Patent Grant
11820653
The invention relates to an improved method for oxidizing ammonia for the production of nitrogen oxides, which is used in particular in the production of nitric acid and of caprolactam. The invention relates also to an improved system for producing oxidation products of ammonia.
In the large-scale production of nitrogen-containing base materials for the chemical industry, the catalytic oxidation of ammonia (NH3) to NOx-nitrogen oxides often forms a base reaction. Mention may be made here of the production of nitric acid (HNO3) as a starting material, for example, for nitrate-containing fertilizers, or of the production of hydroxylamine or hydroxylammonium salts for the production of caprolactam and thus of polyamides.
The following statements concerning the prior art relate by way of example to the production of HNO3 by catalytic oxidation of NH3.
The production of nitric acid is one of the most well-established processes of chemical technology, which was developed to industrial maturity following the introduction of the Haber-Bosch process for NH3 synthesis by W. Ostwald on the basis of platinum catalysts and the design of which still forms the basis of modern HNO3 production even today.
The first commercial system with a platinum catalyst (grooved strips of Pt film) for the production of 1500 tonnes of ammonium nitrate per year was thus constructed in 1906 in Gerthe bei Bochum. A short time later (1909), the first patents relating to the use of woven platinum screens as catalysts appeared. Slightly later again, these were then alloyed with rhodium. Although the catalyst involves high investment costs and is consumed during the NH3 oxidation (platinum burns off), these catalyst systems are still in use today and, in modified form (customized knitted fabrics), still represent the prior art (see Winnacker Küchler, Chemische Technik—Prozesse and Produkte, 5th Edition, Volume 3, Chapter 3, p. 248-275, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA).
Recently, increased use has been made of platinum metal screens with high Pd contents, because they permit not only a certain reduction of costs but also a reduction of the laughing gas (N2O) which is undesirably formed in the NH3 oxidation and which is a greenhouse gas.
Conventional dimensions for platinum metal screens, which are stretched over a wide area in an ammonia oxidation reactor frequently referred to as a “burner”, are in the range of from 0.5 to 5 m diameter. The thickness of the screen packing is conventionally from a few millimeters to approximately two centimeters, depending on the number of screens used.
A gas mixture typically comprising approximately from 9 to 12% by volume NH3 and air flows through the screens, a temperature of approximately from 800 to 950° C. being established at the screens as a result of the exothermic nature of the oxidation reaction. NH3 is thereby oxidized very selectively to nitrogen monoxide (NO) (see reaction scheme 1 below), which is then oxidized in the course of the further process to nitrogen dioxide (NO2) (reaction scheme 2) and finally is converted to HNO3 with water in an absorption tower (reaction scheme 3).
Primary NH3 oxidation—target reaction:
4NH3+5O2→4NO+6H2O (1)
NO oxidation:
2NO+O2→2NO2 (2)
HNO3 formation:
3NO2+H2O→2HNO3+NO (3)
The brutto reaction resulting therefrom is:
NH3+2O2→HNO3+H2O (4)
Even though the O2 content of 21% by volume in the combustion air is accordingly just sufficient formally to ensure complete conversion of 10% by volume NH3 to HNO3, in the commercial production of HNO3 further atmospheric oxygen (secondary air) is supplied to the process gas (also referred to as “process gas”) after the catalytic NH3 oxidation and before entry into the absorption tower, in order to accelerate the NO oxidation and thus the formation of HNO3 in the absorption tower. The residual content of oxygen in the waste gas leaving the absorption tower is typically approximately from 1 to 5% by volume.
According to current understanding of the primary oxidation reaction (see Handbook of Heterogeneous Catalysis, 2nd Edition, Volume 5, 2008, Chapter 12.2.7.1, p. 2582, WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, 2008), a high partial oxygen pressure is required in the combustion of the NH3 in order to suppress the formation of nitrogen and laughing gas, as valueless secondary products, on the surface of the catalyst. This observation is in agreement with the stoichiometries of the formation of N2 and N2O (see reaction schemes 5 and 6 below), which require less oxygen compared with NO formation (reaction scheme 1).
Primary NH3 oxidation—secondary reactions:
4NH3+3O2→2N2+6H2O (5)
4NH3+4O2→2N2O+6H2O (6)
The formation of NO2, which according to reaction scheme (7) would require an increased amount of oxygen, does not take place on platinum metal catalysts.
4NH3+7O2→4NO2+6H2O (7)
The formation of the secondary products, or NOx selectivity, is also dependent on the general operating pressure of the NH3 oxidation. The higher the pressure, the lower the NOx yield. The NOx yields which can be achieved according to the current prior art with different process variants (combustion pressures) are shown in the following table (taken from (Winnacker-Küchler, Chemische Technik—Prozesse and Produkte, 5th Edition, Volume 3, Chapter 3, p. 248-275, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA).
A shortcoming of the platinum metal screen catalysts is, however, the only low stability of the catalyst at the high operating temperature of approximately 900° C. The burning off of the noble metal causes the catalyst to be consumed, at approximately from 0.04 to 0.4 g Pt/t HNO3, according to the prevailing combustion pressure, so that the catalyst must be renewed at regular intervals, approximately every 3 months to 15 months according to the combustion pressure. This leads to not inconsiderable costs, even if a portion of the platinum which has been burnt off is recovered by various catcher systems (e.g. Pd screens).
On account of these disadvantages, attempts have repeatedly been made to develop alternative metal-oxide-based catalyst materials in order in particular to save platinum. An overview of the many different efforts to use oxidic catalysts is given in Sadykov et al., Appl. Catal. General A: 204 (2000), p. 59-87. Thus, especially in Eastern Europe, catalyst systems based on doped iron oxides have been used, often also in combination with platinum metal screens, while in the western hemisphere, cobalt-oxide-based systems have predominantly been employed.
However, none of these attempts at establishing platinum-metal-free NH3 oxidation catalysts has hitherto been able to gain acceptance in industry because such catalysts exhibit lower selectivities of the NO formation as compared with highly selective platinum metal catalysts, and in modern systems for HNO3 production, the product price is determined to the extent of more than 70% by the NH3 price.
