Patent Grant
11933264
The present invention relates generally to wind turbines, and more particularly to wind turbine blades for use on wind turbines and methods and systems for manufacturing wind turbine blades.
Wind turbines are used to produce electrical energy using a renewable resource and without combusting a fossil fuel. Generally, a wind turbine converts kinetic energy into mechanical energy and then subsequently converts the mechanical energy into electrical energy. A horizontal-axis wind turbine includes a tower, a nacelle located at the apex of the tower, and a rotor that is supported in the nacelle. The rotor is coupled either directly or indirectly with a generator, which is housed inside the nacelle. The rotor includes a central hub and a plurality of blades (e.g., three blades) mounted thereto and that extend radially therefrom.
A wind turbine blade is a complex structure that must be constructed to withstand long term service in an abusive environment. To that end, wind turbine blades must satisfy several design criteria. In this regard, to produce electrical energy, the blade must have a shape that interacts with wind to produce lift while minimizing drag. Lift allows the blade to rotate the hub when acted upon by the wind. The blade must also support itself under gravity, under wind loading, and under other dynamic loading as the wind turbine blade rotates the hub. The surface of the blade needs to resist degradation for as long as possible when exposed to abrasive wear, to UV radiation, and to other harsh environmental conditions.
In view of these criteria, the massive wind turbine blades are complex structures. Wind turbine blades are often constructed of a shell, spar caps, and one or more shear webs. The shell is typically a layered composite that forms the exterior surface of the blade and thus encloses the shear webs and spar caps, which enables the shell to resist flap and edgewise loading during use of the blade. The shell is therefore exposed to the environment and is shaped to produce the lift needed to rotate the hub. Conventional wind turbine blades are currently manufactured by a manually intensive production process. In addition, production of large wind turbine blades requires a large amount of capital in the form of large facilities and mold making equipment. In one such process, two large-scale molds must first be produced. The molds define the external shape of the wind turbine blade. Each mold forms approximately one half of the shell.
Once the molds are manufactured, a laminate structure that forms the shell of the wind turbine blade is produced from each mold by placing a fiber-resin composite in the mold. A process that may include vacuum infusion may be utilized to infuse a fabric, such as a glass or carbon fiber fabric, with resin in the mold. Robots and other automation may be used to assist in this process and to reduce the otherwise manually intensive process of laying up the molds. The resin is then cured.
The cured fiber-resin composite structure conforms to the mold surface to form one-half of the shell of the wind turbine blade. The shells may be stiffened by inserting a core of foam or balsa wood where needed. With the aid of cranes, the two shell halves are extracted from their respective molds and are bonded together. Once bonded, the blades are finished. Because it is a manual process, variation from blade to blade may be significant and defects, such as delamination, can occur. Once finished, the large wind turbine blades are transported from the manufacturing facility to the installation site, which may be hundreds to thousands of kilometers away.
By this process, a strong shell is produced. The shell is designed to satisfy each of the several design criteria. That is, it is shaped to provide lift, it is made of a material that significantly resists environmental degradation, and even though it may be structurally reinforced by the spar caps/shear webs, the shell has strength and thus is at least somewhat self-supporting. But this strong shell design may not optimal. By way of example, the properties of the blade cannot be varied along the blade's length. This is because the molding process constrains desirable variation. As a result, the blade is constructed with more material in the shell than is necessary to ensure that the blade is stronger than is necessary. Even though more desirable designs may be available, conventional molding techniques thus inhibit adoption of those designs.
Accordingly, there is a need for improved wind turbine blades and methods and systems for manufacturing wind turbine blades that permit variation in the structure of the turbine blade while also improving resistance to environmental degradation.
