Method of cleaning a heater

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6170493
  • Patent Number
    6,170,493
  • Date Filed
    Friday, October 31, 1997
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 9, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Examiners
    • Gulakowski; Randy
    • Chaudhry; Saeed
    Agents
    • Christensen O'Connor Johnson & Kindness PLLC
Abstract
A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet. While the heater is in operation, a pig is run though the tubing from the inlet to the outlet and then returned to the inlet along return tubing, in parallel connection to the heater tubing. A combined pig launcher and receiver mounted parallel to the tubing, and controlled with three way full port valves, is used to launch pigs into the tubing and remove them from the tubing. A boost pump is used to force pigs back from outlet to inlet.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to processes and apparatus used for cleaning heater tubes.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Heaters are used in petrochemical installations to heat fluids for a variety of purposes, typically to break apart larger hydrocarbon molecules into smaller molecules. The heaters contain tubes, up to and even more than a kilometer long in each of several passes, that pass first through a convection section of a heater and then through a radiant section. During use, the heater tubes gradually become contaminated on their insides. This contamination, often called coke, tends to degrade the efficiency of the heater over time and can eventually cause the heater to stop working.




Various methods are known for decoking heaters. In one method, the heater is shut down and steam cleaned with high pressure steam. In another method, described for example in U.S. Pat. No. 5,358,573 issued Oct. 25, 1994, by the same inventor, the heater is shut down and pigs with appendages run through the heater until it is clean. In another method, described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,186,815 issued Feb. 16, 1993, the heater tubes are treated while the heater is in operation by injecting solid particles of very small size into the heater tubes, recovering the solid particles at the outlet and recirculating the solid particles back to the inlet of the heater.




Use of pigs to clean heater tubes is very effective since the pigs have a robust scraping action. Heater operators in South America who have used the inventor's method described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,358,573 have asked the inventor to provide cleaning of the heater tubes by pigs while the heater is in operation. The inventor has thus come up with a novel solution to the problem of providing a heater cleaning operation by using pigs while a heater is in operation.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




It is an object of this invention to provide a method and apparatus for pigging an operating heater. It is a further object of this invention to provide a pig launcher and receiver connected in parallel with tubing.




Therefor, there is provided in accordance with one aspect of the invention a method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet, the method comprising repeating the steps of:




(A) while the heater is in operation, running a pig through the tubing from the inlet to the outlet; and




(B) returning the pig to the inlet along return tubing, in parallel connection to the heater tubing.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, a boost pump is connected to the return tubing via a boost pump connection pipe to provide pressure for returning the pig to the inlet.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, a pig is launched into one of the heater tubing and the return tubing by use of a pig launcher mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, the method further comprises removing the pig from one of the heater tubing and the return tubing with a pig receiver mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, a single combined pig launcher and receiver functions as the pig launcher and the pig receiver.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, the return tubing is closed by a return valve while the pig is running through the heater tubing, and the return valve is opened after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, the return tubing is connected to the outlet of the heater at a junction, and an outlet valve is provided on the outlet downstream of the junction, and the method further comprises the step of closing the outlet valve after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, when a pig enters the inlet to the heater tubing, after passing through the return tubing, the return valve is closed and the outlet valve is opened.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, there is provided apparatus for pigging heater tubing in an operating heater, the heater tubing having inlet tubing and outlet tubing. Return tubing is connected to the inlet tubing at a first junction and to the outlet tubing at a second junction. A boost pump is connected to the outlet tubing by a boost pump connection pipe. Pig launching and receiving equipment is connected for launching of pigs into and removal of pigs from the heater tubing and return tubing. An outlet valve is provide on the outlet tubing downstream of the second junction. A first pig tripper is provided on the outlet tubing downstream of the boost pump connection pipe. A return valve is provided on the return tubing. A second pig tripper is provided near the inlet tubing for detecting when the pig is close to the inlet tubing.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, the pig launching and receiving equipment comprises a pig launcher mounted parallel to one of the heater tubing and the return tubing; and a pig receiver mounted parallel to one of the heater tubing and the return tubing.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, there is provided a pig launcher and receiver comprising tubing in which fluids may flow; and a pig launcher and receiver body, the pig launcher and receiver body having an interior cavity for receiving pigs, and a motive fluid inlet and a motive fluid inlet, and a door for removal of pigs from and insertion of pigs into the pig launcher and receiver body. A basket is provided in the pig launcher and receiver body for holding pigs. An inlet pipe controlled by an inlet valve, preferably a three way full port valve, is connected to the tubing at a first Y junction and connected to the motive fluid inlet. An outlet pipe controlled by an outlet valve, preferably a three way full port valve, is connected to the tubing at a second Y junction and connected to the motive fluid outlet.




