Methods and apparatus for removing solids from a membrane module

Description

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a U.S. national stage application and claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. §371 of International Application No. PCT/AU2005/001396 filed on Sep. 13, 2005, entitled METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR REMOVING SOLIDS FROM A MEMBRANE MODULE, which is based on Australian Patent Application No. 2004905292 filed on Sep. 14, 2004, entitled METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR REMOVING SOLIDS FROM A MEMBRANE MODULE, each of which is entirely incorporated herein by reference for all purposes, and to which this application claims the benefit of priority.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to membrane filtration systems and, more particularly, to a method and apparatus for improving the filtration efficiency of such systems by providing an improved cleaning system for the membranes.

BACKGROUND ART

In a membrane filtration process, the method used to physically clean membranes is of vital importance. An efficient membrane cleaning strategy can maintain a stable permeability of the membrane and reduce the frequency of chemical cleans. A commonly used method to physically clean membranes is a backwash (also called “backflush” or “backpulse”) with the permeate/filtrate or a gas. The backwash method is typically used to eject solids blocking the membrane pores and partly dislodge the cake that may have formed on the membrane surface. In a system exposed to a feed containing a high concentration of solids, the fouling occurs more quickly and more severely, in particular, where membranes are densely packed in a module.

Backwash with pressurized gas has proved a very efficient cleaning method and is now widely used in the field of microfiltration processes. The limitation to this method is the membrane pore size. Backwash of membranes with permeate has no limitations to the pore size, but the backwash efficiency is generally lower than gas backwash and the transmembrane pressure (TMP) recovery is not enough to offset the fouling rate. Further means are employed to enhance the backwash efficiency, such as dosing chemicals to the backwash permeate, or in combination with gas scrubbing.

Maruyama et al in Japanese Patent No. JP2031200 discloses a hollow fibre membrane backwashing method. The method involves the following sequence: stop filtration, air-scour membrane, fill the membrane vessel, backwash with permeate under pressurized air and drain the waste. This procedure is repeated to achieve a higher efficiency. Sunaoka et al in a U.S. Pat. No. 5,209,852 describes a process for scrubbing hollow fibre membranes in modules. This process is composed of a two-stage air scrubbing and draining to clean the membranes.

In order to minimise footprint and cost, membrane modules are typically manufactured with a high packing density of membranes, usually in the form of fibres. This increases the amount of membrane area for filtration within a module. However, the higher the packing density the more difficult it is to effectively flush solids captured during the filtration process from the membrane bundle. Therefore, improvement in the efficiency of solids removal during backwash allows either higher solids levels to be processed, or higher membrane packing densities to be used, reducing the cost of treatment.

In prior art fibre membrane systems, removal of solids is usually effected by sweeping with feedwater from one end of the module to the other and then out of the module through a side exit port. In this case, solids are first swept along the fibres to the exit end of the module, but must then cross the fibre bundle to exit the module. In many applications this requirement for the flow to change direction and pass perpendicular to the fibre bundle to exit the module can lead to accumulation of solids near the exit due to the tendency for the fibres to act like a string filter and capture or hinder the exit of solids from the module at this point.

DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION

The present invention seeks to overcome or at least ameliorate one or more of the disadvantages of the prior art or at least provide a useful alternative.

According to one aspect, the present invention provides a method of operating a membrane filtration module, said module including one or more membranes extending longitudinally between vertically spaced upper and lower headers into which the ends of the membranes are potted, the membranes having a permeable wall which is subjected to a filtration operation wherein feed containing contaminant matter is applied to one side of the membrane wall and filtrate is withdrawn from the other side of the membrane wall, at least one of said upper and/or lower headers having one or more openings therein, the method including flowing said feed, at least in part, through said one or more openings for application to said membrane wall.

According to another aspect, the present invention provides a method of cleaning a membrane filtration module, said module including one or more membranes located in a feed-containing vessel and extending longitudinally between vertically spaced upper and lower headers into which the ends of the membranes are potted, the membranes having a permeable wall which is subjected to a filtration operation wherein feed containing contaminant matter is applied to one side of the membrane wall and filtrate is withdrawn from the other side of the membrane wall, at least one of said upper and/or lower headers having one or more openings therein, the method including:

- a) performing a filtration operation wherein said feed, at least in part, is flowed through said one or more openings for application to said membrane wall;
- b) suspending the filtration operation;
- c) performing a cleaning process on the membrane wall to dislodge contaminant matter therefrom into liquid surrounding the membrane;
- d) performing a sweep of the feed-containing vessel substantially parallel to the longitudinally extending membranes to remove the liquid containing the dislodged contaminant matter, at least in part, through the openings in the header; and
- e) recommencing the filtration operation.

For further preference, the openings are provided in the lower header and filtrate is withdrawn from the upper header. Preferably, the openings may also be used to introduce gas into the module to produce bubbles for scouring the surface of the membranes during said cleaning process. The sweep may be performed concurrently with the cleaning process. Preferably, the sweep is a high velocity sweep.

The present invention provides for holes or openings in one of the module pots so that during filtration at least part of the feed liquid will also be drawn in through the openings in the bottom pot and flow into the depths of the membrane bundle, reducing shell side pressure drop and generating some crossflow over the membrane surface. The use of these holes or openings for waste flow also allows solids swept along the membranes during the backwash process to continue to flow parallel to the membranes as they exit the module. The requirement for the solids to cross over the fibre bundle to exit at a side port is substantially reduced or eliminated.

The same concept may be applied to submerged membranes operated in an open tank. In the prior art, solids are typically removed by draining the tank. As the feed containing the solids drains from the module it must change direction near the bottom to flow out of the module and drain from the tank. By providing holes or openings in the bottom of the module, solids can continue to flow substantially parallel to the fibres as they pass out of the module. This uninterrupted flow provides for more efficient removal of solid from the module and tank.

According to a further aspect, the present invention provides a method of operating a membrane filtration module, said module including one or more membranes extending vertically from an upper header into which proximal ends of the membranes are potted, the membranes having a permeable wall which is subjected to a filtration operation wherein feed containing contaminant matter is applied to one side of the membrane wall and filtrate is withdrawn from the other side of the membrane wall, the method including during said filtration operation flowing said feed, at least in part, through one or more openings in the module below said membranes for application to said membrane wall.

According to yet a further aspect, the present provides a method of cleaning a membrane filtration module, said module including one or more membranes located in a feed-containing vessel and extending vertically from an upper header into which proximal ends of the membranes are potted, the membranes having a permeable wall which is subjected to a filtration operation wherein feed containing contaminant matter is applied to one side of the membrane wall and filtrate is withdrawn from the other side of the membrane wall, the method including:

- a) performing a filtration operation wherein said feed, at least in part, is flowed through one or more openings in the module below said membranes for application to said membrane wall;
- b) suspending the filtration operation;
- c) performing a cleaning process on the membrane wall to dislodge contaminant matter therefrom into liquid surrounding the membrane;
- d) performing a sweep or drain-down of the feed-containing vessel substantially parallel to the vertically extending membranes to remove the liquid containing the dislodged contaminant matter, at least in part, through said opening or openings in the module beneath said membranes; and
- e) recommencing the filtration operation.

Apparatus for performing the above methods is also included within the scope of the present invention.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING

Embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:

FIG. 1 shows a schematic sectional view of a membrane module according to one embodiment;

FIG. 2 shows a schematic sectional view of a membrane module according to further embodiment; and

FIGS. 3
a and 3b show an enlarged schematic sectional view of the lower header of a non-pressurized filtration system during the aeration and drain-down phases, respectively.

DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

Referring to the FIG. 1, the filtration module 5 is mounted within a housing vessel 6 which contains the feed to be filtered. The filtration module 5 contains a bundle or bundles of hollow fibre membranes 7 extending between upper and lower headers 8 and 9, respectively. The lower header 9 is provided with a number of openings 10 communicating with the interior of the fibre bundle and an open-ended plenum chamber 11 having an opening 11′. An inlet/outlet port 12 is provided at the base of the module 5. Feed is supplied through ports 12, 13 and 14 under the control of valves AV5, AV1 and AV2.

Permeate/filtrate is withdrawn through chamber 15 and port 16 under control of valve AV3. A backwash may also be applied through port 16 under the control of valve AV4.