To address these and other drawbacks, a wind turbine blade includes at least one lengthwise portion that extends between a root region including a root end and the tip region including a tip of the wind turbine blade. The lengthwise portion includes a cross section in which a first region of a first density surrounds a second region of a second density. The second region includes a volume of void space such that the second density is less than the first density. Furthermore, the density of the lengthwise portion may vary from a maximum density at or near an exterior surface of the wind turbine blade to a minimum density at or near the core of the lengthwise portion. This configuration may improve the structural strength of the wind turbine blade. In that regard, the first region may include a first volume of void space and the second region may include a second volume of void space greater than the first volume of void space. In one embodiment, the void space may be formed by a honeycomb structure. In one embodiment, the void space may be formed by a porous structure. The lengthwise portion includes a surface layer that bounds the first region, forms an exterior surface of the wind turbine blade, and is configured to resist environmental degradation. In one embodiment, the lengthwise portion extends from the root region into at least the mid span region. In addition or alternatively, the lengthwise portion may extend to the tip, and in the tip region, the lengthwise portion lacks the second region.
In accordance with one embodiment, a wind turbine includes a tower, a nacelle disposed adjacent a top of the tower, and a rotor including a hub and at least one wind turbine blade including at least one lengthwise portion as described herein extending from the hub.
In one embodiment, the wind turbine blade includes at least one structural element that extends longitudinally through the first region and that is configured to reinforce the blade under load during use of the wind turbine. In this regard, the first region may include a recess and the structural element may be coupled to the first region in the recess. The cross section of the lengthwise portion may further include a third region of a third density in which case the second region may surround the third region. Following the general trend for variation in density, the second density is greater than the third density.
In an aspect of the invention, the lengthwise portion of a wind turbine blade may be made through an additive manufacturing process. In that regard, the lengthwise portion may be made by depositing a main body in a plurality of layers such that a cross section of the main body includes the first region surrounding the second region. The first and second regions are of different density with the second region including a volume of void space that is greater than the void space, if any, in the first region. The void space may be defined by a honeycomb structure or by a plurality of pores in a porous structure. Each layer may be deposited in a plane generally parallel to a longitudinal axis of the lengthwise portion. According to the additive manufacturing process, the material of the first region may be the same as the material of the second region. During the additive manufacturing process, the layers may be built around the structural elements. Alternatively, recesses may be built into the main body and a structural element may then be inserted into a corresponding recess following construction of the main body.
If the main body is not constructed on a film, which may later form the surface layer of the wind turbine blade, in one embodiment, the surface layer is formed by inserting the main body into an envelope and shrinking (e.g., by heating) the envelope onto the main body. In one embodiment, the method includes producing digital data defining a three-dimensional model of the wind turbine blade. A material is deposited to form the lengthwise portion of the wind turbine blade based on the digital data. In particular, the plurality of layers is deposited in accordance with the digital data, layer by layer. Each layer of the material is in the shape of a two-dimensional cross section of the three-dimensional model. The layers are stacked in a third dimension to define the first region and the second region extending the length of the lengthwise portion.
The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate embodiments of the invention and together with the detailed description given below, serve to explain various aspects of the invention.
With reference to
According to embodiments of the invention, one or more of the wind turbine blades 22 (or lengthwise portions thereof) may be manufactured according to an additive manufacturing technique. By way of example only, and not limitation, the wind turbine blades 22 may be produced by a layering process, such as VAT photopolymerization, stereolithography (SL), digital light processing (DLP), selective laser sintering (SLS), selective laser melting (SLM), electron beam melting (EBM), binder jetting, material jetting, direct metal layer sintering (DMLS), or fused deposition modeling (FDM), to name only a few. These processes utilize computer controlled deposition of individual layers of material based on a computer model of a part.
The computer model is divided into model layers. Each model layer may then be reproduced by depositing a layer of material from a 3-D printer. The individual model layers may be deposited from a powder or from a ribbon of extruded material, for example. The deposited layers are based on discrete cross sections of the model as determined by slicing the model into a finite number of individual model layers. By depositing each layer, one deposited layer on a preceding deposited layer, the computer model of the part is used to construct a real part. These 3-D printing processes may utilize various materials including thermoplastics, thermosetting resins, metals, and combinations thereof, and other materials. Additive manufacturing of the blades eliminates the necessity, lead time, and expense of large molds. According to embodiments of the present invention, because the wind turbine blades are produced from an essentially mold-less process, changes in the wind turbine blade design may be incorporated quickly and easily. In addition, advantageously, wind turbine blades may be manufactured at the installation site of the wind turbine thus eliminating problems associated with transportation of the blades.
