The present invention relates to a method for purifying, cooling and separating a gas mixture and to an apparatus for purifying and cooling a gas mixture. When a gas mixture must be cooled to a temperature below the liquefaction temperature, or even the solidification temperature of one of the gaseous components that it contains, this poses particular problems. If the heat exchanger used for cooling the gas mixture is, for example, a plate-fin exchanger comprising passages in which the gas mixture is cooled, these passages risk being obstructed by the formation of solids on the walls of the passages.
This problem is particularly well known to air separation specialists since conventionally the air to be distilled was cooled in heat exchangers and the water and carbon dioxide contained in the air were deposited on the walls of the passages of a first exchanger. Before the blocking of these passages, the air was sent to another heat exchanger in order to be cooled while the first heat exchanger was reheated by passing nitrogen therethrough in order to melt then vaporize the water and remove the carbon dioxide.
These systems were abandoned several decades ago in order to be replaced by a purification upstream of the heat exchanger. In this strategy that has become common, the air is dried and decarbonated by an adsorption process in front-end purification and then cooled.
One object of the present invention is to propose an alternative to the conventional strategies for the purification and cooling, or even liquefaction, of a gas mixture.
One object of the present invention is to propose an alternative to the conventional purification strategies for air separation units and for other separation and/or liquefaction units, operating at low temperature. Among these liquefaction units, mention may be made of air liquefaction units (for example for storing energy, units for liquefaction of a gas produced by separating air, for example nitrogen and units for liquefaction of natural gas. Other examples of separation units comprise for example the units for separating a mixture of carbon dioxide containing at least 30% carbon dioxide and also hydrogen and/or methane and/or oxygen and/or carbon monoxide at subambient temperature. The separation units may also be units for the cryogenic separation of mixtures of hydrogen and/or carbon monoxide and/or nitrogen and/or methane, the mixture containing at least 10 mol % of at least one of these components.
The study of new surface treatment technologies makes it possible to envisage drying and/or decarbonating the air directly in the main exchanger in such a way that the water condensed then frozen and/or the frozen CO2 have a reduced adhesion or even so that they no longer adhere to the walls of this exchanger and therefore so that the clogging increases until the passages on the air side of the exchanger are blocked.
It is known to treat surfaces or cover them with a coating in fields very different from the low-temperature separation of a gas mixture, in particular to reduce, or even prevent, the adhesion of ice or frost on metal surfaces exposed to atmospheric elements, such as aircraft, wind turbines and pylons. These surfaces may also, in certain cases, reduce the amount of ice formed.
A large number of surface treatments make it possible to reduce the adhesion of ice. These are treatments referred to as “passive anti-ice treatments” which in general are based on silicone or fluorocarbon polymers (non-exhaustive list) as described in US-A-2013/0305748.
For example, polytetrafluoroethylene, PTFE, also known under the name Teflon®, allows a weak adhesion of ice owing to a low surface tension as described in M. G. Ferrick, N. D. Mulherin, B. A. Coutermarsh, G. D. Durell, L. A. Curtis, T. L. St. Clair, E. S. Weiser, R. J. Cano, T. M. Smith, C. G. Stevenson and E. C. Martinez, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 26 (2012) 473. The polysiloxane-based NUSIL® R2180 coating also makes it possible to significantly reduce the adhesion of ice.
Similar results have been obtained using another coating based on (DLC or examples of coatings that make it possible to limit the adhesion of ice to aluminum alloys are reported by Menini et al., Cold Regions Science and Technology, 65 (2011) 65.
In most cases, these treatments increase the hydrophobicity of the surfaces, which makes it possible to increase the contact angle of water on these surfaces and therefore to reduce the interactions between water and the surface. Thus, the surfaces that make it possible to reduce the adhesion of ice are in general hydrophobic or superhydrophobic as described in L. Foroughi Mobarakeh, R. Jafari and M. Farzaneh, Applied Surface Science, 284 (2013) 459.
