The present invention is generally related to a positioning system and position sensing. More specifically, the present invention relates to a hybrid positioning method and system for combining high-precision positioning technology, e.g. ultrasound (US) positioning, with low-precision positioning technology, e.g. radio frequency (RF) positioning to provide adaptive positioning resolution for location-based services.
Undoubtedly, location information is a fundamental context to be utilized to extract the geographical relationship between the users and the environments to further understand the user behaviors. The importance and promise of location-aware applications has led to the design and implementation of systems for providing location information, particularly in indoor and urban environments. Currently, there is an increasing market need for accurately tracking of people and assets in real time, in many different application scenarios including office, healthcare, coalmine, subway, smart building, restaurant etc. For instance, in office environment, employees are required to access confidential information database in certain secure zone. Out of the secure zone, any access will be prohibited. The examples of the secure zone can be a single room, part of working area, and even a table.
So far, many positioning systems have been developed to provide location-based services. However, there are some common limitations to the existing positioning systems.
Firstly, from technology perspective, most of positioning system focuses on utilizing a single type positioning device, either US-based or RF-based device for object locating. In fact, each signal type has its own advantages but some shortcomings. For example, US-based localization can achieve high accuracy but small scale, and on the other hand, RF-based approach provides large scale but low accuracy.
Secondly, from application perspective, for example, location-based access control, it is usually the case that people may require different positioning resolutions at different regions. At the interested area, fine-grained positioning granularity is needed so as to make sure that the positioning results in this area are highly accurate. At the other areas, a coarser-grained positioning granularity may be acceptable.
Below will give a brief introduction of the existing popular technologies for indoor positioning. The first point to be noted here is that Global Positioning System (GPS) can provide the object's location information with the accuracy of several ten meters outdoors, however, in indoor environment GPS does not work well since the positioning result of GPS degrades dramatically by multi-path effect and signal obstruction.
In general, there are three technologies commonly used for indoor positioning systems, i.e. ultrasound (US) positioning, radio frequency (RF) positioning and infrared positioning.
For example, in “Bat” system of U.S. Pat. No. 6,493,649 to Jones entitled “Detection system for determining positional and other information about objects”, the user can wear a small badge containing a US transmitter, which emits an ultrasonic pulse when radio-triggered by a central system. The diagram of the “Bat” system is for example shown in
The structural block diagram of such US positioning system as the “Bat” system is shown in
In another article to P. Bahl. etc. entitled “An In-Building RF-based User Location and Tracking System” (In Proc. IEEE INFOCOM, 2000), it is provided a “RADAR” system for positioning an object based on received signal strength of 802.11 wireless network. The basic RADAR location method is performed in two phases. First, in an off-line phase, the system is calibrated and a RF model is constructed, which indicates received signal strengths at a finite number of locations distributed in the target area. Second, during on-line operation in the target area, mobile units report the signal strengths received from each base station and the system determines the best match between the on-line observations and any point in the on-line model. The location of the best matching point is reported as the location estimate.
Moreover, in U.S. Pat. No. 6,216,087 to R. Want entitled “Infrared Beacon Position System”, it is provided a infrared based location system, called “Active badge” system. The system is built over bidirectional infrared link where one infrared beacon is deployed in each room and the mobile unit is a small, lightweight infrared transceiver that broadcast an unique ID every a fixed interval. Since infrared signals can hardly penetrate walls, ID broadcasts are easily contained within an office, providing highly accurate localization at room granularity.
The above-mentioned patent and non-patent documents are combined in their entireties herein by reference for any purpose.
The following Table. 1 shows a detailed comparison between the three signals when used for indoor location applications, i.e. ultrasound signal, radio frequency signal and infrared signal. For purposes of convenience, to make the comparison, we selected the current representative systems for the three signals respectively, i.e., “Active Badge” for Infrared, “RADAR” for RF and “Bat” for Ultrasound.
From the Table.1 we can basically conclude that infrared based location systems is rarely used due to low accuracy and vulnerability to natural light; and that RF systems which use signal strength to estimate location can not yield satisfactory results because RF propagation within buildings deviates heavily from empirical mathematical models.
Regarding US-based Bat system, it is awkward to deploy such a networked system into practical scenario, needing high installation and maintenance costs. In particular, since at least three distance samples are needed to estimate the object's position, very dense ultrasound sensors need to be deployed into building so that system cost is high. On the other hand, Although US positioning approach can achieve highly accuracy, high density of US positioning devices will cause high deployment cost. Especially, it is not necessary to deploy US positioning device at general area where a meter-level location resolution is good enough.
In summary, any existing positioning methods as described above cannot work cost-effectively to achieve high-precision and high-efficiency positioning in an environment where different positioning resolution is required at different regions.
