The present invention relates generally to Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) and more particularly to a method and system for increasing recovery yield over prior EOR methods.
Due to the vast amount of oil and gas trapped in shale reservoirs and extra tight rock reservoirs in the United States and elsewhere, there has been considerable effort in recent years to extract these hydrocarbon fluids. Shale is a mineral form that is particularly easy to fracture along various planes. Shale reservoirs contain “rich” field gas that contains propane (C3) and butane (C4) as well as oil that contains C3 and C4. A typical gas and oil (hydrocarbon) extraction technique for shale is to use methods that fracture the rock at points along a horizontal well. The hydrocarbon fluids can be extracted from these fracture points and recovered using natural pressure. The technique is colloquially known as “fracking”. Extra tight rock reservoirs, including sandstones or carbonates, behave similarly to shale reservoirs. After several years, the production from these wells declines as pressure decreases. Ultimately the wells reach their economic limit where operating expenses exceed revenues, at which point the wells must be refraced, redrilled, or abandoned. Methods to combat this natural decline in production and increase recovery of the remaining hydrocarbon fluids are known as Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR).
There are three major prior art methods of EOR: thermal injection, solvent injection and chemical injection. Thermal injection uses hot water and/or steam to heat the reservoir and cause highly viscous oil to become less viscous, flow to the well bore and be pumped to the surface. Solvent injection is a process by which various gases such as carbon dioxide, nitrogen, or methane rich gas are injected into the reservoir. These gases are used to reduce oil viscosity, promote miscibility, and increase reservoir pressure that in turn pushes some of the remaining oil and gas to the producing wells where it is pumped to the surface. Chemical injection involves surfactants, nano-particles, and/or microbes that employ a variety of mechanisms that release some of the remaining oil and gas. Chemical injection is often used in conjunction with either of the other techniques.
Almost all EOR methods in shale and extra tight rock are cyclic (called “Huff-and-Puff”), involving alternating phases of injection followed by production from the same wells. During an injection phase (Huff), the substance being injected is forced into the well until the pressure reaches a desired maximum in the reservoir which may be between 2000-9000 psi. The injection phase is followed by the production phase (Puff), where the hydrocarbon fluids are produced back up the well as the pressure drops. When the pressure reaches a specified minimum, another Huff and Puff cycle starts. Each Huff phase and Puff phase is variable and can range from days, to weeks, to months, depending on a number of variables determined by the reservoir, oil and other characteristics.
Sheng in U.S. Published Patent Application 2017/0159416 teaches optimization techniques for Huff-and-Puff using a gas such as methane (C1), natural gas, carbon dioxide, nitrogen, or combinations thereof. Sheng attempts to optimize the cycle times and pressures.
Valencia et al. in U.S. Published Patent Application 2017/0283688 teach an EOR process that uses an enriched hydrocarbon fluid derived in-situ for injection. Valencia uses C2+ (which is primarily ethane) or C3 (propane) at reduced temperatures. Enrichment generally is accomplished by removing C1 (methane), and cooling the injection fluid to −30 degrees F. Valencia also teaches fluid reinjection.
Babcock et al. in U.S. Published Patent Application 2018/0057732 teach a method of EOR from a resource reservoir that injects fluids via an injection well and extracts via a nearby production well. The injection fluid may consist of a mixture of C2 (ethane), C3(propane), C4(butane) and C5+ (pentane and longer hydrocarbons). The mixture is cooled below 0 degrees F. Babcock also teaches using C1 (methane), nitrogen and carbon dioxide. Babcock in U.S. Published Patent Application 2018/0058182 teaches using Y-Grade Natural Gas Liquids (NGL) in the same manner described above in this paragraph.
Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) as relates to the present invention takes place in both horizontal and vertical wells in shale and extra tight rock formations that have declined in output. Prior art methods include Huff and Puff where gas or chemicals are injected into the wells on a cyclic basis. The previous methods have several key disadvantages: (1) injecting a gaseous mixture into shale reservoirs requires very high pressures in order to achieve miscibility in the reservoir. Two fluids, such as gas and oil, are “miscible” when they form a single phase after being mixed in any proportion when first brought into contact at a given pressure and temperature. The compressors and related equipment have to be specially designed and fabricated which takes a long lead time, and is very expensive; (2) very large quantities of gas are required for Huff and Puff, necessitating additional pipelines capable of handling high pressures running from gas sources to the compressors and then to the various producing wells. This requirement also adds to the capital expenditures (CAPEX). The increased CAPEX and need to find sufficient availability of the right kind of gas automatically eliminate many oil and gas fields and existing wells from utilizing the previous Huff and Puff methods. Therefore, a Huff-and-Puff method that uses only liquids instead of gases alone or gases combined with liquids would have significant advantages in certain reservoirs and fields by lowering the CAPEX due to (a) substituting existing, easy to modify pumps to push hydrocarbon fluids into the formation to stimulate the oil thereby eliminating the need for costly compressors; (b) being able to transport the hydrocarbon liquids by truck instead of pipeline, eliminating the need to source gas and lay expensive pipelines and taps; and (c) using modular surface equipment that is transportable and has a much smaller “footprint” to accomplish (1) and (2) described above which further reduces the CAPEX.
The present invention relates to Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) from aging horizontal and vertical wells in shale and extra tight rock formations. A mixture of C3 (propane) and C4 (butane) is cyclically pumped as a stimulation treatment into the well in liquid phase to “fill” the well up to a pressure of approximately 3000 psi (although other pressures are within the scope of the present invention). The fill portion of the cycle lasts approximately ten to sixty days (although other time periods are within the scope of the present invention). The well is then allowed to produce for approximately 30 to 120 days (although other time periods are within the scope of the present invention). Because the entire hydrocarbon fluid is in liquid phase, and since the pressure necessary to pump the fluids into the formation is relatively low, the stimulation treatment can be accomplished with a pump rather than a high pressure gas compressor. A “slug” of C3-C4 in liquid phase is loaded from tanker trucks to a holding tank at around 100 psi. The pump delivers the liquid into the well at a pressure of around 3000 psi. The ratio of C3/C4 can be adjusted to optimize recovery from given wells in given basins. The ratio can run from 0 (100% C4) to 1 (100% C3), with any intermediate ratio available. The injection usually starts with a ratio of 0.5 (50-50) but may be adjusted as fluid cost and reservoir characteristics demand. As the production phase of the Huff and Puff proceeds, three fluids return from the wellhead: liquid oil, water, and vapor streams. The method of the present invention recovers almost all of the stimulation treatment C3-C4 mixture from the vapor stream and from the oil stream. Water is removed in standard ways known in the art. The remaining oil and gas are shipped or piped to refineries or other market destinations. The recovered C3-C4 is recycled as a liquid stream and used for the next stimulation treatment Huff phase. The system thus becomes self-sustaining since any of the C3-C4 that is left in the reservoir as part of the process is made up by the additional C3 and C4 that is inherent in the newly recovered oil and gas from the reservoir. Because the equipment required to pump liquid C3-C4, and separate the produced component liquid and vapor streams and recover it is relatively compact and light, the entire surface apparatus can be mounted on a skid that can be transported from location to location as needed. The economic model is driven by the exclusive use of liquid components that are pumped through the wells into the formation instead of first being compressed and then injected. The result is to increase the potential number of wells and reservoirs that can benefit from the present invention by (a) eliminating custom manufactured high pressure compressor systems; (b) eliminating the resulting permanent facility costs including above or below ground storage capacity for the blended gas and treatment fluids necessary for the compressors to use, (c) reducing CAPEX by re-deploying the same skid mounted equipment since it is now transportable instead of relatively permanent; (d) eliminating expensive pipelines to bring the necessary volumes of gas to the injection facility; and (e) reducing CAPEX by eliminating the need to add future gas to mix with the treatment fluids.
