The invention relates to a method for determining the absorption coefficient of turbid media.
The invention further relates to a system for determining the absorption coefficient of turbid media.
The invention still further relates to a computer program product comprising instructions for causing a processor to determine the absorption coefficient of turbid media.
Non invasive measurement of the concentrations of different absorbing substances in optically turbid media, such as living tissue, is challenging. A commonly used method for this employs the measurement of the reflected light from such an optically turbid medium. An essential part of the light reflected from a turbid medium has travelled through the medium and was directed out of the medium by scattering. The main problem of such measurements is that the optical path length of the detected photons is strongly dependent on the optical properties, such as the absorption coefficient, the scattering coefficient and the angular distribution of scattering, also referred to as scattering phase function. As a result, the path length of detected photons is dependent on the measurement geometry and optical properties, and varies with wavelength. Absolute measurements of concentrations based on absorption spectroscopy in turbid media may be compromised by the dependence of the path length on the properties of a medium under consideration.
Classical reflectance spectroscopy devices known from the prior art often utilized multiple optical fibers to deliver and collect light during measurement. However, the potential advantages of reflectance probes with a single optical fiber to deliver/collect light are numerous. Advantages of the single fiber design include small probe size and simple device design, making it more-suitable than multi-fiber probes for clinical applications, such as optical biopsy of potential malignancies via endoscopy or biopsy needles. However, there exists no empirical or analytical description of light transport in the regime associated with overlapping source-detector areas, such as when using a single fiber.
An embodiment of a reflectance spectroscopy system using overlapping illumination-detection areas for determining the absorption coefficient in a turbid medium is known from Kanick et al. Phys. Biol. 54, 6991-7008 (2009). In the known embodiment a method is disclosed wherein a single fiber is used and positioned at a surface of the tissue under investigation. The fiber is used for illuminating the tissue as well as for collecting the reflected light.
It is a disadvantage of the known method that the dependence of the effective path length of photons on scattering phase function as well as the reduced scattering coefficients were guessed, which might lead to inaccurate determination of the absorption coefficient.
It is an object of the invention to provide a method for determining the absorption coefficient of a turbid medium without knowledge of the scattering coefficient and scattering phase function when overlapping illumination and detection areas are used.
To this end the method according to the invention comprises the steps of:
It will be appreciated that a plurality of different per se known embodiments may be used for providing such overlapping illumination-detection geometry. In a preferred embodiment a single optical fiber is used, for example having dimensions between 10 μm and 3 mm.
In accordance with the invention a calibrated assessment of reflectance in the absence of absorption is used to appropriately estimate the combined effect that the reduced scattering coefficient and the scattering phase function have on the effective photon path length. Thereby estimation of the absorption coefficient is substantially improved.
Application of this methodology to measurement of living tissue provides aspects of vascular physiology which may be useful in characterization of tissue health status. For example, blood volume fraction, average vessel diameter and haemoglobin oxygen saturation, as well as concentrations of other light absorbing substances, including billirubin, beta-carotene, melanin, glucose, fat and water may be determined. In addition, the method can be used to measure concentrations of exogenous substances in tissue, such as drugs, optical contrast agents, dyes, pollutants, as long as hey have appropriate absorption properties in the wavelength region used.
The invention is based on the following insights. White-light reflectance measurements provide information about absorption and scattering properties of an optically sampled turbid medium such as tissue. Specifically the absorption coefficient μa relates to aspects of the tissue physiology. It is found that quantitative estimation of μa from a reflectance spectrum requires mathematical correction for the effects that μa, reduced scattering coefficient μs′ and scattering phase function PF have on the effective photon path length LSF. An example of a mathematical representation of this relationship is given by equation (1):
wherein
In the methods known from the prior art, practical application of equation (1) to analyze spectra measured in tissue in vivo has required an assumption about the tissue PF to estimate CPF, as well as an assumption about the value of μs′ at least at one wavelength. This approach is found to be not accurate.
It is further found that the single fiber reflectance intensity in the absence of absorption Rabs0 showed a PF-specific dependence on dimensionless scattering, defined as the product of μs′ and fiber diameter dfiber. However, it will be appreciated that this finding may be generalized to any overlapping illumination-detection geometry. An example of a mathematical representation of the relation between Rabs0 and dimensionless scattering is given in equation (2):
wherein,
Accordingly, in accordance with the insight of the invention, first a reference calibration measurement is carried out. A sample having high scattering coefficient (such that μs′dfiber>10) can be selected, because for very high scattering coefficients the collected reflectance becomes independent of the (often unknown) phase function of the calibration sample and approaches the diffuse limit ηc. Alternatively, a sample with a smaller scattering coefficient may be used if its phase function is known. The measurement may be performed with the fiber in contact with the calibration sample. However, other calibration geometries may be used. The absolute device calibration spectrum in case a high scattering reference sample is used can be calculated from the calibration measurement as follows:
wherein
When the results of the calibration measurements are processed they are further used in the method of the invention in the following way.
