This disclosure relates generally to a system and method for sequestering carbon dioxide from an exhaust stream by direct mineral carbonization. More specifically, this disclosure relates to a system and method for passing flue gas containing carbon dioxide through a bed of particulate material that includes a mineral capable of being carbonized by exposure to carbon dioxide to produce one or more carbonates thereby producing a carbon dioxide-depleted exhaust stream.
Rising levels of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere have prompted concerns about global warming. To address these concerns, the amounts of CO2 released to the atmosphere should be lowered. The primary approaches under consideration include: improving energy efficiency when fossil fuels are employed; making greater use of non-fossil fuel sources; and developing viable technologies for the capture, separation, and long-term storage of CO2. The latter strategy, known as “CO2 sequestration,” is receiving increased attention because it permits continued use of readily available and relatively inexpensive fossil fuels while reducing the amounts of CO2 released to the atmosphere.
One technique for CO2 sequestration is injection of CO2 gas into underground reservoirs, e.g., active or depleted oil and gas fields, deep brine formations, and subterranean coal beds. The underlying premise of this approach is that, after injection, the CO2 will remain sequestered in the host rock indefinitely. In practice, however, such long-term reservoir integrity cannot be guaranteed. Specifically, if either CO2 or CO2-saturated formation water escapes or migrates from the reservoir, water supplies could become contaminated, and/or large amounts of CO2 could be released to the atmosphere. The possibility of CO2 release back into the atmosphere requires continuous monitoring of such underground reservoirs which, in turn, increases the cost of underground CO2 injection strategies. Further, suitable underground reservoirs are limited in number and may be difficult to access for delivery of the CO2.
One way to avoid the reservoir-integrity problems associated with subterranean sequestration of CO2 is to chemically bind CO2 with suitable solid materials. This CO2 sequestration strategy, known as “mineral carbonation,” involves reacting CO2 with mineral oxides (e.g., CaO, MgO) or silicates (e.g, olivine, serpentine, talc) to produce solid carbonate compounds, such as calcite (CaCO3), magnesite (MgCO3), iron carbonates (FeCO3, Fe2(CO3)2), etc.
To date, mineral carbonations include a chemical process carried out in a slurry, at elevated pressures and in a separate reactor. In one example provided by U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2004/0126293, entitled “Process for Removal of Carbon Dioxide from Flue Gases,” CO2 is first extracted from a flue gas using an aqueous amine solution. The CO2-containing amine solution is then heated to regenerate the amine solution and separate the CO2 from the amine solution to provide a CO2-rich gas stream. Then, the CO2-rich gas stream is contacted with an aqueous slurry of magnesium silicate in a separate reactor which results in carbonation of the magnesium silicates and removal the CO2 from the gas stream. Electrolytes in the form of one or more salts are added to the slurry to increase the mineral carbonization reaction rate.
Mineral carbonation has advantages over alternative methods for large-scale CO2 sequestration. First, mineral carbonates are thermodynamically stable need not be monitored for CO2 release. Further, mineral carbonates are environmentally benign and weakly soluble in water. Consequently, mineral carbonates can be used to reduce acidity and/or increase moisture content of soil, can be combined with other materials to strengthen roadbeds, can be used as a filler in the carpet and plastic industries, can be used in mine reclamation or simply dumped in a landfill. Alternatively, the mineral carbonates could be returned to the site of excavation to fill the cavity created by soil/rock removal. Regardless of the particular end use or disposal scheme selected for the carbonates, the reacted CO2 will remain as carbonates and be immobilized for an indefinite period of time.
In weighing the economic and technical feasibility of CO2 sequestration by mineral carbonation, it should be noted the magnesium-rich minerals olivine, serpentine and talc, are readily available. Olivine and serpentine can be carbonated by the following reactions:
However, disadvantages of current mineral carbonation processes include: (1) the need to separate the CO2 from a flue gas and transport the separated and compressed CO2 to a separate carbonization reactor; (2) the need to heat-treat the olivine or serpentine prior to carbonization; (3) the elevated temperatures (e.g.,155° C.) and pressures (e.g., 185 atm) required; (4) the need for a separate carbonization reactor which may or may not be disposed close to the source of the CO2 emissions; (5) the water requirements of the carbonization reactions which are typically carried out in an aqueous slurry as well as the aqueous solvents used to separate the CO2 from the flue stream; and (6) the additives and/or catalysts that are usually required to accelerate the mineral carbonization reaction rate.