In addition to just C3 and C4, other liquid phase products may be added to the stimulation treatment mixture including C5+ (natural gasoline which includes pentane C5 and longer hydrocarbons) and C2 (ethane). Again, the ratios can be adjusted to optimize production.
C5+ refers to higher molecular weight hydrocarbons which are liquid at standard conditions of pressure and temperature including pentane (C5), hexane (C6), heptane (C7), octane (C8), and nonane (C9). The term C5+ can refer to any of these pure hydrocarbons (including isomers) in that molecular weight range, or any mixture of such hydrocarbons in any combination.
In an alternate embodiment, pure C4 is pumped into the well. During the production phase, this C4 exits at the wellhead mostly dissolved in the oil. Under certain market conditions, this enriched oil will bring a higher price than other varieties of crude oil. In this embodiment, the enriched oil is sold as-is after normal stabilization.
Attention is now directed to several inline figures:
Several figures have been presented to illustrate features of the present invention. The scope of the present invention is not limited to what is shown in the figures.
The present invention pumps a liquid C3-C4 mixture into a well at a relatively low pressure, with approximately 3000 psi being preferred, as a stimulation treatment. While this is the preferred pressure, different pressures may be used with different formations at different reservoir depths. By C3 we mean propane, and by C4 we mean butane (including any ratio of straight chain butane to iso-butane). A pre-mix of liquid C3-C4 is loaded from transport vehicles such as a tanker truck into a holding tank on site. A pump is used to pump the mixture into the well at the desired pressure which is typically around 3000 psi. A major advantage of the present invention for Huff and Puff EOR is the use of liquids that only requires a pump to place them into the formation, instead of a high pressure compressor system which is required to inject a vapor stream into wells. The stimulation treatment Huff phase of a given well lasts approximately 10 to 60 days and the production of Puff phase lasts approximately 30 to 120 days. The total Huff and Puff cycle period lasts approximately 40 to 180 days. The Huff and Puff cycle is then repeated. During the production phase, C3-C4 is recovered from the liquid oil stream and the hydrocarbon vapor stream leaving the well head. A major advantage of the present invention is that most of the liquid C3-C4 pumped into the formation in the Huff phase can be recovered during the Puff phase from the hydrocarbon vapor and liquid streams and then pumped back into the formation in the next Huff phase stimulation treatment. Thus, while a low cost of C3-C4 is an important criteria when initiating the first Huff and Puff cycles, the high recovery rate for recycle allows this new Huff and Puff method to potentially be economic in locations where the cost of the treatment liquids may be higher.
As experience with a given well is gained, the ratio of C3/C4 can be adjusted to optimize production based on a variety of factors including the individual liquid component costs. Typically, the ratio starts out at 0.5 with trial adjustments being made during subsequent pumping periods. The entire process may run until production finally drops below economically viable levels. In some embodiments of the invention, the ratio may be re-adjusted after the passage of time.
The equipment needed to perform the above-described operation is light and can be made transportable by assembling it on a skid. Since the skid can be economically transported from site to site, the CAPEX associated with building the infrastructure for a fixed facility is eliminated. Moreover, when the hydrocarbons in a well, or groups of wells, can no longer be economically recovered, or when desired, the equipment can be simply transported to another location.
Turning to
It should be noted that the plan shown in
The skid, if properly constructed, can have a lifetime of at least fifteen years. Given the projected amount of oil that can be economically recovered from a typical well, a skid will probably be transported to a different location at about five years or whenever the wells' oil and gas production reach their economic limit. The number of years a skid is used may vary from site to site. Thus, in this example, if a skid lasts fifteen years, it is in service at three different locations for five years each. The skid can be recycled and refurbished at the five year interval. Thus, a group of two skids, over their fifteen year lifetime, will service approximately sixty wells using each skid three times.
The crude oil is also stabilized by removing C3 and C4 from it, and can be “sweetened” if necessary by removing impurities such as hydrogen sulfide.
