The present invention generally relates to resource allocation to terminals in a telecommunication system which comprises a carrier when this carrier supports multiple subcarrier spacing configurations.
The present invention applies in multicarrier telecommunication systems such using OFDMA, or SC-FDMA or other OFDM-based waveform. Some OFDM-based systems allow several parameters sets, sometimes referred to as “numerology”, to coexist onto the same carrier. This is especially the case in the 5G systems such as the NR (New Radio) standard under definition in 3GPP. A numerology may include parameters such as the subcarrier spacing configuration, the size of the cyclic prefix, the number of symbols, etc. Thus on a carrier with a given bandwidth, different subcarrier spacing configurations can coexist, in a frequency domain multiplexing manner.
This coexistence of different subcarrier spacing configurations causes difficulties in the resource allocation in such a carrier. Indeed, when allocating contiguous groups of subcarriers of different subcarrier spacing configuration, performance degradation can occur due to inter-numerology interference. More specifically, subcarriers of the same numerology respect an orthogonality property, that is the sinc-shaped subcarrier spectra exhibit zero-crossings at the positions of the other subcarriers. This orthogonality property may not be preserved between contiguous subcarriers of different subcarrier spacing configuration, causing inter-numerology interference.
Generally, to limit the signaling overhead, carriers are allocated with a certain granularity N. Groups of N subcarriers are called resource blocks: For example, in LTE/LTE-A/NR N=12. By resource blocks we refer more generally to the smallest scheduling unit of the carrier, which in this example contains 12 subcarriers in the frequency domain across a fixed number of OFDM symbols in the time domain.
Users are allocated a certain number of resource blocks for their communication needs. When users having different numerologies are allocated resource blocks in neighbouring frequency bands, inter-numerology interference can appear. To limit the impact of inter-numerology interference, guard bands can be inserted, during the scheduling process, in the frequency domain between two resource blocks of two different numerologies. That is by leaving unallocated resources between these two resource blocks. On the other hand, inserting a guard band leads to loss of resources in the carrier. Indeed, when allocating a resource block contiguously to a resource block with a different numerology the possibility in setting the size of the guard band depends on the subcarrier spacing configuration of the resource block being scheduled, which can strongly affect the spectral efficiency.
For example and like displayed in
For each numerology and more specifically for each subcarrier spacing configuration there is a raster in the frequency domain defining the possible positions of the subcarriers in the said subcarrier spacing configuration. The pitch of the raster corresponds to the size of a resource block of the same numerology in the frequency domain.
The scheduling in such a carrier is done taking into account the raster of each numerology, indeed each resource block of a defined numerology fills a socket of the same numerology raster.
Since we allocate resource blocks aligned on their own raster, the guard band (represented by shaded areas in
The present invention aims to improve the situation.
To that end, the invention relates to a method for allocating resources to a terminal in a telecommunication system comprising at least a carrier comprising several subcarriers, this carrier supporting at least one subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 and one subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1, with Δf1=q·Δf0, and q being a positive integer, said method comprising:
a) selecting the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1;
b) determining a number L of resource blocks having subcarriers of said subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1;
c) allocating to said terminal subcarriers among the subcarriers of subcarrier spacing configurations Δf1, of the carrier, having their frequencies:
The present invention, within the resource allocation in a carrier which supports several subcarrier spacing configurations, enables to allocate to the terminal only some subcarriers of a resource block. More specifically, allocating to the terminal, among the N subcarriers of the resource block, only the subcarriers after the nth. This enables to define a guard band between two allocations of resource of different subcarrier spacing configurations by not allocating the first subcarriers of the resource block of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1. More specifically, when allocating resource blocks of a specific subcarrier spacing configurations, aligned on their own raster, to a terminal a guard band is implemented when the previous resources, in frequency, are allocated in a different subcarrier spacing configuration to avoid inter-numerology interference. The method enables the first subcarrier allocated to the terminal to be different from the first subcarrier of the resource block of the same subcarrier spacing configuration, to which the first subcarrier allocated belongs. That is the firsts subcarriers of this resource block are not allocated to the terminal. By leaving vacant these first subcarriers, this enables to give some flexibility in the size of the guard band, therefore it enables to reduce the inter-numerology interference while leaving vacant only a small appropriate amount of frequency resources. Indeed, the present invention enables to set the size of a guard band with a granularity of N*Δf0 in contrary to a granularity of N*Δf1, therefore it enables to have a better spectral efficiency. Also, the present invention enables to set the size of a guard band with a granularity of N*Δf0 in contrary to a granularity of min(N*Δf1, N*Δf2) with Δf0<min(Δf1, Δf2) between users using subcarrier spacings Δf1 and Δf2; therefore it enables to have a better spectral efficiency. The subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 may or may not be used effectively for resource allocation. For example, Δf0 may be smaller than Δf1 and Δf2 or the smallest subcarrier spacing configuration supported for resource allocation on the carrier. For example, Δf0 may be the smallest subcarrier spacing configuration defined in the telecommunication system, even if it is not used on the carrier.