In many cases, the potentially active, noble-metal-free transition metal oxide catalysts also experience a considerable deactivation over time under conditions of practice, which is caused not only by sintering effects due to the high thermal stress but often also by a (partial) reduction of the oxides with NH3 to correspondingly lower-valent oxides, which generally exhibit a lower activity and selectivity for NO formation. Mention may be made, for example, of the reduction of MnO2 and Mn2O3 to Mn3O4, the reduction of CuO2 to CuO, the reduction of α-Fe2O3 to Fe3O4 and FeO or, particularly prominently, the reduction of highly active Co3O4 to less active CoO.
In order to counteract such a deactivation, in the case of a commercial use of Co3O4 catalysts for NH3 oxidation in a fixed bed reactor of Incitec Ltd. in Australia, the catalyst bed was periodically rearranged in order to reoxidize with residual oxygen in the rear portion of the catalyst bed the catalyst reduced at a high NH3 concentration in the front portion of the catalyst bed. The same idea is also pursued by corresponding works of Schmidt-Szalowski et al. (see Appl. Catal. A: General 177 (1998), p. 147-157), which publicize the oxidation of NH3 via Co3O4 catalysts in a fluidized bed. The swirling of the catalyst particles is here said to effect in the lower portion of the fluidized bed a continuous reoxidation with oxygen of the CoO that is formed.
A further possibility, which has been investigated many times, for suppressing the deactivating reduction of the oxides is the doping, that is to say stabilization, of the above-mentioned binary oxides with other metal oxides which are difficult to reduce, which is, however, often accompanied by a reduction in the specific activity, as described by Sadykov et al. in Appl. Catal. General A: 204 (2000) p. 59-87. Mention may be made by way of example of the doping of α-Fe2O3 with Al2O3, which formed the basis for the two-stage catalyst systems developed in the 1970s in the USSR for NH3 oxidation in combination with a reduced amount of conventional Pt/Rh screen catalysts. The transition metal oxides can also be converted by doping with other metal oxides into ternary mixed oxides having different crystal structures, in which the higher oxidation states of the transition metals have a reducibility which is in principle low. Mention may be made especially of perovskitic structures, which are distinguished by a high activity for the formation of NO and a high chemical stability.
For example, U.S. Pat. No. 4,812,300 A claims mixed oxide catalysts of the perovskite type having the general formula ABO3±δ for ammonia oxidation, wherein A represents alkali metals, alkaline earth metals, lanthanides or actinides, and B represents one or more elements of groups IB, IVB to VIIB and VIII. The catalysts are said to exhibit an equilibrium oxygen partial pressure of greater than 10−15 bar at 1000° C., so that a good transfer of the lattice oxygen to the NH3 molecule is possible without the structural integrity of the perovskite being impaired. Testing of the catalysts was here carried out in an apparatus or under conditions of temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) at ambient pressure and an NH3 concentration of 3.3% by volume and an oxygen content of 6.7% by volume in helium. Particularly preferred perovskite catalysts comprise lanthanum and/or strontium as the A-position element and cobalt, nickel and/or manganese as the B-position element.
WO-99/25650 A1 describes a device for NH3 oxidation in which there are preferably used mixed oxide catalysts formed of rare earth metals and cobalt. The oxidation of 10% by volume NH3 in air at atmospheric pressure with a lanthanum/cerium/cobalt mixed oxide (atomic ratio La:Ce:Co=8:2:10) is described by way of example.
U.S. Pat. No. 3,888,792 A describes the use of Co3O4 doped with rare earth metals for NH3 oxidation, which is said to have increased selectivity and long-term stability as compared with pure Co3O4. The testing of chosen samples was carried out at an NH3/air volume ratio of 1/10 under atmospheric pressure. In a long-term test over 900 hours with Ce-doped Co3O4, in which an intermediate pressure increase to 7 bar also took place, the yield of NOx was always more than 90%.
WO 2009/028949 A1 claims mixed oxide catalysts for the production of NO by reaction of a gas mixture consisting of NH3 and O2, which catalysts satisfy the general formula A3-xBxO9-y. A and B are selected from metals of the group Mn, Cr, Co, Fe and Al. The catalysts were tested at atmospheric pressure with a gas mixture having a composition of 10% by volume NH3 in air or 10% by volume NH3, 18% by volume O2 and 72% by volume argon. The maximum NOx selectivity achieved of 96% was attained with a mixed oxide having the composition Mn1.5Co1.5O4.
As a further example, mention may be made of U.S. Pat. No. 3,962,138 A. Catalysts for NH3 oxidation which consist of 60-95% Co3O4, 5-15% Al2O3 and 0-25% of an oxide of thorium, cerium, zinc or cadmium are claimed therein. The shaped catalysts were tested in a reactor having a diameter of 10 cm at a pressure of 4-5 bar with a gas mixture comprising 10% by volume NH3 in air. With the best catalysts, each of which contained approximately 10% ThO2, an NOx yield of approximately 93-95% was achieved after an operating time of 400 hours. The addition of Al2O3 and ThO2 brought about a significant improvement in the NOx yield and the lifetime of the catalysts.
DE 10 2012 000 419 A1 discloses a low-temperature oxidation of ammonia in the production of nitric acid by passing an ammonia- and oxygen-containing gas stream over a support layer, heated to less than 500° C., of particles of an LaSrCo oxide catalyst and then cooling the nitrogen-oxide-containing gas stream. This reaction is described by way of example by the reaction of a gas stream which contained 5% by volume carbon dioxide, 5% by volume water, 10% by volume oxygen, 200 ppm ammonia and nitrogen as the remainder.
In WO 2006/010904 A1 there are described oxidation methods which are carried out on selected perovskite catalysts. The catalysts comprise bismuth and/or lanthanides with the exception of lanthanum. The oxidation of ammonia in air is described as a model reaction.
DE 199 03 616 A1 describes a method for producing nitrogen oxides having a low degree of oxidation by catalytic oxidation of ammonia in a mixture with air and steam on an oxidation catalyst. Catalysts comprising noble metals or catalysts comprising metal oxides are mentioned.
WO 01/49603 A1 discloses a catalyst comprising cerium oxide and manganese oxide as well as magnesium, aluminum, zinc or calcium oxide, and an activator for the selective oxidation of ammonia with oxygen to dinitrogen oxide N2O. The reaction takes place at relatively low temperatures of 250° C. or below.