It is also possible to reduce the adhesion of ice using heterogeneous surfaces comprising both hydrophobic and hydrophilic zones as described in WO-A-05075112. In this case, the treatment makes it possible to properly control the water crystallization zones, which facilitates the elimination of the ice with the aid of a flushing of gas or liquid.
Another type of surface makes it possible to reduce the adhesion of the ice, these are lubricated surfaces. The surface is impregnated with a lubricant which may be based on fluorocarbons such as Krytox® or on silicone oils as described in WO-A-2012/100100 and US-A-2006/0281861.
With such surfaces, the ice is in contact with the lubricant, i.e. a liquid phase, thus the adhesion forces are very weak. The lubricant also has another advantage, it makes it possible to improve the erosion resistance of the surfaces.
In the example cited so far, the surface coatings make it possible to reduce the adhesion of the ice. Another type of surface that may prove advantageous within the context of this invention are the coatings referred to as “active anti-ice coatings” that make it possible to slow down the formation of the ice.
It is known that it is possible to lower the ice formation temperature using salt or glycol-type compounds. It turns out that a similar phenomenon may take place when a polymer-type compound, in general a hygroscopic polymer, is grafted to a surface.
This type of coating may lower the ice formation temperature and reduce the amount of ice formed. The best known coatings in this regard are of glycol type (US-A-2010/0086789) but anti-frost coatings inspired by the structure of proteins have a similar effect as described in L. Makkonen, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 26 (2012) 413.
Finally, certain treatments make it possible to combine two effects: modifying the type of frost and reducing its adhesion as described by J. Chen, R. Dou, D. Cui, Q. Zhang, Y. Zhang, F. Xu, X. Zhou, J. Wang, Y. Song and L. Jiang, ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces, 5 (2013) 4026. This is the case for microstructured surfaces comprising a hydroscopic polymer matrix (based on polyacrylic acid for example). These surfaces make it possible to easily eliminate the ice formed and have the advantage of using water as lubricant, thus the surface is self-supplied with lubricant with the aid of the humidity contained in the air.
It is also known to limit, or even prevent the formation of frost by heating, for example with the Joule effect or pneumatic pulsation systems.
There are also techniques with a gas stream with a sufficient flow or an input of mechanical and/or electrical energy, which may be combined with a coating and/or a treatment in order to easily detach the impurities, the adhesion of which has been reduced.
A person skilled in the art who is a specialist in low-temperature purification and cooling or separation or liquefaction processes is not abreast with developments relating to the surface treatments and the coatings used for limiting, or even preventing the formation and/or the adhesion of ice on a surface. A portion of the present invention results from the realization that these techniques may be applied to the field of cooling and purification, for example used upstream of a separation or a liquefaction, for example a distillation, at low temperature or another process operating at low temperature.
GB-A-917286 describes a low-temperature separation process in which a gas containing carbon dioxide is cooled by two exchangers in rotation, each allowing a heat exchange between only two fluids and each comprising a zone designed to avoid the deposition of carbon dioxide.
In this case, as the passages intended to cool the gas to be separated during a first period are also used to reheat a separated gas during a second period, it is necessary to provide the same number of passages and the same type of fins in the exchanger in order to obtain a symmetrical operation during the two operating periods.
The heat exchanger from GB-A-917286 inevitably consists of at least two exchange bodies and cannot be a monoblock body.
A low-temperature separation takes place at at most 0° C., or even at at least −50° C., or even at at least −100° C., depending on the gas mixture to be separated.
The “hot end” is the portion of the heat exchanger that is found operating at a maximum mean temperature. The “cold end” is that portion of the heat exchanger that is found operating at a minimum mean temperature.
A heat exchanger is a single exchange body or a plurality of exchange bodies, capable of carrying out a heat exchange.
The gas mixture to be cooled enters at the hot end of the exchanger and leaves therefrom, generally at the cold end.