FIG. 2 shows a similar arrangement to FIG. 1, however, in this embodiment the hollow fibre membranes 7 are suspended vertically from the upper header 8 and are not potted at their lower distal ends 19. The distal ends 19 of each fibre membrane 7 are closed and filtrate withdrawn through the upper header 8.

In use, solids accumulated within the modules 5 following filtration and backwash are flushed or swept from the modules 5 through the openings 10 by opening port 12 and applying a suitable pressure to the feed within the module 5. The waste is flushed through the opening 11′ in the plenum chamber 11 and removed through open port 12.

FIGS. 3
a and 3b show an enlarged view of the lower headers 9 of a pair of modules 5 connected to a single plenum chamber 11 in a non-pressurized filtration system. The modules 5 in this embodiment are mounted in an open vessel (not shown) and the waste liquid containing solids accumulated within the modules 5 following filtration and backwash is drained through the openings 10 under force of gravity, as shown in FIG. 3b.

As best shown in FIG. 3a, port 17 connected to a gas supply manifold 18 may also be used to supply gas to openings 10 to provide scouring bubbles within the module 5 to assist cleaning of the fibre membrane surfaces.

Systems embodying the invention may provide a number of benefits including:

1. Enhanced solids removal during backwash due to sweeping action along the fibre surface rather than across multiple fibres.

2. Easier contact of feed liquid with the inside of the membrane bundle during filtration (feed liquid can be drawn into the centre of the bundle through the same holes during filtration). This also induces a form of crossflow during filtration.

3. Rack inserts containing sets of membrane modules can be lowered down closer to the bottom of the module as an open area is no longer required beneath the modules to accommodate manifolds and piping used for solids removal and feed inlet, this now takes place through the openings in the pot. The result is better void space reduction efficiency as well as less space for drainage.

4. The plenum chambers can be connected to a pipe or manifold and the backwash waste pumped out of the module rather then gravity flowed, and/or the feedwater pumped in during filtration.

It will be appreciated that further embodiments and exemplifications of the invention are possible with departing from the spirit or scope of the invention described.

Claims

1. A method of cleaning a plurality of membrane filtration modules comprising: performing a filtration operation with the plurality of filtration modules submersed in liquid in a vessel and having lower headers connected to a single open-ended plenum chamber including a as supply manifold disposed between the plurality of filtration modules and configured to direct as downward into the single open-ended plenum chamber between the plurality of filtration modules, each of the plurality of filtration modules including one or more membranes extending longitudinally between vertically spaced upper headers and the lower headers into which the ends of the membranes are potted, the lower headers having one or more openings, the single open-ended plenum chamber having an open lower end spaced from a port in the base of the vessel without any intervening structures therebetween, the membranes having permeable walls which are subjected to a filtration operation wherein the liquid is applied to one side of the membrane walls and filtrate is withdrawn from an other side of the membrane walls, and wherein the liquid is flowed through the one or more openings in the lower headers and the port in the base of the vessel;suspending the filtration operation;performing a cleaning process on the membrane walls to dislodge contaminant matter therefrom into liquid surrounding the membranes;removing the dislodged contaminant matter from the plurality of filtration modules in a direction substantially parallel to the longitudinally extending membranes, the dislodged contaminant matter flowing substantially parallel to the longitudinally extending membranes while exiting the plurality of filtration modules through the openings in the lower headers and proceeding through the open lower end of the single open-ended plenum chamber and the port in the base of the vessel, the dislodged contaminant matter not flowing perpendicular to the membranes and not exiting through side ports of the plurality of filtration modules or vessel during the removal from the plurality of filtration modules such that the membranes do not act as string filters; andrecommencing the filtration operation.
2. The method of cleaning the plurality of membrane filtration modules of claim 1, wherein filtrate is withdrawn from the upper headers.
3. The method of cleaning the plurality of membrane filtration modules of claim 2, wherein the one or more openings in the lower headers are used to introduce gas into the plurality of filtration modules and produce bubbles for scouring the surface of the membranes during the cleaning process.
4. The method of cleaning the membrane filtration modules of claim 1, wherein the feed-containing vessel is open to atmosphere.

Priority Claims (1)

Number	Date	Country	Kind
2004905292	Sep 2004	AU	national

PCT Information

Filing Document	Filing Date	Country	Kind	371c Date
PCT/AU2005/001396	9/13/2005	WO	00	3/14/2007

Publishing Document	Publishing Date	Country	Kind
WO2006/029456	3/23/2006	WO	A

US Referenced Citations (641)