The present invention matches the fact of allocating contiguous resource blocks to the same terminal with the fact of defining a guard band with respect to the previous adjacent frequency domain allocation by leaving vacant the first subcarriers of the first resource block allocated to the terminal. Such an allocation scheme which allocates a specific number L of contiguous resource blocks to the same terminal, is done by specifying the position of the first subcarrier not vacant in the first resource block allocated to the terminal and the number L of the resource blocks allocated. Only the first resource block allocated to the terminal according to the method is not complete in regard to the number of subcarrier allocated through it.
By resource blocks the present invention refers as well to virtual resource blocks or to physical resource blocks. Resource blocks also refer to any other resource allocation unit, such as resource block groups which encompass several resource blocks, or to a group of any pre-defined number of subcarriers.
According to an aspect of the invention, the integer m is determined such as at least one subcarrier of subcarrier spacing configurations Δf1, having a frequency of at least fref+m·N·Δf1 and at the most fref+(m+1)·N·Δf1−Δf1, can be allocated to the terminal. This enables to avoid leaving an unnecessary number of unallocated subcarriers of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1 when resource blocks of a smaller subcarrier spacing configuration than Δf1 are allocated. Indeed, the subcarriers of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1 between these small resource blocks and the following resource block of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1, due to the invention can be allocated. Therefore this enables to maximize the spectral efficiency.
According to an aspect of the invention, the integer k is determined such as fstart−fnear is greater than G, G being a strictly positive threshold, and fnear being a frequency of a subcarrier of a subcarrier spacing configuration different from Δf1, said subcarrier having the highest frequency among frequencies of subcarriers allocated in the carrier having subcarrier spacing configurations different from Δf1 and having lower frequencies than fref+(m+1)·N·Δf1. This enables to implement the required size of the guard band to maintain the orthogonality property between two subcarriers of different subcarrier spacing configuration.
According to an aspect of the invention, the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 is the smallest subcarrier spacing configuration among the subcarrier spacing configurations supported by the carrier. This enables to implement guard bands, whose size can be define with high flexibility. More specifically, the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 will always be at least equal or smaller than the subcarrier spacing configurations of any of two subcarriers between which a guard band is inserted. Therefore the size of the guard band can be set short enough to maximize the spectral efficiency.
It is also possible to define a virtual subcarrier spacing configuration supported by the carrier, which is equal to Δf0′=Δf0/N. Therefore, the granularity of the implementation of the guard band is of N*Δf0′=Δf0 which offers a granularity to set the size of the guard band of one subcarrier of subcarrier spacing configurations Δf0. The smaller Δf0 is chosen the more accurately the size of the guard band can be chosen with the cost of a higher signaling overhead.
According to an aspect of the invention, the number L, L≥1, satisfies to:
q·L+NRBstart(0)≤NRB(0)
where:
If fref is also the lowest frequency among the subcarriers that are allowable for subcarrier spacing Δf0 in the carrier, then
Indeed, the reference frequency (fref(i)) of each numerology can be different, these cases are covered by the present invention.
Alternatively the size L could be understood as excluding the resource block containing the guard band. Therefore in this specific case the L values starts with the value 0. Deducing equivalent formulae when L is understood as excluding the resource block containing the guard band based on the current description which considers L as including the resource block containing the guard band is straightforward.
According to an aspect of the invention, the method further comprises the step of sending to the terminal allocation information based on the subcarriers allocated to the terminal. This enables the terminal to be informed of which subcarriers of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1 are allocated to it.