In DE 2 148 707 A there is described a catalyst for the oxidation of ammonia to nitrogen oxides. This catalyst consists mainly of cobalt oxide and is characterized by a specific surface area of from 0.1 to 7 m2/g and a volume/weight porosity of from 1 to 15%.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,849,257 describes a method for producing nitrogen oxides in which ammonia is reacted with oxygen in the presence of steam on a copper/manganese oxide catalyst. The catalyst is characterized by a specific X-ray spectrum.
EP 0 384 563 B1 describes a method for oxidizing ammonia in the presence of a cobalt oxide catalyst which has been doped with lithium.
US 2013/0039828 A1 discloses a catalyst structure which is suitable for an ammonia oxidation method and is distinguished by a flexible arrangement of catalyst units. Catalysts can comprise platinum metals or also other metals.
In a scientific publication [J. Catal. 276 (2010) 306-313], Biausque and Schuurmann describe the mechanism of the high-temperature oxidation of NH3 to NO over an LaCoO3 catalyst. To that end, various tests are carried out inter alia with variation of the O2 and NH3 content, wherein in one test series—starting from an NH3 concentration of 3% by volume—the oxygen content was varied between 10% by volume and 40% by volume and in a further test series—starting from an oxygen content of 20% by volume—the NH3 content was varied between 1% by volume and 5% by volume. With regard to the NOx yield achieved, a negative dependence on the O2 partial pressure and a positive dependence on the NH3 partial pressure was found. That is to say, as the O2 partial pressure increases and the NH3 partial pressure falls, an increased formation of N2 and N2O was observed, which is contrary to the known behavior of platinum catalysts for NH3 oxidation.
In Catal. Lett. (2011) 141: 1215-8, Tianfeng Hou et al. describe the catalytic oxidation of ammonia to nitrogen monoxide in the presence of perovskite catalysts of the LaMnO3 and LaVO4 type.
In many of the cases from the prior art cited above, the oxidation of NH3 in air, as is usual in the conventional Ostwald process, is studied or, in the practical examples, a corresponding O2/NH3 volume ratio of at least 1.9 is established. In almost all cases, the studies or published data are additionally limited to atmospheric conditions, which yield significantly higher selectivities of the NO formation than are to be expected for elevated pressures.
Nevertheless, the high benchmark of NOx yields set with Pt/Rh screen catalysts is not achieved. This is the case in particular also with high throughputs of NH3, that is to say at a high starting concentration of 10% by volume and elevated operating pressure, which are advantageous and conventional for commercial operation owing to the resulting smaller apparatus sizes and optimal adaptation to the subsequent NO/NO2 absorption. The yield of NOx is thus usually reduced at a high concentration or high (partial) pressure of ammonia. This is the case in particular for known oxide-based catalysts such as, for example, Co3O4 (see, for example, Andrew, S.P.S.; Chinchen, G. C., “The loss in selectivity of a cobalt oxide ammonia oxidation catalyst” in “Studies in surface science and catalysis”; 6 (1980), p. 141-148, (Catalyst deactivation: proceedings of an international symposium, Antwerp, Oct. 13-15, 1980)), which, compared with metal platinum-based catalysts, exhibit a significantly lower activity. A high partial pressure of ammonia promotes to an enhanced degree undesirable secondary and subsequent reactions, which lead to the formation of N2 or also N2O.
Despite various efforts, transition metal oxide catalysts for NH3 oxidation therefore play no role in large-scale applications, apart from the mentioned occasional combination of iron-oxide-based catalysts with noble metal screens.
Pt/Rh screen catalysts are still used almost without exception. As mentioned above, according to the operating pressure of the NH3 combustion (atmospheric/medium pressure/high pressure) and the prevailing pressure level of the NOx absorption in the absorption tower, it is possible to distinguish between different method or system variants (see also Winnacker-Küchler, Chemische Technik—Prozesse and Produkte, 5th Edition, Volume 3, Chapter 3, p. 248-275, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim, 2005; Thiemann, M., Scheibler, E., Wiegand, K. W. Nitric Acid, Nitrous Acid, and Nitrogen Oxides, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, 2000).
Of importance today are especially the so-called single or mono-pressure method, in which medium pressure or high pressure are used both for the NH3 combustion and for the NOx absorption, and the so-called dual pressure method with NH3 combustion under medium pressure and NOx absorption under high pressure. The previously conventional systems with combustion at atmospheric pressure and medium-pressure absorption have today largely been superseded by the single pressure and dual pressure methods, which are more economical in the case of larger capacities.
Systems for producing HNO3 thus typically comprise an NH3 evaporator for providing gaseous NH3, an air compressor for the combustion air, an NH3 oxidation reactor for receiving the Pt screen catalysts with an integrated process gas cooler, various heat exchangers or coolers and condensers for further cooling the process gas or for heating the residual gas leaving the absorption tower, an absorption tower for absorbing NOx and forming HNO3, a reactor for the (catalytic) removal of residual NOx and optionally N2O contained in the residual gas, and a residual gas turbine for energy recovery upon expansion of the residual gas into the atmosphere. In dual pressure systems, an additional compression stage for compressing the process gas to the desired absorption pressure is arranged between the NH3 oxidation reactor and the absorption tower.
Disclosed herein is a method, based on transition metal oxide catalysts, for oxidizing NH3 and a system suitable therefor which, as compared with the yields achieved hitherto with such catalysts, is distinguished by increased yields of NOx. The method is additionally to be distinguished by long catalyst lifetimes and low catalyst costs.
The object is achieved by the provision of a method for oxidizing ammonia with oxygen, wherein the ratio of O2 and NH3 in the reaction gas supplied to the catalyst is adjusted to a value significantly below the conventional ratio of 1.9 mol/mol, so that a high yield of NOx is achieved, and wherein catalysts that are different from the commercially available platinum metal screen catalysts hitherto used are employed.
Surprisingly, it has been found by us that, when non-platinum metal catalysts are used, that is to say selected transition metal oxide catalysts such as, for example, LaCoO3 or LaMnO3, the yield of the useful product NOx can be increased significantly if the oxygen content, or the O2/NH3 ratio, in the reactant gas mixture is so adjusted that almost all the oxygen is converted by ammonia according to the primary oxidation reactions (reaction schemes 1, 5, 6 and 7) and no or only a small amount of residual oxygen remains in the resulting product gas. A high oxygen excess, as is otherwise conventional, has a negative effect here.
