The present invention relates to determining solid and liquid components in sedimentary rocks using NMR relaxation, and in particular to separation of liquid-like (T2e) from solid-like (T2G) 1H NMR transverse relaxation times in porous media.
A method is disclosed, according to embodiments, for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) measurement on a sample. The method comprises: (a) applying a 180° RF pulse to the sample, thereby yielding an inverted longitudinal magnetization Mz=−M0 away from equilibrium; (b) during a selected inversion recovery time τ1, allowing Mz to recover towards an equilibrium value of Mz=M0 governed by a time constant T1; (c) after the selected inversion recovery time τ1, applying a 90° RF pulse for rotating the instantaneous Mz into a transverse plane Mx,y; (d) at a selected pulse-separation time τS, applying a second 90° RF pulse for rotating Mx,y within the transverse plane, creating observable magnetization by formation of a solid-echo; (e) sampling with discretized time steps the observable solid-echo magnetization during a time t following the applying of the second 90° RF pulse to acquire signal amplitude measurements as the observable transverse magnetization decays toward equilibrium with magnetization Mx,y=0, wherein, during the time t, a decay time constant is T*2G; (f) repeating at least once, responsively to a recovery of the sample substantially to equilibrium, steps (a) to (e) with a different selected recovery time τ1 in step (c); and (g) processing the solid-echo measurements to produce a T1-T*2G map for use in characterizing the sample, wherein the characterizing includes at least one of determining a structure and determining a plurality of components.
In some embodiments, the solid-like components can comprise at least one of kerogen, bitumen, and a clay hydroxyl of a geologic sample. In some embodiments, the liquid-like components can comprise at least one of a micropore fluid, a meso-macropore fluid, a fluid dissolved in organic matter, and a clay-bound water of a geologic sample.
In some embodiments, it can be that the instrumental deadtime td is not greater than 0.01 ms.
In some embodiments, the longitudinal magnetization can be saturated (Mz=0) by a series of RF pulses, and/or can be followed by a selected inversion recovery time τ1, and/or can be followed by rotation into the transverse plane to form a solid-echo.
In some embodiments, the method can additionally comprise using the measurements before and after bitumen extraction of the sample to predict bitumen content and bitumen properties including at least one of asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and saturate fractions of the bitumen in the sample. In some embodiments, the method can additionally comprise using the measurements before and after saturation of the sample with light hydrocarbons to predict expelled bitumen content and bitumen properties including at least one of asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and saturate fractions of the bitumen in the sample.
In some embodiments, the sample can comprise bulk crude-oil or bulk bitumen to predict the asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and/or saturate fractions of the bulk crude-oil or bulk bitumen.
In some embodiments, the inversion can be based on 2D inverse Laplace techniques for use in determining structure or components of the sample. In some embodiments, the transverse magnetization Mx,y decay can be inverted with one of an exponential function, a Gaussian function, and a sinc-Gaussian kernel function. In some embodiments, the longitudinal magnetization Mz recovery can be inverted with an exponential kernel.
In some embodiments, one or more of the nominal 90° RF pulse can comprise a different tip angle. In some embodiments, one or more of the nominal 180° RF pulse can comprise a different tip angle.
In some embodiments, it can be that one or more of the steps (a) to (g) is correlated with geochemistry data, such as RockEval or LECO, for determining structure or components of the sample.
In some embodiments, the method can be applied to predict NMR-derived geochemical quantities including S1, S2, S1/S2, HI, OI, as well as elemental ratios H/C, H/S, H/O, H/N of elements for the crude-oil or bitumen.
In some embodiments, a distinction between solid-like and liquid-like NMR signal can be determined by a transverse relaxation time being respectively above or below a value of 0.1 ms. In some embodiments, a distinction between solid-like and liquid-like NMR signal can be determined by a viscosity being respectively above or below a value of 107 cP.
A method is disclosed, according to embodiments, for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) measurement on a sample. The method comprises: (a) measuring liquid-like components using an inversion-recovery CPMG sequence, without dephasing from the inhomogeneous magnetic field; (b) processing the measurements of the liquid-like components to produce a T1-T2e map of the liquid-like components; (c) measuring solid-like components using an inversion-recovery solid-echo sequence, with minimal instrumental deadtime; (d) processing the measurements of the liquid-like components to produce a T1-T*2G map of the solid-like components; (e) combining the T1-T2e map with the T1-T*2G map using a T2 cutoff to create a spliced T1-{T*2G; T2e} map; and (f) analyzing the T1-{T*2G; T2e} map for use in characterizing the sample, wherein the characterizing includes at least one of determining a structure and determining a plurality of components.
In some embodiments, the solid-like components can comprise at least one of kerogen, bitumen, and a clay hydroxyl of a geologic sample. In some embodiments, the liquid-like components can comprise at least one of a micropore fluid, a meso-macropore fluid, a fluid dissolved in organic matter, and a clay-bound water of a geologic sample.
In some embodiments, it can be that the instrumental deadtime td is not greater than 0.01 ms.
In some embodiments, the longitudinal magnetization can be saturated (Mz=0) by a series of RF pulses, and/or can be followed by a selected inversion recovery time τ1, and/or can be followed by rotation into the transverse plane to form a solid-echo.
In some embodiments, the method can additionally comprise using the measurements before and after bitumen extraction of the sample to predict bitumen content and bitumen properties including at least one of asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and saturate fractions of the bitumen in the sample. In some embodiments, the method can additionally comprise using the measurements before and after saturation of the sample with light hydrocarbons to predict expelled bitumen content and bitumen properties including at least one of asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and saturate fractions of the bitumen in the sample.
In some embodiments, the sample can comprise bulk crude-oil or bulk bitumen to predict the asphaltene, resin, aromatic, and/or saturate fractions of the bulk crude-oil or bulk bitumen.
In some embodiments, the inversion can be based on 2D inverse Laplace techniques for use in determining structure or components of the sample. In some embodiments, the transverse magnetization Mx,y decay can be inverted with one of an exponential function, a Gaussian function, and a sinc-Gaussian kernel function. In some embodiments, the longitudinal magnetization Mz recovery can be inverted with an exponential kernel.
In some embodiments, one or more of the nominal 90° RF pulse can comprise a different tip angle. In some embodiments, one or more of the nominal 180° RF pulse can comprise a different tip angle.
In some embodiments, it can be that one or more of the steps (a) to (g) is correlated with geochemistry data, such as RockEval or LECO, for determining structure or components of the sample.
In some embodiments, the method can be applied to predict NMR-derived geochemical quantities including S1, S2, S1/S2, HI, OI, as well as elemental ratios H/C, H/S, H/O, H/N of elements for the crude-oil or bitumen.
In some embodiments, a distinction between solid-like and liquid-like NMR signal can be determined by a transverse relaxation time being respectively above or below a value of 0.1 ms. In some embodiments, a distinction between solid-like and liquid-like NMR signal can be determined by a viscosity being respectively above or below a value of 107 cP.
Currently there is no reliable method to interpret the 1H NMR T2 relaxation (i.e., transverse relaxation) of porous geological media containing both liquid-like and solid-like components without losing information about one of the components. This has an impact on the interpretation of commercial NMR core and log analysis of organic-rich shales, such as shale oil and shale gas, where T1-T2 relaxation maps are routinely used to identify sweet spots and producibility of the hydrocarbon reservoir.
