Method of inserting z-axis reinforcing fibers into a composite laminate

Abstract
A method of inserting z-axis reinforcing fibers into a multi-layer composite laminate. Layers of material made up of z-axis fiber and y-axis fibers are automatically transported into a z-fiber deposition machine having a housing with upper and lower surfaces. Z-axis apertures are formed in the respective upper and lower surfaces. An elongated solid rod having a tapered front tip is aligned in close proximity to the aperture n the bottom surface. The rod is first rotated by a motor and then actuated upwardly completely through the thickness of the layer of x-y material by an actuator. A first hollow tube having a z-axis is axially aligned with the aperture in the top surface and a fiber bundle is threaded downwardly through a first hollow tube to a position adjacent its bottom end. The z-fiber deposition machine has structure to feed a predetermined length of the fiber bundle downwardly through the first hollow tube so that it follows the pathway in the x-y material formed by the rod which is now withdrawn downwardly through the aperture in the bottom wall. The z-axis fiber is thus deposited into the x-y material. The top end of the z-fiber is then severed and the x-y material is then advanced a predetermined distance to complete the cycle and is thus set to be repeated.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The invention relates to a method of producing a composite material and more specifically a process for incorporating z-axis fiber reinforcement into x-y axis composite material.




Traditional composite materials are made up of resin matrix material and a quantity of 2-dimensional fibers, continuous in the x-y axis directions, but laminated in layers to produce a material thickness. Composite material construction, wherein a fiber material such as glass fiber, carbon fiber, or aramid fiber is combined with a matrix material, such as thermoplastic or thermoset resins, is an example of a traditional 2-dimensional structure. The resulting structure is produced from “layering” of the 2-dimensional material (known as plies). Because the matrix is weaker in strength than the fiber (in may cases by at least an order of magnitude), the failure mechanism of these composites when test loaded toward their ultimate strength is a cracking or buckling or separation of the matrix material. When this occurs, the composite is known to have delaminated, or the layers of fiber material have separated.




Attempts have been made to lace or tie multiple layers of 2-dimensional composite materials together with z-axis directional fibers which tie all of the layers together. By doing this, delamination can be delayed or eliminated. Some techniques that have been used include 3-D braiding, 3-D weaving, and z-axis pinning. All of these methods have deficiencies, drawbacks and are expensive and labor intensive.




The Fusco et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,589,015 is directed to a method and system for inserting reinforcing pins in composite structure. Ultra sound energy is applied to the pins and pressure is applied simultaneously to insert the pins into the composite structure to join two laminates or reinforce a single composite structure.




The Childress U.S. Pat. No. 5,935,680 is directed to an interlaced z-axis pin sandwich structure that utilizes a plurality of z-axis pins that extend through the core and into each of the face sheets. The pins are arranged in an interlaced configuration off-normal to provide crack resistance around fasteners for connecting the composite structure to other structural elements in aerospace applications.




The Boyce et al U.S. Pat. No. 4,808,461 discloses a translaminar reinforcement structure that utilizes z-axis reinforcing elements and the method for driving these reinforcing elements into the composite structure as it is subjected to an elevated temperature and decomposes.




The Campbell et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,789,061 discloses a stiffener reinforced assembly and its method of manufacturing. The Boyce et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,667,859 also discloses the use of joining composite parts by including reinforcing elements that pass through the thickness of two composite adherents to be joined. The Campbell et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,827,383 also discloses a stiffener reinforcement assembly and its method of manufacturing.




Other patents that teach the use of tow members that are encapsulated within the foam core and which extend between the opposing face sheets to form a combined composite structure are the Boyce et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,624,622 and the Boyce et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,741,574. The Boyce et al U.S. Pat. No. 5,186,776 teaches a technique for translaminar reinforcement and the method includes heating and softening the composite laminates by ultrasonic energy and then inserting reinforcing fibers therein.




It is an object of the invention to provide a novel method of inserting an unstable reinforcing fiber into a composite laminate for z-axis reinforcement.




It is also an object of the invention to provide novel machinery for inserting an unstable z-axis reinforcing fiber into a composite laminate.




It is another object of the invention to provide a new type of composite material with substantial z-axis fiber reinforcement.




