Method of determining the engine charge temperature for fuel and spark control of an internal combustion engine

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6286366
  • Patent Number
    6,286,366
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, November 11, 1998
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 11, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A technique for determining the charge air temperature within an intake manifold of an internal combustion engine of a vehicle without using a dedicated temperature sensor. The technique includes identifying a non-linear dynamic model based on the physical concepts of thermal transfer and system identification technique. The charge air temperature model uses several available physical measurements from the vehicle, including inlet air temperature, engine coolant temperature, vehicle speed, manifold pressure, engine speed, exhaust gas recirculation condition, and the engine fan on/off state. The model parameters are determined based on specific vehicle characteristics, and collected data from the vehicle. The charge air temperature is predicted by the model at regular predetermined intervals from the physical measurements, the vehicle parameters and the charge air temperature from the previous time. An estimation of an initial charge air temperature when the vehicle is turned on can be obtained based on the available temperature sensor readings when vehicle is turned on and stored data of the charge temperature, and all the measured temperature readings just before the engine was turned off.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates generally to a method of determining the air temperature in the intake manifold of an internal combustion engine and, more particularly, to a method of defining a dynamic temperature model that predict the temperature of the air in the intake manifold of an internal combustion engine based on thermal transfer and vehicle parameters of the engine.




2. Discussion of the Related Art




Most internal combustion engines associated with a vehicle incorporate a temperature sensor positioned within the intake manifold of the engine to determine the temperature of the air entering the engine cylinders, sometimes referred to as the engine charge air temperature. This temperature measurement is important to provide the signals that control fuel and spark to the cylinders at the appropriate time for proper and efficient operation of the engine. Because colder air is more dense than hotter air, the amount of air charge in the cylinders is different depending on the charge air temperature, and thus the application of fuel and spark to the cylinders needs to vary depending on this temperature. In other words, the charge temperature is critical because this temperature determines the charge air quantity entering the cylinders regardless of the different ambient conditions. The charge temperature thus affects automatic idle speed (AIS), knock, start fuel and on-board diagnostics (OBD) features of the engine. Currently, a “speed-density” method is used for the fuel control. In combination with MAP and RPM readings, the charge temperature is used to determine the fuel injection pulse width control signal.





FIG. 1

depicts an engine control module


10


including a central processing unit (CPU)


12


. A number of sensor inputs are applied to the CPU


12


, and outputs from the engine control module


10


control certain operations of the vehicle engine, as is understood in the art. An ambient temperature measurement is currently provided to the engine control module


10


to control the engine radiator fan, A/C, exhaust gas recirculation (EGR), target idle speed, purge, O


2


sensor diagnostics and start fuel controls. It has been determined that a relationship exists between the ambient air temperature and the charge temperature. However, current vehicles incorporate separate temperature sensors to measure both.




Temperature sensors are known, such as thermocouples, that can give highly accurate temperature measurements of the engine charge temperature. However, the type of temperature sensor generally positioned within the intake manifold is typically an inexpensive heat resistive element whose accuracy is limited.




What is needed is a technique for determining the charge temperature of the air in the intake manifold of an internal combustion vehicle that does not require a dedicated charge air temperature sensor, so as to eliminate the cost of the sensor and improve charge temperature accuracy. It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide such a technique.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In accordance with the teachings of the present invention, a non-linear, dynamic charge air temperature model is disclosed for determining the charge air temperature within an intake manifold of an internal combustion engine, where the charge air temperature model is based on the physical concepts of heat transfer and the system identification techniques. The charge air temperature model uses several available physical measurements from the vehicle, including inlet air temperature, engine coolant temperature, vehicle speed, manifold absolute pressure, engine speed, exhaust gas recirculation condition, and the engine radiator fan on/off state. The current charge air temperature is determined by the model at regular predetermined intervals from the physical measurements which are available in the engine systems, and the charge air temperature from the previous time. An estimation of an initial charge air temperature when the vehicle is initially turned on can be obtained based on the measurement of the engine coolant temperature and the inlet air temperature both at the time when the engine is turned off and at the time the engine is turned on, together with the estimated charge air temperature just before the engine is turned off.




