Method for forming a combination door and window channel seal

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6485663
  • Patent Number
    6,485,663
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, December 9, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 26, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
A combination door and window channel seal for sealing between a motor vehicle door frame and movable window glass panel and a method for forming the same are described. The channel seal is formed from thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values and has an elastic joint in a window run channel portion of the seal.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates generally to motor vehicle door and window channel seals and more particularly to a thermoplastic elastomer seal having an elastic joint in a window run channel portion of the seal for sealing between a motor vehicle door frame and movable window glass panel, and to a method of forming the seal.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The motor vehicle industry, particularly the passenger car and van portions of the industry, are increasingly relying on flush glass window mounting for improving the appearance of motor vehicles and reducing the aerodynamic drag of the vehicles to make them more fuel efficient. A number of conflicting requirements for such seals makes them difficult and expensive to produce and install. The increasingly complex shape of motor vehicle bodies requires seals that are not simply bent in a plane to surround the top edge of a flat glass window. The seals are formed not only at the radii (corners of the glass) but are also arched vertically to coincide with the curved top surface of the glass and rounded sides of the automobile.




Heretofore, thermosetting materials such as ethylene-propylenediene-monomer rubber (EPDM) have been used extensively for vehicle window seals. Some complex seals have included portions formed from other materials such as thermoplastic materials, but EPDM has usually been a major portion of the seal. To improve the appearance of motor vehicles, the industry demands window seals that are colored to enhance the appearance of the vehicle, usually by matching the body color. Obtaining a color on EPDM has been less than satisfactory in the past, whereas thermoplastics are readily colored.




Although EPDM is cost effective (inexpensive) as a material, the total cost of making and installing an EPDM seal on a motor vehicle is high. The seal must not only be formed at the radii of the glass by cutting, mitering or welding molded pieces, but it must also be arched in the vertical direction to coincide with the curved glass and rounded sides of the vehicle. To accomplish this with EPDM, a metal support internal to the EPDM is added, usually as the EPDM seal is extruded. Massive and expensive roll forming machinery and tooling and stretch bending equipment and tooling are required to form the extruded seal to the desired configuration in three dimensions. Thus, the total cost, that is the cost of the seal and the capital cost of equipment needed to form it, is high.




It is an object of this invention to provide an improved vehicle door and window channel seal that overcomes the disadvantages of known seals by providing a semi-rigid seal which readily conforms to the desired configuration and allows for a closing action on the window glass. The seal of the invention comprises a channel seal, which is a substantially rigid but flexible channel seal and is thermally formed from at least two different polymers, coming together into one profile. The channel seal is preferably used in conjunction with a sealing insert.




More particularly, it is an object of the invention to improve the sealing action against the glass by incorporating an elastic joint of TPE of lower durometer in the base of the channel seal to provide a winking action when a window engages the sealing insert and causes the legs of the window run channel to pivot inwards and compress the sealing insert against the window glass.




It is an object of the invention to provide a door and window channel seal in which the channel seal comprises a combination of thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) materials of different durometers which attaches to a vehicle body and can be color matched to an automobile and which can be thermally formed to match the general contour of the vehicle, thus eliminating the need for the expensive, massive, roll forming machinery and tooling and stretch bending equipment and tooling mentioned before.




The channel seal can be thermally formed by extrusion or molding in one piece and conformed to the general contour of the vehicle opening. Thus molded joint lines and the need for cutting, mitering or welding of the carrier member to fit the corners are avoided. The sealing insert can be formed by extrusion of a one-piece, relatively flat resilient rubber member which can be readily provided with a sliding surface, such as a slip coating or flocking.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




Briefly stated and in accordance with a presently preferred embodiment of the invention a combination door and window channel seal comprising, an inverted U-shaped window channel defined by a first base having first and second ends, a first leg attached to one end of the base, an elastic joint strip attached to the second end of the base, and a second leg attached to the elastic joint; and a U-shaped flange engaging channel for securing the seal to a door flange defined by a second base, said second leg and a third leg.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention the channel seal comprises a pivot projection attached to the first end of the base, opposite the first leg.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention, the channel seal comprises at least two thermoplastic elastomers of different durometer values.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention, the channel seal is formed by coextruding the at least two thermoplastic elastomers.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention, the channel seal is formed by molding the at least two thermoplastic elastomers.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention the channel seal comprises a thermoplastic elastomer selected from styrenic block copolymers, rubber-polyolefin blends, elastomeric alloys, thermoplastic alloys, thermoplastic elastomeric alloys, thermoplastic ionomers, thermoplastic polyurethanes, polyvinyl chlorides and blends thereof.




