The present disclosure belongs to the field of non-contact non-destructive detection of blades, and particularly relates to a method for detecting a natural frequency of a blade by a single blade tip timing sensor.
Large-scale heat engines, represented by gas turbines and aeroengines, are national key machines with high reliability requirements and extremely complicated technology. The blade is one of the key parts with the most accidents in these large turbine machines. The performance of the blade directly affects the safety and stability of the aero engines, gas turbines and other devices. Therefore, it is an inevitable trend to ensure the safe operation of high-speed rotating blades and realize real-time online monitoring of blade vibration. Blade cracks, fractures and other damage faults are mostly caused by faults. To ensure the safe operation of rotating machine, higher requirements are put forward for the vibration measurement of the rotating blade. The vibration measurement method of the rotating machine may be divided into contact measurement and non-contact measurement. The contact measurement is a method for acquiring measurement information by direct contact between a sensor and a rotating blade, which has low reliability, short service life and a complicated and time-consuming safety method. The non-contact measurement refers to a measurement method in which a sensor is not in contact with a blade, and can achieve the aim of accurate measurement on the premise of not affecting the operation state of the blade and overcome the disadvantages of the contact measurement. The non-contact rotating blade vibration measurement technology based on a blade tip timing principle has attracted a large number of researchers' attention due to the advantages of simple structure, fast response, small volume and capability of monitoring the vibration of a plurality of blades at the same time. Blade tip timing (BTT) is a method for performing non-contact online measurement on the vibration of a rotating blade, wherein a blade tip timing sensor is radially mounted on a stationary casing of the rotating machine, and the sensor is used to receive a pulse signal which is generated by the rotating blade and passes the front of the sensor so as to record arrival time of the blade. A blade tip timing sampling rate is related to a rotational speed and a number of the sensors, due to the limited mounting position of the sensor in actual situations, blade tip timing data has an excessive undersampling characteristic, and even a rotational speed sensor cannot be mounted. The blade tip displacement measurement with a rotational speed reference method needs to convert an arrival time difference of the blade into blade tip displacement by virtue of the rotational speed. Furthermore, in an actual use, a plurality of blade tip timing sensors are often selected to be used to alleviate the aliasing influence caused by undersampling, but the installation of the rotational speed sensor and the plurality of blade tip timing sensors in the actually limited space will cause great trouble and increase the measurement cost. Traditional methods mostly involve a large number of operations when performing modal parameter identification on uniformly distributed and non-uniformly distributed data of the blade tip timing sensors, so that online real-time detection and diagnosis cannot be realized. In addition, most algorithms directly identify the natural frequency and other parameters of a single blade, resulting in a large error. These are the important reasons why the blade tip timing technology cannot be applied to important devices.
The above information disclosed in the background segment is only used to enhance the understanding of the background of the present disclosure, and therefore may include information which does not constitute the prior art well known to those of ordinary skill in the art in China.
For the problems in the prior art, the present disclosure provides a method for detecting a natural frequency of a blade by a single blade tip timing sensor, thereby evaluating the health state of the blade more rapidly and accurately.
An objective of the present disclosure is achieved by the following technical solution. A method for detecting a natural frequency of a blade by a single blade tip timing sensor includes the following steps:
According to the method, in the first step, the single blade tip timing sensor acquires the actual arrival time t of the rotating blade with uniform acceleration or uniform deceleration, a difference between theoretical arrival time and actual arrival time is converted into a blade tip displacement according to the rotational speed fr and the blade length R of the blade; and an expression is as follows: d(ti,j)=2πR·frj·(ti,j−
where θi represents an angle of the i-th blade based on a mounting position of a rotational speed sensor, αk represents an angle of a k-th sensor based on the mounting position of the rotational speed sensor, and n is the rotational speed.
In the method, the rotating process of the blade is an acceleration or deceleration process of a predetermined acceleration; and in the rotating process, gas nozzles distributed uniformly in a circumferential direction are used to simulate gas excitation.
