Method, system and apparatus for NFC security

Abstract

A method, system and apparatus for providing security to RFID and NFC systems. In some exemplary embodiments, a smart poster may be utilized to provide appropriate or desired communications with an RFID or NFC-enabled device. Such exemplary embodiments may utilize an authorized NFC tag to communicate with an NFC-enabled device, and upon activation of the authorized NFC tag, may trigger activation or appearance of one or more related items, such as visual cues. Additionally, aspects of NFC security systems which can include regions of security, states of activity and actions performed when security violations are detected.

Description

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Radio frequency identification (RFID) devices, including near field communication (NFC) enabled RFID devices, are utilized for a variety of purposes. Often such devices are formed as tags or labels and can be utilized to associate an object with an identification code or other data, such as website data. Such RFID devices may be passive and, upon receiving a signal, such as an excitation signal from an RFID or NFC-enabled reader, may be energized. The devices can then respond with a desired communication or provide information associated with a product, item or service associated with the RFID device.

Specifically, NFC is a data exchange protocol designed to allow devices, including suitably equipped mobile phones and the like, to interact with infrastructures, such as point of sale terminals and ticket gates on transportation systems, or RFID devices in the forms of “smart posters” or “touchpoints”, for example. In such situations, bringing an NFC enabled device into proximity of such infrastructure or RFID devices can cause the transmission of data to the NFC enabled device, resulting in, for example, the opening of a web page, the acceptance of a media stream via Bluetooth® or any of a number of other functions.

Often the manner of associating a product, item or service with an RFID device is to physically couple or adhere the RFID device to the product or item, or associate it with advertising relating to the product, item or service, such as the “smart poster” or “touchpoint” described above. For example, RFID labels may be coupled adhesively to objects or may otherwise have surfaces that attach directly to objects. RFID tags may be secured to objects in other manners, such as through the use of a plastic fastener, string or other fastening mechanism. Such RFID devices may then provide data to NFC enabled devices located or placed proximate the RFID devices.

Additionally, RFID devices are often associated with the product or item, or advertising item, in such a manner as to conceal or secure the RFID device. Such methods can provide security against the removal or misuse of an RFID device. However, in such circumstances, and particularly with NFC enabled devices designed to convey information to consumers with NFC enabled mobile phones and devices, there is a designated area (touchpoint) on an advertisement or product that indicates information can be obtained if the NFC enabled device is placed in close proximity to an area associated with the RFID device. However, as it is then known that information can be obtained from such areas, vandal or pirate RFID devices are often placed in close proximity to the indicated NFC area. The vandal or pirate devices often contain deceptive, misleading, undesired or malicious information. These devices can be coupled with or adhered to products and items, or advertisements associated with those items, leading to inappropriate or malicious information being unknowingly communicated to a user's NFC-enabled device. The current invention provides a possible solution to this problem.

SUMMARY

A method, system and apparatus for providing security to RFID and NFC systems. In some exemplary embodiments, a smart poster may be utilized to provide appropriate or desired communications with an RFID or NFC-enabled device. Such exemplary embodiments may utilize an authorized NFC tag to communicate with an NFC-enabled device, and upon activation of the authorized NFC tag, may trigger activation or appearance of one or more related items, such as visual cues. Additionally, aspects of NFC security systems which can include regions of security, states of activity and actions performed when security violations are detected.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Advantages of embodiments of the present invention will be apparent from the following detailed description of the exemplary embodiments. The following detailed description should be considered in conjunction with the accompanying figures in which:

FIG. 1 is an exemplary view of a poster with an embedded RFID device.

FIG. 2 is an exemplary view of a poster with an embedded RFID device and a security system.

FIG. 3 is an exemplary diagram showing a security system that may be used with an RFID device.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Aspects of the invention are disclosed in the following description and related drawings directed to specific embodiments of the invention. Alternate embodiments may be devised without departing from the spirit or the scope of the invention. Additionally, well-known elements of exemplary embodiments of the invention will not be described in detail or will be omitted so as not to obscure the relevant details of the invention. Further, to facilitate an understanding of the description, discussion of several terms used herein follows.

As used herein, the word “exemplary” means “serving as an example, instance or illustration.” The embodiments described herein are not limiting, but rather are exemplary only. It should be understood that the described embodiments are not necessarily to be construed as preferred or advantageous over other embodiments. Moreover, the terms “embodiments of the invention”, “embodiments” or “invention” do not require that all embodiments of the invention include the discussed feature, advantage or mode of operation.

