Method of manufacturing a vehicle frame assembly

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6477774
  • Patent Number
    6,477,774
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, September 30, 1999
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 12, 2002
    21 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus and method are provided for initially performing a heat treatment process on a closed channel structural member to facilitate the subsequent performance of a magnetic pulse welding process so as to manufacture a vehicle frame component or a portion of a vehicle frame assembly. Initially, a workpiece is provided that is preferably formed from a closed channel structural member having a circular or box-shaped cross sectional shape. The workpiece is subjected to a scanning heat treatment process, wherein the workpiece is heat treated in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other. Preferably, the workpiece is supported vertically during the scanning heat treatment process to prevent the shape thereof from becoming distorted. The scanning heat treatment process is preferably a retrogression heat treatment process, wherein the workpiece is rapidly heated to a sufficient temperature that provides for full or partial softening thereof, followed by relatively rapid cooling. In a third step of the method, a deforming process is performed on the workpiece during the period of time following the retrogression heat treatment process in which the workpiece retains the full or partial softening characteristics. In a fourth step of the method, a magnetic pulse welding operation is performed to secure two workpieces together so as to manufacture a vehicle frame component or a portion of a vehicle frame assembly. At least one of the two workpieces is subjected to the scanning heat treatment process to facilitate the magnetic pulse welding process.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates in general to the manufacture of structural members having desired shapes, such as components for use in vehicle frame assemblies. More specifically, this invention relates to an improved apparatus and method for initially performing a heat treatment process on a closed channel structural member to facilitate the subsequent performance of a magnetic pulse welding process so as to manufacture a vehicle frame component or a portion of a vehicle frame assembly.




Many land vehicles in common use, such as automobiles, vans, and trucks, include a body and frame assembly that is supported upon a plurality of ground-engaging wheels by a resilient suspension system. The structures of known body and frame assemblies can be divided into two general categories, namely, separate and unitized. In a typical separate body and frame assembly, the structural components of the body portion and the frame portion are separate and independent from one another. When assembled, the frame portion of the assembly is resiliently supported upon the vehicle wheels by the suspension system and serves as a platform upon which the body portion of the assembly and other components of the vehicle can be mounted. Separate body and frame assemblies of this general type are found in most older vehicles, but remain in common use today for many relatively large or specialized use modem vehicles, such as large vans, sport utility vehicles, and trucks. In a typical unitized body and frame assembly, the structural components of the body portion and the frame portion are combined into an integral unit that is resiliently supported upon the vehicle wheels by the suspension system. Unitized body and frame assemblies of this general type are found in many relatively small modem vehicles, such as automobiles and minivans.




Traditionally, the various components of known vehicle body and frame assemblies have been formed from open channel structural members, i.e., structural members that have a non-continuous cross sectional shape (U-shaped or C-shaped channel members, for example). Thus, it is known to use one or more open channel structural members to form the side rails, the cross members, and other components of a vehicle body and frame assembly. However, the use of open channel structural members to form the various components of a vehicle body and frame assemblies has been found to be undesirable for several reasons. First, it is relatively time consuming and expensive to bend portions of such components to conform to a desired final shape, as is commonly necessary. Second, after such bending has been performed, a relatively large number of brackets or other mounting devices must usually be secured to some or all of such components to facilitate the attachment of the various parts of the vehicle to the body and frame assembly. Third, in some instances, it has been found difficult to maintain dimensional stability throughout the length of such components, particularly when two or more components are welded or otherwise secured together.




To address this, it has been proposed to form one or more of the various vehicle body and frame components from closed channel structural members, i.e., structural members that have a continuous cross sectional shape (tubular or box-shaped channel members, for example). This cross sectional shape is advantageous because it provides strength and rigidity to the vehicle body and frame component. Also, this cross sectional shape is desirable because it provides vertically and horizontally oriented side surfaces that facilitate the attachment of brackets and mounts used to support the various parts of the vehicle to the body and frame assembly. In some instances, the various parts of the vehicle may be directly attached to the vertically and horizontally oriented side surfaces of the vehicle body and frame assembly.