The novel aspects of the invention are set forth with particularity in the appended claims. The invention itself, together with further objects and advantages thereof may be more fully comprehended by reference to the following detailed description of a presently preferred embodiment of the invention taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a section of a channel seal in accordance with the invention before a window is engaged.





FIG. 2

is a section of a channel seal in accordance with the invention after a window is engaged.





FIG. 3

illustrates the corner profile of the door window frame.





FIG. 4

illustrates a pillar cross section of the flange with a channel seal attached.





FIG. 5

illustrates a corner cross section of the flange with a channel seal attached.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




A combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle in accordance with this invention is shown in cross section in FIG.


1


. The channel seal


20


mounts to a door window frame


22


of a motor vehicle to engage three sides of a moveable window glass


24


. The fourth side of the window glass that remains within the door or body of the vehicle is sealed by a belt line seal usually mounted thereon.




The channel seal


20


cooperates with a resilient window engaging sealing insert


30


. The channel seal


20


has a generally U-shaped body member


26


adapted to engage a flange


28


surrounding the window opening of the motor vehicle. The body member


26


has a flange engaging U-shaped first channel


32


formed between an outer leg


34


and an inner leg


36


. The inner leg


36


forms a portion of the broader inverted U-shaped window run channel


38


. The base


40


of the inverted U-shaped window run channel portion of the seal has a substantially rigid strip


42


and an integral elastic joint strip


44


. In addition, the flange engaging U-shaped channel


32


is preferably provided with one or more soft gripping projections


46


and


48


for firmly securing the seal to the vehicle body. Projection


50


on the surface


51


of the U-shaped body member


26


of the channel seal


20


which faces the interior of the vehicle forms another seal to the vehicle body.




The legs


36


,


52


of the window run channel


38


have inwardly depending locking extensions


54


,


56


for engaging the insert


30


. In a preferred embodiment of the channel seal


20


a pivot projection


58


at the end of leg


52


extends above the base


40


and engages the frame


22


. The pivot projection


58


provides a point about which the channel seal


20


can pivot when a window glass


24


engages the insert


30


and deflects the elastic joint strip


44


.





FIG. 2

illustrates the effect of engaging a window glass


24


with the insert


30


. Pressure exerted by the window glass on the base


60


of the insert


30


deflects the base


60


against the rigid strip


42


of channel seal base


40


. The resultant pressure on the channel seal base


40


causes the elastic joint


44


to stretch and base


40


to move toward the frame


22


. Simultaneously, as base


40


moves toward frame


22


, leg


52


pivots inwardly about projection


58


and squeezes the leg extensions


62


and


64


of insert


30


against the glass


24


in a winking action to form a tighter seal. The dotted lines illustrate the position of the rigid strip


42




a,


the elastic joint strip


44




a


and the leg


52




a


before the window glass


24


is engaged. The elastic joint


44


can also be considered to be a flexible hinge about which the base


40


and leg


36


rotate.




It will be apparent to those with skill in this art that the channel seal of this invention can be adapted to seal with a window glass without using a sealing insert. The window run channel


38


can be provided with one or more sealing lips attached to the insides of legs


36


and


52


for slideably engaging the window glass when the window glass engages the base


40


of the channel seal


20


. Such sealing lips could also have a slip coating or flocking on the sliding surface.




The elastic joint strip


44


adjacent to a corner of the channel seal base


40


is advantageous for conforming the channel seal to a corner of the door window frame. The door window frame


22


into which the profile is fitted has a radius at a corner section which is greater than the radius at the pillar section of the frame.