The 1H NMR T2 relaxation (i.e., transverse relaxation) of a hydrogen-bearing liquid in a porous medium with large (>100 nm) pores is known to decay with a multi-exponential distribution of relaxation times T2e. On the other hand, a hydrogen-bearing solid phases such as kerogen and clay hydroxyls are known to decay with a multi-Gaussian distribution of relaxation times T2G [1, 2, 3]. Liquids under nano-pore (<1 nm) confinement (i.e., solvated liquids, or dissolved liquids) in kerogen may also decay with a multi-Gaussian distribution of T2G times, which is a result of residual dipolar coupling from the highly anisotropic rotational motion of the liquid under nano-confinement [3].
The presence of both multi-exponential (T2e) and multi-Gaussian (T2G) decay in the transverse magnetization MCPMG(t) from a CPMG (Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill) sequence causes complications in the interpretation of T2 relaxation. More specifically, forcing a multi-exponential decay on an underlying Gaussian decay results in a poor fit to MCPMG(t), which typically overestimates the total porosity and yields non-physical relaxation times [3]. Meanwhile, fitting a multi-Gaussian decay on an underlying exponential decay results in a poor fit to MCPMG(t) which typically underestimates the total porosity and yields non-physical relaxation times. The presence of both exponential and Gaussian decays therefore creates a conundrum about what kernel function (exponential or Gaussian) to use in the inversion.
One reported method to deal with this scenario is to fit MCPMG(t) using both multi-exponential and multi-Gaussian kernels, but with a sigmoidal penalty function which favors multi-exponential decay at long times and multi-Gaussian decay at short times [4,5].
The limitation with this method is that it introduces four additional parameters into the inversion, and it has not been adapted to T1-T2 mapping.
Another complication with solid-like signal is that the T2G relaxation times are typically shorter (T2G≈0.01 ms) than the shortest echo-spacing tE of a CPMG sequence. Typically, minimum tE≈0.1 ms for 2 MHz relaxometers, while minimum tE≈0.03 ms for 20 MHz relaxometers. One solution is to use an FID (free induction decay) sequence instead of a CPMG sequence. The dead times td of an FID are typically td≈0.07 ms at 2 MHz and td≈0.01 ms at 20 MHz; this is a huge advantage for detecting solid-like signal at 20 MHz. The complication with FID is that the apparent relaxation time τ2 contains both the intrinsic relaxation time τ2 and dephasing in the inhomogeneous magnetic field. This implies that the relaxation time of liquid-like signal with long T2e>>1 ms is piled up at T*2e≈1 ms, meaning that the only intrinsic petrophysical information retained about the liquid-like signal is the liquid-filled porosity. On the other hand, relaxation times of solid-like signals with short T2G≈0.01 ms are not affected by dephasing in the inhomogeneous magnetic field, i.e., T*2G≈T2G.
In such a scenario, incorporating the T1 dimension in the form of a 2D T1-T*2 map has many advantages. There have been several reports of 2D T1-T*2 mapping using recovery-FID sequences [6,7], and imaging sequences [8], which make use of multi-exponential inversions for both T1 and T*2 dimensions. The difference between T1-T*2 maps and T1-T2 is readily apparent in organic-rich shale [6], including the shortening of long T2e>>1 ms components due to dephasing in the inhomogeneous magnetic field. Nevertheless, at sufficiently high magnetic fields (>20 MHz), fluid typing in unconventional cores is possible using T1-T*2 maps [6,9], given the T1 contrast between hydrocarbons and water. At Larmor frequencies ≈20 MHz, it has been shown that T1 is larger for producible hydrocarbons than for clay-bound water and interparticle water [10, 11, 12]; likewise it is generally accepted that T1 is larger for kerogen than for clay hydroxyls [13, 14, 15, 16], although T1 for kerogen does depend on maturity [10] and T1 for clay hydroxyls depends on compaction [1].
There have also been reports of 2D T1-T*2 inversions that separate liquid-like multi-exponential (T*2e) components from solid-like multi-Gaussian (T*2G) (or sinc-Gaussian) components [17,18], which can also be applied in rapid T*1-T*2 sequences [19]. The 2D inversions start with a non-linear parametric fit of a single exponential at long times to isolate the multi-Gaussian components at short times. While a single exponential at long times is a good approximation at high magnetic fields (≈100 MHz), where internal gradients dominate T*2e [20], this is not generally the case at lower magnetic fields (<20 MHz) where the distribution in T*2e depends on the magnetic field inhomogeneity across the sample.
While 2D T1-T*2 maps are effective in unconventional cores at sufficiently high magnetic fields (>20 MHz), the use of 2D T1-T2 maps are still required for logs which are acquired in grossly-inhomogeneous low magnetic fields (≈2 MHz) [21]. For conventional rocks at low magnetic fields (≈2 MHz), it has been shown that T1/T2e of the hydrocarbon phase increases with oil-wetness, implying that T1/T2e is a good measure of wettability in cores and well logs [22]. In unconventional organic-rich shale at low fields (≈2 MHz), the high T1/T2e=3⇔6 ratio of producible light oil is used for fluid typing in cores and logs [23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31], since, by contrast, water in clays has a lower T1/T2e≈2 ratio. These well logging techniques require T1-T2 maps rather than T1-T*2 maps since T2e≈t180≈0.02 ms (where t180 is the RF pulse duration) is prohibitively short for well logging tools [21].
Techniques have been reported to acquire T2 instead of T*2 for liquid-like signal, while still capturing the solid-like signal T*2G≈T2G. One way to do this is to combine (i.e., splice) the FID and CPMG data [5, 16, 32], and then use a sigmoidal penalty function to invert for T*2G and T2e [4]. The motivation for these techniques originates from adding MFID(0) from FID to MCPMG(t) from CPMG [33], thereby gaining a constraint at short times in the T2e inversion. One complication from splicing FID and CPMG data [5, 16, 32, 34] is that the MFID(t) and MCPMG(t) do not always join at the expected time, implying that splicing in the time domain is not a universal approach. One cause for this mismatch is the potential inclusion of pseudo-T1ρ effects in CPMG decays with short tE; this arises from high RF (radio frequency) duty-cycles, which leads to pseudo spin-locking effects [35].
Other advances in this field include the use of the solid-echo sequence [36, 37, 38, 39], and the solid-echo train [40,41]. The original motivation for preferring the solid-echo over the FID is that the deadtime td of the FID necessitates an extrapolation to time-zero in the inversion. On the other hand, the solid-echo results in the detection of a maximum in the echo, which leads to a more stable inversion. The inversion of the solid-echo data currently consists of a parametric fit of a single Gaussian component T*2G plus two exponentials T*2e [38,39], without adaptation to 2D T1-T*2 mapping. Meanwhile, the inversion of the solid-echo train (and magic-echo train) data currently consists of inverting with multi-exponentials 2D T1-T2e [40, 41, 42, 43], without the inclusion of multi-Gaussian 2D T1-T2G components. Nevertheless, a multivariate analysis of 2D T1-T2e maps with a solid-echo train has been shown to correlate well with geochemical properties of raw oil shales and spent oil shale samples exposed to a range of pyrolysis conditions [42]. The oil content determined from multi-exponential 2D T1-T2e maps in oil shale have also been shown to correlate well with the oil content determined from the Dean-Stark method [44,45]. Furthermore, it was also shown that both Dean-Stark and NMR show systematically higher oil content in preserved cores compared to RockEval or thermal desorption-gas chromatography which suffer from loss in oil content (i.e., loss in RockEval S1 signal) during sample preparation [44,45]. Finally, it has also been shown that integrating multi-step solvent extraction experiments with 2D T1-T2e maps enhances the petrophysical interpretation of shale [46].
