This invention relates generally to the field of metal-component fabrication and repair, and more particularly to the fabrication and repair of hollow superalloy components containing cavities and/or holes.
Modern gas turbines require cooling systems to protect the turbine blades, vanes, endwalls, shroud and other components from the increasingly higher metal temperatures that are demanded for improved performance. There are five basic cooling techniques employed in modern gas turbine engines: convection cooling, impingement cooling, film cooling, transpiration cooling and water/steam cooling. Several of these techniques rely in part on the placement of holes or cavities in vital engine components to facilitate fluid flow.
During repair of engine blades and other air-cooled components it is critical to maintain the cooling holes in an unobstructed condition, and it is essential to keep the size and shape of the holes within design limits in order to achieve optimal performance of these components during engine operation. However, maintaining the cooling holes free of obstructions and within design limits of size and shape is especially difficult when performing repairs of components fabricated using superalloy materials, which are often employed in modern gas turbine components subject to increasingly higher temperatures.
Superalloy materials are among the most difficult to fabricate and repair due to their susceptibility of melt solidification cracking and strain age cracking. The term “superalloy” is used herein as it is commonly used in the art—a highly corrosion and oxidation resistant alloy with excellent mechanical strength and resistance to creep at high temperatures. Superalloys typically include high nickel or cobalt content. Examples of superalloys include alloys sold under the trademarks and brand names such as Hastelloy, Inconel alloys (e.g., IN 738, IN 792, IN 939), Rene alloys (e.g., Rene N5, Rene 80, Rene 142), Haynes alloys, and CMSX (e.g., CMSX-4) single crystal alloys to name a few.
Hollow superalloy components are often repaired using laser powder deposition processes to melt a thin layer of alloy powder particles onto an alloy substrate to form a cladding layer. Performing these techniques over holes or cavities present on an outer surface of the alloy substrate, however, can jeopardize the mechanical integrity of both the alloy substrate and the cladding layer.
The physical discontinuity at the cooling hole 10 allows molten metal to run into the cooling hole 10 causing a depression 20 in the surface of the cladding 16 below the desired cladding surface line 18. Furthermore, because the hole imparts a thermal discontinuity during the laser melting process, over-penetration (i.e., excess melting) can lead to cracking 22 in the superalloy substrate 12. Because the hole 10 provides no backing or support, the molten metal is also exposed to air within the hole 10 such that oxidation and nitridation can result in “sugaring” 24 on the lower surface of the cladding 16, as well as porosity and inclusions 26 within the cladding layer 16. Additionally, the lack of shielding in the hole 10 prevents adequate wetting of the molten metal to the superalloy substrate 16—leading to notches 28 located at the upper edges of the cooling hole 10 which increase stress in the resulting component.
Various strategies have been employed to prevent these problems by masking or plugging cooling holes and other cavities prior to performing repair welding or brazing. Masking using wires or weld metal can be effective in plugging cooling holes, but such material must be removed afterwards using time-consuming and expensive techniques. Furthermore, debris from such removal is difficult to control and can cause blockages and other issues in other parts of the component. Masking using evaporative materials such as wax, polymer, epoxy, etc. is also known, but these materials may prematurely dissipate and fail to adequately protect the component. Also, use of such foreign material can contaminate the deposited cladding layer leading to defects such as porosity, cracks and inclusions. Ceramic materials can also be used to plug cooling holes, but these approaches require either tedious installation of pre-formed ceramic inserts or elaborate processing steps to form a ceramic plug or mask within the hole or cavity.
There is a need to develop simple and inexpensive methods and materials to mask and protect cooling holes which allow for the repair and manufacture of hollow superalloy components free from the defects described above. A similar need also exists to develop methods and materials to fabricate metallic (superalloy) layers over open cavities without imparting the defects described above.
The invention is explained in the following description in view of the drawings that show:
The present inventors have discovered novel methods and materials for forming metallic cladding layers over open cavities and holes located in metallic components. In these disclosures, a protective material is employed which can function as a supportive structure (reducing or preventing a molten metal from entering the open space), a barrier structure (preventing a molten metal from entering the open space and optionally defining the shape of the resulting cladding layer), and as a protective agent (reducing or preventing chemical and/or mechanical imperfections in the resulting cladding layer). Such protective support or blocking materials may exist as individual (standalone) structures, or beds of material, or as multi-layered preform structures constructed of metallic filler-containing compartments and at least one protective supporting compartment. The use of multi-layered preform structures enables the additive manufacture and repair of relatively large, hollow superalloy components containing intricate structural features with a high degree of structural precision and with a minimal amount of chemical/mechanical imperfections.