The liquid C3-C4 is recycled as has been discussed.
In an alternate embodiment of the present invention, pure C4 can be pumped into the well to serve as a stimulation treatment, and the C4 can be allowed to remain dissolved in the final oil product. This allows a more valuable oil product to be directly sold.
Different embodiments of the present invention can include one or more control units associated with the skid equipment. In these embodiments, a rugged field computer or PLC can control and monitor the entire pumping-production process at a skid. In some embodiments, a group of skids in operation can communicate wirelessly with a remote station or with each other reporting back operational parameters such as pressures, temperatures, flow rates and other parameters. The skid can also be controlled remotely from the remote station or from a different skid. Typically, this wireless communication is by radio or satellite since most sites are in remote areas. Radios can operate on ISM frequencies or specially licensed frequencies. If the skid happens to be located where there is cellular telephone service, communication may also be established over a cellular network.
Thermal induced fracturing (TIF) is a well-known result of pumping cool liquids into warm formations. TIF has been studied as an additional stimulation method for prior hydraulic fractures in shale reservoirs and tight rock. Various embodiments of the process of the present invention will pump cool 40 to 80 degrees F. so it forms a liquid state, and then pump those liquids into reservoirs that are typically 175 to 300 degrees F. This causes an increased flow rate and stimulated rock volume (SRV) for both pumped and produced fluids resulting in additional oil recovery above the base EOR method. Increasing SRV is a major benefit to the invention process by providing more oil filled rock to be contacted by solvent.
TIF is known to cause secondary fractures perpendicular to the original hydraulic fractures in the zone near the wellbore where rock stress is increased by cooling. Repeated cycles of pumped cool liquids will extend the secondary fracturing deeper into the reservoir on each cycle causing continuously increasing well productivity and SRV.
In addition, to thermal stress the repeated cycles of pressure in this invention cause rock stress to increase and decrease each cycle. Field observations in shale wells indicate that the zone of improved productivity created by hydraulic fracturing with proppant is in a region approximately 200 feet from the wellbore, but micro seismic observations show induced fracturing occurs approximately out to 1000 feet from the wellbore. In shale formations the proppant stays relatively close to the wellbore and far distant induced fractures do not get filled with proppant. During primary production, the pressure drawdown causes stress to increase which in turn closes the far distant fractures that have no proppant. As part of this invention, liquid C3-C4 is pumped as a stimulation treatment causing rock pressure to increase rapidly with an associated decrease in rock stress which allows the previously far distant fractures to reopen. Repeated stress cycles are known to cause “Spalling” of the rock, which is a process where rock chips are formed. Kiel in U.S. Published Patent Application 1976/3933205 teaches that multiple hydraulic fracturing cycles with increasing and decreasing pressure will induce Spalling. The Spalling will cause the induced fractures to be propped open resulting in improved well productivity.
The present invention includes self-propping of far distant induced fractures as a result of rock Spalling caused by pressure and stress increases and decreases in repeated cycles. The repeated cycles of pressure will cause far distant induced fractures to stay permanently open resulting in increased well productivity and SRV resulting in additional oil recovery.
Hydraulic fracturing of shale wells occurs in stages which are spaced approximately 200 feet apart along a wellbore lateral resulting in about 25 stages for a 5000 foot long lateral. Each stage is pumped separately in sequence and is unique relative to the local rock and fluids that are encountered. Field observations indicate that the stages do not flow back uniformly with some stronger than others. In many cases some of the stages do not flow at all and this is attributed to some form of “Formation damage”. Formation damage is a technical category of production engineering that can include many types of phenomenon ranging from mechanical to chemical blockage of flow. This invention pumps liquid C3-C4 into shale wells which is classified as a solvent. As part of this invention, repeated cycles of solvent will remove formation damage from reduced flow or blocked flow fracture stages. The repeated cycles of solvent will cause previously damaged fracture stages to be improved over time resulting in increasing well productivity and increased SRV resulting in additional oil recovery.