Generally, a heat exchanger is mounted so that its hot end is found toward the top and its cold end toward the bottom. In certain cases, as described later on, the present invention may necessitate placing the hot end at the bottom and the cold end at the top.
The heat exchanger is generally placed inside a thermally insulated cold box. Other elements of a separation apparatus may also be found in the cold box, for example a distillation column.
The conclusions regarding the purification of a gas containing water and CO2 are that the purification of the gas by condensation/solidification is more energetically efficient than adsorption. It also makes it possible to eliminate or reduce in size the apparatus used according to the prior art, for example the apparatus for purification particular advantages since being colder at the outlet of the exchanger, the CO2, and especially a portion of the secondary impurities, are stopped even better, which makes it possible to simplify, or even eliminate the downstream purifications and/or to simplify the design and/or the operation of certain downstream equipment (for example the vaporizers).
According to one subject of the invention, a process is provided for cooling, purifying and separating a gas mixture containing at least one impurity, wherein the gas mixture containing at least one impurity is cooled to a temperature below or equal to that at which the at least one impurity solidifies in a heat exchanger comprising at least one exchange body having cooling passages designed to reduce the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages, at least one portion of the solidified impurity leaving the cooling passages of the heat exchanger and/or at an intermediate level of the heat exchanger is collected and the gas mixture, optionally at least partially liquefied, is drawn off from the heat exchanger, preferably at the cold end, the gas mixture is optionally cooled again and the gas mixture is sent to a system of columns in order to be separated by distillation at low temperature, or even cryogenic temperature, in order to produce two fluids, each enriched in one component of the gas mixture, characterized in that the cooling passages are at least partially covered by a coating and/or physically treated and/or chemically treated, the coating and/or the treatment serving to limit, or even prevent, the formation and/or the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages, and in that
i) during substantially the entire time that the separation by distillation is carried out, the gas mixture is cooled in each exchange body having cooling passages designed to reduce the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages and/or
ii) the two fluids, each enriched in one component of the mixture, are reheated in each exchange body having cooling passages designed to reduce the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages.
According to other optional aspects:
Each of the above features may be combined with each of the others above except in the case of an obvious incompatibility.
If the passages of the heat exchanger are treated to limit the deposition of impurities but not to prevent it completely, it will be necessary to remove the solids formed in the passages, for example by heating and/or by passage of the gas mixture at a sufficient flow rate (its nominal flow rate or a higher flow rate) and/or at high pressure relative to the flow rate and/or pressure that are used during the cooling or by mechanical means, for example by variation of the gas mixture flow rate or pulses of the gas mixture flow rate, or else vibrations applied directly to the exchanger.
According to one subject of the invention, an apparatus is provided for cooling and purifying a gas mixture containing at least one impurity comprising a heat exchanger having passages for cooling the gas mixture and passages for reheating a gas, means for sending the gas mixture containing at least one impurity to be cooled in the heat exchanger to a temperature below or equal to that at which the at least one impurity solidifies and means for drawing off the, optionally at least partially liquefied, gas mixture from the heat exchanger, preferably at the cold end and means for collecting at least one portion of the solidified impurity leaving the cooling passages of the heat exchanger and/or at an intermediate level of the heat exchanger and means for taking the gas mixture of the at least one impurity out of the heat exchanger, characterized in that the cooling passages are at least partially covered by a coating and/or physically treated and/or chemically treated, the coating and/or the treatment serving to limit, or even prevent, the formation and/or the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages and in that the apparatus comprises a single heat exchanger connected to means for collecting at least one portion of the solidified impurity, this heat exchanger being a monoblock heat exchanger.
According to other optional aspects:
According to another aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided for separation by distillation at low temperature, or even cryogenic temperature, comprising a cooling and purification apparatus as described above and also a system of columns and means for sending the gas mixture purified and cooled by the cooling and purification apparatus to the system of columns.
The separation apparatus may not comprise means for cooling the gas mixture downstream of the cooling and purification apparatus.
