This application is a 35 U.S.C. § 371 national stage application of PCT International Application No. PCT/EP2020/054181 filed on Feb. 18, 2020, the disclosure and content of which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.
The invention relates to a method for automatically detecting clogging of a sensor pipe extending between a pressure sensor and an exhaust manifold of an internal combustion engine.
The invention can be applied in medium and heavy-duty vehicles, such as trucks, buses and construction equipment. Although the invention will be described with respect to a truck, the invention is not restricted to this particular vehicle, but may also be used in other vehicles such as buses, working machines and boats.
In known manner, an internal combustion engine may include an exhaust pressure sensor for measuring the exhaust pressure (also known as “Back pressure”) and use it as a control parameter of the engine. The exhaust pressure sensor is usually not directly connected to the exhaust manifold, but to a pipe which is connected to the exhaust manifold. This pipe should not be confused with the exhaust pipe which leads the exhaust gas to the atmosphere. To avoid any misunderstanding, the exhaust pressure sensor pipe will be named as “P3 pipe” in this paper.
The exhaust back pressure is the pressure measured in the exhaust manifold after the exhaust valves of the engine and before the turbine.
This pressure is controlled by means of the EPG (Exhaust Pressure Governor, also known as exhaust flap), mainly for two reasons:
The first reason is to perform an exhaust brake. Indeed, at increased exhaust back pressure levels, the engine has to compress the exhaust gases to a higher pressure, which involves additional mechanical work and/or less energy extracted by the exhaust turbine which can affect intake manifold boost pressure. Hence, the power will decrease resulting into an engine brake.
The second reason is to help the engine to quicker reach the correct work temperature. Over time, the exhaust sensor pipe (or P3 pipe) can get clogged with soot, or can rust through. All of these will degrade engine performance and reduce efficiency. A partially clogged P3 pipe will make, for instance, the exhaust sensor to slow down its measurements. This will have a negative side effect to the different Air & Gas actuators, especially to the exhaust flap. A wrong control of the exhaust flap could drive to critical effects on EATS (Exhaust After-Treatment System)
JP2018048561A discloses a clogging detection system for an exhaust pressure sensor tube 30a of an internal combustion engine and the associated method. This publication explains that if the tube 30a gets clogged, the pressure of the exhaust gas Ga in the exhaust passage 15 is not fully transmitted to the exhaust pressure sensor 30 and the pressure value P sensed by the exhaust pressure sensor 30 will be significantly smaller than the actual pressure. This publication teaches to monitor the exhaust back pressure when the exhaust brake valve 22 is closed. Normally, i.e. when the pressure sensor tube is clear (not clogged), the exhaust back pressure should raise significantly. If the sensor does not measure such pressure increase, it means that the pressure sensor tube is at least partly clogged. In practice, D1 teaches to compare the pressure value P measured by the sensor after the exhaust valve brake has been closed to a pre-set value P1, if P is inferior to P1, then it is considered that the pressure pipe (“P3 pipe”) is clogged.
An object of the invention is to provide a new method for the detection of P3 pipe clogging, which is simple for implementation (software solution) and which can be immediately available (without any supplementary hardware).
The method of JP2018048561A is based on the P3 sensor measures but the strategy is different from that of the invention. Typically, the method of the invention is not intrusive at engine level. To the contrary, the strategy of JP2018048561A involves to get the control over the exhaust flap to perform an analysis, while the strategy of the invention is fully transparent and does not need of any specific control over the different actuators. Another fact is that the method of the invention does not consist in comparing the measured pressure to a predefined value, but analyses and monitors its behaviour during the driving cycle. In the example, it seems that competitors are basing in absolute magnitude of P3 signal to perform an analysis instead of analysing its behaviour, thing that we have done in our solution.
The implementation of this new method will enable to save a lot of time and money in aftermarket operations. This solution will enable to perform predictive maintenance and inform the customer (vehicle's owner) that intervention is needed on the engine before a more severe problem happens.
