Patent Application
20240385337
The invention relates to improvements in the detection of radioactive isotopes via liquid scintillation counting by removing background contributors intrinsic in the scintillation media. In liquid scintillation, a sample is incorporated into a liquid scintillation cocktail and the cocktail is placed in a liquid scintillation counter that is shielded from the environment. A schematic illustration of a liquid scintillation cocktail is shown in
The sample to be tested can be in an aqueous or organic phase. In many cases, a surfactant is used to increase acceptance of an aqueous phase in an organic solvent. The liquid scintillation cocktail typically includes a solvent, a surfactant, and a scintillator that emits a photon(s) when struck by a beta particle.
Both commercial-off-the-shelf detectors and custom-built ultralow background counters can be limited in detection sensitivity by the radiopurity of the liquid scintillation cocktails themselves, most specifically from 40K, a long-lived naturally occurringradioisotope of potassium. Otherradioactive contaminants common in the environment include 232Th and 238U and their decay chain progeny.
The invention provides a method for purification and removal of potassium (40K) from liquid scintillation cocktails, nonpolar and surfactant solutions and mixtures, thereby reducing the abundance of 40K from the scintillating cocktail and improving sensitivity of analytical measurements.
In one aspect, the invention provides a method of making a liquid scintillation cocktail, comprising: treating one or more liquid components of a liquid scintillation cocktail with a solid material; wherein the liquid components comprise a solvent and a surfactant; wherein the solid material adsorbs potassium from the one or more liquid components; and separating the solid material from the one or more liquid components.
In another aspect, the invention provides a method of measuring alpha particle or beta particles emitted from a sample by liquid scintillation, comprising: providing a liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail; treating the liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail with a solid potassium absorber to form a treated liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail; adding a radioactive sample to the treated liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail and forming a liquid scintillation cocktail with incorporated sample; and counting particles emitted by the sample in the liquid scintillation cocktail with incorporated sample in a scintillation counter. Preferably, the liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail in the providing step comprises at least 2 mass % of a surfactant.
In a further aspect, the invention provides a method of measuring alpha particle or beta particles emitted from a plurality of samples by liquid scintillation, comprising: counting particles emitted by a first sample in a liquid scintillation cocktail with incorporated first sample in a scintillation counter; subsequent to the step of counting, treating the liquid scintillation cocktail with incorporated first sample with a solid potassium absorber to form a treated liquid scintillation cocktail; separating the solid potassium absorber from the treated liquid scintillation cocktail; combining a second sample to the treated liquid scintillation cocktail, and counting particles emitted by a second sample in the liquid scintillation cocktail with incorporated second sample in a scintillation counter.
In any of the inventive aspects, the invention may be further characterized by one or more of the following: wherein the liquid components further comprise a scintillator; wherein the cocktail further comprises a wavelength shifter; where the solid material comprises an ion exchange resin or zeolite; where the solid material comprises a sodium or alkaline earth silicate; where the step of removing potassium reduces the concentration of potassium by at least 10 times or in the range of 10 to 50 times or 10 to 40 times; wherein the liquid scintillation cocktail or component of a liquid scintillation cocktail in the providing step comprises a surfactant, or at least 2 mass % or at least 5 mass % of a surfactant.
The potassium removal method described herein is easy to implement and effective on cocktails and the individual reagents that make up the cocktails. Moreover, the method described herein can more effectively remove potassium than other methods to lower levels in a more streamlined fashion that involves very few production steps. Conversely, more conventional purification methods (e.g., distillation, liquid-liquid extraction, etc.) are much less straightforward and/or not possible, particularly on the finished cocktail products. Other methods usually include sourcing purer stock reagents to start from, which may be more expensive and vary from lot-to-lot. The method described herein may enable manufacturers to start with lower grade reagents and purify to sufficient levels later, and/or remove other purification steps that are more time and energy intensive, which may result in cost and time benefits.
The invention is useful in the measurement of radioactivity by reducing pernicious background sources of radiation from naturally-occurring radioisotopes in the environment (e.g. 40K). Typically, samples are taken from the environment and mixed into a liquid scintillation cocktail. The material to be analyzed can be, for example, groundwater, river water, medical or other biological samples, runoff, soil, concrete, etc. The material can be processed into a solution and the resulting solution combined into a liquid scintillation cocktail. Alternatively, material can be mixed with a liquid scintillation cocktail, optionally subjected to a step of solids separation or other treatment, and the resulting liquid scintillation cocktail placed into a liquid scintillation counter to measure radioactivity in the sample.
Prior to combining the material to be analyzed into the liquid scintillation cocktail, the liquid scintillation cocktail is treated with a solid potassium adsorber in order to remove the pernicious 40K background. Typically, the treating step comprises stirring or mixing the cocktail with the solid potassium absorber; however, in alternative or additional embodiments, the solution or cocktail can be passed through a column of the solid potassium absorber. To speed the removal of potassium, it may be desirable to heat the cocktail-potassium adsorber mixture during the treatment step; for example to at 110° C. or in the range of 105 to 120° C., or below the flash point of the cocktail or any reagents in the cocktail. The solid with adsorbed potassium (and other metals) can be separated by filtration, decanting or centrifugation.
