a graphically depicts the analyzed parameters from Digital Thermal Monitoring (DTM) data points from a finger on an arm subject to reactive hyperemia (black diamonds). Hypothetical data from a contralateral control finger also shown for purposes of comparison (in grey circles).
a and 4b depict several views of embodiments of a finger cuff and temperature sensor for ambulatory vascular reactivity assessment.
a depicts a dorsal view of another glove embodiment, while
a depicts a ventral view of one embodiment of a sensor wiring harness for fingertip and palm blood flow monitoring, while
Different individuals having the same level of cardiovascular risk factors such as high cholesterol, smoking, diabetes etc may exhibit differences in vascular reactivity and vascular functional responses once exposed to the same level of mental stress. Those with impaired vasoreactivity (less vaso dilative capacity) are more likely at risk of future cardiovascular disease such as heart attack and stroke. However, there are at present no means to readily identify these individuals.
Psychological mental stress and subclinical cardiovascular disease (CVD) interact lethally in certain individuals. Repeated exposure to high levels of physical and, particularly, psychological mental stress, and sustained exposure to low levels of mental stress, both of which are experienced during high mental stress jobs and military service, may impair endothelial function acutely, and cumulatively impair cardiovascular health in the longer term. Mental stress amplifies the interaction between risk factors for atherosclerosis and vascular endothelial dysfunction. Mental stress also impairs mental acuity, awareness, perception, and decision-making ability.
Clinically silent coronary artery disease is well documented in apparently healthy individuals, many of whom are routinely and chronically exposed to episodic psychological mental stress at levels that may promote CVD. Effects of mental stress may manifest suddenly and unexpectedly, as in the case of acute coronary syndromes and sudden cardiovascular death in both civilian and combat-related circumstances. Given inter individual differences in susceptibility, typically subtle and asymptomatic short term CV effects, and the lack of adequate methods to quantify cumulative mental stress exposure, it is impossible to accurately identify those individuals at highest risk of mental stress-dependent CVD, including life-threatening CV events. One embodiment of the present invention provides a method for ambulatory quantitative monitoring of psychological mental stress and vascular function, to identify individuals with hidden susceptibility to pathologic vascular effects of mental stress in order to prevent death, disability, and high costs associated with cardiovascular and mental vulnerability to mental stress.
Vascular Responses Mediated by the Endothelial System: All of the blood vessels in the body are lined by a single layer of cells known as the vascular endothelium. Endothelial dysfunction causes impaired vascular reactivity, compounds the adverse effects of inflammatory factors, and underlies a variety of vascular and non-vascular diseases, particularly heart attack and stroke. Certain of the diseases associated with endothelial dysfunction are depicted graphically in
Endothelial function can be evaluated by various different approaches, including: measurement of structural characteristics of the vascular wall, e.g. intima media thickness, compliance, distensibility, and remodeling indexes; measurement of soluble endothelial markers including von Willebrandt factor, plasminogen activator, inhibitor complex thrombomodulin adhesion molecules, and nitric oxides; and measurement of endothelium-dependent regulation of vascular tone. See Kelm M. “Flow-mediated dilatation in human circulation: diagnostic and therapeutic aspects” Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 282 (2002) H1-H5.
Endothelium-dependent vasodilation as a measure of endothelial function can be determined by invasive vasomotor techniques including quantitative coronary angiography and strain gauge plethysmography of the forearm with intra-arterial acetylcholine challenge. Due to the invasive nature of these methods, brachial artery flow-mediated dilation (FMD) measurement by high-resolution ultrasonography has been alternatively accepted as a research tool, albeit highly technical, for the examination of endothelial function. See Sorensen K E, et al. “Non-invasive measurement of human endothelium dependent arterial responses: accuracy and reproducibility” Br Heart J 74 (1995) 247-253. Brachial artery flow-mediated dilation (FMD) measurement by high-resolution ultrasonography utilizes the phenomena of reactive hyperemia. Reactive hyperemia is defined as hyperemia, or an increase in the quantity of blood flow to a body part, resulting from the restoration of its temporarily blocked blood flow. When blood flow is temporarily blocked, tissue downstream to the blockage becomes ischemic. Ischemia refers to a shortage of blood supply, and thus oxygen, to a tissue. When flow is restored, the endothelium lining the previously ischemic vasculature is subject to a large, transient shear mental stress. In partial response to the shear mental stress, the endothelium normally mediates a vasodilatory response known as flow-mediated dilatation (FMD). The vasodilatory response to shear mental stress is mediated by several vasodilators released by the endothelium, including nitric oxide (NO), prostaglandins (PGI2) and endothelium-derived hyperpolarizing factor (EDHF), among others. A small FMD response is interpreted as indicating endothelial dysfunction and an associated increased risk of vascular disease or cardiac events. See Pyke K E and Tschakovsky M E “The relationship between shear mental stress and flow-mediated dilatation: implications for the assessment of endothelial function” J Physiol 568(2) (2005) 357-9.
