The present invention is a method and a system for repairing rail wheels.
As is well known in the art, trains, trams, and overhead cranes typically include rail wheels that are formed to engage rails. A typical rail wheel set 10 is illustrated in
Portions of a typical rail wheel 12 are illustrated in
As can be seen in
In the prior art, there have been attempts to repair worn tread or a worn flange, e.g., by welding additional material 33 (typically, steel) to a substrate 34 of the hub 19 over the worn profile 32, to replace the material that has been worn away from the tread 26 and from the flange 28. An example is shown in
However, these prior art repair methods have generally been unsatisfactory because the replacement material 33 tends to fall off or otherwise separate from the substrate 34. It is believed that the failure of the replacement material is generally due to a heat-affected zone “HAZ” in the substrate and in the replacement material that is created when the replacement material is welded, using conventional methods, to the substrate 34.
Another conventional repair method involves milling or cutting out the worn metal to form a new tread and a new flange at a smaller radius than the original tread and flange. However, this procedure typically may only be used two or three times with a particular rail wheel due to insufficient metal remaining, at which point the rail wheel may be recycled.
For the foregoing reasons, there is a need for a method and a system that overcomes or mitigates one or more of the defects or deficiencies of the prior art.
In its broad aspect, the invention provides a method of repairing a worn rail wheel in which a selected segment of the worn rail wheel is removed, to provide a remaining segment of a rim of the rail wheel having a first engagement surface. A replacement workpiece is provided having a replacement body element and a second engagement surface that is formed to mate with the first engagement surface. The replacement workpiece is positioned to define a predetermined gap between the first and second engagement surfaces. One or more heating elements are positioned in the predetermined gap, for induction heating of first and second heated portions of the remaining segment and the replacement workpiece and the first and second engagement surfaces, in a non-oxidizing atmosphere, to a hot working temperature.
Once the first and second heated portions and the first and second engagement surfaces are heated to the hot working temperature, the heating elements are removed, and the first and second engagement surfaces are engaged, while at least one of the first and second engagement surfaces is in motion relative to the other, for plastic deformation of at least part of the first and second heated portions and the first and second engagement surfaces. The first and second engagement surfaces and the first and second heated portions are allowed to cool, to bond the replacement workpiece and the remaining segment together.
The invention will be better understood with reference to the attached drawings, in which:
In the attached drawings, like reference numerals designate corresponding elements throughout. In particular, to simplify the description, the reference numerals previously used in
The method is for repairing a rail wheel 112 having a rim 124 including a worn body element 125 and a worn tread 126 and a worn flange 128 thereon formed for engagement with a rail (not shown in
Preferably, the method includes identifying and removing a selected segment 140 of the rim 124, to define a remaining segment 142 of the rim 124. The selected segment 140 preferably includes the worn body element 125, the worn tread 126 and the worn flange 128. As can be seen in
It will be understood that, in
A replacement workpiece 146 is provided, to replace the selected segment 140 that has been removed (
It will be understood that only a portion of the replacement workpiece 146 is shown in
One or more heating elements 158 preferably are positioned in the predetermined gap 156, to heat respective first and second heated portions 136, 138 of the remaining body element 143 and the replacement body element 148, and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150, by induction heating. As can be seen in
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that the first and second preselected distances 137, 139 may be determined based at least in part on various parameters, e.g., the average width or thickness of the remaining segment 142 in the vicinity of the first engagement surface 144, or the overall thickness of the replacement workpiece 146, i.e., between the second engagement surface 150 and the replacement tread 152, and the materials involved. The first and second preselected distances 137, 139 are each only a few millimeters.
It is also preferred that a non-oxidizing atmosphere is provided, to cover the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 and the first and second heated portions 136, 138 while they are heated. It will be understood that the non-oxidizing atmosphere is located inside an envelope or covering schematically represented by a dashed line in
In the non-oxidizing atmosphere, with the heating element(s) 158, the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 preferably are heated by induction heating, to a predetermined hot working temperature. The hot working temperature is less than the material's melting temperature. As will be described, the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 preferably are plastically deformable while at the hot working temperature.
While the first and second heated portions 136, 138 are at the hot working temperature, and while at least one of the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 is moving relative to the other, the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are engaged together, and the replacement workpiece 146 is urged against the remaining segment 142 in a direction away from the vertex “V” and toward the opening 145, and against the remaining segment 142, to plastically deform the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 and also to plastically deform at least respective parts of the first and second heated portions 136, 138. The first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 and the first and second heated portions 136, 138 preferably are then allowed to cool, to bond the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 of the rim 124 together.
