Patent Application
20130019327
The present invention relates to non-human animal models of cancer pathology, which mimic the hierarchical organization of human cancer tissues with cancer stem cells at the top of the hierarchy, reproduce the cancer progression process, and enable assessment of their biological properties. The present invention also relates to methods of screening for anti-cancer agents and methods for assessing the pharmacological effects of test substances, which use the non-human animal model or an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line, which is established by transplanting human tumor tissues into severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice.
Human tumor cells show various tissue structures, and such tissues are known to have a hierarchical organization with cancer stem cells at the top of the hierarchy (Non-patent Document 1). For example, it is known that colon cancer is roughly subdivided into two layers: first an area with differentiated colon epithelium-like cells having a glandular structure, and second an invasive area with cells having a tendency to differentiate into mesenchymal cells (Non-patent Documents 2 and 3). Such findings were obtained based on knowledge accumulated through a vast amount of morphological observations of human colon cancer tissues. However, animal models that mimic the hierarchical organization of cancer tissues are rare. Thus, little is understood about the process leading to the formation of the hierarchical organization of cancer tissues and the involvement of cancer stem cells in this process.
Meanwhile, it has recently been shown that NOG-established cancer cell lines, which are established by transplanting human tumor tissues into severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice, form tissue structures similar to those of human cancer tissues (Non-patent Document 4).
However, useful animal models were unavailable to morphologically observe the process leading to the formation of the hierarchical organization of cancer cell lines in vivo or to elucidate the involvement of cancer stem cells in the formation process. Use of animal models of cancer pathology that reflect a human cancer is known to give results closer to human clinical data when it comes to developing or assessing pharmaceutical agents for treating or preventing cancer, anti-cancer agent screening or assessment of pharmacological effects of test substances. Under these circumstances, there was a need for a non-human animal model exhibiting the cancer pathology more similar to that of a human cancer. Furthermore, there was a need for an in vitro cell culture system that exhibits cell morphology more similar to that of human cancer pathology.
An objective of the present invention is to provide non-human animal models of cancer pathology, which mimic the hierarchical organization of human cancer tissues, cancer progression process, and biological properties thereof. Another objective of the present invention is to provide methods of searching for anti-cancer agent targets, which use the non-human animal model or an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line, which is established by transplanting human tumor tissues into severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice. Still another objective of the present invention is to provide methods of screening for anti-cancer agents that are effective in preventing or treating cancer, which use the non-human animal model or the in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line. Yet another objective of the present invention is to provide methods for assessing the preventive or therapeutic effect of test substances against human cancer, which use the non-human animal model or the in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line.
The present inventors conducted dedicated studies to achieve the objectives described above.
The present inventors predicted that the process leading to the formation of hierarchical organization, the involvement of cancer stem cells in the process, and their biological properties may be elucidated through morphological observation of tissue structures after transplanting NOG mice with NOG-established cancer cell lines, which are established by transplanting human tumor tissues into severely-immunodeficient NOG mice. Based on this prediction, the present inventors conducted the studies described below.
First, NOG-established cancer cell lines derived from colon cancer, stomach cancer, breast cancer, lung cancer, and pancreatic cancer were morphologically observed after the transplantation into the NOG mouse. Observations revealed an area where the human cancer tissue took an epithelium-like structure, and an invasive area where some of the cells have a mesenchymal phenotype (
Furthermore, the hierarchical organization was remarkably similar to that of donors' human cancer tissues, and time-dependent changes were observed during the cancer progression process leading to the formation of the hierarchical organization. In addition, when observing cell lines established from donors' tumors of different tissue types over time, it showed that: cells of each cell line formed tissue morphologies resembling the donor's tumor after going through a progression process with changes unique to the cell line (Table 1); this was repeatedly reproduced (
Furthermore, the present inventors monitored time-dependent changes of cancer stem cells over two generations, and revealed that cells which once lost their characteristics as cancer stem cells and differentiated in the first generation newly acquired stem cell characteristics in the second generation, i.e., the biological property of stem cell plasticity (
In recent years, decrease in expression level of proteins such as P53 have been demonstrated to be involved in the phenomenon called reprogramming by which stem cells acquire pluripotency. Therefore, the present inventors carried out immunostaining for the P53 protein and revealed that the expression level of P53 protein was reduced even in the cancer stem cells detected with the models of the present invention (
Furthermore, it has been recently pointed out that fibroblasts in the tumor stroma may play an important role in tumor growth/progression. In some tumors, the fibroblasts are predicted to be derived from the tumors themselves through complete epithelial-mesenchymal transition (complete-EMT) (Radisky D C, et al., J Cell Biochem. 2007; 101: 830-9). In the present invention, time-course observations after transplantation of NOG-established cancer cell line into mice revealed that the detected fibroblasts were derived not from the host (mouse) but from the transplanted human tissues. This demonstrates that the models of the present invention also mimic the formation of the hierarchical organization including tumor stroma formation (
As described above, time-course observations of NOG mice transplanted with NOG-established cancer cell lines revealed that:
(1) the present invention enables preparation of animal models that repeatedly mimic the hierarchical organization of donors' human cancer tissues;
(2) unique cancer stem cells, which have a property responsible for the formation of each hierarchical organization, are observed in the models of the present invention, and the models mimic the biological properties of cancer stem cells; and
(3) the present invention enables preparation of in vivo animal models that enable observation of the process leading to the transition of cancer cells into tumor stroma-forming fibroblasts through complete-EMT during the process that mimics the formation of the hierarchical organization. These properties could also be mimicked by the in vitro culture system using NOG-established cancer cell lines.