In this regard, as is described below, the wind turbine blade 22 or a lengthwise portion 24 thereof may be manufactured by depositing one layer at a time as determined by a three-dimensional computer model of the wind turbine blade 22. By the additive manufacturing process, the density of the material may be varied generally from at or near the exterior surface of the wind turbine blade 22 to the center or core of the wind turbine blade 22. In addition, the density of the material varies along the length of the lengthwise portion 24. Thus, in one embodiment, the density is varied in three dimensions—along the length and the width and the height (i.e., the cross section) of the wind turbine blade 22. It will be appreciated that the lengthwise portion 24 may extend the full length of the wind turbine blade 22 and so the density may vary along the full length of the wind turbine blade 22.
In general, with regard to density variations in the cross section, the density of the material is relatively high at or near the exterior surface of the wind turbine blade 22. From a high density outer region, the density decreases toward a core of the wind turbine blade 22. This density variation across the cross section of the wind turbine blade 22 from the exterior surface to the core is very much like the density variation in bones and so cross sections of the wind turbine blade 22 according to embodiments of the invention may appear to be bone-like. Advantageously, the density variation strengthens the wind turbine blade 22 while reducing its weight.
To these and other ends, the density variation may be accomplished by an additive manufacturing technique which permits building of different amounts of void space within a pre-defined structure. The void space is controlled through the cross section of the lengthwise portion 24 and along the length of the lengthwise portion 24. While the density variations are described below with regard to
In one embodiment and by way of example only, a honeycomb structure may be built to encapsulate a predetermined volume of void space. The honeycomb structure may change in size along the cross section of the lengthwise portion. As the size of the honeycomb structure is changed, the volume of the void space encapsulated by the structure may be changed. This may be achieved by changing the thickness of the walls of the honeycomb structure, for example. In one embodiment, the honeycomb structure is enlarged while the wall thickness of the honeycomb structure is constant. This construction encapsulates more void space in each honeycomb and reduces the density of the region. The relative enlargement of the void space at constant wall thickness may increase from an exterior surface of the lengthwise portion toward a centroid of the cross section of the lengthwise portion. In this case, the volume of material of the honeycomb structure is decreased (i.e., because the wall thickness of the honeycomb structure is constant) while the volume of void space increases. Thus, the density is generally reduced from the exterior surface toward the center of the wind turbine blade.
In one embodiment, a similar density variation may be achieved by depositing material and controlling the porosity of that material. In contrast to the honeycomb structure, which may be intentionally constructed to a specific size, pore structure may be more random and naturally occurring, though certain aspects of the pore structure are controlled to provide density variation. That is, the void space is controlled through control of the volume of porosity per unit volume of deposited material. The volume of pores in the material may be varied across the cross section from very little or no porosity at or near an exterior surface of the lengthwise portion 24 to a large percentage of porosity at or near the center of the lengthwise portion 24. By way of example, the volume of porosity may be controlled by changing the size of the pores. Where the average pore size is reduced and the number of pores per unit volume is essentially maintained, the density of the region will increase. Thus, in one embodiment, the pore size may increase from at or near the exterior surface of the lengthwise portion 24 toward the center of the lengthwise portion 24. As an alternative, the volume of porosity may be controlled by maintaining the pore size but increasing the number of pores per unit volume of material. It will be appreciated that controlling a combination of pore size and pore number per unit volume may produce the density variation along the cross section and along the length of the lengthwise portion 24.
The material of the pre-defined structure may be a thermoplastic, such as acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS); a polyamide, like nylon; poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA); polylactic acid (PLA); polycarbonate (PC); polyethylene (PE); polypropylene (PP); polyvinyl chloride (PVC); and polyether sulfone (PES), among others. In one embodiment, the structure may be made of recycled plastic materials. In addition, or in the alternative, a variety of thermoset materials may be utilized.