It has been found that, by reducing the oxygen content, or the molar ratio of oxygen to ammonia, before entry of the reactant gas mixture into the catalyst bed, the yield of NOx can be raised to values which can otherwise be achieved only with platinum metal catalysts (Pt/Rh screens), even at elevated partial pressure of NH3, that is to say elevated total pressure or with an elevated NH3 concentration.
Accordingly, the present invention relates to a method for oxidizing ammonia with oxygen in the presence of catalysts comprising at least one transition metal oxide that is not an oxide of a platinum metal, wherein the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen to ammonia at the inlet of the reactant gas mixture into the catalyst bed is adjusted to values of less than or equal to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3.
Typically, the molar ratio of oxygen to ammonia that is to be adjusted according to the invention is in the range of from 1.25 to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3. In particular, the molar ratio is from 1.30 to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3, particularly preferably a ratio of from 1.35 to 1.60 mol O2/mol NH3 is adjusted and most particularly preferably a ratio of from 1.35 to 1.50 mol O2/mol NH3 is adjusted.
When a preferred variant of the method according to the invention is carried out, the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen to ammonia in the reactant gas mixture at the inlet into the catalyst bed is so chosen that it is in the range of from 0.1 mol O2/mol NH3 below to 0.4 mol O2/mol NH3 above an optimal molar ratio, wherein the optimal molar ratio is the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen to ammonia at the inlet of the reactant gas mixture into the catalyst bed at which a maximum yield of NOx is achieved.
Particularly preferably, the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen to ammonia at the inlet into the catalyst bed is from 0.05 mol O2/mol NH3 below to 0.3 mol O2/mol NH3 above the optimal ratio, particularly advantageously from 0.025 mol O2/mol NH3 below to 0.25 mol O2/mol NH3 above the optimal ratio.
The optimal molar ratio of O2/NH3, or the optimal oxygen content, can be determined on the basis of a series of corresponding tests under the specifically desired method conditions, that is to say with a chosen catalyst in a defined system, at a defined space velocity and flow rate, at a defined outlet or inlet temperature, under a defined pressure and with a defined reaction medium comprising oxygen and a defined amount of ammonia. With a constant NH3 concentration, the concentration of oxygen at the inlet into the catalyst bed is thereby so chosen that the corresponding molar O2/NH3 ratio is between a minimum O2/NH3 ratio of, for example, 1.25 mol/mol and a maximum O2/NH3 ratio of, for example, 1.75 mol/mol, the ratio is varied preferably by a chosen increment, for example an increment of less than or equal to 0.1 mol O2/mol NH3, and the yield of NOx achieved in each case is determined. The molar ratio of oxygen to ammonia which produces the maximum yield of NOx under the otherwise constant reaction conditions is the optimal ratio of oxygen to ammonia.
In another preferred variant of the method according to the invention, the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen to ammonia at the inlet of the reactant gas mixture into the catalyst bed is adjusted to values of less than or equal to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3, preferably to values of less than or equal to 1.60 mol O2/mol NH3 and particularly preferably to values of less than or equal to 1.50 mol O2/mol NH3, the oxygen content in the product gas at the outlet of the catalyst bed being at least 0.3% by volume, preferably at least 0.4% by volume and particularly preferably at least 0.5% by volume.
In a preferred embodiment of this preferred variant of the method according to the invention, a molar ratio of O2/NH3 that is suitable according to the invention of less than or equal to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3, or an oxygen content in the reactant gas mixture at the inlet of the catalyst bed that is suitable according to the invention, is specified by the oxygen content of the product gas at the outlet of the catalyst bed, in that a molar ratio of O2/NH3 that is suitable according to the invention or—at a given NH3 inlet concentration—an oxygen content at the inlet of the catalyst bed that is suitable according to the invention is so chosen that the resulting oxygen content in the product gas at the outlet of the catalyst bed is from 0.3% by volume to 10.0% by volume, preferably from 0.4% by volume to 6.0% by volume and particularly preferably from 0.5 to 4.0% by volume, most particularly from 0.3% by volume to 2.0% by volume, in particular from 0.4% by volume to 2.0% by volume, most preferably from 0.5% by volume to 1.5% by volume.
The O2/NH3 ratio that is suitable according to the invention can in practice be adjusted for specific method conditions, that is to say with a chosen catalyst in a defined system, with a defined space velocity and flow rate, at a defined outlet or inlet temperature, under a defined pressure and with a defined reaction medium comprising oxygen and ammonia, in such a manner, for example, that, under those method conditions, starting from a predetermined O2/NH3 ratio, for example starting from a conventional O2/NH3 ratio of 1.9 mol/mol or in particular starting from an O2/NH3 ratio of 1.75 mol/mol, with a fixed amount of ammonia, the oxygen content at the inlet of the catalyst bed is reduced until the above-mentioned low oxygen contents are present or detected in the product gas at the outlet of the catalyst bed.
The NOx and O2 content at the outlet of the catalyst bed can be determined by methods known to the person skilled in the art. For example, the NOx content can be determined by means of IR/UV analyzers using heated gas measuring cells. Suitable analyzers are, for example, multicomponent FT-IR or one-component systems having a plurality of IR or UV channels. Alternatively, the NOx content can also be measured by means of a chemiluminescence analyzer having an upstream converter for reducing NO2 to NO. The oxygen content can advantageously be measured inter alia by means of a heated analyzer for measuring paramagnetism or by means of a zirconia sensor.
The oxygen content of the product gas at the outlet of the catalyst bed can also be determined arithmetically as the difference between the oxygen content in the reactant gas mixture at the inlet of the catalyst bed and the oxygen consumption in the catalyst bed. The oxygen consumption in the catalyst bed is obtained starting from the outlet concentrations of the components N2, NO, NO2 and N2O or the product selectivities derived therefrom from the NH3 inlet concentration and the corresponding stoichiometric ratios of O2/NH3 according to equations (1), (5), (6) and (7).
The method according to the invention is preferably operated at pressures of from 1 bar abs. to 10 bar abs., particularly preferably at pressures of from 1.5 bar abs. to 6 bar abs., most particularly preferably at pressures of from 2 bar abs. to 5 bar abs.
The NH3 concentration at the inlet into the oxidation reactor in the method according to the invention is preferably from 1 to 17% by volume, particularly preferably from 4 to 15% by volume, in particular from 7 to 14% by volume. The upper limit of the NH3 content is advantageously determined by the lower explosion limit of the NH3/oxygen mixtures, which is also dependent on other possible gas components, such as, for example, steam.