Next, since the novel model animals with the properties described above could be prepared, the present inventors tested the applicability of the models as novel methods of searching for anti-cancer agent targets and screening methods therefor.
A possible method of searching for novel anti-cancer agent targets is as follows:
tissue pieces having tissue structures characteristically seen in the progression process in each area (starting from the same cell line) are collected by laser microdissection (LMD); the mRNA expression is assessed to find genes whose expression varies depending on the process, tissue structure, or biological properties thereof.
Since a gene found by the above-described methods, or a protein encoded by the gene, is predicated to contribute to the cancer progression process, an inhibitor of the gene or protein is expected to serve as target for a novel anti-cancer agent that inhibits the cancer progression process.
Meanwhile, a possible novel screening method for assessing pharmaceutical agents is to assess whether a particular step of the cancer progression process is inhibited or a biological property characteristic of cancer stem cells is modulated by administering a pre-existing anti-cancer agent (for example, fluorouracil or irinotecan) to a model of the present invention, focusing attention on the cancer progression process, which can be monitored through the observation of time-dependent changes in the models of the present invention. When this example is applied to the screening for novel anti-cancer agents, the models of the present invention enable identification of the specific biological property or the cancer progression process on which a particular anti-cancer agent acts. Thus, such screening is expected to have greater predictive performance from a clinical viewpoint.
Specifically, the present inventors succeeded in preparing non-human animal models exhibiting cancer pathology more similar to human cancer and in vitro cell culture systems of NOG-established cancer cell lines where the cell morphologies are more similar to those in human cancer. The present inventors thus completed the present invention.
More specifically, the present invention provides:
[1] a non-human animal model, which is obtained by transplanting, into a non-human animal of the same or different species, an NOG-established cancer cell line established by transplanting a human tumor tissue into a severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mouse;
[2] the non-human animal model of [1], which mimics hierarchical organization or cancer progression process of a human cancer tissue;
[3] the non-human animal model of [1], which enables
detection of a unique cancer stem cell having a characteristic for mimicking hierarchical organization and cancer progression process of a human cancer tissue, and,
testing of a biological property of the human cancer tissue;
[4] the non-human animal model of [1], which enables observation of the process leading to transition of a cancer cell into a tumor stroma-forming fibroblast through complete epithelial-mesenchymal transition (complete-EMT) during the process that mimics hierarchical organization of a human cancer tissue;
[5] a non-human animal model, which enables assessment of the cause of anti-cancer agent resistance by administering an anti-cancer agent into the non-human animal model of any one of [1] to [4], and assessing, as an indicator, hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of a cancer cell, or transition through complete epithelial-mesenchymal transition (complete-EMT);
[6] the non-human animal model of any one of [1] to [4], wherein the human tumor tissue is derived from colon cancer, stomach cancer, breast cancer, lung cancer, or pancreatic cancer;
[7] a method of searching for an anti-cancer agent target, wherein assessment is carried out, using as an indicator, hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of a cancer cell in a non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line or in an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line;
[8] the method of searching for an anti-cancer agent target of [7], which comprises the steps of:
The present invention provides non-human animal models of cancer pathology more similar to human cancer and in vitro cell culture systems whose cell morphologies are more similar to those in the human cancer pathology. A result closer to human clinical data is expected be obtained by screening for anti-cancer agents or assessing the pharmacological effects of test substances using an animal model of cancer pathology or a cancer cell culture system that more closely reflects human cancer.
cells which remained resting over two generations (open arrow);
cells which grew slowly in the first generation but stopped growing in the second generation (open triangle); and
cells which underwent differential proliferation in the first generation but stopped growing and became stem cells (arrow).
The present invention relates to non-human animal models of cancer pathology, which can be effectively used for developing pharmaceutical agents for treating or preventing human cancer, and cell culture systems that exhibit in vitro cell morphology more similar to that in a cancer pathology. Specifically, the present invention relates to non-human animal models obtained by transplanting an NOG-established cancer cell line (established by transplanting human cancer tissues into severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice) into non-human animals of the same or a different species, as well as in vitro culture systems of the NOG-established cancer cell lines.
The non-human animal models of the present invention may mimic the hierarchical organization of cancer tissues, cancer progression process, and biological properties thereof, which are unique to pathology of a human cancer. In the present invention, types of target cancers are not particularly limited, but preferably include, for example, colon cancer, stomach cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer, and pancreatic cancer.
Herein, the “hierarchical organization of cancer tissues, which is unique to human cancer pathology” includes a two-layer structure having an area with a glandular structure consisting of cells with epithelial-like differentiation and an invasive area with cells having a tendency to differentiate into mesenchymal cells.