Induction of reactive hyperemia is well-established in clinical research as a means to evaluate vascular health and in particular endothelial function. Typically, a reactive hyperemia procedure is implemented by occluding arterial blood flow briefly (2-5 minutes, depending on the specific protocol) in the arm, by supra-systolic inflation of a standard sphygmomanometer cuff, then releasing it rapidly to stimulate an increase in blood flow to the arm and hand. Reactive hyperemia has been classically measured by high-resolution ultrasound imaging of the brachial artery during and after arm-cuff occlusion. However, the technical difficulties of ultrasound imaging have limited the use of this test to research laboratories. This method is clearly unsuitable to widespread adoption of reactive hyperemia as a test of vascular function. The method is simply inapplicable to evaluation of endothelial function in the context of real life mental stress inducers.
Digital Thermal Monitoring: Certain of the present inventors have previously developed novel methods and apparatus to determine the vascular reactivity based on a measured response of the vasculature to reactive hyperemia utilizing continuous skin monitoring of inherent temperature on a digit distal (downstream) to an occluded arterial flow. By inherent temperature it is meant the unmodified temperature of the skin as opposed to measurement of the dissipation of induced temperature. This principal and technique has been termed Digital Thermal Monitoring (DTM). See WO 05/18516, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference. DTM is typically implemented by measuring temperature changes at the fingertips during reactive hyperemia induced by transient arm-cuff occlusion and subsequent release. A normal reactive hyperemia response, i.e. increased blood flow after occlusion, is manifest by increased skin temperature over the baseline temperature established prior to occlusion.
A pilot study was performed with the aim of evaluating the potential clinical utility in cardiovascular risk stratification of DTM. DTM was performed using a VENDYS ® DTM system 10 generally as depicted in
DTM assessment is conducted generally as follows. In a standard controlled setting, the subject is seated and the cuff 18 is placed on one arm 14. Temperature probe 20a is placed on the index finger of the cuffed arm and temperature probe 20b is placed on the index finger of the contralateral arm. Baseline temperature data is continuously recorded for an equilibration period, for example three minutes. The cuff 18 is inflated rapidly to 200 mm Hg or 50 mm Hg above systolic blood pressure and the pressure is retained at this level for 2 to 3 minutes. During this period skin temperature falls on the fingertip of the occluded arm. After 2 to 3 minutes, the cuff is rapidly deflated and the skin temperature rapidly rises as blood returns to hand and fingers. Temperature is recorded for another 3 minutes after the cuff is deflated and the data from both fingers is captured and displayed by a computer 12. The following primary parameters are calculated as depicted in part in
Measures reflecting the ischemic stimulus/thermal debt:
Parameters reflecting thermal recovery/vascular reactivity:
TR and NP indicate the vasodilatory capacity of the vascular bed (small arteries and micro-vessels) and subsequent hyperemia induced brachial artery dilation. TR and NP indicate the vasodilatory capacity of the vascular bed (small arteries and micro-vessels) and subsequent hyperemia induced brachial artery dilation. TR specifically denotes the ability of the arterial bed to compensate for the duration of the ischemia and to create an overflow (hyperemia) above the baseline level. Given a good vasodilatory response and constant room temperature one would expect a positive TR. The higher the TR, the higher the vasodilatory response of the arterial bed. TR close to zero indicates a lack of strong vasodilatory response and negative TR is likely to represent a vasoconstrictive response. NP and TR largely overlap and both show similar information with TR being a more sensitive marker of overflow (hyperemia response) and NP showing additional factors that affect TF (such as neuroregulatory effect and basal metabolic rate). Factors as TTF, TTR and area under the curve are expected to provide additional insights into the response to the ischemia challenge test.