While the heated portions 136, 138 and the engagement surfaces 144, 150 are at the hot working temperature, they are plastic, and they are forged together and subjected to shear, as described above. However, the temperature of the heated portions 136, 138 and the engagement surfaces 144, 150 quickly falls to below the hot working temperature after the heating elements are removed, and when the temperature thereof is less than the hot working temperature, the engagement surfaces and the heated portions are bonded together, as described above. It is preferred that the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 and the first and second heated portions 136, 138 are subsequently allowed to cool at a relatively slow rate to room temperature (e.g., approximately 20° C.).
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that, once the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 are bonded together as described above, a repaired rail wheel 112′ (
As can be seen in
As noted above, the remaining segment 142 is circular in elevation view, as is the replacement workpiece 146. In one embodiment, as will be described, the external diameter of the inner and outer ends 168, 170 of the first engagement surface 144 relative to the axis preferably are slightly larger than the respective inner and outer ends 180, 182 of the second engagement surface 150.
It can be seen in
As can be seen in
The replacement workpiece 146 preferably has a first internal replacement workpiece radius 184 defined between the second inner end 180 of the second engagement surface 150 and the axis “2X”, when the second engagement surface 150 is engaged with the first engagement surface 144, and a second internal replacement workpiece radius 186 defined between the second outer end 182 of the second engagement surface 150 and the axis “2X”, when the second engagement surface 150 is engaged with the first engagement surface 144 (
The first internal replacement workpiece radius 184 preferably is less than the first external remaining segment radius 172. Also, the second internal replacement workpiece radius 186 preferably is less than the second external remaining segment radius 174.
It will be understood that, because of the slight differences between (i) the first internal replacement workpiece radius 184 and the first external remaining segment radius 172, and between (ii) the second internal replacement workpiece radius 186 and the second external remaining segment radius 174, when the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 are first engaged, the replacement workpiece 146 is offset relative to the remaining segment 142 by a small distance to the right, as viewed in
It will also be understood that the internal diameters of the replacement workpiece 146, i.e., at selected locations along the second engagement surface 150, correspond to the radii at the selected locations on the second engagement surface 150 respectively. Similarly, the external diameters of the remaining segment 142, at corresponding selected locations on the first engagement surface 144, correspond to the radii at the selected locations on the first engagement surface respectively.
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that, when the heated portions 136, 138 and the engagement surfaces 144, 150 are at the hot working temperature, the internal radius of the replacement workpiece 146 at a first selected location on the engagement surface 150 preferably is slightly smaller than the external radius of the engagement surface 144 of the remaining segment 142 at a second selected location corresponding to the first selected location. It will be understood that the differences between the internal radius of the replacement workpiece 146 (defined by the second engagement surface 150) and the external radius of the remaining segment 142 (defined by the first engagement surface 144) are very small, and are not shown in the drawings herein accordingly.
Preferably, the fit between the engagement surfaces 144, 150 is a suitable force fit. That is, when the replacement workpiece 146 is urged onto the remaining segment 142, a certain amount of force is used (i.e., applied in the direction generally indicated by arrow “A” in
As noted above, the heated portions 136, 138 are relatively small parts of the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 respectively. Also, as can be seen in
It is believed that, because the heated portions 136, 138 are relatively small parts of the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 respectively, and also because the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 are circular in elevation view, the heated portions 136, 138 are squeezed and subjected to stress as a result of thermal expansion of the heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150. It is also believed that the plastic deformation of the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 while they are at the hot working temperature at least partially relieves such stress, in a dynamic rebalancing process.
Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that, to the extent that there is thermal expansion of the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 when they are heated to the hot working temperature, such thermal explansion is taken into account when the replacement workpiece 146 and the remaining segment 142 are formed, in order to ensure that the fit between the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 is a suitable force fit.
Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that, after the replacement workpiece 146 is in the final position on the remaining segment 142 (
For convenience, the repaired rail wheel is identified in
As noted above, the selected portion 140 is first removed, by any suitable method, to leave the remaining portion 142 of the rim 124. Those skilled in the art would be aware of suitable methods of removing the selected portion 140. It can be seen in
After the selected segment 140 has been removed, the replacement workpiece 146 is provided, and positioned relative to the remaining segment 142 so that the predetermined gap 156 is defined between the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150. The first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are spaced apart by the predetermined distance 155. Those skilled in the art would appreciate that the predetermined distance 155 may be determined by taking into account, among other things, the heat generated by the heating element(s) 158 and the amount of time required for the heating element(s) 158 to heat the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 to the hot working temperature. The type of steel and the geometry of the rail wheel would need to be taken nto account as well.
As illustrated in
Advantageously, the method of the invention enables the selected portion 140 to be replaced by the replacement workpiece 146 without removing the wheel 112 from the axle 116. In
As can be seen in
In
Those skilled in the art would be aware that the non-oxidizing atmosphere can be created by covering the region in which the non-oxidizing atmosphere is to be located and by displacing the air by a suitable inert gas (e.g., argon) that is pumped into the container. It will be understood that, for such displacement to take place, the container is not airtight. Because those skilled in the art would be aware of how to temporarily establish a non-oxidizing atmosphere over a selected area, further discussion of the non-oxidizing atmosphere is unnecessary.
As noted above, once the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are at the hot working temperature, the heating elements 158 preferably are removed from the gap 156, and the non-oxidizing atmosphere is also removed. Shortly thereafter, one or both of the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 preferably are moved relative to the other in any suitable motion, e.g., in a circular or similar motion. The replacement workpiece 146 is pushed in the direction generally indicated by arrow “A” in
For instance, in one embodiment, the replacement workpiece 146 preferably is rotated about the axis “2X” while the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 and the first and second heated portions 136, 138 are at the hot working temperature and when the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are engaged together.
It will be understood that, immediately after their initial engagement, one or both of the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 preferably are continuously moved relative to each other, e.g., in a circular or similar motion about an axis orthogonal to the engagement surfaces 144, 150, for deformation of at least parts of the first and second heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150. Alternatively, the relative motion may result from movement of the replacement workpiece 146 in the direction indicated by arrow “A” while the remaining segment 142 is stationary. Once the heated portions have cooled to a temperature less than the hot working temperature, the relative motion ceases. The replacement portion 146 and the remaining portion 142 are allowed to cool to ambient temperature, to metallurgical bond the replacement portion 146 and the remaining portion 142 together. Also, as noted above, because the fit is a suitable force fit, upon cooling, the replacement workpiece 146 is secured due to thermal contraction thereof.
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that the hot working temperature may be any suitable temperature, for the material. As noted above, the hot working temperature may be any temperature at which the steel is plastically deformable. For example, the hot working temperature may be approximately 1,265° C. However, different parameters, e.g., the type of steel, may affect the hot working temperature that is selected.
It will be understood that, unlike conventional frictional welding, in the method of the invention, the heat is primarily provided via the heating elements, i.e., via induction heating. It will also be understood that the heat energy generated in the method of the invention due to the motion of one or both of the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 while they are engaged is not significant compared with the heat generated via induction heating. It is believed that approximately 95% or more of the heat required for bonding is provided via induction heating, and the balance of approximately 5% or less is provided by the forging and the shearing to which the heated portions 136, 138 and the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are subjected, when the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 are engaged (i.e., pushed or urged together) and one or both are moved relative to the other.
One consequence of this is that, as compared to the equipment required for conventional friction welding, the equipment utilized for moving one or more of the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150, and for engaging the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 can be relatively less heavy or substantial. Also, because most of the heat is provided by the energized heating elements, using the method of the invention, the worn rail wheel 112 may be repaired while the rail wheel 112 remains mounted on the axle 116.
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that repairing the rail wheel 112 when it is mounted on the axle 116 can be done relatively expeditiously. If conventional repair methods are used, the time spent taking the worn wheel off the axle 116, and subsequently mounting the repaired wheel on the axle 116, may be substantial.
Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that the method of the invention may be used to join elements (i.e., the remaining segment 142 and the replacement workpiece 146) that are made of dissimilar materials. For example, the replacement workpiece 146 may be made of forged steel, and the remaining workpiece 142 may be made of cast steel, or vice versa.