The treatment with a solid potassium adsorber may be conducted on a complete liquid scintillation cocktail or on any neat liquid components of the cocktail, like surfactants, which are typically the vector of contamination for the potassium. Since the treatment removes metals, the sample is not treated; an exception would be where a cocktail, after obtaining a reading, is treated and recycled. Thus, in some embodiments, the invention includes a method of measuring radioactivity of a plurality of samples where the liquid scintillation cocktail is treated with the potassium absorber in a recycling step.
A liquid scintillation cocktail comprises a solvent and a scintillator. In most cases, a surfactant is required to emulsify the aqueous sample (analyte). Other components may include any of the additional components found in liquid scintillation cocktails such as fluors and added wavelength shifters for optimizing response of the photomultipliers in the scintillation detector.
The solvent is typically an organic aromatic solvent and is preferably present in at least 40 mass % of the cocktail, in other embodiments present in the range of 40 to 99 mass %, or 50 to 90% or 50 to 80 mass %. Desirably, the solvent is liquid at laboratory conditions, not excessively volatile, and compatible with the scintillator. In some embodiments, the organic solvent comprises toluene, xylene, phenylcyclohexane, triethylbenzene, pseudocumene, alkylbenzenes, phenylxylxylethane, naphthelenes, decalin, or mixtures thereof. The organic solvent is typically non-polar or low polarity such that the solvent is non-miscible with water. The invention is not limited to particular classes of scintillators. Common scintillators include 2,5-diphenyloxazole (PPO), 2-phenyl-5-biphenyl-1,3,4-oxadiazole (PBP), and butyl-PBP.
The surfactant is preferably present in an amount of 1 mass % or more, more preferably 2 to 40 mass % of the cocktail; or 10 to 40 mass %, or 20 to 40 mass % of the cocktail. The surfactant can be any known surfactant. Typical surfactants may include Triton N35 ((C2H40)nC14H220·xH3O4P)), dodecylbenzosulfonate, and benzethonium chloride. In one preferred embodiment, the surfactants used include a combination of nonylphenol ethoxylates.
The solid potassium adsorber can be any solid material suitable for removing potassium from solution. Suitable materials include: polymeric amines, aluminosilicates especially zeolites, zirconium phosphate, polyacrylic acid, polystyrenesulphonate, poly (sodium styrene sulfonate), poly (2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid), chelating resins, iron oxide hydroxide, In some preferred embodiments, the solid potassium absorber comprises an ion exchange resin or zeolite. In especially preferred embodiments, the solid material comprises a sodium or alkaline earth silicate. An especially preferred adsorber comprises magnesium silicate such as sold under the tradename Magnesol®. Preferably, the solid adsorber has a BET surface area of at least 50 m2/g, or at least 100 m2/g, or in the range of 50 to 500 m2/g.
The method preferably uses high surface area, inorganic particulates (e.g., magnesium silicate) for the chemical adsorption and extraction of metal ions (such as potassium) from neat nonpolar and surfactant liquids and mixtures. The purification method provides a solution for creating more radiopure nonpolar liquids, detergents, and/or cocktails that is easily employable by removing the problematic radioisotopes (e.g., 40K) in those liquid solutions. The method creates an increased radiopure cocktail that allows for better signal-to-noise.
The purification method has been demonstrated to be effective in removal of the background-causing potassium contamination from the cocktail without detriment to the cocktail performance (e.g., light output). The purification method was demonstrated on finished cocktails (typically composed of a mixture of 10+ reagents). Tests were also conducted on neat reagents, specifically the surfactants that are the vector for potassium (K) contamination which typically make up 10-40% of the cocktail by mass. The method worked for the surfactants, as shown in the table below:
We tested four commercial scintillation cocktails in a scintillation counter and found that all exhibited higher decays from 40K than would be expected. Further study showed that the surfactant component contained about five times higher potassium concentrations than the finished cocktails. For example, we calculated 12,000 40K decays/day/spl in the surfactant as compared with 2400 40K decays/day/spl in the finished cocktail (which typically contains 20-40 mass % surfactant) based on the amount of potassium measured by ICP-mass spectrometry.
To remove potassium from commercial scintillation cocktails we used a high surface area insoluble inorganic compound, called the “adsorber”, (e.g., magnesium silicate) for the chemisorption of trace levels of ionic species (e.g., potassium and hydroxide ions) in surfactant and organic (nonpolar) liquids and/or mixtures. In clean containers, we added the adsorber at a relative weight ratio of 3% to that of the liquid phase followed by vigorously shaking the liquid-adsorber mixture and placing in a 110° C. oven for 30-60 minutes. If needed, incubation temperatures can be lowered. The mixture is removed from the oven and allow to cool. The adsorber was separated from the liquid phase using centrifugation or clean filtration. The treated liquids were stored in clean containers.
In one example, a commercial scintillation cocktail was determined to have 5.30 ppm K, 40K=160 mBq/kg, 138 decays/day/spl via inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Treatment of the commercial scintillation cocktail according to a method of the invention resulted in 0.14 ppm K, 40K=4.3 mBq/kg, 3.7 decays/day/spl. This is roughly a 38× reduction in potassium. Other commercial cocktails showed similar reductions with factors of 7-38×.
This application claims the priority benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 63/249,900 filed 29 Sep. 2022.
This invention was made with Government support under Contract DE-AC0576RL01830 awarded by the U.S. Department of Energy. The Government has certain rights in the invention.
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/US22/45290 | 9/29/2022 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 63249900 | Sep 2021 | US |