Although the illustration in
In some embodiments the protective material 44 provides necessary support without the aid of an underlying support structure. For example, some protective materials 44 can be shaped to tightly compliment the interior surface of the hole or cavity. In other examples the protective material 44 is in a moldable form which conforms to the interior surface of the hole or cavity. In still other embodiments the protective material 44 is a multi-layered or multi-sectioned protective material capable of providing necessary support through friction, preloading or complementarity.
In other embodiments the protective material 44 is itself supported by a fugitive support material 46. “Fugitive” means removable after formation of the cladding layer, for example, by direct (physical removal), by a mechanical process, by draining, by fluid flushing, by chemical leaching and/or by any other known process capable of removing the fugitive support material 46 from its position. Examples of fugitive support materials 46 include powders (e.g., metal, glass, ceramic, fiber powders), solid objects (e.g., metal, glass, ceramic, composite, plastic, resinous structures, graphite, dry ice), woolen materials (e.g., steel wool, aluminum oxide wool, zirconia wool) and foamed materials (e.g., polymer foams, high-temperature spray foams) to name a few. Any material or structure capable of providing support and then being removable after the formation of the cladding layer 16 may serve as the fugitive support material 46.
In still other embodiments the protective material 44 acts as an underlying support structure. For example the protective material 44 can fill the entire space of the hole or cavity. As an illustration of such an embodiment, the protective material 44 may be in the form of a powder which fills the entire (or nearly the entire) space of the hole or cavity. Such a protective material 44 in powdered form may then be removed from the metallic component after formation of the cladding layer 16.
In the region of the cooling hole 48, the protective material 44 performs three functions. First, it supports the melt pool 42 to reduce or prevent molten metal from migrating into the cooling hole 48. Second, it acts as a thermal sink or insulator to reduce or minimize thermal discontinuity in the region of the cooling hole and optionally to provide an ability to control the grain size and structure of cladding particles deposited over the cooling hole 48. Third, it protects the cladding layer 16 and the superalloy substrate 12 by generating a protective substance which is capable of performing at least one protective function.
The protective material 44 often contains at least one inorganic material and can be in the form of a powder, a moldable paste or putty, a single-layer or multi-layer sheet, a ceramic, a composite material, a textile, a woolen material, or other forms capable of supporting the melt pool and possessing the necessary (high-temperature) thermal characteristics.
The method of fabricating and/or installing the protective material 44 largely depends upon its form. Non-limiting examples include: (i) introducing a free powder (or mixture of powders) into the cavity or hole using gravity or with the aid of an applicator or a compressed gas or a vacuum; (ii) introducing a powder or composite material contained in a rigid or moldable container fabricated of a metallic material (e.g., a metallic mesh, net or foil) or an organic material (e.g., paper, plastic, resin) or inorganic material (e.g. silica, alumina, zirconia); (iii) introducing a pre-formed ceramic in powder or solid form (optionally within a container as described above) or formation of a ceramic within the hole or cavity through methods known in the relevant art; (iv) introducing a putty or paste into a hole or cavity by physical means (e.g., by physical applicator (e.g., spatula) or under pressure) from the outside or inside of the metallic component; (v) placement of a compressed sheet into a hole or cavity, in which the compressed sheet is either complimentary to the interior surface of the component or is supported by a fugitive support material; (vi) introducing a woolen material into the hole or void (from the outside or inside of the metallic component) with or without a fugitive support material acting as an underlying support, and by other methods known to those skilled in the relevant art.
The term “inorganic material” includes metals, alloys, inorganic oxides, inorganic salts and other inorganic materials and combinations thereof capable of imparting a rigid, supportive form to the protective material 44 under high-temperature conditions (e.g., at or above the melting temperature of a nickel-based superalloy (˜1350° C.)). Inorganic materials can include powdered metals, metal oxides, metal carbonates, metal halides, metal silicates, metal borates, metal fluorides, or mixtures thereof. In some embodiments the inorganic material contains at least one metal oxide selected from a magnesium oxide, a manganese oxide, an aluminum oxide, a silicon oxide, a calcium oxide, a titanium oxide, a yttrium oxide, a zirconium oxide, a hafnium oxide, a cerium oxide, and mixtures thereof. For example, in some embodiments the inorganic material may contain a mixture of metal oxides such as a zirconium oxide, a silicon oxide and a titanium oxide—such that a melting point of the inorganic material exceeds 2000° C. In other instances the inorganic material may be a powdered metal oxide such as zirconium oxide.
The contents of the protective material 44 may be selected to control the magnitude and direction of local heat conduction and the solidification rate and, thus, the solid internal structure of the cladding layer 16 in the vicinity of the hole or cavity. A higher thermal conductivity material will tend to transfer heat out of the melt pool 42 more rapidly. A lower thermal conductivity material will tend to transfer heat out of the melt pool 42 more slowly. A material matching the thermal conductivity of the adjoining component will produce heat management such that the hole is not a thermal discontinuity for the process. Using this approach it is possible to control the grain size, orientation and structure as well, e.g., to promote formation of equiaxed or columnar or even single crystal grain structures.
