This application is the U.S. National Stage of International Application No. PCT/EP2008/053139, filed Mar. 17, 2008, which designated the United States and has been published as International Publication No. WO 2008/116769 and which claims the priority of German Patent Application, Serial No. 10 2007 014 728.9, filed Mar. 24, 2007, pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 119(a)-(d).
The present invention concerns a method of and an apparatus for operating a double-fed asynchronous machine on a mains network upon transient mains voltage changes.
The double-fed asynchronous machine is preferably used in variable-speed systems, for example in high-efficiency wind power installations, as a wave generator or in conjunction with inertia mass storage devices and uninterruptable power supplies. In general the stator of the asynchronous machine is connected to the mains network and the rotor is connected to an inverter by way of slip rings. With such an inverter a target or reference value of an electrical parameter can be impressed on the rotor. The term inverter is to be interpreted broadly. In general in modern installations there is an inverter at the machine side and an inverter at the mains network side, which are connected together by way of an intermediate circuit. Besides voltage and current intermediate circuits, direct inverters are also possible, which manage without an intermediate circuit. Feed for the machine-side inverter is also possible by a dc voltage source or a dc source. The electrical parameter which is impressed on the rotor can be for example a voltage or a current. In general nowadays four-quadrant inverters with IGBTs are used. However other semiconductor switches such as GTOs and thyristors are also possible.
The advantage of the double-fed asynchronous machine over comparable systems lies in the reduced nominal load capacity of the inverter, in relation to the total power which can be fed into the mains network. As a result a system with a double-fed asynchronous machine enjoys comparatively good efficiency.
The amplitude and frequency of the rotor voltage are proportional to the slip of the machine. The slip is defined as the deviation of the mechanical rotary speed from the synchronous rotary speed with respect to the synchronous rotary speed. Typical speed ranges for the double-fed asynchronous machine are between 70% and 130% of the synchronous speed. In that working range in respect of rotary speed the required maximum rotor voltage is considerably lower than when the machine is stationary. The amplitude of the rotor voltage in the stopped condition is more than three times as great as with 30% slip. The absolute value of amplitude depends on the transformation ratio of the machine. The frequency of the induced rotor voltage in the stopped condition is equal to the mains frequency. In the typical speed range the frequency is at a maximum 30% of the mains frequency. The inverter is normally so designed that it can supply at a maximum the required voltage in the defined speed range.
In the course of the increasing number of wind power installations and the demands which are linked thereto and which are becoming ever higher, in respect of the mains network operators, the performance of the double-fed asynchronous machine is of increasing interest, in the case of transient changes in the mains voltage. In that respect transient changes are time-limited deviations in respect of the mains voltage from the steady-state value or from the nominal value. That can be both drops in voltage and also increases in voltage. In general these are called voltage jumps or transient voltage jumps. Drops in voltage can occur in that case for example due to short-circuits in the mains network. In that respect drops in voltage can in the extreme case occur down to 0%. Increases in voltage can occur with a non-compensated reactive power balance in the network, for example when large inductive loads are switched off.
In the case of a double-fed asynchronous machine the stator of the machine is connected directly to the mains network so that, upon a transient change in mains voltage, the stator voltage behaves in a corresponding fashion. The flux vector of the machine rotates in the steady-state condition with the mains frequency. In the case of a transient voltage change that involves a component of the magnetic flux, which is stationary relative to the stator and decreases again only after a number of mains periods. That stationary flux component, also referred to as a direct or steady component of the flux, is proportional to the change in the mains voltage vector. The direct or steady component of the flux induces in the rotor winding a considerably higher voltage than in the steady-state mains network mode of operation with a defined speed range. The inverter however is generally only designed for such a steady-state mains network mode of operation and is therefore not in a position to supply a corresponding counter-voltage. The consequence of this is that the response characteristic on the part of the double-fed system upon voltage jumps exhibits short circuit-like currents in the stator and in the rotor as well as a corresponding air gap torque. The simplest technical solution for an optimum response behavior on the part of the double-fed asynchronous machine would be to design the inverter for a rotor voltage which is necessary for compensation of a maximum mains voltage jump. It will be noted however that that would almost be equal to an inverter nominal load capacity corresponding to the total power of the system. That however nullifies the essential advantage of the double-fed system, namely the comparatively low nominal load capacity of the inverter.
