1. Field of the Invention
The application relates generally to systems and methods for power generation and more specifically to systems and methods for integrating a fossil fueled combined cycle power generation system with a solar Rankine power generation system with enhanced power generation efficiency.
2. Description of the Related Art
Solar thermal generation can be used to generate clean, on-peak energy when used in conjunction with a fossil fuel for backup. Solar thermal generation can be easily hybridized and provide the premium energy desired by summer peaking utilities. Solar-powered generation generally follows the energy load of summer peaking utilities, thereby providing the on-peak energy when it is needed most, i.e., during higher temperature daylight hours. Although simple and reliable, such solar thermal generation facilities are inefficient and cannot compete, in most cases, with traditional fossil fuel generated electrical energy.
Attempts have been made to increase the efficiency of solar thermal generating facilities by combining such facilities with combustion turbine electric generator systems. One example is a system called an Integrated Solar Combined Cycle System (ISCCS), developed by Sandia National Laboratories. The ISCCS is illustrated in
In an ISCCS, the traditional steam Rankine cycle of the solar thermal generation unit is combined with the Brayton cycle of a combustion turbine generating facility. In these systems, working fluid vapor is produced in a working fluid vaporizer using heat developed in a solar thermal array. The working fluid vapor is then transferred to a heat recovery device such as a heat recovery steam generator.
The heat recovery steam generator not only provides super heat for the working fluid vapor produced in the vaporizer, but can also produce additional working fluid vapor in one or more additional vaporizers. Heat for preheating recycled working fluid condensate is also provided by the heat recovery steam generator.
The heat recovery steam generator produces both a high pressure stream of working fluid vapor, a low pressure stream of working fluid vapor and, depending on the system configuration, an intermediate pressure stream of working fluid vapor (combined in
The ISCCS system, unfortunately, has several shortcomings. The solar fractional portion of the total electric energy generated is very low. Thus, many ISCCS plants cannot qualify for various tax and other economic incentives provided by local governing bodies for renewable energy producing facilities. Also, the heat recovery steam generator is inherently inefficient, since it must be carefully designed as a combined unit and cannot be efficiently operated when there is no solar heat addition. Finally, the ISCCS is highly complex in design and operation, and is, for that reason, expensive to build, maintain and operate.
An aspect of at least one of the embodiments disclosed herein includes the realization that solar thermal generators can be made more efficient by utilizing heat from a combined cycle generation system. For example, currently available solar boilers are only able to generate steam of about 700° F. at about 700 psi. This is due to the limitations of the oils used in solar thermal arrays for transporting thermal energy from the solar array to the boiler. However, hardware normally used in power generation plants, including plumbing and expansion turbines, are often designed to operate with steam at pressures well over 1000 psi and temperatures well over 1000° F. Thus, in some embodiments, higher temperature but lower pressure steam from a Heat Recovery System Generator, such as those commonly used in combined cycle systems, can be used to further super heat the steam in a solar thermal system before it is delivered to the expansion turbine. As such, the energy transferred from the lower pressure steam has more thermodynamic “availability” after it is transferred to the much higher pressure but lower temperature solar-generated steam. This is because, as is well understood by those of ordinary skill in the art, pressure is the only form of energy that can be used to drive an expansion generator.
For example, very high temperature steam (1200° F.) at atmospheric pressure cannot be used to drive an expansion turbine. Thus, even though the steam at 1200° F. and atmospheric pressure contains a large amount of thermal energy, this energy is not “available” for use in an expansion turbine; expansion turbines cannot convert thermal energy into shaft power. Rather, expansion turbines rely on the flow of a fluid, such as steam, from a high pressure source, across the turbine, to the low pressure exhaust side of the turbine to generate shaft power.
Thus, in accordance with at least one embodiment, a method for generating power can be provided. The method can comprise generating a heated reheat of a first working fluid in a first power generation system and vaporizing a second working fluid liquid in a second power generation system to form a second working fluid vapor. The method can also comprise transferring energy from the reheat of the first working fluid to the second working fluid vapor thus increasing a temperature and a pressure of the second working fluid vapor of the second power generation system.