Symbols and abbreviations appearing in the disclosure are to be understood in accordance with the following table.
A new 2D inversion methodology is disclosed which: (1) captures the liquid-like T2e components without dephasing from the inhomogeneous magnetic field, (2) captures the solid-like T*2G≈T2G components with minimal deadtime using a solid-echo sequence, (3) does the liquid-solid decomposition with a minimal number of additional free parameters, and (4) is easily adaptable to T1-T2 mapping. The novel NMR method described here satisfies these four requirements and is demonstrated on organic-rich chalks from a NGL (natural gas liquids) reservoir of low (Klinkenberg-corrected) permeability kklink≈0.01 mD and high (total organic carbon) TOC≈11 wt % of Type II-S [47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54], using a 20 MHz 1H NMR relaxometer. The liquid-like (T1-T2e maps) components of water-saturated versus heptane-saturated samples show a clear contrast in T/T2e ratio between water and heptane in the micro/meso-macro pores, which shows potential for improved fluid typing and saturation in organic-rich chalk, and gives insights into the surface relaxivity and diffusive coupling of the pore network. The solid-like (T1-T*2G maps) components are used to quantify the clay minerals (hydroxyapatite and kaolinite), the kerogen content, and solvent-extracted bitumen versus bitumen expelled from kerogen due to swelling from dissolved heptane.
A novel 2D pulse sequence is used, comprising T1 encoding plus a solid-echo to acquire a T1-T*2G map. This is distinct from previous reports of 2D pulse sequences comprising T1 encoding plus FID to acquire a T1-T*2 map [17,18]; the advantage of the solid-echo is that it detects ≈15% more signal from the solid-like components than an FID, which is a result of the shorter effective deadtime for the spin-echo. The novel 2D pulse sequence is also distinct from previous reports of 2D pulse sequences comprising T1 encoding plus a solid-echo train to acquire a T1-T2 map [40,41]; the advantage of the solid-echo is the ≈10 times greater data-sampling rate compared to the solid-echo train, which allows for greater accuracy in the inversion of the solid-like components.
Theoretical Basis
The transverse relaxation function, specifically the Free Induction Decay (FID), can be expressed as follows [55]:
where M(t) is the transverse magnetization, M(0) is the signal amplitude (in porosity units) at t=0, and G(t) is the autocorrelation function for 1H-1H dipole-dipole interactions [56]. The second moment, defined as the strength of the 1H-1H dipole-dipole interaction, is given by Δω2=3G(0). The liquid-like regime exists in the “motional narrowing regime” Δωτc>>1, also known as the “Redfield limit”, where Δω={right arrow over (Δω2)} and τc is the characteristic correlation time of the molecular dynamics. The solid-like regime on the other hand exists in the limit Δωτc>>1. Note that for simplicity, Eq. (1) assumes ω0τc>>1 which for bitumen at 35° C. occurs above a viscosity of η>6.6×103 cP/f0 for frequency f0 in (MHz) units [57]. For example, at f0=20 MHz, the “slow-motion regime” occurs above η>330 cP at 35° C., while the “fast-motion regime” occurs below η<330 cP at 35° C.
For the solid-like signal (kerogen, bitumen, and clay hydroxyls) where Δωτc>>1, G(t) does not change much during the relaxation time T2G, therefore to a good approximation G(t) can be set to G(0) within the integral:
yielding a Gaussian decay with respect to t. The Gaussian relaxation time T2G is given by 1/T2G2=Δω2.
For the liquid-like signal (which includes pore fluids, dissolved fluids and clay-bound water) where Δωτc<<1, G(t) decays to 0 within the relaxation time T2e, therefore to a good approximation the limit of the integral can be taken to infinity:
yielding an exponential decay with respect to t. The exponential relaxation time T2e is given by
Note that one does not expect a sharp transition from exponential decay (where Δωτc<<1) to Gaussian decay (where Δωτc>>1). In other words, the functional form of the decay in M(t) is more complex in the transition regime where Δωτc≈1. In the case of bitumen, one can determine the viscosity at which the transition Δωτc≈1 occurs. Using the value Δω/2π≈20 kHz for the ubiquitous 1H-1H dipole-dipole interactions in bitumen, and assuming the empirical relation τc≈√{square root over (η/T)} for viscous fluids [57], predicts a transition at η≈107 cP at 35° C. In other words, bitumen acquires a solid-like Gaussian decay above η>107 cP at 35° C. Note that by contrast, for typical petrophysical systems T1 remains liquid-like (i.e., exponential) above Δωτc>>1.
Pulse Sequences
The pulse sequences involved in the methodology are illustrated in
Dephasing in an inhomogeneous magnetic field has the following effect on the transverse relaxation [20, 58]:
where T*2 is relaxation time from an FID or solid echo, T2 is the intrinsic relation time from CPMG, γ is the gyromagnetic ratio for 1H (γ/2π=42.57 MHz/T), B0 is the magnetic field strength, ΔB0 is the half-width of the magnetic field inhomogeneity across the 15 mm×20 mm sample, and Δ× is the susceptibility contrast between fluid and mineral. The dephasing term γΔB0 results in a full-width at half-maximum of Δf0≈1/πT*2≈500 Hz for the water calibration sample of size 15 mm×20 mm. Saturated cores of the same size also show Δf0≈500 Hz, implying that the γB0Δχ term is negligible compared to γΔB0. The net effect is that all the liquid-like signal with T2e>>1 ms is piled up at T*2≈1/πΔf0≈0.7 ms.
The RF pulses are t90=0.004 ms and t180=0.008 ms in duration. A dwell-time of tDW=0.4 μs is used. The deadtime of the FID in
For the solid-echo MSolid(t) in
A similar delay should also occur for the solid-echo, i.e., τs≈τS+2t90/π≈0.008 ms after the 90°y pulse. The extended τ′s≈0.008 ms should compensate for the ringing deadtime trdt=0.008 ms, resulting in detection of the solid-echo maximum. However, since the exact delay in τ′s for the solid-echo is not known, for practical purposes we instead compute an effective deadtime for the solid-echo based on (a) the known deadtime time td=0.01 ms for the FID, and (b) the criteria that MSolid(t) cannot be larger than MFID(t) at any given time. This results in an effective deadtime td=0.004 ms for the solid-echo.
The discretized time t for the CPMG magnetization MCPMG(t) in
The inversion recoveries in
All magnetization data M(t) and porosities ϕ are reported in porosity units (pu), where pu≡% BV (bulk volume of core plug), and the NMR hydrogen index is taken to be HINMR1 throughout, which for water and heptane is a good approximation. For convenience the solid components are also reported in (pu) using HINMR=1, which as shown below can then be readily converted to the more common units of mg-H/g-rock (i.e., mg of 1H per g of rock). We specify porosities for liquids ϕe (i.e., with exponential decay), solids ϕG (i.e., with Gaussian decay), and total ϕT=ϕe+ϕG. The units of the y-axis of the T2 distributions are in (pu/div), which stands for porosity unit per division. A division div=log10(T2,i+1)−log10(T2,i) is the logarithmic bin spacing, which is independent of index “i”. This unit convention ensures that a square distribution a decade wide and unit height has an area of 1 pu.