In the method, for the two segments of displacement data vectors di, dj of two blades at the same rotational speed, intercepted data intervals are both [c−N, c+N], a vector length is 2N+1, where c is an index serial number corresponding to a certain position in the displacement data of the two blades, di is a vector, the length is L, and a position of each element is an index serial number of each element, an index serial number of the first element is 1, and an index serial number of the last element is L.
In the method, a sampling frequency fs of the single sensor is approximate to an average rotational frequency,
where frk represents a rotational speed at a k-th turn, and since the above intercepted data is data with the index serial number [c−N, c+N], the data from a (c−N)-th turn to a (c+N)-th turn is intercepted for the single sensor.
According to the method, in the fourth step, the filtered product vector dijlpf is subjected to Hilbert transform to obtain a plural vector Hdij, the instantaneous phase is calculated by using a relationship between a real part and an imaginary part,
where Im(Hdij) represents an imaginary part vector of the plural vector Hdij, and Re(Hdij) represents a real part vector of the plural vector Hdij.
According to the method, in the fourth step, the instantaneous phase φij is subjected to discrete Fourier transform to obtain spectrum data, an amplitude frequency diagram is drawn, and the natural frequency difference Dfij between the two blades is extracted from the amplitude frequency diagram,
where x(n) is a signal obtained by sampling, i is an imaginary number symbol, i=√{square root over (−1)}, n is an iteration number, traversing is performed from 0 to N−1, that is, all elements in x are taken, k is an integer from 0 to N−1, and X(k) represents k-th data after discrete Fourier transform.
According to the method, in the fifth step, the blades on the bladed disk are combined in pairs to obtain Cn
and the natural frequency of the blade is determined to be abnormal in the case of sumDk>HF.
According to the method provided by the present disclosure, the natural frequency differences between different blades can be extracted from the excessively undersampled data only by using the single blade tip timing sensor and without the rotational speed reference; furthermore, whether a fault is in the blade is determined according to the natural frequency differences between different blades without additional signal reconstruction and more blade tip timing sensors, so that the method is rapid and stable to operate, simple and feasible, and capable of detecting the natural frequency of the rotating blade, thereby detecting the fault of the blade on line.
The above description is merely an overview of the technical solution of the present disclosure. To make the technical means of the present disclosure more comprehensible to be implemented by those skilled in the art in accordance with the content of the description and to make the above and other objectives, features and advantages of the present disclosure more obvious and understandable, the specific implementations of the present disclosure are illustrated below.
Various advantages and benefits become apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art upon reading detailed description of the following preferred specific implementations. The accompanying drawings of the description are merely used to show the preferred implementations, and are not considered as limitations to the present disclosure. Apparently, the accompanying drawings described below are merely some embodiments of the present disclosure, and those of ordinary skill in the art may still derive other drawings from these accompanying drawings without creative efforts. In addition, in all of the accompanying drawings, the same parts are represented by the same reference numerals.
In the accompanying drawings:
The present disclosure is further described below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
The specific embodiments of the present disclosure will be described in detail below with reference to
It should be noted that some terms are used in the description and the claims to refer to specific components. It should be understood by those skilled in the art that technicians may use different names to refer to the same component. The description and the claims do not use the difference in names as a way of distinguishing components, but use the difference in functions as a criterion for distinguishing the components. The word “comprise” or “include” as used throughout the description and claims is an open term and should be interpreted as “including but not limited to”. The subsequent description of the description is about preferred implementation of the present disclosure. However, the description is for the purpose of the general principle of the description, and is not intended to limit the scope of the present disclosure. The protection scope of the present disclosure is defined by the appended claims.
In order to facilitate the understanding of the embodiments of the present disclosure, the specific embodiments will be taken as examples for further explanation and description in combination with the accompanying drawings, and the drawings do not constitute a limitation to the embodiments of the present disclosure.
A method for detecting a natural frequency of a blade by a single blade tip timing sensor includes the following steps.
