This application is the U.S. national phase, under 35 USC 371, of PCT/EP2006/061653, filed Apr. 19, 2006; published as WO 2006/117291 A2 and A3 on Nov. 9, 2006 and claiming priority to DE 10 2005 020 728.6, filed May 4, 2005 and to DE 10 2005 021 148.8, filed May 6, 2005, the disclosures of which are expressly incorporated herein by reference.
The present invention is directed to methods for controlling and/or for regulating a register in a printing press, as well as to a device for controlling and/or regulating a circumferential register in such a printing press. The printing press has at least one printing unit with at least two printing groups. Each such printing group has a cylinder pair with at least one forme cylinder and one transfer cylinder.
The present invention relates, in particular, to those rotary printing presses in which the printing cylinders of the printing groups each have a groove on their cylindrical surface. This groove extends in the longitudinal direction of the cylinder and is used for the fastening of printing plates, rubber blankets or the like to the surface of the cylinder. In the course of the grooves on cooperating cylinder being overrolled, bending vibrations are generated in the printing cylinders. Such bending vibrations lead to fluctuations in the printing tension in the printing gap. Depending on the size or magnitude of these tension fluctuations, they can result in the formation of stripes in the printed product. The interferences which are caused by such groove overrolling, or groove beats, are all the greater, the wider the groove is.
Changing of the circumferential register of cooperating cylinders of a printing group, or of a printing unit, has an effect on the relative position of the grooves of these adjoining, cooperating printing cylinders, such as, for example, a plate cylinder and a rubber blanket cylinder. In the optimal case of an initial position, the grooves of the two cylinders are located exactly opposite each other. In the case of cylinder grooves of equal width, the effective groove width then corresponds to the actual groove width. In the case of cylinder grooves of differing width, the effective groove width is determined by the width of the wider one of the two grooves. However, if the circumferential register is changed, with respect to this initial position, in the case of certain register settings, a noticeable increase of the effective groove width, and therefore a stronger groove beat, can be produced, which stronger groove beat leads to stronger fluctuation stripes in the printed image.
Depending on the type of printing units, and in particular double printing units on the one hand, and satellite printing units on the other hand, different situations result regarding the appearance of groove beats.
In double printing groups, such as, for example, in bridge printing units, a groove beat occurs, on the one hand, in the rubber blanket cylinder-plate cylinder nip of each printing group, and on the other hand, a groove beat occurs in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip. In the case of an initial position of the adjustment, or of the setting of the circumferential register of 0 mm, the rubber blanket cylinder groove and the plate cylinder groove roll off each other and are centered. The rubber blanket cylinder groove and the plate cylinder groove, as a rule, have different respective widths. Furthermore, in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip, the two rubber blanket cylinder grooves, which are typically of respectively the same width also roll off each other and they are centered.
If, in the case of the rubber blanket cylinder-plate cylinder nip, the difference in the groove width between the rubber blanket cylinder groove and the plate cylinder groove is less than twice the maximally possible circumferential cylinder adjustment, an enlargement of the effective groove width will occur at certain register settings.
In the case of a register change, either the relative position, or angle of a rubber blanket cylinder with respect to another rubber blanket cylinder, or the relative position or angle of the rubber blanket cylinder to the plate cylinder changes as a function of the drive concept.
In the case of the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip, and based on identical sizes of the two blanket cylinder groove widths, there is always an enlargement of the effective groove width as soon as the register setting of one of the printing groups deviates from that of the other printing group. This is the result when the two rubber blanket cylinder grooves are no longer located exactly opposite each other.
What has been set forth above will now be illustrated by the use of an example of a web-fed rotary offset printing press. A plate cylinder groove is deemed to be 3.1 mm and the rubber blanket cylinder groove is 4.1 mm. A maximum adjustment of the circumferential register, with respect to its initial position, of 2.5 mm, in both directions, is possible.