In vehicle body and frame assemblies of the type described above, it is often necessary to join two or more structural members together to form a vehicle frame component or to form a portion of the vehicle frame assembly. Traditionally, conventional welding techniques have been used to permanently join the various components of the vehicle frame together. As is well known, conventional welding techniques involve the application of heat to localized areas of two metallic members, which results in a coalescence of the two metallic members. Such welding may or may not be performed with the application of pressure, and may or may not include the use of a filler metal. Although conventional welding techniques have functioned satisfactorily in the past, there are some drawbacks to the use thereof in joining metallic vehicle frame components together. First, as noted above, conventional welding techniques involve the application of heat to localized areas of the two metallic frame members. This application of heat can cause undesirable distortions and weaknesses to be introduced into the metallic components. Second, while conventional welding techniques are well suited for joining components which are formed from similar metallic materials, it has been found to be somewhat more difficult to adapt them for use in joining components formed from dissimilar metallic materials. Third, conventional welding techniques are not easily adapted for joining components which have different gauge thicknesses. Inasmuch as the production of vehicle frames is usually an high volume, low margin process, it would be desirable to provide an improved method and apparatus for permanently joining two or more metallic vehicle frame components which avoids the drawbacks of conventional welding techniques.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to an improved apparatus and method for initially performing a heat treatment process on a closed channel structural member to facilitate the subsequent performance of a magnetic pulse welding process so as to manufacture a vehicle frame component or a portion of a vehicle frame assembly. Initially, a workpiece is provided that is preferably formed from a closed channel structural member having a circular or box-shaped cross sectional shape. The workpiece is subjected to a scanning heat treatment process, wherein the workpiece is heat treated in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other. Preferably, the workpiece is supported vertically during the scanning heat treatment process to prevent the shape thereof from becoming distorted. The scanning heat treatment process is preferably a retrogression heat treatment process, wherein the workpiece is rapidly heated to a sufficient temperature that provides for full or partial softening thereof, followed by relatively rapid cooling. In a third step of the method, a deforming process is performed on the workpiece during the period of time following the retrogression heat treatment process in which the workpiece retains the full or partial softening characteristics. In a fourth step of the method, a magnetic pulse welding operation is performed to secure two workpieces together so as to manufacture a vehicle frame component or a portion of a vehicle frame assembly. At least one of the two workpieces is subjected to the scanning heat treatment process to facilitate the magnetic pulse welding process.




Various objects and advantages of this invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art from the following detailed description of the preferred embodiments, when read in light of the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a flow chart of a method for manufacturing a vehicle frame assembly in accordance with the method of this invention.





FIG. 2

is a schematic side elevational view of a first embodiment of an apparatus for performing a scanning heat treatment process on a workpiece in accordance with this invention, wherein the workpiece is located at a starting position at the commencement of the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 3

is a schematic side elevational view similar to

FIG. 2

wherein the workpiece is located at an intermediate position during the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 4

is a schematic side elevational view similar to

FIG. 2

wherein the workpiece is located at an ending position at the conclusion of the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 5

is a schematic side elevational view of a second embodiment of an apparatus for performing a scanning heat treatment process on a workpiece in accordance with this invention, wherein the workpiece is located at an intermediate position during the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 6

is a schematic side elevational view of a third embodiment of an apparatus for performing a scanning heat treatment process on a workpiece in accordance with this invention, wherein the workpiece is located at an intermediate position during the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 7

is a schematic elevational view of an apparatus for performing a magnetic pulse welding operation after the scanning heat treatment process.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring now to the drawings, there is illustrated in

FIG. 1

a flow chart of a method, indicated generally at


10


, for manufacturing a vehicle frame assembly in accordance with this invention. In a first step


11


of the method


10


, a workpiece that is to be manufactured into the vehicle frame component is provided. As will be explained in greater detail below, the workpiece is preferably a closed channel structural member having a circular or box-shaped cross sectional shape. However, the workpiece may be formed having any desired cross sectional shape. The workpiece is preferably formed from a relatively lightweight metallic material, such as aluminum or alloys thereof However, any desired metallic material may be used to form the workpiece.