Preferably, the motive fluid outlet and the motive fluid inlet are located at opposite ends of the interior cavity.




In accordance with a further aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of cleaning a tube in an operating heater, wherein the tube has an inlet and an outlet and fluid being heated is flowing from the inlet to the outlet, the method comprising the steps of:




monitoring the temperature at the outlet of the tube; and




when the temperature at the outlet of the tube indicates a degradation of efficiency of the heater below a given set point, running a pig through the tube to clean the tube while the heater is operating.




These and other aspects of the invention are described in the detailed description of the invention and claimed in the claims that follow.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




There will now be described preferred embodiments of the invention, with reference to the drawings, by way of illustration only and not with the intention of limiting the scope of the invention, in which like numerals denote like elements and in which:





FIG. 1

is a schematic showing the manner of operation of continuous cleaning of a heater while the heater is in operation;





FIG. 2

is a section through a combined pig launcher and receiver that for example may be used in the operation of the invention; and





FIG. 3

is a section through a pig that may be used during the operation of the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring to

FIG. 1

, a heater


10


may contain as much as 10 kilometers of tubing or pipe running through a convection section and a radiant section from an inlet tube


12


to an outlet tube


14


in several passes. Details of the heater are not shown since the invention is intended for application to existing installations, the general construction of which is well known. The invention is intended for cleaning of the tubing in the heater while fluid being heated is flowing through the heater from the inlet tube


12


to the outlet tube


14


. To enable automatic operation of the system according to an embodiment of the invention, a return tube formed of tubes


16


and


18


in parallel with the heater tubes is provided between the outlet


14


and inlet


12


, with a control valve


22


on tube


16


and return control valve


23


on tube


18


. A boost pump


26


on a boost pipe


28


is connected to supply boost fluid to the tube


16


. A bypass tube


32


which also forms part of the outlet tubing is also connected in parallel to the boost pipe


28


between the tube


16


and outlet


14


. A valve


24


is provided on tube


14


, and an outlet valve


25


is provided on tube


32


downstream of the junction between the tube


16


and return tubing


18


. Trippers


34


,


36


and


38


are provided on tubes


14


,


16


and


18


respectively. The trippers


34


,


36


and


38


are conventional pig trippers that are activated when a pig passes them. Tripper


38


should be located close to the junction of return tubing


18


with the inlet tubing


12


. Close or near in this context means in position where it can be determined when the pig enters the inlet tubing


12


. This need not be at the junction if a timer is used and it is known how long it takes for the pig to travel from the tripper


34


to the junction of return tubing


18


and inlet tubing


12


. Tripper


34


should be located close to and upstream of the pig launcher


39


.




A conventional pig receiver


39


is attached to the tube


14


in parallel by tubes


40


,


42


and controlled by valves


43


,


44


and


45


. The parallel construction permits fluid to flow either through the tube


14


or the pig receiver


39


depending on the positioning of the valves


43


,


44


or


45


. Pig receiver


39


is used for removal of pigs from the tube. A conventional pig launcher


49


is attached to the tube


12


in parallel by tubes


50


,


52


and controlled by valves


53


,


54


and


55


. The parallel construction permits fluid to flow either through the tube


12


or the pig launcher


49


depending on the position of the valves


53


,


54


or


55


. Pig launcher


49


is used for launching of pigs into the tube. The pig launcher and receiver may be connected to any tube that connects into the tubes


12


,


14


,


16


or


18


, and is preferably on one of the tubes


12


,


14


,


16


or


18


.




An alternative pig launcher and receiver design is shown in FIG.