Number	Name	Date	Kind
256008	Leak	Apr 1882	A
285321	Tams	Sep 1883	A
511995	Buckley	Jan 1894	A
1997074	Novotny	Apr 1935	A
2080783	Petersen	May 1937	A
2105700	Ramage	Jan 1938	A
2843038	Manspeaker	Jul 1958	A
2926086	Chenicek et al.	Feb 1960	A
3068655	Murray et al.	Dec 1962	A
3139401	Hach	Jun 1964	A
3183191	Hach	May 1965	A
3191674	Richardson	Jun 1965	A
3198636	Bouthilet	Aug 1965	A
3228876	Mahon	Jan 1966	A
3275554	Wagenaar	Sep 1966	A
3442002	Geary et al.	May 1969	A
3462362	Kollsman	Aug 1969	A
3472168	Inoue et al.	Oct 1969	A
3472765	Budd et al.	Oct 1969	A
3492698	Geary et al.	Feb 1970	A
3501798	Carraro	Mar 1970	A
3505215	Bray	Apr 1970	A
3556305	Shorr	Jan 1971	A
3563860	Henderyckx	Feb 1971	A
3591010	Pall et al.	Jul 1971	A
3625827	Wildi et al.	Dec 1971	A
3654147	Levin	Apr 1972	A
3679052	Asper	Jul 1972	A
3693406	Tobin, III	Sep 1972	A
3700561	Ziffer	Oct 1972	A
3700591	Higley	Oct 1972	A
3708071	Crowley	Jan 1973	A
3728256	Cooper	Apr 1973	A
3763055	White et al.	Oct 1973	A
3791631	Meyer	Feb 1974	A
3795609	Hill et al.	Mar 1974	A
3804258	Okuniewski et al.	Apr 1974	A
3843809	Luck	Oct 1974	A
3876738	Marinaccio et al.	Apr 1975	A
3955998	Clampitt et al.	May 1976	A
3968192	Hoffman, III et al.	Jul 1976	A
3982095	Robinson	Sep 1976	A
3992301	Shippey et al.	Nov 1976	A
3993816	Baudet et al.	Nov 1976	A
4049765	Yamazaki	Sep 1977	A
4076656	White et al.	Feb 1978	A
4082683	Galesloot	Apr 1978	A
4105556	O'Amaddio et al.	Aug 1978	A
4105731	Yamazaki	Aug 1978	A
4107043	McKinney	Aug 1978	A
4138460	Tigner	Feb 1979	A
4157899	Wheaton	Jun 1979	A
4183890	Bollinger	Jan 1980	A
4188817	Steigelmann	Feb 1980	A
4190411	Fujimoto	Feb 1980	A
4190419	Bauer	Feb 1980	A
4192750	Elfes et al.	Mar 1980	A
4193780	Cotton, Jr. et al.	Mar 1980	A
4203848	Grandine, II	May 1980	A
4204961	Cusato, Jr.	May 1980	A
4218324	Hartmann et al.	Aug 1980	A
4226921	Tsang	Oct 1980	A
4227295	Bodnar et al.	Oct 1980	A
4230583	Chiolle et al.	Oct 1980	A
4243525	Greenberg	Jan 1981	A
4247498	Castro	Jan 1981	A
4248648	Kopp	Feb 1981	A
4253936	Leysen et al.	Mar 1981	A
4271026	Chen et al.	Jun 1981	A
4272379	Pollock	Jun 1981	A
4302336	Kawaguchi et al.	Nov 1981	A
4315819	King et al.	Feb 1982	A
4323453	Zampini	Apr 1982	A
4340479	Pall	Jul 1982	A
4350592	Kronsbein	Sep 1982	A
4353802	Hara et al.	Oct 1982	A
4359359	Gerlach et al.	Nov 1982	A
4367139	Graham	Jan 1983	A
4367140	Wilson	Jan 1983	A
4369605	Opersteny et al.	Jan 1983	A
4371427	Holler et al.	Feb 1983	A
4384474	Kowalski	May 1983	A
4385150	Miyake et al.	May 1983	A
4388189	Kawaguchi et al.	Jun 1983	A
4389363	Molthop	Jun 1983	A
4405688	Lowery et al.	Sep 1983	A
4407975	Yamaguchi	Oct 1983	A
4414113	LaTerra	Nov 1983	A
4414172	Leason	Nov 1983	A
4415452	Heil et al.	Nov 1983	A
4431545	Pall et al.	Feb 1984	A
4451369	Sekino et al.	May 1984	A
4462855	Yankowsky et al.	Jul 1984	A
4467001	Coplan et al.	Aug 1984	A
4476015	Schmitt et al.	Oct 1984	A
4476112	Aversano	Oct 1984	A
4491522	Ishida et al.	Jan 1985	A
4496470	Kapiloff et al.	Jan 1985	A
4511471	Muller	Apr 1985	A
4519909	Castro	May 1985	A
4539940	Young	Sep 1985	A
4540490	Shibata et al.	Sep 1985	A
4545862	Gore et al.	Oct 1985	A
4547289	Okano et al.	Oct 1985	A
4609465	Miller	Sep 1986	A
4610789	Barch	Sep 1986	A
4614109	Hofmann	Sep 1986	A
4623460	Kuzumoto et al.	Nov 1986	A
4623670	Mutoh et al.	Nov 1986	A
4629563	Wrasidlo	Dec 1986	A
4632745	Giuffrida et al.	Dec 1986	A
4636296	Kunz	Jan 1987	A
4642182	Drori	Feb 1987	A
4647377	Miura	Mar 1987	A
4650586	Ellis, III	Mar 1987	A
4650596	Schlueter et al.	Mar 1987	A
4656865	Callan	Apr 1987	A
4660411	Reid	Apr 1987	A
4666543	Kawano	May 1987	A
4670145	Edwards	Jun 1987	A
4673507	Brown	Jun 1987	A
4687561	Kunz	Aug 1987	A
4687578	Stookey	Aug 1987	A
4688511	Gerlach et al.	Aug 1987	A
4689191	Beck et al.	Aug 1987	A
4702830	Makino et al.	Oct 1987	A
4702836	Mutoh et al.	Oct 1987	A
4702840	Degen et al.	Oct 1987	A
4707266	Degen et al.	Nov 1987	A
4708799	Gerlach et al.	Nov 1987	A
4718270	Storr	Jan 1988	A
4744240	Reichelt	May 1988	A
4749487	Lefebvre	Jun 1988	A
4756875	Tajima et al.	Jul 1988	A
4763612	Iwanami	Aug 1988	A
4767539	Ford	Aug 1988	A
4769140	van Dijk et al.	Sep 1988	A
4774132	Joffee et al.	Sep 1988	A
4775471	Nagai et al.	Oct 1988	A
4779448	Gogins	Oct 1988	A
4781831	Goldsmith	Nov 1988	A
4784771	Wathen et al.	Nov 1988	A
4793932	Ford et al.	Dec 1988	A
4797187	Davis et al.	Jan 1989	A
4797211	Ehrfeld et al.	Jan 1989	A
4800019	Bikson et al.	Jan 1989	A
4810384	Fabre	Mar 1989	A
4812235	Seleman et al.	Mar 1989	A
4816160	Ford et al.	Mar 1989	A
4824563	Iwahori et al.	Apr 1989	A
4834998	Shrikhande	May 1989	A
4839048	Reed et al.	Jun 1989	A
4840227	Schmidt	Jun 1989	A
4846970	Bertelsen et al.	Jul 1989	A
4867883	Daigger et al.	Sep 1989	A
4876006	Ohkubo et al.	Oct 1989	A
4876012	Kopp et al.	Oct 1989	A
4886601	Iwatsuka et al.	Dec 1989	A
4888115	Marinaccio et al.	Dec 1989	A
4889620	Schmit et al.	Dec 1989	A
4904426	Lundgard et al.	Feb 1990	A
4908114	Ayers	Mar 1990	A
4919815	Copa et al.	Apr 1990	A
4921610	Ford et al.	May 1990	A
4931186	Ford et al.	Jun 1990	A
4933084	Bandel et al.	Jun 1990	A
4935143	Kopp et al.	Jun 1990	A
4952317	Culkin	Aug 1990	A
4963304	Im et al.	Oct 1990	A
4966699	Sasaki et al.	Oct 1990	A
4968430	Hildenbrand et al.	Nov 1990	A
4968733	Muller et al.	Nov 1990	A
4969997	Kluver et al.	Nov 1990	A
4980066	Slegers	Dec 1990	A