According to an aspect of the invention the allocation information sent to the terminal is a resource indication value, RIV, which is an integer and a function of L and NRBstart(0). Since for a fstart there is one NRBstart(0) and for a flast, depending on the fstart there is a L, for each allocation of contiguous subcarriers of the same subcarrier spacing configuration achieved according to the invention there exist one couple NRBstart(0) and L an therefore at least a RIV value.
Based on each couple of NRBstart(0) and L, the terminal can recover fstart and flast, fstart being the lowest frequency among frequencies of subcarriers with subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1 having a frequency higher than the frequency of the subcarrier with subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 allowable with the highest frequency among the subcarriers of the NRBstart(0) resource blocks comprising N subcarriers of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 defined above, and flast being the frequency fref+m·N·Δf1+(L·N−1)·Δf1, where m can be recovered with fstart, (m=└(fstart−fref)/N·Δf1┘).
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV function is an injective function of any couple comprising L and NRBstart(0) values. This enables the terminal which receives a RIV value according to the resources that have been allocated to it, to decode a unique couple NRBstart(0) and L.
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV is a surjective function among the integers from 0 to the maximum value taken by RIV. This ensure that the maximum value taken by RIV when going through the different possible resource allocation according to the invention, that is the different pairs of L and NRBstart(0) values with qL+NRBstart(0)≤NRB(0), is the lowest possible. This enables to reduce the number of bits necessary for signaling all the possible resource allocations achieved according to the invention.
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV is defined by:
Where:
This enables a transmitter to code at least a RIV value for each resource allocation achieved according to the invention, this coding being of low complexity.
In addition this enables the terminal which receives a RIV value according to the resources that have been allocated to it to decode a couple of values NRBstart(0) and L.
Indeed the terminal obtains data related to the subcarrier spacing configuration (for example: Δf1 and Δf0, Δf1 and q or Δf0 and q) of the resource blocks that are allocated to it and of the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0). When the terminal further receives the RIV value, the terminal can then decode the couple NRBstart(0) and the L as it follows:
based on NRB(0) and q, the terminal computes:
based on reception of its RIV value the terminal computes:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV is defined by:
Where:
This enables a transmitter to code at least a RIV value for each resource allocation achieved according to the invention, this coding being of low complexity.
In addition this enables the terminal which receives a RIV value according to the resources that have been allocated to it to decode a couple of values NRBstart(0) and L.
Indeed the terminal obtains data related to the subcarrier spacing configuration (for example: Δf1 and Δf0, Δf1 and q or Δf0 and q) of the resource blocks that are allocated to it and of the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0). When the terminal further receives the RIV value, the terminal can then decode the couple NRBstart(0) and the L as follows:
based on NRB(0) and q, the terminal computes:
based on reception of its RIV value the terminal computes:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV is defined by:
Where:
This enables a transmitter to code at least a RIV value for each resource allocation achieved according to the invention, this coding being of low complexity.
In addition this enables the terminal which receives a RIV value according to the resources that have been allocated to it to decode a couple of values NRBstart(0) and L.
Indeed the terminal obtains data related to the subcarrier spacing configuration (for example: Δf1 and Δf0, Δf1 and q or Δf0 and q) of the resource blocks that are allocated to it and of the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0). When the terminal further receives the RIV value, the terminal can then decode the couple NRBstart(0) and the L as follows:
based on N and q, the terminal computes:
based on reception of its RIV value the terminal computes:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
According to an aspect of the invention, the RIV is defined by:
Where:
This enables the transmitter to code a RIV value for each resource allocation achieved according to the invention, this coding being of lower complexity than the coding of the RIVs previously defined, but in return the decoding of the couple NRBstart(0) and the L by the terminal which receives the RIV value is more complex than the decoding of the previous RIV.
Indeed the terminal obtains data related to the subcarrier spacing configuration (for example: Δf1 and Δf0, Δf1 and q or Δf0 and q) of the resource blocks that are allocated to it and of the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0). When the terminal further receives the RIV value, the terminal can then decode the couple NRBstart(0) and the L as follows:
based on NRB(0), q and the RIV value the terminal received, the terminal calculates the value M such as:
then the terminal calculates NRBstart(0) and L as follows:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
Like previously mentioned the decoding of this RIV is more complex since each time the terminal decodes the RIV it needs to calculate the sums Σl=1M−1 Sl or at least load it from a lookup table which requires more calculating resource to decode and/or more memory storage than the previous RIV.