FIG. 3

illustrates the corner profile of the door window frame showing the differential z between the distance x between the bottom of flange


28


and the pillar section


66


of the frame


22


and distance y between the bottom of the flange


28


and the corner section


68


of the frame


22


. The elastic joint strip


44


of the channel seal allows the seal to be accommodated in both sections of the frame


22


.




Referring now to

FIG. 4

there is shown a cross section AA of the door window frame with a channel seal profile attached to the pillar section


66


of frame


22


showing the elastic joint


44


in a normal extruded state and positioned to fit the seal within the distance x of the frame


22


.




Referring now to

FIG. 5

there is shown a cross section BB of the door window frame with a channel seal profile attached to the corner section


68


of frame


22


showing the elastic joint


44


in a stretched state which permits the seal to fit within the distance y of the frame


22


.




The TPE elastic joint allows for corner heat forming which results in a normal extruded shape (Section AA) which seals and fits a differential x to also fit, in a stretched state, a corner differential y as shown in Section BB.




The channel seal


20


is preferably formed from an extruded profile containing three different polymers, coming together into one profile. In one embodiment of the invention, a semi-rigid TPE material forms the structural shape of the profile; a flexible TPE is colored to match the automobile's interior color scheme, and finally an elastic TPE is extruded for the elastic joint and gripping extensions. To this TPE profile an EPDM rubber extrusion sealing insert is snapped into the glass run channel. This rubber extrusion can either have slip coating or flocking on the surfaces that come into contact with the glass. The soft TPE seals the static sealing area, while the EPDM rubber seals the dynamic area.




In one embodiment of the invention, the semi-rigid TPE forms the generally U-shaped frame comprising the legs


34


,


36


and


52


, and rigid strip


42


of base


40


. An elastic TPE forms the elastic joint strip


44


and projections


46


,


48


and


58


. A second flexible strip forms the projection


50


and interior facing surface


51


of the channel seal. The interior facing surface


51


can be colored to match the interior of the vehicle.




The resilient sealing insert


30


is mechanically attached within the window run channel by two anchoring lobes


70


,


72


that engage the locking extensions


56


,


54


to secure the sealing insert in the window run channel


38


of the channel seal


20


.




The insert


30


, which is preferably but not necessarily manufactured in an open, relatively flat configuration, is bent at its corners and inserted into the glass run channel of the carrier. To aid fitting of the insert it can have multiple slits across its length or it can be punched out at the corners.




The plastic portions of the carrier can be formed from a number of different plastic materials, for example, thermoplastics and thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs). Depending on their hardness TPEs are sometimes categorized as thermoplastics and sometimes as elastomers. For the purpose of this invention no such distinction will be made and hard and soft grades of plastic will all be referred to as TPEs.




TPEs are commercially available in several different brands and types. Each type can be obtained in different grades having different properties such as, hardness, tensile strength, compression, elongation, thermal stability and colorability. Selection of the appropriate TPE for a particular application depends on a suitable combination of such properties.




Types of TPEs which are particularly useful for the channel seal of the invention are the styrenic block copolymers, rubber-polyolefin blends, elastomeric alloys, thermoplastic alloys, thermoplastic elastomeric alloys, thermoplastic ionomers, thermoplastic polyurethanes, polyvinyl chlorides and blends thereof.




Styrenic block copolymers are commercially available in many types (and grades within types), for example, Kraton® from Shell Chemical Co. is based on block copolymers of styrene with a diene or an olefin pair, ethylene-butylene. The diene can be isoprene or butadiene.




The rubber-polyolefin blends (or thermoplastic polyolefins (TPOs)) are blends of various polyolefins with ethylene-propylene rubber (EPR) or ethylene-propylene-diene-monomer (EPDM). Suitable polyolefins include polypropylene and various types of polyethylene. Copolymers of propylene and ethylene and blends of TPOs can also be used. TPOs are also useful as modifiers of other TPEs.




Alloying is an interactive combination of two or more materials to give a material having better properties than those of the corresponding blend. Thermoplastic alloys are available with properties enabling them to be painted. Thermoplastic elastomeric alloys and elastomeric alloys (EAs) are composed of synergistic mixtures of two or more polymers that have been treated to give them properties different from simple blends of the major constituents. The two types of elastomeric alloys are melt processible rubbers (MPRs) and thermoplastic vulcanizates (TPVs).