Generally referring to FIGS. 1-3, a smart poster, such as a poster that incorporates an authorized RFID device, including an authorized NFC tag, may be utilized to provide appropriate or desired communications with an RFID or NFC-enabled device. Such exemplary embodiments may utilize an authorized NFC tag to communicate with an NFC-enabled device, and upon activation of the authorized NFC tag, may trigger activation or appearance of one or more related items, such as visual cues. Additionally, aspects of NFC security systems which can include regions of security, states of activity and actions performed when security violations are detected. Additionally, while some of the exemplary embodiments described discuss either RFID or NFC communication capabilities, it may be appreciated that such capabilities may be embodied in the same device or such capabilities may be used interchangeably in some instances.

Referring now to exemplary FIG. 1, a view of a display 100 having a poster 106 with a supporting frame 102 is provided. In the exemplary embodiment, poster 106 may be any type of poster, formed of any type of material, and may be utilized to convey any type of information. The poster can be formed from any acceptable material, including but not limited to paper, foils and plastic/films. The information conveyed can be any desired type, including, but not limited to, advertisements, personal care, health care and product or service information. The structural frame 102 can provide a secure containment of poster 106, an authorized communication device, such as authorized NFC tag 114 and desired related components or electronics, such as, but not limited to, lighting and an NFC security system. Frame 102 may be any type of desired frame and may be formed out of any desired materials. Additionally, frame 102 may be such that it can be formed with an integral antenna or may be retrofitted with an antenna.

In FIG. 1, the exemplary poster 106 may contain visual information 108, for example an advertisement for a product or any other desired visual information. Additionally, NFC tag 114 may be provided with a visual indicator 116 associated therewith. The visual indicator 116 may be any type of static or electronic visual indicator and may be used, for example, to guide user to an appropriate region to place NFC-enabled devices that can read the authorized NFC tag 114. Such devices can include mobile phones with NFC interrogators incorporated into the phones, or any other devices with NFC interrogators associate therewith. Placing a suitably equipped mobile phone (or other NFC-enabled device) in the indicated region 116 can allow for the reading of the contents of the NFC tag 114. Such contents may be any type of information or data, for example data which could point to a website that contains information related to the visual information 108 of the poster 106.

The smart poster or sign may also be equipped with a low power receiver or “watch dog” device that would allow the NFC tag 114 to detect the presence of an NFC reading device, such as a smart phone, at a greater range than the reading device is capable of typically interacting with NFC tags on the surface or in an area. One use for the pre-detection or watch dog device is to allow a security sweep for intruder/pirate tags to be performed before the user or consumer comes close enough to read pirate tags if present. As the sweep is only activated when a consumer approaches, the average power consumption is very low, allowing the function to be supported by a battery which can be resident on the tag or associated with the tag. Pre-detection by such a watch dog device could also be used to activate visual, audible or other functions, such as illuminating the sigh or extending a greeting to the on-coming consumer. By placing a watch dog device within the protected range, the NFC tags can be monitored, and, as the watch dog units can be battery powered because of pre-detection, they can be deployed flexibly without the cost of additional wiring or support structures to implement use of the watch dog device.

Still referring to exemplary FIG. 1, a pirate or vandal tag 104 is shown as being affixed to a visual surface of poster 106. The contents of the vandal tag 104 might contain any type of information or data. In one embodiment, the contents of the vandal tag include information or data that redirects a user's device to a website that contains unauthorized information or could install malicious software on the reading device.