(1) Arrival time and a rotational speed of a rotating blade are acquired by a blade tip timing sensor, and a difference between theoretical arrival time and actual arrival time is converted into a blade tip displacement according to the rotational speed and a blade length.
In this exemplary example, specifically, a single optical fiber blade tip timing sensor is fixed on a casing, an initial rotational speed is set to 60 Hz, an acceleration of the rotational speed is set to 0.5 Hz/s, and a change range of the rotational speed is 60 Hz-100 Hz-60 Hz, wherein the time for the 100 Hz constant speed segment is 20 seconds. A bladed disk adopts a six-blade integrated aluminum alloy bladed disk, wherein the radius of the bladed disk is R=68 mm, the thickness of the blade is d=1 mm, and the width of the blade is w=20 mm. Four nozzles are uniformly distributed on the casing to spray 0.5 Mpa high-pressure gas. The arrival time of the rotating blade is acquired by a single blade tip timing sensor, a rotational speed of a rotating shaft is acquired by a rotational speed sensor, and the difference between the theoretical arrival time and the actual arrival time is converted into the blade tip displacement according to the rotational speed and the blade length.
(2) Two segments of displacement data vectors of two blades to be analyzed at the approximately same rotational speed are selected. If slow acceleration or deceleration data is selected, the intercepted data is inadvisable to be too long, so as to meet the requirement of an approximately constant sampling frequency is met.
In this exemplary example, specifically, displacement data of a blade 1 and a blade 2 is selected, and a serial number range of the intercepted data is [4840,4970]. As shown in
(3) The two displacement data vectors are subjected to dot product operation to obtain a product vector after the corresponding serial numbers are multiplied, and the data is subjected to low-pass filtering.
In this exemplary example, the intercepted displacement vectors of the blade 1 and the blade 2 are d1 and d2. The intercepted two vectors d1 and d2 are multiplied to obtain a product vector d12 of the blade 1 and the blade 2, as shown in
d
12
=d
1
d
2
T (7)
According to the prior knowledge of the natural frequency of the blade, the absolute value of the natural frequency difference between the blades does not exceed 40 Hz at most. Therefore, 40 Hz is selected to be a cutoff frequency for low-pass filtering of the product vector d12 to obtain d12lpf, as shown in
(4) The filtered product vector is subjected to Hilbert transform to obtain an instantaneous phase, the instantaneous phase is subjected to discrete Fourier transform, and an absolute value of a natural frequency difference between blades is extracted from amplitude frequency data.
In this exemplary example, the product vector is subjected to Hilbert transform to obtain a plural vector, and an expression is as follows:
The instantaneous phase φ12 is calculated according to Hd12, as shown in
The instantaneous phase is subjected to discrete Fourier transform, and an absolute value of a natural frequency difference between the blade 1 and the blade 2 is extracted from amplitude frequency data, as shown in
(5) Blades on a bladed disk are subjected to permutation and combination, the steps (2) to (4) are repeated to obtain absolute values of natural frequency differences of all blades, a sum of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between each blade and other blades is calculated, and when the sum of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences of a certain blade is greater than a set threshold, it is considered that the natural frequency of the blade is abnormal and the blade may have a fault.
In this exemplary example, the bladed disk with six blades is adopted, so nb=6, and it is necessary to calculate C62 frequency differences, and the obtained natural frequency differences of all the combined blades are shown in the following table:
Actually, it is only necessary to calculate 15 groups of blade difference frequencies. According to the above 15 groups of difference frequencies, the sum sumDi of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between each blade and other five blades may be calculated.
A threshold HF=50 Hz is selected, which shows that sumD1, sumD3, sumD5 exceed the set threshold HF, so that it is presumed that the natural frequencies of the blade 1, the blade 3 and the blade 5 are abnormal.