Generally a so-called crowbar is used to protect the inverter of a double-fed asynchronous machine. That is a protective circuit with thyristors, by which the rotor can be short-circuited. The tripping criterion for the crowbar can be the fact of exceeding an admissible rotor current, an admissible intermediate circuit current or an admissible intermediate circuit voltage. As already explained a transient mains voltage change can lead to inadmissibly high rotor currents. Correspondingly the voltage induced in the rotor in the case of transient mains voltage changes can also lead to a feed of energy into the intermediate circuit and thus an increase in the intermediate circuit voltage or the intermediate circuit current. The crowbar admittedly protects the inverter from damage to the intermediate circuit, but the use thereof has serious disadvantages in regard to the overall performance of the double-fed asynchronous machine:
A normal mode of operation, controlled by the inverter, of the double-fed asynchronous machine, for example with regulation of the active and reactive power delivery to a fixed value or regulation on the basis of other parameters, is no longer possible during activation of the crowbar. With the rotor short-circuited the machine acts like an asynchronous machine with a squirrel-cage rotor winding, that is to say the machine receives inductive reactive power from the mains network in dependence on the rotary speed and takes active power from the mains network or delivers same. If in the course of a transient mains voltage change the crowbar is activated then generally at least 100 ms elapses after the end of the change in voltage before a defined mode of operation, for example with active and reactive power regulation, is possible again. That means that the requirements of the mains network operators, for also actively regulating active and reactive power in the case of transient voltage changes, cannot be met. There may also be a requirement that, instead of active and reactive power, other corresponding parameters such as mains voltage, power factor, moment or apparent power are to be regulated.
As already mentioned, the short-circuit-like currents in the case of transient mains voltage changes lead to a corresponding air gap torque. Such a torque loads the drive train and the transmission. The torque acting on the drive train and the transmission is further increased by the use of the crowbar. It is not just the amount of the torque that is critical in that case, but also the alternating components which occur in respect of the torque and which occur to a particular degree in the case of asymmetrical mains network faults. Such torque loadings in the normal case admittedly do not lead to direct damage, but with a corresponding frequency thereof the service life of the transmission and other components of the drive train can be considerably reduced.
WO 2004/030199 describes an apparatus for the continuous feed of energy into the mains network with a double-fed asynchronous machine in the event of abrupt mains voltage changes. The apparatus includes an electronic switch in the stator circuit, by which the stator is temporarily separated from the mains network upon voltage changes. That apparatus suffers from the disadvantage that the machine has to be synchronized with the mains network again.
The publication by A Causebrook, D J Atkinson and A G Jack ‘Fault Ride-Through: Shifting the Balance of Power from Blade Pitch to Electrical Resistance’, Athens, EWEC 27.02.-02.03.2006, discloses an arrangement having an electronic switch and a parallel resistor. In that arrangement in the case of a mains fault the resistor is connected into the mains network path and thus permits electrical energy to be conducted out of the machine. Such an arrangement is really good in limiting the current and torque peaks occurring immediately after the fault occurs. To ensure decay of the time alternating components of current and torque however quite long switch-on times are required for the resistor. The required switch-on times for realistically designed resistors are markedly above 20 ms. That is the time after which energy supply companies require regulated operation with the delivery of defined active and reactive power. With longer switch-on times for the resistor it can further happen that not only active power is taken from the machine, as is desired, but also from the mains network. The latter is even prohibited in some mains connection guidelines.
Besides circuitry solutions, considerations relating to the regulating methods for a double-fed asynchronous machine in relation to performance in the case of transient mains voltage changes are also to be found in the state of the art, thus also in the document by Jorun I Marvik, Torstein Bjorgum, Bjarne I Naess, Tore M Undeland and Terje Gjengedal ‘Control of a Wind Turbine with a Doubly Fed Induction Generator after Transient Failures’, NOEPIE 14.-16.02.2004. Here the performance of a reactive power regulator and a flux regulator are compared together.
WO 2006/030183 discloses a stator voltage and stator power regulation with a subordinated rotor flux regulation for the regulation of the double-fed asynchronous machine in the case of steady-state mains voltage and additional auxiliary regulators for optimizing the performance in the case of transient mains voltage changes.