In accordance with at least one embodiment, a method to increase the thermodynamic availability of a first working fluid vapor having a first temperature and a first pressure can be provided. The method can comprising the steps of transferring the first working fluid vapor to a superheater and transferring a second working fluid vapor to the superheater, the second working fluid vapor having a second temperature that is lower than the first temperature and a second pressure that is higher than the first pressure. The method can also comprise transferring heat energy in the superheater from the first working fluid vapor to the second working fluid vapor to increase the temperature and pressure of the second working fluid vapor.
In accordance with at least one embodiment, a power generation system can comprise a solar energy collector, and a solar boiler connected to the solar collector with a working fluid conduit configured to circulate a first working fluid to transfer heat from the solar energy collector to the solar boiler. The power generation system can also include a first expansion turbine and a steam circuit extending from the solar boiler to the first expansion turbine. Additionally, a heat transfer device connected to the steam circuit between the solar boiler and the first expansion turbine, the heat transfer device being configured to transfer heat from reheated steam in a combined cycle power generation system to steam in the solar steam circuit.
The above-mentioned and the other features of the inventions disclosed herein are described below with reference to the drawings of the preferred embodiments. The illustrated embodiments are intended to illustrate, but not to limit the inventions. The drawings contain the following figures:
The following discussion describes in detail several embodiments of power generation systems and various aspects of these embodiments. This discussion should not be construed, however, as limiting the present inventions to those particular embodiments. Practitioners skilled in the art will recognize numerous other embodiments including those that can be made through various combinations of the aspects of the illustrated embodiments.
Combined Cycle Power Generation System
A three pressure combined cycle with reheat is used in the embodiments of combined cycle power generation systems discussed herein, although other combined cycles and other configurations of multiple pressure combined cycles can also be used. An illustrative three pressure combined cycle is illustrated in the upper portion of
In the illustrated combined cycle power generation system, a Brayton cycle combustion turbine is used as a topping cycle with the exhaust (A) of the combustion turbine (CT) used to supply heat to a bottoming Rankine cycle. As illustrated, water is the working fluid for the bottoming Rankine cycle, although in other embodiments, other working fluids could be used.
The combustion turbine uses hot exhaust gas from the combustion of a fuel to drive a turbine and a generator. Operation of the combustion turbine thus generates electricity and produces a flow of hot exhaust gas. Steam flows and pressures used in the bottoming Rankine cycle are the result of heat extraction from the exhaust flow of the CT. After the usable heat is extracted from the CT exhaust, the exhaust flow (B) is directed to a heat rejection stack.
As illustrated in the combined cycle of
After partial expansion in the high pressure steam turbine (HP), the steam is routed via flow path (D) and returned to the HRSG as “cold reheat” for further heating by the combustion turbine exhaust flow (A). This “cold reheat” steam is heated by the HRSG and then exits the HSRG as “hot reheat” through the flow path (E).
The “hot reheat” steam flow is then expanded in an intermediate pressure portion IP of the turbine and can continue to expand through the low pressure portion (LP) of the turbine. In some embodiments, a low pressure steam flow (F) from the HSRG can be added to the flow of hot reheat as it enters the low pressure portion (LP). After expansion in the (IP) and (LP) portions of the turbine, these stem flows are condensed in the condenser.
Typically, the main steam entering the high pressure turbine over flow path (C) is at a pressure of approximately 1,800 psia; the hot reheat in flow path (E) enters the intermediate pressure turbine having a pressure in the range of 350-500 psia; and, the low pressure steam in flow path (F) enters the low pressure turbine having a pressure in the range of ˜50 psia. All steam produced at all three pressures can be expanded in a triple pressure turbine (HP), (IP), (LP) and flows to a condenser over flow path (R). Power is extracted, for example by electrical generators, from both the combustion turbine and the triple pressure turbine (HP), (IP), (LP).