In the above-described epithelium-like glandular area, E-cadherin is expressed on whole cell surface. The expression of E-cadherin can be tested using an anti-E-cadherin antibody.
The above-described invasive area exhibits characteristic morphologies: budding, cluster of tumor cells, dissociated single tumor cells, and reconstruction of tubules. Cells in the invasive area undergo partial-EMT leading to partial loss of the epithelial nature; lack E-cadherin expression at their contact surface with the stromal cells; and express fibronectin, which is normally not expressed on epithelium-like cells.
Furthermore, cancer stem cells, which are slow-cycling cells, can be detected in both the above-described epithelium-like glandular area and invasive area. Whether cancer stem cells are present in these areas can be assessed by using a cell proliferation marker (for example, continuous BrdU labeling and Ki67 staining), a cancer stem cell marker (for example, Lgr5 staining), or the like.
In addition, the present invention enables time-course and simultaneous observation of both the presence of cancer stem cells and the mimicking of the hierarchical organization of cancer tissues, cancer progression process, or biological properties thereof. This helps to elucidate the hierarchical organization and cancer progression process, i.e., how the cancer tissue-specific structure is formed originating from cancer stem cells.
More specifically, in the high stress environment at the early stage after transplantation, mainly surviving are the cancer stem cells and their progenitor cells. After the growth phase starts, gland-forming cancer cells emerge in the above-described epithelium-like glandular area. Meanwhile, slow-cycling cancer stem cells and their progenitor cells are maintained and become responsible for further expansion of the epithelium-like glandular area. On the other hand, in the above-described invasive area, partial-EMT cells such as cluster of tumor cells and dissociated single tumor cells emerge among cells that managed to survive under the high stress environment at the early stage after transplantation. These slow-cycling cancer stem cells are migrating cells since they have undergone partial-EMT, and expand their area while contributing to cancer invasion/dissemination and such. Furthermore, when reaching a specific environment, some partial-EMT cells undergo a so-called mesenchymal-epithelial transition (MET) there. Due to MET, partial-EMT cells which once lost the epithelial nature acquire this epithelial nature again, and then newly form epithelium-like glandular structures there.
In the present invention, the “cancer progression process unique to pathology of a human cancer” includes, for example, the following processes depending on the differentiation status of cancer cells.
In the case of well-differentiated cancer, the major process is an epithelium-like proliferation process (epithelial duct-forming pattern). In the case of moderately-differentiated cancer, the major process is an invasive proliferation process (invasive EMT pattern), while including an epithelium-like proliferation process (epithelial duct-forming pattern). In the case of poorly-differentiated cancer, the major process is an invasive proliferation process (invasive EMT pattern).
Examples that the present invention “enables assessment for the biological properties of cancer stem cells” include those described below.
Since each cell line repeatedly undergoes a uniquely changing progression process, cancer stem cells in situ show the biological property of having their own unique final destination of differentiation.
When following the transition of cancer stem cells over two generations, cells that lost their properties as cancer stem cells and differentiated in the first generation again acquire the properties as stem cells in the second generation, i.e., the biological property so-called stem cell plasticity.
A decreased expression of P53 protein is known to be involved in the stem cells' biological property of the acquirement of the pluripotency, i.e., reprogramming. This property is mimicked by cancer stem cells found in the models of the present invention.
Furthermore, the animal models of the present invention mimic the process of transition of cancer cells into tumor stroma-forming fibroblasts through complete epithelial-mesenchymal transition (complete-EMT). The transition into fibroblasts can be tested by IHC staining. The transition into human-specific fibroblasts can be assessed by IHC staining for human-specific β2 microglobulin.
The animal models of the present invention enable observation of an above-described process unique to the type of target cancer or the status of cancer progression.
Unique cancer stem cells which have the properties of mimicking the above-described hierarchical organization of human cancer tissues and cancer progression process can be detected in the animal models of the present invention.
Animals that can be used to prepare the animal models of the present invention include, for example, non-human mammals commonly used in conventional experiments such as mice, nude mice, rats, nude rats, guinea pigs, hamsters, rabbits, dogs, and monkeys. Preferred animals include, for example, rodents such as mice, nude mice, rats, nude rats, guinea pigs, hamsters, and rabbits. For the convenience of breeding and manipulation, more preferred animals include, for example, mice, nude mice (for example, NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice), rats, and nude rats.
An animal (recipient animal) to be transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line may be of the same or different species from the severely-immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mouse (donor animal) with which an NOG-established cancer cell line is established. From an immunological viewpoint, the animals are preferably of the same species. However, when immunodeficient animals such as nude mice or nude rats are used, the animals may be of different species.
The methods for preparing the animal models of the present invention are described below.
The animal models of the present invention can be prepared by transplanting NOG-established cancer cell lines established by transplanting human tumor tissues into severely immunodeficient NOD/SCID/gamma(c)(null) (NOG) mice as donor animals, subcutaneously into recipient animals, or into their various body cavities, or various organs.
