The invention relates to a method of recording data on a record carrier and to a corresponding apparatus.
The invention further relates to a method of extracting fingerprint data from data recorded on a record carrier and to a corresponding apparatus.
The invention further relates to a record carrier having data recorded thereon.
With the advent of new on-line content distribution channels like iTunes, MusicMatch, PressPlay, Windows-Media Digital Rights Management (DRM) has started to play an increasingly important role. Currently three categories of DRM are employed. They can be distinguished by the way they store and protect the usage rights (such as “copy one time”, “view until Wednesday”, etc.):
1. Network-centric: the rights are stored securely on a dedicated server in a network. Devices wanting to access content consult the server to obtain (and if necessary update) the rights. The server might reside somewhere on the Internet (e.g. at the content owner's), or in a home network. This DRM category requires devices to be (almost) always on-line when accessing content.
2. (Personal) Card-centric: the rights are stored securely on a removable card or token, e.g. a smart-card, SD card, MemoryStick etc. Devices wanting to access content contact the removable security card to obtain (and if necessary update) the rights. This DRM category requires devices to have a slot for a plug-in card.
3. Device-centric: the rights are stored securely inside a fixed playback or storage device (e.g. a PC on which the content resides). A device wanting to access content administers the rights itself. The consequence of this DRM category is that content is always locked to a single device. The MusicMatch—and the original Windows DRM service are examples of such systems.
In the last few years a fourth variant has been developed which aims essentially at marrying the current optical media content distribution business-model to DRM, giving an optical disc almost the same functionality as flash memory cards such as SD-card or MemoryStick:
4. Media-centric: the rights are stored securely on the recordable media itself. Devices wanting to access content have special circuitry to retrieve (and if necessary update) the rights on the media. The consequence of this DRM category is that content can be consumed in any (media-centric DRM compatible) device (rights travel together with the content).
Although the last category looks very appealing from a consumer point of view, technically it is the most complicated one, because the layout of optical media has been standardized giving attackers direct access to all bits and bytes without further need for authentication and knowledge of system secrets etc. Of course, it is well known, e.g. from disc-based copy protection systems (DVD, CD, etc.), how to prevent such bits from being copied, using tools from cryptography (ciphers, key-distribution schemes, broadcast-encryption etc.) and disc-marks/ROM side-channels (wobbles, BCA with unique media ID, . . . ). However none of these systems had to contend with the particularly vicious save-and-restore attack, unique to DRM systems with consumable rights.
Contrary to static rights (copy never, copy free, EPN (encryption plus non-assertion state)), consumable rights are rights which typically get more restrictive every time the content is consumed, e.g. play 4× , or record 3×. The save-and-restore attack goes as follows:
at any given moment the attacker can restore the original rights by copying back the image from the alternate storage (HDD). In this process the original rights are restored as well, even if the attacker doesn't know what the (encrypted) bits which have been copied back mean: the medium has simply been returned to its virgin state. This is independent of the use of any ROM side-channels such as the “Disc Mark” (e.g. a unique, but fixed media identifier in the BCA).
A method to resolve this hack is disclosed in WO02/015184 A1. According to this method a hidden channel (HC) as a side-channel is introduced. A side-channel is a method to store additional information on a recording medium by exploiting the fact that multiple read-out signals represent the same user-data pattern (data available to the user). E.g. an additional message may be coded in the error-correction parities. The error-correction mechanism will remove these parities, so the user does not see any difference, but dedicated circuitry preceding the error-correction mechanism does. Of course in this example the information capacity of the medium has been increased at the expense of decreasing the system's error-correcting capacity.
According to WO02/015184 A1 the HC is a side-channel on the storage medium containing information which observes the constraint that it cannot be recorded by the user but only by some compliant DRM application, and is therefore lost in bit-copies. Simple examples are data stored in sector headers and certain parts of the lead-in area. More sophisticated examples are redundancies in the standard for the storage medium, in which information is stored by making a particular choice for such a redundancy, e.g. selecting certain merging bit patterns on CD, or specific trends in the DSV (digital sum value, the running sum of channel-bits) on a DVD as, for instance, described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,828,754, or intentional errors in sector data (which can be corrected by the redundant ECC-symbols). Yet another example is information stored in slow variations of the channel-bit clock as, for instance, described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,737,286.
During the update of rights, the HC is used as follows:
During read-out of the rights the following check is performed using the HC:
Step (ii) prevents the save-and-restore attack: the image, including the original digital rights may be restored by the attacker, but the HC cannot, therefore the check in step (ii) fails. Rights and content keys can be protected in a Key Locker which in turn is protected by a Key Locker Key, which depends (partially) on the payload of a HC. Further, it is not necessary for the data in the HC to be confidential; however, it should be very difficult for the attacker to modify these bits.