In preliminary studies, several parameters including TF, TR, NP, TTR, TTF were measured. These parameters were correlated against two standard methods of estimating blood flow changes in the forearm: flow-mediated dilatation of the brachial artery, and strain-gauge plethysmography, both during reactive hyperemia in apparently healthy volunteers. In one study, DTM results were compared against Framingham Risk Estimation (FRE) in a community setting. 133 subjects, responding to a local newspaper advertisement, gave informed consent to participate in this study. Subjects agreed to disclose limited medical information regarding any history of cardiovascular disease and cardiovascular risk factors, to a finger stick blood draw for non-fasting lipid profile measurement, and to undergo DTM on up to 3 occasions. Subjects fasted overnight and refrained from smoking, alcohol or caffeine ingestion and use of any vasoactive medications on the day of the testing in both protocols. Subjects remained seated, with the forearms supported at knee level. VENDYS™ DTM probes were affixed to the index finger of each hand as previously described.
In these preliminary studies, DTM appeared to complement FRE in distinguishing between cohorts with and without self-reported CVD.
One embodiment of the present invention now provides novel methods and apparatus that utilize the principal of reactive hyperemia for ambulatory quantitative monitoring of psychological mental stress and vascular function to identify individuals with hidden susceptibility to pathologic vascular effects of mental stress. Thus, assessment of individual vascular reaction to real-life mental stress inducers is available for the first time.
Mental Stress Effects and the Vascular System: Psychological factors such as mental stress, anxiety, and depression show significant correlations with measurable physiological parameters (such as blood glucose levels, peripheral body temperature, and risk factors for cardiovascular disease). Mental stress also results in the secretion of cortisol which affects the blood sugar levels (abnormal levels can lead to diabetes), immune responses, and can also elicit inflammatory responses.
The relation between mental stress and temperature can be understood as follows. The cardiovascular mechanisms that regulate skin temperature in the hands and feet are closely linked with the activity of the sympathetic division of the autonomic nervous system. Upon activation of this system, the smooth muscles surrounding the blood vessels under the skin surface vasoconstrict, resulting in decreased blood flow to the capillaries and capillary beds (body tissue) near the skin surface. Under mental stress, blood flow through the peripheral capillaries and tissues near the skin surface decreases, and the temperature of the skin decreases. To achieve homeostasis (i.e. return to an unstressed mental state), there is an increase in skin temperature as a result of vasodilatation, or relaxation of the smooth muscles surrounding the peripheral blood vessels. Vasodilatation is usually accompanied by a relaxation of sympathetic activity. There is generally an interval of several seconds between vasodilatation and skin temperature increase, because a certain time period must elapse while the increased amount of blood flows into the capillaries and tissues.
Accordingly, vascular reactivity can be affected by mental stress. In an embodiment, the degree with which mental stress affects vascular reactivity can vary according to an individual's resistance to mental stress. In an embodiment, a vascular reactivity difference in mental stress response can be measured between mental stress resistant and vulnerable individuals. In an embodiment, a baseline TR can be measured prior to a mental stress challenge and compared to a TR measured during or soon after a mental stress challenge. Individuals who are resistant to mental stress can maintain a TR at the same level or greater than their baseline measurement. Individuals who are vulnerable to mental stress can have difficulty maintaining baseline TR levels during or after incidences of mental stress. Accordingly, individuals who have cardiovascular vulnerability to mental stress can be profiled as having reduced TR levels during or after a mental stress response.
Individualized Ambulatory Assessment of Mental stress Reactions: Psychological mental stress and subclinical cardiovascular disease (CVD) interact lethally in certain individuals. In animals, including humans, acute psychological mental stress induces a defense reaction mediated by increased sympathetic nerve activity which in turn elicits the hemodynamic responses of increased heart rate, cardiac output, mean arterial pressure, which together with decreased renal blood flow, result in increased blood flow to the skeletal muscle of the limbs. However, in susceptible individuals, these hemodynamic responses are exaggerated and may trigger acute adverse cardiac events. Chronic effects are also implicated as mental stress amplifies the interaction between risk factors for atherosclerosis and vascular endothelial dysfunction. Given inter-individual differences in susceptibility, typically subtle and asymptomatic short term CV effects, and the lack of adequate methods to quantify cumulative mental stress exposure, it has been heretofore impossible to accurately identify those individuals at highest risk of mental stress-dependent CVD, including life-threatening CV events. The present inventors have developed methods and apparatus able to provide individualized assessment of mental stress reactions that is able to isolate the mental stress response from the confounding variables of general physical and environmental condition.