The absolute reflection spectrum of a sample under investigation (tissue) may be obtained using the calibration data as follows:
Rabs(λ)=C(λ)Smedium(λ) (4)
wherein
At the next step in accordance with the invention, the optical properties are extracted from the measured spectrum Rabs(λ). It is appreciated that a general problem in analysing such spectra is that three unknown parameters (reduced scattering coefficient μs′, scattering phase function PF and absorption coefficient μa) for each measurement point have to be calculated. As a result, the equations do not converge to a single solution.
In accordance with the invention the wavelength dependent absorption coefficient μa(λ) is calculated from the measured reflectance Rabs(λ) by minimizing the difference between the measured absolute reflection spectrum Rabs(λ) and the model function Rabsmodel(λ), wherein the model function Rabsmodel(λ) is modelled using a pre-determined equation based on prior knowledge of the combination of the dependence of the effective photon path length LSFmodel(λ) on the phase function PF (e.g. equation 1) and the dependence of the absolute reflectance in the absence of absorption Rabs0(λ) on the phase function PF (e.g. equation 2). The Rabsmodel(λ) may be modelled using the Lambert-Beer equation, according to Rabsmodel(λ)=Rabs0(λ)e(−□a(λ)L
Accordingly, in accordance with the invention, in Equation (2) μs′ is estimated from Rabsmodel such that the effect of a potential mis-estimation of μs′ in Equation (1) is compensated by a corresponding mis-estimation of CPF. In this way the effective path-length is close to its true value (within 7.5% for biological tissues), even when CPF and μs′ are incorrectly specified. Preferably, the values for CPF, P4, P5 and P6 are chosen to be 0.944, 1.55, 6.82, and 0.969, respectively; this choice of parameters minimizes the error in estimated path length LSFmodel(λ).
It will be appreciated, however, that the compensative effect occurs for other combined values of CPF, P4, P5 and P6 as well. Furthermore, different mathematical expressions than shown in Eqs. (1) and (2) may also be used to describe the combined effect of phase function on photon path length LSFmodel(λ) and on absolute reflectance Rabs0(λ). Moreover, lookup tables that directly link Rabs0(λ) to a combined CPF-μs′ set can be used as well. This named compensative effect in the mis-estimation of the core parameters in the equations is found to be surprising, however enabling to solve a single equation having three unknowns. More details on the named compensative effect will be given with reference to
In an embodiment of the method according to the invention the method further comprises the step of using a single fiber for delivering the light beam towards the sample and for collecting the reflected beam from the sample.
It is found that such solution may be practical for clinical purposes as both the impinging and the reflected beams may be delivered by the same fiber, allowing for small fiber-probe profiles and facilitating measurements through thin needles such as Fine Needle Aspiration needles.
In a further embodiment of the method according to the invention the light used for the calibration and sample measurements is generated by a plurality of monochromatic sources. However, it will be appreciated that a source having a continuous spectrum of wavelengths may also be used.
The system according to the invention for determining the wavelength dependent absorption coefficient of a diffuse medium for a light beam comprises:
Advantageous embodiments of the system according to the invention are given in the dependent claims.
The computer program according to the invention comprises instructions for causing a processor to carry out the following steps:
These and other aspects of the invention will be discussed in more detail with reference to figures wherein like reference numerals refer to like elements. It will be appreciated that the figures are presented for illustrative purposes and may not be used for limiting the scope of the appended claims.
It is further found to be advantageous to polish the probe 2 at an angle larger than arcsin(NA/nsample) with respect to a vertical line for minimizing specular reflections, where NA is the numerical aperture of the fiber and nmedium is the refractive index of the sample.
The reflectance of the sample is in case of a high scattering sample given by Rsample=ηc(NA(λ)).
When the absorption coefficient of a turbid medium (tissue) is to be determined, the equation 1 has to be used in a Lambert-Beer equation, according to Rabs=Rabs0exp(−□aLSFmodel). In a general way, the equation 1 can be written as:
As has been indicated earlier, in equation (5) PF and μs′ of tissue are not known, which implies that CPF is not known and that specification of μs′ from reflectance Rabs0 also requires knowledge of PF for specifying the correct constants P4, P5, and P6 in equation 2.
In accordance with the invention, μs′ is estimated from reflectance Rabs0 such that a potential mis-estimation of μs′ is compensated by a corresponding mis-estimation of CPF.
It is found that the ratio of CPF/(μs′)p2 is approximately equal to its true value (within 7.5% for biological tissues), provided the CPF is properly linked to the phase function used to estimate μs′ from Rabs0 (i.e. CPF is linked to the values of P4, P5, and P6 in equation 2).
It is found that as high angle scattering events become more likely, Rabs0 increases because incident photons are more likely to be collected and the photon path length LSF decreases as those collected photons are likely to travel a shorter path.
In
For an unknown sample, such as tissue, utilization of equations (1) and (2) to calculate the photon path length LSF requires an assumption about the phase function PF, which is also unknown.