First to be considered is a double printing group, in which the circumferential register adjustment is performed via the plate cylinder atone, i.e. wherein the relative position of the rubber blanket cylinder, in relation to the plate cylinder, is changed. In accordance with the prior art, and in connection with a common drive mechanism for the entire bridge printing group, such as, for example, a full depth tooth system this adjustment can be accomplished by an oblique tooth arrangement between the rubber blanket cylinder and the plate cylinder. An axial movement of a gear wheel causes an angular change between the two cylinders. In an initial position, the rubber blanket cylinder groove encloses the plate cylinder groove on both sides with a 0.5 mm difference. In this configuration,the width of the rubber blanket cylinder groove determines the extent of vibratory excitation. This effective groove width changes as soon as the circumferential register is adjusted by more than 0.5 mm. Enclosing of the plate cylinder groove by the rubber blanket cylinder groove now no longer occurs, and the effective groove width increases beyond the width of the rubber blanket cylinder groove of 4.1 mm. At a maximum circumferential register adjustment of 2.5 mm, a maximal effective groove width of 6.1 mm results at the plate cylinder rubber blanket cylinder nip.
On the other hand, if a double printing group is being considered, in which a circumferential register adjustment is accomplished by the use of a common adjustment of the plate cylinder and of the rubber blanket cylinder, the relative position of the two rubber cylinders in relation to each other is changed. In accordance with the prior art, such an adjustment can be accomplished, for example, by the use of software, via the drive mechanism control, by a common drive mechanism for each one of the two rubber blanket cylinder-plate cylinder pairs. In accordance with appropriate considerations, a maximum effective groove width of 8.2 mm results in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip, with an oppositely equal, respectively maximum circumferential register adjustment in the two printing groups.
What has been said above, basically also applies to satellite printing units, to the extent that the plate cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip is concerned. However, the considerations regarding the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip do not play a role here, since the counter-pressure cylinder does not have a groove.
Corresponding to the various drive mechanism concepts, in the prior art the circumferential register adjustment is performed in the following manner:
First, the situation in which all of the printing groups of a printing unit have a common main drive mechanism will be considered. In this configuration, all of the rubber blanket cylinders and the plate cylinders of the printing unit are connected by gear teeth, and thus constitute a full depth tooth system. In this configuration, the circumferential registers are adjusted by changing the respective angular positions of the individual plate cylinders. This, as a rule, is done by making use of an oblique tooth arrangement in the gear teeth. Therefore, the above-discussed groove widening occurs, essentially in the rubber blanket cylinder-plate cylinder nip.
Next, the situation in which each printing group of a printing unit has its own main drive, or has a drive mechanism in pairs will be considered. In such a paired drive mechanism, the rubber blanket cylinder and the plate cylinder of each respective printing group are connected with each other by gear teeth. An adjustment of the circumferential register is performed in this configuration by the use of software via the angular position of the drive mechanism. Thus, in the case of the circumferential register adjustment, both cylinders are turned in the same way. Their relative angular position, with respect to each other, does not change, and thus there is no groove widening.
Finally, the situation in which each printing cylinder of a printing unit, either satellite or bridge has its own main drive will be considered. In this configuration there is an individual drive mechanism for the plate cylinder as well as one for the rubber blanket cylinder. Here, depending on the solution selected in accordance with the prior art, to adjust the circumferential register, either the angular position of the plate cylinder will be changed. The situation explained above, in connection with the full depth tooth system, then results. Alternatively, the angular positions of the plate cylinder and of the rubber blanket cylinder are adjusted together. The situation explained above, in connection with the drive in pairs, then results.
A method for driving a processing machine, such as, for example, a web-fed rotary printing press, is known from WO 2004/028825 A1. Several units, which are free of linear shafts, such as printing groups, for example, and a unit for further processing, such as, for example, a folding apparatus, are independently driven by drive mechanisms. Signals from a guide shaft position of a virtual guide shaft are conducted in a signal line which is connecting the drive mechanisms. An offset is assigned to the respective drive mechanisms, which offset fixes a permanent, but adjustable displacement of an angular target position, with respect to the guide shaft position.
A color register system for a printing press is known from EP 0 598 490 A1, in which printed images are monitored by the use of a camera. The appropriate color intensities are compared with reference color intensities which are obtained from the printing plates, and register deviations are thereby appropriately corrected.
It has also already been proposed, for regulating a register in a printing press, that an image sensor takes an image of a printing substrate which has been imprinted in the printing group of the printing press. This image is then evaluated in an evaluating unit. The evaluating unit generates the actuating command for an actuating drive mechanism, for use in adjusting the register, from a comparison of an actually recorded image with the data obtained from a previously recorded image.