One embodiment of the present invention relies on continuous measurement of blood flow at anatomic locations with maximum sympathetic nervous system effects, such as the fingertip, relative to blood flow at anatomic locations with minimum sympathetic nervous system effects in order to provide a catalogue of neurovascular responses in a given individual. By continuous measurement, it is meant a series of repeated closely spaced measurements over a test period. The test period might be during the duration of a discrete administered mental stress test or series of tests or might be over a longer duration such as a period of hours or days.
In one embodiment, blood flow is measured by skin temperature and a combination of finger mounted thermal energy sensor and palm mounted temperature sensor is used to distinguish a neurovascular response (autonomic nervous system—ANS—response) that is maximally detected by monitoring fingertip (cutaneous) blood flow and its surrogate (e.g. fingertip temperature) from areas where the ANS effect is not maximum such as core temperature, skin temperature on the thoracic or truncal (abdominal) part, or else where the blood flow, unlike fingertip, is not maximally ANS affected. The closest location to the fingertip is on the palm. Therefore, monitoring the differential (delta) temperature of palm versus fingertip can provide an indicator of ANS activity and thus serve as a surrogate marker of mental stress. One embodiment of this differential monitoring can be achieved by placing a wireless (or wired) thermosensor patch on the skin of the body elsewhere (e.g. chest, abdomen, etc) which would enable simultaneous differential thermal monitoring.
In order for mental stress responses and vascular function to be assessed in the context of real life situations, including mental stress situations, miniaturized wearable devices can be adapted to not interfere with real-life activities but able to isolate and identify neurovascular mental stress responses. By providing a continuous record of neurovascular mental stress responses, the present invention is able to identify those individuals for whom intervention is medically indicated.
In one embodiment of the invention, a chosen location with maximum sympathetic nervous system effects is the fingertip. In one embodiment, as depicted in
In one embodiment, blood flow is measured by skin temperature and the sensors 200, 210 and 85 are temperature sensors, for example thermister or thermocouple temperature sensors. In one embodiment, the temperature sensors are designed as thin, flexible, multijunction thermocouple arrays having electrical sensor junctions spaced at intervals over the length of the finger and onto the palm such that a temperature gradient can be recorded along the length of the array after calibration for any thermal conductivity effect (k effect) along the multicouple wires in accordance with procedures known in the art. See e.g. M. B. Ducharme and J. Frim “A multicouple probe for temperature gradient measurements in biological materials” J Appl Physiol 65 (1988) 2337-2342.
In the embodiment depicted in
In further embodiments, the finger and palm monitor combination can further include a vascular occlusive cuff, such as a cuff mounted on the base of the finger or on the wrist to induce reactive hyperemia. In one embodiment, the ring 70 is provided with an occluding strap or inflatable cuff 65 for implementing a reactive hyperemia test in conjunction with DTM. Using this combination, neurovascular responses can be determined and compared with hyperemia vascular reactivity response using thermal monitoring. The present invention also provides a solution for obtaining accurate measurements of mental stress that discriminates between neurovascular responses (autonomic response) from hyperemia vascular reactivity responses. Furthermore, the combination of mental stress monitoring and vascular responsiveness in the context of reactive hyperemia provides for a determination of the effects of mental stress on vascular responsiveness, a particularly relevant physiologic correlation in individuals at risk for mental stress related acute and chronic cardiovascular disease.
The palm temperature sensor 85 may be held in place with strap 90. Alternatively or additionally, an adhesive patch 80 may be employed to adhere the sensor to the skin of the palm. Wires 75 communicate temperature data from temperature sensor 85. Temperature data from both sensors 50 and 85 is collected simultaneously and conveyed to a control unit (not shown) conveniently mounted in electrical communication with the sensors. For example, the control unit can be mounted on the back of the hand or on the wrist and secured by further strap 95. One such control unit is depicted in
In another embodiment of the invention, depicted in
Optionally, the glove includes a pulse sensor 125, mounted over the radial artery. One example of a suitable pulse sensor is an oscillometric pressure sensor. The glove also optionally includes one or more of an ambient temperature sensor and a galvanic skin response (i.e., electro dermal response-EDR) monitor. Each of the functional elements of the glove is in electrical communication with a controller mounted on the glove, such as on the back of the hand of the glove or on the top of the wrist. The glove can also include cuff inflation and deflation (tools) mechanisms (built in) to occlude the blood flow (at wrist or elsewhere) for reactive hyperemia and vascular reactivity testing.
