Method for joining tubular members

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6654995
  • Patent Number
    6,654,995
  • Date Filed
    Monday, October 16, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, December 2, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
A method is disclosed for inserting an end of a first tubular member into a complementary end of a second tubular member and attaching (e.g., welding) the adjacent surfaces of the inserted ends in a tight peripheral bond. In the method, a substantially continuous protrusion is formed in either the first or second member. Thereafter, the first and second tubular members are placed relative to each other such that a current may be passed through the protrusion and a seal may be formed, thereby joining the members.
Description




TECHNICAL FIELD




The present invention relates to a method for making a sound circumferential weld at the overlapped joining region of a metal tube-receiving member with an inserted tube. In a particular application, the present invention relates to a practical method for forming such a hydrostatic pressure-tight connection in an assembled tubular structure intended to undergo subsequent hydroforming.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




There are a variety of manufacturing or assembly applications in which the end of one metal tube is inserted into the complementary cylindrical recess of another member for permanent attachment to it. In many applications the receiving member is a second tube with an end sized to receive the end of the first tube. In other applications, for example, the second member is a structural member, such as a nodal piece of a tubular frame structure with an opening adapted to be inserted into, or to receive, the end of one or more such tubes.




Frame structures comprising an assembly of tubes and tube-end attachment members have been used in bicycle frames and small airplane bodies and the like. Such structures are also being considered for car bodies as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,720,092, assigned to the assignee of this invention. In the automotive application, it may be the practice to assemble a group of round metal tubes with each other and tube-end receiving node pieces into an initial frame assembly. The initial assembly is placed between matched dies, filled with water and subjected to sufficient hydrostatic pressure to expand or bend or otherwise reshape the initial tubular assembly into an integral frame member of complex three-dimensional shape. In this hydroforming procedure, it is necessary to have high pressure water-tight connections between tubes or between tubes and mating structural members. Heretofore there has not been a practical and reliable method of obtaining such connections.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




This invention provides a method of providing a sound circumferential weld between the end of a tube and a second member adapted to receive either the inside or outside dimension of the tube end in suitably tight engagement. The pieces to be welded may be two tubes with inter-fitting ends or a tube and a tube-end receiving member. The tube-end receiving member may be sized to receive the outside diameter of the tube, or the tube receiving member may itself have a tube portion that fits within the inside diameter of the tube. While the following description is largely expressed in terms of two tubes for simplicity, the subject method is applicable to both of the above-described applications. As stated, a principal purpose and application of the invention is in assembling tubular frame structures for subsequent hydroforming.




In many, but not necessarily all, applications, the starting workpieces will be round tubes with the outside diameter of the end of the first tube closely fitting the inside diameter of the end portion of the second tube. Of course, the end portions of such tubes can be of any suitable cross section so long as they are complementary, or geometrically similar, for insertion of one into the other. For example, the tubes could be square, rectangular, oval, or the like. Again, for simplicity, in the following description the tubes will often be referred to as round, but the applicability of this process is to tubes of complementary end portions in general.




According to a first embodiment of the invention, a first tubular member is provided having an end with a predetermined, desired outer diameter (sometimes OD herein), or other defining dimension if the tube is not round, and a second tubular member is provided having an internal diameter (sometimes ID herein) slightly larger (for example, about two millimeters larger) than the OD of the first tube. A continuous, circumferential, inwardly directed, shallow protrusion is formed in the end region of the second tube. Preferably, the inside dimension of the annular protrusion is such that it will tightly receive the OD surface of the first tube. Thus, where there is about two millimeters difference in the diameters of the complementary tubes, the protrusion extends radially about one millimeter in from the ID of the outer tube. The end of the first tube is inserted into the end of the second tube through the surrounding protrusion. Initially, the protrusion serves to locate and grip the inserted tube. Then a suitable welding current is passed through the overlapping portions of the assembled tubes and through the projection to form a full circumferential bond between the tubes.




In a preferred embodiment, radial pressure is concurrently applied to the outer tube to press its protrusion against the inner tube and promote a full circumferential welded bond between the facing surfaces of the mated tubes. Such pressure may, for example, be applied mechanically with a tool(s) of suitable circumferential shape, or by non-contact means as with a circumferential electromagnetic forming tool.