Based on the above analysis, the present invention is made to solve the deficiencies of the existing indoor positioning systems. In particular, the present invention provides a hybrid indoor positioning system (HIPS) that incorporates high-precision positioning device (e.g. US sensor) for high-precision localization and low-precision positioning device (e.g. RF sensor) for low-precision localization to provide adaptive positioning resolution for location based services.
In the present invention, the application scenario is divided into two kinds of regions: “Hot Area” where highly accurate positioning is required (for example, in centimeter level), and “General Area” where low positioning accuracy is acceptable (in meters or room level). As an example, ultrasonic positioning device (i.e. US positioning device) is deployed in “Hot Area” for highly accurate localization and RF positioning device is deployed in “General Area” for larger resolution localization. In addition, an online training algorithm is proposed in the present invention, in which the RF model (i.e. RF radio map) can be trained from the real-time position results from the US positioning device. In more details, in the area that can be covered by the US positioning device, i.e. the Hot Area, the more accurate US positioning results can be used to label the RF signal strength (RSS) data, while in the general area, the RSS data will not be labeled because the area cannot be covered by the US positioning device. Then, a semi-supervised learning algorithm can be conducted to train the RF radio map by using the labeled and unlabeled RSS data in real time. In this way, the human calibration efforts for the hybrid positioning system can be reduced.
Moreover, according to the present invention, the setting of the “Hot Area” can be based on the user's requirement or heuristic rules (for example, for a desk or a room etc.). In an embodiment, it is also disclosed that the tracking result of the tag can be used to adjust the position of the US positioning device so that the Hot Area can be covered by the sensing range of the RF positioning device.
According to the first aspect of the present invention, it is provided a method for positioning object with adaptive resolution, comprising: dividing a space to be detected into Hot Area and General Area; arranging, according to the positions of Hot Area and General Area, high-resolution positioning signal transceivers and low-resolution positioning signal transceivers, wherein the detection scope of the low-resolution positioning signal transceivers covers the space and the detection scope of the high-resolution positioning signal transceivers covers the Hot Area; and when the object moving in the space, fusing the detection results from the high-resolution positioning signal transceivers and the low-resolution positioning signal transceivers to determine the position of the object with adaptive resolution.
According to the second aspect of the present invention, it is provided a system for positioning object with adaptive resolution, comprising: a tag device carried by the object for transmitting high-resolution positioning signal (e.g. US signal) and low-resolution positioning signal (e.g. RF signal); a high-resolution positioning apparatus including high-resolution positioning signal transceivers for transmitting and receiving the high-resolution positioning signal; a low-resolution positioning apparatus including low-resolution positioning signal transceivers for transmitting and receiving the low-resolution positioning signal; and a results processing device for fusing the detection results from the high-resolution positioning apparatus and the low-resolution positioning apparatus to determine the position of the object with adaptive resolution, wherein the space to be detected is divided into Hot Area and a General Area, the detection scope of the low-resolution positioning apparatus covers the space, and the detection scope of the high-resolution positioning apparatus covers the Hot Area. As an example, the results processing device can be located locally or remotely in a location server.
As described below in more details, the hybrid indoor positioning system of the present invention can provide adaptive positioning resolution in an environment where different positioning resolutions (precisions or granularities) are required at different regions. Compared with the existing prior arts, the advantages of the present invention are mainly as follow:
Adaptive positioning resolution: based on a positioning fusing method, the system of the present invention can provide different positioning resolutions at different regions.
Low system cost: the deployment cost of the system can be reduced considerably since dense US positioning devices are not needed.
Calibration-less: benefiting from the US positioning device arranged in the Hot Area, the RF module can be trained on-line, so the system needs less human calibration.
Easier area division strategy: based on the user requirement or heuristic rules, it is easy to define the Hot Area. Also, the Hot Area can be accurately covered by adjusting the US positioning system.
The foregoing and other features of this invention may be more fully understood from the following description, when read together with the accompanying drawings in which:
When designing hybrid positioning system of the present invention, the following two aspects are considered:
1. From the application aspect, in location-based access control, it is usually the case that people may require different positioning granularities at different areas. For example, at the interested area, fine-grained positioning granularity is needed so as to make sure that the positioning results for this area are highly accurate. At the other areas, a coarser-grained positioning granularity may be acceptable. In this case, using either RF or ultrasound for positioning is not reasonable. On one hand, the RF positioning is limited in positioning granularity; generally, it can only reach a resolution of meter level. This may not be acceptable for those interested areas with high granularity requirement. On the other hand, although the ultrasound positioning has a high resolution of centimeter level in positioning, the ultrasound sensors are limited in signal coverage and also more expensive than RF sensors. Therefore, directly employing multiple ultrasound receivers for covering a large area is not economical. This motivates the inventors to consider incorporating both ultrasound and RF positioning technologies in providing hybrid positioning granularities.