The present invention process starts at a reservoir pressure lower than initial, after some period of primary production, perhaps as low as 500 psi. Liquid C3-C4 is pumped as a stimulation treatment into the well in a liquid phase to “fill” the well up to a pressure of approximately 3000 psi (although other pressures are within the scope of the present invention). This “fill” phase is relatively expensive in early cycles. Different embodiments of the present invention can include the addition of water, nitrogen or methane dominated field gas to supplement C3-C4 plus other liquid phase products in the early cycles of the EOR process. Water, nitrogen, or methane dominated field gas is lower cost fluid that can assist in the “fill” portion of early cycles. Continued addition of Water, nitrogen, or methane dominated field gas is not beneficial in later cycles as they begin to interfere with oil production. The optimal application of supplemental Water, nitrogen, or methane dominated field gas to selected early cycles is part of this invention.
A further embodiment of the current invention involves the application of one or more well treatment techniques to improve the SRV in the wells used in the C3-C4 process. These treatment techniques involve both prior art and new inventions, but will prove beneficial when economically justified for each well in a project. These treatment techniques may include diverting agents to focus solvent on underperforming stages, a coiled tubing unit to direct the C3-C4 solvent to specific points along the horizontal well's wellbore, the addition of a small amount of proppant to the C3-C4 solvent used in the first and potentially other cycles to help maintain access to newly added SRV, and the addition of a small amount of surfactant to the C3-C4 solvent to alter the wettability of the reservoir system. Any or all of these techniques can be applied to this invention in order to increase the productivity and SRV of an individual well. Increasing SRV is a major benefit to the invention process by providing more oil filled rock to be contacted by solvent.
A further embodiment of the current invention involves the ability to adjust the operating conditions of the Recycle System to allow for the manufacture of a pumpable solvent stream that has a composition designed to be miscible with the reservoir fluids at current reservoir pressures and temperatures, thereby increasing the efficiency of the improved recovery process and increasing the amount of incremental oil recovery achievable from all stimulation cycles. The pumped solvent composition is initially designed specifically based on “equation of state” modeling to be first contact miscible with the oil in the target hydrocarbon reservoir at the low pressure condition existing at the end of primary production. However, since pressure and temperature change with time, the Recycle System is adjustable to optimize the composition with time.
A further embodiment of the current invention involves the ability to adjust the operating conditions of the Recycle System to allow for the manufacture of a larger volume of the pumpable solvent stream that has a composition that is not miscible with the reservoir fluids at current reservoir pressures and temperatures. However, the larger volume will increase the amount of incremental oil recovery achievable from all stimulation cycles.
In an alternate embodiment, pure C4 is pumped into the well. During the production phase, this C4 exits at the wellhead mostly dissolved in the oil. Under certain market conditions, this C4 enriched oil brings a lower price than other varieties of crude oil. In this embodiment, the recycle system is adjusted to capture most of the entrained C4 for recycle into the next stimulation phase thereby increasing the amount of stimulant available and thereby increasing the amount of incremental oil that can be recovered from the project.
A further embodiment of the current invention involves using the Recycle System to treat produced fluids from other wells in the area of interest even though those wells are not being treated with the cyclic stimulation process. Treating the produced fluids from additional wells increases the volume of pumpable solvent available for the stimulation of wells in the project, thereby reducing the amount of solvent that must be imported for the project and thereby increasing the economic value of the project.
A further embodiment of the current invention involves using the Recycle System to treat all produced fluids on a given well pad/production site in order to provide pumpable solvent for stimulation of the reservoir while also reducing the fugitive gas emissions that are inherent in most oil and gas production operations, thereby reducing greenhouse gas emissions associated with the existing operation.