In one embodiment of a glove system, such as that depicted in
In one embodiment, an example of which is depicted in
In one embodiment of the invention, a mental stress challenge test is employed to identify a hyperactive sympathetic nervous system and thus to identify those individuals who are prone to develop sustained hypertension. Responses are monitored for an increase in vasoconstriction by looking at increased temperature rather than increased blood pressure. The sympathetic nervous response is assessed for response to mental stressful tests, i.e. challenging mathematical problems or mental stressful movies/pictures. Temperature of the fingertip and palm are continuously measured. A determination of the relative hyperactivity of the sympathetic nervous system is based on the behavior of palm and fingertip temperature before, during and after the mental stress challenge test. This test can be combined with other markers of mental stress, e.g. temperature response along with heart rate or respiratory rate or blood pressure or skin galvanic response to further evaluate the body's reactivity to mental stress. Thus in one embodiment of the present invention, mental stress is assessed during real-life activities by utilizing combined finger and palm temperature monitoring.
In one embodiment of the invention, a miniaturized device is employed to continuously measure and provide for recording of skin and ambient temperature. Because ambient temperature is also recorded, the skin temperature is provided with a contemporaneous reference. In one embodiment a method is provided to determine an individual's reaction to induced mental stress. A finger mounted miniaturized temperature probe is affixed to a finger and can be additionally be mounted to the palm of the same hand. Temperature recording begins, including baseline temperature recordings. Mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature recording is combined with real and induced mental stress situation to provide individual assessments of mental stress responses. Under mental stress, blood flow through the peripheral capillaries and tissues near the skin surface decreases, and the temperature of the skin decreases. To achieve homeostasis (i.e. return to unmental stressed state), there is an increase in skin temperature as a result of vasodilatation, or relaxation of the smooth muscles surrounding the peripheral blood vessels. Vasodilatation is usually accompanied by a relaxation of sympathetic activity. A vasoconstrictive response induced by a sufficiently mental stressful situation is normal and may be desirable. However, a vasoconstrictive response to a condition that should not evoke a profound mental stress response is undesirable. Furthermore, the intensity and duration of the response may indicate an inappropriate mental stress response. In one embodiment of the present invention, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed to identify dangerous mental stress responses. In another embodiment, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed as an objective biofeedback reporter to teach control of mental stress responses. In another embodiment, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed as an objective reporter of the success of therapies for mental stress control including by pharmacologic interventions.
In another embodiment, vascular reactivity is assessed during real-life activities by utilizing the finger based cuff occlusion of the present invention to implement reactive hyperemia and measure vascular reactivity by DTM and/or fingertip arterial tonometry (for example using a device available from Itamar Medical). The device is worn in ordinary conditions, normally considered to be non-mental stressful, to establish a “normal” individual vascular reactivity profile. The individual is then subject to various mental stressful conditions to determine that individual's vascular reactivity under mental stress.
DTM assessment can be conducted generally similar to the description related to arm cuffs herein. In a standard controlled setting, the subject is seated and a suitable cuff can be placed on at least one finger. A temperature probe can be placed on the tip of the index finger of the cuffed finger and a temperature probe can be placed on the index finger of the contralateral arm. Baseline temperature data can be continuously recorded for an equilibration period, for example three minutes. The finger cuff can be inflated rapidly to 200 mm Hg or 50 mm Hg above systolic blood pressure and the pressure is retained at this level for 2 to 5 minutes. During this period skin temperature falls on the fingertip of the occluded finger. After 2 to 5 minutes, the cuff is rapidly deflated and the skin temperature rapidly rises as blood returns to hand and fingers. Temperature is recorded for another 3 minutes after the cuff is deflated and the data from both fingers is captured and displayed by a computer. The DTM primary parameters using finger cuffs are calculated along the same curve using arm cuffs as depicted in part in
One embodiment of a miniature DTM device (MDTMD) is shown in
Device functionality is briefly described below, elaborating on the physical operating principles. Upon activation, the occluding band first compresses the artery in the finger, causing ischemia (i.e. interruption in the flow of blood to the finger tips). After a pre-set or programmable occlusion time, the finger tips—having been deprived of normal blood circulation—attain a reduced surface temperature closer to ambient. Following this period of constriction, the occluding band can be manually loosened by pressing a button on the occluding band, thereby immediately restoring blood flow. The subsequent time-variations of the finger-tip temperature are measured by the sensor.