4988444	Applegate et al.	Jan 1991	A
4999038	Lundberg	Mar 1991	A
5002666	Matsumoto et al.	Mar 1991	A
5005430	Kibler et al.	Apr 1991	A
5015275	Beck et al.	May 1991	A
5024762	Ford et al.	Jun 1991	A
5034125	Karbachsch et al.	Jul 1991	A
5043113	Kafchinski et al.	Aug 1991	A
5059317	Marius et al.	Oct 1991	A
5066375	Parsi et al.	Nov 1991	A
5066401	Muller et al.	Nov 1991	A
5066402	Anselme et al.	Nov 1991	A
5069065	Sprunt et al.	Dec 1991	A
5069353	Espenan	Dec 1991	A
5075044	Augem	Dec 1991	A
5075065	Effenberger et al.	Dec 1991	A
5076925	Roesink et al.	Dec 1991	A
5079272	Allegrezza, Jr. et al.	Jan 1992	A
5080770	Culkin	Jan 1992	A
5094750	Kopp et al.	Mar 1992	A
5094867	Detering et al.	Mar 1992	A
5098567	Nishiguchi	Mar 1992	A
5102550	Pizzino et al.	Apr 1992	A
5104535	Cote et al.	Apr 1992	A
5104546	Filson et al.	Apr 1992	A
H1045	Wilson	May 1992	H
5135663	Newberth, III et al.	Aug 1992	A
5137631	Eckman et al.	Aug 1992	A
5138870	Lyssy	Aug 1992	A
5147553	Waite	Sep 1992	A
5151191	Sunaoka et al.	Sep 1992	A
5151193	Grobe et al.	Sep 1992	A
5156738	Maxson	Oct 1992	A
5158721	Allegrezza, Jr. et al.	Oct 1992	A
5169528	Karbachsch et al.	Dec 1992	A
5169530	Schucker et al.	Dec 1992	A
5180407	DeMarco	Jan 1993	A
5182019	Cote et al.	Jan 1993	A
5186821	Murphy	Feb 1993	A
5192442	Piccirillo et al.	Mar 1993	A
5192456	Ishida et al.	Mar 1993	A
5192478	Caskey	Mar 1993	A
5194149	Selbie et al.	Mar 1993	A
5198116	Comstock et al.	Mar 1993	A
5198162	Park et al.	Mar 1993	A
5203405	Gentry et al.	Apr 1993	A
5209852	Sunaoka et al.	May 1993	A
5211823	Giuffrida et al.	May 1993	A
5221478	Dhingra et al.	Jun 1993	A
5227063	Langerak et al.	Jul 1993	A
5248424	Cote et al.	Sep 1993	A
5262054	Wheeler	Nov 1993	A
5269919	von Medlin	Dec 1993	A
5271830	Faivre et al.	Dec 1993	A
5275766	Gadkaree et al.	Jan 1994	A
5286324	Kawai et al.	Feb 1994	A
5290451	Koster et al.	Mar 1994	A
5290457	Karbachsch et al.	Mar 1994	A
5297420	Gilliland et al.	Mar 1994	A
5316671	Murphy	May 1994	A
5320760	Freund et al.	Jun 1994	A
5353630	Soda et al.	Oct 1994	A
5354470	Seita et al.	Oct 1994	A
5358732	Seifter et al.	Oct 1994	A
5361625	Ylvisaker	Nov 1994	A
5364527	Zimmermann et al.	Nov 1994	A
5364529	Morin et al.	Nov 1994	A
5374353	Murphy	Dec 1994	A
5389260	Hemp et al.	Feb 1995	A
5393433	Espenan et al.	Feb 1995	A
5396019	Sartori et al.	Mar 1995	A
5401401	Hickok et al.	Mar 1995	A
5401405	McDougald	Mar 1995	A
5403479	Smith et al.	Apr 1995	A
5405528	Selbie et al.	Apr 1995	A
5411663	Johnson	May 1995	A
5417101	Weich	May 1995	A
5419816	Sampson et al.	May 1995	A
5425415	Master et al.	Jun 1995	A
5451317	Ishida et al.	Sep 1995	A
5458779	Odegaard	Oct 1995	A
5468397	Barboza et al.	Nov 1995	A
5470469	Eckman	Nov 1995	A
5477731	Mouton	Dec 1995	A
5479590	Lin	Dec 1995	A
5480553	Yamamori et al.	Jan 1996	A
5482625	Shimizu et al.	Jan 1996	A
5484528	Yagi et al.	Jan 1996	A
5490939	Gerigk et al.	Feb 1996	A
5491023	Tsai et al.	Feb 1996	A
5501798	Al-Samadi et al.	Mar 1996	A
5525220	Yagi et al.	Jun 1996	A
5531848	Brinda et al.	Jul 1996	A
5531900	Raghavan et al.	Jul 1996	A
5543002	Brinda et al.	Aug 1996	A
5552047	Oshida et al.	Sep 1996	A
5554283	Brinda et al.	Sep 1996	A
5556591	Jallerat et al.	Sep 1996	A
5575963	Soffer et al.	Nov 1996	A
5597732	Bryan-Brown	Jan 1997	A
5607593	Cote et al.	Mar 1997	A
5626755	Keyser et al.	May 1997	A
5629084	Moya	May 1997	A
5633163	Cameron	May 1997	A
5639373	Mahendran et al.	Jun 1997	A
5643455	Kopp et al.	Jul 1997	A
5647988	Kawanishi et al.	Jul 1997	A
5670053	Collentro et al.	Sep 1997	A
5677360	Yamamori et al.	Oct 1997	A
5688460	Ruschke	Nov 1997	A
5690830	Ohtani et al.	Nov 1997	A
5733456	Okey et al.	Mar 1998	A
5744037	Fujimura et al.	Apr 1998	A
5747605	Breant et al.	May 1998	A
5766479	Collentro et al.	Jun 1998	A
D396046	Scheel et al.	Jul 1998	S
5783083	Henshaw et al.	Jul 1998	A
D396726	Sadr et al.	Aug 1998	S
5814234	Bower et al.	Sep 1998	A
D400890	Gambardella	Nov 1998	S
5843069	Butler et al.	Dec 1998	A
5846424	Khudenko	Dec 1998	A
5846425	Whiteman	Dec 1998	A
5871823	Anders et al.	Feb 1999	A
5888401	Nguyen	Mar 1999	A
5895521	Otsuka et al.	Apr 1999	A
5895570	Liang	Apr 1999	A
5906739	Osterland et al.	May 1999	A
5906742	Wang et al.	May 1999	A
5910250	Mahendran et al.	Jun 1999	A
5914039	Mahendran et al.	Jun 1999	A
5918264	Drummond et al.	Jun 1999	A
5942113	Morimura	Aug 1999	A
5944997	Pedersen et al.	Aug 1999	A
5951878	Astrom	Sep 1999	A
5958243	Lawrence et al.	Sep 1999	A
5961830	Barnett	Oct 1999	A
5968357	Doelle et al.	Oct 1999	A
5988400	Karachevtcev et al.	Nov 1999	A
5989428	Goronszy	Nov 1999	A
5997745	Tonelli et al.	Dec 1999	A
6001254	Espenan et al.	Dec 1999	A
6007712	Tanaka et al.	Dec 1999	A
6017451	Kopf	Jan 2000	A
6024872	Mahendran et al.	Feb 2000	A
6036030	Stone et al.	Mar 2000	A
6039872	Wu et al.	Mar 2000	A
6042677	Mahendran et al.	Mar 2000	A
6045698	Cote et al.	Apr 2000	A
6045899	Wang et al.	Apr 2000	A
6048454	Jenkins	Apr 2000	A
6048455	Janik	Apr 2000	A
6066401	Stilburn	May 2000	A
6071404	Tsui	Jun 2000	A
6074718	Puglia et al.	Jun 2000	A
6077435	Beck et al.	Jun 2000	A
6083393	Wu et al.	Jul 2000	A
6096213	Radovanovic et al.	Aug 2000	A
6113782	Leonard	Sep 2000	A
6120688	Daly et al.	Sep 2000	A
6126819	Heine et al.	Oct 2000	A
6146747	Wang et al.	Nov 2000	A
6149817	Peterson et al.	Nov 2000	A
6156200	Zha et al.	Dec 2000	A