A method for detecting interferences with the transport of a web of material in a web-fed rotary printing press is known from DE 103 38 973 A1. The print-to-cutting register is monitored and, if a preset threshold value is exceeded, a trouble signal is generated.
DE 44 33 905 A1 discloses a method for adjusting a circumferential register of a printing press having at least one printing unit. In the course of this method, the circumferential register deviations of all printing groups are determined, and the printing groups of at least one printing unit are individually readjusted.
The object of the present invention is directed to methods for controlling and/or for regulating a register in a printing press, as well as to a device for controlling and/or for regulating a circumferential register.
In accordance with the present invention, this object is attained by the provision of a printing press having at least one printing unit which has at least two printing groups. Each of these printing groups includes a cylinder pair with at least a forme cylinder and a transfer cylinder. A phase position of a forme cylinder is adjusted in the circumferential direction by a first amount to attain register adjustment. A phase position of the transfer cylinder of the same printing group is adjusted in the circumferential direction by a second amount. The first and second amounts are not the same and both are not equal to zero. A register deviation can be split into several amounts, each of which is applied to a separate forme cylinder.
The advantages which can be achieved by the present invention consist, in particular, in that less waste of printing materials and/or a higher quality of the printed products is achieved because of the adjustments of the cylinder deviations by the use of two different cylinders. The amount of the register deviation is divided into at least two partial amounts.
In one embodiment of the present invention, the advantage lies in that the main part of the register deviation to be readjusted, namely the mean value of the register deviation existing in each printing group, is compensated for by the regulation of the follow-up processing unit, and in particular of the folding station, such as, for example, the folding arrangement. The printing group shafts then only need to compensate for the respectively remaining difference. Thus, the follow-up processing unit, or the folding station, is regulated relative to the web of material, even before the error, which was formed in the printing groups becomes effective. By the use of this, a regulation of the print-to-cutting register is regulated by the use of a superimposed reaction speed.
In another embodiment of the present invention, which can also be combined with a cutting register adjustment, the advantages to be gained by the use of the present invention consist, in particular, in that all of the drive mechanisms of a printing unit, and in particular on the part of the software, are provided with a common adjustment path in accordance with the determined mean value of the register deviations in all of the printing groups of the printing unit. The individual register adjustment of the individual printing groups of the printing unit, by use of the circumferential adjustment of the plate cylinder, is only performed by the amount of the differential adjustment paths resulting from the calculated difference of the mean value and the circumferential register deviations of the individual printing groups.
Since the calculated differential adjustment paths are always less than the originally determined required adjustment paths in the individual printing groups, the increase in the effective groove width is minimized by this within the meaning of the object on which the present invention is based.
The common adjustment UGEM is calculated from the originally required adjustment paths U1, U2, . . . Un of the n printing groups of a printing unit as the mean value in accordance with
Added to this are the differential adjustment paths ΔU, which are calculated as deviations from the common adjustment path in accordance with
ΔUi=Ui−UGEM.
The required circumferential register adjustment path is now only created to a comparatively small extent, such as, for example, of less than 0.5 mm from non-systematic or statistical deviations from the desired position, as a result of the edges of the plates and the illumination. A large portion of the adjustment path is used for compensating for the differences in the path length between successive print locations of printing units that are arranged along the path of the material to be imprinted, caused by the web path, by web stretching and by roll-off differences of the rubber blankets, or paper feed. Thus, the majority of the required circumferential register adjustment paths is a result of the material to be imprinted, or is a result of the paper web course between successive rubber blanket-paper nips of a web of material to be imprinted, and therefore affects the angular position of all of the printing groups of a printing unit to the same extent.
In the situation of a double printing group, it is therefore possible for the majority of the register adjustment to take place symmetrically, in relation to the web of material to be imprinted, since the nips for both sides of the web of material to be imprinted lie at the same location.
Although, in the case of a satellite printing unit, the nips do not lie at the same location, they are nevertheless located close to each other, so that here, too, a large common adjustment path results in connection with all of the printing groups of the printing unit.