With continued reference to
The wind turbine 10 may be included among a collection of similar wind turbines belonging to a wind farm or wind park (not shown) that serves as a power generating plant connected by transmission lines with a power grid, such as a three-phase alternating current (AC) power grid. The power grid generally consists of a network of power stations, transmission circuits, and substations coupled by a network of transmission lines that transmit the power to loads in the form of end users and other customers of electrical utilities. Under normal circumstances, the electrical energy is supplied from the generator 18 to the power grid as known in the art.
With reference to
In view of the above and with reference now to
The load on the wind turbine blade 22 is instead borne by the regions of different density (described below) in the lengthwise portions 24, which may be reinforced with one or more structural elements 50 (
In the exemplary embodiment shown, the high density region 52 may generally define an outermost ring portion of the wind turbine blade 22 in the root region 34. The surface layer 46 conforms to the outer boundary of the high density region 52 and so forms the exterior surface 48 of the wind turbine blade 22. As shown, the high density region 52 is bounded by the surface layer 46 at one boundary and by the medium density region 54 at the opposing boundary. Similarly, the medium density region 54 is bounded by the high density region 52 and the low density region 56.
The medium density region 54 may also have a ring-like appearance. In the exemplary embodiment shown, the low density region 56 may also be a layered or ring-like structure that defines or surrounds the core 60. This ring-on-ring structure may have a bull's-eye appearance. However, embodiments of the invention are not limited to a layered, concentric ring configuration such as that shown. For example, any single one or all of the regions 52, 54, 56 may be non-symmetrical with respect to the surface layer 46 and with respect to one another. The regions 52, 54, 56 may be shaped to account for a particular distribution of stresses on the wind turbine blade 22.
As described above, the cross sections of the lengthwise portion 24 taken perpendicular to the longitudinal axis 44 may have a bone-like density variation with a decrease in density in a radial direction from the surface layer 46 toward the core 60. With reference to
In one embodiment, each of the regions 52, 54, 56 is about one third the width of the radius of the root region 34, though embodiments of the invention are not limited to equally proportioned regions. In the embodiment shown, each of the regions 52, 54, 56 is substantially thicker than the thickness of the surface layer 46. By way of example only, any single one of the regions 52, 54, 56 may be at least 100 times the thickness of the skin layer 46. Further, the relative thicknesses of the regions 52, 54, 56 may vary along the length of the lengthwise portion 24. For example, one or two of the regions 52, 54, 56 may have a greater thickness in the root region 34 than in the tip region 38. Alternatively, portions of the wind turbine blade 22 may include a cavity at or near the core 60. The cavity at or near the core 60 may extend along the full length or lesser length of the lengthwise portion 24. In this case, and by way of example, one or both of the low density region 56 and the medium density region 54 may be absent at that portion of the wind turbine blade 22 to define a centralized cavity. As another example, the aggregate thicknesses of each of the regions 52, 54, 56 may be reduced to leave a centralized cavity at or near the core 60 of the lengthwise portion 24. In other words, embodiments of the invention are not limited to elimination of one of the regions 52, 54, 56 to define a cavity. Rather, cross sections of the lengthwise portion 24 may include each of the regions 52, 54, 56 where at least a portion of the low density region defines a centralized cavity. The description of the variation of the different regions of density is not intended to be limiting in any way. For example, the variation in density may vary gradually across the cross section rather than having well defined boundaries, as shown. This may be applicable for variation in the density by control of the pore structure, described above. For example, while the number of pores per unit volume of material remains constant, the pore size may be gradually increased from the exterior surface 48 toward the core 60.
With reference to
The structural elements 50 may be positioned between the high density region 52 and the surface layer 46. As shown in
Although not shown, the structural elements 50 may be fully embedded within the high density region 52 such that the high density region 52 surrounds each of the elements 50. Embodiments of the present invention are not limited to the structural elements 50 extending through the high density region 52. In addition or as an alternative, the structural elements 50 may extend through the medium density region 54 and even the low density region 56 along the length of the wind turbine blade 22.
