This application claims priority to Chinese Patent Application No. 202010681241.2, filed on Jul. 15, 2020, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
The disclosure relates to the technical field of wind generation, and particularly relates to a method, system and storage medium for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation.
As the percentage of PMSG (permanent magnet synchronous generators) in the installed capacity of local areas rapidly increases, sub/super-synchronous oscillation caused by the integration of PMSG to weak power grid via inverter occurs ever more frequently, greatly intimidating the safe and stable operation of power grid. Currently, due to lack of effective control measures to suppress sub/super-synchronous oscillation of wind turbines, passive measures such as generator tripping are often taken, which sacrifices large amount of wind power output and causes huge economic loss. Therefore, it is urgent to study active control method to suppress sub/super-synchronous oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine.
Scholars worldwide have conducted extensive research on measures to suppress sub/super-synchronous oscillation, and there are mainly three methods used—adjusting controller structure, adding suppression device and optimizing controller parameters. The method of adjusting controller structure realizes suppression of sub-synchronous oscillation by introducing damping control links. Since no extra equipment is added, this method is economic. The method of adding suppression device suppresses oscillation by designing damping devices and injecting reverse sub/super-synchronous current to power grid. This method has been developed and applied to certain extent. The method of optimizing controller parameters can reduce the risk of sub/super-synchronous oscillation by changing the resonance point of sub-synchronous oscillation between wind turbine and power grid, which is achieved by optimizing the controller parameters of wind turbine and parameters of series-type FACTS (Flexible AC Transmission Systems) and regulating the output impedance characteristic of wind turbine.
However, the above methods are mostly concerning single oscillation frequency and do not consider the suppression effect at other oscillation frequencies. Besides, the impact of variation of controller parameters on fundamental frequency characteristic and dynamic response characteristic of wind turbine is neglected.
In view of the above analysis, the disclosure aims to propose a method and system for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation. It is used to solve the problem of stable operation of the wind power grid-connected system at the current stage.
The purpose of the present disclosure is mainly achieved by the following technical solutions.
On the one hand, the disclosure proposes a method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation, including,
On the basis of the above scheme, the disclosure also makes the following improvements:
Further, wherein the supplementary energy branches in the step S2 includes,
Further, wherein the supplementary energy branch of current loop proportional control link, the input term is idc*, the proportional link with the compensation coefficient kV1 is constructed to act on the d-axis output voltage of grid-side converter control links of direct-drive wind turbine;
Further, wherein the supplementary energy branch of current loop integral control link, the input term is idc*, the integral link with the compensation coefficient kV2 is constructed to act on the d-axis output voltage of grid-side converter control links of direct-drive wind turbine;
Further, wherein the supplementary energy branch of dq axis cross coupling control link, the input term is idc, the proportion link with the compensation coefficient kV3 is constructed to act on the d-axis output voltage of grid-side converter control links of direct-drive wind turbine, the input term is iqc, the proportion link with the compensation coefficient kV3 is constructed to act on the q-axis output voltage of grid-side converter control links of direct-drive wind turbine;
Further, wherein the step S3 includes,
Further, the constraint of the frequency-domain characteristic of control links is
Further, the constraint of fundamental-frequency voltage characteristic of control links is
Further, the pattern search method is used to determine the compensation coefficients of supplementary branches.
On the one hand, the disclosure proposes a system for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation, including,
This disclosure further provides a storage medium encoded with a set of machine-executable instructions to perform a method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation, the method comprises:
The beneficial effects of the present disclosure are as follows:
The disclosure proposes a method and system for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation, which can realize fast frequency-dependent suppression of sub/super-synchronous oscillation in different frequency bands concerning different grid strengths. Besides, the supplementary branches do not affect fundamental-frequency dynamic characteristic of wind turbine.
In the disclosure, the above technical solutions can also be combined with each other to realize more preferred combination schemes. Other features and advantages of the disclosure will be described in subsequent specifications, and some of the advantages may become apparent from the description or understood by implementing the disclosure. The object and other advantages of the disclosure can be realized and obtained through the description, the claims and the drawings.
The attached figures are only for the purpose of illustrating specific embodiments, and are not considered to limit the present disclosure. In the whole figures, the same reference symbols indicate the same components.
The preferred embodiments of the disclosure will be described below in combination with the attached figures in detail, where the attached figures form part of the disclosure and, together with the embodiments of the disclosure, are used to explain the principles of the disclosure, not to define the scope of the disclosure and not intended to limit the scope of the disclosure.