It is a further object of the invention to provide a novel method for producing layer quantities of 3-D bar stock, sheet and composite sandwich structure in a continuous, automated fashion.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The method of inserting an unstable reinforcing fiber into a composite laminate for z-axis reinforcement of the laminate requires a z-axis fiber deposition material. The side plates of the chamber formed between top and bottom plates into which is fed x-y axis material. The side plates of the chamber restrict the edges of x-y axis material. There would be multiple laterally spaced z-axis fiber deposition machines so that multiple z-axis fibers could be deposited into the x-y axis material at the same time. Each would have its own respective aperture in the top plate and the bottom plate and these would be aligned. Below each aperture in the bottom plate is an elongated solid rod having a tapered front tip. This rod is known as the “pathway deposition Probe” (PDP). The PDP is rotated by a motor and then actuated upwardly through the aperture in the bottom plate, the x-y axis material and the aperture in the top plate. Mounted above each aperture in the top plate is a movable hollow tube whose initial position has its bottom end slightly inserted into the aperture in the top plate. Z-axis fiber bundles are contained on stationary rolls and are free to be drawn from the rolls continuously. The front end of each z-axis fiber bundle is threaded downwardly through one of the movable hollow tubes to a position adjacent its bottom end. There would be structure to resupply a predetermined length of z-axis fiber bundle to each movable hollow tube as a new length is needed.




After the PDP has been actuated upwardly to its upper most position, it is then retracted downwardly to its initial position and simultaneously, the movable hollow tube would travel downwardly through the hole created in the x-y axis material. While this is happening, the tip of the PDP would remain inserted into the bottom end of the movable hollow tube to insure a smooth entry of the hollow tube through the aperture in the x-y axis material created by the PDP. Each z-axis fiber deposition unit has a mechanism for preventing withdraw of z-axis fiber from the x-y axis material when the movable hollow tube is withdrawn upwardly. Once the movable hollow tube has been raised to its upper position, the top end of z-axis fiber that has been inserted into the x-axis material is severed. This would complete a whole cycle. Simultaneously, across the width of the housing each of the other z-axis fiber deposition units would have completed their cycle. The next x-y axis material is stepped forwardly to provide a new position for the z-axis fibers to be deposited. Alternatively, the method could provide structure for stepping the housing rearwardly instead of stepping forwardly the x-y axis composite material.




After the x-y axis material has had the z-axis fibers deposited therein, it travels forwardly to a pultrusion die. Here the heated die cures the composite material of the plies and it exits the dies as a cured 3-D fiber composite material. The material is pulled from the die continuously by the alternate gripping edges of multiple grippers that are attached to motion control hydraulic cylinders.











DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a schematic side elevation view of a z-axis fiber deposition unit;





FIG. 2

is a schematic side elevation view of a z-axis fiber deposition units integrated with the pultrusion process;





FIG. 3

is a schematic side elevation view of a first alternative embodiment of the z-axis fiber deposition unit;





FIG. 4

is a schematic partial cross section view illustrating a sandwich structure has a core covered on its top and bottom surface with respective skins formed of a x-y axis fiber material;





FIG. 5

is an enlarged schematic cross sectional view taken along lines


5





5


of

FIG. 4

; and





FIG. 6

is an enlarged schematic cross sectional view taken along lines


6





6


of FIG.


5


.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




The method of inserting z-axis reinforcing fibers into a composite laminate will now be described by referring to

FIGS. 1-6

of the drawings.





FIG. 1

shows a schematic elevation view of the novel z-axis fiber deposition process and the associated machinery. The key element of only one z-axis fiber deposition unit is illustrated in this figure. Following a description of

FIG. 1

, a more detailed, expanded description of multiple z-axis fiber deposition components will be discussed.




In

FIG. 1

, the cross section of a typical x-y axis material is defined by numeral


30


. Material


30


is a continuously traveling laminate of x-y material. The direction of pultrusion and the continuous processing is defined as being in the x-axis direction and is into the paper. The y-axis direction is left-to-right along 3-D material


30


. The z-axis direction is from top- to- bottom, through 3-D material


30


. Only a few layers, or “plies” of x-y axis material


30


is shown, although clearly, multiple layers could be shown. A single layer of material


30


is made up of x-axis material and y-axis material, produced by other processes prior to incorporation into the z-axis fiber deposition process. This x-y axis material could be woven glass fiber or stitched glass fiber or a combination of each, or it could be mat or unidirectional woving, or could be other fiber such as carbon or aramid.