In spite of a good color register, large differences between the register positions on both sides of the web of material to be imprinted can occur in double printing units. This can lead to an undesired increase of the effective groove width in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip. However, for controlling the color register of an m-color print, the color register adjustment of only N−1 printing groups; wherein N is equal to the whole number amount of the printing groups in the printing press is required. For minimizing the effective groove in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip, it has therefore been provided that one of the several printing units of the printing press is designated as the reference printing unit, that the circumferential register of the printing units of this reference printing unit is set to “0”, and that only the printing groups of the other printing units are readjusted. The selected reference printing unit can be any one of the several printing units. The register adjustments, specifically, the common register adjustment and the differential register adjustment, are therefore performed only on the printing groups of the other printing units.
What has been set forth above also applies to web paths in which printing takes place simultaneously by the use of satellite printing units and also by the use of double printing groups.
A substantial advantage of the present invention is that it can be accomplished purely as a software solution. Because of this aspect of the present invention, existing installations can therefore also be retrofitted in a cost-effective manner.
Preferred embodiments of the present invention are represented in the drawings and will be described in greater detail in what follows.
Shown are in:
Referring initially to the web-fed rotary offset printing press represented in
Each printing unit 03, 04, 05, 06 can comprise a forme cylinder 13, a transfer cylinder 14, and at least one counter-pressure cylinder. For making printed products, which are imprinted on both sides, each counter-pressure cylinder is also embodied as a transfer cylinder 14, which, in turn, acts together with a forme cylinder 13 as may be seen in
Only one printing unit 03 of the several printing units 03, 04, 05, 06 has been represented, for example, in
The plate cylinder 13, as well as the rubber blanket cylinders 14, each have a groove, which is not shown in detail, extending on their surface in the longitudinal direction of the respective cylinder 13, 14. Such a groove, in connection with the plate cylinders 13, is used for fastening the printing plate or plates. In connection with the rubber blanket cylinder 14, such a groove is used for fastening the rubber blanket or rubber blankets onto the surface of the blanket cylinder 14.
The method in accordance with the present invention represents a register control. This can either take place manually, i.e. the registration error is detected by the printing press operator, or it can be extended in the form of a regulation by an automatic deviation detection device, such as, for example, a sensor arrangement.
For example, for each printing group 11, 12 of each printing unit 03, 04, 05, 06, the control and/or regulation of the circumferential register includes an arrangement for determining the circumferential register deviation U1, U2. This deviation may be determined, in particular by a sensor device 16, 17 which, in a manner which is generally known, such as, for example, by the use of optical sensors, detects, by the sensing of register markings which are imprinted on the web 01 of material and/or the print image, the circumferential register deviations U1 or U2 between at least two printing groups 11 or 12 of two of the printing units 03, 04, which both imprint the same side of the web 01 of material, and/or between two printing groups 11, 12 outside of a printing unit 03, 04, 05, 06 and/or at least one printing group 11, 12 and a blade cylinder of the folding arrangement 08.
A mean value M is calculated, from the detected circumferential register deviations U1, U2, in an arithmetic device or a calculator or a first computing device 18, for forming a mean value, which calculation can be conducted, for example, in accordance with the equation:
M=(U1+U2)/2.
Furthermore, in a second computing device 19, for use in difference formation, the difference between the respective circumferential register deviation U1 and U2 and the mean value M is determined for each printing group 11, 12 of each one of the printing units 03, 04, 05, 06, i.e. the differential individual adjustment path ΔU1=U1−M and ΔU2=U2−M.
It is understood that the control and/or the regulation of the circumferential register, which will now be explained in connection with the printing unit 03, 04, 05, 06, can be correspondingly also applied to all of the remaining, not specifically represented printing units 03, 04, 05, 06 of the web-fed rotary offset printing press.
In
Assuming, for example, a groove width of a plate cylinder groove of 3.1 mm, and a groove width of the rubber blanket cylinder groove of 4.1 mm, a circumferential adjustment of +1 mm would be required in the printing group 11 and of +1.5 mm in the printing group 12 of the printing unit 03 in comparison with another printing unit 04, 05, 06.