In a second step


12


of the method


10


, the workpiece is subjected to a scanning heat treatment process. The scanning heat treatment process can be generally characterized as any process for heat treating the workpiece in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other. This can be accomplished by initially positioning a first end of the workpiece adjacent to a hollow heat treatment mechanism, such as an annular inductor coil. Then, the workpiece is moved longitudinally through the heat treatment mechanism such that it is heat treated in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other as it passes therethrough. The scanning heat treatment process can be performed in a number of different ways, and the structures of several embodiments of an apparatus for performing such a scanning heat treatment process are discussed in detail below. Preferably, the heat treatment is a retrogression heat treatment process. Generally speaking, the retrogression heat treatment process is performed by rapidly heating the workpiece to a sufficient temperature that provides for full or partial softening thereof, followed by relatively rapid cooling. Notwithstanding this cooling, the workpiece retains the full or partial softening characteristics for at least a relatively short period of time.




The third step


13


of the method


10


involves performing a deforming process on the workpiece. Preferably, this deforming process (which, if desired, can be omitted in its entirety) is performed during the period of time following the retrogression heat treatment process in which the workpiece retains the full or partial softening characteristics. Any desired deforming process may be performed on the workpiece. If, for example, the workpiece is a closed channel structural member, the deforming process may be performed by hydroforming. Hydroforming is a well known process that uses pressurized fluid to deform a closed channel structural member into a desired shape. To accomplish this, the closed channel structural member is initially disposed between two die sections of a hydroforming apparatus that, when closed together, define a die cavity having a desired final shape. Thereafter, the closed channel structural member is filled with a pressurized fluid, typically a relatively incompressible liquid such as water. The pressure of the fluid is increased to a magnitude where the closed channel structural member is expanded or otherwise deformed outwardly into conformance with the die cavity. As a result, the closed channel structural member can be deformed into the desired final shape for the vehicle frame component by the hydroforming process.




The deforming process may alternatively be performed by magnetic pulse forming. Magnetic pulse forming is also a well known process that uses an electromagnetic field to deform a workpiece into a desire shape. To accomplish this, an electromagnetic coil is provided for generating an intense magnetic field about the workpiece. When this occurs, a large pressure is exerted on the workpiece, causing it to be deformed against a support surface. If the electromagnetic coil is disposed about the exterior of the workpiece, then the workpiece is deformed inwardly into engagement with the support surface. If, on the other hand, the electromagnetic coil is disposed within the interior of the workpiece, then the workpiece is deformed outwardly into engagement with the support surface. In either event, the workpiece can be deformed into the desired final shape for the vehicle frame component by the magnetic pulse forming process.




In a final step


14


of the method


10


, the vehicle frame component is secured to one or more other vehicle frame components to form a vehicle frame assembly. The securing of such vehicle frame components is performed by a magnetic pulse welding operation. Magnetic pulse welding is a process wherein first and second vehicle frame components are initially disposed telescopically within one another. When so disposed, one end of the first vehicle frame component longitudinally overlaps one end of the second vehicle frame component. An electromagnetic coil is provided for generating an intense magnetic field about the overlapping portions of the first and second vehicle frame components. When this occurs, a large pressure is exerted on the first and second vehicle frame components, causing them to move toward one another at a high velocity. If the electromagnetic coil is disposed about the exterior of the two vehicle frame components, then the outer vehicle frame component is deformed inwardly into engagement with the inner vehicle frame component. If, on the other hand, the electromagnetic coil is disposed within the interior of the two vehicle frame components, then the inner vehicle frame component is deformed outwardly into engagement with the outer vehicle frame component. In either event, the high velocity impact of the first and second vehicle frame components, as well as the large pressures exerted thereon, cause the two vehicle frame components to become permanently joined together.