According to a second embodiment of the present invention, the protrusion is formed on the OD surface of the inner tube of the assembly. The annular protrusion extends outwardly for full circumferential engagement with the inner ID surface of the outer tube. After the end of the outer tube has been pushed over the protrusion of the inner tube, a suitable welding current is passed through the joined pieces and projection to accomplish a full circumferential weld at the region of the projection.




Complementary projections could be formed on both tubes so that, for example, when the tubes are inserted for welding, the projections lie close and parallel to ultimately provide a wider welded connection between the tubes. As stated, a principle application for the subject method is to form a tubular assembly for subsequent hydroforming.











Advantageously, relatively few tools or parts are required to quickly form a high integrity joint. These and other aspects and advantages of the present invention will become apparent upon reading the following detailed description in combination with the accompanying drawings.




BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

illustrates a sectional side view of a first tubular member being joined to a second tubular member according to an aspect of the present invention.





FIG. 2

illustrates a sectional side view of a first tubular member being joined to a second tubular member according to an aspect of the present invention.





FIG. 3

illustrates a schematic view of a protrusion being formed in a tubular member according to an aspect of the present invention.





FIG. 4

illustrates another schematic sectional view of a protrusion being formed in a tubular member according to an aspect of the present invention.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




In the most general form, the present invention provides a method for joining or attaching a first tubular member to a second tubular member.




In a non-limiting embodiment of the invention the method includes providing a first tubular member, a second tubular member having a portion for matingly engaging the first tubular member, and a protrusion projecting outward of the wall of the second member, inward of the wall of the first member or both types of projections. Referring to

FIG. 1

, there is illustrated a non-limiting embodiment of a first tubular member


10


and a second tubular member


14


being attached or joined to each other.




The first tubular member


10


is generally elongated with a first end


16


and a second end


18


. The first member


10


may include an inner surface


20


(if hollow as shown) and an outer surface


22


. A hollow portion or passageway


24


extends along the length of the member


10


between the first end


16


and the second end


18


. In one embodiment, the first member


10


is generally curved or cylindrical around the hollow portion


24


such that a cross-section of the member


10


taken perpendicular to the length of the member


10


would appear substantially circular or elliptical.




In alternative embodiments, the first member


10


may be other than circular or elliptical. For example, the first member may be generally square, triangular or some other polygon or combination of planar and curved surfaces about its periphery. The cross-sectional shape may also vary along the length of the first member


10


.




In the embodiment shown in

FIG. 1

, the second tubular member


14


is also elongated and extends between a first end


26


and a second end


28


. The second member


14


further includes an inner surface


30


and an outer surface


32


. A hollow portion or passageway


34


extends at least partially along the length of the member


14


between the first end


26


and the second end


28


. In the embodiment shown, the second member


14


is generally circular or cylindrical around the hollow portion


34


such that a cross-section of the member


10


taken perpendicular to the length of the member


14


would appear substantially circular. Also in the embodiment shown, the first end


26


of the second member


14


has a greater diameter than the second end


18


of the first member


10


such that the first end


26


of the second member


14


can receive the second end


18


of the first member


10


within the hollow portion


34


of the second member


14


.




In the embodiment shown, the second member


14


includes a protrusion


36


that extends substantially continuously about the hollow portion


34


or periphery of the second member


14


. Though other sectional configurations are possible including flat or angular surfaces, the protrusion


36


is generally curved or arcuate (e.g., as a ā€œUā€) in cross-section and extends radially inward toward the hollow portion


34


.




In further alternative embodiments, the first tubular member


10


may have an enlarged portion for receiving the second tubular member


14


and the second member


14


may be substantially uniform along its length. The protrusion


36


may be formed in either the first or the second members


10


,


14


and may extend radially inward or outward relative to the hollow portions or relative to the rest of the members


10


,


14


. Particularly in

FIG. 5

, there is shown an outwardly extending radial protrusion


100


from the outer surface


102


of the first tubular member


10


.




The first and second tubular members may be formed from a variety of fusible materials. Such materials include, but are not limited to, steel, aluminum, titanium, magnesium, plastic, ceramic, carbon fiber, composites or the like. Furthermore, the first and second members may be formed in any of a variety of manners. For example, the first and second members may be hydroformed, drawn, extruded, forged, roll-formed, cast, molded or otherwise formed by some suitable process, depending upon the material used for the members. In one non-limiting embodiment, for an automotive vehicle frame, the material used for the first and second members is selected from steel, galvanized steel, aluminum, titanium, magnesium, or a mixture thereof, and the first and second members are conventional tubing which may be utilized as part of the frame of an automotive vehicle. Preferably, the tubing is formed with conventional hydroforming techniques. Optionally the material is coated to help resist corrosion (e.g., by a suitable primer). One of skill in the art will recognize that the choice of material used to form the first and second tubular members and the manner in which such members are formed can vary depending upon the application for which the members are to be used.