Splice Workflow
The novel workflow is illustrated in
A straight-forward extension of the above workflow to T1-T2 mapping is shown in
Inversion Algorithm
The inversion algorithm for either 1D T2 or 2D T1-T2 is based on the “inverse Laplace transform” (or technically speaking, a Fredholm integral of the first kind) outlined in [59,60]. For the 1D T2 case, the generalized equation relating the measured magnetization M(t) to the distribution P(T2) is given by the discrete form of:
M(t)=∫k2(t,T2)P(T2)dT2 (5)
The objective is to determine P(T2) using the following relation:
P=argmin{∥M−KP∥2+α∥P∥2}, for P≥0 (pu/div) (6)
where M(t)≡M and P(T2)≡P are vectors, kernel K is a matrix, and the Tikhonov regularization parameter α is a scalar, with positivity constraint P≥0. The supplementary material of [61] provides more details for how to implement the 1D inversion.
The multi-exponential kernel function k2e≡K is given by:
For the CPMG measurement MCPMG(t), the discretized t is given by t=ntE with echo-spacing tE=0.2 ms and echo number n.
The multi-Gaussian kernel function k2G is given by:
For the solid-echo component MG(t), the discretized t is given by t=td+ntDW with dead-time td, dwell-time tDW=0.4 μs and data number n. t0 is the time of maximum signal in the solid-echo; it is generally considered a free parameter, however for purposes of illustration herein it is fixed to t0=td given that MG(t) is flat at early times. Note that fixing t0=td implies that the inversion results are independent of td.
For the 2D T1-T2 case, the generalized equation relating the measured magnetization M(τ1, t) to the distribution P(T1, T2) is given by the discrete form of:
M(τ1,t)=∫∫k1(τ1,T1)k2(t,T2)P(T1,T2)dT1dT2 (9)
The multi-exponential kernel function k1e used for the inversion recovery (IR) sequences MCPMGIR(τ1, t) and MGIR(τ1, t) is given by:
where τ1 is the (discrete) inversion-recovery time. A saturation recovery (SR) sequence could be used instead, in which case the kernel function k1e is given by:
The 1D T2e and 1D T2G inversions were processed with 250 log-spaced bins ranging from 10−3↔104 ms, while the 2D T1-T2e and 2D T1-T*2G inversions were processed with 250×250 log-spaced bins both ranging from 10−3↔104 ms. A truncated SVD (singular-value-decomposition) of the kernel matrix K was performed; for computational efficiency, only the largest singular values were kept in the computation. Using a condition number of 1000 results in keeping the largest nSVD=9 singular values for the 1D inversions, and nSVD=52 singular values for the 2D inversions.
The χ misfit between SVD data and fit χ=∥M−KP∥ was computed as a function of regularization parameter α. The computation is started at a large α≈106, and then reduced at half-decade increments until the optimized αe is determined when the condition χ/χopt=1 is satisfied. The optimum misfit χopt is given by χopt=σ√{square root over (nSVD)} where σ is the experimental noise, a.k.a. the BRD (Butler-Reeds-Dawson) method. In cases where the condition χ/χopt=1 is not achieved, the condition d log χ/d log α=0.1 is used instead, a.k.a. the “heel” method.
Experimental
The methodologies in
The NMR measurements were performed on a benchtop Bruker minispec relaxometer at a Larmor frequency of ω0/2π=f0=20 MHz for 1H, probe diameter clearance of 18 mm, ambient pressure, and sample temperature of 35° C. The cores were resized from 1″×2″ (diameter×length) down to 15 mm×20 mm (bulk volume of BV≈3 cm3), then placed in a 15 mm ID glass tube with a Teflon stopper. The bulk density of the dry cores was measured by caliper, yielding ρB_dry≈1.76 g/cm3 at 913 m, and ρB_dry≈1.63 g/cm3 at 920 m.
The samples for bitumen extraction at 920 m were prepared differently. The core plugs were dried then underwent a “rough crush” by mortar and pestle down to 1⇔3 mm sized fragments. Half of the homogenized fragments were kept unextracted for NMR, while the other half were bitumen extracted. The bitumen extraction procedure was similar to [62], where 9:1 volume mixture of dichloromethane:methanol azeotrope (boiling point of 37.8° C.) was used in a Bailer-Walker extraction unit for two weeks. The bulk volume (BV≈1.5 cm3) for NMR was determined by mass of the dry fragments and known ρB_dry. The fragments were saturated in the same manner as the core plugs, and the excess surface fluid on the fragments was removed by controlled evaporation and T2 monitoring.
Geochemical analysis of the 920 m core was measured using RockEval-6 Basic pyrolysis [63,64], yielding S1≈3.5 mg_HC/g_rock, S2≈76 mg_HC/g_rock, HI≈725 mg_HC/g_orgC, Tmax≈424° C., and TOC≈10.5 wt %. The LECO method yielded slightly higher TOC≈11.6 wt %, where the rock powder was treated with HCl to remove calcite. Previous publications indicate a high sulfur content of ≈10⇔13 wt % [49].
A novel 1H NMR method is disclosed for separating liquid-like signals (micro/meso-macro fluids, clay-bound water, dissolved fluids) from solid-like signals (kerogen, bitumen, clay hydroxyls) based on T2 relaxation. The method detects solid-like signals (T*2G) with minimal deadtime using a solid-echo in a 20 MHz 1H NMR relaxometer, and liquid-like signal (T2e) using a CPMG measurement with a long echo train. The 1D T2 splice inversion method first separates the solid-like magnetization decay MG(t) from the liquid-like magnetization decay Me(t), then splices together the solid-like distribution P(T*2G) with the liquid-like distribution P(T2e), resulting in the 1D distribution P(T*2G; T2e). The 1D T2 splice technique is adapted to 2D T1-T2, which utilizes the inversion-recovery solid-echo MSolidIR(t) and inversion-recovery CPMG MCPMGIR(τ1, t), resulting in the 2D distribution P(T1, {T*2G; T2e}).
The method is used for analyzing cores from the organic-rich chalks from a NGL (natural gas liquid) reservoir of low kklink≈0.01 mD and high TOC≈11 wt % of Type II-S in the Golan Heights, Israel. The cores were dried then fully saturated with either water or heptane, followed by NMR measurements. A set of cutoffs are applied to the resulting 2D T1-{T*2G; T2e} maps to separate the liquid-like components into three regions: micro\meso-macro pore fluid (water or heptane), clay-bound water, and fluids (water or heptane) dissolved in bitumen. The pore network region shows diffusive coupling effects between the micro pores and the meso-macro pores, the extent of which is a function of the amount of bitumen blocking. The heptane in the pore network has a larger T/T2e≈8.5 than water T/T2e≈2.5, which shows potential for improved fluid typing and hydrocarbon saturation in organic-rich chalks.