Solar Rankine Power Generation System
A solar Rankine power generation system is illustrated in the lower portion of
In the system illustrated in
The heated oil, or other transfer fluid, circulates in thermal contact with a working fluid liquid in a vaporizer. In the illustrated embodiment, the working fluid liquid is water, although other liquids could be used in other embodiments.
As illustrated in
The working fluid vapor produced in the vaporizer can then be further heated in one or more superheaters (not illustrated). In a typical solar thermal generation facility, the heat required by the one or more superheaters is provided by a fossil fuel burning heater. The working fluid vapor can then be used to generate electricity by driving a working fluid vapor turbine electric generator, such as the illustrated steam turbine electric generator. This power generation is illustrated as main steam following a steam flow path (L) to a steam turbine in
The solar Rankine cycle is typically a regenerative cycle and, in various embodiments, can be used with and without reheats and with and without feedwater heaters (1), (2), (3). In the illustrated solar Rankine cycle, no reheats are present. Additionally, three extraction flow paths (G), (H), (I) transfer partially expanded steam from the steam turbine to three corresponding feedwater preheaters (1), (2), (3). In other embodiments, a solar Rankine power generation system can include more or fewer than three extraction flow paths and feedwater heaters, and the numbers and properties of which can be chosen based on desired performance or economic considerations. The feedwater heater drains are routed back to the condenser over flow path (M) such that the partially expanded steam used to preheat the working fluid feedwater is condensed and recirculated. Alternatively, they can be cascaded through the heaters. The use of reheats and preheaters can increase the efficiency of a solar Rankine cycle. But, often, this increased efficiency is at the expense of increased costs and complexity. Therefore, the number and configuration of reheats and preheaters can be determined by economic considerations.
One difference between a fossil fuel fired Rankine cycle and the solar Rankine cycle illustrated in
Integrating the Combined Cycle with the Solar Rankine Cycle
As discussed above, one approach to increasing the efficiency of a solar Rankine power generation system has been to integrate it with a combined cycle power generation system in an ISCCS. However, the ISCCS system only marginally improves power plant performance and requires substantial redesign of the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG) of the combined cycle. Several embodiments of integrated power generation system are discussed herein that improve upon the ISSCS system by enhancing overall efficiency, reducing costs, and reducing both complexity and risk since no modification to the HRSG is required. While the illustrated embodiments relate to integrating a three pressure combined cycle power generation system with a solar Rankine power generation system, it is contemplated that in other embodiments, other combined cycles can be used with the systems and methods disclosed herein to increase performance of two integrated power generation systems.
Methods are provided herein for increasing the efficiency of an integrated power generation system. These methods are further disclosed herein in the context of various embodiments of integrated power generation systems. The methods disclosed herein include transferring, for example through use of a superheater, heat energy from reheat of a first working fluid of a first power generation system to a second power generation system. in some of the embodiments described herein, the hot reheat of the first working fluid has a relatively high temperature, but low pressure and the second working fluid has a moderate temperature and moderate pressure. Both the temperature and the pressure of the second working fluid are increased by the heat energy transfer (which can require higher pressure feedwater pumping). The resulting increased temperature and pressure results in greater availability and a lower enthalpy at the second working fluid steam turbine expansion line end point than would be achieved by stand-alone systems.
The transfer of energy from the hot reheat to the working fluid of the solar Rankine cycle creates higher thermodynamic availability by effectively allowing the solar Rankine cycle working fluid to be expanded at a higher pressure. Thus, the total enthalpy output of the combined cycle working fluid is increased, resulting in higher generator output when compared to the same amount of heat input into the combined cycle and solar Rankine cycle. The increased enthalpy in the solar Rankine power generation system results in a longer turbine expansion line and lower exhaust end point on a Mollier diagram.