In one non-limiting embodiment of the invention, the first tubular member


10


and the second tubular member


14


may be parts or components of a space frame for an automotive vehicle. Space frames for automotive vehicles can include tubes with are either joined directly to each other or are joined by connectors or joints. Examples of such space frames and methods for hydroforming such space frames are disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,720,092, which is herein fully incorporated by reference. It shall be recognized that the first member


10


and the second member


14


of the present invention could be tubes, connectors or joints in a vehicle space frame.




In a non-limiting embodiment of the invention, the method of attaching a first member to a second member includes forming a protrusion on the first member, on the second member or both. The protrusion may be formed in a variety of manners. The protrusion may be formed as the member is formed. For example, a tubular member may be hydroformed, cast or otherwise formed with the protrusion in the member. Alternatively, the protrusion may be formed in a pre-formed member. The protrusion is then welded (e.g., by resistance heating it) to the first or second tubular member.




Referring to

FIGS. 3 and 4

, without limitation as to alternative methods for plastically deforming a material to a predetermined configuration, there is disclosed two illustrative alternative methods of forming a protrusion in a tubular member.





FIG. 3

schematically illustrates a roll grooving technique for forming a groove or protrusion in or on a tubular member. In the embodiment shown, there is an elongated tubular member


50


and one or a plurality of (e.g., three) rollers


52


, which are attached to a conventional roll grooving machine (not shown). The rollers


52


are spaced along the length of the tubular member


50


. A first and second roller


52


contact an outer surface


56


of the tubular member


50


and a third roller


52


contacts an inner surface


58


of the tubular member


50


. In the embodiment shown, the first, second and third rollers


52


are spaced on the tubular member


50


such that the third roller


52


is between the first and second roller


52


relative to the elongation of the tubular member


50


. In operation, the first and second rollers


52


place a force upon the outer surface


56


of the member


50


and the third roller


52


places a force on the inner surface


58


of the member


50


and the first, second and third rollers


52


move about the circumference of the tubular member


50


thereby gradually forming a groove or protrusion in the tubular member


50


with the third roller


52


. It should be recognized that the location of the rotational axis of each roller


52


can be varied as desired to achieve the desired deformation of the workpiece or member.





FIG. 4

schematically illustrates a segmented tooling expansion/reduction technique for forming a groove or protrusion in a tubular member. In the embodiment shown, a protrusion (not shown) is being formed in a tubular member


70


with a suitable expansion/reduction assembly


72


. The assembly


72


includes an internal tapered mandrel


74


, which is surrounded by a plurality of dies


76


. The dies


76


include a convex or a concave bead forming portion (not shown) or some other suitable shaped bead forming portion and the mandrel


74


and the dies


76


are surrounded by or housed within the tubular member


70


. The expansion/reduction assembly


72


also includes external reduction dies


78


and an external tapered ring


80


to reduce or compress the external dies


78


. The dies


76


,


78


include either a convex or a concave bead forming portion (not shown) and the ring


80


and the dies


78


surround the tubular member


70


. In a preferred embodiment, one of the beads on the dies


76


,


78


is convex and one is concave and the bead forming portions are generally complementary.




In operation, the internal tapered mandrel


74


is moved in one direction and the external tapered ring


80


is moved in an opposite direction. The mandrel


74


forces or biases the internal dies


76


outward thereby pushing outwardly upon the tubular member


70


while the external ring


80


forces or biases the external dies


78


inward thereby pushing inwardly upon the tubular member


70


. As the dies


76


,


78


push in opposing directions, the beads on the dies


76


,


78


form a protrusion in the tubular member


70


because the bead on one of the dies


76


,


78


is convex while the bead on the other one of the dies


76


,


78


is concave. For example, the bead on the internal dies


76


may be convex and push a portion of the tubular member


70


into a concave bead of the external dies


78


thereby forming the protrusion.




The person of skill in the art will recognize that the type of protrusion and manner in which the protrusion is formed can be a selective choice based upon the desired characteristics of the attachment of the first member to the second member.




In a non-limiting embodiment of the invention, the method of attaching a first tubular member to a second tubular member also includes placing the protrusion of either the first or the second member such that the protrusion substantially surrounds or is surrounded by the other member.