This embodiment proposes a method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation, as shown in
Step S2: collecting the dynamic angle of PLL when the variation rate of the transient energy of direct-drive wind turbine is positive, calculating the compensation energy and the increments of fundamental-frequency voltage of several supplementary energy branches based on the bus voltage and the node injection current of the wind turbine and the dynamic angle of PLL;
It should be noted that if the variation rate of transient energy of direct-drive wind turbine is constantly positive, direct-drive wind turbine will continuously generate transient energy during oscillation and exhibit negative damping characteristic, causing the system to go unstable. Thus, it is necessary to suppress sub/super-synchronous oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine at this time. In this embodiment, multiple supplementary energy branches are constructed to supplement energy to realize the suppression of sub/super-synchronous frequency oscillation. The specific process is as follows:
In this embodiment, transform equation (1) to dqc coordinate system of direct-drive wind turbine control system, so that the transient energy of direct-drive wind turbine can be expressed as
WPMSG=∫(idcudc+iqcuqc)dΔθpll+∫idcduqc−∫iqcdudc (2)
Since the terminal part of direct-drive wind turbine is electrically decoupled from the grid, and the time scale of wind speed variation is much larger than the time scale of converter control, when studying the transient energy at the terminal of direct-drive wind turbine during sub/super-synchronous oscillation, the impact of grid-side converter is emphasized. Besides, consider that in grid-side converter cascade control, voltage outer loop is dynamically decoupled from current inner loop, and the band width of voltage outer loop is much smaller than the band width of current inner loop, thus the dynamic response of voltage outer loop is slow in sub/super-synchronous frequency band. Therefore, this embodiment is focused on the impact of current inner loop and PLL on the transient energy of direct-drive wind turbine grid-side converter.
In dqc coordinate system of direct-drive wind turbine control system, the control equations of grid-side converter are
Combine equation (2) and equation(3) so that the transient energy of direct-drive wind turbine in dqc coordinate system can be obtained, which is converted into dq coordinate system and decomposed into transient energy of each control loop of direct-drive wind turbine, as shown in equations (4)-(9).
WPMSG=Wp+WI+WL (4)
WI is
WI=WI1+WI2+WI3 (7)
WI1=ki2∫(idc*t(ids+iqsΔθpll)dΔθpll
WI2=−ki2∫(ids+iqsΔθpll)(∫(ids+iqsΔθpll)dt)dΔθpll
WI3=−ki2∫(−idsΔθpll+iqs)(∫(−idsΔθpll+iqs)dt)dΔθpll (8)
WL is
WI=WL1+WL2 (9)
W
L1=ω2L2∫(ids2+iqs2)ΔθplldΔθpll
WL2=ω2L2∫(idsdids+iqsdiqs) (10)
According to Lyapunov's second stability theorem, for a free dynamic system, if the variation rate of system overall energy W (W>0) with time {dot over (W)}(x) is constantly negative, system overall energy will keep decreasing until it reaches the minimum value, then the system will be stable in an equilibrium state. Therefore, by analyzing the accumulation and consumption trends of the overall energy of direct-drive wind turbine WPMSG, the stability of system can be identified. If ΔWPMSG keeps decreasing, i.e. if Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG is constantly negative, direct-drive wind turbine will absorb transient energy during sub/super-synchronous oscillation and exhibit positive damping characteristic. In this case, system oscillation will gradually converge and the system will go stable. Otherwise, if Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG is constantly positive, direct-drive wind turbine will continuously generate transient energy during oscillation and exhibit negative damping characteristic, causing the system to go unstable. Thus, the variation rates of transient energy of different control links Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG characterize the accumulation and consumption trends of the overall energy of direct-drive wind turbine, and the sign of Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG (being positive or negative) directly determines the stability of system.
In the transient energy model of direct-drive wind turbine, the damping characteristic of transient energy of different control links is the key factor that determines whether the oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine converges or not. Thus, screening out the control links that generate negative damping energy is key to suppressing oscillation and guaranteeing the stable operation of system. The transient energy characteristics of different control links in grid-side converter are analyzed as follows.
During sub/super-synchronous oscillation, sub/super-synchronous frequency (ω−/ω+) current components can be expressed as:
Due to sub/super-synchronous frequency voltage components, PLL dynamic angle will be generated, which can be expressed as:
Where kpθ and kiθ are proportion and integration coefficients of PLL; θ0 is the phase angle caused by outlet line reactance; Δθ1 and β are the oscillation amplitude and initial phase angle of PLL dynamic angle.