NOG-established cancer cell lines to be transplanted into recipient animals can be collected and established from the NOG mice. The age of such NOG mice can be selected depending on the type of established cancer cell line to be transplanted and the species of recipient animal.
The age of recipient animals is, for example, preferably 4 to 100 weeks old when they are mice, nude mice, SCID mice, NOD-SCID mice, NOG mice, rats, or nude rats.
Specifically, the animal models of the present invention can be prepared by the following method. First, an NOG-established cancer cell line (Fujii E. et al., Pathol Int. (2008) 58: 559-567), which is established by transplanting human-derived cancer cells into NOG mice and passaging, is transplanted into recipient animals. Subcutaneous transplantation is preferred as a transplantation site, because it is convenient to perform. However, transplantation sites are not particularly limited, and an appropriate transplantation site is preferably selected depending on the animal to be used. Meanwhile, the techniques for transplanting an NOG-established cancer cell line are not particularly limited; it is possible to use conventional transplantation techniques.
After transplantation, the model animals of the present invention may be reared under conventional or sterile conditions, if needed. The rearing conditions are not limited, but specifically include, for example, the conditions of: temperature of 20 to 26° C., humidity of 30 to 70%; feed and water: free intake; light cycle: a 12-hour light-dark cycle.
The period of animal rearing is not particularly limited; in the case of mice, nude mice, rats, or nude rats, it is preferable to rear the animals for three or more days, preferably 28 or more days after transplantation.
By rearing the transplanted animals for a certain period, the transplanted NOG-established cancer cell line grows and differentiates into tissues having the histological features of human tumor tissues at the transplantation site. As described above, the animal models of the present invention have tissues with features of human tumor tissues, and therefore can serve as animal models for human cancer pathology.
The cells are cultured by a culture method using an appropriate medium (D-MEM, MEM, RPMI1640, BME, D-MEM/F12, G-MEM, etc.) supplemented with appropriate additives (inactivated Fetal Bovine Serum, Penicillin, Streptomycin, Glucose, Sodium Hydrogen Carbonate, HEPES, L-Glutamine, Heparin, BSA, FGF, EGF, Transferrin, Insulin, Putrescin, Selenite, Progesterone, etc.) under conditions suitable for mammalian cell culture (for example, at 37° C. under 5% CO2).
When the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells observed in the model animals, or in the in vitro culture system of NOG-established cancer cell lines of the present invention, is used as an indicator for assessment, the model or in vitro culture system of the present invention can be applied to search for anti-cancer agent targets, screen for anti-cancer agents, or screen to assess pharmaceutical agents for treating or preventing human cancer.
The present invention relates to methods of searching for anti-cancer agent targets, which carry out an assessment, using as an indicator, the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of the cancer cells in a non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line or an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line.
In the methods of the present invention, when a non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the search for anti-cancer agent targets can be carried out via steps (1) to (4) described below:
Alternatively, in the methods of the present invention, when the in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the search for targets for anti-cancer agents can be carried out via steps (1) to (3) described below:
In the present invention, the structure of a tissue or cell line characteristic of a cancer progression process can be morphologically observed by HE staining and immunohistochemistry (IHC) of thin sections of tissue samples prepared by the AMeX method or the like. When the above-described hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property specific to a human tumor tissue is detected in a test tissue, the tissue is judged as a cancer-related tissue and is tested for the expression of DNAs, RNAs, or proteins. In the present invention, RNAs include, but are not limited to, mRNA and micro-RNA. Methods for testing the expression of a DNA, RNA, or protein are not particularly limited; testing can be done by conventional methods for assessing expression. For example, mRNA for each gene is extracted by conventional methods. The transcriptional level of each gene can be determined by Northern hybridization or RT-PCR using the mRNA as a template. Alternatively, the expression level of each gene can be measured using DNA array techniques. Furthermore, fractions containing the protein encoded by each gene may be collected by conventional methods. The expression of each protein can be detected by electrophoresis such as SDS-PAGE to determine the translational level of the gene. Alternatively, the expression of each protein can be detected by Western blotting using an antibody against the protein to determine the translational level of the gene.
The present invention relates to methods of screening for anti-cancer agents, which carry out assessment, using as an indicator, the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells in a non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line or an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line.
In the methods of the present invention, when a non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the screening for anti-cancer agents can be carried out via steps (1) to (5) described below:
In another embodiment, when the non-human animal model transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the screening for anti-cancer agents can be carried out via steps (1) to (5) described below:
Alternatively, in the methods of the present invention, when the in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the screening for anti-cancer agents can be carried out via steps (1) to (4) described below:
In another embodiment, when the in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line is used, the screening for anti-cancer agents can be carried out via steps (1) to (4) described below:
The “test substances” in the methods of the present invention are not particularly limited, and include, for example, single compounds such as natural compounds, organic compounds, inorganic compounds, proteins, peptides, and amino acids; as well as compound libraries, expression products of gene libraries, cell extracts, cell culture supernatants, products of fermentation microorganisms, marine organism extracts, plant extracts, prokaryotic cell extracts, unicellular eukaryote extracts, and animal cell extracts. These may be purified substances or crude substances such as extracts of plants, animals, or microorganisms. The methods for producing test substances are also not particularly limited; the substances may be isolated from natural materials, synthesized chemically or biochemically, or prepared by genetic engineering.
