| Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, demand for trail against Japanese patent 2769925, Aug. 28, 2000 (Osaka, Japan). |
| Osaka Association Hospital Pharmacists, Edited, Completely Revised Iyakuhin Youran, Yakugyou Jihou Co., Ltd, published Oct. 5, 1986, cover, explanatory notes, p. 292, and back flap. |
| Written Statement of Austen John Woolfe of Norton Health Care, dated Aug. 17, 2000. |
| Robinson, Joseph R., and Lee, Vincent H.L., “Influence of Drug Properties and Routes of Drug Administration of the Design of Sustained and Controlled Release Systems,” Controlled Drug Delivery, Fundamentals and Applications, chapter 1, pp. 3-4 and 45-47 (Mercel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1987). |
| Certified copy of the Test Report of the Medicines Testing Laboratory dated Aug. 3, 1999, “Report of the Results of the Twelve Month Time Point for Beclomethasone Dipropionate Inhalers Stability Study”. |
| Certified copy of Study Protocol Agreement for Analysis of Chemical Stability of BDP HFA MDI between Norton (Waterford) Ltd. and Medicines Testing Laboratory. |
| Nihon Yakkyoku Hou Kaisetsusho AΩBΩCΩDΩEΩF, 10th Revised Edition, first published Jul. 25, 1981, inside cover flap, table of contents, pp. A-29, A-36, and inside flap of back cover (Hirokawa Shoten Co., Ltd., Japan). |
| Test report dated Aug. 17, 2000, compiled by Hideko Shigefuji of Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo). Particle sizes are measured for Beclazone 50 Inhaler (of Taisho Yakuhin) and Becotide 50 Inhaler (of Nippon Glaxo). |
| Campos, et al, “Beclomethasone Dipropionate in the Treatment of corticosteroid-dependent Bronchial Asthma. Comparative Study of Two Aerosol Preparations”, Pharmatherapeutica, vol. 1, No. 3, 1977, pp. 552-556. |
| Taisho “Reply” dated Aug. 29, 2000, In 3M v. Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, Case No. 12 (Wa) 7221, Osaka, Japan. |
| Taisho “Brief 1” with exhibits B-2-B9, dated Oct. 6, 2000, in 3M v. Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, Case No. 12 (Wa) 7221, Osaka, Japan. |
| Taisho “Preparatory Document (2)” with exhibits B10-B18, dated Jan. 22, 2001, 3M v. Tashio Yakuhin Kogyo, Case No. 12 (Wa) 7221, Osaka, Japan. |
| Taisho “Preparatory Document (3)” with exhibits B19-B22, dated Apr. 9, 2001, 3M v. Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, Case No. 12, (Wa) 7221, Osaka, Japan. |
| Taisho “Description of Exhibits (4),” dated Feb. 8, 2001, 3M v. Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, Case No. 12 (Wa) 7221, Osaka, Japan. |
| IVAX, et al. v. Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company, Complaint filed Aug. 30, 2000, Civil Action 00-3219, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida. |
| ICI News Release, “ICI Announces ‘Ozone Friendly’ Production Plants”, dated Nov. 22, 1988 (ICI Amernicas Inc., Willmington, Delaware). |
| Compos, et al. “Beclomethasone Dipropionate in the Treatment of Corticoteroid-Dependent Bronchial Asthma. Comparative Study of Two Aerosol Preparations”, Pharmatherapeutica, vol. 1, No. 3, 1977, pp. 552-556. |
| 3M v. Taisho Yakuhin Kogyo, Translation of Reply filed by Taisho in response to Complaint by 3M for infringement of Japanese patent 2769925, Aug. 31, 2000 (Osaka 12 (Wa) 7221). |
| Du Pont, “Fluorocarbon Azeotropes”, Research Disclosure, vol. 162 p. 70, #16265 (1977). |
| Gennaro, Remington's Pharmaceutical Sciences, p. 962 (Mack Publishing Company, Inc., 1985). |
| Dalby, R.N. and Byron P.R., “Comparison of Output Particle Size Distributions from Pressurised Aerosols Formulated as Solutions or Suspensions”, Pharmaceutical Res., vol. 5, No. 1 p. 36 (1988). |
| Sciarra, J., in Lachman, Lieberman & Kanig, The Theory and Practice of Industrial Pharmacy, 2nd Edition, pp. 270 and 276-280 (Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, 1976). |
| Ranucci, J., “Pharmaceutical Aerosol Technology, Aerosol Formulation Development”, The Institute for Applied Pharmaceutical Sciences, May 21-23, p.1-122 (1990). |
| Sciarra, J., in Lachman, Lieberman & Kanig, The Theory & Practice of Industrial Pharmacy, 3rd Ed., pp. 589-618 (Lea & Febiger, 1986). |
| Backstrom, K., et al., “Measurements of Droplet Size Distributions from Metered Dose Inhalers with Different Vapour Pressures and Contents of Surfactant”, J. Aerosol Science, vol.19, No. 7, pp. 1097-1100 (1988). |
| Thoma, K., AEROSOLE—Moglichkeiten und Probleme einer Darreichungsform, Werbe- und Vertriebsgesellschaft Dt. Apotheker mbH Frankfurt, p. 153-161 (1970). |