2


. In this embodiment, there is provided a combined pig launcher and receiver


80


, that is mounted parallel to a set of tubing


82


in which fluids may flow, which may for example be the inlet or outlet tubing of a heater or the return tubing


18


. The pig launcher and receiver


80


is formed of a pig launcher and receiver body


84


, having an interior cavity


86


for receiving pigs. Preferably on opposed sides of the interior cavity


86


there is provided a motive fluid inlet


88


and a motive fluid outlet


90


. A door


92


is provided for removal of pigs from and insertion of pigs into the pig launcher and receiver body


80


. A basket


94


is installed in the pig launcher and receiver body


80


for holding pigs. Except as described here, the design of the pig launcher and receiver follows conventional design. An inlet pipe


96


is connected to the tubing


82


at a Y junction


97


and connected to the motive fluid inlet


88


. An outlet pipe


98


is connected to the tubing


82


at a Y junction


99


and connected to the motive fluid outlet


90


. A three way full port valve


100


is provided on the inlet pipe at the Y junction


97


. A three way full port valve


102


is provided on the outlet pipe at the Y junction


99


. A tripper


104


is provided on the tubing


82


upstream of the pig launcher and receiver


80


.




This alternative pig launcher and receiver design works as follows. The three way full port valves


100


and


102


may direct flow and a pig carried by the flow into the pig launcher and receiver


80


or around the pig launcher and receiver


80


through tubing


82


. When the heater tubing is not being cleaned, or a pig is by-passing the pig launcher and receiver


80


valves


100


and


102


are in left open position (tubing


82


is open). When a pig is in the system and needs to be stopped, three way valves


100


and


102


are placed into right position. When the tripper


104


signals a pig has arrived at the pig launcher and receiver


80


, the valves


100


and


102


return to left open position. One combined pig launcher and receiver is used for each pass in a heater.




In the normal operating condition, the inlet


12


is at a lower temperature and higher pressure than the outlet


14


, and with no pigs in the system, valves


22


and


25


are open, and valves


23


and


24


closed, permitting flow through tubes


14


,


16


and


32


which together form an outlet tube. When it is described to operate the system with a pig, a pig is injected into line


14


through pig launcher


49


. To do this, valves


53


and


54


on tubes


52


and


50


respectively are closed, with valve


55


on tube


12


open. A pig may then be placed in the launcher


49


. Valves


53


and


54


are opened and then valve


55


on tube


12


is closed, forcing the pig into tube


12


and into the heater


10


. The pig exits the heater through tube


14


, and since valve


24


is closed, the pig passes into line


16


and trips tripper


36


which is located on the tubing


16


downstream of the junction of the boost pump connection pipe


28


with the tubing


16


. When the pig trips tripper


36


, valves


23


and


24


are opened, valves


22


and


25


are closed and boost pump


26


is started. The boost pump


26


provides the required pressure to force the pig to return to the inlet


12


past tripper


38


. For an exemplary inlet pressure of 150 psi, and outlet pressure of 110 psi, the boost pump pressure is 200 psi.




When tripper


38


is tripped, boost pump


26


is shut off, valves


22


and


25


are opened and valves


23


and


24


are closed, thus completing the cycle automatically. While pigs are being shunted around the system automatically, the valve


45


is kept open and valve


44


closed. When it is desired to remove pigs from the system, for example for inspection of the pigs, upon tripping of tripper


34


by a pig, valve


45


is closed, and valves


43


and


44


opened, permitting the pig to enter the pig launcher. Valve


45


may then be opened and valves


43


and


44


closed, and the pig may be removed from the launcher.




Each of the pig launcher


49


and pig receiver


39


contains a basket


62


and pressure gauge


60


. The basket permits fluid flow through the receiver, while the pig may be caught before or in the basket. The pressure gauges


60


inform an operator that the pressure is low enough for the door of the launcher and receiver to be opened. A drain valve


64


is provided in each of the launcher and receiver to permit draining of fluids. The inside diameter of the launcher and receiver should be two sizes larger than the clean inside diameter of the tube being treated. For example, a launcher and receiver inside diameter of 5 or 6 inches would be used for treatment of a 4 inch tube. The launcher and receiver should be made of metal having similar metallurgical properties to the metal of the heater tubes being treated. A door (not shown) is provided on the launcher or receiver in conventional fashion.