An alternative embodiment of the method of the invention is illustrated in
First, the selected segment 240 is removed from the rim 224, so that a remaining portion 242 of the rim 224 remains (
In this embodiment, the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 preferably are formed and located so as to define an acute angle θ2 relative to the axis “2X” of the axle 116 that opens toward an outer side 262 of the rail wheel 212 (
It will be understood that, in
Preferably, the replacement workpiece 246 is located relative to the remaining portion 242 so that the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 are spaced apart by a predetermined distance 255 to define a predetermined gap 256 therebetween (
It will be understood that in this embodiment also, one or more heating elements 258 preferably are positioned in the gap 256 (
Once the first and second heated portions 236, 238 and the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 are heated to the hot working temperature, the heating elements 258 are removed, and the non-oxidizing atmosphere is also removed.
While the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 and the first and second heated portions 236, 238 are at the hot working temperature, the replacement workpiece 246 is pushed in the direction generally indicated by arrow “B” in
The replacement portion 246 and the remaining portion 242 are then allowed to cool, to bond them together. The repaired rail wheel is identified in
As noted above, after the first and second engagement surfaces are initially engaged, one or both of them preferably is moved relative to the other. Such relative movement may be circular or similar movement about an axis orthogonal to the engagement surfaces, or any other movement while engaged. The first and second engagement surfaces preferably are both at the hot working temperature when they are first engaged. Those skilled in the art would appreciate that, shortly after engagement, the first and second engagement surfaces will become fused together due to a relatively rapid decrease in temperature from the hot working temperature. Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that the temperature of the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 and the first and second heated portions 236, 238 rapidly falls after the heating elements 258 are removed from the predetermined gap.
Accordingly, it will be understood that, as a practical matter, the first and second engagement surfaces preferably are engaged as soon as the heating elements have been removed. As a practical matter, in view of the relatively short time in which the engagement surfaces may be moved relative to each other after they are initially engaged, it may be advantageous to commence moving one or both of the engagement surfaces immediately upon withdrawal of the heating elements, and before the engagement surfaces are engaged.
In practice, in order to move one or both of the engagement surfaces 244, 250 relative to the other, those elements with the engagement surfaces thereon must be engaged or held by suitable elements. Those skilled in the art would appreciate that, where the rail wheel has been repaired while it is mounted on the axle (
As described above, the selected segment 140 preferably is identified and removed to provide the remaining segment 142, and the first engagement surface 144 on the remaining segment element 143. In one embodiment, the first engagement surface 144 preferably is at least partially planar and positioned at least partially transverse to the axis “2X”.
As can be seen, e.g., in
In one embodiment, as shown in
In one embodiment, the first and second engagement surfaces 144, 150 preferably are positioned to define the first acute angle θ having the first acute angle vertex “V” that is located proximal to the outer side 162 of the rail wheel 112 (
In another embodiment, as shown in
In another embodiment, the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 preferably are positioned to define a second acute angle vertex “V2” that is located proximal to the inner side 160 of the rail wheel 112 (
The remaining segment 242 is circular in elevation view, as is the replacement workpiece 246. In one embodiment, as will be described, the external diameter of inner and outer ends 268, 270 of the first engagement surface 244 relative to the axis preferably are slightly larger than respective inner and outer ends 280, 282 of the second engagement surface 250.
It can be seen in
As can be seen in
The replacement workpiece 246 preferably has a first internal replacement workpiece radius 284 defined between the second inner end 280 of the second engagement surface 250 and the axis “2X”, when the second engagement surface 250 is engaged with the first engagement surface 244, and a second internal replacement workpiece radius 286 defined between the second outer end 282 of the second engagement surface 250 and the axis “2X”, when the second engagement surface 250 is engaged with the first engagement surface 244 (
The first internal replacement workpiece radius 284 preferably is less than the first external remaining segment radius 272. Also, the second internal replacement workpiece radius 286 preferably is less than the second external remaining segment radius 274.
It will be understood that, because of the slight differences between (i) the first internal replacement workpiece radius 284 and the first external remaining segment radius 272, and between (ii) the second internal replacement workpiece radius 286 and the second external remaining segment radius 274, when the replacement workpiece 246 and the remaining segment 242 are first engaged, the replacement workpiece 246 is offset relative to the remaining segment 242 by a small distance to the left, as viewed in
It will be understood that the internal diameters of the replacement workpiece 246, i.e., at selected locations along the second engagement surface 250, correspond to the radii at the selected locations on the second engagement surface 250 respectively. Similarly, the external diameters of the remaining segment 242, at corresponding selected locations on the first engagement surface 244, correspond to the radii at the selected locations on the first engagement surface respectively.