FIG. 2

is a schematic side elevational view of a first embodiment of an apparatus, indicated generally at


20


, for performing the scanning heat treatment process in accordance with this invention. The apparatus


20


includes an annular induction heating coil


21


and an annular water quenching ring


22


that are preferably disposed adjacent to one another, as illustrated. The induction heating coil


21


is conventional in the art and is connected to a control circuit


23


for selectively causing an electrical current to flow therethrough. The operation of the induction heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


will be explained further below. The apparatus


20


further includes a support mechanism, a portion of which is illustrated at


24


. The support mechanism


24


includes a collet


24




a


or other mechanism for engaging one end of a workpiece


25


. The illustrated support mechanism


24


is structured so as to suspend the workpiece


25


vertically downwardly from the end engaged by the collet


24




a


, although such is not necessary.




The locations of the support mechanism


24


and the workpiece


25


at the commencement of the scanning heat treatment process to be performed by the induction heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


are illustrated in FIG.


2


. As shown therein, the workpiece


25


is initially suspended vertically above the induction heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


by the support mechanism


24


. Then, the support mechanism


24


is operated to lower the workpiece


25


vertically downwardly through the induction heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


. As this occurs, an electrical current is passed through the induction heating coil


21


by the control circuit


23


. As is well known, when an electrical current is passed through the induction heating coil


21


, corresponding electrical currents are induced to flow within the metallic workpiece


25


. Because of the internal electrical resistance of the metallic workpiece


25


to the flow of electrical current, these induced electrical currents are converted to heat energy. As a result, the leading end of the workpiece


25


that is initially disposed within the induction heating coil


21


is rapidly heated to an elevated temperature. If desired, other heating structures may be provided in lieu of the inductive heating coil


21


.

FIGS. 3 and 4

show the support mechanism


24


and the workpiece at subsequent stages of the scanning heat treatment process. In

FIG. 3

, the support mechanism


24


and the workpiece


25


are located at an intermediate position relative to the heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


during the scanning heat treatment process. In

FIG. 4

, the support mechanism


24


and the workpiece


25


are located at an ending position relative to the heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


at the conclusion of the scanning heat treatment process. As is apparent from these drawings, the support mechanism


24


is effective to lower the workpiece


25


longitudinally downwardly through the inductive heating coil


21


such that the workpiece


25


is heated in a continuous and longitudinal manner from the leading end to the trailing end.




As mentioned above, the quenching ring


22


is disposed adjacent to the induction heating coil


21


. The quenching ring


22


is also conventional in the art and is provided to rapidly cool the workpiece


25


after it has been heated by the induction heating coil


21


. Thus, after the leading end of the workpiece


25


has been moved downwardly through the induction heating coil


21


and rapidly heated, it is immediately moved downwardly through the quenching ring


22


, wherein it is rapidly cooled. If desired, other cooling structures may be provided in lieu of the quenching ring


22


. Thus, the support mechanism


24


is also effective to lower the workpiece


25


longitudinally downwardly through the quenching ring


22


such that the workpiece


25


is also cooled in a continuous and longitudinal manner from the leading end to the trailing end after being heated.




At the conclusion of the scanning heat treatment process, the workpiece


25


can be released from the collet


24




a


of the support mechanism


24


and transferred to a transport mechanism (not shown) for delivery to a apparatus for deforming the workpiece


25


in accordance with the third step


13


of the method


10


described above. Preferably, the workpiece


25


is released from the collet


24




a


without having to be retracted upwardly through the inductive heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


. However, the workpiece


25


may be retracted upwardly through the inductive heating coil


21


and the quenching ring


22


before being transferred to the transport mechanism if desired.




Accordingly, it can be seen that the scanning heat treatment process is performed on the workpiece


25


in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other. As mentioned above, the scanning heat treatment process is preferably a retrogression heat treatment process, wherein the workpiece


25


is rapidly heated by the inductive heating coil


21


to a sufficient temperature that provides for full or partial softening thereof, followed by relatively rapid cooling by the quenching ring


22


. Notwithstanding this cooling, the workpiece


25


retains the full or partial softening characteristics for at least a relatively short period of time in which the subsequent deforming step


13


and the magnetic pulse welding step


14


of the method


10


described above can be performed.