While six structural elements 50 are shown in
Structural elements 50 may be a material that has a higher elastic modulus (i.e., is stiffer) than the material of each of the high density region 52, the medium density region 54, and the low density region 56. By way of example only, and not limitation, the structural elements 50 may be pultruded fibers (e.g., pultruded glass and/or carbon fibers). While rectangular shaped structural elements 50 are shown, it will be appreciated that the structural elements 50 are not limited to any specific shape, for example, the structural elements 50 may have a rod shape.
With reference to
The variation in density in the mid span region 42 may be similar to the density variation in the root region 34 proximate the end 36 as shown in
With reference to
As with the structural elements 50 shown in
With reference to
As introduced above and with reference to
Referring now to
Under computer control, the manufacturing system 100 may deposit material in a layer representing a corresponding layer of the model to build up the wind turbine blade 22 a discrete layer at a time. Depositing material can be by directly depositing layers of material of which the wind turbine blade 22 is made. In particular, the depositing material may include depositing layers from which each of the high density region 52, the medium density region 54, and the low density region 56 is made. Thus, depositing may include building a honeycomb structure or a porous structure in which the volume of void space and volume of material is controlled, as is described above.
In one embodiment, a 3-D printing process is used to produce wind turbine blades, layer by layer, to form a main body 122 having full three-dimensional properties. The wind turbine blade 22 is not produced by assembling separate sections (i.e., from two halves) and so is monolithic in some respects. In one embodiment, at least the main body 122 varies only in density of the material by which the main body 122 is designed to handle loads during use of the wind turbine blade 22. Additive manufacturing processes are particularly useful for wind turbine blades made of materials such as plastics and metals. Wind turbine blades made in this manner may not require extensive machining or may not require any machining. In view of the above, direct 3-D printing processes may eliminate the need to cast custom molds for the wind turbine blade, may eliminate the need to mold the wind turbine blade in two halves for later assembly, and may eliminate the need to machine the wind turbine blade prior to or following assembly of the two halves according to conventional manufacturing techniques.
With reference to
With the system 100, the 3-D printing process may produce the high density region 52, the medium density region 54, and the low density region 56 by changing the structure of the material in each of these regions. As described above, this may include intentionally modifying the ratio of the volume of the material to the volume of void space. Thus, the density of the regions 52, 54, and 56, and their portions of the cross section may be adjusted to account for a particular loading on the wind turbine blade 22 while also reducing the weight of the wind turbine blade 22 relative to conventional blades of the same size.
To that end, the system 100 may include a robotic system 114 that is operatively coupled to the print head 112. The robotic system 114 may be capable of moving the print head 112 in at least the three Cartesian coordinate directions (i.e., X-axis, Y-axis, and Z-Axis) according to instructions from a controller (not shown). The print head 112 deposits each layer from the digital model by translating in each of the directions. In that regard, the exemplary robotic system 114 includes cables 116 on which a carriage 118 rides in the x-axis and possibly along the y-axis. The carriage 118 suspends the print head 112 above the supports 106. The cables 116 may be coupled to a frame 124 which supports the robotic system 114 above the supports 106. The cables 116 extend more than the longitudinal length of the wind turbine blade 22 so that the controller may move the carriage 118 the entire length of the wind turbine blade 22 between the end 36 and the tip 40. The carriage 118 has arms 120 that position and reposition the print head 112 in the y- and z-axes above the supports 106. It will be appreciated that for lengths of lengthwise portions 24 that are less than the full length of the wind turbine blade 22, the cables 116 may extend to a lesser length or the carriage 118 may be adjusted to traverse only the length necessary to manufacture the lengthwise portion desired.
With continued reference to
In addition, in one embodiment, prior to depositing the lengthwise portion 24, a surface film (not shown) may be placed on the supports 106. The film may be a preformed sheet or may be formed by depositing the film on the support 106 with the print head 112. The surface film may form the surface layer 46, described above, or be a release sheet to aid separation of the main body 122 from the support 106.
