Method for driving an addressable matrix display with luminescent pixels, and display apparatus using the method

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6288695
  • Patent Number
    6,288,695
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, August 25, 1998
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 11, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Examiners
    • Hjerpe; Richard
    • Nguyen; Frances
    Agents
    • Venable
    • Wood; Allen
Abstract
A display apparatus employs a field emission display device with pixels which are turned on and off in accordance with different bits of video words that are being displayed. The field emission display device is driven so that its pixels emit light at different intensity levels, depending upon the rank of the bits that are being displayed.
Description




The present patent application was filed during the pendency of Applicant's earlier applications Ser. No. 08/381,156 and Ser. No. 09/063,364, which were filed respectively on Jan. 31, 1995 and Apr. 21, 1998. Application Ser. No. 08/381,156 was filed during the pendency of Applicant's earlier application Ser. No. 08/034,694, which was filed on Mar. 19, 1993. That application was filed during the pendency of Applicant's earlier application Ser. No. 07/862,313, which was filed on Apr. 2, 1992. That application was filed during the pendency of Applicant's earlier application Ser. No. 07/521,399, which was filed on May 10, 1990. That application was filed during the pendency of Applicant's earlier application Ser. No. 07/396,916, which was filed on Aug. 22, 1989. The disclosures of these prior applications are incorporated herein by reference. Application Ser. No. 07/521,399 matured into U.S. Pat. 5,128,782, which issued on Jul. 7, 1992, and application Ser. No. 08/034,694 matured into U.S. Pat. 5,416,496, which issued on May 16, 1995. Application Ser. No. 07/396,916 and application Ser. No. 07/862,313 have been abandoned.




Although, at the time of filing the present application, Applicant does not claim the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 120 of any of the chain of co-pending applications identified above, Applicant reserves the right to claim such benefit if, at any time during the pendency of the present application at the Patent and Trademark Office or thereafter, prior art is discovered which makes such a claim for the benefit of an earlier filing date desirable.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is directed to a display apparatus with an addressable matrix display device of the type having pixels which are driven to produce light. In the present document, such a display device will be called an addressable matrix display device with luminescent pixels. Such display devices are to be distinguished from display devices which employ luminescent pixels but not an addressable matrix, such as cathode ray tubes. Such display devices are also to be distinguished from display devices which employ an addressable matrix of light valves to modulate light from a source that illuminates the light valves. Examples here include liquid crystal display devices and digital micro-mirror devices.




Several families of addressable matrix display devices with luminescent pixels have been proposed. These include LED arrays, plasma display panels, electroluminescent panels, and field-emission display devices. In each case, the display device has an addressable matrix of light-generating means.




A summary of the current (1998) state of the art in field-emissions display devices was presented in an article by Babu R. Chalamala et al, “Fed Up With Fat Tubes,” at pages 42-51 of the April 1998 issue of


IEEE Spectrum


. An example of a conventional field-emission display device


10


is shown in FIG.


1


. It includes a base plate


12


which supports a number of parallel cathode electrodes


14


(only a few of which are shown). A number of parallel gate electrodes


16


(only a few of which are shown) cross the cathode electrodes


14


and are spaced apart from them by a small gap. The gate electrodes


16


have holes


18


to permit passage of electrons. Red phosphor stripes


20


, green phosphor stripes


22


, and blue phosphor stripes


24


are deposited on a transparent anode electrode


26


made, for example, from ITO. The assembly is disposed in a vacuum envelope (not shown).




The cathode electrodes


14


emit electrons when a suitable potential is applied between the cathode electrodes


14


and the gate electrodes


16


. Unlike the emission process in a cathode ray tube, which employs a heater, the cathode electrodes


14


are cold cathodes which are stimulated to emit electrons when a strong electric field is present. Several approaches are known which provide good cathode electrodes. In

FIG. 1

, so-called Spindt tips


28


are included in the cathode electrodes


14


, and project upward at the locations of the holes


18


to provide enhanced electron emissions. Typically, a plurality of Spindt tips are employed in each pixel. For example, in

FIG. 1

, the red pixel


30


is shown as having four Spindt tips


18


which cooperate with four holes


28


to generate current for illuminating the adjacent portion of red phosphor stripe


20


. A green pixel and a blue pixel are provided adjacent the pixel


30


, along the same gate electrodes


16


, to form a three-pixel group having all three primary colors.