The size and texture of particles optionally contained in the protective material 44 may also be controlled to affect the mobility of a molten metal into the hole or cavity. For example, when using a powdered inorganic material the size of the powder particles may be set to be smaller than the size of the particles in the filler material 34. In some embodiments, for instance, the particle size of a powdered protective material 44 is set to be at least one-half of the size of the metal powder 36 in the filler material 34 (see
To accomplish its protective function the protective material 44 contains, or generates upon being heated, a protective substance which provides at least one protective feature.
In some cases the protective substance functions as a barrier shield or blanket to separate one or both of the molten metal and the metallic substrate from the atmosphere, in order to minimize or eliminate oxidation and nitridation of the metallic substrate 12 and/or the resulting cladding layer 16. One non-limiting example of an organic shielding material is cellulose which breaks down into CO, CO2 and H2 that can be effective for shielding. In some cases the protective substance functions as a reducing agent that prevents the formation of (or removes) oxides on the surface (or interior) of the metallic substrate 12 and/or the cladding layer 16. The use of a barrier shield, a reducing agent, or both, can eliminate the necessity of using expensive inert gases or low pressure (vacuum) conditions, and can also reduce or eliminate the occurrence of sugaring 24 on the surface of cladding layer 16 as well as porosity and inclusions 26 (see
In some cases the protective substance functions as a thermal shield or blanket allowing the molten metal and the metallic substrate to cool slowly and evenly, thereby reducing residual stresses that can contribute to post-weld reheat-cracking or strain-age cracking. The use of a thermal shield/blanket can also reduce or eliminate the occurrence of cracks 22 in both the metallic substrate 16 and the cladding layer 16 (see
In some cases the protective substance functions as a wetting agent which improves contact between the molten metal and the metal substrate through various mechanisms such as reducing viscosity of the molten metal and removing oxides from the surface of the metal substrate. The use of a wetting agent can reduce or eliminate the occurrence of notches 28 at the interface of the cladding layer 16 with the metallic substrate 12 (see
In some cases the protective substance functions as a cleanser or absorption agent which can remove trace impurities, such as sulfur and phosphorous, and can also remove unwanted metal oxides. The use of a cleanser or absorption agent can reduce or eliminate the occurrence of post-solidification cracking 22 of the cladding layer 16 and/or the metal substrate 12, and can also reduce or eliminate the occurrence of sugaring 24 as well as porosity and includes 26 in and on the cladding layer 16 (see
In some embodiments the protective material simultaneously provides one or more of the protective functions described above—either through the action of a single protective substance or through the action of a mixture of different protective substances.
The protective material 44 either includes the protective substance as an initial component or generates the protective substance upon heating (which occurs due to melting of the filler material 34 with the energy beam 40). For embodiments wherein the protective substance is generated by heating, the protective substance is formed as a liquid or as a gas or as a compound that is removed by way of slag formation. The formation process may occur by a phase-transition process (e.g., melting, evaporation, or sublimation) or by a reaction process (e.g., thermal decomposition or reaction with another substance). Reaction processes leading to the formation of a protective substance may include, for example, reactions with water (e.g., Y+H2O→Y(OH)2+H2), reactions with acids (e.g., CaF2+HCl→CaCl2+HF), and thermally-induced decompositions (e.g., CuCO3→CuO+CO2).
In some embodiments an inorganic material may act as the protective substance or may undergo a phase change or reaction to from the protective substance. In other embodiments the protective material 44 contains both an inorganic material and at least one additional component that either acts as the protective substance or undergoes a phase change or reaction to form the protective substance.
Compounds acting as, or forming, protective substances include both organic and inorganic compounds.
Examples of organic compounds directly or indirectly fulfilling the protective function of the protective material 44 include high-molecular weight hydrocarbons (e.g., beeswax, paraffin), carbohydrates (e.g., cellulose), natural and synthetic oils (e.g., palm oil), organic reducing agents (e.g., charcoal, coke), carboxylic acids and dicarboxylic acids (e.g., abietic acid, isopimaric acid, neoabietic acid, dehydroabietic acid, rosins), carboxylic acid salts (e.g., rosin salts), carboxylic acid derivatives (e.g., dehydroabietylamine), amines (e.g., triethanolamine), alcohols (e.g., high polyglycols, glycerols), natural and synthetic resins (e.g., polyol esters of fatty acids), mixtures of such compounds, and other organic compounds capable of fulfilling the protective functions described above.