Additional objects, advantages, and features of the present invention will become apparent from the following description and appended claims, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a block diagram showing the inputs and outputs of an engine control module;





FIG. 2

is a system view of a charge temperature prediction model, according to an embodiment of the present invention; and





FIG. 3

is an off-line procedure of model parameter calibration for the prediction module shown in FIG.


2


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




The following description of the preferred embodiments directed to a charge temperature prediction model for an internal combustion engine is merely exemplary in nature, and is in no way intended to limit the invention or its applications or uses. For example, the prediction model of the invention is specifically used for determining the charge air temperature of an internal combustion engine. However, the model may have uses in other areas for estimating or predicting temperature.




According to the present invention, a charge temperature prediction model has been developed based on the physical concepts of heat transfer and system identification technique to determine the charge temperature for a particular vehicle engine. Even though a physical relationship does exist between the ambient air temperature and the charge temperature, determination of the charge temperature is very complicated and affected by many engine operating conditions. In one embodiment, determination of the charge temperature T


m


by the model is based on an inlet air temperature T


in


measurement in combination with other already available engine data, including engine coolant temperature T


c


, vehicle speed V


s


, manifold pressure P, engine speed N, exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) condition, and the engine radiator fan on/off state V


f


. As will be discussed below, these vehicle parameters, in combination with the physical concepts of heat transfer, will be used to estimate the charge temperature T


m


.




First, it may be advantageous to develop a theoretical model of heat transfer that can be used to define the charge temperature model. The charge air temperature in the manifold is not only a heat transfer process but also a gas dynamic process. The basic governing equation of the temperature dynamics in the manifold is given by:

















T
m




t


=







T
m



P
m



V
m



[



a
a
2




m
ai



(

1
-


T
m


γ






T
a




)



+


a
3
2




m
ci



(

1
-


T
m


γ






T
e




)



-
















(

γ
-
1

)



η
vol



P
m



ND
nx


+



hA
w



(

γ
-
1

)




(


T
mw

-

T
m


)



]










where







m
ai

=




A
t



C
D



P
a



a
a
2








2

γ






C
p


R




[

1
-


X
1



γ
-
1

γ



]



1
2




X
1

1
γ











m
ei

=




A
e



C
De



P
e



a
e
2








2

γ






C
p


R




[

1
-


X
1



γ
-
1

γ



]



1
2




X
1

1
γ








(
1
)













where,




η


vol


is the engine volumatic efficiency;




N is the engine speed;




D is the engine displacement;




n is the number of cylinders;




x is the number of fire strokes in one revolution;




h is the heat transfer coefficient;




A is the surface area of the manifold;




γ is the ratio of specific heat;




a is the sound speed of gas;




t is the time;




C


P


is the constant pressure specific heat;




R is the gas constant; and




C


D


is the discharge coefficient.




Subscript:




a is the ambient air;




e is the exhaust gas;




m is the parameters in the manifold;




w is the parameters on the manifold wall; and




t is the parameters at throttle.




In equation (1), X is the pressure ratio across the throttle plate and the EGR valve, a is the speed of sound, X


1


accounts for choked flow (X


1


=0.528 if X<0.528 and X


1


=X if X>0.0528), and T


mw


is the mean manifold surface temperature. The equation defining T


mw


may be expressed as:













T
mw




t


=




T
e

-

T
mw



R
c


+



T
a

-

T
mw



R
a


+



T
i

-

T
mw



R
f


+



T
c
4

-

T
mw
4



R
r







(
2
)













R


c


is the heat conduction heat resistance, R


f


means the forced convection heat resistance R


a


is referred to as the natural convection heat resistance, and R


r


is the radiation heat resistance.




These equations give an understanding to what physical variables the charge temperature is related to. However, these equations can not be used in the real time charge temperature prediction. First, the above equations require several inputs that are not available from the existing measurements in an engine control unit, such as the temperature and pressure of the ambient air and exhaust gas. Secondly, these equations contain many unknown nonlinear parameters and they are not easily determined or identified in a real application. Thirdly, the equations are mathematically complicated for a real time embedded system used in an engine control unit. They include several mathematical operations such as root square, exponential, division, that are time consuming for an embedded system to solve and thus the implementation may be a problem for a processor with limited computational resources. Because of these reasons, a new and simple method for the charge temperature predictions has been developed according to the invention. With the help of system identification techniques and vehicle test data, an empirical dynamic model for the charge temperature has been developed, based on physical concepts.