Again referring to the non-limiting embodiment of

FIG. 1

, there is illustrated the protrusion


36


on the second tubular member


14


which substantially continuously surrounds the first tubular member


10


. In the non-limiting embodiment, the second end


18


of the first member


10


is placed within the first end


26


of the second member


14


such that the protrusion


36


contacts the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


. Preferably, the protrusion


36


is in intimate contact with the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


and; therefore substantially contacts the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


in a substantially continuously manner about or surrounding the hollow portion


20


or the first member


10


.




In a non-limiting embodiment of the invention, the method of attaching a first tubular member to a second tubular member further includes applying energy (e.g., sufficient for heating to about or above the melting point of the protrusion) to the protrusion effective to join the protrusion, and thus the first and second members.




Referring again to

FIG. 1

, there is schematically illustrated one non-limiting method of heating the protrusion


36


by resistance heating. In general this involves applying electrical energy to the proposed joint, heating the joint to cause the metal of the protrusion to fuse to both the first and second tubular member and cooling the resulting joint. In one example, electrical connections


60


are selectively attached to, or contacted with either and preferably both of the first and the second members


10


,


14


. In the embodiment shown, the electrical connections


60


are resistive bands and may be cylindrical or other suitable shape and respectively surround and contact the outer cylindrical surfaces


22


,


32


of the first and second members


10


,


14


. The electrical connections


60


are electrically connected or attached via busses or wires to an electrical power source or supply (not shown).




In non-limiting embodiments, the electrical power source may be chosen from a DC or AC power supply, a conventional transformer, a capacitor or inductor, a pulsing power supply, a capacitive discharge power supply or other power or electrical current supplies. In non-limiting embodiments of the invention, the electrical connections may take a variety of forms as well. For example, the connections could be clamps, blocks, cylinders or the like. The connections could be adjustable or non-adjustable. Furthermore, the connections could be formed from a variety of materials and the materials chosen for the connections may depend upon the material used to form the first and second tubular members. In non-limiting embodiments, the connections are conductive metals (e.g., containing copper, iron, aluminum or the like), and preferably the connections are copper clamps or copper cylinders.




Once the electrical connections


60


have been placed upon the first and second members


10


,


14


, an electric potential is induced between the connections


60


effective to pass a current through the protrusion


36


. Because the protrusion


36


interrupts the natural flow of the current through the tubular members


10


,


14


, the protrusion


36


provides greater resistance to the flow of the current, which causes the protrusion


36


to heat up. Once the protrusion


36


heats, it tends to melt for initiating a weld and a portion of the first member


10


may melt as well. Once initiated, the weld will grow along the protrusion


36


and, when the current is stopped, the protrusion


36


tends to cool thereby welding or attaching the first and second members


10


,


14


together. Because the protrusion


36


substantially surrounds and is in close contact with the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


, a substantially water or fluid tight seal or weld joint that is substantially continuous about the protrusion or the first member


10


is formed between the first and second tubular member


10


,


14


such that water or fluid could be passed from the hollow portion


24


of the first member


10


to the hollow portion


34


of the second member


14


with an insignificant amount, if any, of water or fluid leaking through the joint.




In alternative embodiments, the electrical connections may be placed in alternative places or positions upon one or more members as long as a current is passed through the protrusion upon one or more of the members. For example, and without limitation, the electrical connections


60


could be respectively contacted with the first and second ends


26


,


28


of the second member


14


and a current could still be passed through the protrusion


36


. Furthermore, other methods of passing current through the protrusion may also be used according to the present invention. For example the members or the protrusion may be directly in communication with one or more power supplies.




Advantageously, the seal or weld that is formed at the protrusion


36


is of sufficient strength, malleability or both such that the first an second tubular members or the like may be later hydroformed. Either the portions of the members


10


,


14


including the seal or weld or other portions of the members


10


,


14


may be altered or shaped by hydroforming once the seal or welds have been formed.




In a further non-limiting embodiment of the invention, the method of attaching a first tubular member to a second tubular member includes biasing a portion of the protrusion toward the member to which it is being attached and/or biasing the member toward the protrusion. Various methods may be used to bias the protrusion toward the member or the member toward the protrusion. Such methods may use mechanical, magnetic or other force.