EA-MPRs are a category of TPEs made of a highly plasticized, single phase combination of a chlorinated polyolefin, an ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer and an acrylic ester mixture in which the rubber phase is highly crosslinked, for example, Alcryn® from E. I. du Pont Nemours, Inc. EA-TPVs are made of a rubber/plastic polymer mixture in which the rubber phase is fully crosslinked.




The plastic phase of a TPV is commonly a polyolefin (especially polypropylene), and the rubber phase is often an ethylene-propylene elastomer. A particularly useful TPV, suitable for windows seals, is formed from polypropylene and EPDM rubber and is commercially available in several grades as Santoprene® from Monsanto Chemical Co.




Thermoplastic polyurethanes (TPUs) are formed by copolymerization of diisocyanates with long-chain diols and short-chain diols. TPUs are available commercially in a number of types and grades, for example, Texin® from Mobay Corporation, Estane® from B. F. Goodrich Co., Pellethane® from Dow Chemical Corp. and Q-Thane® from K. J. Quinn and Co., Inc.




Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) based TPEs are also suitable for window seals and are available in different grades and blends with other TPEs and rubbers. P-Valloy is one such material available from GBIE (Gerry Bareich Import Export Inc.) of Canada.




Thermoplastic ionomers are polymers containing interchain ionic bonding which affords tough, durable, transparent thermoplastics, for example, Surlyn® from E. I. du Pont de Nemours, Inc.




The substantially rigid plastic portion of the channel seal is preferably formed from a rigid or semi-rigid TPE. A rigid TPE, for example a polypropylene, preferably has a hardness in the range of 30 to 85 durometers, preferably 70 durometers, according to the Shore D scale. A semi-rigid TPE, for example Kraton®, has a hardness between 40 to 90 durometers preferably 70 durometers, according to the Shore A scale. Thus, as the substantially rigid portion of the channel seal extends along a length of the combination door and window channel seal


20


, seen in

FIG. 4

, the substantially rigid portion forms a strip extending along the longitudinal dimension of the combination door and window channel seal.




The soft plastic portions of the channel seal are formed from a softer more resilient TPE, for example Santoprene®, having a hardness in the range of 40 to 90 durometers, preferably 70 durometers according to the Shore A scale. The elastic joint strip or portion, is preferably formed from a TPE having a hardness in the range of 40 to 90 durometers, preferably 70 durometers according to the Shore A scale.




Such hard and soft TPEs are readily processed and fabricated, for example, by extrusion or molding and are particularly amenable to coextrusion and simultaneous molding of two or more TPEs of different durometer values. The TPEs are readily colored to match the vehicle either by incorporating pigment or by painting. Directly paintable TPE's have a high surface energy material blended into the base polymer to accept water-based paints without any pretreatment. Various hardnesses of this material are available from Ferro Corporation.




The hard TPEs can be made with a high gloss finish, for example a Class A finish or a gloss of at least 60 numerical value when measured at a 60 angle with a gloss meter is readily obtained which is substantially higher than can be obtained with an EPDM rubber seal. This TPE needs to meet the exterior weathering cycle per SAE J1960 with minimum change in color or gloss.




The resilient insert can be formed from a rubber, for example, natural rubber, styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR), ethylene-propylene rubber (EPR) or ethylene-propylene-diene-monomer (EPDM) rubber. EPDM is preferred and exhibits good compression set, durability and resistance to weathering.




In another aspect of the invention there is provided a method for forming a door and window channel seal of the invention in which the thermoplastic elastomer channel seal, for example as described in

FIG. 1

, is obtained by coextruding the thermoplastic elastomers of different durometer values to form a substantially rigid, channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shaped configuration. The extrusion temperature is generally between about 150 to 250 C., preferably about 200 C. In some applications the extrusion is further subjected to heat forming to conform to the shape of the vehicle body. The heat forming step can stretch the Elastic joint more in the corner of the seal than in the remainder of the seal.