Material


30


is contained in the z-axis direction by a chamber in the housing shown only by the top and bottom plates


20


and


21


respectfully. The side plates of the housing, not shown, restrict the edges of material


30


. Since there are multiple z-axis deposition points along the y-axis, and since

FIG. 1

shows only one of these points, the edges of the chamber in the containment housing and the x-y axis material are not shown. Plates


20


and


21


are pre-spaced such that a very compact set of layers


30


are drawn through the housing, compressing the x-y axis material


30


to its nearly final z-axis directional compression prior to receiving the z-axis fiber or entering the protrusion die. Material


30


may be impregnated with resin material and if thermoset, may be debulked prior to entering the chamber in the containment housing defined by plates


20


and


21


.




As stated earlier, material


30


could also be sandwich structure, without changing the operation or process. As shown in

FIG. 1

, the material


30


is a stack of layers of x-y axis fiber material, which, after deposition of the z-axis directional fiber, will be processed into the quasi-isotropic bar stock. If the material


30


, is 1 inch thick (for example) there might be 36 layers of x-y axis material making up the 1-inch thickness. It would be a simple matter of construction to substitute for the middle layers of x-y axis material, a core material


28


, such as foam plastic, honeycomb material, or balsa wood (see FIGS.


4


-


6


). These core materials are low density and are used in sandwich structure construction. In this manner, material


30


could have six layers of x-y axis material on the top, a core material of 0.75 inches in thickness and six layers of x-y axis material on the bottom. The z-axis fiber deposition method described herein would be identical, whether the material


30


was 100% x-y axis fiber material or a sandwich material having a core and top


27


and bottom


29


“skin” material.




The key elements of the z-axis fiber deposition mechanism are shown in

FIG. 1

, although all of the details of how certain mechanisms are supported or actuated are not shown. The first step of the process has the material


30


being drawn into the chamber in the containment housing between upper and lower surfaces


20


and


21


, respectfully. Material


30


is stopped because the machinery moves synchronously to the pultrusion speed. This allows the “pathway deposition probe” (PDP)


35


to be inserted through the material


30


. Alternatively, the material could be moving continuously and the deposition process could be gantry and synchronous with the pultrusion speed. The PDP


35


is an elongated solid rod having a tapered front tip, a shank portion, and a rear end. PDP


35


is first rotated by a motor


50


and then actuated upwardly by way of an actuator


61


.




Then the process begins in which a fiber bundle, shown by the single line


7


, is deposited in the stack of x-y axis material


30


. Although the fiber bundle is shown as a single line, in fact it could be a glass, carbon, or other fiber bundle containing hundreds or even thousands of continuous fiber filaments. This process will be referred to as the z-axis fiber deposition process. The z-axis fiber bundle


7


is contained on a stationary roll


5


which is free to be drawn continuously from the roll


5


. The fiber bundle is fed through a guidance bushing


10


and through two tubes, one of which is stationary outer tube


15


and the other a movable tube


16


. Stationary outer tube


15


and movable inner tube


16


are concentric with very close tolerances and are both penetrated at two locations to accept a fiber clamp


12


A and a fiber clamp


12


B. Fiber clamp


12


A is by definition, stationary, as it penetrates the stationary outer tube


15


. Fiber clamp


12


B is by definition, movable, as it must move with the movement of the mechanism in the z-axis direction of the moveable inner tube


16


. Moveable fiber clamp


12


B may or may not be extended when tube


16


is moving. The actuation mechanism of clamp


12


B is independent of the actuation mechanism for tube


16


, both of which are shown in

FIG. 1

for clarity. The purpose of fiber clamps


12


A and


12


B is to provide positive clamping of the fiber bundle to the interior of tubes


15


and


16


, respectively, at different times and for different purposes.




Once the PDP


35


has rotated, has been actuated in the z-axis direction, and has fully penetrated the x-y axis fiber layers


30


, the PDP


35


is not yet touching the outer movable tube


16


, but has passed completely through material


30


. At this time the PDP


35


is stopped rotating.




As mentioned previously, the rotation of PDP


35


assists in the penetration of material


30


with minimum force and minimum fiber damage in the x-y axis material


30


. The next step in the process is as follows: fiber camp


12


A is unclamped and fiber clamp


12


B is clamped. By actuating fiber clamp


12


B, in the clamped location, fiber bundle


7


is secured to the inner wall of moveable tube


16


and allows fiber bundle


7


to move with tube


16


.