As described with respect to exemplary FIG. 1, authorized NFC tag 114 is associated with poster 106. Authorized NFC tag 114 may be utilized alone to provide desired or authorized communications between authorized NFC tag 114 and an NFC-enabled reader, or may be used with an NFC security system, as described in more detail herein. Additionally, authorized NFC tag 114 may be such that it can function to prevent or limit the functionality of vandal tag 104, or other unauthorized or undesired devices, that are placed in proximity or directly overlapping the NFC tag 114. Authorized NFC tag 114 may be formed in any of a variety of manners, and include elements such as a relatively high dielectric constant substrate, a relatively high magnetic permeability substrate, or include areas of a conductive material beyond that needed to form the antenna. Relatively high dielectric constant material can be further defined as a material with a dielectric constant greater than that of silicon dioxide, or 3.9. Example materials include hafnium silicate, zirconium silicate, hafnium dioxide and zirconium dioxide, but any high dielectric material known in the art may be used. Magnetic permeability is usually expressed as relative magnetic permeability (μ_R), the ratio of the permeability of a specific medium to the permeability of free space, or the ability of a material to attract and sustain a magnetic field. High relative magnetic permeability can be defined as greater than 1. Examples of high relative magnetic permeability substrates include ferro-magnetic materials such as nickel or iron. [http://www.microwaves101.com/encyclopedia/highpermeability.cfm]. These features will cause a vandal tag placed in proximity to be strongly de-tuned, and therefore reduced in functionality. In some embodiments, the structure supporting the poster or the poster itself will incorporate relatively high dielectric constant, high magnetic permeability and conductive areas, or any combination of these, and authorized tag 114 may be designed for a loaded resonant frequency that can compensate for these obstructions or interferences. Unauthorized or vandal tags that are designed for benign substrates typical to many applications, may have their performance significantly impaired or rendered incapacitated due to the presence and functionality of the elements incorporated into the structure, poster, or both. Authorized tag 114, by having prior knowledge of the surface conditions, may implement the concept of a having a special “keyed” or authorized RFID device properties to function on the surface. Thus, any unauthorized or vandal tags without this knowledge may not function to provide their intended communication capabilities.

FIG. 2 can provide an exemplary view of a display 200 with a display frame 202 that may incorporate a poster 206 having visual information 208 and an authorized NFC tag 214. Additionally, in such an exemplary embodiment, an NFC reading zone indicated by a visual guide 216 may also be provided. Further, the display 202 can incorporate an NFC security system (described in more detail with respect to exemplary FIG. 3 below) which can protect the display 200 from vandal tag 204, or any number of other vandal tags. The security system can include a security controller 210, one or more sub-assembly circuit boards 212 associated with the security controller 210, and an NFC antenna 218. For example, the sub-assembly circuit board or boards 212 of the security controller 210 can provide functionality for the operation of the security system. Additionally, NFC antenna 218 can provide an interrogation area which may be substantially equivalent to the entire surface of the display 200. The scanning area can thus include the poster 206, the NFC indicated reading zone 216 and all other surfaces of the display frame 202, as well as some areas located near or proximate the display 200, as desired.

Still referring to exemplary FIG. 2, an unauthorized tag 204 may be shown as affixed to a portion of the poster 206. The security system, as described in more detail below, may periodically energize the NFC antenna 218 to scan for any and all NFC tags affixed to the display 202. The security system could then detect the vandal tag 204 (or some other unauthorized device) and select an appropriate or desired action or set of actions to perform. In one exemplary embodiment, the security system may first scan the memory contents of the vandal tag 204. Then, depending on the persistent states of the vandal tag 204 the security system may attempt to overwrite the memory contents of the vandal tag 204 or otherwise disable the functionality of the vandal tag 204 using a “kill” command commonly found with most NFC tags. Additional or alternative steps which could be performed by the security controller 210 may include jamming the communication channel with noise, sounding an alarm, or turning off display lights associated with display 200 to indicate an out of order state, or signaling an alert using network connections incorporated into the system. Such steps are described in more detail as follows.

FIG. 3 can provide an exemplary view, in functional block diagram form, of components of a security system 300 used in conjunction with NFC or RFID systems. The security controller 210 may be the primary controller to all other controllers in the system. The secondary controllers in the system shown in this exemplary embodiment can include the network controller 320, NFC controller 322 and display controller 310, as well as others, as desired. The secondary controllers 310, 320, 322 in this exemplary embodiment may be connected to the security controller 210 via cables, such as cables 318, 312, and 314. The network controller 320 may further include network transceivers that can support wired standards such as Ethernet or wireless network standards such as cellular network, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connections, or any other wired or wireless standards, as desired. The NFC controller 322 can provide for NFC functions such as, but not limited to, interrogation, reading, writing and disabling NFC tags. The NFC controller 322 may be connected via cable 308 to the NFC antenna 218. The NFC antenna 218 can include one or more near field elements that could provide energy and communications to NFC tags located in proximity to the NFC antenna 218, and may be disposed in any location on or about display 200, for example in frame 202. The display controller 310 can provide for sending and receiving signals from the display 200 through the connecting cable 306.