Accordingly, an improved mineral carbonation process is needed for the economical and convenient sequestration of CO2 from a flue or exhaust stream.
Improved methods for removing carbon dioxide from an exhaust or flue stream are disclosed. In one disclosed method, flue gas that includes carbon dioxide is passed through a bed of particulate material. The bed of particulate material may be disposed directly in the flue or flue conduit so that at least some or all of the flue gas passes through the bed of particulate material. The particulate material includes one or more materials that are carbonized upon exposure to carbon dioxide. The particulate material may be selected from the group consisting of metal silicates, alkaline earth metal oxides and combinations thereof. By passing the flue gas that includes carbon dioxide through the bed of particulate material, the carbon dioxide reacts with the particulate material to produce one or more metal carbonates and a carbon dioxide-depleted flue gas.
Improved flue gas exhaust systems are also disclosed. In one disclosed system, a flue is provided that houses a bed of particulate material. The particulate material may be selected from the group consisting of metal silicates, alkaline earth metal oxides and combinations thereof. The bed may be disposed within the flue so that at least some flue gas passing through the flue also passes through and makes contact with the bed of particulate material. The bed may include an inlet end for receiving carbon dioxide-rich flue gas and an outlet end for releasing carbon dioxide-depleted flue gas.
Referring to
As the mineral particulate material becomes carbonated by the carbon dioxide in the flue gas, it may be replaced. Accordingly, an injection port 17 may be provided near the upper grate 16 for delivering fresh or un-carbonized mineral particulate material to the bed 12. The injection port 17 may be in communication with a pump or conveyor 18 as well as a supply 21 of fresh or un-carbonized mineral particulate material. Similarly, an evacuation port 22 may be disposed near the bottom grate 14 for evacuating spent material from the bed 12. The evacuation port 22 may be in communication with a pump or conveyor 23 and a disposal area 24. As flue gas containing carbon dioxide flows in the direction shown by the arrow 25 towards the bed 12, carbon dioxide reacts with the mineral particulate material of the bed 12 and the material becomes carbonated thereby reducing the amount of carbon dioxide that exits the flue 11 in the direction shown by the arrow 26.
It has been found that mineral carbonization reactions may proceed very quickly and therefore the lower portion of the bed 12 near the bottom grate 13 may have a higher concentration of carbonated mineral material than the upper portion of the bed 12 near the upper grate 15. Accordingly, in the embodiment shown in
For example, another system for replenishing or replacing the bed 12 is illustrated in
Alternatively, as shown in
The bed 12 includes material that is capable of being carbonized with gaseous carbon dioxide either at typical exhaust temperatures or at a desired temperature that would be lower than the decomposition temperature of the carbonate. For magnesium-based minerals, a desired temperature would be less than 500° C.; for calcium-based minerals, a desired temperature would be less than 900° C. As surprisingly found below, olivine and serpentine are suitable magnesium-based materials that are relatively abundant, easy to obtain, and do not require costly heat pre-treatments prior to carbonization or grinding.
As noted above, prior art techniques for carbon dioxide sequestration through mineral carbonization suffer from many disadvantages not found in the disclosed methods or systems. Specifically, currently available mineral carbonization processes require the reaction to be carried out in an aqueous slurry and a feed gas with a high concentration of carbon dioxide. Typically, the carbon dioxide is separated from an exhaust gas stream, compressed and transported to the reactor where the carbonization reaction is carried out in the aqueous slurry. Obviously, the cost to separate the carbon dioxide and transport it to a separate reactor and the water costs associated with the slurry drive-up the overall cost of the mineral carbonization. No economically viable dry mineral carbonization process has been introduced. Further, mineral carbonization processes that utilize naturally occurring mineral reactants such as olivine or serpentine typically require the olivine or serpentine to be heat-treated or chemically-treated prior to use. Heat pre-treatments are energy intensive and drive-up the overall cost and fossil fuel use of the mineral carbonization. Chemical pre-treatments and the use of catalysts add costs and complexity to the mineral carbonization.