Once clamp


12


B has secured the fiber bundle


7


to movable inner tube


16


, a mechanism (not shown) moves inner tube


16


downward in the z-axis direction until the bottom end of the tube


16


makes contact with the outside of the PDP


35


(which has already penetrated the x-y axis material


30


) but at this time is not rotating.




Next, the mechanism that moves inner tube


16


, moves fiber bundle


7


and the PDP


35


through the entire x-y axis material


30


. PDP


35


had created a pathway for inner tube


16


to be inserted through material


30


. A certain amount of low actuation force on the PDP


35


insures that the inner tube


16


stays intimate and in contact with the PDP


35


. This technique insures a smooth entry of tube


16


and the clamped fiber bundle


7


through the x-y axis material


30


. Fiber bundle


7


is pulled off the spool


5


by this process.




Next fiber clamp


12


B is released into the unclamped position and fiber clamp


12


B is actuated into a clamped position. In this way, fiber clamp


12


A secures fiber bundle


7


against the interior wall of stationary tube


15


. This ensures that the fiber bundle


7


remains stationary and deposited in the x-y axis material


30


. Following this, moveable inner tube


16


is withdrawn from the x-y axis material


30


and actuated upwardly in the z-axis direction back to the original position shown in FIG.


1


. When this step is done fiber bundle


7


does not move. Fiber bundle


7


remains as a fully deposited fiber bundle in the z-axis direction. Next, fiber bundle


7


is sheared off at the Top of the x-y axis material


30


by a shear plate


25


and


26


. The stationary part of shear plate


26


never moves. The movable portion


25


is actuated by an actuator


60


. This cuts fiber bundle


7


, much like a scissors cut, and allows the fiber bundle


7


, continuous to spool


5


, to be separated from the z-axis fiber deposited bundle. This allows a preparation for the second z-axis fiber deposition. The preparation includes adjusting the end of the fiber bundle


7


relative to the end of moveable inner plate


16


. As shown in

FIG. 1

, the end of fiber bundle


7


is drawn slightly inwardly from the bottom end of the tube


16


. This is necessary to allow the point on the tip of PDP


35


to enter tube


16


as the next cycle without fiber being caught between the contact points of inner tube


16


and PDP


35


. This is accomplished as follows:




Once sheer plate


25


has cut the deposited z-axis fiber from fiber bundle


7


, the end of fiber bundle


7


is slightly extended below the inner tube


16


. Next, fiber clamp


12


A is released and fiber clamp


12


B is actuated and clamped. Inner tube


16


is actuated further upward in the z-axis direction as shown in

FIG. 1

until the end of fiber bundle


7


is in the same relative position as that shown in FIG.


1


. Next, clamp


12


A is actuated and clamped and clamp


12


B is released, unclamped. Following this, inner tube


16


is moved downward in the z-axis direction to the position shown in

FIG. 1

, thus that the relative position of the end of moveable inner tube


16


and the end of fiber bundle


7


is as shown in FIG.


1


. The cycle is now set to be repeated.




All of the previously described operation can occur rapidly. Several units of the device as illustrated in

FIG. 1

are installed side-by-side. The movement of an entire housing containing all of the devices of

FIG. 1

, occurs with the x-y axis material


30


and the plates


25


and


26


remaining stationary. In this way, for example, while the material


30


is stopped, an extra z-axis fiber can be deposited between the locations of two z-axis fibers deposited on the first cycle. A high number of z-axis fiber bundles in one row, with material


30


stationary, can in fact be deposited. Once a row which is defined as the deposited z-axis fibers lineal in the y direction, is completed, material


30


can be moved relative to the machinery of

FIG. 1 and a

second row of z-axis fibers can be deposited. This new row can have the same pattern or a staggered pattern, as required.




One other device in

FIG. 1

requires mentioning. Spring


40


, located at the base PDP


35


and between the PDP and the motor


50


has a special purpose. When inner tube


16


contacts PDP


35


, and then subsequently pushes PDP


35


back through the layers of x-y axis material


30


, a flaring in the end of the tube can occur, if the relative force between the two exceeds a certain value. The flaring of the tube end


16


will result in failure of the mechanism. Spring


40


prevents this excess differential force, thus resulting in no flaring of the end of tube


16


.