There is minimal electron emission from the cathode electrodes until they are exposed to an electric field that is higher than a threshold value. When the field strength is higher than the threshold, the number of electrodes emitted per unit of time (that is, the current) increases as the strength of the electric field increases.

FIG. 2

illustrates a typical example, with the horizontal axis representing the voltage between a cathode electrode


14


and a gate electrode


16


(which are closely spaced, so that a potential between them of only 45 volts is sufficient to produce an electric field that is larger than the threshold) and the vertical axis represents current in microamperes.




The electrons emitted by the cathode electrodes


14


under the influence of the gate electrodes


16


are accelerated toward the phosphor stripes 20-24 by a positive voltage that is placed on the anode


26


. The higher the anode voltage, the greater the acceleration and, for a given cathode current, the brighter the light produced by the phosphors. The phosphors also glow more brightly when the cathode current is increased. However, increasing the cathode current does not appreciably increase the brightness of the phosphor glow after the current reaches a so-called current saturation level. Furthermore, too high a cathode current degrades the phosphors.




Among other addressable matrix-type display devices that are known are display devices which employ an array of light valves to spatially modulate light that shines on the array. The light valves may have variable optical densities or attenuations properties that are electrically controlled so as to determine the percentage of the impinging light that passes through each light valve. An example is a twisted nematic liquid crystal display device. Other spatial light modulators employ bi-stable light valves, meaning that they are either on or off. Examples here include digital micro-mirror devices and ferroelectric liquid crystal display devices. Since the light valves are bi-stable, rather than having continuously variable attenuation, special measures must be taken in order to provide a gray scale in a display apparatus which includes such a display device. For a display apparatus with a digital micro-mirror device, a gray scale can be achieved by using a pulse width modulation scheme in which the length of time in which the micro-mirrors are in their ON position is controlled, as is explained in U.S. Pat. No. 5,452,024 and in an article entitled “Mirrors on a Chip” that was published in the November 1993 edition of


IEEE Spectrum


at pages 27-31 by Jack M. Younse. For a display apparatus with a ferroelectric display device, a gray scale can be achieved by controlling the intensity or duration of the back-lighting on the basis of the rank or significance of the bits that are being displayed, as is disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,122,791 and 5,416,496. Controlling the intensity of the impinging light on the basis of the rank of the displayed bits can also be used in a display apparatus with a digital micro-mirror device to control the level of gray that is displayed at each pixel, as is explained in Applicant's co-pending applications Ser. Nos. 08/381,156 and 09/063,364, filed respectively on Jan. 31, 1995 and Apr. 21, 1998.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




An object of the invention is to provide an improved method for displaying an image on an addressable matrix display device having luminescent pixels.




A related object is to reduce the time needed to display an image by exciting the luminescent pixels to different degrees so that they emit light at different intensity levels as the image is being displayed. Different bit ranks of video words which specify the image may also be displayed for different time periods.




The above objects can be attained, when the addressable matrix display device is a field emission display device, by placing signals corresponding to bits of video words on the cathode electrodes of the field emission display device while strobing the gate electrodes of the field emission display device with a gate voltage and applying an anode voltage to the anode electrode of the field emission display device. At least one of the anode and gate voltages is changed while this occurs so that the phosphor stripes of the field emission display device emit light at different intensity levels, depending upon the bit rank of the video words that are being displayed.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an exploded perspective view illustrating a portion of a field emission display device;





FIG. 2

is a graph illustrating a typical example of the relationship between cathode current and gate electrode voltage in a field emission display device;





FIG. 3

is a block diagram illustrating an embodiment of a display apparatus which employs the method of the present invention;





FIG. 4

schematically illustrates the format of video words which specify an image that is to be displayed by the display apparatus;





FIG. 5

is a graph schematically illustrating an example of different light intensity levels and different time periods while different bit ranks of the video words are being displayed; and





FIG. 6

is a block diagram illustrating a modification of the display apparatus shown in FIG.


3


.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




A display apparatus


50


in accordance with the present invention is shown in

FIG. 3

, and includes an input unit


52


having an input port


54


which receives digitized signals for an image. In what follows, these digitized signals will be said to consist of red video words for the red component of the image, green video words for the green component, and blue video words for the blue component. The input unit


52


includes a control unit


56


which reads the incoming video words into a video memory


58


, which stores a frame of red, green, and blue video words.