The object of the invention is achieved by a method for automatically detecting clogging of a sensor pipe extending between a pressure sensor and an exhaust manifold of an internal combustion engine, wherein the pressure sensor enables to record a signal representative of the relative pressure over time. According to the invention, the method includes at least one of the following steps:
According to advantageous, but not compulsory aspects of the invention, the method can include one or more of the following features, considered solely or in combination:
The invention also concerns an internal combustion engine (ICE) assembly comprising an exhaust manifold, a pressure sensor and a sensor pipe extending between the exhaust manifold and the pressure sensor. According to the invention, said engine assembly further includes an Electronic Control Unit (ECU) for detecting clogging of the sensor pipe, using the method as defined above. Typically, the ECU it is referred to is preferably the Control unit of the engine, which means that there is one and the same ECU for controlling the engine and for implementing the method of diagnostic of the invention.
Preferably, the engine is a four-stroke engine. It can be either a CI (compression Ignition) engine or a SI (Spark Ignition) engine.
Preferably, wirings or wireless means connect the Electronic Control Unit (ECU) to the pressure sensor.
Advantageously, the Electronic Control Unit is configured for receiving one or more operating parameters of the engine, such as i) the engine speed and torque or ii) the fuel consumption and for processing the received information to check that said operating parameter(s) is or are stable over time, i.e. that a steady operation state has been reached, before implementing step a) of the method.
Eventually, the invention concerns a vehicle comprising an internal combustion engine assembly as defined above.
Typically, the vehicle is a medium-duty or heavy-duty vehicle, such as a truck.
Further advantages and advantageous features of the invention are disclosed in the following description.
With reference to the appended drawings, below follows a more detailed description of two embodiments of the invention cited as examples.
In the drawings:
In variant, the invention can obviously be applied to other types of vehicles, typically to any vehicle comprising an internal combustion engine: It can be a bus, a passenger car, a boat or a working machine.
The ICE assembly 10 further comprises a pressure sensor 14 and a sensor pipe 16 extending between the exhaust manifold 12 and the pressure sensor 14. In the following, sensor pipe 16 can be referred to as the “P3 pipe”.
The pressure sensor 14 enables to record a signal representative of the relative pressure inside the exhaust manifold 12 over the time.
The ICE assembly 10 further includes an Electronic Control Unit (ECU), represented on
Typically, the ECU is connected to the pressure sensor 14, through wire(s) or wirelessly, so that the data measured by the pressure sensor 14 are sent as input parameter to the ECU.
Advantageously, the above-mentioned ECU is the ECU controlling the operation of the engine. Typically, this ECU controls, among others, the strategy of fuel injection into the cylinders of the engine, depending on the acceleration requested by the driver (throttle input). In a variant, the ECU that is used to implement the method of the invention can be different from that of the ECU controlling the operation of the engine, which means that it can be a different (additional) ECU.
Normally, the exhaust pressure (or “Back pressure”) has at least two pikes.
The first pike is produced by the cylinders spontaneous discharge due to the opening of the exhaust valves. Before the end of each of the engine's working stroke, the exhaust valve opens and the high-pressure combustion exhaust is released into the exhaust manifold. Due to the intermittent opening and closing of the exhaust door of the engine, the high pressure exhaust from the cylinder is transmitted along the exhaust manifold in the form of compression wave pulse.
The second pike is due to the ascending movement of the piston. This phase finishes when the piston reaches the upper dead point (or Top Dead Center), namely at the end of the exhaust stroke and at the beginning of intake stroke respectively.
Those wave pulses reach highly noticeable values even at idle conditions and with a fully functional P3 pipe 16. When the pipe 16 is partially clogged, this value is decremented (approximately 5-6 times its normal value). When the P3 pipe 16 gets fully clogged, the pressure value measured by the sensor 14 gets steady, meaning that oscillations are no longer detected.
This is due to the constitution of the plug (not shown) which has naturally been formed inside the P3 pipe 16. Precisely, this plug (or obstruction) has a porous constitution, so that the actual amplitude of the pressure wave that enters to the P3 pipe 16 gets filtered once it passes through the plug.