A set of cutoffs are also applied to the 2D T1-{T*2G; T2e} maps to separate solid-like components into three regions: kerogen/bitumen with T/T*2G≈3700⇔4500, bitumen/hydroxyapatite with T1/T*2G≈1300⇔2000, and clay hydroxyls with T1/T*2G≈100⇔250. The signal in the clay hydroxyl region is identified as kaolinite based on 2D map of kaolinite isolates, plus its characteristic high hydroxyl content and low clay-bound water content. The signal in the bitumen/hydroxyapatite region is most likely bitumen but may also contain hydroxyapatite.
Additional insight into the kerogen/bitumen region is obtained by bitumen extraction of core fragments, and heptane saturation of the fragments before and after extraction. The data indicate a total of 14.9⇔15.6 pu kerogen, plus a total of 2.6⇔3.3 pu bitumen of which ≈1.7 pu can be easily extracted by solvents and 0.9⇔1.6 pu cannot be easily extracted by solvents. Furthermore, there is 2.6⇔3.6 pu heptane with T1/T2e≈50⇔110 which dissolves in the bitumen, causing the bitumen to swell and get expelled from the kerogen into the meso-macro pore network. With organic maturation, more of the kerogen converts to bitumen. With further increasing organic maturation into the oil window, the bitumen thermally cracks into lighter, producible hydrocarbons. The free bitumen signal shifts to longer T2 times as the viscosity is reduced due to the lighter hydrocarbons.
Another interpretation is proposed where the bitumen in the kerogen/bitumen peak consists of asphaltenes alone, while the bitumen signal in the bitumen/hydroxyapatite consists of the resins, aromatics, and saturates (i.e., the other SARA components of the bitumen). This would predict ≈75 wt % asphaltenes in the bitumen, which is reasonable given that this formation is immature.
The 2D maps indicate that the three organic components kerogen, bitumen, and dissolved heptane all have roughly the same T1˜40⇔50 ms. This indicates that strong cross-relaxation effects average out variations in T1 across 1H sites, where the variations in T1 result from differences in 1H-1H dipole-dipole interactions between 1H sites. The cross-relaxation effects in T1 have previously observed in heavy crude-oils and bitumen. On the other hand, cross-relaxation effects do not exist in T2, which allows for clear separation of kerogen, bitumen, and dissolved heptane with T2.
Splice Inversion
1D Inversion
The 1D splice inversion method for 913 m and 920 m cores at SW1 are shown in
Note that according to
The inversion optimization procedures for 913 m and 920 m cores at SW1 are shown in
The results of the 1D P(T*2G; T2e) distribution for 913 m and 920 m cores at SW1 are shown in
2D Inversion
The results of the 2D P(T1, {T*2G; T2e}) distribution obtained from the splice inversion is shown in
Liquid Components
The comparison of T1-{T*2G;T2e} maps between fully water saturated (SW1) and fully heptane saturated (SO1) samples using the splice 2D method are shown in
Table 1 shows signal amplitude ϕ (pu) and (T1/T2)pk (taken at the peak of the 2D distribution in
Micro/Meso-Macro Pores
The chalk is a micritic calcite, with a dual porosity system consisting of micro-pores (ϕ=11⇔12 pu) and meso-macro (ϕe=12⇔13 pu), with a total porosity of ϕe=22⇔24 pu [48]. The micro pore system in the micritic calcite is tight and water wet. On the other hand, the meso-macro pore system contains both calcite and kerogen and becomes mixed-wet as oil-wetting components are generated. For the 920 m core, the relaxation times T2e,pk≈9 ms and T1,pk≈24 ms at SW1 (fully water saturated) are shorter than T2e,pk≈15 ms and T1,pk≤123 ms at SO1 (fully heptane saturated). The difference in relaxation times between SW1 and SO1 is due to larger surface relaxivity for water in the micritic micro-pores compared to heptane in the micritic micro-pores.
The 913 m core shows similar trends between SW1 and SO1, however the T2e distributions are broader for 920 m than for 913 m, see
Fluid Typing
For both 913 m and 920 m cores, the (T1/T2e)pk≈8.5 at SO1 is significantly larger than (T1/T2e)pk≈2.5 at SW1, implying that the contrast in T1/T2e between water and light hydrocarbons is a good tool for fluid typing and saturation in organic-rich chalks at 20 MHz. The contrast in T1/T2e is due to larger confinement effects on heptane than on water, resulting in slower dynamics for heptane. As shown in polymer-heptane mixes, T1/T2e for heptane increases with decreasing concentration (i.e., increasing confinement) of heptane in the viscous polymer, and furthermore T1/T2e for heptane increases with increasing NMR frequency [57,65,66]. At has also been shown that diffusive coupling can play a role in the increase of T1/T2e for heptane as the heptane saturation is decreased (i.e., confinement is increased) in kerogen isolates [31].
In
The other fluid components consist of clay-bound water and dissolved fluids. A small amount of clay-bound water (ϕe=0.2⇔0.4 pu) with (T1/T2e)pk=2⇔5 is found, which is discussed below with regards to clay hydroxyls and clay mineral typing. Note that while the clay-bound water signal is visible on the 1D T2e projections, it is too small and broad to be visible with the 2D contours.
The amount of dissolved fluids depends on whether the fluid is water (ϕe≈1 pu) or heptane (ϕe=2⇔3 pu), indicating that more heptane is dissolved in the bitumen than water, as expected. There is also a large difference in T1/T2e between dissolved water (T1/T2e)pk≈16 at SW1 and dissolved heptane (T1/T2e)pk≈113 at SO1. These findings for the dissolved fluids agree with water versus heptane-saturated kerogen isolates [29]. As discussed below, the dissolved heptane swells the bitumen, which causes the bitumen to be expelled from the kerogen into the pore network.
Solid Components
The solid components in the T1-{T*2G; T2e} maps shown in
Clay Hydroxyls
The observation that there is more signal in the clay-hydroxyls region (ϕG≈1.5 pu) than clay-bound water (ϕe≈0.5 pu) indicates that the clays have a high number of hydroxyls per unit cell and low cation-exchange capacity, which, according to mineralogy shows the clay mineral is most likely kaolinite. According to the mineralogy from XRD at 920 m, there is about ≈3 vol % of unspecified clays, which we assume are kaolinite.
We note however that the location of the kaolinite powder signal in
Mineralogy from XRD also finds apatite (≈6.4 vol %) at 920 m.
The more likely origin of the ϕG≈1 pu signal in the bitumen/hydroxyapatite region of the cores at SW1 is bitumen.
Kerogen/Bitumen
More insight can be obtained about the kerogen/bitumen region of the 2D T1-{T*2G; T2e} maps by solvent extracting the bitumen and/or heptane saturating the samples. Note that the 920 m core was lightly crushed into fragments to improve the solvent extraction process (see Experimental), and that the NMR measurements were performed on the same set of homogenized fragments to maximize the accuracy.
Table 2 shows signal amplitude ϕ (pu) and (T1/T2)pk (taken at the peak of the 2D distributions in
Meanwhile, the smaller peak residing in the bitumen/hydroxyapatite region at T*2G≈0.05 ms remained roughly the same ϕG≈0.9 pu after solvent extraction, most likely because this bitumen is harder to extract. We note however that 30⇔40% of the bitumen in the bitumen/hydroxyapatite region was extracted from the more mature cores deeper in the well (data not shown).