6159373	Beck et al.	Dec 2000	A
6162020	Kondo	Dec 2000	A
6193890	Pedersen et al.	Feb 2001	B1
6202475	Selbie et al.	Mar 2001	B1
6214231	Cote et al.	Apr 2001	B1
6214232	Baurmeister et al.	Apr 2001	B1
6221247	Nemser et al.	Apr 2001	B1
6245239	Cote et al.	Jun 2001	B1
6254773	Biltoft	Jul 2001	B1
6264839	Mohr et al.	Jul 2001	B1
6277512	Hamrock et al.	Aug 2001	B1
6280626	Miyashita et al.	Aug 2001	B1
6284135	Ookata	Sep 2001	B1
6290756	Macheras et al.	Sep 2001	B1
6294039	Mahendran et al.	Sep 2001	B1
6299773	Takamura et al.	Oct 2001	B1
6303026	Lindbo	Oct 2001	B1
6303035	Cote et al.	Oct 2001	B1
6315895	Summerton et al.	Nov 2001	B1
6319411	Cote	Nov 2001	B1
6322703	Taniguchi et al.	Nov 2001	B1
6324898	Cote et al.	Dec 2001	B1
6325928	Pedersen et al.	Dec 2001	B1
6325938	Miyashita et al.	Dec 2001	B1
6331248	Taniguchi et al.	Dec 2001	B1
6337018	Mickols	Jan 2002	B1
RE37549	Mahendran et al.	Feb 2002	E
6349835	Saux et al.	Feb 2002	B1
6354444	Mahendran et al.	Mar 2002	B1
6361695	Husain et al.	Mar 2002	B1
6368819	Gaddy et al.	Apr 2002	B1
6372138	Cho et al.	Apr 2002	B1
6375848	Cote et al.	Apr 2002	B1
6383369	Elston	May 2002	B2
6387189	Groschl et al.	May 2002	B1
6402955	Ookata	Jun 2002	B2
6406629	Husain et al.	Jun 2002	B1
6423214	Lindbo	Jul 2002	B1
6423784	Hamrock et al.	Jul 2002	B1
6432310	Andou et al.	Aug 2002	B1
6440303	Spriegel	Aug 2002	B2
D462699	Johnson et al.	Sep 2002	S
6444124	Onyeche et al.	Sep 2002	B1
6468430	Kimura et al.	Oct 2002	B1
6471869	Yanou et al.	Oct 2002	B1
6485645	Husain et al.	Nov 2002	B1
6495041	Taniguchi et al.	Dec 2002	B2
6517723	Daigger et al.	Feb 2003	B1
6524481	Zha et al.	Feb 2003	B2
6524733	Nonobe	Feb 2003	B1
6550747	Rabie et al.	Apr 2003	B2
6555005	Zha et al.	Apr 2003	B1
6562237	Olaopa	May 2003	B1
6576136	De Moel et al.	Jun 2003	B1
6592762	Smith	Jul 2003	B2
D478913	Johnson et al.	Aug 2003	S
6613222	Mikkelson et al.	Sep 2003	B2
6620319	Behmann et al.	Sep 2003	B2
6623643	Chisholm et al.	Sep 2003	B2
6627082	Del Vecchio et al.	Sep 2003	B2
6632358	Suga et al.	Oct 2003	B1
6635179	Summerton et al.	Oct 2003	B1
6641733	Zha et al.	Nov 2003	B2
6645374	Cote et al.	Nov 2003	B2
6656356	Gungerich et al.	Dec 2003	B2
6682652	Mahendran et al.	Jan 2004	B2
6685832	Mahendran et al.	Feb 2004	B2
6696465	Dellaria et al.	Feb 2004	B2
6702561	Stillig et al.	Mar 2004	B2
6706185	Goel et al.	Mar 2004	B2
6706189	Rabie et al.	Mar 2004	B2
6708957	Cote et al.	Mar 2004	B2
6712970	Trivedi	Mar 2004	B1
6721529	Chen et al.	Apr 2004	B2
6723242	Ohkata et al.	Apr 2004	B1
6723758	Stone et al.	Apr 2004	B2
6727305	Pavez Aranguiz	Apr 2004	B1
6743362	Porteous et al.	Jun 2004	B1
6755970	Knappe et al.	Jun 2004	B1
6758972	Vriens et al.	Jul 2004	B2
6761826	Bender	Jul 2004	B2
6770202	Kidd et al.	Aug 2004	B1
6780466	Grangeon et al.	Aug 2004	B2
6783008	Zha et al.	Aug 2004	B2
6790347	Jeong et al.	Sep 2004	B2
6790912	Blong	Sep 2004	B2
6805806	Arnaud	Oct 2004	B2
6808629	Wouters-Wasiak et al.	Oct 2004	B2
6811696	Wang et al.	Nov 2004	B2
6814861	Husain et al.	Nov 2004	B2
6821420	Zha et al.	Nov 2004	B2
6830782	Kanazawa	Dec 2004	B2
6840251	Gill et al.	Jan 2005	B2
6841070	Zha et al.	Jan 2005	B2
6861466	Dadalas et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6863816	Austin et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6863817	Liu et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6863818	Daigger et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6863823	Cote	Mar 2005	B2
6869534	McDowell et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6872305	Johnson et al.	Mar 2005	B2
6881343	Rabie et al.	Apr 2005	B2
6884350	Muller	Apr 2005	B2
6884375	Wang et al.	Apr 2005	B2
6890435	Ji et al.	May 2005	B2
6890645	Disse et al.	May 2005	B2
6893568	Janson et al.	May 2005	B1
6899812	Cote et al.	May 2005	B2
6936085	DeMarco	Aug 2005	B2
6946073	Daigger et al.	Sep 2005	B2
6952258	Ebert et al.	Oct 2005	B2
6955762	Gallagher et al.	Oct 2005	B2
6962258	Zha et al.	Nov 2005	B2
6964741	Mahendran et al.	Nov 2005	B2
6969465	Zha et al.	Nov 2005	B2
6974554	Cox et al.	Dec 2005	B2
6994867	Hossainy et al.	Feb 2006	B1
7005100	Lowell	Feb 2006	B2
7014763	Johnson et al.	Mar 2006	B2
7018530	Pollock	Mar 2006	B2
7018533	Johnson et al.	Mar 2006	B2
7022233	Chen	Apr 2006	B2
7041728	Zipplies et al.	May 2006	B2
7052610	Janson et al.	May 2006	B2
7083733	Freydina et al.	Aug 2006	B2
7087173	Cote et al.	Aug 2006	B2
7122121	Ji	Oct 2006	B1
7147777	Porteous	Dec 2006	B1
7147778	DiMassimo et al.	Dec 2006	B1
7160455	Taniguchi et al.	Jan 2007	B2
7160463	Beck et al.	Jan 2007	B2
7160464	Lee et al.	Jan 2007	B2
7172699	Trivedi et al.	Feb 2007	B1
7172701	Gaid et al.	Feb 2007	B2
7186344	Hughes	Mar 2007	B2
7208091	Pind et al.	Apr 2007	B2
7223340	Zha et al.	May 2007	B2
7226541	Muller et al.	Jun 2007	B2
7247238	Mullette et al.	Jul 2007	B2
7264716	Johnson et al.	Sep 2007	B2
7279100	Devine	Oct 2007	B2
7279215	Hester et al.	Oct 2007	B2
7300022	Muller	Nov 2007	B2
7314563	Cho et al.	Jan 2008	B2
7329344	Jordan et al.	Feb 2008	B2
7344645	Beck et al.	Mar 2008	B2
7361274	Lazaredes	Apr 2008	B2
7378024	Bartels et al.	May 2008	B2
7387723	Jordan	Jun 2008	B2
7404896	Muller	Jul 2008	B2
7410584	Devine	Aug 2008	B2
7455765	Elefritz et al.	Nov 2008	B2
7481933	Barnes	Jan 2009	B2
7507274	Tonkovich et al.	Mar 2009	B2
7510655	Barnes	Mar 2009	B2
7531042	Murkute et al.	May 2009	B2