In addition to placement of a film, one or more structural elements 50 may be positioned on the supports 106 (or on the film) so as to span the supports 106. After the supports 106 are deposited, any film is placed on the supports 106, and/or the structural elements 50 are positioned, the main body 122 may be deposited in layers 102 according to the three-dimensional model. In embodiments in which multiple supports 106 are utilized, placement of the structural elements 50 and/or the film on the supports 106 prior to deposition may aid deposition of the layers 102 by effectively providing support for the layers 102 at locations between the supports 106.
In that regard, raw materials from one or both tanks 128 may then be deposited in layers 102 on the support 106 or on the film to build the main body 122. Each layer 102 may define a slice of each of the regions 52, 54, 56. In that regard, the layers 102 collectively define a honeycomb structure or another structure that encapsulates a predetermined volume of void space, or the layers 102 collectively define a porous structure in which the size and/or number of pores per unit volume of material is dispersed within the material of the region. The density variation from one region to the next may be produced by changing the ratio of the structure to the void space in each layer 102. In the high density region 52, very little to no void space may be encapsulated by each of the honeycombs, for example. In the medium density region 54, the honeycomb structure may be enlarged to capture more void space within each honeycomb and thus reduce the density in the medium density region 54 relative to the high density region 52. Similarly, in the low density region 56, the honeycomb structure may capture an even larger proportion of void space than in the medium density region 54 and thus reduce the density of the low density region 56 relative to the medium density region 54.
As an alternative and depending on the type of additive manufacturing process utilized to construct the main body 122, the deposited layers 102 may initially include raw material that is ultimately removed from the main body 122 once the main body 122 is formed. By way of example only, a first material may be deposited from Tank #1. A second material may be deposited from Tank #2 in the same layer as the first material. The first material may be removed from the main body 122 subsequent to formation of that layer or construction of the main body 122. Removing that material forms void space with the second material providing the structure of the region 52, 54, and 56 and thus provides the density variation within the main body 122. In this way, the remaining, second material forms the structure of the regions 52, 54, 56. As another alternative, two different materials may be deposited simultaneously from one or more print heads in each layer 102 or the two materials may be deposited and then react to form a porous material of the layer 102.
In one embodiment, as is shown in
With reference to
With reference to
Alternatively, and with reference to
In one embodiment, a combination of the process illustrated in
Once the layers 102 are deposited to complete the main body 122, the main body 122 may be removed from the system 100. Another wind turbine blade may be built from the same model onto the supports 106. If not encased in the main body 122 during the build process, the structural elements 50 may be inserted into the recesses 126 following formation of the main body 122. The surface layer 46 may then be constructed on the main body 122 to encapsulate the main body 122 and the structural elements 50 within a skin of material.
In one embodiment, the layer 46 may be produced by a heat shrinking process. To do so, the main body 122 and the structural elements 50 may be inserted into a large, seamless envelope (e.g., a bag) (not shown) of the material from which the surface layer 46 is to be made. Once the main body 122 is inserted into the envelope, the envelope may be heated within a large oven or with a heat source directed to localized portions of the envelope. The localized source may produce heat sufficient to increase the temperature of the envelope to up to about 100° C. or hotter. Heat sources may include hot water or steam, which may be sprayed onto the envelope or onto the surface of the main body 122. By this process, the envelope may shrink into contact with the main body 122 to produce a seamless surface layer 46. Once encapsulated within the surface layer 46, the wind turbine blade 22 may undergo finishing, which may include sanding and/or painting.
While the system 100 having a single print head 112 is shown, it will be appreciated that additional print heads may be utilized to more quickly produce the main body 122. It will be further appreciated that the system 100 may be constructed at the site at which the wind turbine 10 is to be installed. The system 100 may be transported in separate pieces by, for example, tractor-trailer and then assembled or may be transported via ship to the wind turbine installation site. Advantageously, the system 100 and the necessary materials may be easily transported to the installation site as compared to a wind turbine blade according to conventional (i.e., molding) manufacturing techniques. It will be appreciated that systems having other configurations are possible. As an example, a six-axis robot may be supported on a rail system (not shown) adjacent the supports 106 with a print head mounted on the robotic system. A control system may then control the robot and its position on the rail to deposit layers in a similar manner to that described herein.