The apparatus


50


also includes a field emission display device


10


, which was previously described with reference to FIG.


1


. The display device


10


includes M cathode electrodes


14


(only three of which, identified by reference numbers


14


-


1


,


14


-


2


, and


14


-M, are shown) and N gate electrodes


16


(only three of which, identified by reference numbers


16


-


1


,


16


-


2


, and


16


-N, are shown).




The display apparatus


50


additionally includes a shift register and driver unit


60


having M stages. Each of these stages is connected to an electrically-controlled cathode switch


62


(only three of which, identified by reference numbers


62


-


1


,


62


-


2


, and


62


-M, are shown). A gate strobe unit


64


has N outputs that are connected, respectively, to N gate switches


66


(only three of which, identified by reference numbers


66


-


1


,


66


-


2


, and


66


-N, are shown). A toggle unit


68


, a gate voltage source


70


, and an anode voltage source


72


receive signals from control unit


56


. The M cathode electrodes


14


are connected by M pull-up resistors


74


(only three of which, identified by reference numbers


74


-


1


,


74


-


2


, and


74


-M, are shown) to a positive bias voltage source


76


.





FIG. 4

schematically illustrates two groups of red, green, and blue video words in a row. It will be assumed in what follows that each of these video words has seven bits, ranging from a least significant bit (LSB) to a most significant bit (MSB). As will be described in more detail below, the least significant bits are displayed, row-by-row, for the entire image, and then the LSB+1 bits are displayed, row-by-row, for the entire image, and so on. For example, to display the six video words shown in

FIG. 4

at the six pixels shown in the front row in

FIG. 1

, signals corresponding to the LSB bits of the word group


78


would be placed on the group


82


of cathode electrodes


14


, signals corresponding to the LSB bits of the word group


80


would be placed on the group


84


of cathode electrodes


14


, and the front gate electrode


16


would be strobed. As a result, dots of the appropriate colors at the relevant pixel locations where the LSB bits have a value of 1, and not at pixel locations where the LSB bits have a value of 0, will be displayed. After the LSB bits in other rows have been displayed, signals corresponding to the LSB+1 bits of word group


78


would be placed on group


82


of cathode electrodes


14


, signals corresponding to the LSB+1 bits of word group


80


would be placed on group


84


of cathode electrodes


14


, and the front gate electrode


16


would be strobed again. This process would continue, bit rank by bit rank of the video words, until the most significant bits have been displayed.




Returning now to

FIG. 3

, the operation of display apparatus


50


will be described in more detail. Control unit


56


reads the least significant bits of the red, green, and blue video words for the top row of the image into the shift register and driver unit


60


. While this occurs, the toggle unit


68


holds an isolation switch


86


open. After the least significant bits of the top row have been read into shift register unit


60


, the cathode switches


62


have either an open state or a closed state, depending upon the values of the least significant bits. For example, if the least significant bit stored in the left-most stage of shift register has a value of 1, switch


62


-


1


would be closed and, consequently, cathode electrode


14


-


1


would be connected to ground. If the next left-most stage stored a value of 0, switch


62


-


2


would be open and, consequently, cathode electrode


14


-


2


would carry a positive bias voltage supplied by source


76


.




After the top row of least significant bits has been loaded into the shift register unit


60


, the control unit


56


signals toggle unit


68


to close the isolation switch


86


. Control unit


56


then signals the strobe unit


64


to close the gate switch


66


-


1


for the top row. As a result, the gate voltage source


70


is connected to the top gate electrode


16


-


1


via the switches


86


and


66


-


1


.




Control unit


86


then signals toggle unit


86


to open isolation switch


86


and reads the least significant bits for the next row of the image from video memory


58


into the shift register unit


60


. Toggle unit


68


then closes isolation switch


86


and gate strobe unit


64


closes gate switch


66


-


2


. This process continues until the least significant bits for the bottom row of the image are loaded into shift register unit


60


, and the gate strobe unit


64


closes the last gate switch


66


-N. Then the process starts again, but this time the control unit


56


reads the LSB+1 bits into the shift register unit


60


. The next time around, it is the LSB+2 bits, and so on until the MSB bits are displayed row-by-row for the entire image. Then the procedure begins again in order to display the next frame.