As mentioned above, the workpiece


25


is preferably supported vertically during the scanning heat treatment process to prevent the shape thereof from becoming distorted. This is because vehicle frame components are frequently relatively long in length and are relatively heavy in weight. If a relatively long and heavy workpiece


25


is suspended horizontally at its two ends during the scanning heat treatment process, it is possible that the central portion thereof may bow downwardly or otherwise distort under the influence of gravity during or after the scanning heat treatment process. By suspending the workpiece


25


vertically during the scanning heat treatment process, the likelihood of such distortions is greatly reduced because the weight of the workpiece is insufficient to cause any significant elongation or other shape distortion thereof.





FIG. 5

is a schematic side elevational view of a second embodiment of an apparatus, indicated generally at


30


, for performing the scanning heat treatment process in accordance with this invention. The apparatus


30


includes an annular induction heating coil


31


and an annular water quenching ring


32


that are preferably disposed adjacent to one another, as illustrated. The induction heating coil


31


is conventional in the art and is connected to a control circuit


33


for selectively causing an electrical current to flow therethrough. The operation of the induction heating coil


31


, the quenching ring


32


, and the control circuit


33


are essentially the same as described above. The apparatus


30


further includes a support mechanism, a portion of which is illustrated at


34


. The support mechanism


34


includes an end surface


34




a


or other engaging mechanism for engaging one end of a workpiece


35


. The illustrated support mechanism


34


is structured so as to support the workpiece


35


vertically upwardly from the end engaged by the end surface


34




a


. The support mechanism


34


functions in a similar manner as the above-described support mechanism


24


to lower the workpiece


35


longitudinally downwardly to perform the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 6

is a schematic side elevational view of a third embodiment of an apparatus, indicated generally at


40


, for performing the scanning heat treatment process in accordance with this invention. The apparatus


40


includes an annular induction heating coil


41


and an annular water quenching ring


42


that are preferably disposed adjacent to one another, as illustrated. The induction heating coil


41


is conventional in the art and is connected to a control circuit


43


for selectively causing an electrical current to flow therethrough. The operation of the induction heating coil


41


, the quenching ring


42


, and the control circuit


43


are essentially the same as described above. The apparatus


40


further includes an upper support mechanism, a portion of which is illustrated at


44


. The upper support mechanism


44


includes a collet


44




a


or other engaging structure for engaging an upper end of a workpiece


45


and functions similarly to the support mechanism


24


described above. The apparatus


40


further includes a lower support mechanism, a portion of which is illustrated at


46


. The lower support mechanism


46


includes an end surface


46




a


or other engaging mechanism for engaging a lower end of the workpiece


45


and functions similarly to the support mechanism


35


described above.




The illustrated upper and lower support mechanisms


44


and


46


are structured so as to support the workpiece


45


vertically to lower the workpiece


35


longitudinally downwardly to perform the scanning heat treatment process. This can be accomplished by initially supporting the upper end of the workpiece


45


only by the upper support mechanism


44


and lowering the workpiece


45


partially downwardly through the inductive heating coil


41


and the quenching ring


42


. During this initial movement, the lower end of the workpiece


45


is freely movable through the inductive heating coil


41


and the quenching ring


42


. When the workpiece


45


has been moved partially through the inductive heating coil


41


and the quenching ring


42


, the lower end engages the lower support mechanism


46


, and the upper support mechanism


44


is released. Thereafter, the lower support mechanism


46


continues the lowering of the workpiece


45


. During this subsequent movement, the upper end of the workpiece


45


is freely movable through the inductive heating coil


41


and the quenching ring


42


. Thus, both extreme ends of the workpiece


45


can be fully subjected to the scanning heat treatment process.





FIG. 7

is a schematic elevational view of an apparatus, indicated generally at


50


, for performing a magnetic pulse welding operation in accordance with the final step


14


of the method


10


described above. The apparatus


50


includes an inductor


51


, the structure of which is generally conventional in the art. The illustrated inductor


51


is annular in shape and is sized to be disposed concentrically about first and second workpieces


52


and


53


that are themselves disposed in telescopic relationship. However, it will be appreciated that the inductor


51


may alternatively be sized to be disposed telescopically within the two workpieces


52


and


53


. The illustrated workpieces


52


and


53


can be embodied as separate members (sections of a side rail, for example) that are adapted to be joined together to form a single integral vehicle frame component (such as a side rail) for a vehicle frame assembly. However, the two workpieces


52


and


53


may be embodied as any other structures (such as side rail and a cross member, for example) that form a portion of a vehicle frame assembly. It is contemplated that either or both of the workpieces


52


and


53


may have been subjected to the above-described retrogression heat treatment process.