It is to be seen from the aforementioned state of the art that flux regulation of an electric machine or a double-fed asynchronous machine is known both in the steady-state and also in the transient condition. In that case the reference or target value is generated for the flux to be regulated from a superordinated regulator or is set to a constant value or—in the case of a transient mains voltage change—to a quasi-steady-state value.
An object of the present invention is to reduce the mechanical loading of the drive train in the case of transient mains voltage changes in operation of a double-fed asynchronous machine on a mains network in which various kinds of transient mains voltage changes occur.
To attain that object, there is proposed a method of operating a double-fed asynchronous machine upon transient mains voltage changes, in which the stator is connected to the mains network and the rotor is connected to an inverter, and in which the inverter is adapted to impress a reference value of an electrical parameter on the rotor, in which immediately after detection of a transient mains voltage change a reference value of the electrical parameter, that is determined at least from the rotor flux and the stator flux, is impressed on the rotor in such a way that an active reduction in the torque occurring during the transient mains voltage change is achieved. In accordance with the invention a defined operation in the respective normal regulation mode, for example with active and reactive power regulation, is already made possible again quickly after a mains voltage change.
In accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention after detection of a transient mains voltage change the reference value of the electrical parameter, that is determined at least from the rotor flux and the stator flux, is impressed on the rotor in such a way that in addition an active reduction in the rotor current occurring during the transient mains voltage change is achieved. It is thus possible to ensure an equally optimum performance in respect of the magnitude of the rotor current and the torque.
In particular, in accordance with an embodiment of the invention, a reduction in rotor current and torque, which is equally optimum for all kinds of mains faults, is achieved by suitable weighting for example of the stator flux vector and the rotor flux vector (for example in a ratio of 40% to 60%). That is effected on the boundary condition that the available control parameter (for example rotor voltage) is limited.
The method according to the invention is independent of regulation of the double-fed asynchronous machine in the steady-state mode of operation. In the steady-state mode of operation there is generally a requirement for regulation of the active and reactive power to be received or delivered. Alternatively regulation can also be demanded in respect of other corresponding parameters such as mains voltage, power factor, moment or apparent power. Known methods can be used for that purpose. It is only after the detection of a transient mains voltage change that the situation is switched over to the method according to the invention.
The short-circuit-like currents and the corresponding torque which generally occur with transient mains voltage changes can thus be reduced in the shortest possible time and regulation can be changed over again to active and reactive power regulation or to another steady-state regulation strategy.
The regulation according to the invention is activated only for a short time after detection of a transient mains voltage change and otherwise a standard regulation method, for example for regulation of active and reactive power, is used. In an advantageous configuration of the invention the reference value of the electrical parameter which is to be impressed in the rotor to provide for optimum control of the rotor flux in the case of a mains network fault is already continuously calculated in the steady-state mode of operation. That can avoid a relatively great time delay which occurs if the electrical parameter is determined only after detection of a transient mains voltage change.
There are still further machine parameters, the product of which is proportional to the torque and which can consequently be used instead of rotor flux and stator flux: it is for example possible, and embraced by the invention, to use a respective one of the space vectors for rotor current, rotor flux, stator current or stator flux with suitable weighting for determining the rotor reference value, just like the stator voltage vector in conjunction with the rotor current or rotor flux vector.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the invention the electrical parameter which is impressed on the rotor is the rotor voltage. The most common inverter topology suitable for that purpose, for a double-fed asynchronous machine, is the four-quadrant inverter with IGBTs and a dc voltage intermediate circuit. With other inverter topologies, it may be appropriate to select the rotor current as the electrical parameter which is impressed in the rotor.
In accordance with a further preferred embodiment of the present invention the reference value of the rotor voltage vector which is impressed in the rotor is ascertained from at least one component of the difference vector from the vector of the rotor flux and from the vector of the stator flux.
In accordance with a further preferred embodiment of the present invention the reference value of the rotor voltage vector is proportional to the difference vector from the rotor flux vector and the stator flux vector.
In accordance with a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, because of the natural limit on the magnitude of the rotor voltage, weighting is effected to the benefit of the component of the difference vector from rotor flux vector and stator flux vector which is perpendicular to the stator flux vector.
In accordance with a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, for the same reason weighting is effected to the benefit of the component of the difference vector from the rotor flux vector and the stator flux vector which is parallel to the stator flux vector.