Referring again to
Depiction C of
In another embodiment of a finger cuff ring is depicted in
In one embodiment of the invention, an example of which is depicted in
In one embodiment, the ring including an occluding strap or cuff also contains an additional temperature sensor that measures the ambient temperature. Both these temperature signals are digitized by a microchip-based data acquisition system, placed within the temperature sensing band (TSB). Data is recorded for a pre-set programmable duration, sufficient to capture all relevant trends of the temperature data. Upon completion of the test, the MDTMD transmits the temperature data to a remote telemedic computer system. The transmitted data will also contain “envelope” information identifying the device serial number, thereby identifying the human subject; several hundred simultaneous data transmissions can be handled by a dedicated telemedic computer system.
At the telemedic center, the dedicated computer system analyzes the temperature trends, and looks up relevant patient-specific information from its database. Using these inputs, a computational model calculates the DTM indices describing the functioning of the endothelial system. Physicians will thus be able to query and view various graphs and data tables and analyze the DTM indices to determine the patient's state of health. Having simultaneous access to the patient's medical history, they will be able to compare current data with past data taken under user-selectable environments. This will further allow the medical staff to take into account the various subjective environmental factors before arriving at a diagnosis. Table 1 below summarizes the salient features of this embodiment of a MDTMD according to the invention:
Using a prototype device, it was demonstrated that finger based cuff occlusion yields the same results as the arm occlusion. By employing DTM in conjunction with reactive hyperemia in normal activities versus in mental stress inducing activity, individual responses to mental stress as reflected in vascular function can be determined. Further, one may also thereby determine—indirectly—the effects of mental stress on diseases such as CVD and diabetes, which have been shown to be correlated with mental stress.
In other embodiments of the present invention, finger based cuff occlusion is utilized with other methods of measuring vascular reactivity including fingertip arterial tonometry (for example using a device available from Itamar Medical) or heat-flux metering (for example using a perfusion device by Hemedex Inc).
Military Indications: Recent research has established that combat, exposure to heavy casualties, deployment of units in a war zone, and unexpected mobilizations of reserve units are all correlated with higher levels of psychological mental stress. Clinically silent coronary artery disease is well documented in apparently healthy military personnel, many of whom are routinely and chronically exposed to episodic psychological mental stress at levels that may promote CVD. Because mental stress impairs mental acuity, awareness, perception, and decision-making ability, mental stress is a potential risk factor not only for the individual concerned, but also for subordinates and fellow soldiers in combat situations. Effects of mental stress may manifest suddenly and unexpectedly, as in the case of acute coronary syndromes and sudden cardiovascular death in combat-related circumstances. Indeed, heart attack and mental stress-related illness are leading causes of death and disability, second only to combat casualties. See Enos W F et al. “Coronary Disease Among United States Soldiers Killed in Action in Korea: Preliminary Report” Journal of the American Medical Association 152 (1953) pp. 1090-1093.
Considerable attention has thus been paid to the relationship between combat and the emotional health of military personnel, including in the prevention of post-traumatic mental stress disorder. The effects of chronic mental stress impose an enormous burden on Veterans' health services. In a study conducted on 187 veterans, referred through a Veterans Administration hospital, 100 were confirmed as meeting the DSM-III criteria for PTSD. Nineteen of the 100 veterans had made a post-service suicide attempt, and 15 more had been preoccupied with suicide since the war. Five factors were significantly related to suicide attempts: guilt about combat actions, survivor guilt, depression, anxiety, and severe PTSD. See Hendin H and Haas A P “Suicide and guilt as manifestations of PTSD in Vietnam combat veterans” Am J Psychiatry 148 (1991) 586-591.
The more dramatic aspects of wartime activities have been clearly established as precipitants of psychological mental stress. However, at present there are no practical means to continuously monitor the cardiovascular effects of mental stress in ambulant subjects. The magnitude of the mental stress burden of combat conditions is therefore unknown, as is the extent of variation in individual susceptibilities. Thus it is very difficult to predict which individuals will come to harm from repeated exposure to mental stress. Although heart rate and blood pressure monitoring can provide crude indicators of mental stress and vascular function, the latter is impractical in combat.