Another contribution to the increase in T*2G for the expelled bitumen is that the bitumen acquires a lower viscosity because of the dissolved heptane, and therefore a longer T*2G. Note however that such a viscosity effect would require an exponential (i.e., fluid-like) T2e decay in magnetization MSolid(t) rather than Gaussian. Alternatively, the decay may be in between exponential and Gaussian during the glassy transition between solid and liquid. Based on the empirical relation T2e∝√{square root over (T/η)} for bitumen [57], the expelled bitumen has a viscosity of η≈107 cP at 35° C., which according to Section 2.1 is close to the transition regime. This increase in T2 is qualitatively like a recent publication where T2e of the bitumen increased (i.e., its viscosity decreased) as a result of thermal maturation by hydrous pyrolysis [38].
While the data in
To summarize the collection of data at 920 m in
Alternative Units
While expressing the solid-like signals in porosity units (pu) is convenient for comparing with liquids on the same plot, it is also helpful to convert (pu) into a ratio of 1H mass to dry rock mass. The mass of solid-like 1H is given by:
in units of (mg_H), where BV is the bulk volume of the rock, ρW=1 g/cm3 is the density of water, and ϕG is the signal intensity in (pu), where no HINMR Correction is required, i.e., HINMR=1. The mass of the dry core is Mdry_rock, from which bulk density ρB_dry=Mdry_rock/BV, which yields:
in units of (mg_H/g_rock), for the total mass of 1H per mass of dry rock.
Given that ρB_dry≈1.63 g/cm3 at 920 m, there is a total of ϕG=10.2⇔10.6 mg_H/g_rock from kerogen, and a total of ϕG=1.8⇔2.2 mg_H/g_rock from bitumen of which ϕG≈1.2 mg_H/g_rock are extracted by solvents and ϕG=0.6⇔1.1 mg_H/g_rock are not extracted by solvents.
Further conversion of (mg_H/g_rock) units into (mg_HC/g_rock) units (i.e., RockEval equivalent units for S1 and S2) requires independent knowledge of the H/C molar ratio [68] for both bitumen (S1) and kerogen (S2). Furthermore, given the high sulfur content in these cores (10⇔13 wt %), the H/S molar ratio would also have to be factored into the calculation since NMR relaxation does not distinguish 1H associated with carbon from 1H associated with sulfur.
Asphaltene Content
Another interpretation of the data in
A similar analysis for the saturates, aromatics, and resins can also be made based on the T*2G cutoffs shown in
Using this interpretation on the 920 m core in
Cross-Relaxation
The solid-like components indicate large T1/T*2G ratios, namely (T1/T*2G)pk=3700⇔4500 for kerogen/bitumen, (T1/T*2G)pk=1300⇔2000 for bitumen/hydroxyapatite, and (T1/T2e)pk=50⇔110 for dissolved heptane. However, note that while these three regions are well separated in {T*2G; T2e}, remarkably they all have similar T1,pk=40⇔50 ms values (
Cross relaxation in T1 has also been reported in viscous hydrocarbons such as crude-oils [72] and polymer-heptane mixes [57,65,66] at high frequencies (f0=400 MHz), as evidenced by a narrowing of the T1 distribution with increasing frequency and/or viscosity. This is also shown in the case of Athabasca bitumen in
This patent application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 63/324,710, filed on Mar. 29, 2022, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5497087 | Vinegar | Mar 1996 | A |
6991045 | Vinegar | Jan 2006 | B2 |
7526953 | Goodwin | May 2009 | B2 |
9552462 | Walters | Jan 2017 | B2 |
11099292 | Vinegar | Aug 2021 | B1 |
11131186 | Al-Garadi | Sep 2021 | B1 |
11486949 | MacMillan | Nov 2022 | B1 |
11921069 | Vinegar | Mar 2024 | B1 |
11933932 | Vinegar | Mar 2024 | B1 |
20060055403 | Freedman | Mar 2006 | A1 |
20090256562 | Gao | Oct 2009 | A1 |
20090288881 | Mullins | Nov 2009 | A1 |
20110088895 | Pop | Apr 2011 | A1 |
20120092007 | Li | Apr 2012 | A1 |
20120296617 | Zuo | Nov 2012 | A1 |
20130113480 | Kadayam Viswanathan | May 2013 | A1 |
20130161502 | Pomerantz | Jun 2013 | A1 |
20130234703 | Chen | Sep 2013 | A1 |
20140225607 | Edwards | Aug 2014 | A1 |
20150153433 | Paulsen | Jun 2015 | A1 |
20150168588 | Vinegar | Jun 2015 | A1 |
20150184500 | Vinegar | Jul 2015 | A1 |
20150210917 | Vinegar | Jul 2015 | A1 |
20150329785 | Vinegar | Nov 2015 | A1 |
20160091389 | Zuo | Mar 2016 | A1 |
20160341680 | Kadayam Viswanathan | Nov 2016 | A1 |
20180195383 | Smith | Jul 2018 | A1 |
20190017377 | He | Jan 2019 | A1 |
20200224080 | Nevison | Jul 2020 | A1 |
20200264116 | Gawankar | Aug 2020 | A1 |
20210285902 | Elsayed | Sep 2021 | A1 |
20220050223 | Tang | Feb 2022 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2542406 | Mar 2017 | GB |
2012123863 | Sep 2012 | WO |
2017151928 | Sep 2017 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Hürlimann, M.D., Diffusion and Relaxation Effects in General Stray Field NMR Experiments, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 148, 367-378, 2001. |
Acosta, R.H., Silletta, E.V., Monti, G.A., Garro Linck, Y., Bedini, P.C., Vila, G.S., Masiero, D.M., Domené, E.A., Velsco, M.I., Detection of solid organic material and fluids in the shale rock by means of low field NMR, US 2021/0123874 A1, 2021. |
Birdwell, J.E., Washburn, K.E., Multivariate analysis relating oil shale geochemical properties to NMR relaxometry, Energy Fuels, 29, 2234-2243, 2015. |
Boutis, G.S., Ravinath Kausik, R., Comparing the efficacy of solid and magic-echo refocusing sequences: Applications to 1H NMR echo spectroscopy of shale rock, Solid State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance 88, 22-28, 2017. |
Carvajal-Ortiz, H., Gentzis, T., Critical considerations when assessing hydrocarbon plays using Rock-Eval pyrolysis and organic petrology data: Data quality revisited, International Journal of Coal Geology, 152, 113-122, 2015. |
Chen, Q., Marble, A.E., Colpitts, B.G., Balcom, B.J., The internal magnetic field distribution, and single exponential magnetic resonance free induction decay, in rocks, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 175, 300-308, 2005. |
Chen, Z., Singer, P.M., Kuang, J., Vargas, F.M., Hirasaki, G.J., Effects of bitumen extraction on the 2D NMR response of saturated kerogen isolates, Petrophysics, 58, 470-484, 2017. |
Chen, Z., Singer, P.M., Wang, X., Hirasaki, G.J., Vinegar, H.J., Evaluation of light hydrocarbon composition, pore size, and tortuosity in organic-rich chalks using NMR core analysis and logging, Society of Petrophysicists and Well-Log Analysts, SPWLA-2019-K, 2019. |
Chen, Z., Singer, P.M., Wang, X., Vinegar, H.J., Nguyen, S.V., Hirasaki, G.J., NMR evaluation of light-hydrocarbon composition, pore size, and tortuosity in organic-rich chalks, Petrophysics 60 (06), 771-797, 2019. |