According to an aspect of the invention, the carrier, the resource allocation and the terminal are defined according to a wireless communication protocol being a 5G protocol.
According to an aspect of the invention, the carrier, the resource allocation and the terminal are defined according to a wireless communication protocol being a New Radio standard according to 3GPP standard.
A second aspect of the invention concerns a transmitter configured for allocating resource to a terminal in a telecommunication system comprising at least a carrier comprising several subcarriers, said carrier supporting at least one subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 and one subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1, with Δf1=q·Δf0, q being a positive integer, said transmitter being configured to perform:
a) selecting the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1;
b) determining a number L of resource blocks having subcarriers of said subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1;
c) allocating to said terminal subcarriers among the subcarriers of the carrier of subcarrier spacing configurations Δf1, having their frequencies:
According to an aspect of the invention, the transmitter comprises a memory unit storing, for each couple of possible values of a number NRBstart(0) and said L a unique resource indication value RIV, NRBstart(0) being a maximum number of resource blocks comprising N subcarriers of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 that are allowable in said carrier during a time period of a resource block comprising N subcarriers of said subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0, said resource blocks having all their subcarriers frequencies lower than said frequency fstart.
More particularly, the transmitter is further configured to:
For example the processor of the transmitter can enter the values of a number NRBstart(0) and L in a lookup table corresponding to the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 of the subcarriers that are allocated to it and to the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0), which provides in return the corresponding RIV value.
According to an alternative of the aspect of the invention where the memory unit has in its memory for each couple of possible values of a number NRBstart(0) and L a unique resource indication value RIV, the processor can calculate the RIV by applying the formulas mentioned above.
A third aspect of the invention concerns a terminal, in a telecommunication system, configured to use allocated resources in a carrier, said resources having been allocated according to anyone of claims 1 to 13, comprises:
According to an alternative the terminal further comprises a memory unit storing for each couple of possible values of a number NRBstart(0) and said L a unique resource indication value RIV, NRBstart(0) being a maximum number of resource blocks comprising N subcarriers of the first subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 that are allowable in said carrier during a time period of a resource block comprising N subcarriers of said subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0, said resource blocks having all their subcarriers frequencies lower than said frequency fstart, and more particularly the processing module is configured to read said memory unit and determine the couple values L and NRBstart(0) and recover fstart and flast, upon reception of an RIV value in said resource allocation information.
For example the processing module of the terminal enters the RIV value that he received in a lookup table corresponding to the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 of the subcarriers that are allocated to it, and to the carrier band with respect to another numerology NRB(0), which provides in return the corresponding couple of a number NRBstart(0) and L values.
According to the present invention the terminal encompasses all types of terminals, for instance mobile phones, vehicle communication systems and all kinds of connected devices and more generally all end systems.
According to an alternative of the aspect of the invention where the memory unit has in its memory for each couple of possible values of a number NRBstart(0) and L a unique resource indication value RIV, the processing module can calculate the couple of a number NRBstart(0) and L values by applying the calculating steps mentioned above which enables to calculate a number NRBstart(0) and a number L corresponding to a specific RIV.
For example the terminal receives the RIV and based on the knowledge of NRB(0) and q and on the RIV value the terminal received, the processing module calculates the value M such as:
Then the processing module calculates NRBstart(0) and L as follows:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
A fourth aspect of the invention concerns a computer program product comprising code instructions to perform the method as describe previously when said instructions are run by a processor.
The present invention is illustrated by way of example, and not by way of limitation, in the figures of the accompanying drawings, in which like reference numerals refer to similar elements and in which:
Referring to
The transmitter 1 comprises one communication module (COM_trans) 3, one processing module (PROC_trans) 4 and a memory unit (MEMO_trans) 5. The MEMO_trans 5 comprises a non-volatile unit which retrieves the computer program and a volatile unit which retrieves the allocation parameters. The PROC_trans which is configured to determine the resource allocation information, such as a RIV value, according to the resource blocks that are allocated to the terminal. The COM_trans is configured to transmit to the terminal the resource allocation information.