FIG. 2

is a schematic side elevation view of the z-axis fiber deposition machinery integrated with the pultrusion process. The 2-D layers of x-y axis material


30


are stored on rolls


70


. They are pulled through a resin tank


31


where the 2D material is impregnated with resin. They are then pulled through debulking bushings


72


where, sequentially, the plies are stacked and each succeeding bushing


72


, squeezes progressively a little more resin out of the stack of x-y axis material


30


as it progresses toward the z-axis fiber deposition machine


73


. Once through machine


73


, the 3-D fiber, now identified as numeral


31


, since it has z-axis fibers deposited in it, progresses to pultrusion die


74


. Here a heated die cures the composite material on the fly, and it exits the die as cured 3D fiber composite material


32


. The material is pulled from the die continuously by the alternate gripping action of two grippers


75


that are attached to motion control hydraulic cylinders


76


. Cylinders


76


are CNC type cylinders and can accurately position and time the material


30


for z-axis deposition.




An alternative to the feed mechanism described earlier in FIG.


1


and depicted by clamps


12


A and


12


B, and the outer tube


15


and inner tube


16


, can be replaced by the mechanism illustrated in FIG.


3


. These mechanisms require a more sophisticated motion control than the clamp system of

FIG. 1

, as will be evident in the description below.




The components of

FIG. 3

replace the components of

FIG. 1

that are sown above the carrier plate


20


. The key new components are a tube


16


, a urethane wheel


19


, an idler bearing


18


, a spring


17


, a drive belt


22


and a CNC type motion control motor


23


. All of these components are intimately connected to a frame (not shown), which is driven through carrier plates


20


and


21


, by a CNC-type motor and ball screw (also not shown). In this way, all of the components


16


,


19


,


18


,


17




22


and


23


move together as a synchronous unit.




The embodiment illustrated in

FIG. 3

has the same fiber roll


5


, fiber tow or bundle


7


, and guidance bushing


10


. Idler bearing


18


and urethane wheel


19


provide a positive clamping of the fiber bundle


7


. Spring


17


, assures a side force of known quantity and clamps the fiber bundle


7


. When motion control motor


23


is in a locked position, not rotated, fiber bundle


7


is clamped and cannot be moved. When motor


23


is rotated, fiber bundle


7


moves relative to tube


16


, since the position of tube


16


is always the same as the other components


19


,


18


,


17


,


22


and


23


of FIG.


3


. In this way, fiber bundle


7


can either be clamped so that it can not move inside tube


16


or it can be moved inside tube


16


by rotation of the motion control motor


23


.




It should now be apparent that the mechanisms illustrated in

FIG. 3

can substitute for those identified in FIG.


1


. When tube


16


, with fiber bundle


7


clamped, is moved by a CNC motor (not shown) through the x-y material


30


, motor


23


is not rotated. However, when tube


16


is drawn from the x-y axis material


30


, motor


23


is rotated at the exact rate of speed as the withdraw of PDP


35


. This can be accomplished with present day sophisticated motion control hardware and software. In doing this, fiber bundle


7


, stays stationary relative to x-y axis material


30


, even though tube


16


is being withdrawn.




The advantage of the mechanisms in

FIG. 3

, although they provide identical functions to their counterparts in

FIG. 1

, is that the speed of the process can improve by eliminating the alternative clamping of clamps