Referring to

FIG. 2

, a clamp


90


(generally conformable to the outer surface of the first or second member


10


,


14


) is used to bias the protrusion


36


of the second member


14


toward the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


. In one embodiment, the clamp


90


is mechanically operated and can be selectively placed to surround the protrusion


36


of the second member


14


. The clamp may be adjustable or non-adjustable. In the embodiment shown, where the members


10


,


14


have a generally circular cross-section, the clamp


90


is a substantially cylindrical metal member which may be forcibly placed in a position surrounding the protrusion


36


thereby biasing the protrusion of the second member


14


toward the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


and promoting greater contact between the outer surface


22


and the protrusion


36


.




In an alternative embodiment, the clamp


90


may be a conformable magnetic member


90


which is placed to surround the protrusion


36


. Once in place, a magnetic flux may be induced in the member


90


such that a magnetic field is induced by the member


90


which pushes upon the protrusion


36


effective to bias the protrusion


36


toward the outer surface


22


of the first member


10


and promote greater contact between the protrusion


36


and the first member


10


.




In other embodiments, the magnetic member may be in a variety of forms or shapes. For example the magnetic member may be a wire or other metal member which winds the around the protrusion.




In still further embodiments, a magnetic member may be used to form a protrusion in one of the members. For example, the magnetic member


90


may be placed to surround a portion of the first end


26


of the second member


14


and a magnetic field induced by the member


90


could exert sufficient force upon the portion of the first end


26


of the second member


14


to form the protrusion


36


.




The person of skill in the art will recognize a variety of manners in which members and/or protrusion can be biased toward each other.