Cowan, B. Nuclear magnetic resonance and relaxation; Cambridge University Press, 1997. |
Dang, S.T., Sondergeld, C.H., Rai, C.S, Interpretation of nuclear-magnetic-resonance response to hydrocarbons: application to miscible enhanced-oil-recovery experiments in shales, Society of Petroleum Engineers, SPE Res Eval & Eng, 22 (01): 302-309, SPE-191144-PA, 2019. |
Dick, M.J., Veselinovic, D., Green, D., Review of recent developments in NMR core analysis, Petrophysics, 63 (3), 454, 2022. |
Enjilela, R., Guo, J., MacMillan, B., Marica, F., Afrough, A., Balcom, B., T1-T*2 relaxation correlation measurements, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 326, 106961, 2021. |
Fleury, M., Gautier, S., Norrant, F., Kohler E., Characterization of nano porous systems with low field NMR: application to kaolinite and smectite clays, Society of Core Analysts, SCA2011-32, 2011. |
Fleury, M., Kohler, E., Norrant, F., Gautier, S., M'Hamdi, J., Barré, L., Characterization and quantification of water in smectites with low-field NMR, Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 117, 4551-4560, 2013. |
Fleury, M., Romero-Sarmiento, M., Characterization of shales using T1-T*2 NMR maps, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 137, 55-62, 2016. |
Galeev, R.I., Sakharov, B.V., Khasanova, N.M., Volkov, V.Y., Fazlyyyakhmatov, M.G., Shamanov, I.N., Emelianov, D.A., Kozlova, E.V., Petrashov, O.V., Varfolomeev, M.A., Nurgaliev, D.K., Novel low-field NMR method for characterization content and SARA composition of bitumen in rocks, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 214, 110486, 2022. |
Gentzis, T., Carvajal-Ortiz, H., Xie, Z.H., Hackley, P.C., Fowler, H., An integrated geochemical, spectroscopic, and petrographic approach to examining the producibility of hydrocarbons from liquids-rich unconventional formations, Fuel, 298, 120357, 2021. |
Guo, J., MacMillan, B., Zamiri, M.S., Balcom, B.J., Magnetic resonance T1-T*2 and T1rho-T2* relaxation correlation measurements in solid-like materials with non-exponential decays, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 328, 107005, 2021. |
Guo, J., Zamiri, M.S., Balcom, B.J., Rapid measurement of T*1-T*2 relaxation correlation with a Look-Locker sequence, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 335, 107123, 2022. |
Jiang, T., Rylander, E., Singer, P.M., Lewis, R., Sinclair, S.M., Integrated petrophysical interpretation of Eagle Ford shale with 1-D and 2-D nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log Analysts, SPWLA-2013-LL, 2013. |
Kausik, K. Fellah, K., Rylander, E., Singer, P.M., Lewis, R.E., Sinclair, S.M., NMR relaxometry in shale and implications for logging, Petrophysics, 57, 339-350, 2016. |
Kausik, K., Freed, D., Fellah, K., Feng, L., Ling, Y., Simpson, G., Frequency and temperature dependence of 2D NMR T1-T2 maps of shale, Petrophysics, 60 (1), 2019. |
Khatibi, S., Ostadhassan, M., Xie, Z.H., Gentzis, T., Bubach, B., Gan, Z., Carvajal-Ortiz, H., NMR relaxometry a new approach to detect geochemical properties of organic matter in tight shales, Fuel, 235, 167-177, 2019. |
Kowalewski, J., Maler, L., Nuclear spin relaxation in liquids: theory, experiments, and applications, Series in Chemical Physics, Taylor & Francis, 2006. |
Li, J., Jiang, C., Wang, M., Xu, L., Li, M., Yu, C., Wu, Y., Lu, S., Determination of in situ hydrocarbon contents in shale oil plays. Part 1: Is routine Rock-Eval analysis reliable for quantifying the hydrocarbon contents of preserved shale cores?, Organic Geochemistry, 170, 104449, 2022. |
Li, J., Jiang, C., Wang, M., Xu, L., Li, M., Yu, C., Wu, Y., Lu, S., Determination of in situ hydrocarbon contents in shale oil plays. Part 2: Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (2D NMR) as a potential approach to characterize preserved cores, Marine and Petroleum Geology, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2022.105890, 2022. |
Liu, B., Bai, L., Chi, Y., Jia, R., Fu, X. Yang, L., Geochemical characterization and quantitative evaluation of shale oil reservoir by two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance and quantitative grain fluorescence on extract: A case study from the Qingshankou Formation in Southern Songliao Basin, northeast China, Marine and Petroleum Geology, 109, 561-573, 2019. |
Liu, K., Gentzis, T., Carvajal-Ortiz, H., Xie, Z.H., Ostadhassan, M., Experimental investigation of solid organic matter with a 2D NMR T1-T2 map, Energy Fuels, 35, 19, 15709-15720, 2021. |
McCarthy, K., Rojas, K., Niemann, M., Palrnowski, D., Peters, K., Stankiewicz, A., Basic petroleum geochemistry for source rock evaluation, Oilfield Review, 23(2), 32-43, 2011. |
Mitchell, J., Gladden, L.F., Chandrasekera, T.C., Fordham, E.J., Low-field permanent magnets for industrial process and quality control, Progress in Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy, 76, 1-60, 2014. |
Nicot, B., Vorapalawut, N., Rousseau, B., Madariaga, L.F., Hamon, G., Korb, J.-P., Estimating saturations in organic shales using 2D NMR, Petrophysics, 57(1), 19-29, 2016. |
Ozen A.E., Sigal R.F., T1/T2 NMR surface relaxation ratio for hydrocarbons and brines in contact with mature organic-shale reservoir rocks, Petrophysics 54 (1), 11-19. 2013. |
Panattoni, F., Colbourne, A.A, Fordham, E.J., Mitchell, J., Grey, C.P., Magusin, P.C.M.M., Improved description of organic matter in shales by enhanced solid fraction detection with low-field 1H NMR relaxometry, Energy Fuels, 35 (22), 18194-18209, 2021. |
Powles, J.G., Mansfield, P., Double-pulse nuclear-resonance transients in solids, Physics Letters, 2, 58-59, 1962. |
Powles, J.G., Strange, J.H., Zero time resolution nuclear magnetic resonance transients in solids, Proceedings of the Physical Society, 82, 6-15, 1963. |
Rosenberg, Y.O., Reznik, I.J., Vinegar, H.J., Feinstein, S., Bartov, Y., Comparing natural and artificial thermal maturation of a Type II-S source rock, Late Cretaceous, Israel, Marine and Petroleum Geology, 124, 104773, 2021. |
Rylander, E., Singer, P.M., Jiang, T., Lewis, R.E., McLin, R., Sinclair, S.M., NMR T2-distributions in the Eagle Ford shale: Reflections on pore size, Society of Petroleum Engineers, SPE-164554-MS, 2013. |
Silletta, E.V., Delfa, G.M., Velasco, M.I., Donadelli, J.A., Monti, G.A., Smal, C., Acosta, R.H., Quantification of imbibed heptane in shale rocks determined by edited T1-T2 nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation experiments at high magnetic field, Energy Fuels, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.energyfuels.2c01554, 2022. |