Apply equation (11) and (12) to equation (6), (8) and (10), so that the variation rate of transient energy of each control link in grid-side converter Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG can be obtained:
{dot over (W)}P1=−kp2ωsIdIqe2λt cos(φd−φq) (13)
Δ{dot over (W)}P2=½kp2ωsidc*IdΔθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (14)
Δ{dot over (W)}P3=−kp2ωsids0Idθ02Δθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (15)
Δ{dot over (W)}I1=½ki2ωsIdΔθ1e2λt cos(φd−β)∫idc*dt (16)
Δ{dot over (W)}I2=−½ki2ωsidc0tIdΔθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (17)
Δ{dot over (W)}I3=½ki2ωsθ0iqs0tIdΔθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (18)
Δ{dot over (W)}L1=½ω2ωsL2iqs0IdΔθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (19)
Δ{dot over (W)}L2=−ω2ωsL2Id(½iqs0+ids0θ0)Δθ1e2λt cos(φd−β) (20)
The variation rates of transient energy of different control links Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG characterize the accumulation and consumption trends of the overall energy of direct-drive wind turbine, and the sign of Δ{dot over (W)}PMSG (being positive or negative) directly determines the stability of system. It can be seen from equations (13)-(20) that, the sign of Δ{dot over (W)}P1 is determined by cos(φd−φq), and the signs of equations (14)-(20) are determined by cos(φd−β). Angular difference φd−φq and φd−β have to do with the initial phase angles of sub/super-synchronous frequency current and PLL dynamic angle, which are analyzed in detail below.
1) Initial Phase Angle of Sub/Super-Synchronous Frequency Current
The initial phase angle of sub/super-synchronous frequency current can be obtained by extending sub/super-synchronous frequency components:
When sub/super-synchronous oscillation occurs, super-synchronous frequency components are usually larger than sub-synchronous frequency components, thus equation (21)>0, and equation (13) is constantly negative, i.e. Δ{dot over (W)}P1<0. Therefore, WP1 can effectively reduce the overall energy of wind turbine WPMSG and make for the stability of system.
2) Initial Phase Angle of PLL Dynamic Angle
Detailed derivation of equation (12) reveals that, the initial phase angle of PLL dynamic angle β has to do with the initial phase angle of q-axis sub/super-synchronous frequency voltage ϕq, i.e. β=ϕq+ϕ, where ϕ satisfies the following equations:
Apply β=ϕq+ϕ to cos(φd−β), so that
cos(φd−β)=cos(φd−ϕq)cos ϕ+sin(φd−ϕq)sin ϕ (23)
Similar to the derivation process of equation (21), it can be obtained that angular difference φd−ϕq satisfies the following equations:
Consider that during sub/super-synchronous oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine, super-synchronous frequency components are larger than sub-synchronous frequency components, φd−ϕq can be approximated to the difference between initial phase angles of super-synchronous frequency current and super-synchronous frequency voltage.
When oscillation occurs in direct-drive wind turbine, since the reference value of reactive power of outer-loop control is set to be 0, and the reference value of active power is rated value, the output power is mainly active power. Thus, the difference between initial phase angles of super-synchronous frequency current and super-synchronous frequency voltage is approximately 0, i.e. φd−ϕq≈0. Therefore, in equation (23) the value of cos(φd−ϕq) is positive and much larger than sin(φd−ϕq). Besides, since cos ϕ and sin ϕ are both positive, and sin ϕ is slightly larger than cos ϕ, equation (23) is constantly positive, i.e. cos(φd−β)>0.
Therefore, equation (15), (17) and (20) are constantly negative, i.e. Δ{dot over (W)}P3, Δ{dot over (W)}I2 and Δ{dot over (W)}L2 are all negative, thus they have positive damping effect on system oscillation and make for the converging of oscillation. Equation (14), (16), (18) and (19) are constantly positive, i.e. Δ{dot over (W)}P2, Δ{dot over (W)}I1, Δ{dot over (W)}I3 and Δ{dot over (W)}L1 are positive, thus they have negative damping effect on system oscillation and make against the stability of system. The amplitude of Δ{dot over (W)}I3 is much smaller than the amplitudes of the other three terms, thus Δ{dot over (W)}I3 can be neglected. The transient energy characteristics of different control links in direct-drive wind turbine are shown in
Therefore, through the above analysis, it can be seen that by establishing the transient energy model of direct-drive wind turbine containing grid-side converter control links, WP2, WI1 and WL1 are the negative damping energy leading to the oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine extracted from the transient energy model.
After the negative damping energy which that lead the oscillation of direct-drive wind turbine is determined, backward deduction method is used to construct supplementary energy branches in this embodiment, which transforms from the negative damping energy to voltage compensation of supplementary energy branches; and the compensation energy and the increment of fundamental-frequency voltage of supplementary branches are calculated;
Specifically, the supplementary energy branches, includes:
The compensation energy WV1, WV2 and WV3 of supplementary energy branches VP2, VI1 and VL1 are expressed as:
WV1=kp2∫idc*idcdΔθpll (28)
WV2=ki2∫idc*idctdΔθpll (29)
WV3=ω2L2∫(idc2+iqc2)ΔθplldΔθpll (30).