The terminal comprises one communication module (COM_term) 6, one processing module (PROC_term) 7 and a memory unit (MEMO_term) 8. The MEMO_term 8 comprises a non-volatile unit which retrieves the computer program and a volatile unit which retrieves the parameters of the carrier and the resource allocation information. The PROC_term 7 is configured to determine the subcarriers that are allocated to the terminal according to the resource allocation information. The COM_term 6 is configured to receive from the transmitter a resource allocation information.
In the following, only part of the carrier band or part of a pre-defined portion of the carrier band is represented.
Referring to
To a numerology and more specifically to a subcarrier spacing configuration corresponds a raster, in which the socket of the raster corresponds to the size of a resource block of the same numerology in the frequency domain. All the resource blocks are scheduled aligned on this raster. Each potential resource block aligned on the raster is indexed to an integer number. For example in the logical region each of the NRB virtual resource blocks is numbered from 0 to NRB−1. Several scheme of allocation exist, for example in LTE/LTE-A resource allocation type 2 is a compact format indicating to a terminal a set of contiguously virtual resource blocks which are allocated to it for downlink or uplink transfer. Therefore a resource indication value (RIV) corresponding to the number NRBstart of the first contiguous resource block RBstart allocated to the terminal and a length L in terms of virtually contiguously allocated resource blocks, is sent to the terminal. The RIV may be defined by:
RIV=NRB(L−1)+NRBstart if (L−1)≤└N/2┘,
RIV=NRB(NRB−L+1)+(NRB−1−NRBstart), otherwise.
Where NRBstart is the number corresponding to the position of RBstart.
The RIV value enables the terminal to decode the position of the first virtual resource block RBstart which is allocated to it and the number of virtually contiguous resource blocks that are allocated to the terminal. Once RBstart and L are decoded the terminal is able to define the resource blocks that where allocated to it. In the example of
Referring to
It should be noted that for certain subcarrier spacing configurations one extra RB can exist if fractional RBs containing less than N subcarriers are allowed for example at band edge. For the numerical example {Δf0, Δf1, Δf2}={kHz, 30 kHz, 60 kHz} and with N=12 subcarriers per resource block. The boxes represent resource blocks containing 12 subcarriers in the frequency domain
Like mentioned above, between two subcarriers of different subcarrier spacing configurations, equally to resource blocks of different subcarrier spacing configurations a guard band (represented on
For this reason it is necessary to include a guard band between two resource block of two different numerologies. As shown in
For the simplicity of the expose, in
Referring to
The situation is similar between the last subcarrier of the resource allocation of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf2 and the following subcarrier of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf1.
More specifically the first subcarrier of the resource allocation of subcarriers of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf2 is made according to the raster of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0. This enables to set the size of the guard band with a scale of N·Δf0, which is more flexible than a scale of N·Δf2. Therefore, the transmitter can determine a guard band of N·Δf0, 2·N·Δf0 or 3·N·Δf0. It is important to notice that when a guard band is set, for instance k·N·Δf0, it is possible that no subcarrier of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf2 exist at k·N·Δf0, this is the case when q2, such as Δf2=q2·Δf0, is not a divisor of N. In this case the SCstart of the resource allocation is the first subcarrier of the subcarrier spacing configuration Δf2 after the guard band.
To allocate such a resource allocation the transmitter defines the number NRBstart(0) of resource blocks of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf0 containing subcarriers with frequencies lower than the frequency of the end of the guard band. In addition the transmitter defines the number L, L−1 corresponding to the resource block of subcarrier spacing configuration Δf2 (L(2) on
Therefore a specific RIV is defined as a function of L and NRBstart(0).
For example:
Where r2 is the remainder of the division of NRB(0) by q2 (In the example of
Referring to
At step S11 the transmitter sends to the terminal parameters concerning the cell settings including the carrier bandwidth BW and information on supported numerologies. More specifically the transmitter sends to the terminal information allowing the terminal to know directly or deduce at least the following parameters: Δf0, Δf2, NRB(0).