Examples of inorganic compounds directly or indirectly fulfilling the protective function of the protective material 44 include reactive metals (e.g., iron ore), metal oxides (e.g., magnesium oxide, manganese oxide, aluminum oxide, silicon dioxide, calcium oxide, titanium oxide, yttrium oxide, zirconium oxide, hafnium oxide, copper oxide, cerium oxide), metal halides (e.g., lithium chloride, zinc chloride, barium chloride, magnesium chloride, tin chloride, calcium fluoride), halide salts (e.g., ammonium chloride), borates (e.g., borax), metal fluoroborates (e.g., potassium fluoroborate), metal sulfides (e.g., lead sulfide), metal carbonates (e.g., calcium carbonate, sodium carbonate, sodium bicarbonate, potassium carbonate), metal aluminates (e.g., cryolite), mineral acids (e.g., hydrochloric acid, hydrobromic acid, phosphoric acid), metal silicates (e.g., sodium silicate), mixtures of such compounds, and other inorganic compounds capable of fulfilling the protective functions described above.
In some embodiments the protective substance is provided by a commercially available flux material. Examples of known flux materials capable of fulfilling at least one protective function include Lincolnweld P2007, Bohler Soudokay NiCrW-412, ESAB OK 10.16 or 10.90, Special Metals NT100, Oerlikon OP76, Sandvik 50SW or SAS1 or specialized fluxes that are specifically formulated for laser (versus arc) processing (i.e., without the need for arc stabilizers) and are known in the relevant art. In some instances the inorganic material of the protective material 44 is a commercially available flux material. In other instances the protective material 44 contains both an inorganic material (e.g., zirconium oxide) and a commercially available flux material. The flux particles may be ground to a desired smaller mesh size range before use.
Use of a protective material 44 satisfying the requirements described above not only prevents or minimizes intrusion of the molten metal (i.e., the melt pool 42) into the cooling hole 48 (see
After performing laser powder deposition (e.g., laser cladding, selective laser melting or sintering, etc.) to produce the cladding layer 16, the protective material 44 may be removed using a number of techniques depending upon the form of the protective material 44. Non-limiting examples include: (i) removing a remaining powder through the hollow interior of the metallic component using physical agitation with or without the aid of a gas flow; (ii) laser drilling an access hole through the cladding layer (into the cooling hole) and physically removing the remnants of the protective material 44 either through the hole or through the hollow interior; (iii) chemically removing the remnants of a ceramic protective material 44 using a leaching agent (e.g., a potassium hydroxide solution); (iv) physically removing the remnants of a sheet-like protective material 44 by using a chemical leaching agent or by using a physical method (e.g., ultrasound) to break up the remnants; (v) dissolving a spray foam fugitive support material 46 allowing the remnants of a sheet-like protective material 44 to be readily removed from the interior of the hollow metallic component, and by other methods known to those skilled in the relevant art.
The protective material 60 may contain the same materials described above for the protective supporting material 44. The protective material 60 may also be in the form of a powder, a moldable paste or putty, a single-layer or multi-layer sheet, a ceramic, a composite material, a textile, a woolen material, or other forms capable of (fully or partially) withstanding contact with a molten metal and shaping the melt pool into a defined shape 64.
The protective material 60 may also contain a lower protrusion 84 capable of providing a registration function allowing easier placement and improved adherence to the surface of the substrate 12. In some embodiments wherein the diameter of the protective material 60 is not sufficient to provide adequate support over the hole or open cavity 82, a fugitive support material 62 may be employed to support the protective material 60. In the non-limited example depicted in
In the non-limiting exemplary embodiment of
The lower compartment in the embodiment of
In some embodiments the preform 72 may contain additional compartments (on the either or both of the upper and the lower compartments 74, 76) to account for additional physical structures to be fabricated in an additive manufacturing process. In some embodiments the protective material 78 may be separate from the preform, such that the preform only contains a single level including, for example, a filler compartment 66 and a central and/or peripheral blocking compartment 68, 70. In some embodiments the upper compartment 74 or the lower compartment 76 may themselves be multi-layered compartments containing different materials. In one non-limiting example the lower compartment 76 contains both a protective material 78 and a lower fugitive support material. In another non-limiting example the lower compartment 76 contains a commercial flux material in an upper level and the protective material 78 in a lower level.
As will be realized, the present invention is capable of other and different embodiments, and its several details are capable of modifications in various obvious respects, all without departing from the present invention. In this regard, the description herein is to be understood as illustrative in nature, and not as restrictive. Accordingly, it is intended that the invention be limited only by the spirit and scope of the appended claims.
This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/956,635 filed on 1 Aug. 2013 (attorney docket number 2013P12505US), incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13956635 | Aug 2013 | US |
Child | 14444108 | US |