If needed, the above test samples can be used after appropriately labeling. Labels include, for example, radiolabels and fluorescent labels. The test samples include not only those described above, but also mixtures of several types of such test samples.
In the present invention, methods for administering a test substance to non-human model animals are not particularly limited. It is possible to appropriately select oral administration or parenteral administration such as subcutaneous, intravenous, local, transdermal, or enteral (rectal) administration depending on the type of test substance to be administered.
In the methods of the present invention, methods for treating cultured an NOG-established cancer cell line with a test substance are not particularly limited. Such a treatment can be carried out by adding a test sample to a cell culture medium or cell extract. When the test sample is a protein, the treatment can be carried out, for example, by introducing a vector carrying a DNA encoding the protein into an NOG-established cancer cell line or adding the vector to a cell extract of an NOG-established cancer cell line. Alternatively, it is possible to use, for example, a two hybrid method using yeast, animal cells, or the like.
After treatment, the test substance can be assessed by excising the transplanted tissue (tissues transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line) from the model animal and observing histological features of the transplanted tissue or by studying the histological features using a cell culture system.
Specifically, the test substance can be assessed by observing the hierarchical organization of the transplanted tissue or cancer cells in a culture system in a non-human animal model or an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line, to assess the characteristic of hierarchical organization formation unique to human cancer cells or to confirm an effect on the cancer progression process characteristic of a human cancer. The structure of tissue or cell line characteristic of the cancer progression process can be morphologically observed by HE staining and immunohistochemistry (IHC) of thin sections of tissue samples prepared by the AMeX method or the like.
More specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can be carried out by the following procedure:
control non-human model animals or an NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance; in the same manner as described above, the hierarchical organization of the transplanted tissue or cancer cells in a culture system are observed and the formation of the hierarchical organization unique to human cancer cells is checked; and the hierarchical organization of cancer cells is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the hierarchical organization unique to human cancer cell is not observed in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animals, or when the level of hierarchy is reduced, the test substance can be selected as an effective substance having a therapeutic or preventive effect against a human cancer.
More specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can also be carried out by the following procedure:
control non-human model animals or the NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance, and in the same manner, the cancer progression process of the transplanted tissue or cancer cells in a culture system are observed and presence of a cancer progression process unique to human cancer cells is checked; and the cancer progression process of cancer stem cell is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the cancer progression process unique to human cancer cells is not seen in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animals, the test substance can be selected as an effective substance having a therapeutic or preventive effect against a human cancer.
In addition, more specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can be carried out by the following procedure:
control non-human model animals or the NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance, and in the same manner, biological properties of cancer stem cells of the transplanted tissues or cancer cells in the culture system are observed and the presence of the properties unique to human cancer cells is checked; and the properties of cancer stem cells is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the property unique to human cancer cells is not present in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animal, the test substance can be selected as an effective substance having a therapeutic or preventive effect against a human cancer.
Substances effective for preventing or treating a human cancer, which are selected by the above-described screening methods, may be further assessed by other drug efficacy tests or safety tests, if needed, and/or by clinical tests with human cancer patients to select more effective therapeutic or preventive substances with a higher practical use.
Furthermore, such effective therapeutic or preventive substances selected can also be industrially produced by chemical synthesis or biochemical synthesis (fermentation), or using genetic manipulation based on the result of structural analyses thereof.
The present invention relates to screening methods for assessing pharmaceutical agents for treating or preventing human cancer, which carry out assessment using as an indicator the hierarchical organization or cancer progression process of the cancer cells in non-human model animals transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line.
When non-human model animals transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line are used in the methods of the present invention, pharmaceutical agents can be assessed via steps (1) to (5) described below:
Alternatively, when an in vitro culture system of NOG-established cancer cell lines is used in the methods of the present invention, pharmaceutical agents can be assessed via steps (1) to (4) described below:
In the present invention, pharmaceutical agents can be assessed by administering a test substance of interest to an above-described non-human model animal or treating an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer cell line with a test substance of interest, and testing whether administration of the test substance produces a preventive or ameliorating effect on the transplanted tissues (tissues transplanted with the NOG-established cancer cell line) or the culture system.
Specifically, the preventive or ameliorating effect of an administered test substance on the transplanted tissue or the culture system can be assessed by identifying or observing the morphology of hierarchical organization, the cancer progression process, or biological properties of cancer cells. The assessment can be carried out by observing the hierarchical organization of the transplanted tissues in the non-human animal model or of the cancer cells in an in vitro culture system of an NOG-established cancer line to verify the formation of the hierarchical organization characteristic of human cancer cells or an effect on the cancer progression process characteristic of a human cancer.
More specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can be carried out by the following procedure: control non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance, and in the same manner as described above, the transplanted tissues or cancer cells in the culture system are observed for the hierarchical organization of cancer cells and checked for the formation of the hierarchical organization unique to human cancer cell; and the hierarchical organization of cancer cells is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the hierarchical organization unique to human cancer cell is not observed in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animals, or when the level of hierarchy is reduced, the test substance administered to the test animal or with which the culture system is treated can be judged to have the preventive or therapeutic effect against the human cancer, and the level of the preventive or therapeutic effect can be evaluated based on the level of reduction.