At step S12 the transmitter sends to the terminal the allocation parameters, for example, indications allowing the terminal to deduce which type of subcarriers (subcarrier spacing configuration of the resource blocks) will be allocated to the terminal and therefore which set of formulae or lookup table will be necessary to decode the RIV value, if several sets are possible.
At step S13 the transmitter defines the contiguous subcarriers it allocates to the terminal.
At step S14 the transmitter sends the RIV value through a control channel. The RIV value is calculated with the RIV formula mentioned above based on the contiguous subcarriers the transmitter allocates to the terminal.
Referring to
At step S21 the terminal receives from the transmitter the parameters concerning the cell settings including the carrier bandwidth BW and information on supported numerologies. More specifically the terminal receives from the transmitter information allowing the terminal to know directly or deduce at least the following parameters: Δf0, Δf2, NRB(0).
At step S22 the terminal receives from the transmitter the allocation parameters, for example indications allowing the terminal to deduce which type of subcarriers (subcarrier spacing configuration of the resource blocks) will be allocated to it and therefore which set of formula or lookup table will be necessary to decode the RIV value, if several sets are possible.
At step S23 the terminal receives from the transmitter through a control channel, the RIV value corresponding to the subcarriers allocated to the terminal.
At step S24 based on:
Based on the values NRBstart(0) and L, decoded by the terminal, the terminal can determine a unique fstart and a unique flast as shown above.
Of course, the present invention is not limited to the examples of embodiments described in details above, but encompasses also further alternative embodiments.
For example the present invention refers to carrier band of a specific bandwidth but the invention can also be implemented on a pre-defined portion of the entire carrier band, more specifically the pre-defined portion seen by a terminal as the maximum band where its own resource allocation and control signaling can occur.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
16306449 | Nov 2016 | EP | regional |
17305171 | Feb 2017 | EP | regional |
17305326 | Mar 2017 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/JP2017/040341 | 11/1/2017 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2018/084322 | 5/11/2018 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20190222348 | Zhang | Jul 2019 | A1 |
20200169375 | Yi | May 2020 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2 830 378 | Jan 2015 | EP |
Entry |
---|
Japanese Office Action for Japanese Application No. 2018-566985, dated Jan. 28, 2020, with English translation. |
ZTE et al., “About RB Grid Definition and Handling Inter-numerology Interference in NR,” 3GPP TSG-RAN WG1 Meeting #86bis, R1-1608963, Lisbon, Portugal, Oct. 10-14, 2016, 9 pages. |
Ericsson, Mixed Numerology in an OFDM System [online], 3GPP TSG, 4 1 to R 165833, R, and R RAN WG1#85, Internet <URL:http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/tsg_ran/WG1_RL1/TSGR1_1902/Docs/R1165833.zip>, May 30, 2016. |
Notice of Reasons for Refusal issued in corresponding Japanese Application No. 2019-519449 dated Nov. 12, 2019. |
Panasonic, Resource allocation of PDSCH for Rel.13 MTC [online], 3GPP TSG/RAN WG1#83, Internet <URL:http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/tsg_ran/WG1_RL1/TSGR1_83/Docs/R1, R 1 - 156946 (documents showing well-known arts) 156946.zip>, Nov. 6, 2015. |
Alcatel-Lucent Shanghai Bell et al., “Design of Scheduling Assignment,” R1-142050, 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #77, Seoul, Korea, May 19-23, 2014, pp. 1-4. |
Anritsu Ltd. et al., “Update 7.1.7.x test cases with UE Category 11 and 12 information,” R5-155783, 3GPP TSG-RAN WG5 Meeting #69, Anaheim, USA, Nov. 16-20, 2015, pp. 1-98. |
Ericsson, “Mixed Numerology in an OFDM System,” R1-165833, 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #85, Nanjing, May 23-27, 2016, pp. 1-9. |
Panasonic, “Resource allocation of PDSCH for Rel.13 MTC,” R1-156946, 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #83, Anaheim, USA, Nov. 15-22, 2015, pp. 1-3. |
Qualcomm Europe [TSG-RAN WG1], “[Draft] LS Response to Semi-Persistent Scheduling Activation with single PDCCH,” R1-083782, 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #54bis, Prague, Czech, Sep. 29-Oct. 3, 2008, pp. 1-2. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190306860 A1 | Oct 2019 | US |