For each volume percent ammonia in the gas mixture that is converted chemically on the catalysts, a specific amount of heat is liberated which, in the case of a reactant mixture of NH3 in air, corresponds to a temperature increase between the reactant mixture and the product mixture of approximately 68 K under adiabatic conditions. In the case where the temperature of the inlet mixture comprising ammonia and oxygen is specified by the system, the temperature in the process gas stream at the outlet of the oxidation catalyst is therefore specified by the ammonia concentration of the gas mixture at the inlet of the oxidation catalyst.
The catalyst used according to the invention develops its greatest capacity preferably in a lower temperature range than the platinum-based metal catalysts. The temperature at the outlet from the catalyst bed, for example from the arrangement of the shaped catalyst bodies, is to be adjusted according to the invention preferably to from 700° C. to 950° C., particularly preferably from 750° C. to 850° C. (measured at the outlet of the gas mixture from the catalyst bed or, in the case of a plurality of catalyst beds, at the outlet of the last catalyst bed). This can be achieved by adjusting the inlet temperature of the reactant gas mixture and/or the ammonia concentration in the reactant gas mixture.
The greater spatial extent of the arrangement of the shaped catalyst bodies used according to the invention, as compared with platinum-based metal catalyst screens, further permits polytropic operation by the partial dissipation or discharge of the heat of reaction. This can be achieved, for example, by cooling the reactor walls or by accommodating integrated cooling devices in the catalyst arrangement.
As already mentioned, the high activity of the shaped catalyst bodies permits a low reaction temperature or low “blow-out” temperature and thus a low inlet temperature of the reactant gas mixture comprising NH3 and oxygen into the (first) catalyst bed, for example into an arrangement of shaped catalyst bodies. This inlet temperature can be from 20° C. to 300° C., preferably from 50° C. to 200° C., particularly preferably from 50° C. to 150° C.
Catalysts
There are suitable for the method according to the invention in principle any catalysts which contain as active component at least one transition metal oxide that is not an oxide of a platinum metal.
Within the context of this description, a platinum metal is an element of the 5th and 6th periods of groups 8 to 10 of the periodic system of the elements, that is to say an element of the group Ru, Rh, Pd, Os, Ir and Pt.
Under the operating conditions of the method according to the invention, that is to say at an NH3/O2 ratio, adjusted according to the invention, in the range of from 0.1 mol O2/mol NH3 below to 0.4 mol O2/mol NH3 above the optimal molar ratio, the catalysts used according to the invention surprisingly exhibit increased yields of NOx, as compared with the yields of NOx under the operating conditions of the conventional methods of ammonia oxidation, in which the ratio of the molar amounts of oxygen and ammonia at the inlet of the reactant gas mixture into the catalyst is at least 1.9 mol O2/mol NH3.
Accordingly, under the operating conditions of the method according to the invention, the catalysts used according to the invention permit NOx yields which are comparable with or even better than the NOx yields in the Ostwald process using commercially available platinum metal screen catalysts.
Particularly suitable are catalysts which comprise transition metal oxides that are not oxides of platinum metals and do not experience any irreversible reduction to less active lower-valent oxides under the above-mentioned conditions.
There can accordingly be used in particular catalysts which comprise stabilized, that is to say doped, transition metal oxides that are not oxides of the platinum metals, or which comprise mixed oxides of such transition metal oxides. Examples of doped transition metal oxides are iron oxides doped with, for example, bismuth oxide, chromium oxide or manganese oxide.
The mixed oxides which can be used particularly preferably have a spinel, delafossite or, particularly preferably, a perovskite or brownmillerite structure.
Perovskites used according to the invention preferably have the structure ABO3-δ, wherein A represents mono-, di- or tri-valent cations and B represents tri-, tetra- or penta-valent cations, the ionic radius of A is greater than the ionic radius of B, and δ is a number from 0.001 to 1.5, preferably from 0.01 to 0.09 and particularly preferably from 0.01 to 0.5. Mixtures of different cations A and/or cations B can also be present in the perovskites used according to the invention.
Brownmillerites used according to the invention typically have the structure A2B2O5-δ, wherein A, B and δ have the meanings defined above. Mixtures of different cations A and/or cations B can also be present in the brownmillerites used according to the invention.
Cations B can occur within a compound preferably in a plurality of oxidation states. Some or all of the cations of type B can, however, also be tri- or higher-valent cations with a constant oxidation state.
The use of perovskites of the general empirical formula ABO3±δ and/or of brownmillerites of the general empirical formula A2B2O5±δ whose A position is occupied to the extent of more than 50%, preferably more than 80%, particularly preferably more than 95%, by one or more elements selected from the group of the rare earth metals and alkaline earth metals and whose B position is occupied to the extent of more than 50%, preferably more than 80%, particularly preferably more than 95%, by one or more elements selected from the group Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni is particularly advantageous. Of those elements, Co is particularly preferred. A particularly suitable perovskitic compound is LaCoO3±δ wherein δ is from 0.01 to 0.5.
Further suitable doping agents are in particular transition metals whose oxides are preferably in the tetravalent state, such as, for example, Ce or Mn.
There can of course be added to the catalysts used according to the invention small amounts of platinum metals or of oxides of platinum metals, for example up to 10% by weight, in particular up to 5% by weight, based on the active component(s) of catalyst. The presence of other metal (oxides) which are conventionally used as additional dopants is also possible. Examples of such dopants are alkali and/or alkaline earth metals. These dopants—where present—are also present in only small amounts, for example in amounts of up to 10% by weight, in particular up to 5% by weight, based on the active component(s) of catalyst.
The preparation of the catalytically active components, or transition metal oxides, used in the method according to the invention, and the shaping thereof, will be discussed only by way of example at this point, because various preparation methods suitable for this purpose are known to the person skilled in the art from practice. Technologies corresponding to the prior art which can be used for the preparation of the catalytically active components will be described hereinbelow.
The catalytically active components used in the method according to the invention can be prepared by means of a solid state reaction. To that end, mixtures of oxides, binary oxides, or oxide formers, for example carbonates, are conventionally used as starting materials. The starting materials are intimately mixed in a composition adapted to the target phase and are then calcined. The catalytically active phases form under calcination conditions in the form of crystallites.