| Oradell N.J., Physicians' Desk Reference, PDR 40 Edition, p. 1900 (Medical Economics Company Inc., 1986). |
| Dalby R.N., et al., “CFC Propellant Substitution: P-134a as a Potential Replacement for P-12 in MDI's”, Pharmaceutical Technology, pp. 26-33, (Mar. 1990). |
| Oberholz, A., “Fur den Schutz des Lebens auf der Erde, Die schwierige Suche nach Alternativen zu den Fluorochlorkohlenwasserstoffen”, Frankfurter Allegemeine Zeitung, p. 7 (Oct. 25, 1989). |
| Product brochure, “Hoechst zum Ersatz von FCKW”, Hoechst Chemikalien, pp. 1-3, Sep. 1990 (Hoechst Aktiengesellschaft, Frankfurt, Germany). |
| Morck, H., “EG-Kommission: FCKW-Verbot 1997”, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, Nr. 9, 135. Jahrgang, pp. 30-31 (Frankfurt, Germany, Mar. 1990). |
| Product information, “DIN-Sicherheitsdatenblatt der Hoechst AG vom betreffend FKW 227”, (Hoechst Aktiengesellschaft, Germany, Jan. 1988). |
| The Merck Index, 11th Ed., p. 158-159 (Merck and Company, Inc., 1989). |
| Gunella G., Melica A., Fabbri M., Cavalli A., Schiavina M., “Effetti sulla funzione ventilatoria e surrenalica di un cortisonico a grossa molecola, il beclometasone dipropionato, soministrato per via inalatoria”, Minerva Pneumologica14(1), pp. 34-45, 1975. |
| Gunella G., Melica A., Fabbri M., Cavalli A., Schiavina M., Galeri C., “Effetti sulla funzione ventilatoria e surrenalica di un cortisonico a grossa molecola, il beclometasone dipropionato, soministrator per via inalatoria”, Folia Allergol Immunol Clin, XXI (5), pp. 360-375, 1974. |
| Oradel, N.J., Physicians' Desk Reference, PDR 39 Edition, 1985, Medicinal Economics Company Inc., pp. 1291-1293. |
| European Patent Office Opposition Division decision, dated Dec. 27, 1996, re European Patent EP-B-0 553 298 (3M). |
| Jacob, J., United Kingdom Patents Court decision, dated Jun. 30, 1997, in the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent No. 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298. |
| Expert Report of John Sciarra, dated Mar. 14, 1997, in the U.K. High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent Nos. 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298). |
| Expert Report of Ian Smith, dated Mar. 17, 1997, in the U.K. High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent No. 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298. |
| Extracts from the transcripts of the proceedings in the U.K. Patents Court, dated Jun. 4-10, 1997, in the High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent No. 0,372,7772, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298). |
| Extract from IPACT history, “A Case for Cooperation, The Story of IPACT-I and II”, p. 4, submitted in the U.K. High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent Nos. 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298). |
| L'Informatore Farmaceutico, Italian Directory of Drugs and Manufacturers, 38 th edition, p. 142 (Clenil Spray), (Organizzione Editoriale Medico-Farmaceutica S.R.L., Milano, Italy, 1978). |
| Statement of Dr. Ian Smith, pp. 1-6, dated Nov. 2, 1998 in European Opposition Proceedings re EP 0553298 (Appeal Case No. T0153/97-332). |
| Moren, F., “Pressurized Aerosols for Inhalation”, International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 8, No. 1, Mar, 1981, pp. 1-4 (Elsevier/North-Holland Biomedical Press). |
| Moren, F., “Aerosol Dosage Forms and Formulations”, Aerosols in Medicine Principles, Diagnosis and Therapy, Chapter 10, pp. 261-287, (Elsevier 1985). |
| Denoel, A., “Aerosols”, Galenic Pharmaceutics, vol. IV, Chapter III, p. 153-168 (Liege University Press 1969). |
| Atkins, P., “the Design and Development of Inhalation Drug Delivery Systems”, Pharmaceutical Inhalation Aerosol Technology, Chapter 6, p. 155-185, edited by A. Hickey (Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York 1992). |
| Aerosol Search through Physician's Desk Reference (PDR) (1991), submitted in European Opposition Proceedings re EP 0553298 (Appeal Case No. T0153/97-332). |
| Frank, Bruce H., letters to R.F. Browne dated Feb. 6, 1997 and Feb. 25, 1997 in European Opposition Proceedings re EP 0553298 (Appeal Case No. T0153/97-332) (with Nov. 2, 1998 cover letter from Urquart-Dykes & Lord). |
| Gennaro, A.R. (1985) Remington's Pharmaceutical Science, Mack Publishing Co., Easton, PA, 1672. |
| Ansel, H.C. et al, (1995), Pharmaceutical Dosage Forms and Drug Delivery Systems, Williams & Wilkins, pp. 450-453. |
| European Patent Office Technical Board of Appeals decision, dated Dec. 2, 1998, re European Patent EP-B-0 553 298 (3M). |