In a preferred manner of operation of the invention, the automatic cleaning of the heater tube may be effected whenever there is a degradation of efficiency of the heater. Efficiency of the heater may be monitored by monitoring the temperature at the outlet


14


of the heater


10


with a conventional temperature sensor. For a given heat input to the heater


10


, the fluid in the tube will be heated a lesser amount when there is a greater amount of contamination in the tube. The contamination in effect acts as an insulator for the fluid in the tube. Hence, when the temperature at the outlet


14


of the heater


10


indicates a degradation of efficiency of the heater


10


below a given set point, a pig may be run through the tube in the manner described to clean the tube while the heater is operating.




The tubes, valves and launchers should all be made of similar metal to the metal in the heater tubes. The pigs may be made of similar metal, or may be made from elastic polymer that is capable of withstanding the temperatures in the heater. The pigs must be able to bend sufficiently to move around the bends in the tubes, and must also be strong enough to retain cleaning devices such as bolts, studs, grit, and other conventional cleaning elements in the pig to effect a cleaning action. Exemplary cleaning devices are shown in U.S. Pat. No. 5,265,302. The appendages should also be made of similar metal to the tubes. Exemplary polymers for moderate temperature applications include the following materials: ETFE Fluropolymer (Tefzel™), a melt processable fluropolymer available from Dupont; LCP (Polyester Liquid Crystal Polymer), under the tradename Vectra™, Xydar™, available from Amoco, Hoechst Celanese, respectively. LCPs are relatively new materials with unusual properties, whose strength is in the skin. Good design data is not available for these materials, so prototyping is a must: prototypes must be molded, because of the molecular orientation mentioned above. Other materials that may be used include PEEK Polyetheretherkeytone, known as Victrex™, Thermocomp™ available from ICI, LNP respectively; PET Polyetherimid, known as Ultem™ available from GE; PES Polyethersulfone, known as Thermocomp™, Victrex™ available from LNP, ICI respectively; Polyimide thermoplastic, known as Aurum™ available from Mitsui Toatsu; PPA Polyphthalamide, known as Amodel™, Verton™ available from Amoco, LNP respectively; PPS Polyphenylene Sulfide, known as Fortron™, Lubricomp™, Ryton™, Supec™ available from GE, Hoechst Celanese, LNP Phillips, respectively; Polysulfone, known as Udel and Mindel™ available from Amoco. Design data on these materials is available from their manufacturers.




So far as known to this inventor, some of these moderate temperature polymers are satisfactory for operation up to about 500° F. Above this temperature, metallic pigs are currently believed to be required. However, it is believed that as other polymers become available the process described herein will operate at higher temperatures with polymer based pigs.




An exemplary metallic pig is shown in FIG.


3


. An exterior partly cylindrical and partly conical shell


70


is made of spring metal of the same material that the tubes in the heater are made from, or such other material that will withstand the high temperature corrosive conditions within the heater tubes. Bristles or metallic wires


72


acting as cleaning elements are formed into U-shapes and pass through openings in the cylindrical portion of the shell


70


in conventional fashion for forming a brush with bristles. The metallic wires


72


extend circumferentially around the cylindrical portion of the conical shell


70


. Other methods of securing the wires


72


may be used. An interior cylindrical and conical shell


74


of similar but slightly smaller cross-section than the conical shell


70


is pressed into the conical shell


70


to assist in securing the metallic wires


72


in the conical shell


70


. An annular lip


76


holds the interior shell


74


inside the exterior shell


70


. The metallic wires


72


and the shell


74


should be made of the same material as the shell


70


or a material having equivalent characteristics.




Another embodiment of a metallic pig is shown in United Kingdom patent specification No. 844,116 published Aug. 10, 1960, and also in United kingdom patent application No. 2,175,666. These metallic pigs are believed to have utility when used in the method of the invention, but are not believed to be as effective a cleaning device as the well known polymer based pigs with hard cleaning elements that are described for example in U.S. Pat. No. 5,265,302. Hence, where polymer based pigs are sufficiently tolerant of high temperatures that they may be used in an operating heater, it is preferred that they be used.