In order to increase the homogeneity of the starting mixture, intensive grinding of the starting materials, optionally with the addition of auxiliary substances, such as, for example, water, is frequently carried out. In order to increase the conversion of desired crystal phase, a plurality of grinding and calcining steps can be carried out alternately. When a sufficient degree of crystallinity of target phase has been determined, a particle size that is suitable for further shaping treatment steps for producing the shaped catalyst bodies, such as extrusion or pressing, is carried out, for example by dry grinding.
A further suitable preparation method is the precipitation technique, in which the starting materials are obtained from solutions by precipitation. As precursors for metal oxides there can be used for this purpose, for example, metal hydroxides or complexed metal cations, for example in the form of citrates or oxalates, which can be precipitated from metal salt solutions, which can contain the primary component alone or the primary and secondary component, by means of precipitation reagents. Suitable precipitation reagents are, for example, alkalis, such as ammonia, or ammonium carbonate.
The hydrolysis of alkoxides can also be used to prepare precursors of the metal oxides. A particular technique which can be employed is so-called sol-gel synthesis, wherein stable colloidal systems are used as starting material instead of solutions. In the case of alkoxides there can be used as hydrolysis agents, for example, water or various alcohols. The stoichiometry of the metal oxide phases that are to be prepared is given by suitably choosing the relative proportions of the starting compounds, for example metal salts or alkoxides.
The metal oxide precursors so prepared are treated by filtration, washing and drying. In the calcination step which follows, the metal oxide phases are formed, which can be homogenized further by alternate grinding and calcination steps. There follow further steps of powder treatment, in particular grinding and fractionation, in order to make the resulting powders amenable to shaping by, for example, extrusion or pressing.
The catalytically active components can also be prepared by pyrolysis reactions. To that end, metal-containing starting materials, for example metal salts, organometallic compounds or products obtained by means of precipitation technology, are reacted in a highly exothermic reaction at high temperatures, for example up to 1000° C. In this type of preparation, oxidizing agents, for example ammonium nitrate, and organic fuels such as urea, citric acid or glycine, can be added to the starting materials. The pyrolysis reaction can be initiated starting from solutions, suspensions or solids. In this method, the stoichiometry of the target phase can be adjusted by suitably providing the starting materials. The resulting powders are of high phase purity with a high to very high specific surface area.
For the shaping of the transition metal oxide powders that are prepared, these and other active components or co-components can be incorporated or embedded into any desired, preferably ceramics, matrix or applied to any desired, preferably ceramics, support.
Preference is given to ceramics material based on oxides, carbides or nitrides of elements selected from the group Si, Al, Mg, Zr and B; particular preference is given to ceramics materials such as cordierite, mullite, magnesium oxide or, most particularly, silicon carbide, which is distinguished by high chemical and mechanical resistance and excellent thermal conductivity.
The use of solid catalysts, that is to say shaped bodies which consist substantially of catalytically active material, is also particularly suitable and preferred within the meaning of the invention. The shaped catalyst bodies are thus to consist of more than 70%, preferably more than 80%, particularly preferably more than 85%, based on the total weight of the shaped body, catalytically active material.
The shaped catalyst bodies can be in the form of shaped bodies of any size and geometry, preferably in geometries which have a large surface area to volume ratio and in which a minimal pressure loss is generated when a medium flows through them. Preference is given to shaped bodies in which the surface area to volume ratio is from 0.5 to 10 mm−1, in particular from 1 to 5 mm−1. Typical geometries are all geometries known in catalysis, such as, for example, cylinders, hollow cylinders, multihole cylinders, rings, broken granules, trilobes or honeycomb structures. Particular preference is given to honeycomb monoliths or so-called miniliths, that is to say very small honeycomb shaped bodies which are generally used as bulk material. The shaped bodies can be produced by shaping methods known in ceramics processing, such as, for example, dry pressing, granulation or extrusion.
The arrangement of the shaped catalyst bodies can be, for example, in the form of a random filling or in the form of an ordered packing.
Reactor
The ammonia oxidation reactor used according to the invention can be configured like a conventional ammonia oxidation reactor or “burner”. This is particularly advantageous in the case of the retrofitting of existing systems because no or only negligible apparatus-related changes are necessary. The Pt/Rh screens are often located on a loose filling of ceramics rings. In the method according to the invention, the shaped catalyst body can then be fitted into the reactor in place of the Pt/Rh screens and ceramics rings, as already mentioned above, as a filling or as an ordered packing, for example of honeycomb bodies. Special precautions must generally be taken at the edge of the reactor to prevent a portion of the ammonia/oxygen-containing reactant gas mixture from flowing past the catalyst. Such precautions can be, for example, gas-tight, high-temperature-resistant metal strips which are connected to the wall of the reactor and on which the catalyst filling or the outer elements of the ordered catalyst packing rest in part.
In the case of new systems especially, it can be very advantageous to use alternative designs to the conventional design of ammonia oxidation reactors, which are characterized by a large diameter with a very small height of the catalyst packing in the flow direction. By reducing the flow cross-section, possible difficulties with the uniform distribution of the inflowing gas mixture can thus be reduced. A rapid flow through the catalyst bed with short dwell times is particularly preferred, because undesirable secondary reactions, such as the catalytic decomposition of the NO that forms, can thereby be suppressed and, in addition, a space-saving, compact design of the ammonia oxidation reactor is possible. For further possible configurations of the ammonia oxidation reactor, equipped with a catalyst according to the invention, reference is made to WO 2008/148487A1.
The method according to the invention is preferably operated at space velocities of from 50,000 h−1 to 500,000 h−1, particularly preferably from 100,000 h−1 to 300,000 h−1. Within the context of this description, the expression space velocity is understood as meaning the quotient of the volume fractions of gas mixture (measured at 273.15 K and 1.01325 bar) per hour, based on one volume fraction of catalyst, that is to say of the filling or packing volume. The space velocity can accordingly be adjusted via the volume flow of the gas and/or via the volume of the catalyst or the amount thereof.
Regardless of which design is preferred in a particular application, the ammonia oxidation reactor of the method according to the invention is preferably equipped with a device for igniting the reaction on the catalyst. For example, there can be used for this purpose a hydrogen flame from a movable lance directed at the gas inlet side of the shaped catalyst body.
Procedure
The molar ratio of O2/NH3 according to the invention in the gas stream at the inlet into the oxidation catalyst can be achieved technically in various ways.