Still referring to exemplary FIG. 3, the display 200 can contain components or methods of controlling electronics in the display 200, for example visual lighting, auditory electronics speakers, buzzers and locking mechanisms. The display 200 can indicate states through the use of toggle switches, or any other desired components. Additionally, sensors incorporated into the display 200 can include light sensors, motion sensors, proximity sensors, vibration sensors, and the like. Signals from sensors and switches may provide information for control of scanning intervals and security elements of the NFC display 200. For example, the security system 300 can be programmed to stop scanning when a user or consumer is present so that the user's NFC mobile device is not interfered with and a desired NFC communication may take place.

Referring now to both exemplary FIG. 2 and exemplary FIG. 3, an area protected by the NFC security system 300 can be one or more regions or zones. Such regions or zones can be any size deemed appropriate or desired for the protection of the display 200. The zone can be within the boundary of the display. The zone of security may, in some exemplary embodiments, extend past the physical boundary of the display 200. Further, for an NFC security system 300 with multiple zones, the size and configurations of each zone can be different from the configuration of all other zones. The technology used to secure such a zone can be achieved by any desired combination of near field or far field structures. Examples of near field structures can include inductive coils, capacitive structures or transmission lines. Examples of far field structures can include any physical configuration of conductive material used as an antenna for detecting electromagnetic wave energy. The structures used for the security of a zone can be operated in configurations suitable for RFID interrogation, detecting alternating fields or transmission of alternating fields.

In one exemplary embodiment, the zone or area, which may correspond to the size of frame 202, can have of a large inductive coil antenna 218 which can follow an outside perimeter directly behind the visual part of the display 200. The coil antenna 218 may be energized in order to provide an alternating magnetic field for deactivating unauthorized tags 204. The energy and control of the coil antenna 218 can be provided by NFC controller 322, which can attempt to interrogate any NFC tags, such as a vandal tag 204, affixed to the visual face of the display 200.

In another exemplary embodiment, and still referring to both FIG. 2 and FIG. 3, a security scanning zone can be created by one or more magnetic probes positioned on the display 200. The magnetic probes may be used to scan for alternating magnetic fields which might correspond to an NFC interrogation system of a user's device. High power fields detected in zones where no authorized NFC tag exists, such as authorized NFC tag 214 located proximate indicator 216, could indicate the presence of an unauthorized tag 204 on the display.

In yet another exemplary embodiment, a secure zone can be provided by an antenna 218 inside the display 200 which may record far field signals at an NFC operating radio frequency. The signals can be analyzed by a component of the security system for timing and content related to the authorized NFC tag 214 on the display 200. Discrepancies or irregularities in the analyzed data might indicate the presence of an unauthorized tag 204.

In still another exemplary embodiment, the security system may initiate scans of an area or zone associated with display 200. This can be done through a watch dog type device or other components provided for this activity. Scanning activity performed by the security system can be operated by constant polling or may be triggered by conditional rules, as desired. Conditional control of the scanning activity may have the benefit of a lower power usage or consumption of the display 200 and may also reduce potential interference with legitimate NFC activity by users of the display 200, such as a reading of authorized NFC tag 214. Parameters that may be used for triggering NFC security scanning activity can include, but is not limited to, time, sensor states, display states, or external requests. Examples of time parameters include, but are not limited to, regular intervals, fixed time of day, or a timed interval after a conditional state change of another parameter. Examples of sensor states include, but are not limited to, infrared, acoustic, proximity, and vibration sensors, as well as environmental sensors such as light, temperature and humidity. Examples of display states can include, but are not limited to, user NFC interrogation activity or initialization directly after a new authorized NFC tag 214 has been installed. Examples of external requests can include, but are not limited to, signals and communication sent via wireless communication methods associated with network controller 320, such as Bluetooth, NFC or Wi-Fi as well as wired communication from connections such as an Ethernet connection.

Conditions for triggering scanning activity may further be any logical or desired combinations of parameter triggers and states as well as sequential conditions of gating previously triggered activity. For example, the security system 300 may conduct a scan at regular intervals during daytime hours while light sensors in the top of the display 200 are triggered by overhead fluorescent lights. In another exemplary embodiment, the security system 300 may scan the display after a designated time interval after an acoustic sensor in the front of the display 200 has been triggered. In yet another exemplary embodiment, security scans may be triggered when the authorized NFC tag 204 is interrogated by the user.