Normally, the amplitude of the P3 oscillations is greater at high engine load (engine torque) and high engine speed (red field in engine map). It can be noticed that with a clogged P3 pipe (right picture), the amplitude of the P3 oscillations remains constant in all engine map.
Even at idle conditions (Engine ON, vehicle stopped), the difference is noticeable between both cases. Nevertheless, the greatest difference can be found at high engine load and speed.
In the Embodiment of
For the record, the engine is considered to be in a “steady operation state” when the amount of fuel injected in the engine cylinders is approximately stable over time. This is to be opposed to a “transient state” in which the amount of fuel is not really stable. The “steady operation state” can also be known as a state in which the engine speed and torque remain constant.
Therefore, and in order to determine whether the engine is in a steady operation state, the ECU can monitor the evolution of the amount of fuel injected into the engine cylinders. Since such control is known as such, it is not detailed further herein.
Typically, an example of a steady operation state is the “idle state” in which the vehicle is stopped with the engine ON and disengaged from the wheels. Another example of a steady operation state is the “coasting state”, in which the vehicle is moving with engine ON and disengaged from the wheels. Another example of a steady operation state is the “cruising state” in which the vehicle moves at a constant speed on a flat road.
Typically, the first period of time T1 is comprised between 5 s and 10 s.
In detail, and as represented on
In this embodiment, and as shown on
Exhaust Back Pressure Fast Acquisition (1):
In the example, the exhaust back pressure (“raw” pressure) is acquired every certain CAD slot (Crank Angle Degree), which is inherent to the number of cylinders of the engine. Typically, the exhaust back pressure can be acquired every 22.5° CAD (Crank Angle Degree) for a 4-cylinder application and every 15° CAD for a 6-cylinder application.
Crankshaft degrees is a unit (equal to one “ordinary” degree) that is used to measure the piston travel (position) e.g. to adjust ignition. A four-stroke cycle engine is an internal combustion engine that utilizes four distinct piston strokes (intake, compression, power, and exhaust) to complete one operating cycle. The piston makes two complete passes in the cylinder to complete one operating cycle. An operating cycle involves two revolutions (720°) of the crankshaft. In other words, in a four-stroke engine, the crankshaft turns twice for the ignition cycle. When the piston is at its highest point, known as the Top Dead Center (TDC), the crankshaft angle (crank angle) is at 0° crank angle degree.
As shown on
This step corresponds to an exhaust back pressure fast acquisition (Step 1 on
Exhaust Back Pressure Oscillations (3):
As shown on
The amplitude of the exhaust pressure wave is then obtained from the difference between the maximum and the minimal value stored into this data buffer.
In order to improve the robustness of the solution and to avoid biasing the diagnostic because of misfire phenomena (when one or more of the cylinders inside the engine fail to fire correctly), the buffer length (i.e. the time period T1 on
Indeed, when a misfire happens in one cylinder, the amplitude of the pressure wave will drastically decrease, and this could be mistaken with a clogged P3 pipe.
In other words, it is known that the cylinders of an internal combustion engine are ignited following a specific cycle that is known as the ignition cycle. This means that the combustion phases inside the cylinders are carried out sequentially in time. Accordingly, an ignition cycle includes a plurality of successive combustion phases, whose number obviously depends on the number of the cylinders of the engine. Typically, the number of combustion phases during the ignition cycle is equal to the number of cylinder of the engine.
If the time period T1 would be chosen as inferior or equal to the combustion phase of one cylinder, and that misfire happens in that specific cylinder, then the amplitude of the measured wave would be very low and this could be interpreted as arising from pipe clogging. To avoid such misinterpretation, the time period T1 is chosen to encompass at least two, preferably three successive combustion phases (in three different cylinders), i.e. to last enough time to record the data during at least two, preferably three successive combustion phases. More precisely, the time period T1 can be chosen so that the whole sequence of ignition can be recorded. In that way, the wave pulses can be detected even if the combustion inside one or more of the engine cylinders has failed.