Due to a lack of rigorous and sensitive methods of measuring the impact of the psychological factors on the cardiovascular system, the insidious and slowly developing symptoms of mental stress often go unrecognized and the effects of mental stress are often only recognized subsequent to severe trauma or functional disruption of the patient. See Blood C G and Gaucher E D “The relationship between battle intensity and disease rate among Marine Corps infantry units” Milit Med 158 (1993) 340-4. Treatment strategies commonly involve drastic life-style changes or heavy medication; there is no other recourse given the acuteness of the disease.
In a military context, seemingly healthy military personnel may also be at considerable risk of cardiovascular events, particularly in mission-critical situations with high levels of physical and psychological mental stress. At present, the cardiovascular fitness levels sufficient to tolerate mental stress, and the adverse short- and long-term cardiovascular effects of mental stress cannot be quantified. Conventional clinical assessment of cardiovascular (CV) fitness in apparently healthy subjects, such as active duty military personnel (e.g. screening for CV risk factors, exercise mental stress testing), fails to identify individuals with occult coronary heart disease (CHD), who are at increased near-term risk of cardiovascular events. The routine use of coronary imaging technologies (such as computer tomography, CT, heart scanning) to screen for silent CHD is cost-prohibitive, particularly in relatively young subjects.
It is clear that the investigation of psycho-social impacts is vital, especially in military contexts where mental stress reactions can be widespread and acute. The present invention is adapted to (a) identifying individual-specific susceptibilities to mental stress, (b) quantifying the risk factors, and (c) promoting early identification and thus effective prevention and rehabilitation of pathologic mental stress responses. The present invention provides methods and apparatus for ambulatory monitoring of mental stress response as manifest by cooling of the skin temperature. In addition, vascular reactivity can be assessed by implementing reactive hyperemia in ambulatory individuals as implemented using a finger-mounted arterial occlusion cuff.
In one embodiment of the present invention, mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature recording is combined with real and induced mental stress situation to provide individual assessments of mental stress responses. In another embodiment, vascular reactivity is assessed during real-life activities by utilizing combined finger and palm temperature monitoring. In another embodiment, finger based cuff occlusion of the present invention implements reactive hyperemia to measure vascular reactivity by DTM and/or fingertip arterial tonometry. The device is worn in ordinary conditions, normally considered to be non-mental stressful, to establish a “normal” individual vascular reactivity profile. The individual is then subject to various mental stressful conditions to determine that individual's vascular reactivity under mental stress.
In one embodiment, the mental stress is induced by a virtual reality combat situation simulator. One example of a combat-level mental stress simulator is the Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) high-definition, use-of-force firearms simulator system developed by VirTra Systems Inc. The simulator—originally designed as a training system—creates environments mimicking real-life combat situations using advanced projection technologies. The fear of injury can also be simulated using VirTra Systems' Threat-Fire™ belt, which permits an instructor to deliver an electric “stun” to a trainee, simulating the sensation of being shot, thus realistically simulating the real mental stress associated with such a situation. The simulator affords a variety of scenarios, ranging from military “fourth-generation” combat to urban law enforcement.
Use of mental stress simulators in conjunction with ambulatory temperature recording as a monitor of an individual mental stress response confers several benefits. First, it allows standardization of mental stress conditions. Second, a series of controlled experiments with varying degrees of mental stress under repeatable conditions can be simulated, thereby facilitating precise measurements. Third, potentially significant variations in factors such as weather conditions, food intake and other conditions that could lead to increased measurement noise can be avoided. Use of IVR systems permits isolation of physiological mental stress from that of the mental stress experience due to physical exertion. Individuals who are more susceptible to mental stress can be readily identified. In a further embodiment, mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature recording is combined with ambulatory vascular response monitoring using finger cuff occlusion to stimulate reactive hyperemia to identify those individuals who react dangerously to mental stress and to quantify relative responses. In another embodiment, mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature recording and/or ambulatory vascular response monitoring is further utilized to teach control of potentially dangerous mental stress and vascular responses.
In one embodiment of the invention, ambulatory mental stress response monitors and/or vascular response monitors are combined with mental stress inducers to monitor correlations between emotional mental stress and current or future cardiovascular health, as conventionally measured in the art (e.g. using treadmills with EKG). Such correlations provide for improved screening and monitoring methods for military personnel, and facilitate early diagnosis and treatment as well as provide a metric for developing and implementing remedial or preventive treatments.