The first post extrusion operation is forming the arches on the end of the extrusion. These curves will match the curvatures of the doors and glass. The arches are bent on each end of the part, allowing a precise fit with the pillars of the door. After the arches are formed, the corners are formed. After the TPE extrusion is formed to fit the door, the EPDM extrusion is snapped into the channel. A segmented strip across the base of the rubber extrusion, allows the extrusion to fit into the corners while maintaining wrinkle free sealing lips.




Installation of the TPE system is easy. The semi-rigid nature of this product allows for rough treatment. The product can be deformed and will snap back into position. When the window is rolled up the geometric design of the profile along with the special TPE material allows for closing action. When the window is rolled up, the elastic joint which is strategically located on the profile is responsible for the winking action when the window comes into contact with the seal. The winking action also occurs in the corner areas, making the seal close tightly on the glass.




The insert member is formed by extruding an elastomer, preferably an EPDM rubber, in a generally flat configuration and curing said extrusion. In a preferred embodiment of the invention the flat extrusion is then provided with a sliding surface, for example, by flocking. The extruded insert is then folded into the U-shaped channel seal to mechanically secure them together, for example, by interlocking the projections of the insert with the extensions of the channel seal.




In another aspect of the invention the thermoplastic elastomer channel seal, for example as described in

FIG. 1

, is obtained by thermally molding the thermoplastic elastomers of different durometer values to form a substantially rigid, thermoplastic channel seal a one-piece generally U-shaped configuration. The molding temperature is generally between about 150 to 250 C., preferably about 200 C.




This invention thus provides a combination door and window channel seal which is easily formed from substantially rigid and soft TPE's. The elastic joint allows the legs of the channel seal to pivot and form a tight seal with the window glass.




The TPE system with the rubber insert offers the following advantages: a 40% to 50% weight reduction per door; interior color matching; a wide variety in Class A surfaces on exterior surfaces from flat black to high gloss black; exterior color matching is possible. The TPE is environmentally friendly and can be recycled. The soft TPE seals the static sealing area, while the EPDM rubber seals the dynamic area.




The channel seal of the present invention has other advantages. The channel seal formed from substantially rigid thermoplastic material does not require a wire carrier, a stamped metal carrier or a solid metal support and can be provided with a finish gloss as high as 60 compared to rubber which is usually limited to a 20 gloss or less. The assembly requires less labor and capital expenditures not only to produce, but to install. The completed assembly is lighter than the all-rubber assemblies used in the past. Overall, the seal of this invention is more versatile, more attractive, and easier to maintain than known seals.