In the example of
Exhaust Back Pressure Oscillations Diagnostic (5):
In order to start the evaluation, the Air & Gas actuators of the engine (including the Intake Throttle Valve (ITV), the Exhaust Pressure Governor (EPG), the EGR (Exhaust Gas Recirculation) Valve and Variable Geometry Turbine (VGT)) should reach a target position. In addition, Engine Speed and Torque should reach a target position as well and remain at a steady state.
It is possible, by calibration, to reach any point in the engine map. The points around idle speed could benefit from a high level of opportunities during a driving cycle to perform successful evaluations. Nevertheless, even if the difference in terms of amplitude of back pressure oscillations between a clogged pipe and a non-clogged P3 pipe is very noticeable, it would be preferable to run the diagnostic when the engine is in idle operation state.
Once said conditions are fulfilled, the software (i.e. the ECU) will start the amplitude evaluation of the back exhaust pressure oscillations.
Precisely, the ECU calculates the average amplitude of the back pressure waves during the time period T1. To do that, and as shown on
The sensor pipe 16 is considered as being clogged when said average amplitude is lower than a first threshold. In this case, a signal is sent to the driver. Such signal is preferably a light that is displayed on the vehicle dashboard.
In the example, the first threshold is variable depending on the operating point of the engine, which is given by the engine torque and speed. Indeed, and as mentioned above, the higher are the engine load (torque) and speed, the higher are the amplitude of the oscillations.
Engine torque and speed are parameters that are known at each time. In other words, these are input parameters to the ECU provided for controlling the operation of the engine.
Basically, the first threshold can be derived from a pre-established 3D-map in which the first threshold (1D) is determined for each engine speed (2D) and torque (3D). Such 3D-map can be based on experiment and/or on a theoretical model.
Typically, said first threshold is a percentage, for example 50%, of an expected normal average amplitude.
Another abnormal behaviour that can be detected through the method is a slow “response” of the P3 sensor 14 during a specific event, in which the exhaust pressure is expected to change. For example, it is known that, when the engine is turned off, the pressure inside the exhaust manifold (or Exhaust back pressure) is expected to drop to the atmospheric pressure. However, when a plug (or obstruction) is formed inside the P3 pipe 16, i.e. when the P3 pipe is clogged, the plug acts as a filter, which implies that the signal measured by the P3 sensor 14 does not change as fast as the real pressure inside the exhaust manifold. Typically, when the P3 pipe is clogged, the pressure sensor 16 can measure a pressure drop of 10 kPa during 1 ms (for example), while the real pressure inside the exhaust manifold has dropped by 50 kPa during the same time period. The evolution of the signal recorded by the pressure sensor 14 after a specific event (at which the pressure is expected to change) is known as the “response” of the signal.
In the Embodiment of
In the example, the second period of time corresponds to the period between the time at which the engine 10 is shut off and the time at which the Electronic Control Unit (ECU) of the engine 10 is shut off. This period of time is comprised between 1 s and 10 s.
In this embodiment, and as shown on
Exhaust Back Pressure Filtered (2):
In this method, the “raw” exhaust back pressure measured by the sensor 14 is filtered by means of a Finite Impulse Response (FIR) filter in order to prepare the signal for the next steps. This step corresponds to the exhaust back pressure filtration (Step on
Exhaust Back Pressure Response (4):
A target exhaust back pressure can be set by the ECU of the ICE, as a function of the operation point (speed, torque) of the engine. In this respect, the exhaust back pressure can be controlled by different actuators, such as the EPG, VGT, ITV or WG (Waste Gate) in order to reach said target exhaust back pressure. Typically, when engine braking is to be achieved, then the Back pressure has to be increased up to a high target in order to enhance braking effect. Another example in which the Back pressure needs to be increased is to help the engine to quicker reach the appropriate working temperature, for instance to regenerate one or more components of the EATS, such as the DPF.