Still referring to both exemplary FIG. 2 and exemplary FIG. 3, if the security system 300, after conducting a scan, detects an unauthorized NFC tag 204 or corrupted authorized NFC tag 214, the NFC security system 300 may select an appropriate action or set of actions to be performed and perform them. The security actions performed by the system 300 may be any type of actions, for example ranging from direct actions performed on an unauthorized tag 204 to progressively more indirect actions in an attempt to mitigate threats caused by the unauthorized tag 204. For example, it may be desired for the direct actions to be attempted first, with indirect actions performed for redundancy and backup.

Examples of direct actions to an unauthorized tag 204 can include inspection of memory contents and operational states, commands issued to disable the tag 204, reprogramming the memory contents of the tag 204, or jamming the communication channel of said tag 204. The inspection of the memory contents and states of the unauthorized tag 204 can determine a threat level and severity of a security violation. The inspection might also aid in the identification of unauthorized NFC tags that contain code which could exploit weaknesses in user device software or contain pointers to install malicious software on a user's device. The memory contents of an unauthorized tag 204 may be recorded by the security system for later analysis by authorized personnel. Disabling unauthorized tags 204 can be achieved via known and established commands commonly available for NFC tags such as the “kill” command commonly used for privacy functions. Jamming the communication channel can be implemented by methods such as issuing read commands to the unauthorized tag 203 or transmitting random noise or pulses to disrupt communication with the unauthorized tag 204.

Other examples of indirect security actions can include alerting authorized personnel, warning a user, or disabling the display 200. Alerting authorized personnel can be achieved via a wireless or wired network communication channel available to the security system, for example through network controller 320. If a network connection is not available to the security system, coded messages can be sent via reprogramming the authorized NFC tag 214. In such an example, information can be embedded into the URL pointer that sends coded messages to the website server but does not affect the website content that a user will see on their NFC enabled device. Another exemplary method of signaling can be achieved by storing the alert in the memory of the security system 300 for communication during maintenance intervals by authorized personnel. Visual displays such as lighted indicators can be used to request maintenance by authorized personnel. Such indicators may be provided on or around display 200, on frame 202, on or in conjunction with poster 206, or as a part of indictor 216. Similarly, warnings to the user can be achieved by audio or visual indicating lights or by reprogramming the authorized NFC tag 214 to indicate a problem with the display 200. Disabling the display 200 can be also be achieved by reprogramming the authorized NFC tag 214 in combination with switching off the display 200 backlight to indicate a non-functional state.

In some other exemplary embodiments, the NFC security system 300 can interrogate the intended and authorized NFC tag 214 to check if memory contents and identification codes remain uncorrupted. A previously stored unique identification code and known good data of the authorized NFC tag 214 can be established during the period of the installation of the authorized tag 214 into the display 200 by authorized personnel. If the security system determines that the authorized NFC tag 214 is non-functional or has corrupted memory contents, a set of actions similar to the previous described actions for unauthorized tags 204 can be performed.

In a further exemplary embodiment, an integrated RFID interrogator system, such as NFC controller 322, can verify a unique identification code and memory contents belonging to the authorized NFC tag 214. The unique identification code and memory contents of the authorized NFC tag 214 may then be compared with previously stored, known good data. If corrupted data is detected in the authorized NFC tag 214, the integrated RFID reader (e.g. NFC controller 322) can start repeatedly issuing tag reads to the authorized NFC tag 214. Such repeated tag reads may jam the communication channel and prevent interrogation of the authorized NFC tag 214 by a user's NFC-enabled device. Additionally, the display 200 backlight can be switched off, or some other indicator provided, which signals that the display 200 is no longer functioning. The display 200 may return to normal use and appearance after the issue is corrected.

In another exemplary embodiment, the NFC security system 300 can report the presence of an unauthorized NFC tag 204 to an internet server via a cellular network connection, or other desired communication method. Such a report may be sent using network controller 320. The memory contents of the unauthorized tag(s) 204 may then be uploaded to the server using network controller 320 for later analysis. Authorized personnel may also be alerted via a message from the server or directly from network controller 320 of the nature of the unauthorized tag 204.