However, the system known from WO 02/015184 suffers from a disadvantage: because this known system relies on a universal secret present in every consumer device, viz. the algorithm by which bits are stored in the hidden channel. An attacker could therefore build a non-compliant device which would enable him to get access to the hidden information so that he could manipulate the hidden information, and thus could provide him with illegal access to encrypted content by manipulating any digital rights. It is therefore desired to provide measures which make it very difficult, expensive or even impossible to construct such a device for reasons which do not depend on the presence of a universal secret.
This disadvantage is overcome according to non-prepublished EP application No. 04106504.6 (filed on Dec 13, 2004 by the same applicant), which describes a method for controlling distribution and use of a Digital Work (DW), wherein the DW, along with appended Usage Right Information (URI), specifying the conditions under which the DW can be accessed, is recorded on a record carrier. The described method foresees that:
This method relies on extracting the fingerprint data from a pattern recorded on the record carrier. In particular, a distinctive feature of a recorded pattern, known in the art as “fingerprint”, can be represented by channel-bit errors of predetermined data recorded on said record carrier, or from the positions of the zero-crossings of a read-out signal with respect to channel bit boundaries of predetermined data recorded on said record carrier, or from the highest or lowest values, respectively, at a predetermined position of predetermined data recorded on said record carrier.
In other words the “fingerprint” of a recorded pattern is a feature by which the recorded pattern can be distinguished from any other recorded pattern, even when representing the same data. Moreover, the fingerprint is obtained as result of some non-controlled process, in this case is inherent to the recording process, so that it is either impossible or unfeasible to record a pattern having a desired fingerprint.
It is a first object of the present invention to provide a method of recording data on a record carrier, from which data fingerprint data can be extracted in an alternative manner, and a corresponding apparatus.
It is a second object of the present invention to provide an alternative method of extracting fingreprint data from data recorded on a record carrier, and a corresponding apparatus.
It is a third object of the present invention to provide a record carrier having recorded data, from which data fingerprint data can be extracted in an alternative manner.
According to the invention, the first object is achieved by a method of recording data as claimed in claim 1, and by an apparatus for recording data as claimed in claim 8. Therefore, according to the invention the distinctive feature of the recorded pattern from which the fingerprint data is extracted are variations in the channel bit length, i.e. variations in the longitudinal density of the recorded pattern. While according to the above-mentioned non-prepublished EP application No. 04106504.6 the distinctive feature is found in unavoidable differences between recorded patterns, resulting as a side effect of the recording process, in the method according to the present invention instead, the distinctive feature is purposely created. This has the advantage of making more robust and reliable the extraction of the fingerprint data, since the recording process can be adapted to creating a recorded pattern where the distinctive feature is sufficiently easy to detect, i.e. a longitudinal density having sufficiently large variations, or in other words where the distinctive feature can be detected with a sufficiently high signal-to-noise ratio. Yet the distinctive feature is created with an uncontrollable and substantially random process, so that it will be generally not possible to record a pattern with a predetermined fingerprint. The fingerprint data can then be extracted from this irreproducible feature, for example by measuring the channel bit length at a plurality of fixed sampling positions.
It is observed that WO 02/067255 A1 describes record carrier having recorded a primary signal having variable bit length, where a secondary signal is embedded in the primary signal, encoded in variations of the bit length. However in this case the variations of the bit length carry a predetermined information and therefore are controlled, whereas, in the case of the present invention the variations in the channel bit length are the result of an uncontrollable and substantially random process, and therefore do not carry any predetermined information.
As it will be clear from the foregoing discussion, the second object is achieved, according to the invention, by a method of extracting fingerprint data as claimed in claim 2, and by an apparatus for extracting fingerprint data as claimed in claim 12. Similarly, the third object is achieved by a record carrier as claimed in claim 14.
Various advantageous embodiments are claimed in the dependent claims.
These and other aspects of the methods and apparatuses according to the invention will be further elucidated and described with reference to the drawings. In the drawings:
Generally, the recorded pattern 12 has to respect some standard specifications given for the relevant type of record carrier, like for instance affecting the width or length of the areas, the steepness of the transition from a first area to a second area and vice-versa, etc. In spite of these standard specifications to which any recorded pattern has to adhere, it is possible to define some properties according to which a recorded pattern is highly likely to be different from any other recorded pattern, similarly to a person's fingerprint. These properties, can for example refer to:
The data 10 can be retrieved from the recorded pattern 12 by generating a read-out signal, depending on the relevant physical parameter, while scanning the recording track 15. A channel bit clock signal, which can be recovered from the read-out signal, can be used for sampling the read-out signal, thereby allowing retrieval of the data 10.
The channel bit length shall still remain within the boundaries of a maximum/minimum length, if any such specification is given. The overall trend of the channel bit length can thus be used as “fingerprint” of the recorded pattern 22 in a corresponding fingerprint extraction process 26, where the fingerprint data 17 are derived in a step of determining the fingerprint data from the channel bit length of the recorded pattern 22. The fingerprint data 17 may consist for example of a collection of samples of the channel bit length, measured at predetermined sampling points. These predetermined sampling points may be determined upon a timing and/or synchronization information present in the recording track 15, like in the case of recordable optical discs, where timing and/or synchronization information are present in the recording track 15 in the form of wobble frequency of the track and/or information encoded therein.