The control unit


56


emits a digital signal to the gate voltage source


70


to set a positive voltage that is applied to the gate electrodes


16


. The gate voltage source


70


thus controls the cathode current that is emitted by those of the cathode electrodes


14


that are grounded (those of the cathode electrodes


14


that are not grounded carry a positive bias supplied by source


76


and do not emit a cathode current). Similarly, the control unit


56


emits a digital signal to anode voltage source


72


, which applies a corresponding positive voltage to the anode


26


. The gate voltage source


70


and the anode voltage source


72


jointly determine the brightness of the dots that are displayed at the pixel locations. In the present invention, the brightness is controlled in accordance with which bit rank of the video words is being displayed. One example is shown in FIG.


5


.





FIG. 5

schematically illustrates the display of a frame. The horizontal axis indicates duration in arbitrary units of time, and the vertical axis indicates the light intensity at the pixel locations that are on, again in arbitrary units. During the display of the least significant bits, as rows of least significant bits are loaded into shift register


60


and the gate strobe unit


64


sequentially closes the gate switches


66


, control unit


56


sets the gate voltage source


70


and the anode voltage source


72


so that the light intensity for pixels that are on (i.e., the least significant bit has a value of 1) has a light intensity level of 1 unit. The control unit


56


sets the strobe rate of unit


64


so that the duration of the display for the least significant bits is 1 time unit.




During the display of the LSB+1 bits, the gate voltage and anode voltage remain the same, but gate strobe unit closes the gate switches


66


for twice as long. As a result, the pixels that are on during the display of the LSB+1 bits emit twice the amount of light that on pixels emitted during display of the least significant bits. During display of the LSB+2 bits, the gate voltage and anode voltage still remain unchanged, but the gate strobe unit


64


doubles the closure time of the gate switches


66


again. As a result, the pixels that are one emit four times as much light.




If this process were to continue throughout all of the bits of the video words, then the display time would become excessive. Instead, during display of the LSB+3 bits, control unit


56


signals anode voltage source


72


to increase the positive voltage that is applied to anode


26


. The increased anode voltage, coupled with the old gate voltage, raises the intensity of the pixels that are on. As is shown in

FIG. 5

, this raised intensity is set to be eight times the prior intensity, so that the LSB+3 bits can be displayed during one unit of time. The LSB+4 bits are displayed at the increased intensity during two units of time, and the LSB+5 bits are displayed at the increased intensity during four units of time. If the MSB bits were displayed at the same intensity, eight units of time would be needed.




Instead, during display of the MSB bits, the control unit


56


keeps the anode voltage unchanged, but signals the gate voltage source


70


to increase the positive gate voltage, and thus also the cathode current. In order to avoid excessive cathode current and consequent degradation of the phosphors, the gate voltage is selected so that the intensity is only twice what it was during display of the bits LSB+3 through LSB+5. The most significant bits can thus be displayed during four units of time.




The magnitude of the positive bias voltage that is supplied by source


76


is selected so that the highest gate voltage does not result in cathode current from cathode electrodes


14


that are connected to open cathode switches


62


. For the example shown in

FIG. 2

, a bias voltage of about +40 v would permit the gate voltage to be raised to about +80 v without turning on pixels that are supposed to be off (although +80 v might result in an excessive cathode current). The point to be made is that the provision of a suitable positive bias voltage permits a relatively wide range of gate voltages and thus allows the cathode current to be set within a wide range.




For the sake of convenient illustration and discussion,

FIG. 5

has been simplified by omitting the intensity drops that occur when the isolation switch


86


is opened during strobing of the gate electrodes


16


. Nevertheless,

FIG. 5

illustrates a fundamental feature of the present invention, which is that the light intensity is controlled in accordance with the rank or significance of the bits of the video words that are being displayed. It will be apparent that increasing the pixel intensity during display of a frame decreases the amount of time needed for the frame. The intensity can be controlled by setting the gate and anode voltages, and the total amount of light emitted at pixel locations that are on during display of any particular bit rank of the video words depends jointly on the light intensity and the duration.