Those skilled in the art would appreciate that, when the heated portions 236, 238 and the engagement surfaces 244, 250 are at the hot working temperature, the internal radius of the replacement workpiece 246 at a first selected location on the engagement surface 250 preferably is slightly smaller than the external radius of the engagement surface 244 of the remaining segment 242 at a second selected location corresponding to the first selected location. It will be understood that the differences between the internal radius of the replacement workpiece 246 (defined by the second engagement surface 250) and the external radius of the remaining segment 242 (defined by the first engagement surface 244) are very small, and are not shown in the drawings herein accordingly.
Preferably, the fit between the engagement surfaces 244, 250 is a suitable force fit. That is, when the replacement workpiece 246 is urged onto the remaining segment 242, a certain amount of force is used (i.e., applied in the direction generally indicated by arrow “B” in
Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that the thermal expansion of the replacement workpiece 246 and of the remaining segment 242 (i.e., due to heating of the first and second heated portions 236, 238 and the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 to the hot working temperature) is taken into account when the replacement workpiece 246 and the remaining segment 242 are formed, in order to ensure that the fit between the first and second engagement surfaces 244, 250 is a suitable force fit.
Those skilled in the art would also appreciate that, after the replacement workpiece 246 is in the final position on the remaining segment 242 (
For convenience, the repaired rail wheel is identified in
In one embodiment, the method of the invention preferably additionally includes providing one or more first projections 387 extending from an outer side 378 of the replacement workpiece 346. Preferably, each of the first projections 387 is engaged by a first engagement tool 388 (
It will be understood that the first and second heated portions and the heating elements are omitted from
In one embodiment, while the first engagement tool 388 is engaged with one or more of the first projections 387, the replacement workpiece 346 is urged thereby to rotate about the axis “2X” (
It will be understood that a number of the engagement tools 388 may be respectively engaged with a number of the projections 387, simultaneously. Only one engagement tool 388 is shown, in
As can be seen in
It will be understood that, as described above, one or more heating elements (not shown in
From the foregoing, it can be seen that the first tool 388 is mounted to the first teeth 387 by moving the first tool 388 in the direction generally indicated by arrow “E” in
After the replacement workpiece 346 is fused with the remaining portion 342 of the rim 324, the tool 388 and the first teeth 387 may be removed, in any suitable manner.
Another alternative embodiment of the method of the invention is illustrated in
The first tool 488 is mounted to the first teeth 487 by moving the first tool 488 in the direction generally indicated by arrow “E” in
The movement of the replacement workpiece 446 about the axis “2X” in either clockwise or counterclockwise directions is indicated by the arrows “G” and “H” in
It will be understood that, as described above, one or more heating elements (not shown in
In
After the replacement workpiece 446 and the remaining portion 442 of the rim 424 are fused together, the tools 488, 492 and the first and second teeth 487,490 may be removed, by any suitable method.
As noted above, in one embodiment, the rail wheel to be repaired may remain mounted on the axle while the rail wheel is repaired. In this situation, as shown in
As illustrated in
It will be understood that the engagement surfaces 544, 550 are heated by one or more heating elements (not shown) located in a predetermined gap 556 to a hot working temperature in a non-oxidizing atmosphere, at which point the heating elements are removed.
To mount the first tool 588 to the first teeth 587, the first tool is moved in the direction indicated by arrow “J” toward the first teeth 587 until engaged. To mount the second tool 592 to the second teeth 590, the second tool is moved in the direction generally indicated by arrow “K” in
Preferably, the replacement workpiece 546 is rotated about the axis “2X” by the first and second tools as the first tool pushes the replacement workpiece 546 in the direction generally indicated by arrow “J” in
As described above, after the engagement surfaces have been at least partially plastically deformed due to the rotation of the replacement workpiece 546 about the axis “2X” after the engagement of the engagement surfaces with each other, the replacement workpiece 546 and the remaining portion 542 are allowed to cool, to fuse together. The first and second teeth 587, 590 may thereafter be removed, by any suitable means.
It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the invention can take many forms, and that such forms are within the scope of the invention as claimed. The scope of the claims should not be limited by the preferred embodiments set forth in the examples, but should be given the broadest interpretation consistent with the description as a whole.
This application claims priority from U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 63/212,745, filed on Jun. 21, 2021, the entire disclosure whereof is hereby incorporated by reference herein.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/CA2022/050985 | 6/20/2022 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63212745 | Jun 2021 | US |