It is found that it is particularly suitable to assume that the phase function PF is characterized by CPF=0.944, P4=1.55, P5=6.82 and P6=0.969 (see solid line, curve 1 in
Utilization of the P4, P5 and P6, discussed with reference to the foregoing regarding an assumed phase function PF in equation (2) corresponding to curve number 1 in
The following effect has been found when analyzing equations (1), (2) and the graphs given in
However, the initially assumed CPF (0.944), corresponding to the assumed sample curve 1 is larger than the “true” CPF (0.86), corresponding to the “true” sample curve 2. Accordingly, an over-estimation of CPF compensates for the effect of over-estimation of μs′ on LSF in Eq. (1).
Next, if the true phase function PF has in fact a smaller backscattering component than the value assumed for the phase function PF (e.g. the true sample PF corresponds to curve 3 in
Preferably, for the assumed scattering phase function PFassumed a gamma value between γ=1.6 and 1.8 is used, where gamma is related to the first and second moments (g1 and g2, respectively) of the scattering phase function according to γ=(1−g2)/(1−g1).
The inter-related, compensating effects of mis-estimation of CPF and μs′ through assumption of an estimated phase function PF can be further analysed by evaluation of the ratios CPFest/CPFreal and (μs′(Est)/μs′(Real))0.18.
It is found that these two metrics either both are smaller than unity or both are greater than unity, indicating a compensating effect on estimates of LSF. Moreover, the magnitudes of these effects are also very similar: CPFest/CPFreal ranges from 0.9 to 1.12 in biological tissues, while (μs′(Est)/μs′(Real))0.18 ranges from 0.85 to 1.25 in case equation (2) is used to calculate μs′(Est) from Rabs0.
The inset (I) in
It will be appreciated that while specific embodiments of the invention have been described above, the invention may be practiced otherwise than as described. For example, for specific turbid media different constants in the equations may be used. However, the method for determining the appropriate constants will lie within the ordinary skill of the person skilled in the art, when reducing the invention into practice.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/NL2012/050188 | 3/26/2012 | WO | 00 | 12/30/2013 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2012/128634 | 9/27/2012 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6014204 | Prahl et al. | Jan 2000 | A |
6850656 | Bevilacqua | Feb 2005 | B1 |
7420656 | Sandusky | Sep 2008 | B1 |
20080004842 | Amelink et al. | Jan 2008 | A1 |
20080194929 | Pesach et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 |
20100042005 | Bigio | Feb 2010 | A1 |
20100261958 | Webb | Oct 2010 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
Kanick et al., “Measurment of the reduced scattering coefficient of turbid media using single fiber reflectance spectroscopy: fiber diameter and phase function dependence”, Biomedical Optics Express, vol. 2, No. 1, Jan. 1, 2011. |
Kanick et al., “Integration of single-fiber reflectance spectroscopy into ultrasound-guided endoscopic lung cancer staging of mediastinal lymph nodes”, Journal of Biomedical Optics, vol. 15(1), Jan./Feb. 2010. |
Kanick et al., “Integration of single-fiber reflectance spectroscopy into ultrasound-guided endoscopic lung cancer staging of mediastinal lymph nodes”, Journal of Biomedical Optics 15(1), 017004, Jan. 15, 2010. |
Kanick et al., “Empirical model of the photon path length for a single fiber reflectance spectroscopy device”, Optics Express, vol. 17, No. 2, Jan. 19, 2009. |
Kanick et al., “Monte Carlo analysis of single fiber reflectance spectroscopy: photon path lengthand sampling depth”, Phys. Med. Biol. 54 6991, Nov. 4, 2009. |
Amelink, Arjen et al., “Measurement of the local optical properties of turbid media by differential path-length spectroscopy,” Applied Optics (May 20, 2004), 43(15):3048-3054. |
Doornbos, R. M. P. et al., “The determination of in vivo human tissue optical properties and absolute chromophore concentrations using spatially resolved steady-state diffuse reflectance spectroscopy,” Phys. Med. Biol. (1999), 44:967-981. |
Kanick, Stephen C. et al., “Empirical model description of photon path length for differential path length spectroscopy: combined effect of scattering and absorption,” Journal of Biomedical Optics (Nov./Dec. 2008), 13(6):064042-1-064042-8. |
Kanick, S. C. et al., “Empirical model of the photon path length for a single fiber reflectance spectroscopy device,” Optics Express (Jan. 19, 2009), 17(2):860-871. |
Kanick, S. C. et al., “Monte Carlo analysis of single fiber reflectance spectroscopy: photon path length and sampling depth,” Phys. Med. Biol. (2009), 54:6991-7008. |
Phillips, et al., “Calculation of Photon Path Changes due to Scatter in Monte Carlo Simulations,” 32nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE EMBS, Buenos Aires, Argentina, Aug. 31-Sep. 4, 2010, pp. 4959-4962. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20140107951 A1 | Apr 2014 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | PCT/NL2011/050205 | Mar 2011 | US |
Child | 14006643 | US |