While the present invention has been illustrated by a description of various embodiments and while these embodiments have been described in some detail, it is not the intention of the inventor to restrict or in any way limit the scope of the appended claims to such detail. Thus, additional advantages and modifications will readily appear to those of ordinary skill in the art. The various features of the invention may be used alone or in any combination depending on the needs and preferences of the user.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 70780 | Nov 2015 | DK | national |
This application is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/779,297, filed May 25, 2018 (pending), which is a U.S. National Phase Application of PCT Application No. PCT/DK2016/050401, filed Nov. 29, 2016 (expired), which claimed the priority to Danish Application No. PA 2015 70780, filed Nov. 30, 2015, the disclosures of which are incorporated by reference herein in their entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2326430 | Blanchard | Aug 1943 | A |
| 3273833 | Windecker | Sep 1966 | A |
| 7855250 | Ui et al. | Dec 2010 | B2 |
| 8662853 | Vasudeva et al. | Mar 2014 | B2 |
| 9500179 | Arendt | Nov 2016 | B2 |
| 9951751 | Yarbrough | Apr 2018 | B2 |
| 10018175 | Marcoe et al. | Jul 2018 | B2 |
| 10113532 | Riahi et al. | Oct 2018 | B2 |
| 10487797 | Hancock et al. | Nov 2019 | B2 |
| 10830206 | Tobin et al. | Nov 2020 | B2 |
| 10865769 | Tobin et al. | Dec 2020 | B2 |
| 20070251090 | Breugel | Nov 2007 | A1 |
| 20090083960 | Holland | Apr 2009 | A1 |
| 20100135816 | Cairo | Jun 2010 | A1 |
| 20100143148 | Chen | Jun 2010 | A1 |
| 20100260612 | Vasudeva | Oct 2010 | A1 |
| 20110031759 | Mitsuoka et al. | Feb 2011 | A1 |
| 20110123343 | Ronner | May 2011 | A1 |
| 20110135487 | Rao et al. | Jun 2011 | A1 |
| 20110150661 | Robbins et al. | Jun 2011 | A1 |
| 20140322023 | Tapia | Oct 2014 | A1 |
| 20150252779 | Sievers | Sep 2015 | A1 |
| 20150330231 | McGuire et al. | Nov 2015 | A1 |
| 20170120336 | DeMuth et al. | May 2017 | A1 |
| 20180037000 | Church | Feb 2018 | A1 |
| 20180044002 | Cotton et al. | Feb 2018 | A1 |
| 20180311927 | Tyan | Nov 2018 | A1 |
| 20190032491 | Nissen et al. | Jan 2019 | A1 |
| 20190152165 | Tobin et al. | May 2019 | A1 |
| 20190152168 | Tobin et al. | May 2019 | A1 |
| 20190153995 | Tobin et al. | May 2019 | A1 |
| 20190153996 | Tobin et al. | May 2019 | A1 |
| 20190293048 | Roberts et al. | Sep 2019 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 2735731 | May 2014 | EP |
| 2915996 | Sep 2015 | EP |
| 2569571 | Jun 2019 | GB |
| 20130096867 | Sep 2013 | KR |
| 2011066279 | Jun 2011 | WO |
| 2013178228 | Dec 2013 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Xingxing Lu, “Accurate detection of porosity in glass fiber reinforced polymers by terahertz spectroscopy”, Aug. 1, 2022, Composites Part B: Engineering, vol. 242 (Year: 2022). |
| Eun-Suk Jang, “Porosity analysis of three types of balsa (Ochroma pyramidale) wood depending on density”, May 26, 2022, Journal of Wood Science, vol. 68 (Year: 2022). |
| Danish Patent and Trademark Office, Search and Examination Report in PA 2015 70780, dated Jul. 15, 2016. |
| European Patent Office, International Search Report and Written Opinion in PCT/DK2016/050401, dated Feb. 17, 2017. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20210381485 A1 | Dec 2021 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 15779297 | US | |
| Child | 17408795 | US |