In various embodiments, additional efficiency enhancements can be gained from the use of regeneration and the pre-heating of the return oil to the solar collectors in the solar Rankine cycle. Although the illustrated embodiments include a three pressure combined cycle system, the enhanced efficiency of this integrated power generation system can also be attained in single and double pressure configurations depending on the operating parameters of the combined cycle.
Referring to
For example, in some embodiments, integrated power generation systems can include a valve to allow a power generation operator to arrest flow of hot reheat over flow path (Q) during night hours or periods of substantial cloudiness when the Solar Boiler would not adequately generate working fluid vapor in the solar Rankine cycle.
As illustrated, the working fluid vapor of the solar Rankine cycle is vaporized in the Solar Boiler, then is transferred, over flow path (L) to the Superheater. It is contemplated that the Superheater can be one of various designs of heat exchanging device known in the art with desired heat transfer capabilities and properties. In the Superheater, heat energy is transferred from the hot reheat working fluid vapor of the combined cycle, which is at a relatively high temperature, but a relatively low pressure, to the working fluid vapor of the solar Rankine cycle, which is at a temperature and pressure limited by operating constraints of the Solar Boiler.
For illustrative purposes, common flows and temperatures for a three pressure combined cycle power generation system and a regenerative solar Rankine power generation system are discussed below. However, different power generation system configurations can use different working temperatures and pressures. In the embodiments illustrated in
The steam generated by the Solar Boiler, is at a pressure of approximately 700 psia and a temperature of approximately 700° F. In the Superheater, the energy transfer from the hot reheat steam diverted over flow path (Q) raises the temperature of the steam in the solar Rankine cycle to approximately 1,000° F. (reflecting an approximately 50° F. “pinchpoint”). This increase in temperature of the steam in the solar Rankine cycle is accompanied by a corresponding increase in pressure to approximately 1,200 psia. This higher pressure steam then follows flow path (W) and is expanded in a steam turbine that drives a power generator in the solar Rankine cycle.
The higher pressure steam in the turbine will have a lower turbine enthalpy point at the end of the expansion line than would be present for a turbine driven by the hot reheat of the combined cycle power generation system. Thus, by exchanging the heat to a higher pressure fluid in the solar Rankine cycle power generation system, greater availability is established and a lower enthalpy is achieved at the steam turbine expansion line end point than could be achieved for the two illustrated power generation systems operating independently as in
As illustrated in
As illustrated in
As illustrated, the working fluid condensate is returned to the combined cycle over flow path (U) where it can be recirculated in the combined cycle power generation system over flow path (N). Thus, in the illustrated embodiments, the combined cycle working fluid and the solar Rankine cycle working fluid are not mixed. Rather, only heat is exchanged between the two working fluids. Therefore, while the illustrated embodiment and discussion thereof relates to the use of water as the working fluid in both cycles, in other embodiments, each cycle can use a different working fluid.
With reference to
In the embodiments illustrated in
A portion of the mixed working fluid condensate exiting the condenser over flow path (J) is recirculated over flow path (U′) to the combined cycle power generation system. To avoid accumulation of working fluid in one of the power generation systems, the volume of condensate that is recirculated over flow path (U′) can be metered to maintain sufficient volumes of working fluid in each power generation system.
Advantageously, the embodiments illustrated in
With reference to
Unlike the previously-discussed embodiments, in some embodiments of
In the embodiments of
Typically, combined cycle power generation systems are outfitted with duct firing in order to boost the output by 10% or higher. When duct fired, the incremental heat rate is significantly higher than the plant heat rate and, consequently, duct firing is normally performed only when additional peaking capacity/energy is required. Thus, a turbine of a combined cycle power generation system typically has additional power generation capacity that remains unused during normal operating conditions. As illustrated in
In the illustrated embodiments, the superheated working fluid vapor generated by the solar Rankine cycle is exits the Superheater over flow path (W″) and is fed into the turbine of the combined cycle power generation system. This working fluid vapor flow from the solar Rankine cycle power generation system utilizes spare turbine capacity that would otherwise be available for use with duct firing. Duct firing can still be performed to provide back up for the solar Rankine cycle power generation system during cloud transients, rainy days or whenever emergency capacity/energy is needed as the duct firing is always available notwithstanding the operation of the solar system.