12


A and


12


B. Nevertheless, either set of mechanisms is viable for the disclosed invention.



Claims
  • 1. A method of inserting an unstable reinforcing fiber into a composite laminate for z-axis reinforcement of the laminate comprising:providing at least one layer of material made up of x-axis fibers and y-axis fibers prior to incorporation of a z-axis fiber into said layer of material; said layer having a top surface, a bottom surface and a predetermined thickness; providing an elongated solid rod having a tapered front tip, a shank portion, a rear end and a z-axis and positioning said front tip of said rod in close proximity to one of said top or bottom surfaces of said at least one layer of material; providing an elongated moveable first hollow tube having a front end, a rear end, an inner wall surface and a z-axis; positioning said front end of said moveable first hollow tube in close proximity to said other of said top or bottom surfaces of said at least one layer of material; providing a z-axis fiber bundle having a front end and inserting said front end of said fiber bundle into said rear end of said moveable first hollow tube until it travels substantially to said front end of said moveable first tube; inserting said solid rod into and through said layer of material a predetermined distance; temporarily securing said z-axis fiber bundle to said inner wall of said first hollow tube so that said fiber bundle will move with said first hollow tube; moving said first hollow tube in the z-axis direction until said front end of said first hollow tube makes contact with the outside surface of said solid rod; and moving said first hollow tube and said z-axis fiber bundle secured thereto through the entire thickness of said layer of material while at the same time withdrawing said solid rod from said layer of material; further comprising the next step of unsecuring said z-axis fiber bundle from said inner wall of said first hollow tube and then withdrawing said first hollow tube from said layer of material thus causing said z-axis fiber bundle to remain within said layer of material as said first hollow tube is withdrawn; and further comprising the step of severing the z-axis fiber that is within said layer of material from said z-axis fiber bundle.
  • 2. A method as recited in claim 1 wherein said solid rod is spinning during insertion into said layer of material.
  • 3. A method as recited in claim 1 further comprising stepping said layer of material forwardly so that the previous steps can be repeated in order to deposit additional z-axis fiber into said layer of material.
  • 4. A method as recited in claim 1 further comprising stepping rearwardly the machinery that performs the operations of inserting an unstable reinforcing fiber into a composite laminate for z-axis reinforcement; said layer of material would remain stationary.
  • 5. A method as recited in claim 4 further comprising the step of passing said layer of material with its newly inserted z-axis fibers through a pultrusion die for curing composite material.
  • 6. A method as recited in claim 1 further comprising multiple layers of material stacked upon each other and into which z-axis fibers are inserted.
  • 7. A method as recited in claim 6 in which some of said layers of material are vertically spaced from each other by a core layer of material.
  • 8. A method as recited in claim 7 wherein said core layer of material is made of foam plastic.
  • 9. A method as recited in claim 7 wherein said core layer of material is made of balsa wood.
  • 10. A method as recited in claim 1 wherein said fiber bundle is made of glass fibers.
  • 11. A method as recited in claim 1 wherein said fiber bundle is made of carbon fibers.
  • 12. A method as recited in claim 7 wherein said core layer of material is made of honeycomb material.
  • 13. A method as recited in claim 1 wherein said fiber bundle is made of aramid fibers.
  • 14. A method as recited in claim 1 wherein said rear end of said solid rod has a dampening spring to prevent flaring of said front end of said hollow tube.
  • 15. A method as recited in claim 3 wherein the stepping of said layer of material forwardly and the depositing of said additional z-axis fiber into said layer of material is done synchronously.
Parent Case Info

This patent application claims the priority of provisional patent application 60/281,838 filed Apr. 4, 2001 and provisional patent application 60/293,939 filed May 29, 2001.

Government Interests

This invention was made with United States Government support under Cooperative Agreement 70NANB8H4059 awarded by NIST. The United States Government has certain rights in the invention.