An inverter with IGBTs or other semiconductor switches can only switch discrete states. A three-phase bridge circuit can assume eight discrete states. In the rotary vector modulation method various discrete states are assumed during a sampling period for a respective given time, more specifically in such a way that the mean value of the rotary vector corresponds to the reference value as well as possible. It is thus possible to generate continuous voltage values. In the case of a transient mains voltage change the inverter must deliver a counter-voltage that is as high as possible, in relation to the voltage induced by the stator flux in the rotor winding. In accordance with a further preferred embodiment of the present invention therefore during a sampling period only one discrete switching state of the inverter is switched, that switching state being selected whose phase position is closest to the phase position of the reference value of the rotor voltage. In that way the maximum possible amount of voltage with the inverter is impressed into the rotor. The fault which occurs in that case in the phase position of the voltage can be disregarded in this context as the angular deviations from the reference vector statistically balance out over time.
The rotor flux and the stator flux are not parameters which can be directly measured and are therefore calculated by means of an observer. In that case, in accordance with a suitable model, the instantaneous time values of the stator and rotor flux vectors can be calculated just like the quasi-steady-state vectors. The latter denote the stator flux and rotor flux vectors if the instantaneous value of the stator voltage were to persist so long that all compensation processes have died away. In accordance with a further embodiment of the present invention the transient rotor flux and the quasi-steady-state stator flux are used for determining the reference value of the rotor voltage. The use of the transient stator flux requires a higher level of computing expenditure and involvement but also gives more accurate results. In accordance with another embodiment therefore the transient rotor flux and the transient stator flux are used to determine the reference value of the rotor voltage.
The observer for determining the rotor and stator flux calculates the parameters which are not directly measurable, from directly measurable parameters. In accordance with a preferred embodiment the rotor flux and the stator flux are calculated from at least one respective one of the measured parameters of stator voltage, stator current and rotor current. Depending on the respective kind of the model used a measured parameter is sufficient, as for example in the case of the quasi-steady-state stator flux. With more accurate models two or all the stated measurement parameters may also be required.
When hereinbefore the stator voltage, stator current and rotor current but not the rotor voltage are mentioned as available measurement parameters, that involves the implementation of the invention in the case of a double-fed asynchronous machine, in which the rotor voltage is controlled at the inverter side, for which reason the rotor voltage in that case represents a control parameter and is therefore generally not available as a measurement parameter. With alternative control systems—for example with a rotor current control—it is however also possible to take account of the rotor voltage as a measurement parameter.
Furthermore, to attain the stated object, there is proposed an apparatus which has an inverter and at least one control unit and in which the control unit has means by which a reference value of the electrical parameter is determined from the rotor flux and the stator flux in such a way that an active reduction in the torque occurring during the transient mains voltage change is achieved, wherein after detection of a transient mains voltage change the reference value of the electrical parameter is impressed into the rotor.
With the apparatus according to the invention the inverter can be operated with only one control unit. It is however also possible to use separate control units for a machine-side inverter and a mains network-side inverter. Each control unit can have one or more microcontrollers or microprocessors. The control unit further has suitable output interfaces for transfer of the actuation signal to the inverter.
In an embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the electrical parameter which is impressed into the rotor is the rotor voltage.