Any pig used in the operation of the invention should be dimensioned to fit within the tube with its cleaning elements able to compress against contaminants in the tube and effect a scraping action. The pig itself is constructed to bias the cleaning elements against the contaminants.




While the system may be manually operated, it is preferred to operate the system automatically. For this purpose, a control system may be connected to the trippers, valves, boost pump and pig launcher and receiver for controlling their operation in accordance with the operating principles outlined herein. Other than as described, the tubing, trippers, valves, and boost pump mentioned herein are all conventional.




It should be appreciated that the drawing shown is not to scale. In practice, both inlet


12


and outlet


14


may pass out of the heater in close proximity to each other, and this the return tubing


18


may be a very short length.




A person skilled in the art could make immaterial modifications to the invention described in this patent document without departing from the essence of the invention that is intended to be covered by the scope of the claims that follow.



Claims
  • 1. A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater in a petrochemical installation, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet, the method comprising repeating the steps of:(a) while the heater is in operation in the petrochemical installation, running a pig through the tubing from the inlet to the outlet, the pig being dimension to fit compressed within the tubing; and (b) returning the pig to the inlet along return tubing, in parallel connection to the heater tubing, the return tubing being connected to a boost pump via a boost pump connection pipe to provide pressure for returning the pig to the inlet, and said return tubing being closed by return valve while the pig is running through the heater tubing, and the return valve is opened after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.
  • 2. The method of claim 1 in which the return tubing is connected to the outlet of the heater at a junction, and an outlet valve is provided in the outlet downstream of the junction, and the method further comprises the step of:closing the outlet valve after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.
  • 3. The method of claim 2 in which, when a pig enters the inlet to the heater tubing, after passing through the return tubing, the return valve is closed and the outlet valve is opened.
  • 4. The method of claim 1 in which a pig is launched into one of the heater tubing and the return tubing by use of a pig launcher mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing.
  • 5. The method of claim 4 further comprising removing the pig from one of the heater tubing and the return tubing with a pig receiver mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing.
  • 6. The method of claim 5 in which a single combined pig launcher and receiver functions as the pig launcher and the pig receiver.
  • 7. A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater in a petrochemical installation, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet, the method comprising:(a) running a pig through the tubing from the inlet to the outlet while the heater is in operation in the petrochemical installation, the pig being dimensioned to fit compressed within the tubing; (b) returning the pig to the inlet along return tubing, in parallel connection to the heater tubing, (c) removing the pig from one of the heater tubing and the return tubing with a pig receiver mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing; and in which a boost pump is connected to the return tubing via a boost pump connection pipe to provide pressure for returning the pig to the inlet, and said pig being launched into one of the heater tubing and the return tubing by use of a pig launcher mounted parallel to the one of the heater tubing and the return tubing, and a single combined pig launcher and receiver functions as the pig launcher and the pig receiver, and the return tubing is closed by a return valve while the pig is running through the heater tubing, and the return valve is opened after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.
  • 8. The method of claim 7 in which the return tubing is connected to the outlet of the heater at a junction, and an outlet valve is provided on the outlet downstream of the junction, and the method further comprises the step of:closing the outlet valve after the pig passes the boost pump connection pipe.
  • 9. The method of claim 8 in which, when a pig enters the inlet to the heater tubing, after passing through the return tubing, the return valve is closed and the outlet valve is opened.