In contrast,
The material may be ground for use in either a packed or fluidized bed. It has been found that surface area per unit mass may be more relevant than particle size and therefore the material may be ground to a surface area per unit mass ranging from about 0.15 to about 35 m2/g. If surface area per unit mass data is unavailable, mean particle size can provide some guidance and the mean particle size can range from about 2.5 to about 60 μm, depending upon the mineral material being utilized.
Referring now to
In addition, the carbonation efficiency in the 100-500° C. range using 0.5 g olivine becomes significantly higher than the efficiency obtained using 5 g olivine. The CO2 capture capacity of 0.5 g of olivine is approximately 2 g CO2/g olivine, while the CO2 capture capacity of 5 g of olivine is 0.12 g CO2/g olivine. In comparison to commercially available reactants with CO2 capture capacities of 0.08-0.088 g CO2/g reactant, these results show that, under optimized operational conditions, even small amounts of olivine have a high CO2 capture capacity and affinity.
In contrast to prior art processes that require the reaction to take place in an aqueous slurry, it has been surprisingly found that water vapor present in most hydrocarbon combustion flue gases provides a sufficient amount of water. As noted above, water is not a primary reactant for the mineral carbonization process. However, water vapor can be useful to convert oxides that may be present to hydroxides which may then be carbonated. An exemplary reaction sequence for magnesium oxide is shown below:
MgO+H2O→Mg(OH)2
Mg(OH)2+CO2→MgCO3
Oxides may be present in mined material such as olivine and serpentine or may be generated as byproducts during the carbonation process. Hence, as shown below, the presence of some water may be beneficial but the disclosed methods exploit the presence of water vapor in hydrocarbon combustion flue gases thereby avoiding the necessity of adding water.
A comparison of with water vapor and without water vapor results for 0.5 g olivine beds is provided in
MgCO3(s)+H2O (g)→Mg(OH)2(s)+CO2(g),
at temperatures above about 500° C. as the Gibbs free energy as a function of temperature becomes negative at temperatures exceeding about 500° C. In contrast, solid magnesium carbonate can decompose to solid magnesium oxide and carbon dioxide gas without the presence of water vapor via the following reaction
MgCO3(s)→MgO(s)+CO2(g),
at temperatures above about 305° C. as the Gibbs free energy as a function of temperature becomes negative at temperatures exceeding about 305° C.
On the other hand, using the same Gibbs free energy/temperature analysis, calcium carbonate can decompose to calcium hydroxide in the presence of water vapor at temperatures above about 1590° C. while calcium carbonate decomposes to calcium oxide without the presence of water vapor at temperatures above about 900° C. Therefore, mineral carbonations using calcium-based minerals can be carried out at substantially higher temperatures than mineral carbonations using magnesium-based minerals. Specifically, because calcium carbonate will not decompose at temperatures of less than about 900° C., mineral carbonizations employing calcium-based minerals can be carried out at temperatures less than about 900° C.
Suitable calcium-based minerals include, but are not limited to calcium silicate, wollastonite (calcium metasilicate—CaSiO3), bredigite (Ca7Mg(SiO4)4), rankinite (Ca3Si2O7), minerals comprising mixtures of Ca2SiO7 and CaCO3, such as tilleyite (Ca5Si2O7(CO3)2), and spurrite (Ca5(SiO4)2(CO3)).
A packed or fluidized bed 12 like those shown in
By avoiding the need for a mineral carbonization process carried out in an aqueous slurry, the disclosed systems and methods reduce water consumption and the costs associated therewith. The disclosed systems and methods also avoid the need to separate carbon dioxide from a flue stream and transport the separated carbon dioxide to a separate reactor. The costs associated with constructing and maintaining a separate reactor may also be avoided as the disclosed systems and methods may be practiced by simply retrofitting an existing flue or exhaust and or can be easily and economically installed as original equipment in new plants. Further, carrying out a mineral carbonization at the source of carbon dioxide production eliminates disadvantages associated with separating, storing and transporting carbon dioxide which is required for subterranean sequestration and other mineral carbonization processes.