In the above example adjustment, the adjustment of the main drive mechanism 09 of the printing unit 03, in relation to another printing unit 04, 05, 06, then amounts to M=+1.25 mm, because of which no groove widening is created, because the rubber blanket cylinders 14 are not adjusted with respect to each other in the printing unit 03. Then, the differential individual adjustment of the plate cylinder 13 in the printing group 11 is ΔU1=+0.25 mm, and in the printing group 12 ΔU2=−0.25 mm. In the selected example, the adjustment prescription, as a whole, would therefore not result in a groove widening.
In contrast thereto, if, in accordance with the prior art, only the plate cylinder circumferential register would be used for adjusting the required circumferential register, in the printing group 11 a groove widening of 0.5 mm would result, and in the printing group 12 a groove widening of 0.75 mm would result.
A further preferred embodiment of the present invention is represented in
In this further preferred embodiment, as seen in
Now, the mean value M is used as the correcting variable for the regulation of all of the individual drive mechanisms 21 of the printing unit 03. It represents the common adjustment path of the printing groups 11, 12 of the printing unit 03.
In the adjustment example, the common adjustment path of the drive mechanisms 21 of all cylinders 3, 14 then amounts to M=+1.25 mm, because of which no groove widening is formed. The differential individual adjustment of the plate cylinder 13 in the printing group 11 is ΔU1=+0.25 mm, and in the printing group 12 it is ΔU2=−0.25 mm. In the selected example, the adjustment prescription, as a whole, would therefore not result in a groove widening.
In contrast thereto, if, in accordance with the prior art, only the plate cylinder drive mechanism would be used for adjusting the required circumferential register, in the printing group 11 a groove widening of 0.5 mm would result, and in the printing group 12 a groove widening of 0.75 mm would result.
If, alternatively, the two drive mechanisms of the rubber blanket cylinder 14 and of the plate cylinder 13 of each of the printing groups 11, 12, in accordance with the prior art, would be together adjusted by the originally required amount U1 or U2, no groove widening would occur in the rubber blanket cylinder-plate cylinder nip, but a groove widening of 0.5 mm would occur in the rubber blanket cylinder-rubber blanket cylinder nip.
The differential amount of the circumferential register adjustment, which is individual for each of the printing groups 11, 12, is now used as the correcting variable for individual readjustment or re-regulation of the plate cylinder drive mechanism of each of the printing groups 11, 12 of the printing unit 03. This represents the differential individual adjustment path of the printing groups 11, 12 of the printing unit 03.
The arrangement 26 for regulating the cutting register, as may be seen in
Among other factors, the size of the possible cutting register fluctuations is a function of the web length and of the color and damping agent volume applied to the web 01 of material. The register fluctuations to be expected are all the greater the longer the web path to the follow-up processing unit 08 is and/or the greater the applied color and dampening agent volume is.
This mean value MS; which is formed from the weighted register deviations G1, G2, G3, G4, is now used as the correcting variable for regulating the follow-up processing unit 08, such as, in the case of the present preferred embodiment, the folding arrangement 08. In particular, the shaftless drive mechanism 32, as may be seen in of the folding arrangement 08, is regulated via the signal line 31, with respect to the angular position of the driven follow-up processing arrangement, such as, for example, the cutting cylinder 33. The position of the cutting cylinder 33 can be preset by the use of an angle encoder, which is assigned to the cutting cylinder 33, or via a virtual guide shaft.
Moreover, in the arrangement 26 for regulating the cutting register, the difference D is formed for each printing group 11, 12 of the printing unit 03, 04, 05, 06 in an arithmetic or calculating device 34 from the respective weighted register deviations G1, G2, G3, G4 and the mean value MS, i.e. D1=ΔUS1−MS, D2=ΔUS2−MS, D3=ΔUS3−MS and D4=ΔUS4−MS. This difference D is now used as the correcting variable for regulating the printing groups 11, 12 of the printing units 03, 04, 05, 06. In particular, the shaftless drive mechanisms of these printing groups 11, 12 of the printing units 03, 04, 05, 06 in particular are regulated via a signal line 36, with respect to the respective angular position of the respective forme cylinder 13.