The increment of fundamental-frequency voltage Δudc1*, Δudc2*, Δudc3* and Δuqc3* of supplementary energy branches VP2, VI1 and VL1 are expressed as:
Step S3: with the compensation energy of supplementary branches reaching the maximum and the increment of fundamental-frequency voltage being the minimum as the objective, and with the frequency-domain characteristic and fundamental-frequency voltage characteristic of control links being satisfied as the constraints, determining the compensation coefficients of supplementary energy branches, and enabling the supplementary energy branches after the compensation coefficients are determined.
Specifically, the objective function is
The constraint of the frequency-domain characteristic of control links is
The constraint of fundamental-frequency voltage characteristic of control links is
Preferably, the pattern search method is used to determine the compensation coefficients of supplementary branches, which comprises the following steps:
This embodiment proposes a system for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation. Because the system for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation adopts the same inventive concept as the aforementioned method, only the structure of this system will be described below. For the technical effects and technical problems solved by its specific disclosure, please refer to the previous statement. As shown in
Each of the first processor, the second processor and the third processor is independent processor, or all of them are integrated in a single processor.
Based on the same principle, the above method of the first embodiment and system of this embodiment can learn from each other and achieve the same technical effect.
This embodiment proposes a storage medium encoded with a set of machine-executable instructions to perform a method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation. The method comprises:
The specific fourth embodiment of the disclosure discloses a specific implementation process of a method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine based on energy compensation. A model of power system integrated with direct-drive wind turbines is built in RTLAB for simulation tests, as shown in
To verify the correctness and effectiveness of the proposed method, different sub/super-synchronous oscillation cases with different power grid strengths are set in this embodiment, i.e. diverging oscillation (Case 1), constant-amplitude oscillation (Case 2) and converging oscillation (Case 3). Concerning the three cases, the variation of transient energy of different control links in grid-side converter and the suppression effect of supplementary energy branches are analyzed.
1) Transient Energy of Different Control Links in Grid-Side Converter
The transient energy of different control links in grid-side converter in Case 1, Case 2 and Case 3 is calculated (per unit values of variables are used in the calculation). The simulation curves of transient energy are shown in
2) Suppression Effect of Supplementary Energy Branches
Construct supplementary energy branches according to the method proposed in step S2 in the first embodiment, and combining the simulation data of Case 1, the model to optimize the compensation coefficients of multiple branches is built according to the method for suppressing sub/super-synchronous oscillation for direct-drive wind turbine in step S3 in the first embodiment. And then the pattern search method is used to determine the optimal compensation coefficients. Since supplementary branch VL1 does not generate any increment of fundamental-frequency voltage, its compensation coefficient kV3 is set to render its compensation energy the maximum, i.e. kV3 applies the maximum value in the parameter interval. Optimization of compensation coefficients of supplementary branches VP2 and VI1 is shown in
To verify the effectiveness of the proposed supplementary energy branches, the suppression effects of supplementary energy branches corresponding to different grid strengths and different oscillation frequencies are analyzed. Besides, the impact of supplementary energy branches on the fundamental frequency characteristic of wind turbine is verified.
Suppose the optimal supplementary energy branches are added in Case 1, Case 2 and Case 3, and the variation curves of output power of direct-drive wind turbine are shown in
The oscillation in Case 1, Case 2 and Case 3 are all sub/super-synchronous oscillation with frequency of 28/72 Hz, where the supplementary energy branches have relatively good suppression effect. To verify the adaptability of supplementary energy branches to different oscillation frequency bands, forced oscillation is used. Suppose 5 Hz-100 Hz harmonic current is injected to the grid which causes oscillation to occur in the system, and the suppression effect of supplementary energy branches is shown in
It can be seen from
Furthermore, the impact of supplementary energy branches on the fundamental frequency characteristic of direct-drive wind turbine is analyzed. Suppose supplementary energy branches are added at certain moment in normal operation state, the variation of fundamental-frequency voltage of wind turbine is shown in
It can be seen from
It can be understood by those skilled in the art that the whole or part of the process of realizing the above embodiment method can be completed by instructing the relevant hardware through a computer program, and the program can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium. The computer-readable storage medium is a disk, an optical disk, a read-only memory or a random storage memory, etc.