In the simplest way, gaseous NH3 can be added to an air stream in such an amount that the desired molar ratio of O2/NH3 results. An NH3 content of from 14.4% by volume to 10.7% by volume in this case corresponds to a ratio of from 1.25 to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3, an NH3 content of from 13.9% by volume to 10.7% by volume corresponds to a ratio of from 1.3 to 1.75 mol O2/mol NH3, and an NH3 content of from 13.5% by volume to 11.6% by volume corresponds to a ratio of from 1.35 to 1.6 mol O2/mol NH3.
Another possible step for adjusting the molar ratio of O2/NH3 according to the invention consists, for example, in supplying to the NH3 combustion, together with the air or in place thereof, a gas stream which comprises less than 20% by volume, preferably less than 10% by volume, particularly preferably less than 5% by volume, oxygen.
When the method for oxidizing NH3 according to the invention is integrated into a process for producing nitric acid or caprolactam, it is possible to supply to the NH3 combustion, together with the air or in place thereof, preferably a certain proportion of the low-oxygen residual gas, for example removed downstream of a reactor for residual gas purification for N2O and NOx reduction. This is shown by way of example in
The recycled, purified residual gas is to have an oxygen content of <5% by volume, in particular <3% by volume, most particularly <2% by volume. The residual content of NOx is to be <20 ppmv, preferably <10 ppmv, particularly preferably <5 ppmv.
It is also possible for the air stream supplied to the NH3 combustion to be divided into an O2-reduced and an O2-enriched partial stream, for example by a pressure swing adsorption, by a cryogenic decomposition or also by means of membranes, for example by means of a ceramics membrane that conducts oxygen anions. Such a form is shown by way of example in
The O2/NH3 ratio according to the invention can further be adjusted before the NH3 is fed in and before contact with the NH3 oxidation catalyst, by diluting the O2-containing gas stream with steam. The steam can then be condensed out again after the NH3 combustion upon cooling of the process gas stream before entry into the absorption tower, with the formation of weak acid.
The addition of other inert gas components to dilute the O2-containing gas stream is also conceivable.
The above-mentioned possibilities for adjusting the molar ratio of O2/NH3 according to the invention do not constitute a conclusive list and can additionally also be used in any desired combination.
Systems
The invention relates also to a system for oxidizing ammonia, comprising:
The system according to the invention can be operated under elevated pressure. In this variant, the system comprises at least one compressor (1) by means of which an oxygen-containing gas stream, for example air, is compressed and supplied to a reactor (3) for ammonia oxidation. The ammonia can be supplied to the reactor (3) by introducing the ammonia into the compressed oxygen-containing gas stream.
Expanding the process gases from the reactor (3) or from system parts downstream of the reactor (3) to ambient pressure takes place downstream after leaving the reactor (3) or system parts located downstream of the reactor (3) by suitable measures known to the person skilled in the art. If the system according to the invention is used, for example, for producing nitric acid, oxygen-containing secondary gas, for example secondary air, is added to the nitrogen oxide produced in the reactor (3) and it is oxidized to NO2 and introduced into an absorption tower (8), where the conversion of the NO2 to nitric acid with water takes place. The nitrogen-oxide-containing residual gas from the absorption tower (8) leaves the absorption tower, is supplied to a residual gas purification (9), leaves the residual gas purification as purified residual gas, is then supplied to a residual gas turbine (10), where it is expanded with the recovery of energy and discharged into the environment.
The system according to the invention preferably comprises at least a second compressor for compressing the oxygen-containing secondary gas stream before entry into an absorption tower (8) in which the nitrogen oxide that is produced is treated with water.
In a particular embodiment, the dilution of the air stream according to c1) is carried out with steam and/or nitrogen having an O2 content of <5% by volume.
In a further particular embodiment, the depletion of oxygen according to c2) from an oxygen-containing gas mixture, preferably from air, is carried out by pressure swing adsorption, cryogenic decomposition or by means of membranes.
The invention relates also to a system for oxidizing ammonia and subsequently absorbing NOx, comprising:
In a particular embodiment, the dilution of the air stream according to c1) is carried out with steam or with a nitrogen stream comprising less than 20% by volume, preferably less than 10% by volume, particularly preferably less than 5% by volume, oxygen. Particularly preferably, the nitrogen stream having an O2 content of <5% by volume is removed from the residual gas line downstream of the absorption tower.
In a further particular embodiment, the depletion of oxygen according to c2) from an oxygen-containing gas mixture, preferably from air, is carried out by pressure swing adsorption, cryogenic decomposition or by means of membranes.
The production of the oxygen-containing gas stream which is combined according to E) with the NOx-containing process gas stream is preferably carried out by oxygen enrichment of air by pressure swing adsorption, cryogenic decomposition or by means of membranes.
Further preferably, an addition of a stream containing a peroxide is carried out at the head of the absorption tower (8). The stream can be a liquid stream which comprises a dissolved peroxide. Examples thereof are solutions comprising an inorganic peroxide compound, such as hydrogen peroxide or perborate, or solutions comprising an organic peroxy compound, such as an organic peroxide, an organic hydroperoxide or an organic percarboxylic acid or esters thereof.
The above-mentioned systems for the oxidation of ammonia are preferably integrated into a system for producing nitric acid or caprolactam.