Normally, when a new target exhaust back pressure is set, the pressure value measured by the pressure sensor 14 should normally change to meet the new target (with a time response of maximum 500 ms). However, if the P3 pipe 16 to which is connected the sensor 14 is clogged, the time response can be longer, for example of 900 ms.
The goal of this diagnostic is to detect when the “response” of the pressure sensor 14 gets slowed down, in order to detect that the P3 pipe 16 is getting clogged.
To do so, an evaluation is performed at each engine stop.
When the engine is turned off (i.e. when the ignition key is switched off), the back pressure (which is considered here as a relative pressure) normally drops to 0 kPa. Thus, an evaluation can be performed at least one time at each driving cycle.
When a potential diagnostic zone is detected, the integral of the filtered back pressure signal [obtained in step (2)] is calculated. Indeed, the integral value is an indicator for the rapidity of the back pressure decrease. So, the higher is the integral, the slower is the signal decrease (or signal drop).
On
To discretize this, this integral is considered as a back pressure “accumulator” during the second period of time T2.
Exhaust Back Pressure Slow Response Diagnostic (6):
To determine if the integral value of the back exhaust pressure is usable to perform the diagnostic, two more complementary conditions can be considered when the engine is turned off (i.e. switched from “On” state to “Off” state):
(1) Engine speed conditions: At the time the engine is turned off, the engine speed value should be between a predefined interval. This is to avoid, prior to the engine stop, engine speed accelerations that may interfere in the back pressure behaviour.
(2) Back exhaust pressure conditions: At the time the engine is turned off, the back pressure value should be between a predefined interval. This is to improve diagnostic robustness, by avoiding too low or too high back pressure levels at engine stopping phase that may have an impact in the back pressure integral calculation.
If all the conditions are fulfilled, then the integral value calculated in step (4) is compared to a second threshold (or fault limit).
Typically, said second threshold is variable depending on the exhaust gas pressure at the time the engine has been turned off.
Indeed, the higher is the exhaust back pressure when the engine is turned off, the longer is the time to reach the atmospheric pressure.
Basically, the second threshold can be derived from a pre-established 1D-map in which the second threshold (1D) is determined for each exhaust back pressure. Such 1D-map can be established using experimental data and/or on a theoretical model.
For example, said second threshold is a percentage, typically 50%, of an expected normal pressure integral.
A fault will be detected if the integral value of the exhaust back pressure is greater than this fault limit. This means that the sensor pipe 16 is considered as being clogged when the integral of the signal is greater than the second threshold.
Final Decision (7):
Once one evaluation is completed, the results are processed in order to evaluate the final state of the diagnostic.
It is possible, by calibration, to set an alarm in two different ways:
Typically, when the driver receives the alert signal, he has to go the workshop and the P3 pipe should be changed.
Last, but not least, the steps of the method are iteratively implemented as long as the Electronic Control Unit of the engine is on. Basically, the ECU is ON as long as the driver has turned the ignition key in the key lock to awake the system.
It is to be understood that the present invention is not limited to the embodiments described above and illustrated in the drawings; rather, the skilled person will recognize that many changes and modifications may be made within the scope of the appended claims.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2020/054181 | 2/18/2020 | WO |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2021/164849 | 8/26/2021 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20040040285 | Strohmaier | Mar 2004 | A1 |
20050178272 | Kariya | Aug 2005 | A1 |
20080314021 | Sisken | Dec 2008 | A1 |
20090211247 | McEwan | Aug 2009 | A1 |
20100139247 | Hiemstra | Jun 2010 | A1 |
20140069081 | Tylutki | Mar 2014 | A1 |
20140331752 | Hall | Nov 2014 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
102008005989 | Jul 2009 | DE |
102012200917 | Jul 2013 | DE |
102017222313 | Jun 2019 | DE |
2018048561 | Mar 2018 | JP |
2018048561 | Mar 2018 | JP |
Entry |
---|
International Search Report and Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority, PCT/EP2020/054181, dated Aug. 20, 2020, 11 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20230068752 A1 | Mar 2023 | US |