Regardless, the two workpieces


52


and


53


are initially disposed in a spaced apart relationship, as shown. Although the clearance between the two workpieces


52


and


53


may be adjusted as desired, it has been found acceptable to provide a clearance in the range of from 0.050 inch to 0.100 inch. The inductor


51


is then disposed about the two workpieces


52


and


53


. When the inductor


51


is energized in a manner that is well known in the art, an electromagnetic field is generated about the two workpieces


52


and


53


. This electromagnetic field causes the outer workpiece


52


to be collapsed inwardly into engagement with the inner workpiece


53


at a high velocity. As a result, the two workpieces


52


and


53


are welded or molecularly bonded together. Preferably, this joining process is performed during the period of time following the retrogression heat treatment process in which the workpiece


52


retains the full or partial softening characteristics. This is because the retrogression heat treatment process temporarily alters the material properties of the workpiece


52


, eliminating the need for extremely high power and extremely tight tolerances during the magnetic pulse welding process.




In accordance with the provisions of the patent statutes, the principle and mode of operation of this invention have been explained and illustrated in its preferred embodiment. However, it must be understood that this invention may be practiced otherwise than as specifically explained and illustrated without departing from its spirit or scope.



Claims
  • 1. A method for permanently joining first and second workpieces together comprising the steps of:(a) providing a first workpiece having an end portion and a second workpiece having an end portion; (b) performing a scanning heat treatment process on the first workpiece in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end of the end portion to the other end of the end portion so as to soften the end portion of the first workpiece; (c) disposing the end portion of the first workpiece and the end portion of the second workpiece in an overlapping relationship; and (d) while the end portion of the first workpiece remains softened, performing a magnetic pulse welding operation on the overlapping end portions of the first and second workpieces to permanently join them together.
  • 2. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said step (a) is performed by providing the first workpiece as a closed channel structural member.
  • 3. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said step (b) is performed by moving the end portion of the first workpiece through an inductive heating coil and a quenching ring.
  • 4. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said step (b) is performed while the first workpiece is oriented vertically.
  • 5. The method defined in claim 4 wherein said step (b) is performed by suspending the first workpiece vertically by an upper end and moving the first workpiece downwardly through an inductive heating coil and a quenching ring.
  • 6. The method defined in claim 4 wherein said step (b) is performed by supporting the first workpiece vertically by a lower end and moving the workpiece downwardly through an inductive heating coil and a quenching ring.
  • 7. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said step (b) is performed by initially suspending the first workpiece vertically by an upper end and moving the workpiece partially downwardly through an inductive heating coil and a quenching ring, and by subsequently supporting the first workpiece vertically by a lower end and moving the first workpiece further downwardly through the inductive heating coil and the quenching ring.
  • 8. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said step (b) is performed by (1) performing a scanning heat treatment process on the first workpiece in a continuous and longitudinal manner from one end to the other so as to soften the first workpiece, and (2) while the first workpiece remains softened, deforming the first workpiece to form a vehicle frame component.
  • 9. The method defined in claim 8 wherein said step (b)(2) is performed by hydroforming.
  • 10. The method defined in claim 8 wherein said step (b)(2) is performed by magnetic pulse forming.
US Referenced Citations (10)
Number Name Date Kind
3258573 Morin et al. Jun 1966 A
3603760 Khrenov et al. Sep 1971 A
4150274 Minin et al. Apr 1979 A
4362578 Mills et al. Dec 1982 A
4766664 Benedyk Aug 1988 A
5332281 Janotik et al. Jul 1994 A
5435110 Stol et al. Jul 1995 A
5442846 Snaper Aug 1995 A
5716155 Yoshida et al. Feb 1998 A
5794398 Kaekler et al. Aug 1998 A