In still another exemplary embodiment, the detection of an unauthorized NFC tag 204 can be made through an integrated RFID interrogation system, such as with NFC controller 322. As discussed previously, the antenna 218 of the security system can encompass the perimeter of the display 200, for example inside frame 202, so as to protect the entire surface of the display 200 and region around the display 200. The NFC controller 322 can execute an NFC (or RFID, as desired) inventory function to check for the presence of unauthorized tags 204. The inventory function can determine the quantity and identification codes of NFC tags 204 in proximity to the energized antenna coil 218. Upon detection of an unauthorized tag 204, the security system 300 can disable the unauthorized tag 204 by reading the unique identification code of the tag and executing a kill function to the unauthorized tag 204, as described in previous exemplary embodiments.

In yet another exemplary embodiment, the security system 300 can include an RF or NFC radio detection system that can scan for local emissions of RF energy in the 13.56 MHz frequency band. Such scanning may be accomplished through the use of NFC controller 322, an RFID controller or any other component with the desired scanning or interrogating capabilities. The system may then compare the detection of emissions above specified signal strength with timing of interrogations of the intended and authorized tag 214. RF or NFC emissions may then be analyzed by the security system 300 to determine if a user in proximity of the display 200 is reading an unauthorized tag 204. Statistical information about the presence and nature of the emissions can then be used to alert maintenance personnel to the potential presence of unauthorized tags 204.

The foregoing description and accompanying figures illustrate the principles, preferred embodiments and modes of operation of the invention. However, the invention should not be construed as being limited to the particular embodiments discussed above. Additional variations of the embodiments discussed above will be appreciated by those skilled in the art.

Therefore, the above-described embodiments should be regarded as illustrative rather than restrictive. Accordingly, it should be appreciated that variations to those embodiments can be made by those skilled in the art without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the following claims.

Claims

1. A security system for detecting unauthorized near field communication (NFC) tags, comprising: a NFC radio detection system having a NFC controller with scanning or interrogating abilities and with at least one sub-assembly circuit boards;an antenna, periodically energized by the NFC radio detection system;a structure for housing the NFC radio detection system and at least one authorized NFC tag;a display provided on the structure and containing the at least one authorized NFC tag; at least one unauthorized NFC tag emitting a radio frequency (RF) signal applied on or near the display or the structure; andwhere the at least one authorized NFC tag is programed with information about a surface of the display and has authorized radio frequency identification (RFID) device properties to function on the surface and the at least one unauthorized NFC tag without the information about the surface of the display does not provide intended communication capabilities;the NFC controller interrogating an area including the display and the structure to detect whether the at least one unauthorized NFC tag is present; andan alarm to signal the presence of the at least one unauthorized NFC tag and selects an action or set of actions to perform based on results from interrogating the area.

2. The security system of claim 1, wherein the area extends past a physical boundary of the display.

3. The security system of claim 1, wherein the area corresponds to a size of the display.

4. The security system of claim 1, wherein the security system further includes the antenna that follows an outside perimeter of the display.

5. The security system of claim 4, wherein the antenna is an inductive coil antenna.

6. The security system of claim 1, further comprising magnetic probes positioned on the display.

7. The security system of claim 1, wherein the security system scans the at least one unauthorized NFC tag and overwrites the at least one unauthorized NFC tag.

8. The security system of claim 1, wherein the security system disables a functionality of the at least one unauthorized NFC tag.

9. The security system of claim 1, wherein the display is a smart poster.

10. The security system of claim 9, wherein the smart poster includes a low power receiver.

11. The security system of claim 1, wherein the at least one authorized NFC tag is designed for a loaded resonant frequency that can compensate for the at least one unauthorized NFC tag.

12. A security system for detecting unauthorized near field communication (NFC) tags, comprising: a NFC radio detection system having a NFC controller with scanning or interrogating abilities, where scanning is operated by polling or triggered by conditional rules;a structure for housing the NFC radio detection system and at least one authorized NFC tag;a display provided on the structure and containing the at least one authorized NFC tag;at least one unauthorized NFC tag emitting a radio frequency (RF) signal applied on or near the display or the structure, and the at least one authorized NFC tag is designed for a loaded resonant frequency that can compensate for the at least one unauthorized NFC tag; andwhere the at least one authorized NFC tag is programed with information about a surface of the display and the at least one unauthorized NFC tag without the information about the surface of the display does not provide intended communication capabilities;the NFC controller interrogating an area including the display and the structure to detect whether the at least one unauthorized NFC tag is present;magnetic probes positioned on the display; andan alarm to signal the presence of the at least one unauthorized NFC tag to perform based on results from interrogating the area.