It should be understood that the invention is not limited to the exact embodiment or construction which has been illustrated and described but that various changes may be made without departing from the spirit and the scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A method for joining a first tubular member, having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, to a second tubular member having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, the end portion of said second tubular member being of a size and shape for receiving, upon insertion, the end portion of said first tubular member such that the outer surface of said first member then is adjacent the full periphery of the inner surface of said second member, said method comprising the steps of:forming a continuous peripheral protrusion from and around the outer surface of said first tubular member or the inner surface of said second tubular member, said protrusion being directed and sized to engage the adjacent surface of the other of said members upon said insertion; inserting said end portion of said first tubular member into the end portion of said second tubular member such that the full periphery of said protrusion contacts said adjacent surface; passing a current through said protrusion effective to form a sealing bond between said protrusion and said adjacent surface; and hydroforming said first and second tubular members including the sealing bond.
  • 2. A method as in claim 1 in which at least one said protrusion is formed generally radially inwardly from the inner surface of said second tubular member.
  • 3. A method as in claim 1 in which at least one said protrusion is formed generally radially outwardly from the outer surface of said first tubular member.
  • 4. A method as in claim 1 further comprising, exerting a force effective to promote contact between said protrusion and said adjacent surface at substantially the same time as said step of passing current through said protrusion.
  • 5. A method as in claim 4, wherein said step of exerting said force includes placing a magnetic member adjacent said protrusion.
  • 6. A method as in claim 1, wherein said step of forming said protrusion includes roll grooving.
  • 7. A method as in claim 1, wherein said step of forming said protrusion includes simultaneously placing an expanding and a reducing force upon said tubular member.
  • 8. A method for joining a first tubular member, having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, to a second tubular member having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, the end portion of the second tubular member being of a size and shape for receiving, upon insertion, the end portion of the first tubular member such that the outer surface of the first member then is adjacent the full periphery of the inner surface of the second member, the method comprising the steps of:forming a continuous peripheral protrusion from and around the outer surface of the first tubular member or the inner surface of the second tubular member, the protrusion being directed and sized to engage the adjacent surface of the other of the members upon insertion; inserting the end portion of the first tubular member into the end portion of the second tubular member such that the full periphery of the protrusion contacts the adjacent surface wherein contact of the full periphery with the adjacent surface is the only contact between the first tubular member and the second tubular member; passing a current from a first electrical connection through the protrusion to a second electrical connection by inducing an electrical potential between the connections wherein the current is effective to form a sealing weld between the protrusion and the adjacent surface; and hydroforming said first and second tubular members including the sealing weld.
  • 9. A method as in claim 8 in which at least one said protrusion is formed generally radially inwardly from the inner surface of the second tubular member prior to the insertion step.
  • 10. A method as in claim 8 in which at lest one said protrusion is formed generally radially outwardly from the outer surface of the first tubular member prior to the insertion step.
  • 11. A method as in claim 8 further comprising exerting a force effective to promote contact between the protrusion and the adjacent surface at substantially the same time as the step of passing a current through the protrusion.
  • 12. A method as in claim 11 wherein the step of exerting the force includes placing a magnetic member adjacent to the protrusion.
  • 13. A method as in claim 8 wherein the step of forming the protrusion includes roll grooving.
  • 14. A method as in claim 8 wherein the step of forming the protrusion includes simultaneously placing an expanding and a reducing force upon the tubular member.
  • 15. A method for joining a first tubular member, having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, to a second tubular member having an end portion with an inner surface and an outer surface, the end portion of the second tubular member being of a size and shape for receiving, upon insertion, the end portion of the first tubular member such that the outer surface of the first member is adjacent the full periphery of the inner surface of the second member, the method comprising the steps of:forming a continuous peripheral protrusion from and around the outer surface of the first tubular member or the inner surface of the second tubular member, the protrusion being directed and sized to engage the adjacent surface of the other of the members upon insertion; inserting the end portion of the first tubular member into the end portion of the second tubular after forming the protrusion, thereby contacting the full periphery of the protrusion with the adjacent surface; biasing the protrusion and the adjacent surface together with a magnetic flux for promoting greater contact between the protrusion and the adjacent surface; passing a current from a first electrical connection through the protrusion to a second electrical connection by inducing an electrical potential between the connections with a pulsing power supply wherein the current is effective to form a sealing weld between the protrusion and the adjacent surface; and hydroforming the first and second tubular members including the sealing weld to form a component of a space frame of an automotive vehicle.
  • 16. A method as in claim 15 in which at least one said protrusion is formed generally radially inwardly from the inner surface of the second tubular member prior to the insertion step.
  • 17. A method as in claim 15 in which at least one said protrusion is formed generally radially outwardly from the outer surface of the first tubular member prior to the insertion step.
  • 18. A method as in claim 15 further comprising exerting a force effective to promote contact between the protrusion and the adjacent surface at substantially the same time as the step of passing a current through the protrusion.
US Referenced Citations (50)
Number Name Date Kind
1020991 Lachman Mar 1912 A
1703037 Heck Feb 1929 A
1822197 Bowlus Sep 1931 A
1901176 Lawson Mar 1933 A
1977567 Eksergian Oct 1934 A
2757028 Latzen Jul 1956 A
3114030 Ruskin Dec 1963 A
3118049 Gros et al. Jan 1964 A
3125493 D'Amore Mar 1964 A
3162940 Kuhn Dec 1964 A
3208136 Joslin Sep 1965 A
3210102 Joslin Oct 1965 A
3467414 Downing Sep 1969 A
3473359 Joslin Oct 1969 A
3867824 Takagi et al. Feb 1975 A
3885821 Philibert May 1975 A
3909045 Meagher Sep 1975 A
3916504 Thorne et al. Nov 1975 A
4091648 McCaslin May 1978 A
4257155 Hunter Mar 1981 A
4269438 Ridenour May 1981 A
4396213 Hawkins Aug 1983 A
4442586 Ridenour Apr 1984 A
4495397 Opprecht et al. Jan 1985 A
4497428 Baumann Feb 1985 A
4504714 Katzenstein Mar 1985 A
4513188 Katzenstein Apr 1985 A
4547641 Nebergall et al. Oct 1985 A
4677271 Opprecht Jun 1987 A
4804819 Farrow Feb 1989 A
4850621 Umehara Jul 1989 A
4902048 Washizu Feb 1990 A
4902049 Umehara Feb 1990 A
5073693 Kikuchi et al. Dec 1991 A
5168142 Gartner et al. Dec 1992 A
5283413 Favre-Tissot Feb 1994 A
5333775 Bruggemann et al. Aug 1994 A
5544406 Ridenour et al. Aug 1996 A
5720092 Ni et al. Feb 1998 A
5813264 Steingroever Sep 1998 A
5890287 Fukaya Apr 1999 A
5937496 Benoit et al. Aug 1999 A
6010155 Rinehart Jan 2000 A
6104012 Durand Aug 2000 A
6244088 Compton Jun 2001 B1
6361244 Ni et al. Mar 2002 B1
6421913 Bonnah, II et al. Jul 2002 B1
6427309 Viegener Aug 2002 B1
6460250 Amborn et al. Oct 2002 B1
6474534 Gabbianelli et al. Nov 2002 B2
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
134566 Mar 1985 EP