The flow diagram of a typical dual pressure system for the production of HNO3 differs from the mono-medium pressure system shown in
Likewise not shown in
Air compressor (1), ammonia evaporator (2), reactor (3), heat exchangers (3b, 4), condenser (5), pump (6), absorption tower (8), residual gas purification (9) and residual gas turbine (10) as well as lines 100, 110, 120, 130, 140, 150, 160, 170, 180, 190, 200 and 230 correspond to the elements shown in
Furthermore, in contrast to
There is additionally provided in the system of
By means of these measures (supply of a diluting medium having an oxygen content of <20% by volume via line 220 or partial recycling of the purified residual gas via line 210), individually or in combination, the ratio of oxygen to ammonia that is desired according to the invention in the reactant gas mixture can be adjusted in a controlled manner. It is further possible, by means of the system shown in
There is additionally shown in
To that end, honeycomb catalysts having a length of 1 cm, a diameter of approximately 18 mm and a cell density of 200 cpsi or 400 cpsi were inserted into a tubular reactor of quartz glass having an inside diameter of 20 mm, and a synthetic gas mixture of ammonia, oxygen and nitrogen was passed through. Analysis of the gas streams was carried out by means of thermal mass flow devices (MFC), whereby, with set ammonia concentrations of 5% by volume (
In order to compensate for heat losses, the reaction tube was surrounded by a metal jacket and placed in two tubular furnaces arranged one above the other. The resulting reaction temperature was measured by means of a thermoelement approximately 1 mm below the honeycomb (Tout). This outlet temperature was approximately 750° C. in the case of the ammonia inlet concentration of 5% by volume (
The indicated volume concentrations correspond at a first approximation to the molar concentrations of the individual components. For each adjustment of a new oxygen inlet concentration, the attainment of a steady-state operating point was awaited on the basis of the analytical result of the gas at the reactor outlet. In
There can clearly be seen in each case a pronounced maximum in the NOx yield corresponding to the density of the measuring points in
There can further clearly be seen that, at a ratio of the molar O2 and NH3 inlet concentrations of 1.9 mol/mol, which is not in accordance with the invention and is typically used in conventional industrial processes for ammonia oxidation (10% by volume NH3 in air), a significantly lower NOx yield is achieved than in the range chosen according to the invention around the optimal molar ratio of oxygen to ammonia.
If the ratio is below the above-mentioned range, the NOx yield is reduced significantly, as can be seen in
The honeycomb bodies were produced by extrusion of correspondingly treated LaMnO3 or LaCoO3 powders, with addition of corresponding binders and plasticizing aids and subsequent drying and calcination. The starting powders for the tested catalysts were produced by alkaline precipitation from stoichiometrically prepared solutions of the corresponding metal salts, filtration, washing and finally calcination of the precipitates thereby obtained. The phase formation and purity of the respective perovskite phases was checked by XRD (X-ray diffractometry).
This application is a divisional application of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/776,422, filed Sep. 14, 2015, which is pending and is the national stage entry of International Patent Application No. PCT/EP2014/000669, filed Mar. 13, 2014, which designed the United States, and which claims priority to German Patent Application DE 102013004341.7, filed Mar. 14, 2013. Each of these documents is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3888792 | Hughes | Jun 1975 | A |
| 3962138 | Ray | Jun 1976 | A |
| 4124687 | Whelan | Nov 1978 | A |
| 4183906 | Blakey | Jan 1980 | A |
| 4692321 | James | Sep 1987 | A |
| 4812300 | Quinlan | Mar 1989 | A |
| 5131220 | Linnhoff | Jul 1992 | A |
| 5736116 | LeBlanc | Apr 1998 | A |
| 5849257 | Fujiwara | Dec 1998 | A |
| 6165435 | Echegaray | Dec 2000 | A |
| 20090108239 | Caro | Apr 2009 | A1 |
| 20100181530 | Kneuper | Jul 2010 | A1 |
| 20110002836 | Dubois | Jan 2011 | A1 |
| 20120034148 | Schwefer | Feb 2012 | A1 |
| 20120183467 | Qi | Jul 2012 | A1 |
| 20130039828 | Coupland | Feb 2013 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 101678297 | Mar 2010 | CN |
| 1040002 | Oct 1958 | DE |
| 20148707 | Jun 1972 | DE |
| 19903616 | Aug 2000 | DE |
| 102005023605 | Nov 2006 | DE |
| 102012000419 | Jul 2012 | DE |
| 384563 | Aug 1990 | EP |
| 799792 | Oct 1997 | EP |
| 0834466 | Apr 1998 | EP |
| 1342577 | Jan 1974 | GB |
| 2000004203 | Jul 2000 | KR |
| 2296706 | Apr 2007 | RU |
| 9828073 | Jul 1998 | WO |
| 9925650 | May 1999 | WO |
| 9925652 | May 1999 | WO |
| 0149603 | Jul 2001 | WO |
| 02090256 | Nov 2002 | WO |
| 2006010904 | Feb 2006 | WO |
| 2009028949 | Mar 2009 | WO |
| 2014114764 | Jul 2014 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Perez-Ramirez et al., “Formation and control of N20 in nitric acid production—Where do we stand today”, Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, (2003), vol. 44, pp. 117-151. |
| “Nitric acid”, inorganic chemical industry, (1998), pp. 1-7, US Environmental Protection Agency. |
| Perez-Ramirez et al., “Mechanism of ammonia oxidation over oxides studied by temporal analysis of products”, Journal of Catalysis, (2007), vol. 250, pp. 240-246. |
| Sadykov et al., “Oxide catalyst for ammonia oxidation in nitric acid production: properties and perspectives”, Applied Catalysis A: General 204 (2000) 59-87. (Year: 2000). |
| Mischenko K.P., Ravdel A.A., Kratkii Spravochnik Fisico-himicheskih Velichin, Leningrag, Himiya, 1972, pp. 149-150, Table 78, and Machine Translation of Search Report citing same. |
| Schmidt-Szalowski, Krawcyzk et al., The Properties of Cobalt Oxide Catalyst for Ammonia Oxidation, Applied Catalysis A: General 175, (1998), pp. 147-157. |
| Gregory Biausque et al., The Reaction Mechanism of the High Temperature Ammonia Oxidation to Nitric Oxide Over LC0O3, Journal of Catalysis 276 (2010), pp. 306-313. |
| Andrew, S.P.S. et al, The Loss in Selectivity of a Cobalt Oxide Ammonia Oxidation Catalyst, in Studies in Surface Science and Catalysts; 6 (1980), 141 (Catalyst deactivation: Proceedings of an International Symposium, Antwerp, Oct. 13-15, 1980), pp. 141-148. |
| Hatcher, et al., Ammonia Oxidation Catalyst Handbook, 12.2, pp. 2575-2592. |
| Hou et al, Catalytic Oxidation of Ammonia to NO Over Perovskite-Type LaMnO3 and LaVO4 Catalysts, Catal. Lett. 2011) 141, pp. 1215-1218. |
| Machine Translation of Bohland, et al., Inorganic Nitrogen Compounds, 1173, Winnacker Küchler, Chemische Technik—Prozesse und Produkte, 2005. |
| PCT Application No. PCT/EP2014/000669 International Search Report and Written Opinion dated May 19, 2014, 12 pages. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20190359486 A1 | Nov 2019 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 14776422 | US | |
| Child | 16534044 | US |