US Referenced Citations (109)
Number Name Date Kind
2762739 Weiss Sep 1956 A
2954001 Luxenburg Sep 1960 A
3211115 Burillon et al. Oct 1965 A
3241508 Chezaud et al. Mar 1966 A
3328218 Noyes Jun 1967 A
3647606 Notaro Mar 1972 A
3761345 Smith Sep 1973 A
3833695 Vidal Sep 1974 A
3837985 Chase Sep 1974 A
3870580 Belcher Mar 1975 A
3948194 Gunold Apr 1976 A
3993523 Hunt et al. Nov 1976 A
4032383 Goldsworthy et al. Jun 1977 A
4059468 Bouillon Nov 1977 A
4077340 Braum et al. Mar 1978 A
4080915 Bompard et al. Mar 1978 A
4196251 Windecker Apr 1980 A
4206895 Olez Jun 1980 A
4218276 King Aug 1980 A
4256790 Lackman et al. Mar 1981 A
4291081 Olez Sep 1981 A
4299871 Forsch Nov 1981 A
4331091 Parker et al. May 1982 A
4335176 Baumann Jun 1982 A
4495231 Laskaris et al. Jan 1985 A
4495235 Tesch Jan 1985 A
4498941 Goldsworthy Feb 1985 A
4506611 Parker et al. Mar 1985 A
4528051 Heinze et al. Jul 1985 A
4541349 Inoue Sep 1985 A
4571355 Elrod Feb 1986 A
4628846 Vives Dec 1986 A
4752513 Rau et al. Jun 1988 A
4761871 O'Connor et al. Aug 1988 A
4808461 Boyce et al. Feb 1989 A
4854250 Stuvecke et al. Aug 1989 A
4913937 Engdahl et al. Apr 1990 A
4917756 Cahuzac et al. Apr 1990 A
4955123 Lawton et al. Sep 1990 A
4963408 Huegli Oct 1990 A
5055242 Vane Oct 1991 A
5095833 Darrieux Mar 1992 A
5186776 Boyce et al. Feb 1993 A
5286320 McGrath et al. Feb 1994 A
5314282 Murphy et al. May 1994 A
5324377 Davies Jun 1994 A
5327621 Yasui et al. Jul 1994 A
5333562 LeMaire et al. Aug 1994 A
5361483 Rainville et al. Nov 1994 A
5373796 Besemann Dec 1994 A
5429853 Darrieux Jul 1995 A
5445693 Vane Aug 1995 A
5445861 Newton et al. Aug 1995 A
5466506 Freitas et al. Nov 1995 A
5490602 Wilson et al. Feb 1996 A
5549771 Brooker Aug 1996 A
5580514 Farley Dec 1996 A
5589015 Fusco et al. Dec 1996 A
5589243 Day Dec 1996 A
5624622 Boyce et al. Apr 1997 A
5632844 Pate et al. May 1997 A
5639410 Amaike et al. Jun 1997 A
5642679 Monget et al. Jul 1997 A
5667859 Boyce et al. Sep 1997 A
5681408 Pate et al. Oct 1997 A
5736222 Childress Apr 1998 A
5741574 Boyce et al. Apr 1998 A
5759321 Cahuzac Jun 1998 A
5778806 Badillo Jul 1998 A
5789061 Campbell et al. Aug 1998 A
5827383 Campbell et al. Oct 1998 A
5829373 Baxter Nov 1998 A
5832594 Avila Nov 1998 A
5834082 Day Nov 1998 A
5862975 Childress Jan 1999 A
5863635 Childress Jan 1999 A
5868886 Alston et al. Feb 1999 A
5869165 Rorabaugh et al. Feb 1999 A
5873973 Koon et al. Feb 1999 A
5876540 Pannell Mar 1999 A
5876652 Rorabaugh et al. Mar 1999 A
5876832 Pannell Mar 1999 A
5882756 Alston et al. Mar 1999 A
5882765 Pastureau et al. Mar 1999 A
5916469 Scoles et al. Jun 1999 A
5919413 Avila Jul 1999 A
5935475 Scoles et al. Aug 1999 A
5935680 Childress Aug 1999 A
5935698 Pannell Aug 1999 A
5941185 Selbach et al. Aug 1999 A
5958550 Childress Sep 1999 A
5968639 Childress Oct 1999 A
5972524 Childress Oct 1999 A
5980665 Childress Nov 1999 A
6027798 Childress Feb 2000 A
6051089 Palmer et al. Apr 2000 A
6090465 Steele et al. Jul 2000 A
6106646 Fairbanks Aug 2000 A
6117260 Rossi Sep 2000 A
6128998 Freitas et al. Oct 2000 A
6139942 Hartness et al. Oct 2000 A
6151439 Wainwright Nov 2000 A
6187411 Palmer Feb 2001 B1
6190602 Blaney et al. Feb 2001 B1
6196145 Burgess Mar 2001 B1
6291049 Kunkel et al. Sep 2001 B1
20010031350 Day et al. Oct 2001 A1
20020014302 Fanucci et al. Feb 2002 A1
20020069503 Sentmanat Jun 2002 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (8)
Number Date Country
4342575 Apr 1995 DE
1275705 Jun 1970 GB
2245862 Jan 1992 GB
63-60738 Mar 1988 JP
5-200884 Oct 1993 JP
WO-9200845 Jan 1992 WO
WO 9808271 Feb 1998 WO
WO 03011577 Feb 2003 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
Larry E. Stanley and Daniel O. Adams Development and Evaluation of Stitched Sandwich Panels, Jun. 2001, NASA-CR 2001-211025.
Provisional Applications (2)
Number Date Country
60/281838 Apr 2001 US
60/293939 May 2001 US