7563363	Kuzma	Jul 2009	B2
7591950	Zha et al.	Sep 2009	B2
7632439	Mullette et al.	Dec 2009	B2
7648634	Probst	Jan 2010	B2
7662212	Mullette et al.	Feb 2010	B2
7708887	Johnson et al.	May 2010	B2
7713413	Barnes	May 2010	B2
7718057	Jordan et al.	May 2010	B2
7718065	Jordan	May 2010	B2
7722769	Jordan et al.	May 2010	B2
7761826	Thanvantri et al.	Jul 2010	B1
7819956	Muller	Oct 2010	B2
7850851	Zha et al.	Dec 2010	B2
7862719	McMahon et al.	Jan 2011	B2
7931463	Cox et al.	Apr 2011	B2
7938966	Johnson	May 2011	B2
20010047962	Zha et al.	Dec 2001	A1
20010052494	Cote et al.	Dec 2001	A1
20020027111	Ando et al.	Mar 2002	A1
20020070157	Yamada	Jun 2002	A1
20020117444	Mikkelson et al.	Aug 2002	A1
20020148767	Johnson et al.	Oct 2002	A1
20020153313	Cote	Oct 2002	A1
20020185435	Husain et al.	Dec 2002	A1
20020189999	Espenan et al.	Dec 2002	A1
20020195390	Zha et al.	Dec 2002	A1
20030038080	Vriens et al.	Feb 2003	A1
20030042199	Smith	Mar 2003	A1
20030052055	Akamatsu et al.	Mar 2003	A1
20030056919	Beck	Mar 2003	A1
20030057155	Husain et al.	Mar 2003	A1
20030075495	Dannstrom et al.	Apr 2003	A1
20030121855	Kopp	Jul 2003	A1
20030127388	Ando et al.	Jul 2003	A1
20030146153	Cote et al.	Aug 2003	A1
20030150807	Bartels et al.	Aug 2003	A1
20030159988	Daigger et al.	Aug 2003	A1
20030178365	Zha et al.	Sep 2003	A1
20030196955	Hughes	Oct 2003	A1
20030226797	Phelps	Dec 2003	A1
20030234221	Johnson et al.	Dec 2003	A1
20040007523	Gabon et al.	Jan 2004	A1
20040007525	Rabie et al.	Jan 2004	A1
20040035770	Edwards et al.	Feb 2004	A1
20040045893	Watanabe et al.	Mar 2004	A1
20040050791	Herczeg	Mar 2004	A1
20040055974	Del Vecchio et al.	Mar 2004	A1
20040084369	Zha et al.	May 2004	A1
20040108268	Liu et al.	Jun 2004	A1
20040112831	Rabie et al.	Jun 2004	A1
20040139992	Murkute et al.	Jul 2004	A1
20040145076	Zha et al.	Jul 2004	A1
20040149655	Petrucco et al.	Aug 2004	A1
20040154671	Martins et al.	Aug 2004	A1
20040168978	Gray	Sep 2004	A1
20040168979	Zha et al.	Sep 2004	A1
20040173525	Hunniford et al.	Sep 2004	A1
20040178154	Zha et al.	Sep 2004	A1
20040188341	Zha et al.	Sep 2004	A1
20040211726	Baig et al.	Oct 2004	A1
20040217053	Zha et al.	Nov 2004	A1
20040222158	Husain et al.	Nov 2004	A1
20040232076	Zha et al.	Nov 2004	A1
20040238442	Johnson et al.	Dec 2004	A1
20040245174	Takayama et al.	Dec 2004	A1
20050006308	Cote et al.	Jan 2005	A1
20050023219	Kirker et al.	Feb 2005	A1
20050029185	Muller	Feb 2005	A1
20050029186	Muller	Feb 2005	A1
20050032982	Muller	Feb 2005	A1
20050045557	Daigger et al.	Mar 2005	A1
20050053878	Bruun et al.	Mar 2005	A1
20050061725	Liu et al.	Mar 2005	A1
20050077227	Kirker et al.	Apr 2005	A1
20050098494	Mullette et al.	May 2005	A1
20050103722	Freydina et al.	May 2005	A1
20050109692	Zha et al.	May 2005	A1
20050115880	Pollock	Jun 2005	A1
20050115899	Liu et al.	Jun 2005	A1
20050121389	Janson et al.	Jun 2005	A1
20050126963	Phagoo et al.	Jun 2005	A1
20050139538	Lazaredes	Jun 2005	A1
20050184008	Schacht et al.	Aug 2005	A1
20050194305	Vido et al.	Sep 2005	A1
20050194310	Yamamoto et al.	Sep 2005	A1
20050194315	Adams et al.	Sep 2005	A1
20050258098	Vincent et al.	Nov 2005	A1
20060000775	Zha et al.	Jan 2006	A1
20060021929	Mannheim et al.	Feb 2006	A1
20060065596	Kent et al.	Mar 2006	A1
20060081533	Khudenko	Apr 2006	A1
20060131234	Zha et al.	Jun 2006	A1
20060201876	Jordan	Sep 2006	A1
20060201879	Den Boestert et al.	Sep 2006	A1
20060249448	Fujishima et al.	Nov 2006	A1
20060249449	Nakhla et al.	Nov 2006	A1
20060261007	Zha et al.	Nov 2006	A1
20060273007	Zha et al.	Dec 2006	A1
20060273038	Syed et al.	Dec 2006	A1
20070007205	Johnson et al.	Jan 2007	A1
20070007207	Mahendran et al.	Jan 2007	A1
20070007214	Zha et al.	Jan 2007	A1
20070039888	Ginzburg et al.	Feb 2007	A1
20070045183	Murphy	Mar 2007	A1
20070051679	Adams et al.	Mar 2007	A1
20070056904	Hogt et al.	Mar 2007	A1
20070056905	Beck et al.	Mar 2007	A1
20070075017	Kuzma	Apr 2007	A1
20070075021	Johnson	Apr 2007	A1
20070084791	Jordan et al.	Apr 2007	A1
20070084795	Jordan	Apr 2007	A1
20070108125	Cho et al.	May 2007	A1
20070131614	Knappe et al.	Jun 2007	A1
20070138090	Jordan et al.	Jun 2007	A1
20070170112	Elefritz et al.	Jul 2007	A1
20070181496	Zuback	Aug 2007	A1
20070227973	Zha et al.	Oct 2007	A1
20080093297	Gock et al.	Apr 2008	A1
20080156745	Zha et al.	Jul 2008	A1
20080179249	Beck et al.	Jul 2008	A1
20080190846	Cox et al.	Aug 2008	A1
20080203017	Zha et al.	Aug 2008	A1
20080257822	Johnson	Oct 2008	A1
20080277340	Hong et al.	Nov 2008	A1
20090001018	Zha et al.	Jan 2009	A1
20090194477	Hashimoto	Aug 2009	A1
20090223895	Zha et al.	Sep 2009	A1
20090255873	Biltoft et al.	Oct 2009	A1
20100000941	Muller	Jan 2010	A1
20100012585	Zha et al.	Jan 2010	A1
20100025320	Johnson	Feb 2010	A1
20100051545	Johnson et al.	Mar 2010	A1
20100170847	Zha et al.	Jul 2010	A1
20100200503	Zha et al.	Aug 2010	A1
20100300968	Liu et al.	Dec 2010	A1
20100326906	Barnes	Dec 2010	A1
20110023913	Fulling	Feb 2011	A1
20110049047	Cumin et al.	Mar 2011	A1
20110056522	Zauner et al.	Mar 2011	A1
20110100907	Zha et al.	May 2011	A1
20110114557	Johnson et al.	May 2011	A2
20110127209	Rogers et al.	Jun 2011	A1
20110132826	Muller et al.	Jun 2011	A1
20110139715	Zha et al.	Jun 2011	A1
20110192783	Cox et al.	Aug 2011	A1
20110198283	Zha et al.	Aug 2011	A1
20120091602	Cumin et al.	Apr 2012	A1