The above are only preferred specific embodiments of the present disclosure, but the scope of protection of the present disclosure is not limited to this, any person skilled in the art can easily think of changes or replacement changes within the technical scope disclosed by the present disclosure should be covered within the protection scope of the present disclosure.
The foregoing descriptions of specific exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure have been presented for purposes of illustration and description. They are not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the disclosure to the precise forms disclosed, and obviously many modifications and variations are possible in light of the above teachings. The exemplary embodiments were chosen and described in order to explain certain principles of the disclosure and their practical disclosure, to thereby enable others skilled in the art to make and utilize various exemplary embodiments of the present disclosure, as well as various alternatives and modifications thereof. It is intended that the scope of the disclosure be defined by the Claims appended hereto and their equivalents.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
202010681241.2 | Jul 2020 | CN | national |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
106356874 | Jan 2017 | CN |
106972511 | Jul 2017 | CN |
WO-2019128038 | Jul 2019 | WO |
Entry |
---|
S. Zhao, R. Li, B. Gao, N. Wang and S. Song, “Sub and Super Synchronous Oscillations between Type 4 Wind Turbines and Series Compensated AC Transmission Systems,” 2018 IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting (PESGM), Portland, OR, USA, 2018, pp. 1-5, doi: 10.1109/PESGM.2018.8586539. (Year: 2018). |
W. Du, et al., ‘Concept of Modal Repulsion for Examining the Subsynchronous Oscillations Caused by Wind Farms in Power Systems’, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 2019, 34, (1), pp. 518-526. |
K. Gu, et al., ‘Sub-synchronous interactions in power systems with wind turbines: a review’, IET Renewable Power Generation, 2019, 13, (1), pp. 4-15. |
K. Narendra, et al., ‘New microprocessor based relay to monitor and protect power systems against sub-harmonics’, 2011 IEEE Electrical Power and Energy Conference, Winnipeg, MB, 2011, pp. 438-443. |
H. Liu, et al., ‘Subsynchronous Interaction Between Direct-Drive PMSG Based Wind Farms and Weak AC Networks’, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 2017, 32, (6), pp. 4708-4720. |
S. O. Faried, et al., ‘Utilizing DFIG-Based Wind Farms for Damping Subsynchronous Resonance in Nearby Turbine-Generators’, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 2013, 28, (1), pp. 452-459. |
J. Zhang, et al., ‘Subsynchronous Control Interaction Analysis and Trigger-based Damping Control for Doubly Fed Induction Generator-based Wind Turbines’, Electric Power Components and Systems, 2016, 44, (7), pp. 713-725. |
H. Tang, et al., ‘Impact of grid side converter of DFIG on sub-synchronous oscillation and its damping control’, 2016 IEEE PES Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference (APPEEC), Xi'an, 2016, pp. 2127-2130. |
H. Chen, et al., ‘Sub-Synchronous Oscillation Caused by HVDC and the Damping Characteristic Analysis’, Advanced Materials Research, 2014, 971-973, pp. 1353-1356. |
W. Ning, et al., ‘Method to suppress sub-synchronous oscillation of DFIG-based wind farms based on virtual impedance’, The Journal of Engineering, 2017, 2017, (13), pp. 2173-2177. |
L. Wang, et al., ‘Mitigation of Multimodal Subsynchronous Resonance Via Controlled Injection of Supersynchronous and Subsynchronous Currents’, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 2014, 29, (3), pp. 1335-1344. |
S. Wang, et al., ‘A control strategy of STATCOM for suppressing subsynchronous oscillation’, 12th IET International Conference on AC and DC Power Transmission, Beijing, 2016, pp. 1-5. |
Y. Yan, et al., ‘Interaction analysis of multi VSCs integrated into weak grid in current control time-scale’, 2016 IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting (PESGM), Boston, MA, 2016, pp. 1-6. |
H. Liu, et al., ‘Voltage Stability and Control of Offshore Wind Farms with AC Collection and HVDC Transmission’, IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, 2014, 2, (4), pp. 1181-1189. |
M. Anju, et al., ‘Co-ordination of SMES with STATCOM for mitigating SSR and damping power system oscillations in a series compensated wind power system’, 2013 International Conference on Computer Communication and Informatics, Coimbatore, 2013, pp. 1-6. |
Moon, Young Hyun, et al., ‘Energy conservation law and its application for the direct energy method of power system stability’, IEEE Power Engineering Society Winter Meeting IEEE, New York, 1999, pp. 695-700. |
W. Liu, et al., ‘Frequency-coupled impedance model based subsynchronous oscillation analysis for direct-drive wind turbines connected to a weak AC power system’, The Journal of Engineering, 2019, 2019, (18), pp. 4841-4846. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20220021211 A1 | Jan 2022 | US |