The apparatus may comprise means for sending a fluid enriched in one component of the gas mixture to be reheated in the heat exchanger in reheating passages.
According to other optional features:
The separation and purification apparatus may comprise means for supplying frigories to the gas mixture which is cooled at at least one intermediate point of the heat exchanger.
The separation and purification apparatus may comprise means for supplying frigories to the gas mixture which is cooled at at least one intermediate point of the heat exchanger, preferably downstream and/or upstream of a point for drawing off at least one portion of the solidified or liquefied impurity at an intermediate level of the heat exchanger.
The separation and purification apparatus may comprise means for supplying frigories to the gas mixture by taking at least one portion of the gas mixture out of the heat exchanger.
The separation and purification apparatus may comprise means for supplying frigories to the gas mixture by means of a refrigerant fluid sent to an intermediate level of the heat exchanger.
In all the strategies for separation by liquefaction and condensation of the impurities, the issue is to compensate for the phase change enthalpies of the various constituents by input of energy (here refrigeration make-up) via devices external to the main exchanger (example: heat pump, refrigerating unit).
If no refrigeration make-up is made, the exchange graph is moved apart at the cold end as is seen in
In the curve from
The case of
The invention will be described in greater detail by referring to
Detailed here are process diagrams to which the concept of the invention could be applied. They are diagrams of a single-column, low-pressure air separation unit. They could be transposed to other separation and/or liquefaction processes, such as cryogenic separation processes for the H2/CO mixture as explained above.
Represented in
The air to be separated 1 contains water and carbon dioxide, which must be purified upstream of the distillation. After filtering through a filter F and compression in a compressor C, the compressed air 1 enters the heat exchanger 3 constituted by a single exchange body and referred to as an “exchange line” without passing through beds of adsorbents conventionally present in an air separation apparatus. It can be envisaged to eliminate a portion of the water contained in the air by separating the water that is condensed, during the compression of the air followed by a cooling step. However, at least 20% of the water present in the ambient air will be removed by passing through the exchanger. The extraction of the water on the one hand then the remainder of the water and the CO2 on the other hand are carried out at two different locations in the exchange line 3. A large portion of the water is removed in liquid form (around 75% of the water present in the air 1 on arriving in the exchanger 3, after compression followed by a cooling step) at a temperature close to 0° C.: the air 5 at this location is drawn off by separating the air and the water 5B in a phase separator 2 then the dried air 5A is reinjected in order to finish the cooling thereof and to carry out the same separation at its outlet from the exchange line 3 with the remainder of the water and the CO2 this time, the two being solid. To compensate for the latent heat of liquefaction and of condensation of the impurities, two refrigeration make-ups are necessary via two heat pumps, for example at 0° C. and at −25° C.
Thus air 7 drawn off at an intermediate level of the exchange line 3 is cooled by means of a first heat pump 4 and the cooled air is sent back to the exchange line 3.
Next air 11 drawn off at a colder intermediate level of the exchange line 3 is cooled by a second heat pump 6 supplied by a fluid 13. The cooled air 11A is sent back to the exchange line.
The air already purified of water and cooled in two steps 15 contains ice and solid carbon dioxide and is sent to a phase separator 17 and the ice and the solid carbon dioxide 19 are removed.
The walls of the cooling passages are treated in order to limit, even prevent, the formation and/or the adhesion of ice and of carbon dioxide to the surfaces, at least in the regions where the temperature of the passage is anticipated to be below the solidification temperature of the water and/or of the carbon dioxide.
This treatment may be a physical treatment of the surface or the installation of water and solid carbon dioxide remain in the air and pass through the exchange line to the cold end before being collected in the second phase separator 17.
A portion of the secondary impurities of the air (in particular propane, acetylene, propylene, C4+, N2O) are also separated in the separator 17 at the cold end of the exchanger, either in solid form, or in liquid form.