Foreign Referenced Citations (424)

Number	Date	Country
3440084	Apr 1985	AU
5584786	Sep 1986	AU
7706687	Feb 1988	AU
762091	Jun 2003	AU
2004289373	May 2005	AU
2460207	Mar 2003	CA
2531764	Mar 2005	CA
86104888	Feb 1988	CN
1050770	Jan 1995	CN
2204898	Aug 1995	CN
2236049	Sep 1996	CN
1159769	Sep 1997	CN
1244814	Feb 2000	CN
1249698	Apr 2000	CN
1265636	Sep 2000	CN
1319032	Oct 2001	CN
1468140	Jan 2004	CN
1541757	Nov 2004	CN
3904544	Aug 1990	DE
4117281	Jan 1992	DE
4113420	Oct 1992	DE
4117422	Nov 1992	DE
4326603	Feb 1995	DE
19503060	Aug 1996	DE
29804927	Jun 1998	DE
29906389	Jun 1999	DE
10045227	Feb 2002	DE
10209170	Aug 2003	DE
202004012693	Oct 2004	DE
012557	Feb 1983	EP
126714	Nov 1984	EP
050447	Oct 1985	EP
194735	Sep 1986	EP
250337	Dec 1987	EP
327025	Aug 1989	EP
344633	Dec 1989	EP
090383	May 1990	EP
407900	Jan 1991	EP
463627	Jan 1992	EP
0464321	Jan 1992	EP
492942	Jul 1992	EP
518250	Dec 1992	EP
547575	Jun 1993	EP
280052	Jul 1994	EP
395133	Feb 1995	EP
662341	Jul 1995	EP
492446	Nov 1995	EP
430082	Jun 1996	EP
734758	Oct 1996	EP
763758	Mar 1997	EP
824956	Feb 1998	EP
848194	Jun 1998	EP
855214	Jul 1998	EP
627255	Jan 1999	EP
911073	Apr 1999	EP
920904	Jun 1999	EP
0937494	Aug 1999	EP
1034835	Sep 2000	EP
1052012	Nov 2000	EP
1156015	Nov 2001	EP
1300186	Apr 2003	EP
1349644	Oct 2003	EP
1350555	Oct 2003	EP
1236503	Aug 2004	EP
1445240	Aug 2004	EP
1466658	Oct 2004	EP
1659171	May 2006	EP
1420874	Jan 2011	EP
2620712	Mar 1989	FR
2674448	Oct 1992	FR
2699424	Jun 1994	FR
2762834	Nov 1998	FR
702911	Jan 1954	GB
996195	Jun 1965	GB
2253572	Sep 1992	GB
52-078677	Jul 1977	JP
53-5077	Jan 1978	JP
53108882	Sep 1978	JP
54162684	Dec 1979	JP
55099703	Jul 1980	JP
55129107	Oct 1980	JP
55129155	Oct 1980	JP
56021604	Feb 1981	JP
56118701	Sep 1981	JP
56121685	Sep 1981	JP
57190697	Nov 1982	JP
58088007	May 1983	JP
60019002	Jan 1985	JP
60-206412	Oct 1985	JP
60260628	Dec 1985	JP
61097005	May 1986	JP
61097006	May 1986	JP
61107905	May 1986	JP
61167406	Jul 1986	JP
61167407	Jul 1986	JP
61171504	Aug 1986	JP
61192309	Aug 1986	JP
61222510	Oct 1986	JP
61242607	Oct 1986	JP
61249505	Nov 1986	JP
61257203	Nov 1986	JP
61263605	Nov 1986	JP
61291007	Dec 1986	JP
61293504	Dec 1986	JP
62004408	Jan 1987	JP
62068828	Mar 1987	JP
62114609	May 1987	JP
62140607	Jun 1987	JP
62144708	Jun 1987	JP
62163708	Jul 1987	JP
62179540	Aug 1987	JP
62237908	Oct 1987	JP
62250908	Oct 1987	JP
62187606	Nov 1987	JP
62262710	Nov 1987	JP
63-93307	Apr 1988	JP
63097634	Apr 1988	JP
63099246	Apr 1988	JP
63143905	Jun 1988	JP
63-1602	Jul 1988	JP
63171607	Jul 1988	JP
63180254	Jul 1988	JP
S63-38884	Oct 1988	JP
64-075542	Mar 1989	JP
1-501046	Apr 1989	JP
1111494	Apr 1989	JP
01151906	Jun 1989	JP
01-307409	Dec 1989	JP
02-017925	Jan 1990	JP
02017924	Jan 1990	JP
02026625	Jan 1990	JP
2031200	Feb 1990	JP
02040296	Feb 1990	JP
02107318	Apr 1990	JP
02126922	May 1990	JP
02144132	Jun 1990	JP
02164423	Jun 1990	JP
02174918	Jul 1990	JP
02241523	Sep 1990	JP
02277528	Nov 1990	JP
02284035	Nov 1990	JP
03018373	Jan 1991	JP
03028797	Feb 1991	JP
03-086529	Apr 1991	JP
03110445	May 1991	JP
04108518	Apr 1992	JP
04110023	Apr 1992	JP
4-190889	Jul 1992	JP
04187224	Jul 1992	JP
4-256425	Sep 1992	JP
04250898	Sep 1992	JP
04256424	Sep 1992	JP
04265128	Sep 1992	JP
04293527	Oct 1992	JP
04310223	Nov 1992	JP
04317793	Nov 1992	JP
04334530	Nov 1992	JP
04348252	Dec 1992	JP
05023557	Feb 1993	JP
05096136	Apr 1993	JP
05137977	Jun 1993	JP
05157654	Jun 1993	JP
05161831	Jun 1993	JP
05184884	Jul 1993	JP
05279447	Oct 1993	JP
05285348	Nov 1993	JP
05305221	Nov 1993	JP
06-027215	Feb 1994	JP
06071120	Mar 1994	JP
06114240	Apr 1994	JP
06170364	Jun 1994	JP
06-190250	Jul 1994	JP
06-238273	Aug 1994	JP
06218237	Aug 1994	JP
06-292820	Oct 1994	JP
06277469	Oct 1994	JP
06285496	Oct 1994	JP
06343837	Dec 1994	JP
07000770	Jan 1995	JP
07024272	Jan 1995	JP
07047247	Feb 1995	JP
07068139	Mar 1995	JP
07136470	May 1995	JP
07136471	May 1995	JP
07155564	Jun 1995	JP
07155758	Jun 1995	JP
7-39921	Jul 1995	JP
07178323	Jul 1995	JP
07185268	Jul 1995	JP
07185270	Jul 1995	JP
07185271	Jul 1995	JP
07185272	Jul 1995	JP
07-204635	Aug 1995	JP
07236819	Sep 1995	JP
07-256253	Oct 1995	JP
07251043	Oct 1995	JP
07275665	Oct 1995	JP
07289860	Nov 1995	JP
07303895	Nov 1995	JP
07313973	Dec 1995	JP
08010585	Jan 1996	JP
8039089	Feb 1996	JP
08-197053	Aug 1996	JP
08323161	Dec 1996	JP
08332357	Dec 1996	JP
09000890	Jan 1997	JP
09 038470	Feb 1997	JP
09038648	Feb 1997	JP
09-075689	Mar 1997	JP
09072993	Mar 1997	JP
09099227	Apr 1997	JP
09103655	Apr 1997	JP
9103661	Apr 1997	JP
9117647	May 1997	JP
9138298	May 1997	JP
09141063	Jun 1997	JP
09155345	Jun 1997	JP
09187628	Jul 1997	JP
09192458	Jul 1997	JP
09220569	Aug 1997	JP
09271641	Oct 1997	JP
09-313902	Dec 1997	JP
09324067	Dec 1997	JP
10-015365	Jan 1998	JP
10024222	Jan 1998	JP
10033955	Feb 1998	JP
10048466	Feb 1998	JP
10 076144	Mar 1998	JP
10066972	Mar 1998	JP
10076264	Mar 1998	JP
10-085566	Apr 1998	JP
10085562	Apr 1998	JP
10085565	Apr 1998	JP
10156149	Jun 1998	JP
10180048	Jul 1998	JP
10225685	Aug 1998	JP
10-249171	Sep 1998	JP
10235168	Sep 1998	JP
10286441	Oct 1998	JP
10328538	Dec 1998	JP
11005023	Jan 1999	JP
11-031025	Feb 1999	JP
11028339	Feb 1999	JP
11028467	Feb 1999	JP
11033365	Feb 1999	JP
11033367	Feb 1999	JP
11076769	Mar 1999	JP
11076770	Mar 1999	JP
11090189	Apr 1999	JP
11156166	Jun 1999	JP
11156360	Jun 1999	JP
11165200	Jun 1999	JP
11-179171	Jul 1999	JP
11-309351	Nov 1999	JP
11300177	Nov 1999	JP
11302438	Nov 1999	JP
11319501	Nov 1999	JP
11319507	Nov 1999	JP
11333265	Dec 1999	JP
2000000439	Jan 2000	JP
2000-51670	Feb 2000	JP
2000051669	Feb 2000	JP
2000061466	Feb 2000	JP
200079390	Mar 2000	JP
2000070684	Mar 2000	JP
2000-093758	Apr 2000	JP
2000-157845	Jun 2000	JP
2000157850	Jun 2000	JP
2000185220	Jul 2000	JP
2000189958	Jul 2000	JP
2000233020	Aug 2000	JP
2000237548	Sep 2000	JP
2000300968	Oct 2000	JP
2000317276	Nov 2000	JP
2000-334276	Dec 2000	JP
2000342932	Dec 2000	JP
2001009246	Jan 2001	JP
2001070967	Mar 2001	JP
2001079366	Mar 2001	JP
2001079367	Mar 2001	JP
2001104760	Apr 2001	JP
2001120963	May 2001	JP
2001-510396	Jul 2001	JP
2001179059	Jul 2001	JP
2001179060	Jul 2001	JP
2001190937	Jul 2001	JP
2001190938	Jul 2001	JP
2001205055	Jul 2001	JP
2001232160	Aug 2001	JP
2001-269546	Oct 2001	JP
2002011472	Jan 2002	JP
2002143849	May 2002	JP
2002177746	Jun 2002	JP
3302992	Jul 2002	JP
2002-527229	Aug 2002	JP
2002525197	Aug 2002	JP
2002263407	Sep 2002	JP
2002-336663	Nov 2002	JP
2003024751	Jan 2003	JP
2003-053157	Feb 2003	JP
2003047830	Feb 2003	JP
2003053160	Feb 2003	JP
200371254	Mar 2003	JP
2003062436	Mar 2003	JP
2003135935	May 2003	JP
2003190976	Jul 2003	JP
2003-265597	Sep 2003	JP
2003-275548	Sep 2003	JP
2003266072	Sep 2003	JP
2003275759	Sep 2003	JP
2003340250	Dec 2003	JP
2004-008981	Jan 2004	JP
2004073950	Mar 2004	JP
2004-230287	Aug 2004	JP
2004216263	Aug 2004	JP
2004230280	Aug 2004	JP
2004249168	Sep 2004	JP
2004-322100	Nov 2004	JP
2004-536710	Dec 2004	JP
2004337730	Dec 2004	JP
2005-502467	Jan 2005	JP
2005-087887	Apr 2005	JP
2005144291	Jun 2005	JP
2005154551	Jun 2005	JP
2005279447	Oct 2005	JP
2006-116495	May 2006	JP
2007-547083	Aug 2010	JP
4833353	Dec 2011	JP
20-0232145	Jul 2001	KP
1020020067227	Aug 2002	KR
20-0295350	Nov 2002	KR
2002-0090967	Dec 2002	KR
2003-033812	May 2003	KR
2003-060625	Jul 2003	KR
2005-063478	Jun 2005	KR
1006390	Dec 1998	NL
1020491	Oct 2003	NL
1021197	Oct 2003	NL
20053769	Feb 2006	NO
510394	May 2003	NZ
537874	Feb 2007	NZ
347343	Dec 1998	TW
8501449	Apr 1985	WO
8605116	Sep 1986	WO
8605705	Oct 1986	WO
8800494	Jan 1988	WO
8801529	Mar 1988	WO
8801895	Mar 1988	WO
8806200	Aug 1988	WO
8900880	Feb 1989	WO
9000434	Jan 1990	WO
9104783	Apr 1991	WO
9116124	Oct 1991	WO
9302779	Feb 1993	WO
9315827	Aug 1993	WO
9323152	Nov 1993	WO
9411094	May 1994	WO
9511736	May 1995	WO
9534424	Dec 1995	WO
9603202	Feb 1996	WO
9607470	Mar 1996	WO
9628236	Sep 1996	WO
9629142	Sep 1996	WO
9641676	Dec 1996	WO
9706880	Feb 1997	WO
9822204	May 1998	WO
9825694	Jun 1998	WO
9828066	Jul 1998	WO
9853902	Dec 1998	WO
9901207	Jan 1999	WO
99-55448	Nov 1999	WO
9959707	Nov 1999	WO
WO0018498	Apr 2000	WO
0030742	Jun 2000	WO
0100307	Jan 2001	WO
0105715	Jan 2001	WO
0108790	Feb 2001	WO
0119414	Mar 2001	WO
0132299	May 2001	WO
0136075	May 2001	WO
0143856	Jun 2001	WO
0145829	Jun 2001	WO
0226363	Apr 2002	WO
0230550	Apr 2002	WO
0240140	May 2002	WO
0247800	Jun 2002	WO
03000389	Jan 2003	WO
03013706	Feb 2003	WO
WO 03024575	Mar 2003	WO
03053552	Jul 2003	WO
03057632	Jul 2003	WO
03059495	Jul 2003	WO
03068374	Aug 2003	WO
03095078	Nov 2003	WO
2004018084	Mar 2004	WO
2004024304	Mar 2004	WO
2004033078	Apr 2004	WO
WO2004050221	Jun 2004	WO
2004056458	Jul 2004	WO
2004078327	Sep 2004	WO
2004101120	Nov 2004	WO
2005005028	Jan 2005	WO
2005021140	Mar 2005	WO
2005028085	Mar 2005	WO
2005028086	Mar 2005	WO
2005037414	Apr 2005	WO
2005046849	May 2005	WO
2005077499	Aug 2005	WO
2005082498	Sep 2005	WO
2005107929	Nov 2005	WO
2006026814	Mar 2006	WO
2006029456	Mar 2006	WO
2006029465	Mar 2006	WO
2006047814	May 2006	WO
2006066350	Jun 2006	WO
2007053528	May 2007	WO
2007065956	Jun 2007	WO
2007135087	Nov 2007	WO
2008025077	Mar 2008	WO
2008034570	Mar 2008	WO
2008071516	Jun 2008	WO
2008141080	Nov 2008	WO
2008153818	Dec 2008	WO
2009030405	Mar 2009	WO