According to the invention, the charge temperature equation is given as:
















T
m




t


=








f
cv



(

N
,
P
,
EGR

)








(


T
m

-

T
in


)


+



f
cd



(


V
s

,

V
f

,

T
c


)




(


T
o

+

T
in


)


+















f
cr



(


V
s

,

V
f

,

T
c


)




T
ck
4


+


f
mr



T
mk
4










(
3
)













The function f


cv


in the first term of equation (3) provides the heat transfer contribution to the rate of charge temperature change dT


m


/dt as the difference between the charge temperature T


m


and the inlet air temperature T


in


entering the manifold. This contribution is based on the engine speed N, the pressure P in the intake manifold and the exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) condition. The function F


cd


in the second term of equation (3) provides the heat transfer contribution to the rate charge temperature change dT


m


/dt as the difference of the engine coolant temperature T


c


and the air inlet temperature T


in


. This contribution is based on the vehicle speed V


s


, the radiator fan on/off state V


f


and the temperature of the engine coolant T


c


. The function f


cr


in the third term of equation (3) provides the heat transfer contribution from heat radiation from the engine block based on the coolant temperature T


ck


. This contribution is based on the vehicle speed V


s


, the radiator fan on/off state V


f


and the engine coolant temperature T


c


. The function f


mr


in the fourth term of equation (3) provides the radiation heat transfer effect from the manifold itself, where T


ck


and T


mk


are the absolute temperature of T


c


and T


m


, respectively.




Since the gas dynamic process is much faster than the heat transfer process, the engine speed N, the manifold pressure P and the EGR condition play the most significant roles in the quick response change of charge temperature T


m


. The coolant temperature T


c


, the inlet air temperature T


in


and the vehicle speed V


s


which evolve in the intake manifold heat transfer process have a slow influence on the charge temperature. When the engine is hot, the radiative heat transfer is also not negligible.




Based on the theoretical models, the rate of intake charge temperature change dT


m


/dt has now been defined as a function of related engine operation variables, as discussed above. For the practical implementation in the engine control unit, a discrete model of the difference equation (3) can then be defined as:






T


m


(n)=T


m


(n−1)+f


cv


[T


m


(n−1)−T


in


(n−1)]+f


cd


[T


c


(n−1)−T


in


(n−1)]+f


cr


T


ck




4


(n−1)+f


mr


T


mk




4


(n−


1)


  (4)






where,






f


cv


=a


0


+a


1


N(n−1)+a


2


N


2


(n−1)+a


3


N


3


(n−1)+a


4


N(n−1)P(n−1) +a


5


R(n−1)+a


6


P(n−1)R(n−1)+a


7


P


2


(n−1)+a


8


P


3


(n−1)R(n−1)








f


cd


b


0


+b


1


V


s


(n−1)+b


2


V


n


(n−1)+b


3


V


f


(n−1)








f


cr


C


0


+C


1


V


s


(n−1)+C


2


V


n


(n−1)+C


3


V


f


(n−1)








V


n


(n−1)=[α


0


−T


c


(n−1)][1−V


s


(n−1)]if T


c


(n−1)<α


0


; otherwise V


n


(n−1)=0








T


ck


(n−1)=β


0





1


T


c


(n−1)








T


mk


(n−1)=β


0





1


T


m


(n−1)






Here, n represents the current time and n−1 represents the previous time. The sampling time or the time interval between the executions is fixed. The current charge air temperature T


m


(n) is calculated from the previous charge air temperature T


m


(n−1), coolant temperature T


c


(n−1), inlet air temperature T


in


(n−1), vehicle speed V


s


(n−1), fan on/off state V


f


(n−1), engine speed N(n−1), manifold absolute pressure P(n−1), exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) duty cycle percentage R(n−1). Here, a


0


. . . a


8


, b


0


. . . b


3


, C


0


. . . C


3


, α


0


, β


0


and β


1


are predetermined parameters and constants for a particular vehicle engine based on actual tests conducted on the engine at the development stage. Therefore, once these coefficients are determined for a particular vehicle, they are fixed for that vehicle to accurately determine the charge temperature T


m


.