FIG. 6

illustrates a modified display apparatus


50


′ in which the cathode current is not adjusted by varying the gate voltage. Instead, the gate voltage source


70


′ is set at a fixed positive value, and the cathode current is adjusted by control unit


56


using a cathode voltage source


88


that is connected to the cathode switches


62


.




It will be apparent to those ordinarily skilled in the art that the above description illustrates specific embodiments of the invention, but that many modifications are possible. The video words need not have seven bits, but may have more than seven to improve the gray scale, or less than seven if a coarser gray scale is acceptable. Furthermore, the display need not proceed from least significant bits to LSB+1 bits to LSB+2 bits, and so on to the MSB bits. The order in which the bit ranks are displayed is arbitrary. The LSB+3 bits of a frame could be displayed first, for example, followed by the MSB bits, followed by the LSB+2 bits, and then the other bit ranks.




Nor is it necessary that the specific light intensity profile shown in

FIG. 5

be followed.

FIG. 5

shows only three light levels, each having an intensity corresponding to a power of 2, but additional light intensity levels could be used in order to reduce the display time. For example, if the light intensity were increased to 2 units during display of the LSB+1 bits, one time period would be saved, and if the light intensity were to be increased to 4 units during display of the LSB+2 bits, three additional time periods would be saved. It is desirable, however, to avoid an excessive cathode current during display of the higher-order bits, particularly the MSB bits, since excessive cathode current degrades the phosphors. Excessive cathode current can be avoided (if necessary) by increasing the display time for the MSB bits, and possibly also for other high-ranking bits.




Although not shown, it would be possible to isolate the top or bottom row of pixels or the left or right column, and to display the image on the remaining portions of the display


10


. The isolated row or column could then be used in conjunction with light sensors to measure the light intensity while supplying known signals to the isolated row or column. The gate and/or anode voltage and/or the display time could be incremented or decremented in accordance with the measurements to accommodate variations due to manufacturing tolerances or aging. Using such a measurement and adjusting scheme would permit the light intensity and display time to be adjusted so as to provide accurate binary levels.