The purified air 20 is divided into two portions 23, 25. The portion 23 is sent to the middle of the single distillation column 27 where it is separated to form nitrogen-enriched gas 47 at the top of the column and an oxygen-enriched liquid 43 at the bottom of the column 27.
The portion 15 of the air is condensed at least partially in a heat exchanger 59 by heat exchange with a flow of fluid 57 that is cooled by means of a heat pump 21 using the magnetocaloric effect.
A cooling fluid 53, typically ambient air or cooling water is sent to the heat pump 21 using the magnetocaloric effect. Reheated water 55 leaves the heat pump 21.
The column comprises a bottom reboiler 29 and an overhead condenser 31. The reboiler is heated by means of a fluid circuit 41 in connection with a heat pump 33 using the magnetocaloric effect. This heat pump 33 using the magnetocaloric effect also serves to cool a fluid 37 which cools the overhead condenser 31. The fluids 37 and 41 may be identical or different. An oxygen-enriched liquid 43 is drawn off at the bottom of the column 19 and a nitrogen-enriched gas drawn off via a pipe 47 is reheated in the exchanger 3 and is not used to regenerate a purification unit since there is none. An oxygen-enriched gas 45 is drawn off at the bottom of the column 27, is reheated in the exchanger 3 and is compressed by a compressor 49.
Unlike
The solidified carbon dioxide and/or the (solidified) water is collected for both bodies and sent to a single container 17. The use of several containers can obviously be envisaged.
The purified air from both bodies is mixed to form the flow 20 and continues its treatment as for
The gas 47 is reheated simultaneously in the two exchange bodies during the distillation, being divided into two upstream of the bodies 3a, 3b and remixed downstream of these bodies.
The gas 45 is reheated simultaneously in the two exchange bodies during the distillation, being divided into two upstream of the bodies 3a, 3b and remixed downstream of these bodies.
As each passage only receives one gas to be reheated or one gas to be cooled and the flows are not reversed during the distillation, the number of passages dedicated to cooling the air is not identical to the number of passages intended to reheat the gas 47 for a given body.
Illustrated schematically in
In the variant from
Thus air 7 drawn off at an intermediate level of the exchange line 3 is cooled firstly by means of a first heat pump 4 and then is removed from the line in order to remove the ice. The cooled air 5A sent back to the exchange line 3 is again cooled by the second cooler 6.
For the case of
It should be noted that in all cases, there may be only a single refrigeration make-up at the exchange line 3, or even none at all, if one is ready to sacrifice energy, the necessary refrigeration make-up then being introduced at the cold end of the exchanger, where it costs the most.
In the variant from
But in this example, the solids or liquids 19 (the remainder of the water, the CO2 and other secondary impurities) collected in the separator 17 are sent to the exchange line 3 in order to provide refrigeration thereto. This makes it possible to recover a portion of the latent heat, and therefore to reduce, or even simplify the necessary refrigeration make-ups.
In order not to complicate the exchange line, they may be injected into at least one dry and cold fluid, for example originating from the cryogenic separation, for example the nitrogen 47 in order to form a mixed flow 61. In this case, it may be prudent to treat at least certain portions of the nitrogen reheating passages in order to limit, or even prevent, the deposition of these solids.
Other means may be envisaged for removing the solid impurity, which may be released to the atmosphere. The heat exchanger may cool the gas containing at least one impurity periodically and the impurity may be melted, for example while the heat exchanger is not operating.
The solid could also be evacuated by consenting to lose a portion of the gas mixture that then transports the solid, with a pneumatic style transportation.
In
In the variant from
In the case from
Indeed, by solidifying and/or liquefying, the water becomes heavier and falls counter-current to the gas, which is cooled. It emerges in liquid form at the hot end of the exchanger 3.
This variant does not use phase separators but generally needs supplies of refrigeration at the exchange line.
Conversely, the cold flows 45, 47 enter through the top of the exchange line and exit through the bottom.
For greater clarity, the figure is drawn as if the water and/or the ice 19 descended through a passage other than the passage through which they entered, present in the air.