Silletta, E.V., Vila, G.S., Domené, E.A., Velasco, M.I., Bedini, P.C., Garro-Linck, Y., Masiero, D., Monti, G.A., Acosta, R.H., Organic matter detection in shale reservoirs using a novel pulse sequence for T1-T2 relaxation maps at 2 MHZ, Fuel, 312, 122863, 2022. |
Singer, P. M., Valiya Parambathu, A., Wang, X., Asthagiri, D., Chapman, W.G., Hirasaki, G.J., Fleury, M., Elucidating the 1H NMR relaxation mechanism in polydisperse polymers and bitumen using measurements, MD simulations, and models, J. Phys. Chem. B, 124, 4222, 2020. |
Singer, P.M, Asthagiri, D., Chapman, W.G., Hirasaki, G.J., Molecular dynamics simulations of NMR relaxation and diffusion of bulk hydrocarbons and water, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 277, 15-24, 2017. |
Singer, P.M, Chen, Z., Hirasaki, G.J., Fluid typing and pore size in organic shale using 2D NMR in saturated kerogen isolates, Petrophysics, 57, 604-619, 2016. |
Singer, P.M., Arsenault, A., Imai, T., Fujita, M., 139La NMR investigation of the interplay between the lattice, charge, and spin dynamics in charge ordered high Tc cuprate La1.875Ba0.125CuO4, Physical Review B, 101, 174508, 2020. |
Singer, P.M., Asthagiri, D., Chen, Z., Valiya Parambathu, A., Hirasaki, G.J., Chapman, W.G., Role of internal motions and molecular geometry on the NMR relaxation of hydrocarbons, Journal of Chemical Physics, 148 (16), 164507, 2018. |
Singer, P.M., Chen, Z., Alemany L.B., Hirasaki, G.J., Zhu, K., Xie, Z.H., Vo, T.D., Interpretation of NMR relaxation in bitumen and organic shale using polymer-heptane mixes, Energy Fuels, 32 (2), 1535, 2018. |
Singer, P.M., Chen, Z., Wang, X., Hirasaki, G.J., Diffusive coupling in heptane-saturated kerogen isolates evidenced by NMR T1-T2 and T2-T2 maps, Fuel, 280, 118626, 2020. |
Singer, P.M., Rylander, E., Jiang, T., Lewis, R.E., McLin, R., Sinclair, S.M., 1D and 2D NMR core-log integration in organic shale, Society of Core Analysts, SCA2013-18, 2013. |
Song, Y.Q., Venkataramanan, L., Hurlimann, M.D., Flaum, M., Frulla, P., Straley, C., T1-T2 correlation spectra obtained using a fast two-dimensional Laplace inversion, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 154, 261-268, 2002. |
Ungerer, P., Collell, J., Yiannourakou, M., Molecular modeling of the volumetric and thermodynamic properties of kerogen: Influence of organic type and maturity, Energy Fuels, 29, 91-105, 2015. |
Valiya Parambathu, A., Singer, P.M., Hirasaki, G.J., Chapman, W.G., Asthagiri, D., Critical role of confinement in the NMR surface relaxation and diffusion of n-heptane in a polymer matrix revealed by MD simulations, J. Phys. Chem. B, 124, 3801, 2020. |
Valori, A., Hursan, G., Ma, S.M., Laboratory and downhole wettability from NMR T1/T2 ratio, Petrophysics, 58, 352-365, 2017. |
Valori, A., Van Den Berg, S., Ali, F., Abdallah, W., Permeability estimation from NMR time dependent methane saturation monitoring in shales, Energy Fuels, 31, 5913, 2017. |
Venkataramanan, L., Song, Y.Q., Hurlimann, M. D., Solving Fredholm integrals of the first kind with tensor product structure in 2 and 2.5 dimensions, IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, 50, 1017-1026, 2002. |
Vinegar, E.G., Rosenberg, Y.O., Reznick, I., Gordin, Y., Singer, P.M., Wang, X., Chen, Z., Nguyen, S.V., Li, W., Bradley, T., Hirasaki, G.J., Lake, L.W., Feinstein, S., Hatzor, Y.H., Vinegar, H.J., What happens to the petrophysical properties of a dual porosity organic-rich chalk during early-stage organic maturation?, Society of Petrophysicists and Well-Log Analysts, SPWLA-5092, 2020. |
Volkov, V.Y., Al-Muntaser, A.A., Varfolomeev, M.A., Khasanova, N.M., Sakharov, B.V., Suwaid, M.A., Djimasbe, R., Galeev, R.I., Nurgaliev, D.K., Low-field NMR-relaxometry as fast and simple technique for in-situ determination of SARA-composition of crude oils, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 196, 107990, 2021. |
Wang, X., Singer, P.M., Chen, Z., Hirasaki, G.J., Vinegar, H.J., A new method of estimating tortuosity and pore size in unconventional formations using NMR restricted diffusion measurements, Society of Petrophysicists and Well-Log Analysts, SPWLA-5046, 2020. |
Wang, X., Singer, P.M., Liu, Y., Chen, Z., Hirasaki, G.J., Vinegar, H.J., Pore size, tortuosity, and permeability from NMR restricted diffusion in organic-rich chalks, Petrophysics 62(3), 244-264, 2021. |
Washburn, K.E., Anderssen, E., Vogt, S.J., Seymour, J.D., Birdwell, J.E., Kirkland, C.M., Codd, S.L., Simultaneous Gaussian and exponential inversion for improved analysis of shales by NMR relaxometry, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 250, 7-16, 2015. |
Washburn, K.E., Birdwell, J.E., Updated methodology for nuclear magnetic resonance characterization of shales, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 233, 17-28, 2013. |
Washburn, K.E., Relaxation mechanisms and shales, Concepts in Magnetic Resonance Part A, 43A (3), 57-78, 2014. |
Xie, Z.H., Gentzis, T., Carvajal-Ortiz, H., Measuring kerogen, solid organics, and oil production potentials of unconventional source rocks using solid type 20-MHZ NMR techniques, Society of Petrophysicists and Well-Log Analysts, SPWLA-2021-0094, 2021. |
Xu, C., Xie, R., Guo, J., Jin, G., Fan, W., Xiao, L., Comprehensive characterization of petrophysical properties in shale by solvent extraction experiments and 2D NMR, Fuel, 335, 127070, 2023. |
Yang, K., Connolly, P.R.J., Li, M., Seltzer, S.J., McCarty, D.K., Mahmoud, M., El-Husseiny, A., May, E.F., Johns, M.L., Shale rock core analysis using NMR: Effect of bitumen and water content, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 195, 107847, 2020. |
Yang, Z., Hirasaki, G.J., NMR measurement of bitumen at different temperatures, Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 192, 280-293, 2008. |
Zamiri, M.S., Guo, J., Marica, F., Romero-Zerón, L., Balcom, B.J., Characterization of kerogen in shale core plugs using T2*-based magnetic resonance methods, Fuel, 324, 124573, 2022. |
Zamiri, M.S., MacMillan, B., Marica, F., Guo, J., Romero-Zerón, L., Balcom, B.J., Petrophysical and geochemical evaluation of shales using magnetic resonance relaxation correlation, Fuel, 284, 119014, 2021. |
Zamiri, M.S., Marica, F., Romero-Zeron, L., Balcom, B.J., Monitoring shale water uptake using 2D magnetic resonance relaxation correlation and SPRITE MRI, Chemical Engineering Journal, 428, 131042, 2022. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63324710 | Mar 2022 | US |