It will be understood that the above description of the present invention is susceptible to various other modifications, changes, and adaptations, and the same are intended to be comprehended within the meaning and range of equivalents of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A method for displaying an image on an addressable matrix, field emission display device having gate electrodes and having luminescent pixels at an anode electrode, the image being specified by video words having least significant bits and most significant bits, comprising:(a) associating the pixels of the display device with corresponding video words; (b) selecting pixels of the display device that are to be illuminated using the least significant bits of the corresponding the video words; (c) exciting the pixels selected during step (b) so that they glow at a first light intensity level; (d) selecting pixels of the display device that are to be illuminated using the most significant bits of the corresponding video words; and (e) exciting the pixels selected during step (d) so that they glow at a second light intensity level that is higher than the first light intensity level, wherein step (e) comprises changing an anode voltage that is applied to the anode electrode.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, wherein steps (b) and (c) are conducted at a faster rate than steps (d) and (e).
  • 3. The method of claim 2, wherein the video words additionally have LSB+X intermediate bits with bit ranks between the LSB bits and the MSB bits, X being an integer, and wherein the method further comprises steps (f) selecting pixels of the display device that are to be illuminated using the LSB+X intermediate bits of the corresponding video words, and (g) exciting the pixels selected during step (f) so that they glow at a third light intensity level that is between the first and second light intensity levels.
  • 4. The method of claim 3, wherein steps (f) and (g) are conducted at a rate that is different from steps (b) and (c) and also different from steps (d) and (e).
  • 5. The method of claim 1, wherein the second light intensity level is about a power of two times larger than the first light intensity level.
  • 6. The method of claim 1, wherein step (e) further comprises also changing the gate voltage.
  • 7. A method for displaying an image on a field emission display device having an anode electrode, gate electrodes, and cathode electrodes, the gate electrodes and cathode electrodes of the display device crossing at pixel locations of the display device, the image being specified by video words having least significant bits and most significant bits, comprising:(a) associating the pixel locations of the display device with corresponding video words; (b) using the least significant bits of the video words to select cathode electrodes at pixel locations corresponding to the video words; (c) applying an anode voltage to the anode electrode, strobing the gate electrodes, and establishing a predetermined potential difference between the cathode electrodes selected in step (b) and the strobed gate electrodes; (d) using the most significant bits of the video words to again select cathode electrodes at pixel locations corresponding to the video words; and (e) applying an anode voltage to the anode electrode, strobing the gate electrodes, and establishing a predetermined potential difference between the cathode electrodes selected in step (d) and the strobed gate electrodes, wherein both of the anode voltage and the potential difference employed in step (e) are different from the anode voltage and the potential different employed in step (c).
  • 8. The method of claim 7, wherein steps (b) and (c) are conducted at a faster rate than steps (d) and (e).
  • 9. A method for displaying an image on an addressable matrix display device having luminescent pixels, the image being specified by video words having least significant bits and most significant bits, comprising:(a) associating the pixels of the display device with corresponding video words; (b) selecting pixels of the display device that are to be illuminated using the least significant bits of the corresponding the video words; (c) exciting the pixels selected during step (a) so that they glow at a first light level; (d) selecting pixels of the display device that are to be illuminated using the most significant bits of the corresponding video words; and (c) exciting the pixels selected during step (d) so that they glow at a second light intensity level that is higher than the first light intensity level, wherein steps (b) and (c) arc conducted at a faster rate than steps (d) and (e).
  • 10. The method of claim 9, wherein the display device is a field emission display device having an anode electrode and cathode electrodes, wherein step (c) comprises applying a predetermined cathode voltage on selected cathode electrodes and applying a predetermined anode voltage on the anode electrode, and wherein step (e) comprises changing at least one of the cathode and anode voltages.
  • 11. The method of claim 10, wherein step (e) comprises changing both the cathode and anode voltages.
  • 12. A method for displaying an image on a field emission display device having an anode electrode, gate electrodes, and cathode electrodes, the gate electrodes and cathode electrodes of the display device crossing at pixel locations of the display device, the image being specified by video words having least significant bits and most significant bits, comprising:(a) associating the pixel locations of the display device with corresponding video words; (b) using the least significant bits of the video words to select cathode electrodes at pixel locations corresponding to the video words; (c) applying an anode voltage to the anode electrode, strobing the gate electrodes, and establishing a predetermined potential difference between the cathode electrodes selected in step (b) and the strobed gate electrodes; (d) using the most significant bits of the video words to again select cathode electrodes at pixel locations corresponding to the video words; and (e) applying an anode voltage to the anode electrode, strobing the gate electrodes, and establishing a predetermined potential difference between the cathode electrodes selected in step (d) and the strobed gate electrodes, wherein at least one of the anode voltage and the potential difference employed in step (e) is different from the anode voltage and the potential different employed in step (c), and wherein steps (b) and (c) are conducted at a faster rate than steps (d) and (e).
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 09/063,364 filed on Apr. 21, 1998, and a continuation of application Ser. No. 08/381,156 filed on Jan. 31, 1995, and a continuation of application Ser. No. 07/862,313 filed on Apr. 2, 1992 abandoned and a continuation of application Ser. No. 07/521,399 filed on May 10, 1990 now U.S. Pat. No. 5,128,782, and a continuation application Ser. No. 07/396,916 filed Aug. 22, 1989 now abandoned.

US Referenced Citations (19)
Number Name Date Kind
5103144 Dunham Apr 1992
5122791 Gibbons et al. Jun 1992
5157309 Parker et al. Oct 1992
5196839 Johary et al. Mar 1993
5262698 Dunham Nov 1993
5317334 Sano May 1994
5416496 Wood May 1995
5452024 Sampsell Sep 1995
5530457 Helgeson Jun 1996
5578906 Smith Nov 1996
5644195 Browning Jul 1997
5757348 Handschy et al. May 1998
5767828 McKnight Jun 1998
5847515 Lee et al. Dec 1998
5936355 Kim Aug 1999
5936597 Hyun et al. Aug 1999
5945968 Hush Aug 1999
6184854 Hotto et al. Feb 2001
6184874 Smith et al. Feb 2001
Continuations (5)
Number Date Country
Parent 09/063364 Apr 1998 US
Child 09/139757 US
Parent 08/381156 Jan 1995 US
Child 09/063364 US
Parent 07/862313 Apr 1992 US
Child 08/381156 US
Parent 07/521399 May 1990 US
Child 07/862313 US
Parent 07/396916 Aug 1989 US
Child 07/521399 US