In fact, the water and/or the ice 19 will exit through the same passage through which they entered.
In the variant from
For the case where the exchange line is divided into two exchange bodies in series, the two lines 3,3A may be constructed with the same technology or different technologies (plate-fin exchanger, coil exchanger, shell and tube exchanger). Similarly, if the exchange lines are of the same technology, they do not necessarily have the same construction and may differ by the dimensions of the passages, the number of passages, the type of coating and/or treatment used to limit the deposition of solids, the type of fins use, the material out of which they are constructed, etc.
These eleven examples all relate to the separation of air by distillation in a single column. The invention may be applied to the cryogenic separation of air by any known system of columns, other than that described and using any known means of producing refrigeration, other than those described.
The air separation apparatus may for example be a double air separation column producing at least one gaseous product and/or at least one liquid product.
The invention may also be applied to the purification and cooling of other gas mixtures having at least one impurity capable of solidifying during the cooling. An impurity is a component that represents no more than 10 mol % or 5 mol % or even 1 mol %, or even 0.1 mol %, or even 0.01 mol % of the gas mixture.
It is applied in particular to other gas mixtures, for example to mixtures of carbon dioxide containing for example at least 30% carbon dioxide and water. In this case, the passages of the exchange line are treated in order to limit, or even prevent, the deposition of the water and the pressure and the temperature are chosen in order to avoid the deposition of CO2. A mixture of this type may be separated in a process from
For all the figures, the supply of refrigeration, if there is any, may be carried out with any known and suitable means (for example, magnetocaloric cooler, compression-expansion conventional refrigerating unit, turbine).
In the figures, a portion of the gas mixture leaves the exchange line in order to be cooled in the element supplying refrigeration while the remainder of the gas mixture continues its cooling in the exchange line. The portion cooled by the supply of refrigeration is then mixed with the remainder of the mixture which has not left the exchange line.
It is also possible to take the entire gas mixture out of the exchange line in order to send it to the element supplying refrigeration and send back the cooled mixture to the exchange line.
In the examples from the figures, it is seen that a portion or several portions 7, 11 of the air leave the exchanger 3 in order to be cooled and sent back (flows 7A, 11A) to the exchanger. It is also possible in all or some of the cases to use a heat transfer fluid in a closed circuit which transfers heat from the heat exchanger 3 to the cooling means 4,6 and returns to the heat exchanger in order to supply refrigeration thereto.
In all cases, it can be envisaged to provide a final purification downstream of the exchanger and, where appropriate, downstream of the phase separator or endless screw, in order to eliminate the remaining impurities in the flow of mixture 20.
In all cases, the heat exchanger 3 may comprise passages, at least one section of which has a treatment and/or a coating and/or a geometry and/or a type of fin, in the case of a plate-fin exchanger, that differs from that of another section that has to operate at a lower temperature range.
For example, the passage section of the exchanger that is at a temperature between 20° C. and 0° C. will be treated in one way or will have a coating of one type and the passage section that is at a temperature between 0° C. and −60° C. will be treated in another way. The treatment or coating may be chosen in order to adapt to the type of physical phenomenon change (gas→liquid, gas→solid, liquid→solid), or else the type of impurities in question (for example water/carbon dioxide).
The heat exchanger 3 may comprise passages, at least one section of which has a treatment and/or a coating and/or a geometry and/or a type of fin, in the case of a plate-fin exchanger, that differs from that of another section that is found downstream of an intermediate point for drawing off solidified impurities.
The heat exchanger may be constituted by at least two heat exchangers made of different materials, for example one brazed aluminum exchanger and one brazed copper exchanger.
For all the examples, during substantially the entire time that the separation by distillation is carried out, the gas mixture is cooled in each exchange body having cooling passages designed to reduce the adhesion of the solidified impurity on a surface of the passages.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
1454000 | Apr 2014 | FR | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/FR2015/051166 | 4/30/2015 | WO | 00 |