Finally, the present invention may be used in a Greenfield Development. Greenfield Developments typically refer to developing on previously undeveloped land. This includes newly discovered oil reservoirs. Hence, a further embodiment of the current invention involves the incorporation of the cyclic stimulation process and the Recycle System in the design of any new development project in existing or newly discovered oil reservoirs deemed susceptible to benefits from the cyclic stimulation system, thereby increasing the expected volume of oil to be recovered from the project and reducing the amount of fugitive gas emissions expected to be generated from the project with an overall improvement in the economic outlook for the new development project.
Several descriptions and illustrations have been presented to aid in understanding the present invention. One with skill in the art will realize that numerous changes and variations may be made without departing from the spirit of the invention. Each of these changes and variations is within the scope of the present invention.
The following patents and publications relate to the present invention:
This is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 17/555,381 filed Dec. 12, 2021 which was a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 17/087,814 filed Nov. 3, 2020, now U.S. Pat. No. 11,280,170 issued Mar. 3, 2022 which claimed priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62/930,402 filed Nov. 4, 2019. U.S. Pat. No. 11,280,170 and U.S. application No. 62/930,402 are hereby incorporated by reference in their entireties.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3933205 | Kiel | Jan 1976 | A |
5073666 | Zemanian | Dec 1991 | A |
6769486 | Lim | Aug 2004 | B2 |
6883607 | Nenniger | Apr 2005 | B2 |
7527096 | Chung | May 2009 | B2 |
8727000 | O'Dowd | May 2014 | B2 |
9476817 | Guillot | Oct 2016 | B2 |
10724351 | Babcock | Jul 2020 | B2 |
10570715 | Babcock et al. | Nov 2020 | B2 |
20130228330 | Loree | Sep 2013 | A1 |
20140014375 | Boerrigter | Jan 2014 | A1 |
20150006124 | Zhang | Jan 2015 | A1 |
20150060075 | Blom | Mar 2015 | A1 |
20170159416 | Sheng | Jun 2017 | A1 |
20170218743 | Babcock | Aug 2017 | A1 |
20170283688 | Valencia et al. | Oct 2017 | A1 |
20180057732 | Babcock et al. | Mar 2018 | A1 |
20180058182 | Babcock | Mar 2018 | A1 |
20180298731 | Bishop | Oct 2018 | A1 |
20180347328 | Aguilera et al. | Dec 2018 | A1 |
20190055825 | Babcock | Feb 2019 | A1 |
20210115775 | Hotton et al. | Apr 2021 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
Wan, T., Sheng, J. J., and Soliman, M. Y. 2013. Evaluation of the EOR Potential in Fractured Shale Oil Reservoirs by Cyclic Gas Injection, paper SPE-168880 or URTeC-1611383. |
Stephen Rassenfoss, JPT, Oct. 2017 Shale EOR Works, But Will It Make a Difference? |
Todd Hoffman and David Reichhardt; URTeC: 147, Jul. 2019. Quantitative Evaluation of Recovery Mechanisms for Huff-n-puff Gas Injection in Unconventional Reservoirs. |
Trent Jacobs; JPT, Mar. 2019. Shale EOR delivers, so why won't the sector go big? |
Doyle G. Marrs, JPT, Apr. 1961 Field Results of Miscible-Displacement Program Using Liquid Propane Driven by Gas, Parks Field Unit, Midland County, Texas. |
Roger E. Sessions, JPT, Jan. 1962 Small Propane Slug Proving Success in Slaughter Field Lease. |
Kwanghee Chun, Stanford Geothermal Workshop Proceedings, 2013 Fracture Propagation Under Poro-Thermally Induced Stress Using The Displacement Discontinuity Method. |
Qibin Lin, et al, Advances in Civil Engineering, Article 4068918, Mar. 2018 An Experimental Study on Cracking Behavior of Precracked Sandstone Specimens under Seepage Pressure. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62930402 | Nov 2019 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 17555381 | Dec 2021 | US |
Child | 17719442 | US | |
Parent | 17087814 | Nov 2020 | US |
Child | 17555381 | US |