In accordance with an embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the means determine the reference value of the rotor voltage vector from at least one component of the difference vector from the vector of the rotor flux and the vector of the stator flux.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the reference value of the rotor voltage vector is proportional to the difference vector from the rotor flux vector and the stator flux vector.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the reference value of the rotor voltage does not exceed an established value and the means implement weighting to the benefit of that component of the difference vector from the rotor flux vector and the stator flux vector, which is perpendicular to the stator flux vector.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the reference value of the rotor voltage does not exceed an established value and the means implement weighting to the benefit of that component of the difference vector from the rotor flux vector and the stator flux vector, which is parallel to the stator flux vector.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention only one discrete switching state of the inverter is switched by means of the control unit during a sampling period and the means select the switching state whose phase position is closest to the phase position of the reference value of the rotor voltage.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the means for determining the reference value of the rotor voltage use suitable weighting of the transient rotor flux and the quasi-steady-state stator flux.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the means for determining the reference value of the rotor voltage use suitable weighting of the transient rotor flux and the transient stator flux.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the rotor flux and the stator flux are calculated from at least a respective one of the measured parameters of stator voltage, stator current and rotor current (and optionally rotor voltage). Suitable measurement transducers can be used for that purpose. The control unit has suitable input interfaces for receiving the data.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention a controllable series impedance is arranged in the mains network path of the double-fed asynchronous machine. Such a controllable series impedance comprises an impedance and a parallel switch. An ohmic resistor which can take energy from the machine can be considered as the impedance. An inductive component can additionally limit the current rise. Preferably an electronic switch is considered as the switch as suitably fast reaction times are required to attain the object of the invention, and they can scarcely be embodied with a mechanical switch, for example a relay. Preferably an active semiconductor switch is used for that purpose, such as for example a GTO. It is however also possible to use thyristors with a suitable quenching circuit. In normal operation the switch is conducting and the impedance is short-circuited. After detection of a transient mains voltage change the switch is opened and the impedance is switched into the network path. Alternatively, clock-controlled operation of the electronic switch is also possible so that the impedance values are adjustable. The impedance provides in particular immediately after the occurrence of the transient mains voltage fault for an additional reduction in torque.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention a controllable series impedance is arranged in the stator path of the double-fed asynchronous machine. Firstly, the same advantages apply as for an arrangement of the series impedance in the network path. In addition, an arrangement in the stator path enjoys the advantage that the electronic switch has to be designed for a lower level of power. On the other hand the network-side inverter remains connected directly to the mains network so that reactive power can be delivered into the network by way of the network-side inverter even during a transient mains voltage jump. Those advantages apply irrespective of whether a suitable reference value is impressed into the rotor at the same time.
In accordance with a further embodiment of the apparatus according to the invention the inverter has a voltage intermediate circuit to which a circuit with a resistor for reducing the intermediate circuit voltage is connected to the voltage intermediate circuit. Such a circuit is also referred to as an intermediate circuit chopper. Such an intermediate circuit chopper can be used alternatively or additionally to a series impedance in the network or stator path. Active power is actively taken from the generator by a reference value of an electrical parameter being impressed into the rotor, which is determined by suitable weighting for example from a stator flux vector and a rotor flux vector (for example in a ratio of 40% to 60%). That active power can be received by the chopper resistor. The intermediate circuit chopper additionally involves protection from an inadmissibly high rise in the intermediate circuit voltage.
Further configurations of the invention are to be found in the description and the appendant claims. The invention is described in greater detail hereinafter by means of embodiments by way of example with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
A standard regulating method is used during the normal steady-state operation.
In that respect Ustator denotes the stator voltage vector and ωstator denotes the stator circuit frequency.
The output 30 of the observer 13 is subtracted from the output 31 of the observer 14. The result corresponds to the difference vector out of the vector of the rotor flux and the vector of the stator flux in a two-phase, rotor-oriented co-ordinate system. To generate a voltage value from the flux difference, multiplication with a proportionality factor is still required in the block 28. The voltage value ascertained in that way is then transformed to the three-phase system again in the re-transformation block 15. In the block 16, a firing pattern for the inverter is generated from the three-phase rotor voltage reference value. That can occur for example by means of pulse width modulation.
The sign can be influenced by means of a weighting factor c. The component 60b of the difference vector from the stator flux and the rotor flux parallel to the stator flux is multiplied in block 46 by the factor c. Block 47 determines the magnitude of the stator flux and block 48 multiplies that magnitude by the factor (1−c). The result is taken off from the output of the block 46 and the sign is determined in the block 49. The sign is then made available to the multiplication block 45. If the factor c=1 is selected, only an approximation of stator flux and rotor flux is assisted. If the factor c=0 is selected the rotor voltage component parallel to the stator flux is only used to reduce the stator flux. The rotor voltage components 60a and 60b then have to be transformed into a rotor-fixed co-ordinate system in the transformation block 50. The stator flux 31 and the rotor position 1c are used for that purpose.
The three-vector modulation operation affords a possible way of implementing pulse width modulation. A three-phase bridge circuit can assume eight discrete switching states.
