deviations of the measured flow value m from the flow setpoint r, as indicated by the error value e, is foremost caused by pressure changes, control of adjusting the flow of fluid is significantly left (passed) to the feedback control block B, such that deviations caused by pressure changes are compensated more quickly under the control of the feedback control block B.
In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 uses the plurality of data points D to determine temporal changes of the flow of fluid ϕ in the fluid transport circuit 10. By discerning rapid changes of the flow of fluid ϕ, caused by pressure changes, from comparatively slower changes of the flow of fluid ϕ along the installed valve characteristics, caused by changing the valve position, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 determines an estimated differential pressure Δp over the fluid transport circuit 10. Effectively, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 further augments approximating the installed valve characteristics ƒ(x) with the differential pressure Δp, i. e. {tilde over (ƒ)}(x)=ƒ(x)·{circle around (Δp)}. The differential pressure Δp is learned simultaneously with the other function parameters. Flow control can be further improved by accounting for changes in differential pressure Δp. In an embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 generates an output signal, e.g. on display, which indicates the estimated current differential pressure Δp.
In a further embodiment, the electronic circuit 20 of the control device 2 receives an air temperature value t from the air temperature sensor T. As outlined above, the temperature value t measured and provided by the air temperature sensor T indicates the current air temperature associated with the secondary fluid circuit 12, for example, the air temperature at the exit port of the thermal energy exchanger X, as illustrated in
It should be noted that, in the description, the sequence of the steps has been presented in a specific order, one skilled in the art will understand, however, that the computer program code may be structured differently and that the order of at least some of the steps could be altered, without deviating from the scope of the invention.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| CH000304/2022 | Mar 2022 | CH | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/EP2023/056145 | 3/10/2023 | WO |