The channel bit length, can be measured my measuring the channel bit frequency of the channel bit clock which is recovered from the read-out signal by means of a PLL. The frequency ofthe recovered channel bit clock is generally available: for example an output of the integrator, which is part of the PLL loop filter, can be used to observe variations in the recovered channel bit clock. In this way only the component of the variations of the channel bit length, introduced while recording, that lies within the bandwidth of the PLL (during readout) can be observed. Unfortunately there are noise sources that can give rise to variations in the recovered channel bit clock. In reference to a rotatable disc for example, the dominant noise source here is eccentricity. However, due to its periodic nature, the variations in the recovered channel bit clock due to eccentricity can be removed.
If a synchronization information is present in the recording track 15, the channel bit length can be calculated by counting the periods of the recovered channel bit clock during intervals of equal length, the intervals of equal length being defined on the basis of said synchronization information. In a recordable optical disc, where a wobble is present, it is possible to count the number of channel bits present in different wobble periods. An advantage of this method is that variations due to eccentricity do not affect the measurement. The reason is that eccentricity influences the wobble frequency in the same way as it affects the frequency ofthe recovered channel bit clock. It is in a way a relative measurement.
The method of extracting fingerprint data shown in
The reference fingerprint data 41 can be subsequently used in a method of authentication, like schematically shown in
The method can be enhanced by use of a helper data, by use of which the comparison is done on those parts of the fingerprint data 17 that are more reliably consistent at each instance of the fingerprint extraction step 26.
Clearly, if the method of extracting fingerprint data comprises an authentication data derivation step 30 as shown in
The invention can also be exploited in an alternative method of protecting data recorded on a record carrier as shown in
The channel bit clock 86 is provided by synchronization means 89, i.e. a clock control loop, also known as PLL. Within this clock control loop, the channel bit clock 86 is generated by a clock generator 85, and compared with a reference synchronization signal 80 inside a controller 82, operating according to some control parameters 83, which generates a control signal 84, controlling the clock generator 85 to increase/decrease the rate of the channel bit clock 86, according to what is necessary to bring in phase the reference synchronization signal 80 and the channel bit clock 86.
In reference with an apparatus for recording data on a recordable optical disc, the recording means 87 comprise a laser which supplies via a radiation beam a thermal energy sufficient for changing the reflectivity of an area subjected to the radiation beam. The reference synchronization signal 80 is a synchronization signal recovered from the wobble modulation of the recording track 15, and reflects the speed at which the recording track is scanned. Clearly in this case, before comparing the channel bit clock 86 and the reference synchronization signal 80, one of these two signals must be scaled by a scaling factor reflecting the desired relation between these two signals. Therefore the synchronization means 89 effectively control the channel bit length in the recorded pattern.
An alternative embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention is shown in
In both the embodiments shown in
Clearly, the various measures described have to be designed so that the resulting recorded pattern 22 is compliant with the specifications of the relevant standard, for example regarding the average channel bit length and its maximum deviation from a nominal value, if any such specifications are given. Moreover, preferably, the resulting variations in the channel bit length should have a spectral extension within the bandwidth of a channel bit clock recovery unit, which is used for recovering the channel bit clock from the read-out signal, so as not to hamper retrieval of the data 10. Subject to this considerations however, preferably, the resulting variations in the channel bit length are rather fast and with high frequency components, so as to render more difficult any attempt to form a recorded pattern 22 having a desired fingerprint.
Although the invention has been elucidated with reference to an optical record carrier, it will be evident that other applications are possible, for example to a rotatable non optical record carrier. The scope of the invention is therefore not limited to the embodiments described above.
It must further be noted that the term “comprises/comprising” when used in this specification, including the claims, is taken to specify the presence of stated features, integers, steps or components, but does not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, components or groups thereof. It must also be noted that the word “a” or “an” preceding an element in a claim does not exclude the presence of a plurality of such elements. Moreover, any reference signs do not limit the scope of the claims; the invention can be implemented by means of both hardware and software, and several “means” may be represented by the same item of hardware. Furthermore, the invention resides in each and every novel feature or combination of features.
The invention can be summarized as follows. In the field of content distribution a typical problem is the protection of Digital Rights information (DRM), which is appended to the content and recorded on a record carrier in the form of a corresponding recorded pattern, from tampering by malicious users. According to some known schemes, the protection is implemented by linking the DRM to some physical distinctive feature of the corresponding recorded pattern. From this distinctive feature fingerprint data can be extracted with some conventional method, and used for the authentication of the DRM. The invention proposes a method of recording data wherein variations in the density of the recorded pattern are formed, as result of a perturbation imposed in the recording process, which perturbation is a non-controllable substantially random process.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
05112259.6 | Dec 2005 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/IB2006/054711 | 12/8/2006 | WO | 00 | 6/12/2008 |