  • 10. A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater in a petrochemical installation, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet, the method comprising repeating the steps of:(a) while the heater is in operation in the petrochemical installation, running a pig through the tubing from the inlet to the outlet, the pig being dimensioned to fit compressed within the tubing; and (b) returning the pig to the inlet along return tubing, in parallel connection to the heater tubing, and the temperature of the fluid flowing through the tubing is in excess of 500° F.
  • 11. The method of claim 10 in which the heater has a convection section and a radiant section, and the pig is run through tubing in both the convection section and the radiant section.
  • 12. The method of claim 10 in which the pig is made entirely of metal.
  • 13. A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater in a petrochemical installation, in which the tubing has an inlet and an outlet, the method comprising running a pig through the tubing from the inlet to the outlet while the heater is in operation in the petrochemical installation, the pig being dimensioned to fit compressed within the tubing, and returning the pig to the inlet, and the temperature of the fluid flowing through the tubing is in excess of 500° F.
  • 14. The method of claim 11 in which the heater has a convection section and a radiant section, and the pig is run through tubing in both the convection section and the radiant section.
  • 15. The method of claim 11 in which the pig is made entirely of metal.
  • 16. A method of cleaning tubing in an operating heater in a petrochemical installation, the tubing having an outlet and an inlet, the method comprising the steps of:(a) operating the heater in a petrochemical installation with the fluid to be heated flowing through the tubing at a temperature in excess of 500° F.; and (b) selectively cleaning the operating heater while the fluid to be heated flows through the tubing, by: (i) launching a pig into the tubing of the heater; (ii) running the pig through the tubing of the operating heater from the inlet to the outlet at least one pass, with the pig compressed within the tubing; and (iii) removing the pig from the tubing of the operating heater.
  • 17. The method of claim 16 in which the heater has a convection section and a radiant section, and the pig is run through tubing in both the convection section and the radiant section.
  • 18. The method of claim 16 in which the pig is made entirely of metal.
US Referenced Citations (32)
Number Name Date Kind
1547440 Penn Jul 1925
1597850 Weis Aug 1926
1673890 Smith Jun 1928
1713895 Ford May 1929
1795348 Schmidt Mar 1931
3425083 Wennerberg et al. Feb 1969
3460180 Girard Aug 1969
3474479 Girard Oct 1969
3939519 Muirhead Feb 1976
4079782 Soderberg et al. Mar 1978
4283807 Bizard Aug 1981
4350202 Schulz et al. Sep 1982
4383346 Bochinski et al. May 1983
4390058 Otake et al. Jun 1983
4406031 Eimer et al. Sep 1983
4435872 Leikam Mar 1984
4476917 Otake et al. Oct 1984
4556102 Bochinski et al. Dec 1985
4566533 Bochinski et al. Jan 1986
4709719 Littleton et al. Dec 1987
5010950 Voith Apr 1991
5153963 Saxon et al. Oct 1992
5176199 Czolkoss Jan 1993
5186815 Lenglet Feb 1993
5213623 Burtner May 1993
5358573 Sivacoe Oct 1994
5431545 Knight et al. Jul 1995
5473787 Echols Dec 1995
5592990 Ben-Dosa Jan 1997
5607513 Sims Mar 1997
5630471 Taprogge May 1997
5647428 Echols Jul 1997
Foreign Referenced Citations (8)
Number Date Country
1147106 May 1983 CA
1290110 Oct 1991 CA
0234072A1 Feb 1986 EP
0 371 859 Jun 1990 EP
0 646 423 A1 Apr 1995 EP
780093 Jul 1957 GB
2175666A May 1986 GB
WO 9117843 Nov 1991 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (9)
Entry
Declaration of Shiuchi Wada, Oct. 15, 1996.
Decarbonization, PEC, System, Oct. 1984.
PEC-PIG Decoking System For Your B-2 Furnace/EXXON, PEC International (USA), Inc., Jan. 15, 1988.
Proposal For PIG Decoking/Furnace PV-F-01, PEC International (USA), Inc., Mar. 6, 1990.
Finding the basic design for your application, Herbert L. Berman, Caltex Petroleum Corp., Chemical Engineering Jun. 19, 1978, p. 99 -170.
UCISCO, A Linde Service Company, brochure entitled “Sandjet Furnace Tube Cleaning—An Energy Conservation Tool”, Gary E. Diehl, Union Carbide Industrial Services, Houston, Texas, presented at Phillips Energy Conservation Seminar, Bartlesville, Oklahoma, Apr. 14, 1982, 7 pages.
Computer Search dated Feb. 9, 1997, 4 pages, “decok”.
Abstract of U.S. Patent 4,917,787, issued Apr. 17, 1990, 2 pages.
Abstract of U.S. Patent 5,183,642, issued Feb. 2, 1993, 2 pages.