While the invention has been described in connection with a presently preferred embodiment thereof, those skilled in the art will recognize that many modifications and changes may be made therein without departing from the true spirit and scope of the invention, which accordingly is intended to be defined solely by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A method for forming a combination door and window channel seal comprising:extruding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shaped configuration so that a corner of a window channel section of the seal has an elastic strip of increased flexibility disposed between substantially rigid strips of a material having less elasticity than the elastic strip, the window channel section selected to operably receive a resilient window engaging sealing insert, and the door and the window channel seal including a second generally U-shaped flange engaging portion.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, further comprising heat forming the elastic strip to fit a corner differential of a door and window frame of the motor vehicle.
  • 3. The method of claim 2, wherein the heat forming step further comprises stretching the elastic strip more in the corner of the door and window channel seal than in the remainder of the door and window channel seal.
  • 4. A method for forming a combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle, the method comprising:molding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shaped configuration so that a corner of a window channel section of the seal has an elastic strip of increased flexibility disposed between adjacent strips, the elastic strip of a more elastic material than the adjacent strips, the window channel section adapted to receive a resilient window engaging sealing insert to contact a glass panel.
  • 5. The method of claim 4, further comprising heat forming the elastic strip to fit a corner differential of a door and window frame of the motor vehicle.
  • 6. The method of claim 5, wherein the heat forming step further comprises stretching the elastic strip more in the corner of the door and window channel seal than in the remainder of the door and window channel seal.
  • 7. The method of claim 4, further comprising molding the door and window channel seal to include a second generally U-shaped flange engaging channel.
  • 8. A method for forming a combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle, the method comprising extruding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values, one of the thermoplastic elastomers being of a greater elasticity, to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shape configuration having an elastic joint strip of the greater elasticity thermoplastic elastomer intermediate a pair of strips formed of thermoplastic elastomer of less elasticity, the generally U-shape configuration of the door and window channel seal adapted to receive and retain a resilient window engaging sealing insert.
  • 9. The method of claim 8, further comprising locating the elastic joint strip at a corner of a window channel section of the seal.
  • 10. The method of claim 8, further comprising heat forming the elastic joint strip to fit a corner differential of a door and window frame.
  • 11. A method for forming a combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle, the method comprising:molding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shaped configuration so that a corner of a window channel section of the door and window channel seal has an elastic strip of increased flexibility disposed between adjacent strips, the elastic strip of a more elastic material than the adjacent strips; and inserting a resilient window engaging seating insert into the window channel section.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, further comprising locating the elastic joint strip at a corner of a window channel section of the seal.
  • 13. The method of claim 11, further comprising heat forming the elastic strip to fit a corner differential of a door and window frame.
  • 14. A method for forming a combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle, the method comprisingextruding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values, to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece frame having a first generally U-shape window channel section for operably receiving a resilient window engaging sealing insert and a second generally U-shaped flange engaging section, the window channel section having an elastic joint strip of a first durometer intermediate a pair of strips formed of a higher second durometer material; and inserting a resilient window engaging sealing insert into the window channel section.
  • 15. The method of claim 14, further comprising forming the elastic joint strip of a material having a Shore A durometer scale value.
  • 16. The method of claim 14, further comprising forming the pair strips of a material having a Shore D durometer scale value.
  • 17. The method of claim 14, further comprising forming the elastic joint strip of a material having a Shore A durometer scale value between 40 and 90.
  • 18. The method of claim 14, further comprising forming the pair strips of a material having a Shore D durometer scale value between 30 and 85.
  • 19. The method of claim 14, further comprising locating the elastic joint strip at a corner of a window channel section of the seal.
  • 20. The method of claim 14, further comprising heat forming the elastic strip to fit a corner differential of a door and window frame.
  • 21. A method forming a combination door and window channel seal for a motor vehicle, the method comprising molding thermoplastic elastomers of at least two different durometer values, to form a door and window channel seal in a one-piece generally U-shape window channel section having an elastic joint strip of a first durometer intermediate a pair of strips formed of a higher second durometer material, the window channel section adapted to receive a resilient window engaging sealing insert for contacting a window; andinserting a resilient window engaging sealing insert for contacting a window into the window channel section.
  • 22. The method of claim 21, further comprising forming the elastic joint strip of a material having a Shore A durometer scale value.
  • 23. The method of claim 21, further comprising forming the pair strips of a material having a Shore D durometer scale value.
  • 24. The method of claim 21, further comprising forming the elastic joint strip of a material having a Shore A durometer scale value between 40 and 90.
  • 25. The method of claim 21, further comprising forming the pair strips of a material having a Shore D durometer scale value between 30 and 85.
  • 26. The method of claim 21, further comprising locating the elastic joint strip at a corner of a window channel section of the seal.
  • 27. The method of claim 21, further comprising heat forming the elastic strip to fit a corner differential of a door arid window frame.
Parent Case Info

This application is a division of 08/719,988 filed Sep. 25, 1996, now U.S. Pat. No. 6,023,888.

US Referenced Citations (14)
Number Name Date Kind
4649668 Skillen et al. Mar 1987 A
4843763 Mesnel Jul 1989 A
4970828 Mesnel et al. Nov 1990 A
5009947 McManus et al. Apr 1991 A
5010689 Vaughan Apr 1991 A
5014464 Dupuy et al. May 1991 A
5317835 Dupuy et al. Jun 1994 A
5343609 McManus Sep 1994 A
5377449 Hineribara et al. Jan 1995 A
5408784 Wruck et al. Apr 1995 A
5475947 Dupuy Dec 1995 A
6023888 Dover Feb 2000 A
6070364 Berry Jun 2000 A
6138338 Berry Oct 2000 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
0 403 854 Dec 1990 EP
58-49515 Mar 1983 JP