FIG. 2

shows a block diagram of a first order non-linear dynamic system


16


based on equations (3). The dynamic system


16


is separated into a feed forward portion


18


and a feedback portion


20


. In the feed forward portion


18


, the f


cd


heat transfer contribution is determined by subtracting the inlet air temperature T


in


from the engine coolant temperature T


c


in a summer


22


, and applying the difference to a function block


24


that determines f


cd


based on the vehicle speed V


s


, the radiator fan on/off state V


f


, and the coolant temperature T


c


. To determine the heat transfer contribution from heat radiation from the engine block, the engine coolant temperature T


ck


is multiplied to the fourth power in block


26


, and the coefficient function f


cr


is determined in block


28


based on the vehicle speed V


s


, the radiator fan on/off state V


f


, and the coolant temperature T


c


.




In the feed forward portion


18


, to determine the heat contribution from the term f


cv


, the inlet air temperature T


in


is subtracted from the charge temperature Tm in a summer


30


, and f


cv


is determined in block


32


based on the engine speed N, the manifold pressure P, and the EGR condition. To determine the contribution from the heat radiation from the intake manifold, the charge temperature T


mk


is multiplied to the fourth power in block


34


, and f


mr


is then determined in block


36


. Each of the heat contribution from function blocks f


cd


, f


cr


, f


cv


and f


mr


are then added together in a summer


38


. This gives the change in charge temperature with respect to time dT


m


/dt, which is integrated by an integrator


40


to generate the charge temperature T


m


.




The technique for the parameter identification is to first define a prediction error function ε


i


(q) in terms of the measured charge temperature {circumflex over (T)}


m


(t


i


)for N=1, . . . , N, and the predicted charge temperature T


in


(t


i


,q), for i=1, . . . , N, from the model including the parameter vector q=[a


0


,a


1


, . . . , a


8


, b


1


, . . . , b


3


, c


0


, c


1


, . . . . c


3


]. The error function is given as:






ε


i


(q)=T


m


(t


i


,q)−{circumflex over (T)}


m


(t


i


)  (5)






Then, the parameters q are determined by minimizing the square error in all t


i


, for i=1, . . . , N, as:









min









i
=
1

N




ϵ
i
2



(
q
)







(
6
)













The procedure for determining the coefficients is illustrated in a flow diagram


46


shown in FIG.


3


. The charge temperature T


m


and the model's input data are collected for training at box


48


. Then, initial values and coefficients for the particular vehicle are identified at box


50


. The parameters are downloaded to an engine controller for real time prediction as indicated by box


52


. The performance verification includes data collection for evaluation during the performance test, as indicated by box


54


. A decision diamond


56


determines if the coefficients accurately satisfy the charge temperature prediction based on the comparison with actual temperature measurements. If not, the process is performed again with new or modified coefficients.




When the engine is cool, the charge temperature T


m


is equal to the inlet air temperature T


in


In the case of a hot restart, the charge temperature T


m


is different from the inlet air temperature T


in


due to the air flow pipe and manifold heating effect. Therefore, an estimation of initial charge temperature is required.




When the engine is off, there is no way to keep track of the charge temperature T


m


. When the engine is turned on, the coolant temperature T


c


and the inlet air temperature T


in


are immediately available. These values are not enough to accurately determine the initial charge temperature T


m


. In order to estimate the initial charge temperature T


m


, the values of the coolant T


c


, inlet air temperature T


in


and predicted charge temperature T


m


just before the engine was turned off in the previous engine start are required. These values could be stored in a non volatile memory when the engine is shut off.




To obtain the initial value of the charge temperature T


m


after the engine is turned on, a set of engine-off differential equations are solved from the available information. To simplify the problem, the radiation effect is neglected in the engine-off model. Three unknowns, T


m


, T


i


, and t can be obtained by solving the following three equations.