In one embodiment of the invention, ambulatory mental stress and/or vascular response monitors are combined with mental stress inducers to differentiate the subjects most susceptible to mental stress (most acutely manifested in military environments) from other mentally and physically healthy individuals. The objective data provided by the present invention enables development and implementation of remedial or preventive treatments for mental stress-susceptible individuals in mission critical situations. Remedial action taken in early stages of CVD has been clearly shown to cause disease regression and improved CV health.
In one embodiment, the ambulatory mental stress and/or vascular response monitors of the present invention are continuously worn by soldiers to enable not only the gathering of data during periods of mental stress, but also in the long term aid in better health management and deployment of medical aid. Advances in information technologies enable rapid data retrieval and electronic communications in all aspects of military operation. In particular, technologies that facilitate medical force management using telemedics and advanced diagnostics complement the existing resources of modern highly mobile and remotely deployed armed forces. The telemedic computer system will also be potentially capable of transmitting any medical prescriptions or advice to the communication systems carried by the military personnel in the field. The deployment of the MDTMD fits well with the military's evolving philosophy of how technology can aid the diagnosis of medical conditions and their effective and efficient treatment through telemedics. In one embodiment of the present invention, finger based cuff occlusion is utilized with methods of measuring vascular perfusion including DTM and fingertip arterial tonometry (for example using a device available from Itamar Medical). The device is worn in ordinary conditions, normally considered to be non-mental stressful, to establish a “normal” individual vascular reactivity profile. The individual is then subject to various mental stressful conditions to determine that individual's vascular reactivity under mental stress. In one embodiment, the mental stress is induced by a virtual reality combat situation simulator.
Use of Ambulatory Mental stress and Vascular Response Monitors in Conjunction with Risk Factor Assessment: Mental stress may manifest itself in different ways in healthy young military soldiers as compared to the older war veterans or high rank officers as well as civilians. Among sensitive individuals, the presence of inflammatory markers that promote CHD could contribute to a condition in which the slightest of the triggers due to psychological mental stress can be fatal. Military personnel and civilians alike include individuals who have subclinical atherosclerosis as measured by coronary artery calcium score (CACS) and carotid intima media thickness (CIMT). Certain of these individuals are more susceptible than others to psychological mental stress that is manifest in sympathetic nervous system vasoconstriction that is potentially life threatening. These are the individuals who are on the “fast-track” to CHD. On the other hand, the effect of mental stress on younger soldiers and civilians could be slightly different and will have a long-term effect on vascular health. Therefore, there is a need to identify those individuals that are classified as Very-High-Risk according to further criteria including for example those put forth in the SHAPE Task Force guidelines. See Naghavi M et al. “From Vulnerable Plaque to Vulnerable Patient: A Call for New Definitions and Risk Assessment Strategies Part I” Circulation 108 (2003) 1664-1672; Naghavi M et al. “From Vulnerable Plaque to Vulnerable Patient: A Call for New Definitions and Risk Assessment Strategies: Part II.” Circulation 108 (2003) 1772-1778.
Use of Ambulatory Mental stress and Vascular Response Monitors in Secondary Prevention: In one embodiment of the invention, the ambulatory mental stress and/or vascular response monitors described herein are implemented for use in heart attack patients after they are released from hospital. Certain of these individuals are more susceptible than others to detrimental effects of psychological mental stress that increase their risk of recurrent (future) adverse events. It is believed that individuals with psychological mental stress such as mental depression and anxiety have a 4-5 times increased risk of a second heart attack. The present invention provides means to identify these individuals. Thus, in one embodiment of the present invention, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed to identify dangerous mental stress responses and thus provides a mechanism to identify these susceptible individuals as prevention modality for a secondary heart attack.
In one embodiment, the software or algorithms governing such ambulatory (or non-ambulatory) monitoring device can include other useful information related to psychological status of the patient (e.g. questions from standard depression evaluation questionnaires) to complement the diagnostic value of the device. In another embodiment, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed as an objective biofeedback reporter to teach control of mental stress responses. In one embodiment, the device can have (or be accompanied or coupled with) biochemical sensors for measurement of biomarkers of mental stress (such as saliva cortisol) to complement the diagnostic accuracy of the monitoring device (system). In another embodiment, ambulatory mental stress monitoring by continuous skin temperature measurement is employed to monitor the effects of intervention strategies as an objective reporter of the success of therapies for mental stress control including by pharmacologic interventions.
This application claims priority under 35 USC §119 to U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/827,518, filed Sep. 29, 2006, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60827518 | Sep 2006 | US |