To produce a rotary vector u23, the vector 1U22a is firstly switched for a given time duration t1 during the sampling period T. That on average in accordance with equation (2) gives the rotary vector 1u23a:
For a subsequent time duration t2 the vector 2U22b is switched. That on average in accordance with equation (3) during the time duration t2 gives the vector 2u23b:
In addition a zero vector t0 is switched for a time t0. During the sampling period T that is followed on average by the desired vector u23. The calculation is shown by equation (4):
u=1u+2u+u0 (4)
The total of the switch-on times for the three vectors gives the period duration:
T=t1+t2+to (5)
The circular line shown in
In the case of a transient mains voltage change generally a rotor voltage which is as high as possible is required. It is therefore particularly advantageous for the reference value of the rotor voltage, which is ascertained by the method or the apparatus according to the invention, not to be switched by means of rotary vector modulation or a comparable method, but to use that of the six discrete switching states 22a to 22f, which is closest to the phase position of the rotor voltage reference value, throughout the entire sampling period. That achieves the maximum possible voltage magnitude. A diagrammatic view of such a method is shown in
In that case an excessively great voltage would be generated by switching only one discrete state during a sampling period. For that reason, switching over can be effected by the switching device 21 between a method with pulse width modulation and a method with discrete switching states, during a sampling period. The switching device 21 is actuated by the evaluation device 20. That determines the magnitude of the rotor voltage reference value and switches over between the methods in dependence on that magnitude.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10 2007 014 728 | Mar 2007 | DE | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2008/053139 | 3/17/2008 | WO | 00 | 9/23/2009 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2008/116769 | 10/2/2008 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3975646 | Kilgore et al. | Aug 1976 | A |
4565957 | Gary et al. | Jan 1986 | A |
4973174 | Losic et al. | Nov 1990 | A |
4973896 | Shiga et al. | Nov 1990 | A |
4980620 | Losic et al. | Dec 1990 | A |
4982147 | Lauw | Jan 1991 | A |
4994684 | Lauw et al. | Feb 1991 | A |
5028804 | Lauw | Jul 1991 | A |
5083077 | Wallace et al. | Jan 1992 | A |
5272429 | Lipo et al. | Dec 1993 | A |
5333105 | Fortune | Jul 1994 | A |
5334923 | Lorenz et al. | Aug 1994 | A |
6198248 | Thomas et al. | Mar 2001 | B1 |
6636012 | Royak et al. | Oct 2003 | B2 |
7176658 | Quazi et al. | Feb 2007 | B2 |
7372174 | Jones et al. | May 2008 | B2 |
7511385 | Jones et al. | Mar 2009 | B2 |
7570027 | Teramoto et al. | Aug 2009 | B2 |
7592785 | Kimura et al. | Sep 2009 | B2 |
7605487 | Barton et al. | Oct 2009 | B2 |
7622815 | Rivas et al. | Nov 2009 | B2 |
7656052 | Jones et al. | Feb 2010 | B2 |
7692321 | Jones et al. | Apr 2010 | B2 |
7755209 | Jones et al. | Jul 2010 | B2 |
7989974 | Fortmann et al. | Aug 2011 | B2 |
8030791 | Lang et al. | Oct 2011 | B2 |
8053917 | Wakasa et al. | Nov 2011 | B2 |
8084892 | Yasugi | Dec 2011 | B2 |
8125178 | Hammel et al. | Feb 2012 | B2 |
8125193 | Page et al. | Feb 2012 | B2 |
8125195 | Kouwa | Feb 2012 | B2 |
8129957 | Martin | Mar 2012 | B2 |
8134345 | Bray et al. | Mar 2012 | B2 |
8138729 | Konishi | Mar 2012 | B2 |
8164312 | Eitzmann | Apr 2012 | B1 |
8164313 | Maehara | Apr 2012 | B2 |
8169197 | Rittiger | May 2012 | B2 |
20020101221 | Stefanovic et al. | Aug 2002 | A1 |
20050013085 | Kinsella et al. | Jan 2005 | A1 |
20050116476 | Feddersen | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20060238929 | Nielsen | Oct 2006 | A1 |
20070052244 | Hudson | Mar 2007 | A1 |
20070080007 | Teramoto et al. | Apr 2007 | A1 |
20080157529 | Rivas et al. | Jul 2008 | A1 |
20090146426 | Jones et al. | Jun 2009 | A1 |
20090146500 | Jones et al. | Jun 2009 | A1 |
20100327798 | Stichweh | Dec 2010 | A1 |
20120043994 | Alvarez Valenzuela et al. | Feb 2012 | A1 |
20120049629 | Miller et al. | Mar 2012 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
WO 2004030199 | Apr 2004 | WO |
WO 2006030183 | Mar 2006 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20100117605 A1 | May 2010 | US |