T
m




t


=



f
11



T
c


+


f
12



T
i


+


f
13



T
in


+


f
14



T
m







(
7
)










T
c




t


=



f
21



T
c


+


f
22



T
i


+


f
23



T
in


+


f
24



T
m







(
8
)










T
in




t


=



f
31



T
c


+


f
32



T
i


+


f
33



T
in


+


f
34



T
m







(
9
)













where T


i


is the ambient temperature, t denotes time and f


ij


are the constants which may be equal to zero when the coefficient is very small. Once the initial value is established, the estimation becomes a routine with each time step.




The foregoing discussion discloses and describes merely exemplary embodiments of the present invention. One skilled in the art will readily recognize from such discussion, and from the accompanying drawings and claims, that various changes, modifications and variations can be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as defined in the following claims.



Claims
  • 1. A method of determining a charge air temperature of a vehicle, said method comprising the steps of:determining an inlet air temperature to a manifold of the vehicle; determining an engine coolant temperature; determining a speed of the vehicle; determining a manifold absolute pressure within the manifold of the vehicle; determining a speed of the vehicle engine; determining an exhaust gas recirculation condition; determining an on/off state of a vehicle engine fan; and determining the charge air temperature based on heat transfer and vehicle parameters, including determining the charge air temperature by an equation that uses the inlet air temperature, the engine coolant temperature, the vehicle speed, the manifold pressure, the engine speed, the exhaust gas recirculation condition and the engine fan on/off state as inputs to the equation, wherein the step of determining the charge air temperature includes adding together several heat contribution terms, wherein a first heat contribution term is based on the engine speed, the manifold pressure and the exhaust gas recirculation condition, a second heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state, and the engine coolant temperature, a third heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state and the engine coolant temperature, and a fourth heat contribution term is based on the heat transfer of the manifold, and wherein the equation is: ⅆTmⅆt= ⁢fcv⁡(N,P,EGR)⁢ ⁢(Tm-Tin)+fcd⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢(To+Tin)+ ⁢fcr⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢Tck4+fmr⁢Tmk4where fcv is a coefficient for the first term, fcd is a coefficient for the second term, fcr is a coefficient for the third term and fmr is a coefficient for the fourth term, wherein the coefficients fcv, fcd, fcr, and fmr are based on vehicle parameters, N is the engine speed, P is the intake manifold pressure, BGR is the exhaust gas recirculation condition, Vs is the vehicle speed, Vf is the radiator fan on/off state, Tc is the engine coolant temperature and Tm is the charge air temperature.
  • 2. The method according to claim 1 wherein the step of determining the charge air temperature includes using an already determined charge air temperature from a previous step of determining the charge air temperature.
  • 3. The method according to claim 1 further comprising the steps of determining particular system data and model parameters for a particular vehicle.
  • 4. The method according to claim 3 wherein the steps of determining particular system data and model parameters for a particular vehicle includes performing an estimation routine including collecting data during a vehicle test for the particular vehicle.
  • 5. The method according to claim 3 wherein the steps of determining the particular system data and model parameters includes identifying a plurality of unique variables for the particular vehicle.
  • 6. The method according to claim 3 wherein the step of determining model parameters includes defining a prediction error function in terms of measured charged temperatures.
  • 7. The method according to claim 1 further comprising the step of determining initial values for the charge air temperature when the vehicle engine is first turned on.
  • 8. The method according to claim 7 wherein the step of determining the initial parameters includes determining the initial values based on the model, measured vehicle parameters remembered before the engine was turned off, and all other available measured data when the engine is turned on.