Alternatively and more specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can be carried out by the following procedure:
control non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance, and in the same manner, the transplanted tissues or cancer cells in the culture system are observed for their cancer progression process and checked for the presence of a cancer progression process unique to human cancer cells; and the cancer progression process unique to cancer stem cells is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the cancer progression process unique to human cancer cells is not present in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animals, the test substance administered to the test animal or with which the culture system is treated can be judged to have a preventive or therapeutic effect against the human cancer, and the level of the preventive or therapeutic effect can be evaluated based on the level of advancement in the cancer progression process.
More specifically, the above-described assessment of a test substance can also be carried out by the following procedure:
control non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell line are prepared without administering the test substance, and in the same manner, the transplanted tissues or cancer cells in a culture system are observed for the biological properties of cancer stem cells and checked for the presence of a property unique to human cancer cells; and the property unique to cancer stem cells is compared between the control animals and non-human model animals or NOG-established cancer cell lines administered with the test substance. In this case, when the property unique to human cancer cells is not present in the non-human animal model or NOG-established cancer cell line administered with the test substance as compared to the control animals, the test substance administered to the test animal or with which the culture system is treated can be judged to have a preventive or therapeutic effect against the human cancer, and the level of the preventive or therapeutic effect can be evaluated based on the incidence of the properties.
The present invention relates to methods of using a non-human animal transplanted with an NOG-established cancer cell line or an NOG-established cancer cell line as a cancer model animal or cell line which mimics the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells.
The hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells can be artificially or artifactually mimicked in vivo by transplanting an NOG-established cancer cell line into non-human animals. Thus, such non-human animals transplanted with the NOG-established cancer cell line can serve as very useful cancer model animals, for example, when assessing pharmaceutical agents, searching for candidate target molecules as pharmaceuticals or diagnostic agents, or assessing compounds or biological preparations that act on the candidate molecules using the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells.
Furthermore, the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells can be artificially or artifactually mimicked in vivo or in vitro by an NOG-established cancer cell line alone. Thus, the NOG-established cancer cell lines can serve as very useful cancer model animals, for example, when assessing pharmaceutical agents, searching for candidate target molecules as pharmaceutical agents or diagnostic agents, or assessing compounds or biological preparations that act on the candidate molecules using the hierarchical organization, cancer progression process, or biological property of cancer cells.
“Mimic” means that the model mimics to a level enough to achieve the objective depending on the model's purpose of use. Thus, it is not necessary to mimic the in vivo events perfectly.
All prior art documents cited herein are incorporated herein by reference.
Hereinbelow, the present invention will be described more specifically with reference to the Examples, but it is not limited thereto.
The present inventors used NOG-established cancer cell lines that had been established so as to meet the criterion that human colon cancer, stomach cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer, or pancreatic cancer can be transplanted or passaged over three or more generations in NOG mice (Fujii E. et al., Pathol Int. 2008; 58: 559-567). In this Example, NOG-established cancer cell lines were subcutaneously transplanted into NOG mice. 28 days after transplantation, the mice were dissected, and the implants were excised and fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde at 4° C. for 16 to 24 hours. Then, the fixed samples were embedded and sliced into thin section samples by the AMeX method (Fujii E. et al., Pathol Int. 2008; 58: 559-567). The tissues were stained by HE and immunohistochemistry (IHC). Anti-E-cadherin antibody (DakoCytomation) and anti-fibronectin antibody (DakoCytomation) were used as a primary antibody. The visualization was carried out by LSAB method using DAB (DAB Map kit, Roche Diagnostics).
In addition, for in vitro culture, cell masses collected from mice were minced physically with scissors. Next, Collagenase/Dispase (Roche, Cat. No. 10 269 638 001) and DNaseI (Roche, Cat. No. 11 284 932 001) were added, and the cells were stirred at 37° C. for 30 minutes. Then, pipetting was repeated to prepare minced cells. The prepared cells were suspended in Cell Banker 1 (JUJI FIELD, Cat. No. BLC-1) and stored at −80° C. or below.
The cells prepared as described above were cultured in Medium 1 (RPMI1640, 10% Fetal Bovine Serum, Penicillin, Streptomycin) supplemented with Fetal Bovine Serum that had been inactivated by incubating at 56° C. for 30 minutes or more.
Spheroid preparation was carried out by suspending cells at 4×105 cells/ml in Medium 1 and plating 5 ml of the cells in 6-cm Hydro cell Dish (NUNC, Cat. No. 174912). After 3 to 6 days of incubation, spheroid formation was verified under a microscope. Following spheroid formation, the spheroid cells alone were collected by filtering all cells with 40-μm cell strainer (BD, Cat. No. 352340) and cultured in Medium 1.