Non-Patent Literature Citations (40)

Entry
International Search Report dated Nov. 23, 2005 for Application No. PCT/AU2005/001396.
New Zealand Examination Report dated May 20, 2009 for Patent Application No. 553742.
Almulla et al., Desalination, 153 (2002), pp. 237-243.
Anonymous, “Nonwoven Constructions of Dyneon “THV and Dyneon”THE Fluorothermoplastics”, Research Disclosure Journal, Apr. 1999, RD 420013, 2 pages.
Cote et al., Wat. Sci. Tech. 38(4-5) (1998), pp. 437-442.
Cote, et al. “A New Immersed Membrane for Pretreatment to Reverse Osmosis” Desalination 139 (2001) 229-236.
Craig, Jones, “Applications of Hydrogen Peroxide and Derivatives,” The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK 1999 Chapters 2 and 5.
Crawford et al., “Procurement of Membrane Equipment: Differences Between Water Treatment and Membrane Bioreactor (MBR) Applications” (2003).
Davis et al., Membrane Technology Conference, “Membrane Bioreactor Evaluation for Water Reuse in Seattle, Washington” (2003).
DeCarolis et al., Membrane Technology Conference, “Optimization of Various MBR Systems for Water Reclamation” (2003).
Delgrange-Vincent, N. et al., Desalination 131 (2000) 353-362.
Dow Chemicals Company, “Filmtec Membranes—Cleaning Procedures for Filmtec FT30 Elements,” Tech Facts, Online, Jun. 30, 2000, XP002237568.
Husain, H. et al., “The ZENON experience with membrane bioreactors for municipal wastewater treatment,” MBR2: Membr. Bioreact. Wastewater Treat., 2nd Intl. Meeting; School of Water Sciences, Cranfield University, Cranfield, UK, Jun. 1999.
Johnson, “Recent Advances in Microfiltration for Drinking Water Treatment,” AWWA Annual Conference, Jun. 20-24, 1999, Chicago, Illinois, entire publication.
Kaiya et al., “Water Purification Using Hollow Fiber Microfiltration Membranes,” 6th World Filtration Congress, Nagoya, 1993, pp. 813-816.
Kang et al. “Characteristics of microfiltration membranes in a membrane coupled sequencing batch reactor system” Water Research, Elsevier, Amsterdam, NL, vol. 37, No. 5, Mar. 2003.
Lloyd, D.R. et al. “Microporous Membrane Formation Via Thermally Induced Phase Separation/Solid-Liquid Phase Separation” Journal of Membrane Science (Sep. 15, 1990), pp. 239-261, vol. 52, No. 3, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, NL.
Lozier et al., “Demonstration Testing of ZenoGem and Reverse Osmosis for Indirect Potable Reuse Final Technical Report,” published by CH2M Hill, available from the National Technical Information Service, Operations Division, Jan. 2000, entire publication.
Nakayama, “Introduction to Fluid Mechanics,” Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, UK, 2000.
Ramaswammy S. et al. “Fabrication of Ply (ECTFE) Membranes via thermally induced phase Separation”, Journal of Membrane Science, (Dec. 1, 2002), pp. 175-180, vol. 210 No. 1, Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, NL.
Rosenberger et al., Desalination, 151 (2002), pp. 195-200.
U.S. Appl. No. 60/278,007, filed Mar. 23, 2001.
Ueda et al., “Effects of Aeration on Suction Pressure in a Submerged Membrane Bioreactor,” Wat. Res. vol. 31, No. 3, 1997, pp. 489-494.
Water Encyclopedia, edited by Jay Lehr, published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, 2005. Available at http://wwwmmrw.interscience.wiley.com/eow/.
White et al., The Chemical Engineering Journal, 52 (1993), pp. 73-77.
Wikipedia, “Seawater,” available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seawater, Jul. 15, 2007.
Yamamoto et al., Water Science Technology, vol. 2, pp. 43-54; 1989.
Yoon: “Important operational parameters of membrane bioreactor-sludge disintegration (MBR-SD) system for zero excess sludge production” Water Research, Elsevier, Amsterdam, NL, vol. 37, No. 8, Apr. 2003.
Zenon, “Proposal for ZeeWeed® Membrane Filtration Equipment System for the City of Westminster, Colorado, Proposal No. 479-99,” Mar. 2000, entire publication.
Japanese Official Action dated Feb. 1, 2011 for Application No. 2007-530550.
Mark et al., “Peroxides and Peroxy Compounds, Inorganic” Kirk—Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, Peroxides and Peroxy Compounds, Inorganic, To Piping Systems, New York, Wiley & Sons, Ed., Jan. 1, 1978, pp. 14-18.
Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, Merriam-Webster Inc., Publishers, Springfield, Massachusetts, USA, Copyright 1986, p. 1298.
Coulson et al., “Coulson and Richardson's Chemical Engineering,” 1999, vol. 1, pp. 358-364.
Australian Examiner's Report dated Nov. 9, 2009 for Application No. 2005284677.
Canadian Office Action dated Oct. 26, 2011 for Application No. 2,579,857.
Chinese First Office Action dated Sep. 15, 2006 for Application No. 200480006910.5 (with translation.
Chinese Second Office Action dated Jan. 25, 2011 for Application No. 200580034570.1 (with translation).
Chinese Third Office Action dated May 30, 2011 for Application No. 200580034570.1 (with translation).
Cui et al., “Airlift crossflow membrane filtration—a feasibility study with dextran ultrafiltration,” J. Membrane Sci. (1997) vol. 128, pp. 83-91.
European Search Report dated Jul. 21, 2011 for Application No. 05 779 037.0.

Related Publications (1)

	Number	Date	Country
	20080053923 A1	Mar 2008	US

Methods and apparatus for removing solids from a membrane module

Information

Patent Number

Date Filed

Date Issued

Inventors

Original Assignees

Examiners

CPC

US Classifications

Field of Search

US

International Classifications

Term Extension

Abstract