  • 9. A method of determining a charge air temperature of a vehicle, aid method comprising the steps of:determining physical concepts of thermal transfer associated with the vehicle; determining a plurality of vehicle system parameters, said vehicle parameters including an exhaust gas recirculation condition and an on/off state of a vehicle engine fan; and determining the charge air temperature by an equation that calculates the charge air temperature from inputs of the physical concepts of heat transfer and the vehicle system parameters, wherein the step of determining the vehicle system parameters includes determining an inlet air temperature to a manifold of the vehicle, an engine coolant temperature, the speed of the vehicle, a manifold pressure within the manifold of the vehicle, the speed of the vehicle engine, an exhaust gas recirculation condition, and the on/off state of a vehicle engine fan, and wherein the step of determining the charge air temperature includes adding together several heat contribution terms, wherein a first heat contribution term is based on the engine speed, the manifold pressure and the exhaust gas recirculation condition, a second heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state, and the engine coolant temperature, a third heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state and the engine coolant temperature, and a fourth heat contribution term is based on the heat transfer of the manifold, said equation being: ⅆTmⅆt= ⁢fcv⁡(N,P,EGR)⁢ ⁢(Tm-Tin)+fcd⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢(To+Tin)+ ⁢fcr⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢Tc4+fmr⁢Tm4where fcv is a coefficient for the first term, fcd is a coefficient for the second term, fcr is a coefficient for the third term and fmr is a coefficient for the fourth term, wherein the coefficients fcv, fcd, fcr, and fmr are based on vehicle parameters, N is the engine speed, P is the intake manifold pressure, EGR is the exhaust gas recirculation condition, Vs is the vehicle speed, Vf is the radiator fan on/off state, Tc is the engine coolant temperature and T m is the charge air temperature.
  • 10. The method according to claim 9 wherein the step of determining a plurality of vehicle system parameters includes defining a prediction error function in terms of measured charge temperature.
  • 11. The method according to claim 9 further comprising the steps of determining particular system data and coefficient variables for a particular vehicle.
  • 12. The method according to claim 11 wherein the step of determining system data and coefficient variables includes performing an estimation routine including collecting data during a vehicle test for the particular vehicle.
  • 13. The method according to claim 9 further comprising the step of determining initial value for the charge air temperature when the vehicle is first turned on based on all the measured vehicle data when the vehicle is turned on and the data stored before the engine was turned off.
  • 14. A system for determining a charge air temperature of a vehicle, said system comprising:a device for determining an inlet air temperature to a manifold of the vehicle; a device for determining an engine coolant temperature; a device for determining a speed of the vehicle; a device for determining manifold pressure within the manifold of the vehicle; a device for determining a speed of the vehicle engine; a device for determining an exhaust gas recirculation condition; a device for determining an on/off state of a vehicle engine fan; and a control device for determining the charge air temperature based on heat transfer, said control device using an equation that combines inputs from the inlet air temperature, the engine coolant temperature, the vehicle speed, the manifold pressure, the engine speed, the exhaust gas recirculation condition, and the engine fan on/off state to determine the charge temperature, wherein the control device determines the charge air temperature by adding together several heat contribution terms, wherein a first heat contribution term is based on the engine speed, the manifold pressure and the exhaust gas recirculation condition, a second heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state, and the engine coolant temperature, a third heat contribution term is based on the vehicle speed, the radiator fan on/off state and the engine coolant temperature, and a fourth heat contribution term is based on the heat transfer of the manifold, and wherein the equation is: ⅆTmⅆt= ⁢fcv⁡(N,P,EGR)⁢ ⁢(Tm-Tin)+fcd⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢(To+Tin)+ ⁢fcr⁡(Vs,Vf,Tc)⁢Tc4+fmr⁢Tm4where fcv is a coefficient for the first term, fcd is a coefficient for the second term, fcr is a coefficient for the third term and fmr is a coefficient for the fourth term, wherein the coefficients fcv, fcd, fcr, and fmr are based on vehicle parameters, N is the engine speed, P is the intake manifold pressure, EGR is the exhaust gas recirculation condition, Vs is the vehicle speed, Vf is the radiator fan on/off state, Tc is the engine coolant temperature and Tm is the charge air temperature.
  • 15. The system according to claim 14 wherein the control device determines the charge air temperature based on an already determined charge air temperature from a previous determination of the charge air temperature.
US Referenced Citations (16)
Number Name Date Kind
3875913 Price Apr 1975
4659977 Kissel et al. Apr 1987
4961319 Lyon Oct 1990
5014549 Morley, II et al. May 1991
5036668 Hardy Aug 1991
5365917 Adams et al. Nov 1994
5406921 Noble et al. Apr 1995
5408870 Noble et al. Apr 1995
5435285 Adams et al. Jul 1995
5526788 Noble et al. Jun 1996
5526871 Musser et al. Jun 1996
5584277 Chen et al. Dec 1996
5631831 Bird et al. May 1997
5654501 Grizzle et al. Aug 1997
5791319 Friedrich et al. Aug 1998
5809437 Breed Sep 1998