As for a culture system to mimic the glandular structure, a stock solution of Matrigel Basement Membrane Matrix (BD, Cat. No. 354234) was added at 50 μl/well to 96-well plates. For coating, the 96-well plates were allowed to stand at 37° C. for 5 minutes. Next, the spheroid cells were added at 50 μl/well. Then, Matrigel Basement Membrane Matrix diluted to 20% with Medium 1 was added at 50 μl/well, and the plates were allowed to stand at 37° C. for 5 minutes. Finally, Medium 1 was added at 100 μl/well, and the cells were cultured until the glandular structure appeared.
The epithelium-like glandular area of human colon cancer tissue has been reported to be characteristic in that the cells express E-cadherin on their whole surface (Kirchner T. et al., Am J. Pathol. 2000; 157: 1113-1121). This characteristic was also observed in the NOG-established cancer cell line (
Meanwhile, the invasive area having the nature of mesenchymal cells, which are less differentiated, is known to exhibit characteristic morphologies such as budding, cluster of tumor cells, dissociated single tumor cells, and reconstruction of tubules. Cells in the invasive area have been said to undergo partial-EMT leading to a partial loss of the epithelial nature. It is known that the cells lack E-cadherin expression at their contact surface with the stroma and express fibronectin which is normally not expressed on epithelium-like cells (Kirchner T. et al., Am J. Pathol. 2000; 157: 1113-1121). In the present invention, these features were mimicked in the tumor that resulted from transplantation of an NOG-established colon cancer cell line (
Similar epithelium-like areas and invasive areas were also observed in stomach cancer, lung cancer, breast cancer, and pancreatic cancer (
The above-described results demonstrate that NOG-established cancer cell lines mimic the hierarchical organization of human cancer tissues.
Each NOG-established cancer cell line whose tissue morphology was (1) well-differentiated adenocarcinoma, (2) moderately-differentiated adenocarcinoma, or (3) poorly-differentiated adenocarcinoma in the donors' human colon cancer were subcutaneously transplanted into NOG mice. The mice were dissected 3, 7, 14, 17, or 21 days after transplantation, and HE staining and IHC were carried out in the same manner as described above to morphologically determine the ratio between the epithelium-like area and invasive area.
Furthermore, with respect to stomach cancer, colon cancer, and lung cancer, HE-stained samples from donors' cancer tissues and NOG-established cancer cell lines were observed to verify whether they repeatedly mimic the tissue organization.
The present invention demonstrated that:
in the unique cancer progression process leading to the formation of the hierarchical organization equivalent to the donors' human colon cancer tissues, the major process was an epithelium-like proliferation process (epithelial duct forming pattern) in the case of well-differentiated adenocarcinoma; the major process was an invasive proliferation process (invasive EMT pattern), while including an epithelium-like proliferation process (epithelial duct forming pattern) in the case of moderately-differentiated adenocarcinoma; and the major process was an invasive proliferation process (invasive EMT pattern) in the case of poorly-differentiated adenocarcinoma.
Furthermore, the hierarchical differentiation unique to each line can be repeatedly mimicked even after several transplant passages (
aDays after inoculation
bβ-catenin nuclear accumulation are detected in the IHC sections.
Cancer stem cells are known to be slow-cycling cells whose cell turnover is in general very slow (Li L, Neaves W B. Cancer res. 2006; 66: 4553-4557). The present inventors focused on this nature and started continuous labeling of BrdU, which is incorporated at the mitotic phase, at the same time when an NOG-established cancer cell line was subcutaneously transplanted into NOG mice. After 14 days of labeling, the mice were dissected to process the tissues. HE staining was performed in the same manner as described above to observe the morphologies of the tissues. In addition, BrdU-incorporated cells were detected by IHC staining (antibody, Beckton Dickinson), and IHC staining was carried out using an antibody against Ki67 (DakoCytomation) as a mitotic phase marker to identify proliferative cells and slow-cycling cells. Moreover, samples adjacent to those described above were stained by IHC using an antibody (MBL) against Lgr5 that is known as a cancer stem cell marker (McDonald S A C, et al., Virchows Arch. (2009) 455: 1-13).
Tissues treated by continuous BrdU labeling showed that both epithelium-like growth area and invasive growth area contained some non-labeled cells. The cells were negative for Ki67. The findings described above suggest that both areas include slow-cycling cells whose cell turnover is very slow, which is known to be a characteristic of cancer stem cells. When samples adjacent to the above samples were stained for Lgr5, which is a cancer stem cell marker, the stained images were consistent with the localization of the slow-cycling cells (
The existence of stationary stem cells, which are localized in the epithelium-like growth area, and migrating stem cells, which contribute to the formation of hierarchical organization at metastatic sites, has previously been predicted based on observations of human colon cancer. However, the present experiments demonstrated the existence of stem cells described above, as shown in
In addition, as described in Example 2, the NOG-established cancer cell lines faithfully mimicked the final destination of differentiation in each donor's human cancer tissue. This was always mimicked even after several passages. Thus, it was proven that the cancer stem cells present in the tissues determined the respective final destinations of differentiation. The findings described above show that the models of the present invention are suitable to assess the biological properties unique to cancer stem cells.