2. From the technical aspect, ultrasound positioning and RF positioning can benefit from each other. The ultrasound positioning is highly accurate, but is limited by the ultrasound signal's transmission range. Generally, the ultrasound signal can propagate in less than 10 meters; and it is easy to be blocked by the obstacles, which is always the case in indoor office environments. The RF positioning is less accurate, and generally model training methods are exploited to improve the positioning accuracy. And, this model training process often requires many calibration efforts. On the other hand, the advantage of RF signals is that it has larger transmission range, e.g. 30-40 meters in indoor environments, and can penetrate the obstacles such as walls. We will further show that the present invention can utilize both of the ultrasound and RF signals and avoid their disadvantages by providing a calibration-less solution.
In the setting-up phase, first, in the step 301, the space to be detected is divided into “Hot Area” and “General Area”. The strategy for dividing the areas can be based on the user's requirement or according to some heuristic rules. Then, in the step 302, according to the divided “Hot Area” and “General Area”, positioning devices need to be arranged. In an embodiment, for the “Hot Area” which requires high-precision positioning, relatively dense US receivers are arranged, while for the “General Area” which can accept larger resolution localization, it can be arranged with RF, infrared or Wifi receivers. These receivers can provide advantages such as the scale is relatively large and the deployment cost is relatively low.
In the localization phase (step 303), when the object with the tag device is moving in the space to be detected, if it is in the Hot Area which can be covered by ultrasound, its position can be determined by US positioning device because US positioning can usually achieve higher positioning resolution than RF positioning. If the object moves to outside of the Hot Area, the position of the object can be determined by searching a trained RF radio map.
In the
Generally, the user can carry the tag device and move in the detected environment. Since the tag device can emit both of the ultrasound and RF signals simultaneously, both of the two signals correspond to the same position. Assume that there are n US receivers and p RF receivers. Each time when the US transmitter and the RF transmitter of the tag device emit US and RF signals, the US and RF receivers can obtain for example the following result vector:
wherein toai (1≦i≦n) represents TOA distance information received by the ith US receiver, m is the number of US receivers which have successfully detected the TOA results, and rssj (1≦j≦p) represents RSS information received by the jth RF receiver, q is the number of RF receivers which have successfully detected the RSS results. Please be noted that m≦n for the reason that there may be some barriers that prevent some of the US receivers from detecting the US signal, and q≦p for the reason that the RSS results from some RF receivers may be too weak and can be ignored.
With reference to the flow chart shown in
Next, as shown in
The RF radio map after training can be used for positioning of the object during the localization phase. In an embodiment, the position of the object can be estimated based for example on the following fusing strategy:
if m≧3, only [toal, toa2, . . . , toam] vector is utilized by trilateration or multilateration algorithm for highly accurate positioning.
If m<3, only [rssi, rss2, . . . , rssq] vector is utilized to search the RF radio map trained by an offline learning algorithm. The positioning accuracy achieved by this method is relatively low. But for the General Area which does not require high-precision positioning, it is acceptable.
Finally,
From the foregoing description, the hybrid positioning system according to the present invention and the method for positioning an object with adaptive resolution by using the hybrid positioning system has been explained in details with reference to the accompanying drawings. According to the above description, it can be seen that the present invention can bring the following beneficial effects:
Based on the positioning fusion algorithm, the system according to the present invention can provide adaptive positioning resolution in different application areas. Also, since it is not necessary to arrange dense array of US receivers to cover the whole application environment, the system cost can be reduced. Moreover, because of the US positioning device arranged in the Hot Area, the RF module (radio map) can be trained on-line. So the system needs less calibration. In the present invention, based on the user's requirement or heuristic rules, it is easy to divide the Hot Area and the General Area, and it is also easy to adjust the US positioning system to better and more accurately cover the Hot Area.
In the above embodiments, several specific steps are shown and described as examples. However, the method process of the present invention is not limited to these specific steps. Those skilled in the art will appreciate that these steps can be changed, modified and complemented or the order of some steps can be changed without departing from the spirit and substantive features of the invention.
Although the invention has been described above with reference to particular embodiments, the invention is not limited to the above particular embodiments and the specific configurations shown in the drawings. For example, some components shown may be combined with each other as one component, or one component may be divided into several subcomponents, or any other known component may be added. The operation processes are also not limited to those shown in the examples. Those skilled in the art will appreciate that the invention may be implemented in other particular forms without departing from the spirit and substantive features of the invention. The present embodiments are therefore to be considered in all respects as illustrative and not restrictive. The scope of the invention is indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description, and all changes that come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are therefore intended to be embraced therein.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
200810161869.9 | Oct 2008 | CN | national |