The major part of the compensation of the cutting register deviation is performed via the regulation of the rotatory driveshaft of the folding arrangement 08. Only the clearly lesser portion, namely the respective difference D between the weighted register deviation D and the mean value MS of the deviation needs to be compensated by the regulation of the rotatory driveshafts of the printing groups of the printing units 03, 04, 05, 06.
Customarily, the sensor device 17, 16, 27 in the above preferred embodiment detects the respective circumferential deviations of the cylinders of the printing units 03, 04, 05, 06 in the form of a linear measurement. If now, in accordance with another preferred embodiment, the sensor device 16, 17, 27 emits a register signal only when a defined pre-settable threshold is exceeded, it is possible to calculate the common weighted register path to be adjusted as a function of the triggering web 01 of material and to regulate it out, and the difference D can be eliminated via the respective driveshafts of the printing units 03, 04, 05 or 06.
It is to be understood that the present invention is not to be limited to printing presses only with four printing groups. In general, the number of the printing groups is “i,” wherein “i” is a whole number greater than 2. The weighted circumferential offset, or register error, of the respective printing group then is Gi=ai×ΔUi, and the mean value is M=ΣGi/i.
It is furthermore understood that the present invention can also be employed in printing presses wherein units other than folding arrangements 08 are used as follow-up processing units. For example cutting units, perforating units, stamping devices, collecting arrangements, or the like can be used as follow-up processing units. Moreover, such an independently driven unit can also be constituted in the form of traction rollers, skip slitters, register rollers, or the like.
Cutting register deviations of several, and in particular, of all webs covered in a printing press are preferably detected by the use of sensors. From this, a mean deviation of several, and in particular of all cutting registers is calculated, and the phase of a cutting cylinder of the follow-up processing unit 08, which transversely cuts several/all webs, is adjusted by this mean deviation in the circumferential direction relative to the printing groups. It is thus, for example, achieved that a major portion of the register offset is reduced even prior to this portion of the register offset occurring in the follow-up processing unit.
Preferably, an amount of a register deviation and/or an amount of a cutting register deviation is split into at least two partial amounts. The phases of two different cylinders are adjusted in the circumferential direction by the use of these two partial amounts.
The circumferential register adjustment of the printing groups and the cutting register adjustment can be combined with each other.
While preferred embodiments of methods for controlling and/or adjusting a register in a printing machine and a device for controlling and/or adjusting a circumferential register, in accordance with the present invention have been set forth fully and completely hereinabove, it will be apparent to one of skill in the art that various changes in, for example, the specific structures of the printing cylinders, the type of web being printed, and the like could be made without departing from the true spirit and scope of the present invention which is accordingly to be limited only by the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10 2005 020 728 | May 2005 | DE | national |
10 2005 021 148 | May 2005 | DE | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2006/061653 | 4/19/2006 | WO | 00 | 9/14/2007 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2006/117291 | 9/9/2006 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3701464 | Crum | Oct 1972 | A |
3742849 | Greiner et al. | Jul 1973 | A |
3841216 | Huffman | Oct 1974 | A |
4572074 | Guaraldi | Feb 1986 | A |
4614155 | Shimizu | Sep 1986 | A |
5412577 | Sainio et al. | May 1995 | A |
5689425 | Sainio et al. | Nov 1997 | A |
5771805 | Branas et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
6293194 | Vrotacoe | Sep 2001 | B1 |
6499397 | Stern | Dec 2002 | B2 |
6505555 | Kanda | Jan 2003 | B2 |
6526889 | Tokiwa | Mar 2003 | B2 |
6568323 | Tokiwa | May 2003 | B2 |
6647874 | Siegl et al. | Nov 2003 | B1 |
7096789 | Hammond et al. | Aug 2006 | B2 |
20010045166 | Albus et al. | Nov 2001 | A1 |
20020185022 | Stieler et al. | Dec 2002 | A1 |
20040134364 | Schultze et al. | Jul 2004 | A1 |
20050284316 | Rugamer | Dec 2005 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
44 33 905 | Apr 1995 | DE |
103 38 973 | Apr 2004 | DE |
0 598 490 | May 1994 | EP |
0 806 294 | Apr 1997 | EP |
0 882 587 | Dec 1998 | EP |
2 282 565 | Apr 1995 | GB |
WO 2004028805 | Apr 2004 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20080105153 A1 | May 2008 | US |