Continuous IdU labeling was started at the same time when an NOG-established cancer cell line was subcutaneously transplanted into NOG mice. After 28 days of labeling, the mice were dissected to prepare an IdU-labeled transplanted cell line for the next generation. Continuous BrdU labeling was started at the same time when the cell line was transplanted for the next generation. The mice were dissected three days after transplantation and the tissue treatment was performed. The resulting serial tissue sections were stained by IHC using an antibody recognizing both IdU and BrdU (Beckton Dickinson) and an antibody recognizing BrdU alone (Serotec) in order to detect transitions of proliferative cells and slow-cycling cells over the generations.
As shown in
The above-described phenomenon that cells which had once undergone differential proliferation undergo transition into stem cells has been regarded as a biological property of cancer stem cells, which is called plasticity (Gupta P B. et al., Nature med. (2009) 15: 1010-12). Thus, the findings described above show that the models of the present invention are suitable to assess the plasticity that is a biological property of cancer stem cells.
Recent years have shown that P53 protein is involved in the transition of somatic cells into stem cells by reprogramming, because, when producing so-called induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells, the production efficiency is drastically increased by reducing the expression level of the P53 protein. Furthermore, this mechanism has been reported to play an important part in cancer stem cells (Krizhanovsky V and Lowe S W, Nature 2009; 460: 1085-6).
In this context, to test whether cancer stem cells found among an NOG-established cancer cell line are consistent with cells expressing low levels of P53, the present inventors subcutaneously transplanted established cell lines into NOG mice treated by continuous BrdU labeling. The mice were dissected 28 days after transplantation and tissue processing was performed. The resulting serial tissue sections were visualized by IHC staining using an antibody against P53 (DakoCytomation) and an antibody against BrdU (Beckton Dickinson). The sections were observed to assess the consistency.
P53 has been reported to be overexpressed in many cancers (Toledo F and Wahl G M., Nature rev cancer (2006) δ: 909-923). The present invention also revealed that the protein was overexpressed in many NOG-established cancer cells. Meanwhile, loss or reduced expression of P53 was consistent with BrdU-negative or weakly positive cells (
In recent years, as a biological property of stem cells including cancer stem cells, the reduced expression of P53 protein has been demonstrated to play an important role in so-called reprogramming which results in acquisition of pluripotency by somatic cells. Accordingly, the finding that the expression level of P53 protein is also reduced in the cancer stem cells of the models of the present invention suggests that a reprogramming mechanism similar to stem cells works in these cancer stem cells. Thus, the models of the present invention were demonstrated to be suitable to assess their biological properties.
NOG-established cancer cell lines were subcutaneously transplanted into NOG mice. The animals were dissected 14 days after transplantation to obtain tumor masses. By IHC staining specific to human β2 microglobulin, the tumor masses were assessed for species origin.
In addition, before in vitro culture, cells to be plated were tested for the species origin by flow cytometry using Anti-Human HLA-ABC Antigen/RPE antibody (DAKO, Cat. No. R7000; human specific) and Anti-mMuse MHC class I antibody (Abcam, Cat. No. ab15680-50; mouse specific). Then, the cells were cultured in Medium 1 to monitor the emergence of fibroblast-like cells.
Human-derived fibroblasts were observed in the tumor stroma (
Furthermore, cells which had been confirmed to include about 90% of human cells before culture were cultured in Medium 1 used in Example 1. The emergence of fibroblasts was detected (
Well-differentiated adenocarcinoma and moderately-differentiated adenocarcinoma were each transplanted into three heads of NOG mice, and 5-fluorouracil (5-FU, Mayne Pharma) was administered at 100 mg/kg into the peritoneal cavities 7, 10, and 14 days after transplantation, a total of three times. On the day following the final administration (15 days after transplantation), the tumor masses were harvested and processed by the same method as described above to prepare HE-stained samples. The samples were histopathologically compared with samples prepared from a control group (3 cases) administered with the vehicle alone.
As shown in Table 2 and
As described above, since characteristic groups of cells and tissue structures were demonstrated to be resistant to anti-cancer agents, the models of the present invention are expected to be applicable to assess the process of selecting them, the process of acquiring the resistance as a result of a long-term drug treatment, the process of recurrence after treatment with anti-cancer agents, etc. Thus, the present invention demonstrated that the models of the present invention enables search for factors involved in the above-described processes and search/screening for pharmaceutical agents that target an above-described factor.
aC, Control; F, 5FU administration
The present invention's non-human animal models and culture systems with NOG-established cancer cell lines can be considered as models that reflect more closely the pathology of human cancer patients, because they maintain the hierarchical organization of cancer cells unique to human cancer patients, exhibit the cancer progression process, and faithfully mimic the biological properties thereof. Thus, the present invention's non-human animal models and culture systems with NOG-established cancer cell lines can be effectively used to screen for agents that produce a preventive or therapeutic effect against human cancer or to assess the drug efficacy of the agents. Accordingly, the present invention can contribute to the development of pharmaceutical agents for preventing or treating human cancer.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2009-295426 | Dec 2009 | JP | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/JP2010/073266 | 12/24/2010 | WO | 00 | 10/5/2012 |