The natural frequency of the rotating blade is identified by a strain gauge and an electrically conductive slip ring, and the obtained results are shown in the following table:
It is known that the normal natural frequencies of the blades of the bladed disk are about 350 Hz, wherein the natural frequencies of the blade 1, the blade 3 and the blade 5 are quite different from 350 Hz. Actually, the roots of the blade 1 and the blade 5 on the bladed disk have tiny cracks, and the natural frequency of the blade 3 is higher due to a machining error. Therefore, by the method provided by the present disclosure, the abnormity of the natural frequency of the blade can be identified by the signal of the single blade tip timing sensor. According to the present disclosure, the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between different blades can be extracted from the excessively undersampled data only by the single blade tip timing sensor; furthermore, the sum of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between each blade and other blades is calculated, whether the natural frequency of the blade is abnormal is determined according to the set threshold HF, thereby determining whether the blade is in fault. According to the method of the present disclosure, additional signal reconstruction and more blade tip timing sensors are not required, the identification system is simple, operation is rapid and stable, simplicity and feasibility are achieved, and real-time health monitoring of the rotating blade can be realized.
On a blade tip timing sensor testbed as shown in
Displacement data of a blade 1 and a blade 2 is selected, and the serial number range of the intercepted data is [4840,4970]. As shown in
The intercepted displacement vectors of the blade 1 and the blade 2 are d1 and d2. The intercepted two vectors d1 and d2 are multiplied to obtain a product vector d12 of the blade 1 and the blade 2, as shown in
d
12
=d
1
d
2
T (10)
According to the prior knowledge of the natural frequency of the blade, the absolute value of the natural frequency difference between the blades does not exceed 40 Hz at most. Therefore, 40 Hz is selected to be a cutoff frequency for low-pass filtering of the product vector d12 to obtain d12lpf, as shown in
The product vector d12lpf is subjected to Hilbert transform to obtain a plural vector, and an expression is as follows:
The instantaneous phase φ12 is calculated according to Hd12, as shown in
The instantaneous phase is subjected to discrete Fourier transform, and an absolute value of a natural frequency difference between the blade 1 and the blade 2 is extracted from amplitude frequency data, as shown in
In this example, the bladed disk with six blades is adopted, so nb=6, and it is necessary to calculate C62 frequency differences, and the obtained natural frequency differences of all the combined blades are shown in the following table:
Actually, it is only necessary to calculate 15 groups of blade difference frequencies. According to the above 15 groups of difference frequencies, the sum sumDi of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between each blade and other five blades may be calculated.
A threshold HF=50 Hz is selected, which shows that sumD1, sumD3, sumD5 exceed the set threshold HF, so that it is presumed that the natural frequencies of the blade 1, the blade 3 and the blade 5 are abnormal.
The natural frequency of the rotating blade is identified by a strain gauge and an electrically conductive slip ring, and the obtained results are:
It is known that the normal natural frequencies of the blades of the bladed disk are about 350 Hz, wherein the natural frequencies of the blade 1, the blade 3 and the blade 5 are quite different from 350 Hz. Actually, the roots of the blade 1 and the blade 5 on the bladed disk have tiny cracks, and the natural frequency of the blade 3 is higher due to a machining error. Therefore, by the method provided by the present disclosure, the abnormity of the natural frequency of the blade can be identified by the signal of the single blade tip timing sensor. According to the present disclosure, the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between different blades can be extracted from the excessively under sampled data only by the single blade tip timing sensor; furthermore, the sum of the absolute values of the natural frequency differences between each blade and other blades is calculated, whether the natural frequency of the blade is abnormal is determined according to the set threshold HF, thereby determining whether the blade is in fault. According to the method of the present disclosure, additional signal reconstruction and more blade tip timing sensors are not required, the identification system is simple, operation is rapid and stable, simplicity and feasibility are achieved, and real-time health monitoring of the rotating blade can be realized.
Although the embodiments of the present disclosure are described above in combination with the accompanying drawings, the present disclosure is not limited to the above specific embodiments and application field, and the above specific embodiments are only illustrative and instructive, rather than being restrictive. Those of ordinary skills in the art can make various forms under the inspiration of this description and without departing from the protection scope of the claims of the present disclosure, which all fall within the protection scope of the present disclosure.