In the embodiments of integrated power generation system illustrated in
In the embodiments illustrated in
Alternatively, a more traditional shell and tube heater where the drips are returned to the condenser can be used to preheat the solar Rankine cycle working fluid. Since the working fluids of the two cycles are commingled in the turbine, the solar Rankine cycle working fluid can be supplied by a side stream on flow path (S″) from the combined cycle power generation system condenser. Thus, in the embodiments of
While the integrated power generation system embodiments of
Where different entities own the individual power generation systems, concerns may arise over the purity of the working fluid flow entering the combined cycle turbine. For example, in embodiments where water steam is the working fluid vapor, in a steam turbine, if the steam flow includes droplets or impurities, there can be a risk of damage to the turbine. Therefore while the common turbine of embodiments of
With reference to
In the embodiments of
Alternatively, a more traditional shell and tube heater where the drips are returned to the condenser can be used to preheat the solar Rankine cycle working fluid. Since as illustrated the working fluids of the two cycles are commingled in the feedwater heater, the solar Rankine cycle working fluid can be supplied by a side stream on flow path (S′″) from the combined cycle power generation system condenser.
In the embodiments illustrated in
In any of the embodiments discussed above with reference to
Additionally, the integrated power generation systems disclosed herein can provide a utility with the ability to qualify for tax and other economic incentives based upon facilities producing a high percentage of renewable energy. Additionally, the integrated power generation systems disclosed herein are simple and inexpensive to build, operate and maintain. These integrated power generation systems can be used in both new construction and in retrofit applications. In most retrofit applications, retrofitting is a simple process since no internal modifications are needed to the heat recovery device or turbine combined cycle power generation system.
Additionally, the methods disclosed herein of superheating a working fluid in a solar Rankine cycle provide a power generation operator with flexibility, both in initial design and in subsequent operation. The power generation operator can mix and match several different gas combustion electrical generators with a solar field to meet different operating criteria and different solar fractions. Unlike the ISCCS, the systems and methods disclosed herein are not bound by a single integrated power generation system design. The solar field and the gas combustion electrical generator can be efficiently operated without the other when necessary.
For example, the integrated power generation systems can include valves to isolate the combined cycle power generation system from the solar Rankine power generation system at night or during highly cloudy periods. This separation of power generation systems is virtually impossible in an ISCCS, where both the solar field and the gas turbine electric generator are adapted to work together. Moreover, the power generation system operator can design the integrated power generation systems disclosed herein over a wide range of temperatures and pressures to meet different operating criteria and solar fractions, without markedly effecting overall efficiency.
Although certain embodiments and examples have been described herein, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that many aspects of the systems and methods shown and described in the present disclosure may be differently combined and/or modified to form still further embodiments. Additionally, it will be recognized that the methods described herein may be practiced using any systems or devices suitable for performing the recited steps. Such alternative embodiments and/or uses of the methods, systems, and devices described above and obvious modifications and equivalents thereof are intended to be within the scope of the present disclosure. Thus, it is intended that the scope of the present invention should not be limited by the particular embodiments described above, but should be determined only by a fair reading of the claims that follow.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/665,048, entitled “Method to Integrate Fossil Fueled Combined Cycle Power Plant with a Solar Rankine Power Plant,” filed on Mar. 25, 2005; and U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/693,111, entitled “Method to Integrate Fossil Fueled Combined Cycle Power Plant with a Solar Rankine Power Plant Using a Common Steam Turbine,” filed on Jun. 23, 2005. These provisional applications are incorporated by reference herein in their entireties.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60665048 | Mar 2005 | US | |
60693111 | Jun 2005 | US |